From 826b1c0cc3653e0b6d38ffecc03cadc99ecb2f9a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Jake Tiller Date: Fri, 14 Aug 2026 09:23:55 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] Close the service-worker drift left unresolved by observation 0001 Observation 0001 recorded repository aaig-v85 against production aaig-v84 and deferred. The pin has since advanced to aaig-v87 and no later receipt had re-observed the deployed file, so an unresolved finding was aging out of view rather than being closed. Fetched sw.js from production and compared it to the committed bytes. They are byte identical, and both name cache aaig-v87. The receipt closes the current-state question only. It records that the v85 and v86 generations were never observed in production and cannot be reconstructed from it, that one edge was sampled, and that installed client caches were not inspected. Checkpoint 000013 seals the new event. The projection root is unchanged at 22852b5a3025, because an OBSERVE decision with effect NONE must not advance accepted state. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 --- .../ledger/checkpoints/checkpoint-000013.json | 73 +++++++++++ .../000003-service-worker-drift-closed.json | 117 ++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 190 insertions(+) create mode 100644 governance/ledger/checkpoints/checkpoint-000013.json create mode 100644 governance/ledger/events/deployment/000003-service-worker-drift-closed.json diff --git a/governance/ledger/checkpoints/checkpoint-000013.json b/governance/ledger/checkpoints/checkpoint-000013.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d7d0ac8 --- /dev/null +++ b/governance/ledger/checkpoints/checkpoint-000013.json @@ -0,0 +1,73 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "2.0.0", + "checkpoint_id": "checkpoint-000013", + "recorded_at": "2026-08-14T13:22:48Z", + "previous_checkpoint_root": "a58ddf0b75e3d1c9ddd5a454e01503edc017263ac67d098c58b2a7eb211464cf", + "event_count": 17, + "event_file_hash_basis": "SHA-256 of UTF-8 event JSON with CRLF normalized to LF.", + "event_files": { + "governance/ledger/events/deployment/000001-wp0-production-observation.json": "34bde4ec2eb4d1bfb70b8d44df6439cb295bd1dc1293df0ae47490193ad3fa97", + "governance/ledger/events/deployment/000002-public-explanation-production-observed.json": "4917a927727e3b0cc03cd057100a698ccc18e51751f69dd33f5bed14344fa24f", + "governance/ledger/events/deployment/000003-service-worker-drift-closed.json": "f03960cb1927a2c89fa5b9e98bd9cdf0cdd977c6b45fe19937346264251158e4", + "governance/ledger/events/feedback/000001-public-researcher-comment.json": "ba6c14fee16552d485c8343e07fe29aa5bfee295bdd854367a44dc27904183ed", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000001-wp0-authority-freeze.json": "8179bbd5216dfaf91e7b5dd10a04722f4928fd8a9ae9ff2acd834f904ebdc337", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000002-public-metadata-release-acceptance.json": "b42cf6d6da3ae197e8726d8809887c941109a7e25b359a3b775d1be114f519f3", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000003-stp-v1-2-public-reproduction-authorized.json": "16c2f324bb63a671963f38eaab92a22fb8ec0b055cf4107e67d6e14db158d25f", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000004-six-signal-public-method-authorized.json": "a60602c90396b34081da5896079e3721197147226ecde63e0a3377ad6fec3cfb", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000005-six-signal-release-binding-corrected.json": "25a825fa2be627ce6a0eb36bff6242f4f39b388b0eaf5a4e2cef5548771d01a5", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000006-git-pages-source-hardening-authorized.json": "b3110e7aded56cc4c3a49902ef6fcb97a27c386ab442e8a7c0e66de6de242954", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000007-atlas-foundational-repair-source-review.json": "00ed4f2dcfb92e58bc7f37927bae36a0cfba263ddc64a4e5a3f6dc4382cd7906", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000008-atlas-data-sync-portability-corrected.json": "9ea2836edcb4e6bf9008977b96be5d72bc3e697a7958b66d6d10444417b955d1", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000009-atlas-navigation-history-corrected.json": "52ed487051c53256262c9293a19102b7dbb4621d141882a1bec2d90f7b076b83", + "governance/ledger/events/governance/000010-public-explanation-surfaces-prepared.json": "0f04bbd6b8cf08180365363d040f95c6d0cd1053ab8bfa1f4996d527df3de865", + "governance/ledger/events/publication/000001-stp-v1-2-public-release-observed.json": "c505f5ea075344f29e67540a9f3178a6e7e5bec7e1e079cf132ab2b0fbae5bc6", + "governance/ledger/events/research/000001-wp0-artifact-search.json": "f9997b300db7ac4181bcc2755c872c206fbab838c3012c26930cb469a4afee29", + "governance/ledger/events/semantics/000001-status-vocabulary-boundary.json": "407c36c1c412f1c3d6f8eecda2bcd1a9ddcf5069f2e5febb9d0dacee70415fe5" + }, + "streams": { + "deployment": { + "sequence": 3, + "event_id": "evt_deployment_service_worker_drift_closed_0003", + "event_hash": "0914ca90d73804b045655c3ce0c7cefbdc3474b87691aa842ed3fd09a3b1222e" + }, + "feedback": { + "sequence": 1, + "event_id": "evt_feedback_public_researcher_comment_0001", + "event_hash": "d30d65d43a51491bb51d08538d8e6e5ba7621a0461cc65f7ff633b4393774435" + }, + "governance": { + "sequence": 10, + "event_id": "evt_governance_public_explanation_surfaces_prepared_0010", + "event_hash": "a63fb75269ffc54da67e0bf31601c77d70dc7b60fd745c929c3a4e339f5a4841" + }, + "publication": { + "sequence": 1, + "event_id": "evt_publication_stp_v1_2_release_0001", + "event_hash": "91cb238abfda22b2fdea65f56f0e4515e1b8df8c9a512569d9302c59a0901534" + }, + "research": { + "sequence": 1, + "event_id": "evt_research_wp0_artifact_register_0001", + "event_hash": "b8661fda03f6da05e89507eb632c81a42bbdbe287c507ef66b9b8cb4074d105a" + }, + "semantics": { + "sequence": 1, + "event_id": "evt_semantics_status_vocabulary_boundary_0001", + "event_hash": "cca5be5a16d815990fd23a1006d731e9704e9db16bbeacb76bedc0e45916ff96" + } + }, + "capability_policies": { + "governance/ledger/policy/capabilities.v1.json": "8d144987a039561ccf80f6c8c703901150b32061843db2f48d9dcde2c78cd2d4", + "governance/ledger/policy/capabilities.v2.json": "3d6d25510d489e295a3321298c0ca6b46495393fc558f108afb5988a68d8a696" + }, + "projection_root": "22852b5a3025d4ed7ee1d26cc4efcd51ae2e3e02ba2a20332c2a09827d6462ca", + "witnesses": [ + { + "kind": "git_commit_or_release", + "status": "NOT_OBSERVED", + "locator": null, + "limit": "The checkpoint is internally sealed but has not yet been anchored by a protected signed ref or independent witness." + } + ], + "checkpoint_root": "725824151f03b61542c37f5e1f5e1cfd964c9915834b4f9ee4cd8a29297a500e" +} diff --git a/governance/ledger/events/deployment/000003-service-worker-drift-closed.json b/governance/ledger/events/deployment/000003-service-worker-drift-closed.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f298c06 --- /dev/null +++ b/governance/ledger/events/deployment/000003-service-worker-drift-closed.json @@ -0,0 +1,117 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "2.0.0", + "status_vocabulary": "stp-v1.1-status-axes", + "capability_policy_ref": "governance/ledger/policy/capabilities.v2.json", + "event_id": "evt_deployment_service_worker_drift_closed_0003", + "stream_id": "deployment", + "sequence": 3, + "event_type": "deployment.production_observed", + "occurred_at": "2026-08-14T13:20:30Z", + "recorded_at": "2026-08-14T13:20:30Z", + "actor": { + "id": "adapter:claude-code", + "role": "agent_observer", + "auth_basis": "evt_deployment_public_explanation_production_observed_0002" + }, + "classification": "PUBLIC", + "consequence_class": "C1", + "parents": [ + "evt_deployment_public_explanation_production_observed_0002" + ], + "prev_event_hash": "636df04813901f3168bc62366e496a152e14096c27683a668c441b5488cc80a3", + "payload_hash": "b348def185ce59be11c6c7447f9fe9372fee13965965ab7c0a0767e0f2f43758", + "event_hash": "0914ca90d73804b045655c3ce0c7cefbdc3474b87691aa842ed3fd09a3b1222e", + "read_set": [ + "sw.js", + "governance/ledger/events/deployment/000001-wp0-production-observation.json", + "governance/ledger/events/deployment/000002-public-explanation-production-observed.json" + ], + "write_set": [ + "governance/ledger/events/deployment/000003-service-worker-drift-closed.json" + ], + "precondition_refs": [ + "evt_deployment_wp0_production_observation_0001", + "evt_deployment_public_explanation_production_observed_0002" + ], + "evidence_refs": [ + { + "ref_id": "repository-service-worker", + "kind": "repository_file", + "classification": "PUBLIC", + "sha256": "fa01638d739955c4db7b5c220aee2309cb7ede03f6101433697732fb9043fa4f", + "source_locator": "sw.js" + }, + { + "ref_id": "live-service-worker", + "kind": "http_response_body", + "classification": "PUBLIC", + "sha256": "fa01638d739955c4db7b5c220aee2309cb7ede03f6101433697732fb9043fa4f", + "source_locator": "https://resilience-eval-ai.pages.dev/sw.js" + }, + { + "ref_id": "prior-observation-event", + "kind": "governance_event", + "classification": "PUBLIC", + "sha256": "34bde4ec2eb4d1bfb70b8d44df6439cb295bd1dc1293df0ae47490193ad3fa97", + "source_locator": "governance/ledger/events/deployment/000001-wp0-production-observation.json" + } + ], + "authority_ref": "evt_deployment_public_explanation_production_observed_0002", + "idempotency_key": "service-worker-drift-closure-2026-08-14T13:20:30Z", + "decision": "OBSERVE", + "status_axes": { + "evidence": "SUPPORTED", + "authority": "APPROVED", + "preparation": "READY", + "execution": "APPLIED", + "observation": "MATCHED", + "acceptance": "PRESERVED", + "outcome": "UNMEASURED" + }, + "effect": { + "kind": "NONE", + "target": null, + "reversible": true, + "recovery_ref": null + }, + "supersedes": [], + "correction_of": [], + "payload": { + "observation_id": "service-worker-drift-closure-0003", + "closes": { + "prior_observation_event": "evt_deployment_wp0_production_observation_0001", + "prior_finding": "Repository cache name is aaig-v85; production cache name is aaig-v84.", + "prior_finding_path": "sw.js", + "prior_repository_sha256": "5acd2a7818a67b6551707e0209b2ebd6cc57168208e55c5a6094a6058a2fbd42", + "prior_live_sha256": "2e98e8558e832ad711572184faa40b12f823b3bc8f81b13fd14f881b1000381f", + "prior_status": "UNRESOLVED", + "intervening_versions_unobserved": [ + "aaig-v85", + "aaig-v86" + ], + "closure_basis": "CURRENT_STATE_MATCHED" + }, + "observation": { + "path": "sw.js", + "url": "https://resilience-eval-ai.pages.dev/sw.js", + "method": "GET", + "http_status": 200, + "observed_at": "2026-08-14T13:20:30Z", + "live_sha256": "fa01638d739955c4db7b5c220aee2309cb7ede03f6101433697732fb9043fa4f", + "repository_sha256": "fa01638d739955c4db7b5c220aee2309cb7ede03f6101433697732fb9043fa4f", + "repository_commit": "ecbaa7589ed292cd7b3567f3e85fc772b3cc17c3", + "byte_identity": "MATCHED", + "live_cache_name": "aaig-v87", + "repository_cache_name": "aaig-v87", + "response_etag": "\"fc71f9cb0ba83ca5d9e866548aca21c8\"", + "content_security_policy": "NOT_PRESENT" + }, + "residual": { + "single_edge_only": true, + "installed_client_caches_unobserved": true, + "intervening_drift_never_observed": true, + "note": "This closes the current-state question only. The v85 and v86 generations were never observed in production and cannot be reconstructed from this receipt." + }, + "claim_ceiling": "Establishes that one sampled production edge served bytes identical to the repository at the recorded time. Does not establish global edge convergence, installed service-worker cache state, past generations, or any future response." + } +}