diff --git a/EstateReportingAPI.BusinessLogic/ReportingManager.cs b/EstateReportingAPI.BusinessLogic/ReportingManager.cs
index abeff19..5e723a7 100644
--- a/EstateReportingAPI.BusinessLogic/ReportingManager.cs
+++ b/EstateReportingAPI.BusinessLogic/ReportingManager.cs
@@ -651,7 +651,11 @@ from s in sJoin.DefaultIfEmpty()
         // Ok now enumerate the results
         var queryResults = await query.ToListAsync(cancellationToken);
         if (queryResults.Any() == false)
-            return response;
+            return new TransactionDetailReportResponse
+            {
+                Summary = new TransactionDetailSummary(),
+                Transactions = new List<TransactionDetail>()
+            };
         
         // Now to translate the results
         response = new TransactionDetailReportResponse {