From b0be3673e57cfcd70388f5dffb2080799017356a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2026 22:21:04 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 1/9] chore(harness): bootstrap OpenAPI MCP wave-0 proofs --- .../context-pack.md | 69 +++++++++++++++++++ .../drift.md | 27 ++++++++ .../plan.md | 16 +++++ .../research.md | 50 ++++++++++++++ .../supervisor.md | 30 ++++++++ .../worklog.md | 26 +++++++ 6 files changed, 218 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/research.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/supervisor.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..87536282a2 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +# Context Pack: OMB wave-0 proofs + +## Run Metadata + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | +| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | +| Current phase | research | +| Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | +| Scope overlays | service | + +## Current State + +The clean proof branch is rebased exactly to current `origin/main`. Required issues and RFC sections +are read. Aspire 13.4 exposes a plausible TypeScript post-allocation callback, but no P1/P2/P3 +experiment has run and no verdict is implied. The harness Plan-Gate remains closed. + +## Completed + +- Required skill / harness / doctrine / RFC / issue reading. +- Current-main re-baseline and shared-host inventory. +- Initial source and official Aspire API research. + +## In Progress + +- Locking the proof design, exact measurement methods, and gate set. + +## Next Steps + +1. Complete `research.md`, `plan.md`, and the `## Design` checkpoint. +2. Commit/push the plan state and obtain separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. +3. Launch one tracked implementation thread and serialize P1, P2, then P3. + +## Key Decisions + +| Decision | Source | Notes | +| --- | --- | --- | +| No `packages/**` changes | User contract / doctrine boundary | Productization belongs to #1133 and later waves. | +| P1 is not pre-decided | RFC §9 / #1127 | Only measured verdict selects F1(a) or F1(b). | +| Foreign resources are immutable | Shared-host hazard | Exact-path targeting and ownership proof only. | + +## Files Changed + +| Path | Status | Notes | +| --- | --- | --- | +| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | new | Harness bootstrap only. | + +## Gates + +| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Plan-Gate | NOT_RUN | Plan/design still being completed. | +| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | +| Runtime | NOT_RUN | No experiment started. | +| Resource hygiene | initial inventory only | Foreign resources listed; no mutation. | + +## Open Questions + +- P1, P2, and P3 measured outcomes remain open by design. + +## Drift and Debt + +- Drift: supervisor route override and stale overlay read paths recorded in `drift.md`. +- Debt: none. + +## Commits + +- See the draft PR's commit list + per-slice PR comments. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..ad44a66275 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +# Drift Log: OMB wave-0 proofs + +Drift is append-only. + +## 2026-08-03 — User-addressed Codex supervisor + +- **What:** The current Codex root session supervises planning instead of launching the default + Fable `planning_decisions` route. +- **Source:** User directive: “You are the implementation supervisor”. +- **Expected:** Lane policy defaults orchestration to Fable with Codex as fallback. +- **Actual:** The existing user-addressed Codex session remains supervisor; separate canonical + implementation, review, and formal evaluator sessions are still required. +- **Severity:** minor +- **Action:** accept +- **Evidence:** `supervisor.md` route table. + +## 2026-08-03 — Service overlay read paths absent + +- **What:** `SCOPE-service.md` points to `.claude/04-services.md` and + `.claude/06-infrastructure.md`, which are absent on the current branch. +- **Source:** Direct filesystem lookup after reading the overlay. +- **Expected:** Both additional-read files exist. +- **Actual:** Neither path resolves; focused package/service/Aspire source and official Aspire docs + are used instead. +- **Severity:** minor +- **Action:** accept +- **Evidence:** `rg --files` produced no matching paths. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..bcac2b92e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +# Plan: OMB wave-0 proofs + +## Run Metadata + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | +| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | +| Phase | `research` | +| Target | Wave-0 proof / measurement artifacts for #1127–#1129 | +| Archetype | N/A — no published-surface change | +| Scope overlays | service | + +The locked plan is intentionally pending completion of focused source/API research. No experiment +implementation may begin until this file and the Design checkpoint are complete and a separate +PLAN-EVAL writes `PASS` to `plan-eval.md`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/research.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/research.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..7a79e17c59 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/research.md @@ -0,0 +1,50 @@ +# Research — test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0 + +## Re-baseline + +- Carried-in source: RFC #1123 and `.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/` (rev 2). +- Re-derived against `origin/main` @ `fb75cf6fc5ad02130ada0ac42e6f44035ac03a9b` on 2026-08-03. +- GitHub issue bodies read in full: #1127, #1128, #1129; epic #1126 and RFC #1123 also read. +- RFC authority reread: `rfc.md` §4 Wave 0 and §9 F1 in the seed run directory. +- What changed vs the carried-in version: + - Aspire on this host is 13.4.6. Its official eventing documentation and generated TypeScript SDK + now expose `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` plus `EndpointReference.getValueAsync()`. + - This is positive research evidence only. F1 remains proof-arbitrated until P1 measures a real + generated scaffold and emits the required verdict. + +## Findings + +| # | Finding | How to verify | +| --- | --- | --- | +| 1 | Branch and `origin/main` are the same clean baseline; the proof branch did not exist remotely at bootstrap. | `git rev-list --left-right --count HEAD...origin/main` → `0 0`; `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` → empty | +| 2 | RFC §4 requires committed `proofs/P-verdict.md` files in the implementing run and defines skipped as non-pass. | `.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md:256` | +| 3 | RFC §9 leaves F1 to P1: PASS selects (a); an explicit FAIL legitimately selects (b). | `.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md:367` | +| 4 | Current generated AppHost code registers resources before `builder.build().run()`, so helper-body endpoint reads remain pre-allocation. | `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/aspire/helpers/apphost.ts.template`; `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/generated/aspire/helpers/generate-index-1.ts.template` | +| 5 | Aspire 13.4 documents and generates a TypeScript resource callback at the exact allocation event, with an endpoint API that can await a concrete URL. | `aspire docs get apphost-eventing-apis`; generated SDK `onResourceEndpointsAllocated`, `EndpointReference.getValueAsync()` | +| 6 | Existing service behavior already supplies a precise P3 fixture shape: unauthenticated spec fetch → 401, wrong scope → 403, correct scope → 200. The proof must rerun and ratify wording rather than infer. | `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` | +| 7 | MCP central truncation currently caps arrays at 50 and strings at 2,000 characters; P2 must report measurements against those exact current bounds. | `packages/mcp/src/application/runner/truncation.ts` | +| 8 | The no-database scaffold contract is built from bare `oc`, so common error-family presence cannot be assumed. | `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/contract.memory.ts.template`; canonical design `03-projection-and-naming.md` §3 | +| 9 | The host is shared: two foreign AppHosts and six foreign containers were already running before this slice. They are out of scope and must not be stopped or mutated. | `aspire ps --format json`; `docker ps` captured 2026-08-03 | +| 10 | The task changes only run artifacts / experiment evidence and the ratified RFC record; no `packages/**` or `plugins/**` public surface is owned. | User slice contract; clean baseline | + +## Doctrine / scope classification + +- Archetype: N/A — proof/measurement slice; no published package or plugin surface changes. +- Overlay: `SCOPE-service.md` because measurements exercise generated services and Aspire runtime. +- Current relevant doctrine verdicts are read-only context: `@netscript/aspire` is Archetype 2 / Keep; + `@netscript/service` is Archetype 4 / Refactor; `@netscript/cli` is Archetype 6 / Restructure. +- Doctrine debt delta: none expected; any required product change is a rescope and belongs to S7 + (#1133), not this proof PR. + +## jsr-audit surface scan (package/plugin waves) + +- N/A. This run does not change a package/plugin export, dependency, README, or publish surface. + +## Open questions + +- P1: does the TypeScript allocation callback produce a concrete host URL in a real scaffold, and + can an experiment atomically emit every service with `projectRoot` + per-run `runId`? +- P2: what exact operation-row and schema-view byte counts result from the generated live specs, + including the no-DB template, and which JSON Schema/OpenAPI keywords actually occur? +- P3: what exact 401/403 response envelope is observed on the current branch, and what concise + `spec_unavailable` text names both likely cause and corrective exemption? diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/supervisor.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/supervisor.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..4271216e77 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/supervisor.md @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ +# Supervisor Identity — test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0 + +Written at run start per `workflow/lane-policy.md` § Supervisor identity. + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Model | Codex GPT-5 root session (exact product model id is not exposed to the workspace) | +| Session | `/root` API session; no external session URL exposed | +| Host | `YogaBook9i` · Linux/WSL · user `codex` | +| Checkout | `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs` | +| Worktree | `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs` | +| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | +| Baseline | `fb75cf6fc5ad02130ada0ac42e6f44035ac03a9b` · `origin/main` · 2026-08-03 | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | + +## Routes in force + +| Task lane | Provider / model / effort | Role in this run | +| --- | --- | --- | +| `planning_decisions` | OpenAI / current Codex root session / high-equivalent | User-addressed implementation supervisor; research, orchestration, and sign-off commits | +| `normal_implementation` | OpenAI / `gpt-5.6-sol` / medium | Separate daemon-attached Codex implementation thread; experiment execution and draft artifacts only | +| `review_codex` | Anthropic / `fable-5` / low | Opposite-family substantive slice review before supervisor sign-off commits | +| `formal_evaluation` | OpenRouter / `qwen/qwen3.7-max` / high | Separate local PLAN-EVAL and IMPL-EVAL sessions through `claude-openrouter` / `claude-print` | + +## Recorded lane/eval overrides + +- The owner explicitly addressed the current Codex session as the implementation supervisor, so + `planning_decisions` uses the policy's Codex fallback instead of launching a new Fable supervisor. + Implementation, ordinary review, and formal evaluation remain separate sessions on their canonical + routes. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..47b6ea68bd --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +# Worklog: OMB wave-0 proofs + +## Run Metadata + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | +| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | +| Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | +| Scope overlays | service | + +## Design + +Design checkpoint pending. It will be completed before PLAN-EVAL and before any experiment file or +verdict artifact is created. + +## Progress Log + +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | + +## Gate Results + +All implementation gates are `NOT_RUN`; the Plan-Gate is the current hard stop. From 1fc6e39355d4ac8d6e8fb74157d6f0eec8e2f110 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2026 22:39:07 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 2/9] docs(harness): lock OpenAPI MCP proof plan --- .../briefs/plan-eval.md | 23 +++ .../context-pack.md | 74 ++++--- .../drift.md | 56 ++++++ .../implement.md | 28 +++ .../plan-eval.md | 88 ++++++++ .../plan.md | 189 ++++++++++++++++-- .../research.md | 32 +-- .../supervisor.md | 32 +-- .../worklog.md | 148 ++++++++++++-- 9 files changed, 582 insertions(+), 88 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/plan-eval.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/implement.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan-eval.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/plan-eval.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/plan-eval.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..e49be57852 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/plan-eval.md @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +use harness + +# PLAN-EVAL brief — OMB wave-0 proofs + +## SKILL + +Read and follow `.agents/skills/netscript-harness`, `.agents/skills/netscript-doctrine`, and +`.agents/skills/netscript-tools`. This is a formal evaluator turn, not implementation. + +You are the separate OPEN-model Qwen PLAN-EVAL session for `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0`. +Follow `.llm/harness/evaluator/plan-protocol.md` exactly. Read the plan gate, verdict definitions, +this run's `research.md`, `plan.md`, `worklog.md` Design, service overlay, gate matrix, and debt +registry. Recheck at least one load-bearing research claim against current source/docs. Confirm the +proof-only N/A archetype, exact commit slices, false-green skip handling, shared-host mitigations, +no-product-change boundary, and all open decisions. + +Write only this run's `plan-eval.md` using the harness template, with exactly one `PASS` or +`FAIL_PLAN` verdict. Do not implement a proof, edit the plan, commit, push, modify GitHub, run an +AppHost, touch `deno.lock`, or inspect credentials. + +Perform every read and checklist step in this session yourself. Do not invoke the Agent/Task tool, +spawn a subagent, or delegate any work: the Claude CLI's default child model is closed and the +formal-evaluator request guard will terminate the turn if any child model is requested. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md index 87536282a2..fcb92657ff 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md @@ -2,68 +2,76 @@ ## Run Metadata -| Field | Value | -| --- | --- | -| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | -| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | -| Current phase | research | -| Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | -| Scope overlays | service | +| Field | Value | +| -------------- | -------------------------------------- | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | +| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | +| Current phase | implementation | +| Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | +| Scope overlays | service | ## Current State -The clean proof branch is rebased exactly to current `origin/main`. Required issues and RFC sections -are read. Aspire 13.4 exposes a plausible TypeScript post-allocation callback, but no P1/P2/P3 -experiment has run and no verdict is implied. The harness Plan-Gate remains closed. +Research and Design are locked at D1–D12. Separate Qwen PLAN-EVAL passed. No P1/P2/P3 experiment or +verdict exists and no outcome is implied. Draft PR #1182 is open with the required labels/milestone +and no closing keywords. Implementation may begin only in the separate tracked Codex lane. ## Completed -- Required skill / harness / doctrine / RFC / issue reading. +- Required skills, issue bodies, epic, RFC §§4/9, doctrine, harness, source, and Aspire API reading. - Current-main re-baseline and shared-host inventory. -- Initial source and official Aspire API research. +- Harness bootstrap commit/push, draft PR #1182, and research phase comment. +- Locked plan, Design checkpoint, measurement schemas, commit slices, and gate set. +- Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high `plan-eval.md` with `PASS`. ## In Progress -- Locking the proof design, exact measurement methods, and gate set. +- S0 sign-off commit/push and draft-PR Plan/PLAN-EVAL reporting. ## Next Steps -1. Complete `research.md`, `plan.md`, and the `## Design` checkpoint. -2. Commit/push the plan state and obtain separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. -3. Launch one tracked implementation thread and serialize P1, P2, then P3. +1. Commit/push S0 and post the plan / plan-eval phase comments. +2. Launch one tracked Codex implementation thread from `implement.md`. +3. Serialize S1–S3 with Fable review and supervisor sign-off after each. ## Key Decisions -| Decision | Source | Notes | -| --- | --- | --- | -| No `packages/**` changes | User contract / doctrine boundary | Productization belongs to #1133 and later waves. | -| P1 is not pre-decided | RFC §9 / #1127 | Only measured verdict selects F1(a) or F1(b). | -| Foreign resources are immutable | Shared-host hazard | Exact-path targeting and ownership proof only. | +| Decision | Source | Notes | +| -------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ | +| No `packages/**` changes | User contract / doctrine boundary | Productization belongs to #1133 and later waves. | +| P1 is not pre-decided | RFC §9 / #1127 | Only measured evidence selects F1(a) or F1(b). | +| Two owned scaffolds run serially | #1128 / shared-host hazard | SQLite P1/P2 first, no-DB P2 second. | +| Incomplete/skipped is FAIL | RFC §4 / user contract | Never represent a missing proof as pass. | +| Formal evaluation stays Qwen/open-only | Harness lane policy | No closed-model or supervisor fallback. | ## Files Changed -| Path | Status | Notes | -| --- | --- | --- | -| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | new | Harness bootstrap only. | +| Path | Status | Notes | +| ------------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------------------------- | +| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | modified/new | Harness research, plan/design, prompts, and drift only. | ## Gates -| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | -| Plan-Gate | NOT_RUN | Plan/design still being completed. | -| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | -| Runtime | NOT_RUN | No experiment started. | -| Resource hygiene | initial inventory only | Foreign resources listed; no mutation. | +| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | +| ---------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | +| Plan-Gate | PASS | Separate Qwen verdict in `plan-eval.md`. | +| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | +| Runtime | NOT_RUN | No experiment started. | +| Resource hygiene | baseline inventory only | Foreign resources listed; no mutation. | ## Open Questions -- P1, P2, and P3 measured outcomes remain open by design. +- P1/P2/P3 measured values remain open by design; their decision rules are locked. +- Evaluator credential availability is resolved: the parser-backed live canary passed with tools, + reasoning, and streaming supported. ## Drift and Debt -- Drift: supervisor route override and stale overlay read paths recorded in `drift.md`. +- Drift: supervisor route override, stale overlay read paths, and resolved first-canary credential + inheritance recorded in `drift.md`. - Debt: none. ## Commits -- See the draft PR's commit list + per-slice PR comments. +- `b0be3673e57cfcd70388f5dffb2080799017356a` — harness bootstrap / draft-PR seed. +- See the draft PR's commit list + per-slice PR comments for subsequent sign-off commits. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md index ad44a66275..8483a435e6 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md @@ -25,3 +25,59 @@ Drift is append-only. - **Severity:** minor - **Action:** accept - **Evidence:** `rg --files` produced no matching paths. + +## 2026-08-03 — Evaluator credential not inherited by first canary + +- **What:** The first canonical Qwen live provider canary returned `auth_required` because + `OPENROUTER_API_KEY` was not exported into the invoking shell. +- **Source:** + `deno task agentic:provider-canary --live --profile claude-openrouter --model + qwen/qwen3.7-max --effort high --worktree /home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs`. +- **Expected:** The canonical evaluator route has a credential in its isolated child environment. +- **Actual:** The documented `$HOME/.config/netscript-agentic/openrouter.env` file exists, but the + provider canary does not auto-load it (the OpenCode launcher does). No secret was read into logs. +- **Severity:** minor unless the documented parser-backed retry fails. +- **Action:** retry once using the repository's `parseOpenRouterApiKey()` and child-environment + policy; if it does not pass, block before implementation and request owner action. +- **Evidence:** structured canary diagnostic `auth_required`; file-presence check only. + +## 2026-08-03 — Evaluator credential route resolved + +- **What:** The parser-backed retry passed on the exact canonical formal-evaluator route. +- **Source:** The documented `parseOpenRouterApiKey()` loaded only the named assignment into the + isolated provider-canary child; no credential value was logged or written to the run. +- **Expected:** Qwen 3.7 Max at high effort reports an available credential and live agentic + capabilities before PLAN-EVAL. +- **Actual:** `status=passed`; tools, reasoning, and streaming all `supported`; exit code 0. +- **Severity:** resolved. +- **Action:** proceed to a separate local PLAN-EVAL session on the same canonical route. +- **Evidence:** structured provider-canary result in the supervisor turn; no secret-bearing output. + +## 2026-08-03 — Formal evaluator attempted a closed default child model + +- **What:** The first full Qwen PLAN-EVAL retry attempted to delegate through the Claude CLI's + default `claude-opus-5` child model. +- **Source:** Formal-evaluator request-guard audit event; the top-level route remained Qwen 3.7 Max. +- **Expected:** Every model-bearing request in the evaluator turn uses an approved open model. +- **Actual:** The loopback guard denied the child request before it reached OpenRouter, terminated + the evaluator with exit 78, and no `plan-eval.md` was written. +- **Severity:** minor prompt-routing drift; no policy or cost breach occurred. +- **Action:** add an explicit no-Agent/no-subagent constraint to the evaluator brief and retry in a + fresh top-level Qwen session. Do not weaken the guard or widen the model allowlist. +- **Evidence:** credential-blind audit event under `.llm/tmp/agentic/evaluator-policy/` naming only + the denied model, requesting session, and timestamp. + +## 2026-08-03 — Generic evaluator adapter bound too short + +- **What:** The repository's generic Claude/Codex process adapter uses a 30-second timeout, which + expired before a full plan evaluator could read the required files and write an atomic verdict. +- **Source:** `AGENT_COMMAND_TIMEOUT_MS = 30_000` in the agentic adapter and the first full-turn + `timeout` diagnostic. +- **Expected:** A bounded formal evaluator turn completes and writes `plan-eval.md`. +- **Actual:** No partial artifact was written at 30 seconds. A fresh session using the same planned + command, isolated environment, Qwen model, high effort, and model guard completed in under the + supervisor's 240-second bound and wrote PASS. +- **Severity:** minor orchestration drift; provider and evaluation policy were unchanged. +- **Action:** accept for this proof run and retain both failed-attempt evidence and the successful + separate-session verdict. Do not modify agentic runtime product code in this slice. +- **Evidence:** first outcome `timedOut=true`; successful retry outcome exit 0; `plan-eval.md`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/implement.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/implement.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..537d54ff9f --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/implement.md @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +# Implementation Prompt: OMB wave-0 proofs + +use harness + +## SKILL + +Read and follow `.agents/skills/netscript-harness`, `.agents/skills/netscript-pr`, +`.agents/skills/netscript-cli`, `.agents/skills/netscript-doctrine`, +`.agents/skills/netscript-tools`, `.agents/skills/rtk`, and `.agents/skills/aspire` before acting. + +## Required Reading + +1. `supervisor.md`, `research.md`, `plan.md`, `plan-eval.md`, `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, and + `drift.md` in this run. +2. RFC #1123 §4 Wave 0 and §9 in `.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md`. +3. Full issue bodies #1127, #1128, and #1129. +4. Harness run-loop, service overlay, runtime gates, evaluator definitions, and lane policy. + +## Assignment + +Execute only the approved S1–S3 proof experiments in order after `plan-eval.md` says `PASS`. Create +draft experiment/evidence/verdict files but do not commit, push, edit GitHub, or change +product/template source. Run no more than one AppHost at a time. Never stop a foreign resource or +any `aspire mcp start` process. Treat every skipped, incomplete, or missing proof as FAIL. + +After each slice, update the run worklog/context and stop for the supervisor's separate Fable review +and sign-off. If the plan requires a product change, a lock/cache mutation, concurrent AppHosts, or +weaker evidence, write drift and return `FAIL_RESCOPE` without making that change. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan-eval.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan-eval.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9e4dee3910 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan-eval.md @@ -0,0 +1,88 @@ +# PLAN-EVAL — test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0 + +- Plan evaluator session: Qwen 3.7 Max / high · OpenRouter via `claude-openrouter` / `claude-print` + · 2026-08-03 (third attempt; no subagent delegation) +- Run: `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` +- Surface / archetype: N/A — proof/measurement slice; no published-surface change +- Scope overlays: service + +## Checklist results + +| Plan-Gate item | Result | Evidence / location | +| --------------------------------------- | ------ | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Research present and current | PASS | `research.md` re-baselines against `origin/main` @ `fb75cf6fc`; finding 7 (MCP `maxItems=50`, `maxStringLength=2000`) re-verified at `packages/mcp/src/application/runner/truncation.ts:10`; finding 6 (auth fixture with 401/403/200) re-verified at `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts`; finding 4 (AppHost template pre-allocation helper body) re-verified at `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/aspire/helpers/apphost.ts.template`; finding 1 (branch parity `0 0`) re-verified with `git rev-list --left-right --count HEAD...origin/main` | +| Decisions locked | PASS | D1–D12 each state rationale; cover verdict paths (D1), experiment/evidence location (D2), serialized scaffolds (D3), P1 method and PASS bar (D4–D5), F1 arbitration rule (D6), P2 measurement schema (D7), P2 truncation comparison (D8), P3 re-run and ratified wording (D9), normalization (D10), separation of concerns (D11), and rescope rule (D12) | +| Open-decision sweep | PASS | Three "must resolve now" items (P1/P2/P3 empirical values) are proof outputs, not design decisions; three "safe to defer" items (production manifest S7/#1133, MCP redesign Wave 1+, authenticated-spec Wave 4) cannot force proof-artifact rework; evaluator independently found no additional deferred decision that would require rework | +| Commit slices (< 30, gate + files each) | PASS | 5 slices (S0–S4); each names proving gate and files in the worklog commit-slices table; well under the 30-slice cap | +| Risk register | PASS | 11 risks with mitigations covering shared-host foreign resources, descendant-process survival, callback-race partial manifests, host normalization (localhost/IPv4/IPv6/wildcard), lock/source churn, P2 measurement unit accuracy, local-deref loops, error-envelope inference from one template, skipped-command false green, P3 wording overpromising, and evaluator credential route | +| Gate set selected | PASS | N/A archetype correctly selected; service overlay's 5 additional gates (contract check, service check, runtime health, trace/log review, consumer check) mapped in the fitness-gates table with correct NOT_RUN status; release gate correctly marked N/A (no scaffold/template product change; user explicitly prohibits `deno task e2e:cli`); static-gate validation plan lists 12 ordered verification steps | +| Deferred scope explicit | PASS | Plan "Non-Scope" enumerates production endpoint discovery, MCP server, auth policy change, truncation redesign, `e2e:cli`, and foreign-resource mutation; worklog "Deferred Scope" maps each to S7/#1133, Wave 1+, Wave 4, or separate product work | +| jsr-audit surface scan (pkg/plugin) | N/A | `research.md` §jsr-audit: "This run does not change a package/plugin export, dependency, README, or publish surface." Correct for a proof-only slice; plan archetype and non-scope confirm | + +## Open-decision sweep (evaluator-run) + +None. The plan's locked decisions D4–D9 fix every measurement method, pass/fail bar, and verdict +rule for all three proofs. The three empirical values (post-allocation callback behavior, spec sizes +and keyword subsets, auth-guarded response envelopes) are proof _outputs_ that the proofs themselves +resolve — they are not deferred design choices. The three deferred items (production +manifest/template at S7/#1133, MCP projection/truncation redesign at Wave 1+, authenticated-spec +support at Wave 4) are downstream of the proof verdicts and cannot force proof-artifact rework. I +found no additional open decision that would require rework if deferred. + +## Verdict + +`PASS` + +## Notes + +### Load-bearing research re-verification + +1. **Finding 7 (MCP truncation constants):** `truncation.ts:10` reads + `DEFAULT_TRUNCATION_POLICY: TruncationPolicy = { maxItems: 50, maxStringLength: 2000 }`. Plan D8 + correctly compares P2 measurements against these exact current bounds and explicitly reports that + there is no whole-result byte ceiling. + +2. **Finding 4 (AppHost template pre-allocation):** The `apphost.ts.template` shows + `await createNetScriptAppHost(builder, '{{configPath}}'); await builder.build().run();` — + resource registration happens inside the helper call, before `run()`. Helper-body endpoint reads + are indeed pre-allocation. P1's test of `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` + + `EndpointReference.getValueAsync()` is the correct post-allocation seam to evaluate. + +3. **RFC §4 (skip-as-fail rule):** Line 260: "a skipped proof must be indistinguishable from a + failed one, not from a passed one." Plan hidden scope and D6 both implement this correctly: + `NOT_RUN`, missing evidence, or skipped execution maps to FAIL; P1 FAIL selects F1(b). + +4. **RFC §9 (F1 proof-arbitrated fork):** Lines 367–379: option (a) stands only if P1's committed + verdict demonstrates the post-allocation seam; a FAIL verdict legitimately selects (b). Plan D6 + correctly encodes: "P1 PASS selects F1(a); P1 FAIL, including skipped or incomplete execution, + selects F1(b)." + +### Evaluator preflight history + +- First canary: `auth_required` (credential not inherited to shell). Resolved via parser-backed + retry using `parseOpenRouterApiKey()` with isolated child environment. +- Second attempt (Qwen PLAN-EVAL): model guard denied default child `claude-opus-5` (exit 78); no + closed request reached OpenRouter. Brief tightened to require single-session evaluation without + subagent delegation. +- This session: no Agent/Task tool invocation; all reads and checklist steps performed inline. + +### Service overlay additional-read gap + +`SCOPE-service.md` references `.claude/04-services.md` and `.claude/06-infrastructure.md`, which do +not exist on this branch. This is correctly recorded as drift in `drift.md` (2026-08-03 — Service +overlay read paths absent) with accepted severity and the corrective action of using focused +package/service/Aspire source and official Aspire docs instead. Not a plan defect. + +### Shared-host constraint + +The plan's risk register and mitigations correctly account for two foreign AppHosts and six foreign +containers inventoried at bootstrap. D3 serializes owned scaffolds (SQLite first, no-DB second, +never concurrent). The leak reporter is invoked with the exact run/worktree and owned scratch root. +No plan step mutates a foreign resource. + +### Doctrine debt delta + +No new architecture debt is expected from a proof-only slice. The plan correctly states that any +required product change discovered during proofs is a `FAIL_RESCOPE` to S7/#1133, not a debt entry +in this run. Consistent with the debt registry's current open entries (none of which this run +touches or deepens). diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan.md index bcac2b92e4..f016bdbd48 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/plan.md @@ -2,15 +2,180 @@ ## Run Metadata -| Field | Value | -| --- | --- | -| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | -| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | -| Phase | `research` | -| Target | Wave-0 proof / measurement artifacts for #1127–#1129 | -| Archetype | N/A — no published-surface change | -| Scope overlays | service | - -The locked plan is intentionally pending completion of focused source/API research. No experiment -implementation may begin until this file and the Design checkpoint are complete and a separate -PLAN-EVAL writes `PASS` to `plan-eval.md`. +| Field | Value | +| -------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | +| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | +| Phase | `implementation` | +| Target | Wave-0 proof / measurement artifacts for #1127–#1129 | +| Archetype | N/A — no published-surface change | +| Scope overlays | service | + +## Archetype + +N/A. This is a proof/measurement slice. It exercises generated CLI/service/Aspire output but owns +only committed run artifacts and the RFC decision record. Any required product or published-surface +change is a rescope to S7 (#1133) or another later wave. + +## Current Doctrine Verdict + +Read-only context: `@netscript/aspire` is Archetype 2 / Keep, `@netscript/service` is Archetype 4 / +Refactor, and `@netscript/cli` is Archetype 6 / Restructure. This PR does not remediate or widen any +of those surfaces. + +## Axioms in Play + +| Axiom | Why it matters | +| ----- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| A1 | The proof records the endpoint manifest and discovery/error shapes before productization. | +| A6 | Disposable measurement helpers must have one explicit experimental purpose. | +| A7 | The experiment uses `fetch`, `URL`, Web Crypto, and atomic Deno file operations directly. | +| A13 | A missing spec and an unavailable lifecycle seam are explicit failures, not silent fallbacks. | +| A14 | Measured runtime evidence, not plausible source inspection, determines each verdict. | + +## Goal + +Produce three empirical, committed Wave-0 verdicts at the RFC-authoritative paths: +`proofs/P1-verdict.md`, `proofs/P2-verdict.md`, and `proofs/P3-verdict.md` inside this run. P1 must +select F1(a) or F1(b); P2 must quantify the real DB and no-DB scaffold surfaces against current MCP +truncation; P3 must ratify the exact `spec_unavailable` wording from a real auth-guarded fixture. + +## Scope + +- Scaffold two local-source scratch applications: one SQLite-backed, one `--db none`. +- Run at most one owned AppHost at a time and collect endpoint/spec/log evidence. +- Commit narrowly scoped experiment programs and normalized, credential-free evidence under + `proofs/experiments/` and `proofs/evidence/`. +- Commit P1/P2/P3 verdicts, including an explicit FAIL when evidence does not meet a proof bar. +- Update the seed RFC's §9 F1 record and GitHub RFC #1123 plus epic #1126 after P1 arbitrates F1. +- Maintain harness, draft-PR, review, and evaluator evidence for every slice. + +## Non-Scope + +- No changes under `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, generated templates, or published exports. +- No production endpoint-discovery implementation, MCP server, auth policy change, or truncation + redesign; those belong to #1133 and later RFC waves. +- No `deno task e2e:cli`; merge-readiness is the orchestrator's decision. +- No mutation of foreign AppHosts, containers, ports, worktrees, caches, or lock files. + +## Hidden Scope + +- Normalize endpoint identity against both Aspire's allocated-endpoint view and a successful live + HTTP request; a plausible callback without those checks cannot pass P1. +- Measure both the discovery row and each schema-view payload, including source and locally + dereferenced representations, because the current MCP truncator has per-array/per-string limits + but no whole-result byte cap. +- Inspect operation-level non-success responses and component schemas rather than treating one + example error as proof of a common envelope. +- Verify process-tree death and ownership after every AppHost; exit-code success alone is not stop + evidence. +- Treat `NOT_RUN`, missing evidence, or a skipped branch as FAIL in a proof verdict and in + summaries. + +## Locked Decisions + +| ID | Decision | Rationale | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| D1 | The authoritative verdict paths are `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P{1,2,3}-verdict.md`. | RFC §4 places proof artifacts in the implementing run. | +| D2 | Supporting committed material lives only below that run's `proofs/experiments/` and `proofs/evidence/`; disposable scaffolds live below `.llm/tmp/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs/`. | Keeps proof logic auditable without leaking experiment code into product templates. | +| D3 | Use a local-source SQLite scaffold for P1/P2, stop it with verified process-tree death, then use a local-source no-DB scaffold for P2. Never run both AppHosts concurrently. | Covers both required P2 shapes and respects shared-host ownership. | +| D4 | P1 tests `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` and awaits `EndpointReference.getValueAsync()` for every generated service. It writes an atomic temp-then-rename manifest with schema version, real project root, per-run UUID, timestamp, service identity, and allocated URL. | This is the documented post-allocation seam and the RFC identity-binding contract. | +| D5 | P1 PASS requires the committed manifest to agree with the same owned run's Aspire description and successful live request, with non-zero allocated ports and complete service identity. Otherwise P1 is explicit FAIL. | Source availability is not lifecycle proof. | +| D6 | P1 PASS selects F1(a); P1 FAIL, including skipped or incomplete execution, selects F1(b). The selected outcome is written to the verdict, local RFC §9, RFC issue #1123, and epic #1126. | Implements RFC §9's proof-arbitrated fork without a false-green state. | +| D7 | P2 records total live-spec bytes; operationId values/shapes; discovery-row bytes; each request, response, error, and all-schema view's source and dereferenced bytes; non-2xx response schemas/envelopes; and recursively observed OpenAPI/JSON-Schema keywords for both scaffolds. | Directly answers #1128 and exposes both per-item truncation and aggregate-size risk. | +| D8 | P2 compares arrays and strings to the current `maxItems=50` and `maxStringLength=2000` implementation and explicitly reports that there is no whole-result byte ceiling. | Avoids implying protection the runner does not provide. | +| D9 | P3 reruns the existing auth fixture and records the observed 401, 403, and 200 envelopes. The ratified text is: `spec_unavailable: OpenAPI document could not be fetched. The spec route may require authentication; allow anonymous access to the OpenAPI route (for NetScript auth, add /api/openapi.json to auth.authn.allowAnonymous) or provide a reachable public spec URL.` | Names both the likely cause and the concrete NetScript corrective exemption without changing auth behavior. | +| D10 | All raw evidence is normalized to omit credentials, absolute foreign paths, and volatile process noise; verdicts cite commands, timestamps, versions, and evidence paths. | Makes results reproducible and safe to commit. | +| D11 | A separate Codex implementation thread executes slices; a separate Fable review checks each slice; this supervisor alone signs, commits, pushes, and comments. Formal PLAN/IMPL evaluation uses separate Qwen sessions. | Preserves harness generator/reviewer/evaluator separation. | +| D12 | Product changes, failed scaffolding caused by product defects, or a need to relax the evidence bar trigger `FAIL_RESCOPE`; they are not repaired inside this PR. | The user explicitly bounded this to proof/measurement work. | + +## Open-Decision Sweep + +| Decision | Status | Notes | +| -------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Whether the real allocation callback satisfies P1 | must resolve now by P1 | The result is deliberately not pre-decided; the locked pass/fail bar removes implementation ambiguity. | +| Exact operation/schema sizes and observed keyword subset | must resolve now by P2 | The committed measurement schema is locked; values come only from live scaffold specs. | +| Exact current auth-guarded responses | must resolve now by P3 | Expected 401/403/200 shapes are re-measured rather than copied from source. | +| Production manifest/template implementation | safe to defer | S7 (#1133), after F1 arbitration. | +| MCP row/schema projection and truncation redesign | safe to defer | Wave 1+ RFC implementation issues. | +| Production authenticated-spec support | safe to defer | Wave 4 after the P3 wording is ratified. | + +All decisions that would change these proof artifacts or force experimental rework are resolved by +D1–D12. The three empirical values remain proof outputs, not deferred design choices. + +## Risk Register + +| Risk | Mitigation | +| ----------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Shared host contains foreign Aspire/container resources. | Inventory first; use explicit owned paths/PIDs; never stop by name/pattern; run leak reporter with the exact run/worktree and owned scratch root. | +| Aspire stop reports success while descendants live. | Capture the owned process tree, request exact-target stop, and prove every owned PID/port is gone before the next scaffold. | +| Per-resource callbacks race and publish a partial manifest. | Closure tracks the full expected service set; write only after all allocated endpoint values resolve; atomic rename the complete sorted payload. | +| Allocated hosts differ (`localhost`, IPv4, IPv6, wildcard). | Compare normalized URLs/ports and separately prove a live request; preserve raw allocated URLs in evidence. | +| Scaffold or Aspire commands create lock/source churn. | Snapshot status and `deno.lock`; use documented CLI flags; reject/restore only slice-owned scratch, never mutate caches or lock files. | +| P2 measurement accidentally counts presentation formatting. | Define UTF-8 byte length of canonical compact JSON for every measured object/string and record the measurement tool version. | +| Local dereferencing loops or crosses external `$ref`s. | Resolve only local document refs with cycle detection; report unresolved/external refs rather than fetching them. | +| Error-envelope presence is inferred from one template. | Enumerate every operation's non-2xx responses for both DB and no-DB specs and report absent as well as present. | +| A skipped command is summarized as success. | Verdict schema permits only PASS/FAIL; `NOT_RUN`, incomplete, timeout, or missing evidence maps to FAIL. | +| P3 wording overpromises a universal fix. | Name NetScript's exact exemption as a parenthetical and retain the generic public/reachable alternative. | +| Formal evaluator route lacks inherited credentials. | Use only the documented `$HOME/.config/netscript-agentic/openrouter.env` assignment parser to populate the isolated child environment; if live canary still fails, stop and record blocked drift. | + +## Anti-Patterns to Resolve or Avoid + +| AP | Status | Plan | +| ------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| AP-1 / large files | risk | Keep each experiment single-purpose and review size; no product file changes. | +| AP-2 / generic helpers | risk | Name experiments by proof and use platform primitives directly. | +| AP-10 / swallowed errors | risk | Record command exit, timeout, missing evidence, and runtime response as explicit FAIL conditions. | +| AP-20 / hidden runtime coupling | risk | Bind endpoint evidence to real project root, run UUID, resource identity, and allocated port. | + +## Fitness Gates + +The archetype F-* matrix is N/A because no package/plugin source or published surface changes. The +service overlay still requires the following manual/runtime fitness evidence. + +| Gate | Required | Expected evidence | +| ---------------------- | -------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Contract check | yes | P2 measurement validates each live OpenAPI document and records malformed/unresolved refs. | +| Service check | yes | Scoped Deno check/lint/fmt for committed experiment TypeScript. | +| Runtime health | yes | Owned Aspire resource status, allocated endpoint, HTTP response, and verified teardown evidence. | +| Trace/log review | yes | Owned AppHost/service logs checked for startup/request failures and hidden retries. | +| Consumer check | yes | The generated live spec is fetched and projected by the committed measurement experiment. | +| Release gate / CLI E2E | no | No scaffold/template product change; user explicitly prohibits `deno task e2e:cli`. | + +## Arch-Debt Implications + +| Entry | Action | Notes | +| -------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| `.llm/harness/debt/arch-debt.md` | none | Measurement work creates no doctrine debt; product defects cause rescope. | + +## Validation Plan + +| Order | Gate | Command or check | Expected result | +| ----- | ---------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 1 | Plan-Gate | Separate Qwen PLAN-EVAL using `claude-openrouter` / `claude-print` | `plan-eval.md` says `PASS` before any experiment file exists. | +| 2 | P1 runtime | Serialized owned SQLite scaffold/AppHost; callback manifest; Aspire description; live fetch; logs | Verdict PASS/F1(a) or evidence-backed FAIL/F1(b); never NOT_RUN-as-pass. | +| 3 | P1 hygiene | Exact owned process/port teardown check | No owned descendants/listeners remain; foreign resources unchanged. | +| 4 | P2 measurement | `deno run --no-lock --allow-read --allow-net /proofs/experiments/p2-measure-spec.ts ...` against each owned live spec | Stable JSON evidence for DB and no-DB operation/schema/error/keyword measurements. | +| 5 | P3 fixture | Targeted existing auth test filter in `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` | Observed 401/403/200 behavior matches committed evidence or verdict explicitly FAILs. | +| 6 | Static check | `deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root /proofs --ext ts,tsx` | PASS for touched experiment source. | +| 7 | Static lint | `deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts --root /proofs --ext ts,tsx` | PASS; no new lint ignores. | +| 8 | Static format | `deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root --ext ts,tsx,md` | PASS for owned run artifacts. | +| 9 | Lock/status | Raw `git diff --exit-code origin/main -- deno.lock` plus owned-path diff review | No `deno.lock`, package, plugin, or unrelated churn. | +| 10 | Resource hygiene | `deno task agentic:leak-check -- --slice-dir --worktree --owned-root ` | No unreviewed owned leaks; foreign entries remain untouched. | +| 11 | Slice review | Separate Fable review after every proof slice | No unanswered blocking finding before supervisor sign-off commit. | +| 12 | IMPL-EVAL | Separate new Qwen session follows evaluator protocol | `evaluate.md` supplies a merge-eligible harness verdict. | + +## Dependencies + +- Deno 2.9.3, .NET SDK 10.0.110, Aspire CLI 13.4.6, Docker, current local-source NetScript CLI. +- Existing foreign resources are an environmental constraint, not a dependency. +- GitHub issue/RFC/epic edits occur only after corresponding committed evidence exists. + +## Drift Watch + +- Aspire callback signature or allocated endpoint value differs from current documentation. +- Scaffold layout, operationId convention, schema/error shape, or truncation constants differ from + the re-baseline. +- Any proof needs product source changes or a second concurrent AppHost. +- Any planned gate cannot run, is skipped, or leaves owned resources alive. +- Formal evaluator/provider/reviewer lane is unavailable or differs from `supervisor.md`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/research.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/research.md index 7a79e17c59..a199b43f6e 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/research.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/research.md @@ -14,25 +14,26 @@ ## Findings -| # | Finding | How to verify | -| --- | --- | --- | -| 1 | Branch and `origin/main` are the same clean baseline; the proof branch did not exist remotely at bootstrap. | `git rev-list --left-right --count HEAD...origin/main` → `0 0`; `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` → empty | -| 2 | RFC §4 requires committed `proofs/P-verdict.md` files in the implementing run and defines skipped as non-pass. | `.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md:256` | -| 3 | RFC §9 leaves F1 to P1: PASS selects (a); an explicit FAIL legitimately selects (b). | `.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md:367` | -| 4 | Current generated AppHost code registers resources before `builder.build().run()`, so helper-body endpoint reads remain pre-allocation. | `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/aspire/helpers/apphost.ts.template`; `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/generated/aspire/helpers/generate-index-1.ts.template` | -| 5 | Aspire 13.4 documents and generates a TypeScript resource callback at the exact allocation event, with an endpoint API that can await a concrete URL. | `aspire docs get apphost-eventing-apis`; generated SDK `onResourceEndpointsAllocated`, `EndpointReference.getValueAsync()` | -| 6 | Existing service behavior already supplies a precise P3 fixture shape: unauthenticated spec fetch → 401, wrong scope → 403, correct scope → 200. The proof must rerun and ratify wording rather than infer. | `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` | -| 7 | MCP central truncation currently caps arrays at 50 and strings at 2,000 characters; P2 must report measurements against those exact current bounds. | `packages/mcp/src/application/runner/truncation.ts` | -| 8 | The no-database scaffold contract is built from bare `oc`, so common error-family presence cannot be assumed. | `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/contract.memory.ts.template`; canonical design `03-projection-and-naming.md` §3 | -| 9 | The host is shared: two foreign AppHosts and six foreign containers were already running before this slice. They are out of scope and must not be stopped or mutated. | `aspire ps --format json`; `docker ps` captured 2026-08-03 | -| 10 | The task changes only run artifacts / experiment evidence and the ratified RFC record; no `packages/**` or `plugins/**` public surface is owned. | User slice contract; clean baseline | +| # | Finding | How to verify | +| -- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 1 | Branch and `origin/main` are the same clean baseline; the proof branch did not exist remotely at bootstrap. | `git rev-list --left-right --count HEAD...origin/main` → `0 0`; `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` → empty | +| 2 | RFC §4 requires committed `proofs/P-verdict.md` files in the implementing run and defines skipped as non-pass. | `.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md:256` | +| 3 | RFC §9 leaves F1 to P1: PASS selects (a); an explicit FAIL legitimately selects (b). | `.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md:367` | +| 4 | Current generated AppHost code registers resources before `builder.build().run()`, so helper-body endpoint reads remain pre-allocation. | `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/aspire/helpers/apphost.ts.template`; `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/generated/aspire/helpers/generate-index-1.ts.template` | +| 5 | Aspire 13.4 documents and generates a TypeScript resource callback at the exact allocation event, with an endpoint API that can await a concrete URL. | `aspire docs get apphost-eventing-apis`; generated SDK `onResourceEndpointsAllocated`, `EndpointReference.getValueAsync()` | +| 6 | Existing service behavior already supplies a precise P3 fixture shape: unauthenticated spec fetch → 401, wrong scope → 403, correct scope → 200. The proof must rerun and ratify wording rather than infer. | `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` | +| 7 | MCP central truncation currently caps arrays at 50 and strings at 2,000 characters; P2 must report measurements against those exact current bounds. | `packages/mcp/src/application/runner/truncation.ts` | +| 8 | The no-database scaffold contract is built from bare `oc`, so common error-family presence cannot be assumed. | `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/contract.memory.ts.template`; canonical design `03-projection-and-naming.md` §3 | +| 9 | The host is shared: two foreign AppHosts and six foreign containers were already running before this slice. They are out of scope and must not be stopped or mutated. | `aspire ps --format json`; `docker ps` captured 2026-08-03 | +| 10 | The task changes only run artifacts / experiment evidence and the ratified RFC record; no `packages/**` or `plugins/**` public surface is owned. | User slice contract; clean baseline | ## Doctrine / scope classification - Archetype: N/A — proof/measurement slice; no published package or plugin surface changes. - Overlay: `SCOPE-service.md` because measurements exercise generated services and Aspire runtime. -- Current relevant doctrine verdicts are read-only context: `@netscript/aspire` is Archetype 2 / Keep; - `@netscript/service` is Archetype 4 / Refactor; `@netscript/cli` is Archetype 6 / Restructure. +- Current relevant doctrine verdicts are read-only context: `@netscript/aspire` is Archetype 2 / + Keep; `@netscript/service` is Archetype 4 / Refactor; `@netscript/cli` is Archetype 6 / + Restructure. - Doctrine debt delta: none expected; any required product change is a rescope and belongs to S7 (#1133), not this proof PR. @@ -48,3 +49,6 @@ including the no-DB template, and which JSON Schema/OpenAPI keywords actually occur? - P3: what exact 401/403 response envelope is observed on the current branch, and what concise `spec_unavailable` text names both likely cause and corrective exemption? + +These are empirical proof outputs, not unresolved design decisions. `plan.md` D4–D9 lock the +measurement and verdict rules that will resolve them after PLAN-EVAL. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/supervisor.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/supervisor.md index 4271216e77..fed78b74c2 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/supervisor.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/supervisor.md @@ -2,25 +2,25 @@ Written at run start per `workflow/lane-policy.md` § Supervisor identity. -| Field | Value | -| --- | --- | -| Model | Codex GPT-5 root session (exact product model id is not exposed to the workspace) | -| Session | `/root` API session; no external session URL exposed | -| Host | `YogaBook9i` · Linux/WSL · user `codex` | -| Checkout | `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs` | -| Worktree | `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs` | -| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | -| Baseline | `fb75cf6fc5ad02130ada0ac42e6f44035ac03a9b` · `origin/main` · 2026-08-03 | -| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | +| Field | Value | +| -------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Model | Codex GPT-5 root session (exact product model id is not exposed to the workspace) | +| Session | `/root` API session; no external session URL exposed | +| Host | `YogaBook9i` · Linux/WSL · user `codex` | +| Checkout | `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs` | +| Worktree | `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs` | +| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | +| Baseline | `fb75cf6fc5ad02130ada0ac42e6f44035ac03a9b` · `origin/main` · 2026-08-03 | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | ## Routes in force -| Task lane | Provider / model / effort | Role in this run | -| --- | --- | --- | -| `planning_decisions` | OpenAI / current Codex root session / high-equivalent | User-addressed implementation supervisor; research, orchestration, and sign-off commits | -| `normal_implementation` | OpenAI / `gpt-5.6-sol` / medium | Separate daemon-attached Codex implementation thread; experiment execution and draft artifacts only | -| `review_codex` | Anthropic / `fable-5` / low | Opposite-family substantive slice review before supervisor sign-off commits | -| `formal_evaluation` | OpenRouter / `qwen/qwen3.7-max` / high | Separate local PLAN-EVAL and IMPL-EVAL sessions through `claude-openrouter` / `claude-print` | +| Task lane | Provider / model / effort | Role in this run | +| ----------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| `planning_decisions` | OpenAI / current Codex root session / high-equivalent | User-addressed implementation supervisor; research, orchestration, and sign-off commits | +| `normal_implementation` | OpenAI / `gpt-5.6-sol` / medium | Separate daemon-attached Codex implementation thread; experiment execution and draft artifacts only | +| `review_codex` | Anthropic / `fable-5` / low | Opposite-family substantive slice review before supervisor sign-off commits | +| `formal_evaluation` | OpenRouter / `qwen/qwen3.7-max` / high | Separate local PLAN-EVAL and IMPL-EVAL sessions through `claude-openrouter` / `claude-print` | ## Recorded lane/eval overrides diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md index 47b6ea68bd..8d342212f0 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -2,25 +2,147 @@ ## Run Metadata -| Field | Value | -| --- | --- | -| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | -| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | -| Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | -| Scope overlays | service | +| Field | Value | +| -------------- | -------------------------------------- | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | +| Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | +| Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | +| Scope overlays | service | ## Design -Design checkpoint pending. It will be completed before PLAN-EVAL and before any experiment file or -verdict artifact is created. +### Public Surface + +- `proofs/P1-verdict.md` — empirical Aspire lifecycle verdict and F1(a)/(b) arbitration. +- `proofs/P2-verdict.md` — empirical DB/no-DB spec fidelity and truncation-budget verdict. +- `proofs/P3-verdict.md` — empirical auth-guarded spec verdict and ratified wording. +- RFC #1123 §9 and epic #1126 — decision records updated only from the committed P1 outcome. +- No package, plugin, template, service, or CLI export changes. + +### Domain Vocabulary + +- `ProofStatus` — exactly `PASS` or `FAIL`; incomplete and skipped executions are FAIL. +- `F1Outcome` — exactly `(a)` post-allocation callback or `(b)` Aspire CLI discovery. +- `EndpointManifest` — schema version, real project root, run UUID, timestamp, and sorted service + identity/allocated-URL entries. +- `P2Measurement` — compact-JSON byte counts, operationId observations, schema views, errors, refs, + and keyword subset for one live scaffold spec. +- `SpecUnavailableEnvelope` — ratified MCP-facing text for an OpenAPI document blocked by auth or + otherwise unreachable. + +### Ports + +- Aspire `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` event — existing lifecycle boundary tested by P1. +- `EndpointReference.getValueAsync()` — existing allocated-value boundary tested by P1. +- Live `/api/openapi.json` HTTP route — runtime evidence boundary for P1/P2/P3. +- Existing auth fixture in `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` — P3 behavior + boundary; it is executed, not edited. +- GitHub RFC/epic issue bodies — external decision record updated after local P1 evidence commits. + +### Constants + +- Verdict files: `P1-verdict.md`, `P2-verdict.md`, `P3-verdict.md`. +- Experiment roots: `/proofs/{experiments,evidence}` and `.llm/tmp/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs/`. +- Current MCP limits: `maxItems=50`, `maxStringLength=2000`; whole-result bytes are unbounded. +- Default spec route: `/api/openapi.json`. +- Manifest path under the scratch app: `.netscript/run/endpoints.json`. + +### Commit Slices + +| # | Slice | Gate | Files | +| -- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| S0 | Lock plan/design and formal PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen `plan-eval.md=PASS`; format run Markdown | `plan.md`, `research.md`, `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `implement.md`, `briefs/plan-eval.md`, `plan-eval.md` | +| S1 | Prove/refute post-allocation endpoint manifest and arbitrate F1 | Owned Aspire status + manifest/describe/live-request agreement + log review + verified teardown; separate Fable review | `proofs/P1-verdict.md`, `proofs/experiments/p1-*`, `proofs/evidence/P1-*`, seed `rfc.md` §9, run logs/context | +| S2 | Measure DB and no-DB live spec fidelity/size | Measurement script check/lint/fmt + two normalized evidence files + schema/error/keyword completeness review + verified teardown; separate Fable review | `proofs/P2-verdict.md`, `proofs/experiments/p2-*`, `proofs/evidence/P2-*`, run logs/context | +| S3 | Prove auth-guarded spec behavior and ratify wording | Targeted existing auth test + response evidence + wording review; separate Fable review | `proofs/P3-verdict.md`, `proofs/evidence/P3-*`, run logs/context | +| S4 | Final hygiene and evaluation | Scoped wrappers, no lint ignores, lock/scope audit, leak check, review-thread gate, separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL | `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `evaluate.md`, PR metadata/comments | + +### Deferred Scope + +- Production lifecycle discovery/template implementation — S7 (#1133), after P1. +- MCP discovery/search/schema tools and bounded output implementation — later RFC Wave 1 slices. +- Production `spec_unavailable` emission/auth feature work — later RFC Wave 4 slices. +- Any service/CLI/Aspire doctrine remediation — separately scoped product work. + +### Contributor Path + +To reproduce a proof, create fresh local-source scratch scaffolds below the named `.llm/tmp/` root, +run only the matching experiment with one owned AppHost, normalize evidence into the committed JSON +shape, tear the complete owned process tree down, and update the verdict. Do not copy experiment +logic into a product template in this run. ## Progress Log -| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| ---------- | --------- | ------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | PR | Committed/pushed harness bootstrap and opened draft PR #1182 with required milestone/taxonomy; closing keywords remain withheld. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | design | Locked D1–D12, proof schemas, serialized runtime method, gate set, commit slices, and skip-as-FAIL rule. No experiment files created. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | First canonical live canary reported `auth_required` because the shell lacked an exported key. The documented OpenRouter env file is present; retry will use its assignment parser and isolated child environment without exposing the value. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | Parser-backed retry passed on Qwen 3.7 Max/high: credential available and tools/reasoning/streaming supported. No secret entered logs or files. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The model guard denied Qwen's attempted delegation to default child `claude-opus-5` (exit 78); no closed request reached OpenRouter and no verdict was written. Brief tightened to require single-session evaluation. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The generic agent adapter's 30-second bound expired before the first full evaluator turn could write an artifact. A fresh single-session retry used a 240-second orchestration bound without changing provider/model/guard policy. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | + +## Decisions + +| Decision | Reason | Source | +| ---------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- | +| Verdict artifacts live in this run | RFC explicitly names implementing-run `proofs/` | RFC #1123 §4 | +| P1 has no presumed outcome | FAIL is a valid proof result selecting F1(b) | RFC #1123 §9 / #1127 | +| Two scaffolds, serialized | P2 requires DB and no-DB; shared host forbids concurrent AppHosts | Plan D3 / user hazard | +| No product/template edits | Productization is S7 and public surface is excluded | User contract / doctrine boundary | +| Skip/incomplete means FAIL | Prevents false-green proof status | RFC #1123 §4 / user contract | + +## Drift + +| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | +| ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------- | ------------------ | +| User-addressed Codex supervisor route | minor | yes | +| Service overlay's two additional-read files absent | minor | yes | +| First evaluator canary did not inherit documented file credential | minor, resolved | yes | ## Gate Results -All implementation gates are `NOT_RUN`; the Plan-Gate is the current hard stop. +### Static Gates + +| Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | +| ------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ------- | ------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Plan artifact format | scoped run formatter | PASS | All owned run Markdown checked after PLAN-EVAL output. | +| Experiment check/lint/fmt | scoped wrappers under `/proofs` | NOT_RUN | No experiment source exists before Plan-Gate PASS. | +| No lint ignores | diff scan | NOT_RUN | Final slice. | +| Lock/scope audit | raw git diff vs `origin/main` | NOT_RUN | Final slice; `deno.lock` and product paths must be untouched. | + +### Fitness Gates + +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ---------------------- | ------- | ------------------------- | ---------------- | +| Archetype F-* | N/A | No package/plugin surface | Proof-only run. | +| Service contract check | NOT_RUN | P2 live spec evidence | After Plan-Gate. | +| Service runtime health | NOT_RUN | P1/P2 evidence | After Plan-Gate. | +| Trace/log review | NOT_RUN | P1/P2 evidence | After Plan-Gate. | +| Consumer check | NOT_RUN | P2 projector evidence | After Plan-Gate. | + +### Runtime Gates + +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ----------------------- | ------- | ---------------------- | ------------------------------------- | +| P1 lifecycle | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P1-*` | Hard-gated by PLAN-EVAL. | +| P2 DB/no-DB measurement | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | Hard-gated by PLAN-EVAL. | +| P3 auth fixture | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P3-*` | Hard-gated by PLAN-EVAL. | +| Resource leak check | NOT_RUN | final reporter output | Foreign baseline already inventoried. | + +### Consumer Gates + +| Consumer | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ----------------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------------------------------- | +| Generated DB scaffold spec | NOT_RUN | P2 evidence | Must be live, not source-inferred. | +| Generated no-DB scaffold spec | NOT_RUN | P2 evidence | Must be live, not source-inferred. | + +## Handoff Notes + +- PLAN-EVAL should first verify D4–D9 against RFC §4/§9 and ensure no empirical result is presumed. +- Spot-check research finding 5 against Aspire's documented event API and finding 6 against the + existing auth test. +- Implementation must not begin unless `plan-eval.md` contains a separate-session `PASS`. From 641ae63ba06f5d093908b9d43cde35d5339ff56b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2026 22:41:34 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 3/9] docs(harness): fix implementation brief activation --- .../drift.md | 12 ++++++++++ .../implement.md | 4 ++-- .../worklog.md | 23 ++++++++++--------- 3 files changed, 26 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-) diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md index 8483a435e6..3f7797bfdf 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md @@ -81,3 +81,15 @@ Drift is append-only. - **Action:** accept for this proof run and retain both failed-attempt evidence and the successful separate-session verdict. Do not modify agentic runtime product code in this slice. - **Evidence:** first outcome `timedOut=true`; successful retry outcome exit 0; `plan-eval.md`. + +## 2026-08-03 — Implementation brief activation line reordered + +- **What:** The committed implementation brief contained `use harness` after its Markdown title; the + agentic launcher requires that exact activation text on the first line. +- **Source:** `agentic:launch-codex-slice --dry-run` brief-contract validation. +- **Expected:** The launcher accepts the committed brief before any child turn is sent. +- **Actual:** Dry-run failed closed and launched nothing. +- **Severity:** minor. +- **Action:** move `use harness` to line 1 without changing assignment content; reformat, commit, + and repeat dry-run before live launch. +- **Evidence:** dry-run diagnostic `must begin with use harness`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/implement.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/implement.md index 537d54ff9f..40c94e2081 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/implement.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/implement.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ -# Implementation Prompt: OMB wave-0 proofs - use harness +# Implementation Prompt: OMB wave-0 proofs + ## SKILL Read and follow `.agents/skills/netscript-harness`, `.agents/skills/netscript-pr`, diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md index 8d342212f0..7a385f4aee 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -73,17 +73,18 @@ logic into a product template in this run. ## Progress Log -| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | -| ---------- | --------- | ------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | PR | Committed/pushed harness bootstrap and opened draft PR #1182 with required milestone/taxonomy; closing keywords remain withheld. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | design | Locked D1–D12, proof schemas, serialized runtime method, gate set, commit slices, and skip-as-FAIL rule. No experiment files created. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | First canonical live canary reported `auth_required` because the shell lacked an exported key. The documented OpenRouter env file is present; retry will use its assignment parser and isolated child environment without exposing the value. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | Parser-backed retry passed on Qwen 3.7 Max/high: credential available and tools/reasoning/streaming supported. No secret entered logs or files. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The model guard denied Qwen's attempted delegation to default child `claude-opus-5` (exit 78); no closed request reached OpenRouter and no verdict was written. Brief tightened to require single-session evaluation. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The generic agent adapter's 30-second bound expired before the first full evaluator turn could write an artifact. A fresh single-session retry used a 240-second orchestration bound without changing provider/model/guard policy. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| ---------- | --------- | ---------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | PR | Committed/pushed harness bootstrap and opened draft PR #1182 with required milestone/taxonomy; closing keywords remain withheld. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | design | Locked D1–D12, proof schemas, serialized runtime method, gate set, commit slices, and skip-as-FAIL rule. No experiment files created. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | First canonical live canary reported `auth_required` because the shell lacked an exported key. The documented OpenRouter env file is present; retry will use its assignment parser and isolated child environment without exposing the value. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | Parser-backed retry passed on Qwen 3.7 Max/high: credential available and tools/reasoning/streaming supported. No secret entered logs or files. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The model guard denied Qwen's attempted delegation to default child `claude-opus-5` (exit 78); no closed request reached OpenRouter and no verdict was written. Brief tightened to require single-session evaluation. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The generic agent adapter's 30-second bound expired before the first full evaluator turn could write an artifact. A fresh single-session retry used a 240-second orchestration bound without changing provider/model/guard policy. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | implementation handoff | Launcher dry-run failed closed because `use harness` followed the brief title instead of occupying line 1. Reordered the activation line; no implementation process was started. | ## Decisions From 7f62ff71d7c5246ab8d1c4c37a71601131efb03f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2026 22:44:54 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 4/9] chore(harness): record implementation lane --- .../codex-thread-ids.md | 24 +++++++++++++++++++ .../drift.md | 16 +++++++++++++ .../worklog.md | 1 + 3 files changed, 41 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/codex-thread-ids.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/codex-thread-ids.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/codex-thread-ids.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..6eecaecf1d --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/codex-thread-ids.md @@ -0,0 +1,24 @@ +# openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs-impl — Codex implementation thread + +- **Thread / session id:** `019fc95d-ce57-7893-98b3-36977bec0cf1` +- **Rollout:** + `/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/03/rollout-2026-08-03T22-43-16-019fc95d-ce57-7893-98b3-36977bec0cf1.jsonl` +- **Worktree:** `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl` +- **Branch:** `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs-impl` @ `641ae63ba` (NO upstream by design). +- **Push rule:** no push; the implementation brief forbids commit/push and the supervisor integrates + reviewed drafts into `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs`. +- **Requested route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=medium +- **Observed route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=medium +- **Route verdict:** matched +- **Runtime:** approval=never · sandbox=dangerFullAccess +- **Brief (staged):** `/home/codex/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs-impl-brief.md` + +## Steering (same thread — never a second sender at this worktree) + +```bash +deno task agentic:codex-resume --thread-id 019fc95d-ce57-7893-98b3-36977bec0cf1 \ + --message-file --worktree /home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl +``` + +Initial identity was written by `.llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts`; the supervisor +copied this credential-free route record into the PR worktree. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md index 3f7797bfdf..bfee143462 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md @@ -93,3 +93,19 @@ Drift is append-only. - **Action:** move `use harness` to line 1 without changing assignment content; reformat, commit, and repeat dry-run before live launch. - **Evidence:** dry-run diagnostic `must begin with use harness`. + +## 2026-08-03 — Separate implementation worktree required by sender ownership + +- **What:** The supervisor's API session is also the durable app-server sender for the provided PR + worktree, so the agentic suite refused a second implementation sender there. +- **Source:** `agentic:launch-codex-slice` returned `duplicate_sender_risk`; session metadata proved + the recorded owner was this user-addressed supervisor turn. +- **Expected:** PLAN-EVAL and implementation run in sessions separate from the supervisor without + violating one-sender-per-worktree. +- **Actual:** A local no-upstream implementation branch/worktree was created at the approved commit: + `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl`, `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs-impl`. The child may draft + only; it cannot commit, push, or edit GitHub. Supervisor integration remains on the PR branch. +- **Severity:** minor orchestration drift; role/model/effort and commit authority are unchanged. +- **Action:** accept; use only thread `019fc95d-ce57-7893-98b3-36977bec0cf1` at that worktree and + transfer reviewed drafts into the PR worktree with explicit scope checks. +- **Evidence:** `codex-thread-ids.md`; live launch observed provider/model/effort match. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md index 7a385f4aee..660ba219c9 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -85,6 +85,7 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The generic agent adapter's 30-second bound expired before the first full evaluator turn could write an artifact. A fresh single-session retry used a 240-second orchestration bound without changing provider/model/guard policy. | | 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | | 2026-08-03 | S0 | implementation handoff | Launcher dry-run failed closed because `use harness` followed the brief title instead of occupying line 1. Reordered the activation line; no implementation process was started. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | implementation launch | One tracked Codex `gpt-5.6-sol`/medium thread launched in a dedicated no-upstream worktree after one-sender safety rejected the supervisor-owned PR worktree. Child has draft-only authority and must stop after each slice. | ## Decisions From a9a28c4d1408b2e50b659c15d4bfe6b54f01045d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2026 23:13:57 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 5/9] test(openapi-mcp): record P1 lifecycle verdict --- .../runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md | 11 +- .../briefs/S1-fable-rereview.md | 27 ++++ .../briefs/S1-fable-review.md | 36 +++++ .../briefs/S1-review-fixes.md | 31 ++++ .../context-pack.md | 38 +++-- .../drift.md | 30 ++++ .../proofs/P1-verdict.md | 46 ++++++ .../proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md | 14 ++ .../proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json | 19 +++ .../proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json | 93 ++++++++++++ .../p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts | 136 +++++++++++++++++ .../reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md | 58 ++++++++ .../reviews/S1-fable.md | 139 ++++++++++++++++++ .../worklog.md | 37 +++-- 14 files changed, 686 insertions(+), 29 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-fable-rereview.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-fable-review.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-review-fixes.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P1-verdict.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/experiments/p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md b/.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md index 9a1c7012ce..7b87b64598 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md +++ b/.llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md @@ -374,6 +374,14 @@ legitimate result that activates option (b) (the `aspire-cli` source), not a blo verdict is the deciding artifact; #1131 and #1133 may not start before it exists. The original fork table is retained below as the decision record: +**P1 verdict (2026-08-03): `FAIL`; F1(b) selected for the current decision record.** The +post-allocation callback did emit a complete identity-bound manifest with the allocated +`http://localhost:3001` endpoint, so the seam itself was not refuted. The locked coherent-owned-run +bar failed because the generated SQLite service exited without `--allow-ffi`; a later HTTP 200 was +unattributed and could not establish manifest/description/health agreement. F1(b) is therefore the +first-class endpoint source now, while a future healthy owned-run proof may legitimately revisit F1. +Both mechanisms remain additive implementations of the same endpoint-source port. + | # | Fork | Options | Seed recommendation | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | F1 | Endpoint manifest mechanism | (a) generated run-mode **post-allocation** callback writes the run-state manifest (b) `aspire` CLI query adapter (c) MCP as Aspire-hosted HTTP resource | **(a), [P1]-arbitrated** — S-7 proved the naive helper-body write impossible, so (a) stands only if P1's artifact demonstrates the post-allocation seam; (b) is a first-class source in the same port contract otherwise; (c) rejected (no HTTP transport exists; port chicken-and-egg; `.mcp.json` churn) | @@ -388,4 +396,5 @@ fork table is retained below as the decision record: document condenses the run's normative record (`design/canonical/00–06` rev 2, `plan.md` rev 2, `design/examples/`). Where this RFC and the run docs conflict, the run docs win until ratification, then GitHub wins. Refs #1117 #1102 #1072 #1071 #1093 — no closing keywords; the §7 -board is now live (epic #1126, children #1127–#1140); F1 remains open pending #1127's verdict. +board is now live (epic #1126, children #1127–#1140); F1 was resolved to qualified F1(b) by +#1127's committed proof verdict. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-fable-rereview.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-fable-rereview.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..21f9afab21 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-fable-rereview.md @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +use harness + +# S1 Fable re-review — amended P1 proof + +You are the separate opposite-family slice reviewer. Work only in +`/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl`. Do not edit implementation or evidence files, do not run an +AppHost or scaffold, do not delegate, and do not create a commit or contact GitHub. + +Read the locked plan and PLAN-EVAL, then the original review at `reviews/S1-fable.md`. Re-review +the amended stable S1 artifacts, especially: + +- `proofs/P1-verdict.md` +- `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` +- `proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md` +- `worklog.md` +- `context-pack.md` +- `drift.md` + +Verify each original finding M1, M2, M3, m1, m2, and m3 is resolved without weakening the locked +D5/D6 gate or misrepresenting the unattributed HTTP 200. Confirm that P1 remains an explicit FAIL, +that F1(b) is causally qualified and revisitable, that only DB-backed P2 is product-blocked, and +that evaluator vocabulary and supervisor-owned RFC updates are correctly scoped. + +Write exactly one review artifact at `reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md`. Its first line must be exactly +`APPROVED` or `CHANGES_REQUESTED`. Include a per-finding disposition table and list any new finding +with severity and a concrete required action. If all original findings are resolved and no new +blocking issue exists, approve. This is advisory slice review, not IMPL-EVAL. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-fable-review.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-fable-review.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0703ad81b7 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-fable-review.md @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +use harness + +# S1 opposite-family review — P1 lifecycle verdict + +## SKILL + +Read and follow `.agents/skills/netscript-harness`, `.agents/skills/netscript-doctrine`, +`.agents/skills/netscript-tools`, `.agents/skills/aspire`, and `.agents/skills/netscript-pr`. This +is an advisory `review_codex` lane, not formal IMPL-EVAL. + +You are the separate native Claude Fable 5/low reviewer for Codex-authored S1 in +`test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0`. Work from `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl` and review +the stable uncommitted diff only. + +Read the run's `plan.md` D4–D6, `plan-eval.md`, `worklog.md`, `drift.md`, all `proofs/P1-*` and +`proofs/experiments/p1-*` / `proofs/evidence/P1-*` files, RFC #1123 §4 and §9, and issue #1127's +acceptance contract. Inspect the scratch manifest/AppHost only as needed; do not change it. + +Adversarially answer: + +1. Does the callback + `getValueAsync()` + atomic identity-bound manifest actually demonstrate the + RFC's post-allocation seam, or does D5 correctly require coherent Aspire description/health/live + request evidence and therefore make this an explicit FAIL selecting F1(b)? +2. Is the later HTTP 200 after Aspire `Finished`/exit 1 adequately explained and safe to use, or is + the evidence contaminated/ambiguous? +3. Are manifest identity, endpoint allocation, atomicity, multi-service completion, evidence + normalization, exact teardown, scope, and static gates truthful and sufficient? +4. Does `FAIL_RESCOPE` improperly block independent P2/P3 proof work, given that a P1 FAIL is a + legitimate deliverable rather than a slice failure? +5. Identify every correctness, evidence, path, wording, or acceptance-box defect that must be fixed + before supervisor sign-off. + +Write only `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable.md`. Begin with exactly +`APPROVED` or `CHANGES_REQUESTED`, then list severity-ranked findings with file/line evidence and a +specific required action. Do not edit any proof, plan, worklog, drift, product/template source, or +scratch file; do not commit, push, post to GitHub, run a new AppHost, or spawn subagents. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-review-fixes.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-review-fixes.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..6a9c102618 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S1-review-fixes.md @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +use harness + +# S1 Fable findings amendment + +## SKILL + +Continue following the already-loaded harness, tools, Aspire, CLI, doctrine, and PR skills. This is +the same Codex implementation thread; do not self-sign off. + +Read `reviews/S1-fable.md` and resolve every M1, M2, M3, m1, m2, and m3 finding without rerunning an +AppHost and without changing product/template source: + +- De-attribute the unexplained HTTP 200 in `P1-runtime.json`; it must not remain a satisfied + pass-bar condition. State that listener ownership/timing was not established and preserve the + observation only as ambiguous evidence. +- Qualify the P1/F1(b) verdict and future RFC/epic wording: the post-allocation seam produced + correct allocated endpoint values, but the locked D5 coherent owned-run bar failed due service + health; a later healthy proof may legitimately revisit F1. +- Distinguish the DB-backed P2 block from runnable no-DB P2 and P3. The product rescope + recommendation must not halt independent proof work. +- Make `FAIL_RESCOPE` explicitly an implementation recommendation, not a self-issued evaluator + verdict. +- Annotate RFC §9 as supervisor-applied after review in the S1 file list. +- Rename/qualify `literalLoopbackUrl` because the raw host was the `localhost` name, not a literal + numeric loopback. +- Update `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, and `drift.md` truthfully; preserve explicit P1 + FAIL/F1(b), teardown, static-gate, and no-product-change evidence. + +Run scoped format/check/lint only for the touched run/proof artifacts. Do not commit, push, edit +GitHub, rerun Aspire, or begin P2/P3. Stop with a concise handoff for the supervisor's Fable +re-review. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md index fcb92657ff..1003963d7a 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md @@ -12,9 +12,12 @@ ## Current State -Research and Design are locked at D1–D12. Separate Qwen PLAN-EVAL passed. No P1/P2/P3 experiment or -verdict exists and no outcome is implied. Draft PR #1182 is open with the required labels/milestone -and no closing keywords. Implementation may begin only in the separate tracked Codex lane. +Research and Design are locked at D1–D12 and separate Qwen PLAN-EVAL passed. The tracked Codex lane +completed S1 with explicit P1 `FAIL`, selecting qualified F1(b). The callback emitted correct +allocated values and a complete manifest, but the generated SQLite users process exited because +`--allow-ffi` is absent. Listener ownership and precise timing for a later HTTP 200 were not +captured, so that observation is ambiguous and cannot satisfy D5. Separate Fable re-review approved +the amended evidence and causal qualifier. No S2/S3 work has begun. ## Completed @@ -23,16 +26,20 @@ and no closing keywords. Implementation may begin only in the separate tracked C - Harness bootstrap commit/push, draft PR #1182, and research phase comment. - Locked plan, Design checkpoint, measurement schemas, commit slices, and gate set. - Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high `plan-eval.md` with `PASS`. +- S1 disposable SQLite scaffold, documented DB preparation, callback experiment, normalized + evidence, explicit P1 `FAIL`/F1(b) verdict, exact owned-resource teardown, and separate Fable + approval after one amendment cycle. ## In Progress -- S0 sign-off commit/push and draft-PR Plan/PLAN-EVAL reporting. +- Supervisor integration of the approved S1 artifact set and RFC/epic decision-record update. ## Next Steps -1. Commit/push S0 and post the plan / plan-eval phase comments. -2. Launch one tracked Codex implementation thread from `implement.md`. -3. Serialize S1–S3 with Fable review and supervisor sign-off after each. +1. Commit/push reviewed S1 and synchronize local/GitHub RFC §9 plus epic #1126. +2. Authorize no-DB P2 and P3 in the tracked Codex thread. +3. Resolve how the explicit DB-backed P2 failure is recorded without productizing the permission + defect in this proof PR. ## Key Decisions @@ -42,33 +49,36 @@ and no closing keywords. Implementation may begin only in the separate tracked C | P1 is not pre-decided | RFC §9 / #1127 | Only measured evidence selects F1(a) or F1(b). | | Two owned scaffolds run serially | #1128 / shared-host hazard | SQLite P1/P2 first, no-DB P2 second. | | Incomplete/skipped is FAIL | RFC §4 / user contract | Never represent a missing proof as pass. | +| P1 selects qualified F1(b) | Plan D5/D6 + reviewed evidence | The seam worked; owned-run coherence failed. | | Formal evaluation stays Qwen/open-only | Harness lane policy | No closed-model or supervisor fallback. | ## Files Changed | Path | Status | Notes | | ------------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------------------------- | -| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | modified/new | Harness research, plan/design, prompts, and drift only. | +| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | modified/new | Harness records plus reviewed S1 proof artifacts. | ## Gates | Gate family | Current status | Evidence | | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | | Plan-Gate | PASS | Separate Qwen verdict in `plan-eval.md`. | -| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | -| Runtime | NOT_RUN | No experiment started. | -| Resource hygiene | baseline inventory only | Foreign resources listed; no mutation. | +| Static | PASS | Scoped S1 check/lint/fmt and scope audit. | +| Runtime | P1 FAIL | Qualified F1(b); DB-path rescope recommended. | +| Resource hygiene | PASS | No owned survivors; foreign resources untouched. | ## Open Questions -- P1/P2/P3 measured values remain open by design; their decision rules are locked. +- P1 is resolved as explicit `FAIL` / qualified F1(b), with separate Fable approval. +- DB-backed P2 is product-blocked; no-DB P2 and P3 remain runnable. - Evaluator credential availability is resolved: the parser-backed live canary passed with tools, reasoning, and streaming supported. ## Drift and Debt -- Drift: supervisor route override, stale overlay read paths, and resolved first-canary credential - inheritance recorded in `drift.md`. +- Drift: supervisor route override, stale overlay read paths, resolved evaluator credential + inheritance, and the significant generated `--allow-ffi` permission defect are recorded in + `drift.md`. - Debt: none. ## Commits diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md index bfee143462..782dee2d56 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md @@ -109,3 +109,33 @@ Drift is append-only. - **Action:** accept; use only thread `019fc95d-ce57-7893-98b3-36977bec0cf1` at that worktree and transfer reviewed drafts into the PR worktree with explicit scope checks. - **Evidence:** `codex-thread-ids.md`; live launch observed provider/model/effort match. + +## 2026-08-03 — P1 generated SQLite runtime lacks FFI permission + +- **What:** The prepared SQLite scaffold's generated users resource exits because its Deno command + omits `--allow-ffi`, which the generated `libsql` dependency requires. +- **Source:** Owned Aspire `users` console log and description from the final P1 run. +- **Expected:** After documented DB initialization, the generated users service becomes healthy so + the manifest, Aspire description, and live request can agree. +- **Actual:** The allocation callback wrote a complete manifest, but Aspire described `users` as + `Finished` / exit 1 with no URL. A later HTTP 200 was not tied to a listener owner or precise + timing and therefore cannot satisfy D5's coherent same-run evidence bar. +- **Severity:** significant; product/template change required for a healthy repeat. +- **Action:** Record explicit P1 `FAIL` and qualified F1(b); recommend eventual `FAIL_RESCOPE` only + for the DB-backed product path. Leave product/template source unchanged. +- **Evidence:** `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json`, `proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md`, and + `proofs/P1-verdict.md`. + +## 2026-08-03 — S1 Fable evidence/disposition amendment + +- **What:** Separate Fable review found the initial S1 wording over-attributed an unexplained HTTP + 200, under-qualified F1(b), and made the DB-path rescope appear to halt independent proofs. +- **Source:** `reviews/S1-fable.md` findings M1–M3 and m1–m3. +- **Expected:** P1 remains explicit `FAIL` under D5/D6 while evidence attribution, decision cause, + evaluator authority, and independent downstream work are stated precisely. +- **Actual:** The same Codex thread amended evidence and wording without rerunning Aspire. Separate + native Fable re-review approved every disposition and found no new blocker. +- **Severity:** major evidence/decision-record clarification; no runtime or product change. +- **Action:** Keep P1 `FAIL` and qualified/revisitable F1(b); only a separate evaluator may issue + `FAIL_RESCOPE`. Permit the supervisor to authorize independent no-DB P2 and P3 work. +- **Evidence:** `reviews/S1-fable.md`, `reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md`, and amended P1 artifacts. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P1-verdict.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P1-verdict.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0f129db6f3 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P1-verdict.md @@ -0,0 +1,46 @@ +# P1 verdict — post-allocation endpoint manifest + +## Verdict + +`FAIL` + +## Arbitrated F1 outcome + +**F1(b): use the `aspire-cli` query adapter as the first-class endpoint source for the current +decision record.** + +The post-allocation seam itself produced correct allocated endpoint values. F1(b) is selected +because the locked D5 coherent-owned-run bar was not met due to service health, not because the seam +was shown impossible. A later healthy owned-run proof may legitimately give the owner reason to +revisit F1; both sources remain additive implementations of the same endpoint-source port. + +The TypeScript `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` callback and `EndpointReference.getValueAsync()` did +atomically emit a complete identity-bound manifest with the localhost-name URL +`http://localhost:3001`. No literal numeric loopback address was observed. That is necessary but not +sufficient for the locked P1 bar. In the prepared owned run, Aspire described `users` as `Finished` +with exit code 1 and no resource URL; the generated command lacked `--allow-ffi`, which `libsql` +requires. A later request to the manifest URL returned HTTP 200, but listener PID/ownership and +precise describe-to-fetch timing were not captured. That observation could reflect a restart, stale +description, or foreign listener and is therefore ambiguous—not a satisfied pass-bar condition. The +manifest, owned description, healthy resource, and attributed live request did not agree in one +coherent observation. Per D5/D6, any incomplete or inconsistent proof is `FAIL` and selects F1(b). + +## Evidence + +- Experiment: `proofs/experiments/p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts` +- Normalized runtime evidence: `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` +- Attempt and teardown record: `proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md` +- Normalized owned-resource report: `proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json` + +## Implementation recommendation + +Rescope the generated SQLite service permission fix outside this proof PR. The implementation lane +recommends `FAIL_RESCOPE` as the eventual IMPL-EVAL disposition for that DB-backed product path; +this is not a self-issued evaluator verdict. + +Making the generated SQLite service healthy requires a product/template permission change. This +proof run does not own that change and did not make it. The DB-backed half of P2 is blocked pending +that fix because it needs the same service to expose a coherent live spec. The no-DB half of P2 and +P3 do not depend on `libsql` or `--allow-ffi`; they remain runnable after the supervisor clears the +normal review/sequence gate. The seed RFC §9, RFC issue #1123, and epic #1126 remain for the +supervisor to update only after separate Fable review and sign-off of this draft verdict. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..94d1686b9f --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +# P1 attempt record + +All paths below are normalized to the owned scratch root. No foreign AppHost, container, or +`aspire mcp start` process was stopped. + +| Attempt | Result | Evidence | +| ----------------------- | ------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Static-import preflight | No AppHost started | Aspire TypeScript rejected the committed experiment's static import because it was outside the disposable AppHost `rootDir`. The scratch AppHost changed to a computed runtime import; the committed experiment was unchanged. | +| First retained runtime | Service failed before listening | The documented DB initialization/generation/seed prerequisites had not run; the service could not import `schema/.generated/zod/crud.ts`. Exact AppHost teardown passed before DB preparation. | +| Prepared runtime | P1 `FAIL` | The post-allocation callback atomically wrote the complete manifest, but Aspire described `users` as `Finished` with exit code 1. Console logs show missing `--allow-ffi` for `libsql`. A later spec fetch returned 200, but listener PID/ownership and precise describe-to-fetch timing were not captured. Possible explanations include a restart, stale description, or foreign listener; the observation is ambiguous and does not satisfy D5. | + +The root `deno.lock` hash remained `264f029ec1a000c9a2880eb1db926373a35a589d`. The final +exact-target stop left no owned AppHost process, port 3001 listener, or container. Normalized counts +for foreign/unproven survivors are in `P1-resource-hygiene.json`; they were left untouched. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..6666474c35 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json @@ -0,0 +1,19 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "capturedAt": "2026-08-03T20:54:27.018Z", + "ownedRoot": "", + "probes": { + "aspire": "ok", + "docker": "ok" + }, + "survivors": { + "ownedAppHosts": 0, + "ownedContainers": 0, + "ownedPort3001Listeners": 0, + "foreignAppHosts": 2, + "foreignContainers": 4, + "unprovenContainers": 2 + }, + "foreignResourcesMutated": false, + "mcpServerProcessesStopped": false +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..e4b479ebaa --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json @@ -0,0 +1,93 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "proof": "P1", + "capturedAt": "2026-08-03T20:54:27.018Z", + "versions": { + "aspireCli": "13.4.6", + "deno": "2.9.3" + }, + "scratchProject": "/p1-sqlite", + "experiment": "proofs/experiments/p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts", + "setup": { + "scaffoldExitCode": 0, + "aspireRestoreExitCode": 0, + "dbInitExitCode": 0, + "dbGenerateExitCode": 0, + "dbSeedExitCode": 0, + "rootDenoLockBefore": "264f029ec1a000c9a2880eb1db926373a35a589d", + "rootDenoLockAfter": "264f029ec1a000c9a2880eb1db926373a35a589d" + }, + "manifest": { + "schemaVersion": 1, + "projectRoot": "/p1-sqlite", + "runId": "1fb3eb9b-53bd-45f0-8b70-d83e8dab9598", + "writtenAt": "2026-08-03T20:53:11.536Z", + "services": [ + { + "service": "users", + "endpoint": "http", + "url": "http://localhost:3001", + "scheme": "http", + "host": "localhost", + "port": 3001, + "allocated": true + } + ], + "atomicWriteMarkerObserved": true + }, + "aspireDescription": { + "resource": "users", + "state": "Finished", + "exitCode": 1, + "healthStatus": null, + "urls": [], + "healthReport": "Unhealthy: endpoint not responding in the 200 range" + }, + "serviceLog": { + "classification": "generated-runtime-permission-defect", + "message": "NotCapable: Requires ffi access to the libsql native module; run again with --allow-ffi", + "generatedCommandPermissions": [ + "--allow-net", + "--allow-env", + "--allow-read", + "--allow-sys" + ], + "missingPermission": "--allow-ffi" + }, + "ambiguousObservations": { + "liveRequest": { + "url": "http://localhost:3001/api/openapi.json", + "ok": true, + "status": 200, + "contentType": "application/json", + "attributedToOwnedService": false, + "listenerOwnershipEstablished": false, + "describeFetchOrderingPreciselyTimestamped": false, + "candidateExplanations": [ + "an Aspire restart after the captured description", + "a stale Aspire description", + "a foreign or otherwise unowned listener" + ], + "note": "HTTP 200 was observed, but the port-3001 listener's PID and ownership were not captured and precise describe-to-fetch timing was not recorded. The owned Aspire description showed users Finished/exit 1 with no URL, so this ambiguous observation is not pass evidence." + } + }, + "passBar": { + "completeServiceIdentity": true, + "nonZeroAllocatedPort": true, + "allocatedHostUsesLoopbackName": true, + "literalNumericLoopbackUrl": false, + "hostQualification": "The raw allocated host was the localhost name; no numeric 127.0.0.1/[::1] normalization or resolution proof was captured.", + "manifestAgreesWithOwnedAspireDescription": false, + "ownedServiceHealthy": false, + "attributedSuccessfulLiveRequest": false, + "allConditionsSatisfied": false + }, + "teardown": { + "exactAppHostStopExitCode": 0, + "ownedAppHostProcessesRemaining": 0, + "ownedPort3001ListenersRemaining": 0, + "ownedContainersRemaining": 0, + "foreignResourcesMutated": false, + "resourceHygieneEvidence": "P1-resource-hygiene.json" + } +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/experiments/p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/experiments/p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..c063bc6300 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/experiments/p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts @@ -0,0 +1,136 @@ +import { mkdir, realpath, rename, writeFile } from 'node:fs/promises'; +import { dirname, join, resolve } from 'node:path'; + +interface EndpointReferenceLike { + exists(): Promise; + getValueAsync(): Promise; + host(): Promise; + isAllocated(): Promise; + port(): Promise; + scheme(): Promise; +} + +interface ExecutableResourceLike { + getEndpoint(name: string): EndpointReferenceLike; + onResourceEndpointsAllocated( + callback: () => Promise, + ): PromiseLike; +} + +type AddExecutable = ( + name: string, + command: string, + workingDirectory: string, + args: string[], +) => ExecutableResourceLike; + +interface BuilderLike { + addExecutable: AddExecutable; + appHostDirectory(): Promise; +} + +interface EndpointManifestEntry { + readonly service: string; + readonly endpoint: string; + readonly url: string; + readonly scheme: string; + readonly host: string; + readonly port: number; + readonly allocated: boolean; +} + +interface EndpointManifest { + readonly schemaVersion: 1; + readonly projectRoot: string; + readonly runId: string; + readonly writtenAt: string; + readonly services: readonly EndpointManifestEntry[]; +} + +const ENDPOINT_NAME = 'http'; +const MANIFEST_RELATIVE_PATH = join('.netscript', 'run', 'endpoints.json'); + +/** Captures generated service resources and installs the P1 allocation callback. */ +export function captureP1ServiceResources( + builder: BuilderLike, + expectedServices: readonly string[], +): { subscribe(): Promise } { + const expected = new Set(expectedServices); + const captured = new Map(); + const originalAddExecutable = builder.addExecutable.bind(builder); + + builder.addExecutable = (name, command, workingDirectory, args) => { + const resource = originalAddExecutable(name, command, workingDirectory, args); + if (expected.has(name)) captured.set(name, resource); + return resource; + }; + + return { + async subscribe(): Promise { + builder.addExecutable = originalAddExecutable; + + const missing = [...expected].filter((name) => !captured.has(name)); + if (missing.length > 0) { + throw new Error(`P1 did not capture expected service resources: ${missing.join(', ')}`); + } + + const projectRoot = await realpath(resolve(await builder.appHostDirectory(), '..')); + const runId = crypto.randomUUID(); + const observations = new Map(); + let writeChain = Promise.resolve(); + + for (const name of [...expected].sort()) { + const resource = captured.get(name); + if (!resource) throw new Error(`P1 resource disappeared after capture: ${name}`); + + await resource.onResourceEndpointsAllocated(async () => { + const endpoint = resource.getEndpoint(ENDPOINT_NAME); + const [url, scheme, host, port, allocated, exists] = await Promise.all([ + endpoint.getValueAsync(), + endpoint.scheme(), + endpoint.host(), + endpoint.port(), + endpoint.isAllocated(), + endpoint.exists(), + ]); + if (!exists) throw new Error(`P1 endpoint ${name}/${ENDPOINT_NAME} does not exist`); + + observations.set(name, { + service: name, + endpoint: ENDPOINT_NAME, + url, + scheme, + host, + port, + allocated, + }); + + writeChain = writeChain.then(async () => { + if (observations.size !== expected.size) return; + + const manifest: EndpointManifest = { + schemaVersion: 1, + projectRoot, + runId, + writtenAt: new Date().toISOString(), + services: [...observations.values()].sort((a, b) => + a.service.localeCompare(b.service) + ), + }; + const destination = join(projectRoot, MANIFEST_RELATIVE_PATH); + const temporary = `${destination}.${runId}.tmp`; + await mkdir(dirname(destination), { recursive: true }); + await writeFile(temporary, `${JSON.stringify(manifest, null, 2)}\n`, { + encoding: 'utf8', + flag: 'wx', + mode: 0o600, + }); + await rename(temporary, destination); + console.log(`P1_ENDPOINT_MANIFEST_WRITTEN ${destination} ${runId}`); + }); + await writeChain; + }); + } + }, + }; +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..fbf92ed29d --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +APPROVED + +# S1 opposite-family re-review — amended P1 proof + +- Reviewer: Claude Fable 5, separate native session (advisory `review_codex` lane, not IMPL-EVAL) +- Scope: amended stable S1 artifacts only; no implementation, evidence, runtime, or GitHub action + taken by this session. +- Inputs read: `plan.md` (D4–D6, D12), `plan-eval.md`, `reviews/S1-fable.md`, + `proofs/P1-verdict.md`, `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json`, `proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md`, + `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`. + +## Per-finding disposition + +| Finding | Original issue | Disposition | Evidence in amended artifacts | +| ------- | -------------- | ----------- | ----------------------------- | +| M1 | HTTP 200 unattributed; `successfulLiveRequest: true` overstated inside `passBar` | **Resolved** | `P1-runtime.json` moves the fetch into a dedicated `ambiguousObservations.liveRequest` block with `attributedToOwnedService: false`, `listenerOwnershipEstablished: false`, `describeFetchOrderingPreciselyTimestamped: false`, all three candidate explanations, and an explicit not-pass-evidence note (`P1-runtime.json:57-73`). `passBar` now carries `attributedSuccessfulLiveRequest: false` and `allConditionsSatisfied: false` (`P1-runtime.json:74-84`). `P1-attempts.md` row 3 and `P1-verdict.md:21-26` state the listener owner/timing were not captured and name the candidate explanations. Timestamps were not retroactively invented — correctly, since they were not captured. | +| M2 | F1(b) record read as flat seam refutation; causal qualifier missing | **Resolved** | `P1-verdict.md:12-15`: the seam "produced correct allocated endpoint values"; F1(b) selected "because the locked D5 coherent-owned-run bar was not met due service health, not because the seam was shown impossible"; a later healthy owned run "may legitimately give the owner reason to revisit F1; both sources remain additive implementations of the same endpoint-source port." Matches the required causal-qualifier and revisitability language and is positioned to carry into the supervisor's RFC §9/epic update. | +| M3 | Rescope stop read as whole-run halt; independent work not distinguished | **Resolved** | `P1-verdict.md:42-45` splits blocked vs runnable: only DB-backed P2 is blocked pending the product permission fix; no-DB P2 and P3 "do not depend on `libsql` or `--allow-ffi`" and remain runnable after the normal review/sequence gate. Mirrored in `worklog.md` runtime-gate notes ("DB half product-blocked; no-DB half remains review/sequence-gated", "Independent of the permission defect"), handoff notes, and `context-pack.md` Next Steps/Open Questions. | +| m1 | `FAIL_RESCOPE` used as implementation-lane verdict vocabulary | **Resolved** | `P1-verdict.md:37-39`: "recommends `FAIL_RESCOPE` as the eventual IMPL-EVAL disposition … this is not a self-issued evaluator verdict." The append-only drift amendment (`drift.md:113-129`) explicitly supersedes the earlier unqualified `Action: FAIL_RESCOPE` wording and states only a separate evaluator may issue that verdict. Worklog and context-pack use "recommended/recommends" throughout. The original drift entry's `Action: FAIL_RESCOPE` remains in place, but drift is append-only by rule, and the superseding entry addresses it correctly. | +| m2 | S1 slice file list promised `rfc.md` §9, which S1 defers | **Resolved** | `worklog.md:55` S1 row now reads "seed `rfc.md` §9 is supervisor-applied after review", matching `P1-verdict.md:45-46` (RFC #1123 / epic #1126 updates remain for the supervisor after review and sign-off). | +| m3 | `literalLoopbackUrl: true` for a hostname URL | **Resolved** | `passBar` now distinguishes `allocatedHostUsesLoopbackName: true` from `literalNumericLoopbackUrl: false` and adds a `hostQualification` stating no numeric normalization or resolution proof was captured (`P1-runtime.json:77-79`). `P1-verdict.md:18-19` states "No literal numeric loopback address was observed." | + +## Gate-integrity checks from the brief + +- **D5/D6 not weakened.** The pass bar still requires manifest + same-owned-run Aspire description + + attributed live request coherence; the amendment tightened it (attribution is now an explicit + condition) rather than relaxing it. `allConditionsSatisfied: false` and the verdict remains an + explicit `FAIL` mapping to F1(b) per D6 — no NOT_RUN-as-pass, no reinterpretation of the bar. +- **HTTP 200 not misrepresented.** It appears only as an ambiguous observation with attribution + explicitly false and candidate explanations listed; nowhere is it used as satisfied pass-bar + evidence. The in-file contradiction with the `Finished`/exit-1 description is preserved, not + smoothed over. +- **F1(b) causally qualified and revisitable.** Confirmed as above (M2); the qualifier is present in + the verdict, worklog progress log, drift amendment, and context-pack, so any future RFC §9/epic + text drawn from these artifacts inherits it. +- **Only DB-backed P2 product-blocked.** Confirmed as above (M3); consistent across verdict, + worklog gate tables, handoff notes, and context-pack. +- **Evaluator vocabulary scoped.** Confirmed as above (m1); the implementation lane recommends, the + separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL decides. +- **Supervisor-owned RFC updates scoped.** Local seed `rfc.md` §9, RFC issue #1123, and epic #1126 + updates are consistently reserved for the supervisor after review/sign-off; the S1 slice table no + longer promises them as slice files. + +## New findings + +No new blocking finding. + +- **i1 (info, typo — non-blocking):** `P1-verdict.md:13` reads "not met due service health" + (missing "to"). Cosmetic; the supervisor may fix it in the sign-off pass without re-review. + +## Summary + +All six original findings (M1, M2, M3, m1, m2, m3) are resolved faithfully: the amendments tighten +evidence attribution and decision-record precision without weakening the locked D5/D6 bar, without +laundering the unattributed HTTP 200 into pass evidence, and without expanding the implementation +lane's authority. P1 remains an explicit, evidence-backed `FAIL` selecting a causally qualified, +revisitable F1(b). The draft is fit for supervisor sign-off; this is advisory slice review, not +IMPL-EVAL. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8282feaea7 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S1-fable.md @@ -0,0 +1,139 @@ +CHANGES_REQUESTED + +# S1 opposite-family review — P1 lifecycle verdict + +- Reviewer: Claude Fable 5 / low, separate native session (advisory `review_codex` lane, not + IMPL-EVAL) +- Reviewed: stable uncommitted diff of `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` only +- Inputs read: `plan.md` D4–D6/D12, `plan-eval.md`, `worklog.md`, `drift.md`, `proofs/P1-verdict.md`, + `proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md`, `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json`, + `proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json`, `proofs/experiments/p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts`, + seed RFC `plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md` §4 (lines 256–266) and §9 (lines 367–391), + issue #1127 body/acceptance. + +## Verdict-level answers to the brief + +1. **Is the FAIL correct?** Yes, under the locked plan. The callback + `getValueAsync()` + + atomic identity-bound manifest is genuine post-allocation evidence (real allocated port 3001, + complete identity binding, atomic `wx`+rename — `p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts:108-131`), but + D5 (`plan.md:83`) requires the manifest, the same owned run's Aspire description, and a + successful live request to agree with a healthy resource. The owned description recorded + `users` as `Finished`/exit 1 with no URL (`P1-runtime.json:38-45`), so the D5 bar is not met, + and D6 (`plan.md:84`) maps any FAIL — including incomplete execution — to F1(b). The explicit + FAIL selecting F1(b) is the correct application of the PLAN-EVAL-passed rules. Note for the + RFC record: the seam itself was *not* refuted; the failure cause is an orthogonal generated + permission defect (missing `--allow-ffi`). F1(b) must be recorded as "selected because the P1 + bar was not met," not as "post-allocation seam demonstrated impossible" (see finding M2). +2. **Is the later HTTP 200 safe to use?** No, and the verdict is right not to use it — but the + evidence currently under-explains it (finding M1). A process Aspire reports as exited with + code 1 cannot itself have served the 200; the origin of the port-3001 listener at fetch time + is unattributed on a shared host that carries 2 foreign AppHosts, 4 foreign containers, and 2 + unproven containers (`P1-resource-hygiene.json:13-15`). The 200 is ambiguous/potentially + contaminated evidence and must not appear as a satisfied pass-bar condition. +3. **Truthfulness/sufficiency:** manifest identity, atomicity, race handling (write chain + + completeness check), single-service completion, credential/path normalization, exact-target + teardown, lock hygiene, scope containment (only run artifacts changed per `git status`), and + the scoped static gates all check out against the evidence. Two evidence-quality gaps are + listed below (M1, m3). +4. **Does `FAIL_RESCOPE` improperly block P2/P3?** Partially — see M3. The rescope is correctly + scoped to the product fix, but the worklog framing ("stopped before S2", `worklog.md:91`) + does not distinguish blocked work from merely sequence-gated work. P3 reruns an existing auth + test with no scaffold and no AppHost; the no-DB half of P2 has no `libsql` dependency. + Neither depends on `--allow-ffi`. Only the DB half of P2 is genuinely blocked by the defect + (its live spec would come from the same crashing service, and the ambiguous 200 cannot be + used). The supervisor should be able to authorize S2(no-DB)/S3 to proceed in parallel with + the product-fix rescope; the current artifacts read as if the whole run is halted. + +## Findings (severity-ranked) + +### M1 (major, evidence integrity) — HTTP 200 origin unattributed; `successfulLiveRequest: true` overstates + +- Evidence: `P1-runtime.json:57-63` (the fetch), `:70` (`"successfulLiveRequest": true` inside + `passBar`), `:44` (`healthReport` says "endpoint not responding in the 200 range" — an + in-file contradiction with the 200), `P1-resource-hygiene.json:13-15` (foreign/unproven + survivors on the shared host). +- Problem: no PID/owner capture of the port-3001 listener at fetch time, and no timestamps + ordering describe → fetch, so the 200 cannot be attributed to the owned `users` process (which + Aspire says had exited). Possible origins include an Aspire restart, a stale description, or a + foreign listener. Marking the pass-bar condition `true` from unattributed evidence is exactly + the false-green shape the plan's hidden scope forbids. +- Required action (Codex lane, no re-run needed): in `P1-runtime.json`, either move + `successfulLiveRequest` out of `passBar` into an `ambiguousObservations` block or set it with + an explicit `"attributed": false` qualifier; add the describe/fetch ordering timestamps if + captured; extend the `liveRequest.note` (and `P1-attempts.md` row 3, `P1-verdict.md:16-18`) to + state the listener's owner was not established and name the candidate explanations. The FAIL + verdict itself is unaffected — every candidate explanation still fails D5 coherence. + +### M2 (major, decision-record wording) — F1(b) record must carry the causal qualifier + +- Evidence: `P1-verdict.md:7-18`; RFC §9 (`rfc.md:379`) frames F1(b) activation on P1's verdict; + #1127 states "A FAIL verdict is a legitimate result, not a blocker." +- Problem: the verdict text does say the callback evidence was "necessary but not sufficient," + but the "Arbitrated F1 outcome" heading reads as a flat seam refutation. When the supervisor + updates RFC §9 and epic #1126, an unqualified "F1(b)" entry would misrecord *why* — the seam + produced correct allocated values; the bar failed on service health caused by a generated + permission defect outside this run's scope. +- Required action: add one sentence to `P1-verdict.md` §"Arbitrated F1 outcome" (and carry it + into the eventual RFC §9/epic update): the post-allocation seam itself yielded correct + allocated endpoint values; F1(b) is selected because the locked D5 coherence bar was not met + in an owned run, and a future healthy re-run is a legitimate basis for the owner to revisit + F1 — the RFC keeps (a) and (b) in the same port contract, so this is additive, not wasted. + +### M3 (medium, disposition) — rescope stop over-blocks independent proof work + +- Evidence: `P1-verdict.md:29-34`, `worklog.md:91`, `worklog.md:138-139` (P2/P3 NOT_RUN "hard- + gated"), plan D12 (`plan.md:90`). +- Problem: `FAIL_RESCOPE` correctly routes the `--allow-ffi` product fix out of this PR, but + nothing in the artifacts records that P3 and the no-DB half of P2 are independent of the + defect and remain runnable under the existing plan. As written, the rescope reads as a + whole-run halt, which the brief's question 4 correctly challenges. +- Required action: add a "Blocked vs runnable" note to `P1-verdict.md` (or worklog handoff): + DB-scaffold P2 evidence is blocked pending the product fix; no-DB P2 and P3 are only + review/sequence-gated and may be authorized by the supervisor without waiting for the rescope. + +### m1 (minor, vocabulary) — `FAIL_RESCOPE` is evaluator-verdict vocabulary + +- Evidence: `P1-verdict.md:27-29`; harness verdict definitions reserve + `PASS/FAIL_FIX/FAIL_RESCOPE/FAIL_DEBT` for IMPL-EVAL. +- Problem: the implementation lane emitting an evaluator token as a "Rescope disposition" risks + being read as a self-issued eval verdict — the lane must not self-certify or pre-empt the + separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL. +- Required action: reword to "Rescope required (per D12); recommended IMPL-EVAL disposition: + FAIL_RESCOPE" or similar, making clear the token is a recommendation to the evaluator. + +### m2 (minor, consistency) — S1 slice file list names `rfc.md §9`, which S1 deliberately did not touch + +- Evidence: `worklog.md:55` (S1 files include "seed `rfc.md` §9") vs `P1-verdict.md:31-34` and + `worklog.md:151-152` (RFC/epic updates withheld for supervisor). +- Problem: the slice table promises a file the slice intentionally defers; an evaluator diffing + slice-files vs actual changes will flag it. +- Required action: annotate the S1 row (e.g. "seed `rfc.md` §9 — supervisor-applied after + review") or move it to the supervisor sign-off step. + +### m3 (minor, evidence precision) — `literalLoopbackUrl: true` for a hostname URL + +- Evidence: `P1-runtime.json:29,67`; #1127 requires "literal-loopback URLs"; plan risk register + (`plan.md:113`) requires normalized-host comparison with raw URLs preserved. +- Problem: `http://localhost:3001` is a loopback *name*, not a literal loopback address + (`127.0.0.1`/`[::1]`); `localhost` can resolve to either family. The evidence records no + normalization or resolution check backing the `true`. +- Required action: rename the field (e.g. `loopbackUrl`) or add a note that the allocated host + was the `localhost` name and no literal-address normalization was performed. Cosmetic for a + FAIL verdict, but the field name would be load-bearing on a future PASS re-run. + +### i1 (info) — acceptance boxes and PR hygiene + +- #1127's second acceptance box ("epic + RFC §9 updated") is correctly still open; the PR must + not carry `Closes #1127` until the supervisor lands those updates. First box is satisfiable by + committing this evidence set (explicit FAIL + measured evidence) once M1/M2 amendments land. +- Static gates, lock hash stability (`264f029e…` before/after), exact-target teardown with zero + owned survivors, and untouched foreign resources are all consistent across + `P1-attempts.md`, `P1-runtime.json`, and `P1-resource-hygiene.json` — no discrepancy found. + +## Summary + +The P1 `FAIL` → F1(b) arbitration is the correct application of locked D5/D6 and is supported by +the evidence; no finding overturns it. Sign-off should wait for the M1 evidence-attribution +amendment, the M2 causal qualifier on the F1(b) record, and the M3 blocked-vs-runnable +clarification; the minors are wording/consistency fixes the Codex lane can apply in the same +amendment pass without re-running any AppHost. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md index 660ba219c9..f1726fd84d 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ | # | Slice | Gate | Files | | -- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | S0 | Lock plan/design and formal PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen `plan-eval.md=PASS`; format run Markdown | `plan.md`, `research.md`, `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `implement.md`, `briefs/plan-eval.md`, `plan-eval.md` | -| S1 | Prove/refute post-allocation endpoint manifest and arbitrate F1 | Owned Aspire status + manifest/describe/live-request agreement + log review + verified teardown; separate Fable review | `proofs/P1-verdict.md`, `proofs/experiments/p1-*`, `proofs/evidence/P1-*`, seed `rfc.md` §9, run logs/context | +| S1 | Prove/refute post-allocation endpoint manifest and arbitrate F1 | Owned Aspire status + manifest/describe/live-request agreement + log review + verified teardown; separate Fable review | `proofs/P1-verdict.md`, `proofs/experiments/p1-*`, `proofs/evidence/P1-*`, run logs/context; seed `rfc.md` §9 is supervisor-applied after review | | S2 | Measure DB and no-DB live spec fidelity/size | Measurement script check/lint/fmt + two normalized evidence files + schema/error/keyword completeness review + verified teardown; separate Fable review | `proofs/P2-verdict.md`, `proofs/experiments/p2-*`, `proofs/evidence/P2-*`, run logs/context | | S3 | Prove auth-guarded spec behavior and ratify wording | Targeted existing auth test + response evidence + wording review; separate Fable review | `proofs/P3-verdict.md`, `proofs/evidence/P3-*`, run logs/context | | S4 | Final hygiene and evaluation | Scoped wrappers, no lint ignores, lock/scope audit, leak check, review-thread gate, separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL | `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `evaluate.md`, PR metadata/comments | @@ -86,6 +86,11 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | | 2026-08-03 | S0 | implementation handoff | Launcher dry-run failed closed because `use harness` followed the brief title instead of occupying line 1. Reordered the activation line; no implementation process was started. | | 2026-08-03 | S1 | implementation launch | One tracked Codex `gpt-5.6-sol`/medium thread launched in a dedicated no-upstream worktree after one-sender safety rejected the supervisor-owned PR worktree. Child has draft-only authority and must stop after each slice. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | experiment setup | Scaffolded the owned local-source SQLite fixture, restored Aspire SDK modules, and ran the documented DB init/generate/seed steps serially. Root `deno.lock` hash remained unchanged. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | allocation callback | `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` + `getValueAsync()` atomically emitted a complete identity-bound manifest for `users` at `http://localhost:3001`. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | runtime verdict | P1 is explicit `FAIL`: Aspire described `users` as `Finished` / exit 1 because generated permissions omit `--allow-ffi`. The later HTTP 200 is unattributed and cannot satisfy D5. Qualified F1(b) is selected without refuting the seam. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | Fable review | First review requested six evidence/wording corrections; the same Codex thread amended them without rerunning Aspire. Native Fable re-review approved all dispositions and found no new blocker. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | rescope recommendation | Product fix remains outside this PR. Only DB-backed P2 is blocked; no-DB P2 and P3 remain independently runnable after supervisor authorization. Exact owned teardown and hygiene checks passed. | ## Decisions @@ -96,6 +101,7 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | Two scaffolds, serialized | P2 requires DB and no-DB; shared host forbids concurrent AppHosts | Plan D3 / user hazard | | No product/template edits | Productization is S7 and public surface is excluded | User contract / doctrine boundary | | Skip/incomplete means FAIL | Prevents false-green proof status | RFC #1123 §4 / user contract | +| P1 selects qualified F1(b) | D5 coherence failed on health/attribution; allocation seam worked | Reviewed P1 evidence / Plan D5-D6 | ## Drift @@ -104,6 +110,7 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | User-addressed Codex supervisor route | minor | yes | | Service overlay's two additional-read files absent | minor | yes | | First evaluator canary did not inherit documented file credential | minor, resolved | yes | +| P1 generated SQLite runtime lacks `--allow-ffi` | significant | yes | ## Gate Results @@ -112,9 +119,9 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | | ------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ------- | ------------------------------------------------------------- | | Plan artifact format | scoped run formatter | PASS | All owned run Markdown checked after PLAN-EVAL output. | -| Experiment check/lint/fmt | scoped wrappers under `/proofs` | NOT_RUN | No experiment source exists before Plan-Gate PASS. | -| No lint ignores | diff scan | NOT_RUN | Final slice. | -| Lock/scope audit | raw git diff vs `origin/main` | NOT_RUN | Final slice; `deno.lock` and product paths must be untouched. | +| Experiment check/lint/fmt | scoped wrappers under `/proofs` | PASS | One TypeScript file selected; zero check/lint/fmt findings. | +| No lint ignores | owned-source scan | PASS | No lint-ignore directive in the P1 experiment. | +| Lock/scope audit | raw status + root lock hash | PASS | Only run artifacts changed; root lock hash remained unchanged. | ### Fitness Gates @@ -122,18 +129,18 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | ---------------------- | ------- | ------------------------- | ---------------- | | Archetype F-* | N/A | No package/plugin surface | Proof-only run. | | Service contract check | NOT_RUN | P2 live spec evidence | After Plan-Gate. | -| Service runtime health | NOT_RUN | P1/P2 evidence | After Plan-Gate. | -| Trace/log review | NOT_RUN | P1/P2 evidence | After Plan-Gate. | +| Service runtime health | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` | Generated users process exits without `--allow-ffi`. | +| Trace/log review | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` | Failure and ambiguous HTTP observation preserved. | | Consumer check | NOT_RUN | P2 projector evidence | After Plan-Gate. | ### Runtime Gates | Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | | ----------------------- | ------- | ---------------------- | ------------------------------------- | -| P1 lifecycle | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P1-*` | Hard-gated by PLAN-EVAL. | -| P2 DB/no-DB measurement | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | Hard-gated by PLAN-EVAL. | -| P3 auth fixture | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P3-*` | Hard-gated by PLAN-EVAL. | -| Resource leak check | NOT_RUN | final reporter output | Foreign baseline already inventoried. | +| P1 lifecycle | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-*` | Explicit P1 `FAIL`; qualified/revisitable F1(b). | +| P2 DB/no-DB measurement | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | DB half product-blocked; no-DB half remains runnable. | +| P3 auth fixture | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P3-*` | Independent of the permission defect. | +| Resource leak check | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json` | No owned survivors; foreign entries untouched. | ### Consumer Gates @@ -144,7 +151,9 @@ logic into a product template in this run. ## Handoff Notes -- PLAN-EVAL should first verify D4–D9 against RFC §4/§9 and ensure no empirical result is presumed. -- Spot-check research finding 5 against Aspire's documented event API and finding 6 against the - existing auth test. -- Implementation must not begin unless `plan-eval.md` contains a separate-session `PASS`. +- S1 passed separate Fable re-review after the Codex lane resolved M1–M3 and m1–m3; the explicit + P1 `FAIL` and causally qualified/revisitable F1(b) are ready for supervisor decision-record sync. +- The later HTTP 200 has no captured listener owner or precise timing and remains ambiguous; it is + not pass evidence. +- No-DB P2 and P3 may proceed independently; DB-backed P2 requires an explicit failed-proof record + or a separately authorized scratch-only workaround, never a product/template edit in this PR. From 5b0ba26b5bd4be87288d981cdb951c978618ca6e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2026 23:40:45 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 6/9] test(openapi-mcp): record P2 fidelity verdict --- .../briefs/S2-fable-rereview.md | 18 + .../briefs/S2-fable-review.md | 35 ++ .../briefs/S2-no-db-rescope.md | 41 ++ .../briefs/S2-review-fixes.md | 28 + .../context-pack.md | 29 +- .../drift.md | 40 ++ .../proofs/P2-verdict.md | 55 ++ .../proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md | 2 +- .../proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json | 1 + .../proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md | 17 + .../proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json | 19 + .../proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json | 1 + .../proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json | 532 ++++++++++++++++++ .../proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json | 57 ++ .../experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts | 328 +++++++++++ .../reviews/S2-fable-rereview.md | 91 +++ .../reviews/S2-fable.md | 135 +++++ .../worklog.md | 27 +- 18 files changed, 1435 insertions(+), 21 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-fable-rereview.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-fable-review.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-no-db-rescope.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-review-fixes.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P2-verdict.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S2-fable-rereview.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S2-fable.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-fable-rereview.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-fable-rereview.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..b8cd7504a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-fable-rereview.md @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +use harness + +# S2 Fable re-review — amended P2 evidence + +You are the same separate opposite-family review role in a fresh native session. Work read-only in +`/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl`; do not edit, run runtime/scaffold work, delegate, commit, +push, or contact GitHub. + +Read `reviews/S2-fable.md`, `briefs/S2-review-fixes.md`, and every amended artifact named there. +Verify M1 and m1–m3 are resolved: `summary` and all actually-present standard keywords are captured; +unknown/non-allowlisted keys remain auditable with paths; the context-blind limitation is honest; +the retained raw spec exactly matches the recorded bytes/hash and regenerated evidence; lint-ignore, +plan-command drift, and digest-algorithm records are corrected. Reconfirm the measurement script's +claims, the explicit combined P2 FAIL, and that #1128 acceptance must remain unchecked. + +Write only `reviews/S2-fable-rereview.md`. First line exactly `APPROVED` or +`CHANGES_REQUESTED`; include a per-finding disposition and any new blocking finding. This is +advisory slice review, not IMPL-EVAL. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-fable-review.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-fable-review.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..a26d09e8ab --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-fable-review.md @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +use harness + +# S2 Fable review — P2 no-DB measurement and DB failure + +You are the separate opposite-family slice reviewer. Work only in +`/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl`. Do not edit implementation/evidence files, run an AppHost or +scaffold, delegate, commit, push, or contact GitHub. + +Read plan D3/D7/D8/D10/D12, `plan-eval.md`, issue #1128, RFC §4, the approved S1 re-review, and the +stable S2 diff. Review at minimum: + +- `proofs/P2-verdict.md` +- `proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts` +- `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json` +- `proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json` +- `proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json` +- `proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md` +- the P1 evidence carried into the DB failure +- `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, and `drift.md` + +Determine whether the explicit combined P2 `FAIL` is the only truthful D7/D12 verdict. Confirm the +unattributed P1 HTTP 200 was not reused; the no-DB spec is attributed to one owned healthy real +scaffold; all required operationId, compact-byte, discovery-row, request/response/error/all-schema, +source/dereference, error-envelope, reference, keyword, and truncation-budget observations are +measured rather than inferred; and the tool's algorithms support every claim. + +Adversarially check evidence consistency, normalization under D10 (including volatile PIDs/times), +fixed-port ownership, teardown, lock/scope hygiene, static-gate claims, and whether any result could +be misread as satisfying #1128 acceptance despite the missing DB measurement. Confirm no product +or template workaround was made. + +Write exactly one artifact at `reviews/S2-fable.md`; first line exactly `APPROVED` or +`CHANGES_REQUESTED`. Rank findings by severity with concrete required actions. State separately +whether #1128's acceptance box may truthfully be checked. This is advisory slice review, not +IMPL-EVAL. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-no-db-rescope.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-no-db-rescope.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2ab2cba4fc --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-no-db-rescope.md @@ -0,0 +1,41 @@ +use harness + +# S2 implementation follow-up — P2 no-DB measurement and explicit DB failure + +Resume the existing tracked Codex implementation thread in +`/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl`. Read the current run artifacts, the approved +`reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md`, plan D3/D7/D8/D10/D12, issue #1128, and RFC §4 before acting. + +Execute S2 only, then stop for supervisor/Fable review. Do not start P3. Do not commit, push, edit +GitHub, update the seed RFC, or change any product/template file. + +The supervisor accepts S1 and authorizes the independent no-database P2 half. The SQLite/DB P2 +half remains failed/rescoped because the generated service lacks `--allow-ffi`. Do not rerun, +patch, wrap, or manually relaunch that DB scaffold, and do not reuse the unattributed P1 HTTP 200. +Carry the normalized P1 runtime failure forward as the DB-side P2 evidence. Because D7 requires +both scaffolds, the resulting P2 verdict must be explicit `FAIL`, never partial PASS or NOT_RUN. + +For the no-database half: + +1. Re-inventory shared AppHosts, containers, and relevant ports read-only; leave every foreign or + unproven resource untouched. +2. Create a fresh local-source no-database scaffold under the approved `.llm/tmp/` root. Run at + most one owned AppHost and capture exact ownership/PID/port before fetching the live + `/api/openapi.json` document. +3. Commit-ready experiment/evidence must record the D7 schema for the valid no-DB live spec: + compact UTF-8 spec bytes; every operationId and shape classification; discovery-row bytes; + request, response, error, and all-schema views in source and local-dereferenced form; every + non-2xx response/envelope observation; local/external/unresolved refs; and the recursively + observed OpenAPI/JSON-Schema keyword subset. +4. Compare every measured array/string with `maxItems=50` and `maxStringLength=2000`, and state + explicitly that the current MCP path has no whole-result byte ceiling. Never infer a common + error envelope where the no-DB template lacks one. +5. Normalize paths/process noise and record commands, versions, timestamps, teardown, root-lock + hash, and attribution evidence. Stop the exact owned tree and prove zero owned survivors before + writing the verdict. +6. Run the scoped check/lint/fmt wrappers on owned TypeScript and scan for lint ignores. Update + worklog/context/drift. Leave a stable uncommitted S2 diff and stop. + +The verdict must distinguish measured no-DB results from the failed DB branch and explain that a +skipped/blocked branch maps to FAIL under D7/D12. Do not claim #1128 acceptance or issue an +IMPL-EVAL disposition. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-review-fixes.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-review-fixes.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8464e141c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S2-review-fixes.md @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +use harness + +# S2 review fixes — keyword fidelity and record hygiene + +Resume the same tracked Codex thread in `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-impl`. Read +`reviews/S2-fable.md` completely and resolve M1 plus m1–m3. Do not run a scaffold/AppHost, start +P3, change product/template source, commit, push, or contact GitHub. + +Required amendments: + +1. Fix `p2-measure-live-spec.ts` so the observed OpenAPI 3.1 / JSON Schema 2020-12 keyword evidence + cannot silently omit present standard keywords such as `summary`. Use a defensible complete + standard-key set and also emit non-allowlisted object keys with paths (or an equally auditable + mechanism). Document the context-blind property-name limitation if it remains. +2. Copy the retained, hash-matched, credential-free 3657-byte raw no-DB spec into normalized + committed evidence under `proofs/evidence/` using `apply_patch`, then rerun only the measurement + script against that retained spec to regenerate `P2-no-db.json`. Do not fetch the network. +3. Update `P2-verdict.md` so its keyword claim exactly matches the amended evidence. +4. Update the no-lint-ignore gate note to cover both P1 and P2 experiment files. +5. Append drift for the split fetch/measurement command and its filename/permissions deviation. +6. Name the lock-digest algorithm in P1/P2 evidence, or otherwise make the 40-vs-64-hex distinction + explicit without changing the historical values. +7. Re-run the scoped wrappers, JSON assertions, raw-spec hash/byte checks, lint-ignore scan, and + diff/scope checks. Update worklog/context/drift, leave a stable uncommitted amendment, and stop + for Fable re-review. + +The combined P2 verdict remains `FAIL`; do not claim #1128 acceptance or issue an IMPL-EVAL +disposition. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md index 1003963d7a..89028173d5 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md @@ -17,7 +17,9 @@ completed S1 with explicit P1 `FAIL`, selecting qualified F1(b). The callback em allocated values and a complete manifest, but the generated SQLite users process exited because `--allow-ffi` is absent. Listener ownership and precise timing for a later HTTP 200 were not captured, so that observation is ambiguous and cannot satisfy D5. Separate Fable re-review approved -the amended evidence and causal qualifier. No S2/S3 work has begun. +the amended evidence and causal qualifier. S2 is also complete and separately re-reviewed: the +attributed no-DB live spec was measured, but the required DB branch remains unavailable, so the +combined P2 verdict is explicit `FAIL`. P3 has not begun. ## Completed @@ -29,17 +31,20 @@ the amended evidence and causal qualifier. No S2/S3 work has begun. - S1 disposable SQLite scaffold, documented DB preparation, callback experiment, normalized evidence, explicit P1 `FAIL`/F1(b) verdict, exact owned-resource teardown, and separate Fable approval after one amendment cycle. +- S2 fresh no-DB scaffold measurement with exact attribution/teardown, committed raw-spec input, + complete/auditable keyword inventory, explicit combined P2 `FAIL`, and separate Fable approval + after one amendment cycle. ## In Progress -- Supervisor integration of the approved S1 artifact set and RFC/epic decision-record update. +- Supervisor integration and PR reporting for the approved S2 artifact set. ## Next Steps -1. Commit/push reviewed S1 and synchronize local/GitHub RFC §9 plus epic #1126. -2. Authorize no-DB P2 and P3 in the tracked Codex thread. -3. Resolve how the explicit DB-backed P2 failure is recorded without productizing the permission - defect in this proof PR. +1. Commit/push reviewed S2 and report its explicit partial-progress FAIL on #1128 without checking + acceptance or adding a closing keyword. +2. Launch P3 on the required medium-effort implementation route, preserving the one-sender rule. +3. Run separate Fable review after P3, then final hygiene and Qwen IMPL-EVAL. ## Key Decisions @@ -56,7 +61,7 @@ the amended evidence and causal qualifier. No S2/S3 work has begun. | Path | Status | Notes | | ------------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------------------------- | -| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | modified/new | Harness records plus reviewed S1 proof artifacts. | +| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | modified/new | Harness records plus reviewed S1/S2 proof artifacts. | ## Gates @@ -64,21 +69,23 @@ the amended evidence and causal qualifier. No S2/S3 work has begun. | ---------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | | Plan-Gate | PASS | Separate Qwen verdict in `plan-eval.md`. | | Static | PASS | Scoped S1 check/lint/fmt and scope audit. | -| Runtime | P1 FAIL | Qualified F1(b); DB-path rescope recommended. | +| Runtime | P1 FAIL; P2 FAIL | P2 no-DB measured; DB branch remains unavailable. | | Resource hygiene | PASS | No owned survivors; foreign resources untouched. | ## Open Questions - P1 is resolved as explicit `FAIL` / qualified F1(b), with separate Fable approval. -- DB-backed P2 is product-blocked; no-DB P2 and P3 remain runnable. +- P2 is resolved as explicit combined `FAIL`, with sound no-DB measurements and separate Fable + approval; #1128 acceptance remains open because DB measurements are absent. +- P3 remains runnable and not started. - Evaluator credential availability is resolved: the parser-backed live canary passed with tools, reasoning, and streaming supported. ## Drift and Debt - Drift: supervisor route override, stale overlay read paths, resolved evaluator credential - inheritance, and the significant generated `--allow-ffi` permission defect are recorded in - `drift.md`. + inheritance, the significant generated `--allow-ffi` permission defect, S2 command/runtime + deviations, and resumed-thread effort reporting are recorded in `drift.md`. - Debt: none. ## Commits diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md index 782dee2d56..0a5625b92d 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md @@ -139,3 +139,43 @@ Drift is append-only. - **Action:** Keep P1 `FAIL` and qualified/revisitable F1(b); only a separate evaluator may issue `FAIL_RESCOPE`. Permit the supervisor to authorize independent no-DB P2 and P3 work. - **Evidence:** `reviews/S1-fable.md`, `reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md`, and amended P1 artifacts. + +## 2026-08-03 — S2 detached-start controlling-session behavior + +- **What:** Two initial owned `aspire start` attempts reported success but disappeared when their + command sessions ended, before the no-DB service listened. A retained controlling shell kept the + third serialized start alive for attribution, measurement, and exact stop. +- **Source:** Owned `aspire ps`, port, process-tree, and startup-log observations. +- **Expected:** A detached start remains discoverable after the launching command returns. +- **Actual:** The first two starts left no AppHost or listener and produced no fetch. The third used + the same fresh unmodified scaffold and remained healthy while its controlling session stayed open. +- **Severity:** minor environment/transport behavior; no product or evidence-bar change. +- **Action:** Preserve failed attempts, attribute only the retained run, and stop its exact path. +- **Evidence:** `proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md` and `proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json`. + +## 2026-08-03 — P2 split fetch/measurement command + +- **What:** The locked validation row named `p2-measure-spec.ts` with network permission. S2 instead + used `p2-measure-live-spec.ts`: a separately recorded bounded fetch wrote a retained raw spec, + then a file-only measurement command used `--no-lock --allow-read --allow-write` and no network. +- **Source:** Plan validation row 4 and executed S2 command record. +- **Expected:** One measurement filename/command with `--allow-read --allow-net`. +- **Actual:** Fetch and measurement were split; the measurement filename and permissions differ. +- **Severity:** minor; narrower measurement authority and more auditable retained input. +- **Action:** Retain the exact 3657-byte raw input and regenerate evidence without network access. +- **Evidence:** `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json`, `proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json`, and + `proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts`. + +## 2026-08-03 — Resumed Codex thread reports low effort + +- **What:** The agentic suite resumed the approved implementation thread and preserved its thread, + model (`gpt-5.6-sol`), provider, approval, and sandbox identity, but the resumed CLI transcript + reported reasoning effort `low` rather than the launch-time `medium` route. +- **Source:** `agentic:codex-resume` S2 and amendment transcripts versus `codex-thread-ids.md`. +- **Expected:** Same-thread resume preserves the recorded implementation route including effort. +- **Actual:** The resume interface exposes no effort flag and the transcript reports `low`. +- **Severity:** minor route drift; S2 was separately reviewed twice and supervisor-integrated. +- **Action:** Do not use another low-reported resume for P3. Re-establish the required medium route + through the agentic suite before authorizing new implementation work. +- **Evidence:** supervisor turn command records; `reviews/S2-fable.md` and + `reviews/S2-fable-rereview.md`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P2-verdict.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P2-verdict.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9f7bc1e79d --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P2-verdict.md @@ -0,0 +1,55 @@ +# P2 verdict — live spec fidelity and size + +## Verdict + +`FAIL` + +D7 requires measured DB and no-DB scaffolds. The independently authorized no-DB branch produced a +valid, attributable live measurement, but the SQLite branch remains blocked by the generated +service's missing `--allow-ffi` permission. Under D7/D12, a blocked or skipped required branch maps +to explicit `FAIL`; this is neither a partial PASS nor `NOT_RUN`. + +## Measured no-DB result + +The owned healthy `health` service returned a compact 3657-byte OpenAPI 3.1.1 document containing +three operations. Every operationId was a dotted contract path: + +- `v1.health.list` — POST `/v1/health/list` +- `v1.health.updateStatus` — POST `/v1/health/updateStatus` +- `v1.health.health.check` — GET `/v1/health/health/check` + +Discovery rows measured 73, 89, and 88 compact UTF-8 bytes respectively. Per-operation request, +response, error, and all-schema source/local-dereferenced byte counts and every array/string limit +observation are recorded in `P2-no-db.json`. There were no local, external, or unresolved refs, so +source and locally dereferenced measurements are identical. + +The spec declared no non-2xx response for any operation. Each error view is therefore `{}` (2 +bytes). No common error envelope is observed or inferred for this no-database template. + +The context-blind object-key audit records the observed OpenAPI 3.1/JSON Schema 2020-12 allowlisted +keyword subset—including the present `summary` key—and separately records every non-allowlisted key +with its paths. Because the scan is context-blind, a schema property name matching a standard +keyword can appear as an observed keyword; the evidence states this limitation explicitly. No +measured array exceeded `maxItems=50`; the largest contained 5 items. No measured string exceeded +`maxStringLength=2000`; the longest contained 34 characters. These per-array/per-string limits do +not impose an aggregate cap: the current MCP path has no whole-result byte ceiling. + +## Failed DB branch + +The DB branch carries forward only the attributed normalized P1 failure: the generated SQLite +service exited 1 and remained unhealthy because its command omitted `--allow-ffi`, required by +`libsql`. It did not yield an attributable live DB spec. Per supervisor direction, it was not rerun, +patched, wrapped, or manually relaunched, and the ambiguous P1 HTTP 200 was not reused. + +## Evidence + +- `proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts` +- `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json` +- `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json` (retained 3657-byte hash-matched raw spec) +- `proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json` +- `proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json` +- `proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md` +- `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` (carried DB failure source) + +This implementation verdict does not claim #1128 acceptance and does not issue an IMPL-EVAL +disposition. It stops for separate supervisor/Fable review. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md index 94d1686b9f..6227072de3 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-attempts.md @@ -9,6 +9,6 @@ All paths below are normalized to the owned scratch root. No foreign AppHost, co | First retained runtime | Service failed before listening | The documented DB initialization/generation/seed prerequisites had not run; the service could not import `schema/.generated/zod/crud.ts`. Exact AppHost teardown passed before DB preparation. | | Prepared runtime | P1 `FAIL` | The post-allocation callback atomically wrote the complete manifest, but Aspire described `users` as `Finished` with exit code 1. Console logs show missing `--allow-ffi` for `libsql`. A later spec fetch returned 200, but listener PID/ownership and precise describe-to-fetch timing were not captured. Possible explanations include a restart, stale description, or foreign listener; the observation is ambiguous and does not satisfy D5. | -The root `deno.lock` hash remained `264f029ec1a000c9a2880eb1db926373a35a589d`. The final +The root `deno.lock` SHA-1 digest remained `264f029ec1a000c9a2880eb1db926373a35a589d`. The final exact-target stop left no owned AppHost process, port 3001 listener, or container. Normalized counts for foreign/unproven survivors are in `P1-resource-hygiene.json`; they were left untouched. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json index e4b479ebaa..ef881c3441 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json @@ -9,6 +9,7 @@ "scratchProject": "/p1-sqlite", "experiment": "proofs/experiments/p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts", "setup": { + "rootDenoLockDigestAlgorithm": "SHA-1", "scaffoldExitCode": 0, "aspireRestoreExitCode": 0, "dbInitExitCode": 0, diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..c786e17902 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +# P2 attempt and ownership record + +The read-only baseline contained two foreign AppHosts, six foreign/unproven containers, multiple +`aspire mcp start` processes, and no listener on port 43127. None was mutated. + +The first two detached no-DB starts exited when their launching command session ended, before a +service listener existed; no HTTP fetch was attempted or attributed to them. The retained owned run +used the same unmodified fresh scaffold with a live controlling session. Before fetching, Aspire +reported the `health` resource `Running`/`Healthy` at `http://localhost:43127`; the exact owned tree +was CLI PID 79779, AppHost PID 79849, service PID 80461, and DCP listener PID 80298. + +Only after that capture, the live `/api/openapi.json` request returned HTTP 200 and 3657 bytes at +2026-08-03T21:20:47.409Z. The exact AppHost path was then stopped. Port, process-tree, container, +and owned-root checks found zero owned survivors; the foreign baseline remained untouched. + +The SQLite branch was not restarted, patched, wrapped, or manually launched. Its normalized P1 +failure is carried through `P2-db-failure.json`; the ambiguous P1 HTTP 200 is expressly excluded. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..aefcd71f92 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json @@ -0,0 +1,19 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "proof": "P2", + "scaffold": "sqlite-db", + "status": "FAIL", + "execution": "not-rerun-by-supervisor-direction", + "carriedEvidence": "P1-runtime.json", + "serviceState": "Finished", + "serviceExitCode": 1, + "serviceHealth": "Unhealthy", + "liveSpecAttributed": false, + "failure": { + "classification": "generated-runtime-permission-defect", + "missingPermission": "--allow-ffi", + "dependency": "libsql" + }, + "excludedObservation": "The unattributed P1 HTTP 200 is not reused as DB-side P2 evidence.", + "d7Mapping": "D7 requires both scaffolds; a blocked or skipped branch maps to FAIL under D12." +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..063870a233 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +{"info":{"title":"Health API","version":"1.0.0","description":"health service"},"servers":[{"url":"/api"}],"openapi":"3.1.1","paths":{"/v1/health/list":{"post":{"operationId":"v1.health.list","requestBody":{"required":true,"content":{"application/json":{"schema":{"type":"object","properties":{"limit":{"type":"integer","minimum":-9007199254740991,"maximum":9007199254740991,"exclusiveMinimum":0,"description":"Number of records to return"},"offset":{"type":"integer","minimum":0,"maximum":9007199254740991,"description":"Starting offset"},"search":{"type":"string","minLength":1,"description":"Optional record name search"}},"required":["limit","offset"]}}}},"responses":{"200":{"description":"OK","content":{"application/json":{"schema":{"type":"object","properties":{"items":{"type":"array","items":{"type":"object","properties":{"id":{"type":"integer","minimum":-9007199254740991,"maximum":9007199254740991,"exclusiveMinimum":0,"description":"Stable identifier"},"name":{"type":"string","minLength":1,"description":"Display name"},"summary":{"type":"string","minLength":1,"description":"Short record summary"},"status":{"enum":["active","draft","archived"],"type":"string","description":"Record lifecycle status"},"createdAt":{"type":"string","format":"date-time","description":"ISO creation timestamp"}},"required":["id","name","summary","status","createdAt"]},"description":"Returned service records"},"total":{"type":"integer","minimum":0,"maximum":9007199254740991,"description":"Total matching records"},"limit":{"type":"integer","minimum":-9007199254740991,"maximum":9007199254740991,"exclusiveMinimum":0,"description":"Requested page size"},"offset":{"type":"integer","minimum":0,"maximum":9007199254740991,"description":"Requested offset"},"hasMore":{"type":"boolean","description":"Whether more records are available"}},"required":["items","total","limit","offset","hasMore"]}}}}}}},"/v1/health/updateStatus":{"post":{"operationId":"v1.health.updateStatus","requestBody":{"required":true,"content":{"application/json":{"schema":{"type":"object","properties":{"id":{"type":"integer","minimum":-9007199254740991,"maximum":9007199254740991,"exclusiveMinimum":0,"description":"Stable identifier"},"status":{"enum":["active","draft","archived"],"type":"string","description":"Next lifecycle status"}},"required":["id","status"]}}}},"responses":{"200":{"description":"OK","content":{"application/json":{"schema":{"type":"object","properties":{"id":{"type":"integer","minimum":-9007199254740991,"maximum":9007199254740991,"exclusiveMinimum":0,"description":"Stable identifier"},"name":{"type":"string","minLength":1,"description":"Display name"},"summary":{"type":"string","minLength":1,"description":"Short record summary"},"status":{"enum":["active","draft","archived"],"type":"string","description":"Record lifecycle status"},"createdAt":{"type":"string","format":"date-time","description":"ISO creation timestamp"}},"required":["id","name","summary","status","createdAt"]}}}}}}},"/v1/health/health/check":{"get":{"operationId":"v1.health.health.check","parameters":[],"responses":{"200":{"description":"OK","content":{"application/json":{"schema":{"type":"object","properties":{"status":{"enum":["healthy","unhealthy","degraded"],"type":"string","description":"Service health status"},"service":{"type":"string","description":"Service name"},"version":{"type":"string","description":"Service version"},"timestamp":{"type":"string","format":"date-time","description":"ISO timestamp"},"uptime":{"type":"integer","minimum":0,"maximum":9007199254740991,"description":"Uptime in seconds"}},"required":["status","service","version","timestamp"]}}}}}}}}} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8c00c9e679 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json @@ -0,0 +1,532 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "proof": "P2", + "scaffold": "no-db", + "measuredAt": "2026-08-03T21:32:02.002Z", + "sourceSpec": { + "compactUtf8Bytes": 3657, + "fetchedRawBytes": 3657, + "sha256": "8f8cf105d9eecac2b701354815ef94e6d509948019ae4129772759bdf0a985c3" + }, + "operationCount": 3, + "operations": [ + { + "operationId": "v1.health.list", + "operationIdShape": "dotted-contract-path", + "method": "POST", + "path": "/v1/health/list", + "discoveryRow": { + "bytes": 73, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 3, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 15, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "views": { + "request": { + "source": { + "bytes": 485, + "limits": { + "arrays": 2, + "strings": 9, + "maxArrayLength": 2, + "maxStringLength": 27, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 485, + "limits": { + "arrays": 2, + "strings": 9, + "maxArrayLength": 2, + "maxStringLength": 27, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "response": { + "source": { + "bytes": 1221, + "limits": { + "arrays": 3, + "strings": 37, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 34, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 1221, + "limits": { + "arrays": 3, + "strings": 37, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 34, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "error": { + "source": { + "bytes": 2, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 0, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 0, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 2, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 0, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 0, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "allSchemas": { + "source": { + "bytes": 1731, + "limits": { + "arrays": 5, + "strings": 46, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 34, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 1731, + "limits": { + "arrays": 5, + "strings": 46, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 34, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + } + }, + "non2xx": [], + "commonErrorEnvelopeInferred": false + }, + { + "operationId": "v1.health.updateStatus", + "operationIdShape": "dotted-contract-path", + "method": "POST", + "path": "/v1/health/updateStatus", + "discoveryRow": { + "bytes": 89, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 3, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 23, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "views": { + "request": { + "source": { + "bytes": 387, + "limits": { + "arrays": 3, + "strings": 10, + "maxArrayLength": 3, + "maxStringLength": 21, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 387, + "limits": { + "arrays": 3, + "strings": 10, + "maxArrayLength": 3, + "maxStringLength": 21, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "response": { + "source": { + "bytes": 634, + "limits": { + "arrays": 2, + "strings": 21, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 23, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 634, + "limits": { + "arrays": 2, + "strings": 21, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 23, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "error": { + "source": { + "bytes": 2, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 0, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 0, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 2, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 0, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 0, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "allSchemas": { + "source": { + "bytes": 1046, + "limits": { + "arrays": 5, + "strings": 31, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 23, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 1046, + "limits": { + "arrays": 5, + "strings": 31, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 23, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + } + }, + "non2xx": [], + "commonErrorEnvelopeInferred": false + }, + { + "operationId": "v1.health.health.check", + "operationIdShape": "dotted-contract-path", + "method": "GET", + "path": "/v1/health/health/check", + "discoveryRow": { + "bytes": 88, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 3, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 23, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "views": { + "request": { + "source": { + "bytes": 36, + "limits": { + "arrays": 1, + "strings": 0, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 0, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 36, + "limits": { + "arrays": 1, + "strings": 0, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 0, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "response": { + "source": { + "bytes": 563, + "limits": { + "arrays": 2, + "strings": 20, + "maxArrayLength": 4, + "maxStringLength": 21, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 563, + "limits": { + "arrays": 2, + "strings": 20, + "maxArrayLength": 4, + "maxStringLength": 21, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "error": { + "source": { + "bytes": 2, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 0, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 0, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 2, + "limits": { + "arrays": 0, + "strings": 0, + "maxArrayLength": 0, + "maxStringLength": 0, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + }, + "allSchemas": { + "source": { + "bytes": 624, + "limits": { + "arrays": 3, + "strings": 20, + "maxArrayLength": 4, + "maxStringLength": 21, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + }, + "localDereferenced": { + "bytes": 624, + "limits": { + "arrays": 3, + "strings": 20, + "maxArrayLength": 4, + "maxStringLength": 21, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + } + } + } + }, + "non2xx": [], + "commonErrorEnvelopeInferred": false + } + ], + "references": { + "local": [], + "external": [], + "unresolved": [] + }, + "recursivelyObservedKeywords": [ + "content", + "description", + "enum", + "exclusiveMinimum", + "format", + "get", + "info", + "items", + "maximum", + "minLength", + "minimum", + "name", + "openapi", + "operationId", + "parameters", + "paths", + "post", + "properties", + "requestBody", + "required", + "responses", + "schema", + "servers", + "summary", + "title", + "type", + "url", + "version" + ], + "nonAllowlistedObjectKeys": [ + { + "key": "/v1/health/health/check", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/health/check" + ] + }, + { + "key": "/v1/health/list", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list" + ] + }, + { + "key": "/v1/health/updateStatus", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus" + ] + }, + { + "key": "200", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200", + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus/post/responses/200", + "$/paths//v1/health/health/check/get/responses/200" + ] + }, + { + "key": "application/json", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/requestBody/content/application/json", + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200/content/application/json", + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus/post/requestBody/content/application/json", + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus/post/responses/200/content/application/json", + "$/paths//v1/health/health/check/get/responses/200/content/application/json" + ] + }, + { + "key": "createdAt", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/items/items/properties/createdAt", + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/createdAt" + ] + }, + { + "key": "hasMore", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/hasMore" + ] + }, + { + "key": "id", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/items/items/properties/id", + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus/post/requestBody/content/application/json/schema/properties/id", + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/id" + ] + }, + { + "key": "limit", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/requestBody/content/application/json/schema/properties/limit", + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/limit" + ] + }, + { + "key": "offset", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/requestBody/content/application/json/schema/properties/offset", + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/offset" + ] + }, + { + "key": "search", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/requestBody/content/application/json/schema/properties/search" + ] + }, + { + "key": "service", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/health/check/get/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/service" + ] + }, + { + "key": "status", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/items/items/properties/status", + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus/post/requestBody/content/application/json/schema/properties/status", + "$/paths//v1/health/updateStatus/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/status", + "$/paths//v1/health/health/check/get/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/status" + ] + }, + { + "key": "timestamp", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/health/check/get/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/timestamp" + ] + }, + { + "key": "total", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/list/post/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/total" + ] + }, + { + "key": "uptime", + "paths": [ + "$/paths//v1/health/health/check/get/responses/200/content/application/json/schema/properties/uptime" + ] + } + ], + "keywordScanLimitation": "Context-blind object-key scan: a schema property name equal to a standard keyword is reported as observed; non-allowlisted keys and paths make omissions auditable.", + "wholeSpecLimits": { + "arrays": 12, + "strings": 105, + "maxArrayLength": 5, + "maxStringLength": 34, + "arrayViolations": [], + "stringViolations": [] + }, + "truncationPolicy": { + "maxItems": 50, + "maxStringLength": 2000, + "wholeResultByteCeiling": null, + "note": "The current MCP path has no whole-result byte ceiling." + }, + "interpretation": { + "validLiveSpec": true, + "commonErrorEnvelopeObserved": false, + "note": "No non-2xx response was declared by this no-database template; no common error envelope is inferred." + } +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..25f5ee83ca --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json @@ -0,0 +1,57 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "proof": "P2", + "capturedAt": "2026-08-03T21:22:04.495Z", + "versions": { "aspireCli": "13.4.6", "deno": "2.9.3" }, + "commands": [ + "netscript-dev init p2-no-db --db none --service --service-name health --service-port 43127 --no-git --ci --json", + "aspire restore --apphost ./apphost.mts", + "aspire start --apphost ./apphost.mts", + "aspire describe --apphost /p2-no-db/p2-no-db/aspire/apphost.mts --format Json", + "deno eval ", + "deno run --no-lock --allow-read --allow-write proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json", + "aspire stop --apphost /p2-no-db/p2-no-db/aspire/apphost.mts --non-interactive --nologo", + "deno task agentic:leak-check -- --slice-dir --worktree --owned-root /p2-no-db" + ], + "baseline": { + "foreignAppHosts": 2, + "foreignOrUnprovenContainers": 6, + "port43127Listener": false, + "aspireMcpProcessesPresentAndUntouched": true + }, + "ownedRun": { + "scratchProject": "/p2-no-db/p2-no-db", + "appHostPath": "/p2-no-db/p2-no-db/aspire/apphost.mts", + "cliPid": 79779, + "appHostPid": 79849, + "servicePid": 80461, + "proxyPid": 80298, + "service": "health", + "serviceStateBeforeFetch": "Running", + "serviceHealthBeforeFetch": "Healthy", + "serviceUrlBeforeFetch": "http://localhost:43127", + "listenerBeforeFetch": "127.0.0.1:43127 owned by DCP proxy PID 80298 in AppHost tree", + "fetch": { + "url": "http://localhost:43127/api/openapi.json", + "status": 200, + "contentType": "application/json", + "fetchedAt": "2026-08-03T21:20:47.409Z", + "bytes": 3657, + "sha256": "8f8cf105d9eecac2b701354815ef94e6d509948019ae4129772759bdf0a985c3", + "attributedToOwnedService": true + } + }, + "rootLock": { + "digestAlgorithm": "SHA-256", + "before": "c031d4f71e30f3792a071381b51fa82ae37b7c7f953842ae4d26383a4cf91b24", + "after": "c031d4f71e30f3792a071381b51fa82ae37b7c7f953842ae4d26383a4cf91b24" + }, + "teardown": { + "exactAppHostStopExitCode": 0, + "ownedAppHostsRemaining": 0, + "ownedPort43127ListenersRemaining": 0, + "ownedProcessesRemaining": 0, + "ownedContainersRemaining": 0, + "foreignResourcesMutated": false + } +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..690d488c4b --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts @@ -0,0 +1,328 @@ +const MAX_ITEMS = 50; +const MAX_STRING_LENGTH = 2000; +const METHODS = new Set(['get', 'put', 'post', 'delete', 'options', 'head', 'patch', 'trace']); +const encoder = new TextEncoder(); + +type Json = null | boolean | number | string | Json[] | { [key: string]: Json }; +type Obj = { [key: string]: Json }; + +const [inputPath, outputPath] = Deno.args; +if (!inputPath || !outputPath) { + throw new Error('usage: p2-measure-live-spec.ts '); +} + +const bytes = await Deno.readFile(inputPath); +const spec = JSON.parse(new TextDecoder().decode(bytes)) as Obj; +const compactBytes = (value: Json) => encoder.encode(JSON.stringify(value)).length; +const pointer = (root: Json, ref: string): Json | undefined => { + if (!ref.startsWith('#/')) return undefined; + let current: Json | undefined = root; + for (const raw of ref.slice(2).split('/')) { + const key = raw.replaceAll('~1', '/').replaceAll('~0', '~'); + if (!current || Array.isArray(current) || typeof current !== 'object') return undefined; + current = current[key]; + } + return current; +}; + +const refs = { + local: new Set(), + external: new Set(), + unresolved: new Set(), +}; +const scanRefs = (value: Json): void => { + if (!value || typeof value !== 'object') return; + if (Array.isArray(value)) return value.forEach(scanRefs); + if (typeof value.$ref === 'string') { + const ref = value.$ref; + if (ref.startsWith('#')) { + refs.local.add(ref); + if (pointer(spec, ref) === undefined) refs.unresolved.add(ref); + } else refs.external.add(ref); + } + Object.values(value).forEach(scanRefs); +}; +scanRefs(spec); + +const dereference = (value: Json, stack = new Set()): Json => { + if (!value || typeof value !== 'object') return value; + if (Array.isArray(value)) return value.map((item) => dereference(item, new Set(stack))); + if (typeof value.$ref === 'string' && value.$ref.startsWith('#')) { + const ref = value.$ref; + const target = pointer(spec, ref); + if (target === undefined || stack.has(ref)) return value; + const next = new Set(stack); + next.add(ref); + const resolved = dereference(target, next); + return resolved && !Array.isArray(resolved) && typeof resolved === 'object' + ? { + ...resolved, + ...Object.fromEntries(Object.entries(value).filter(([key]) => key !== '$ref')), + } + : resolved; + } + return Object.fromEntries( + Object.entries(value).map(([key, item]) => [key, dereference(item, new Set(stack))]), + ); +}; + +const STANDARD_KEYWORDS = new Set([ + // JSON Schema 2020-12 core, applicator, validation, format, content, and metadata vocabularies. + '$anchor', + '$comment', + '$defs', + '$dynamicAnchor', + '$dynamicRef', + '$id', + '$ref', + '$schema', + '$vocabulary', + 'additionalProperties', + 'allOf', + 'anyOf', + 'const', + 'contains', + 'contentEncoding', + 'contentMediaType', + 'contentSchema', + 'default', + 'deprecated', + 'description', + 'dependentRequired', + 'dependentSchemas', + 'enum', + 'examples', + 'exclusiveMaximum', + 'exclusiveMinimum', + 'format', + 'if', + 'items', + 'maximum', + 'maxContains', + 'maxItems', + 'maxLength', + 'maxProperties', + 'minimum', + 'minContains', + 'minItems', + 'minLength', + 'minProperties', + 'multipleOf', + 'not', + 'oneOf', + 'pattern', + 'patternProperties', + 'prefixItems', + 'properties', + 'propertyNames', + 'readOnly', + 'required', + 'then', + 'title', + 'type', + 'unevaluatedItems', + 'unevaluatedProperties', + 'uniqueItems', + 'writeOnly', + // OpenAPI 3.1 fixed fields across the root and component object families. + 'allowEmptyValue', + 'allowReserved', + 'callbacks', + 'components', + 'contact', + 'content', + 'cookies', + 'description', + 'discriminator', + 'email', + 'encoding', + 'example', + 'explode', + 'expression', + 'externalDocs', + 'flows', + 'headers', + 'identifier', + 'implicit', + 'in', + 'info', + 'jsonSchemaDialect', + 'label', + 'license', + 'links', + 'name', + 'oauth2', + 'openIdConnectUrl', + 'openapi', + 'operationId', + 'parameter', + 'parameters', + 'password', + 'paths', + 'refreshUrl', + 'requestBodies', + 'requestBody', + 'responses', + 'schema', + 'schemas', + 'scopes', + 'security', + 'securitySchemes', + 'servers', + 'style', + 'summary', + 'tags', + 'termsOfService', + 'tokenUrl', + 'type', + 'url', + 'userName', + 'variables', + 'version', + 'webhooks', + 'xml', +]); +const keywordSet = new Set(); +const nonAllowlistedKeyPaths = new Map(); +const scanKeywords = (value: Json, path = '$'): void => { + if (!value || typeof value !== 'object') return; + if (Array.isArray(value)) { + return value.forEach((item, index) => scanKeywords(item, `${path}/${index}`)); + } + for (const [key, item] of Object.entries(value)) { + if (STANDARD_KEYWORDS.has(key) || METHODS.has(key)) keywordSet.add(key); + else { + const paths = nonAllowlistedKeyPaths.get(key) ?? []; + paths.push(`${path}/${key}`); + nonAllowlistedKeyPaths.set(key, paths); + } + scanKeywords(item, `${path}/${key}`); + } +}; +scanKeywords(spec); + +const limits = (value: Json) => { + let arrays = 0, strings = 0, maxArrayLength = 0, maxStringLength = 0; + const arrayViolations: string[] = [], stringViolations: string[] = []; + const visit = (item: Json, path: string): void => { + if (typeof item === 'string') { + strings++; + maxStringLength = Math.max(maxStringLength, item.length); + if (item.length > MAX_STRING_LENGTH) stringViolations.push(path); + } else if (Array.isArray(item)) { + arrays++; + maxArrayLength = Math.max(maxArrayLength, item.length); + if (item.length > MAX_ITEMS) arrayViolations.push(path); + item.forEach((child, index) => visit(child, `${path}/${index}`)); + } else if (item && typeof item === 'object') { + Object.entries(item).forEach(([key, child]) => visit(child, `${path}/${key}`)); + } + }; + visit(value, '$'); + return { arrays, strings, maxArrayLength, maxStringLength, arrayViolations, stringViolations }; +}; + +const measureView = (source: Json) => { + const localDereferenced = dereference(source); + return { + source: { bytes: compactBytes(source), limits: limits(source) }, + localDereferenced: { + bytes: compactBytes(localDereferenced), + limits: limits(localDereferenced), + }, + }; +}; + +const paths = spec.paths as Obj ?? {}; +const operations: Json[] = []; +for (const [path, pathItem] of Object.entries(paths)) { + if (!pathItem || Array.isArray(pathItem) || typeof pathItem !== 'object') continue; + for (const [method, operation] of Object.entries(pathItem)) { + if ( + !METHODS.has(method) || !operation || Array.isArray(operation) || + typeof operation !== 'object' + ) continue; + const operationId = typeof operation.operationId === 'string' ? operation.operationId : null; + const responses = operation.responses && !Array.isArray(operation.responses) && + typeof operation.responses === 'object' + ? operation.responses as Obj + : {}; + const success = Object.fromEntries( + Object.entries(responses).filter(([status]) => /^2\d\d$/.test(status)), + ); + const errors = Object.fromEntries( + Object.entries(responses).filter(([status]) => !/^2\d\d$/.test(status)), + ); + const request = { + parameters: operation.parameters ?? [], + requestBody: operation.requestBody ?? null, + } as Json; + const allSchemas = { request, responses } as Json; + const row = { operationId, method: method.toUpperCase(), path } as Json; + operations.push({ + operationId, + operationIdShape: operationId === null + ? 'missing' + : operationId.includes('.') + ? 'dotted-contract-path' + : 'non-dotted', + method: method.toUpperCase(), + path, + discoveryRow: { bytes: compactBytes(row), limits: limits(row) }, + views: { + request: measureView(request), + response: measureView(success), + error: measureView(errors), + allSchemas: measureView(allSchemas), + }, + non2xx: Object.entries(errors).map(([status, response]) => ({ + status, + response, + bytes: compactBytes(response), + })), + commonErrorEnvelopeInferred: false, + }); + } +} + +const evidence = { + schemaVersion: 1, + proof: 'P2', + scaffold: 'no-db', + measuredAt: new Date().toISOString(), + sourceSpec: { + compactUtf8Bytes: compactBytes(spec), + fetchedRawBytes: bytes.length, + sha256: await crypto.subtle.digest('SHA-256', bytes).then((hash) => + Array.from(new Uint8Array(hash), (byte) => byte.toString(16).padStart(2, '0')).join('') + ), + }, + operationCount: operations.length, + operations, + references: { + local: [...refs.local].sort(), + external: [...refs.external].sort(), + unresolved: [...refs.unresolved].sort(), + }, + recursivelyObservedKeywords: [...keywordSet].sort(), + nonAllowlistedObjectKeys: [...nonAllowlistedKeyPaths.entries()].sort(([left], [right]) => + left.localeCompare(right) + ).map(([key, paths]) => ({ key, paths })), + keywordScanLimitation: + 'Context-blind object-key scan: a schema property name equal to a standard keyword is reported as observed; non-allowlisted keys and paths make omissions auditable.', + wholeSpecLimits: limits(spec), + truncationPolicy: { + maxItems: MAX_ITEMS, + maxStringLength: MAX_STRING_LENGTH, + wholeResultByteCeiling: null, + note: 'The current MCP path has no whole-result byte ceiling.', + }, + interpretation: { + validLiveSpec: true, + commonErrorEnvelopeObserved: false, + note: + 'No non-2xx response was declared by this no-database template; no common error envelope is inferred.', + }, +}; + +await Deno.writeTextFile(outputPath, `${JSON.stringify(evidence, null, 2)}\n`); diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S2-fable-rereview.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S2-fable-rereview.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..271a5e48d5 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S2-fable-rereview.md @@ -0,0 +1,91 @@ +APPROVED + +# S2 Fable re-review — amended P2 evidence + +- Reviewer: Claude Fable 5, fresh separate native session (advisory slice review, not IMPL-EVAL). +- Scope: read-only verification of the amendments named in `briefs/S2-review-fixes.md` against + `reviews/S2-fable.md`. No implementation/evidence file was edited; no scaffold, AppHost, commit, + push, or GitHub contact occurred. Two verification commands were run: a read-only + `sha256sum`/`wc -c` over the committed and scratch raw specs, and a sandboxed re-run of + `p2-measure-live-spec.ts` against the committed raw spec writing only to the session scratch + directory, followed by a structural diff and an independent key-completeness check. + +## Per-finding disposition + +### M1 (keyword evidence omitted a present standard keyword) — RESOLVED + +- `p2-measure-live-spec.ts` now carries an explicit `STANDARD_KEYWORDS` allowlist covering the + JSON Schema 2020-12 vocabularies and OpenAPI 3.1 fixed fields (including `summary`, `tags`, + `license`, `contact`, `const`, `prefixItems`, `$schema`), plus HTTP method keys, and every + non-allowlisted object key is emitted with its full paths in `nonAllowlistedObjectKeys`. +- Independently re-verified: I re-ran the amended script on the committed raw spec into a scratch + output; excluding `measuredAt`, the regenerated evidence is byte-for-byte structurally identical + to the committed `P2-no-db.json`. An independent traversal of every object key in the raw spec + confirms the union of `recursivelyObservedKeywords` and `nonAllowlistedObjectKeys` covers **all** + keys with an empty remainder and no overlap — no key can now be silently dropped. `summary` is + present in the committed keyword list. +- The context-blind property-name limitation is documented in the evidence + (`keywordScanLimitation`) and restated honestly in `P2-verdict.md`. + +### Raw-spec retention (M1 action 3) — RESOLVED + +`proofs/evidence/P2-no-db-live-spec.json` is exactly 3657 bytes, SHA-256 +`8f8cf105d9eecac2b701354815ef94e6d509948019ae4129772759bdf0a985c3`, matching both the scratch copy +and the recorded fetch in `P2-runtime.json` (`fetchedRawBytes: 3657`, same hash). It is +credential-free. Keyword completeness stays auditable after scratch cleanup. + +### Verdict sentence (M1 action 4) — RESOLVED + +`P2-verdict.md` now states the allowlisted-subset claim precisely, names the present `summary` key, +describes the separate non-allowlisted key record, and states the context-blindness limitation. + +### m1 (lint-ignore gate note) — RESOLVED + +The worklog static-gate row now reads "No lint-ignore directive in either P1 or P2 experiment." +Verified: neither `p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts` nor `p2-measure-live-spec.ts` contains a +`deno-lint-ignore` directive. + +### m2 (undrifted plan-command deviation) — RESOLVED + +`drift.md` has an append-only entry ("P2 split fetch/measurement command") recording the filename +change (`p2-measure-spec.ts` → `p2-measure-live-spec.ts`), the split bounded fetch, and the +narrowed permissions (`--no-lock --allow-read --allow-write`, no network), with severity minor and +evidence pointers. `P2-runtime.json`'s command list matches the executed split. + +### m3 (digest algorithm) — RESOLVED + +`P1-runtime.json` now names `rootDenoLockDigestAlgorithm: "SHA-1"` and `P2-runtime.json` names +`"digestAlgorithm": "SHA-256"`; the historical hex values are unchanged, so the 40-vs-64-hex +distinction is explicit and cross-slice comparison is possible. + +## Reconfirmed from the first review + +- **Combined P2 `FAIL` stands and remains the only truthful D7/D12 outcome.** The DB branch is + carried solely as the attributed normalized failure (`P2-db-failure.json`: exit 1, missing + `--allow-ffi`, `liveSpecAttributed: false`); the ambiguous P1 HTTP 200 remains expressly + excluded in the failure record, attempts record, and verdict. No partial PASS or `NOT_RUN` + laundering appeared during amendment. +- **Measurement claims still hold.** Regeneration from the committed raw spec reproduces every + byte/limit/reference/keyword value in `P2-no-db.json`; the source vs locally-dereferenced + equality remains legitimate (zero `$ref`s); error views remain `{}`/2 bytes with + `commonErrorEnvelopeObserved: false` stated, not inferred; truncation policy values still match + `DEFAULT_TRUNCATION_POLICY`, with the absent whole-result byte ceiling stated explicitly. +- **Scope hygiene.** `git status` shows only run-dir changes; no product, template, or lock churn. +- **#1128 acceptance must remain unchecked.** Only the no-DB half of the required two-scaffold + measurement exists; the DB half awaits the rescoped `--allow-ffi` product fix. The verdict, + worklog gate tables, and context-pack all map the combined state to `FAIL` and withhold any + acceptance or closing-keyword claim. Checking the box would misrepresent a missing required + measurement as done, exactly what RFC §4 S-17 forbids. + +## New blocking findings + +None. + +## Summary + +All four findings from `reviews/S2-fable.md` are resolved with verifiable evidence: the keyword +record is now provably complete over the hash-matched committed raw spec (independent full-key +audit shows zero uncaptured keys), unknown keys are auditable with paths, the limitation is honest, +and the three record-hygiene items are corrected without altering historical values. The combined +P2 `FAIL` is unchanged and correctly not represented as #1128 acceptance. This is advisory slice +review, not IMPL-EVAL. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S2-fable.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S2-fable.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0ba75efc43 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S2-fable.md @@ -0,0 +1,135 @@ +CHANGES_REQUESTED + +# S2 opposite-family review — P2 no-DB measurement and DB failure + +- Reviewer: Claude Fable 5, separate native session (advisory `review_codex` slice review, not + IMPL-EVAL). +- Scope: stable uncommitted S2 diff only. This session edited no implementation/evidence file, ran + no AppHost or scaffold, and contacted no GitHub surface. One read-only verification command was + run against the already-existing scratch copy of the fetched spec + (`.llm/tmp/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs/p2-no-db-live-spec.json`); nothing was mutated. +- Inputs read: `plan.md` (D3/D7/D8/D10/D12), `plan-eval.md`, seed `rfc.md` §4/§9, + `research.md` (#1127–#1129/#1123 re-baseline), `briefs/S2-no-db-rescope.md`, + `reviews/S1-fable-rereview.md` (APPROVED), `proofs/P2-verdict.md`, + `proofs/experiments/p2-measure-live-spec.ts`, `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json`, + `proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json`, `proofs/evidence/P2-runtime.json`, + `proofs/evidence/P2-attempts.md`, `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` (carried DB failure), + `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, and + `packages/mcp/src/application/runner/truncation.ts`. + +## Verdict-shape determination + +**The explicit combined P2 `FAIL` is the only truthful D7/D12 outcome.** D7 requires measured +evidence for *both* the DB and no-DB scaffolds. The DB branch has no attributable live spec: the +generated SQLite service exited 1 for lack of `--allow-ffi` (attributed in `P1-runtime.json`), the +supervisor's brief forbade rerunning/patching/wrapping it, and the unattributed P1 HTTP 200 is +explicitly excluded (`P2-db-failure.json:17`, `P2-attempts.md:16-17`). A partial PASS would launder +a missing required branch; `NOT_RUN` is barred by the plan's skip-as-FAIL rule and RFC §4 S-17 +("a skipped proof must be indistinguishable from a failed one, not from a passed one"). The verdict +correctly issues neither a #1128-acceptance claim nor an IMPL-EVAL disposition. + +## Confirmed sound (adversarially checked) + +- **No P1-200 reuse.** The DB-side carry-forward is only the normalized failure record; the + ambiguous P1 HTTP 200 is expressly excluded in `P2-db-failure.json`, `P2-attempts.md`, and the + verdict. +- **Attribution of the no-DB spec.** One owned fresh scaffold; pre-fetch Aspire state + `Running`/`Healthy` at `http://localhost:43127`; the port-43127 listener bound to DCP proxy + PID 80298 inside the captured owned tree (CLI 79779 → AppHost 79849 → service 80461); baseline + showed no pre-existing 43127 listener; fetch timestamp (21:20:47Z) precedes measurement + (21:21:55Z) and capture (21:22:04Z). This satisfies the attribution bar S1's M1 established. The + two failed detached starts produced no fetch and are preserved, not smoothed over. +- **Measured, not inferred (byte/limit claims).** I recomputed independently: the compact-UTF-8 + spec byte count (3657) and SHA-256 (`8f8cf105…`) of the retained raw spec match both + `P2-runtime.json` and `P2-no-db.json`; the `v1.health.list` discovery row is exactly 73 compact + bytes by hand count. Source and locally dereferenced views are legitimately identical because the + spec contains zero `$ref`s (local/external/unresolved all empty). Error views are `{}`/2 bytes + because no operation declares a non-2xx response; `commonErrorEnvelopeObserved: false` is stated, + not inferred — matching research finding 8 for the bare-`oc` no-DB contract. +- **D8 statement.** `maxItems=50`/`maxStringLength=2000` match + `truncation.ts` (`DEFAULT_TRUNCATION_POLICY`), per-item limits are compared everywhere + (max array 5, max string 34, zero violations), and the absent whole-result byte ceiling is + stated explicitly rather than implied as protection. +- **Tool algorithms (except M1 below).** JSON-pointer resolution handles `~0`/`~1`; dereference has + per-branch cycle guards and preserves `$ref` siblings; operation extraction filters to real HTTP + methods; the 2xx/non-2xx split is a correct status-code regex; limits traversal counts every + array/string with violation paths. +- **Normalization under D10.** Scratch paths are ``-normalized; no credentials or + foreign absolute paths appear. The retained owned PIDs and timestamps are load-bearing + attribution/ordering evidence, which D10's "verdicts cite commands, timestamps" clause requires — + they are not gratuitous volatile noise. +- **Fixed-port ownership, teardown, hygiene.** Baseline read-only inventory (2 foreign AppHosts, + 6 foreign/unproven containers, Aspire MCP processes) untouched; exact-path stop exit 0; zero + owned processes/listeners/containers surviving; root `deno.lock` hash identical before/after; + git status shows only run-dir changes — no product or template workaround was made. +- **Misreading risk.** No artifact can be honestly read as satisfying #1128: verdict, worklog gate + tables, context-pack, and `P2-db-failure.json` all state the DB half is missing and map it to + FAIL. + +## Findings (ranked) + +### M1 (major) — keyword evidence omits an actually-present OpenAPI keyword + +`p2-measure-live-spec.ts:69-124` derives `recursivelyObservedKeywords` by filtering object keys +through a hardcoded `STANDARD_KEYWORDS` allowlist. That list omits real OpenAPI/JSON-Schema +keywords (`summary`, `tags`, `license`, `contact`, `const`, `prefixItems`, `$schema`, …). I +verified against the retained raw spec (SHA-256 matches the committed evidence): the spec contains +**`summary`**, which is absent from the committed keyword list in `P2-no-db.json`. The verdict's +claim that "the recursively observed OpenAPI/JSON-Schema keyword subset is recorded" is therefore +false for at least one present keyword — an A14/D7 evidence-fidelity defect, and consequential +because RFC §4 routes exactly this list into the Wave-1 S-5 validator-subset design; a silent +undercount there produces a validator that rejects legitimate generated specs. Secondary design +caveat: the scan is context-blind, so a schema *property* named like a keyword (e.g. a property +`title`) would be counted as an observed keyword — no confirmed false positive in this spec, but +the limitation is undocumented. + +**Required action (no runtime rerun needed):** the raw spec survives at +`/p2-no-db-live-spec.json` and hash-matches the evidence. (1) Fix the keyword +derivation — either scan all object keys and report unrecognized keys in a separate +`nonAllowlistedKeys` field, or complete the allowlist against the OpenAPI 3.1 / JSON Schema +2020-12 keyword sets — and note the context-blindness limitation; (2) re-run the script on the +retained spec and regenerate `P2-no-db.json`; (3) commit the normalized raw spec (3657 bytes, +credential-free) under `proofs/evidence/` so keyword completeness stays auditable after scratch +cleanup; (4) update the verdict sentence accordingly. None of this changes the combined `FAIL`. + +### m1 (minor) — stale lint-ignore gate note + +`worklog.md` static-gate row still reads "No lint-ignore directive in the P1 experiment"; S2 added +a second experiment file. I verified `p2-measure-live-spec.ts` contains no ignore directive, so the +fact holds — update the note to cover both files so the gate table matches its evidence. + +### m2 (minor) — undrifted deviation from the plan's P2 command row + +Plan validation row 4 names `p2-measure-spec.ts` with `--allow-read --allow-net`; the actual run +used `p2-measure-live-spec.ts` with `--no-lock --allow-read --allow-write` plus a separate bounded +`deno eval` fetch. The split (fetch separately, measure from file) is *better* — the measurement +tool needs no network — but it is a plan deviation and drift is explicit by Operating Rule 5. Add a +minor drift entry. + +### m3 (info) — root-lock hash algorithm inconsistent across evidence + +`P1-runtime.json` records a 40-hex root-lock digest; `P2-runtime.json` a 64-hex one. Both prove +no-change within their own run, but the algorithm should be named (or unified) so cross-slice +comparison is possible. + +## May #1128's acceptance box be checked? + +**No.** #1128 requires the spec-fidelity/size dry-run for both the DB-backed and no-database +scaffolds (D7; RFC §4 P2). Only the no-DB half is measured; the DB half is blocked by the +attributed generated `--allow-ffi` defect and was correctly not worked around. Until a healthy +DB-backed scaffold is measured after the rescoped product fix, checking the box would represent a +missing measurement as done — precisely the false-green state S-17 forbids. The truthful state is: +P2 verdict committed as explicit `FAIL`; issue remains open with the no-DB half's evidence linked +as partial progress (no closing keyword). + +## Summary + +The S2 draft is honest where it matters most: the combined `FAIL` is the only truthful verdict, the +DB branch is carried as an attributed failure rather than laundered, the no-DB measurement is +attributably owned, independently recomputed values check out, teardown/hygiene/lock evidence is +sound, and no product workaround occurred. `CHANGES_REQUESTED` rests on M1: the committed keyword +observation is provably incomplete (`summary` present in the hash-matched raw spec, absent from +evidence), and that list is a named input to Wave-1 validator design. M1 is fixable from the +retained raw spec without any new runtime run; m1–m3 are record-hygiene fixes. After amendment, +this reviewer expects re-review to be a fast APPROVED. This is advisory slice review, not +IMPL-EVAL. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md index f1726fd84d..a944512d07 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -91,6 +91,11 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | 2026-08-03 | S1 | runtime verdict | P1 is explicit `FAIL`: Aspire described `users` as `Finished` / exit 1 because generated permissions omit `--allow-ffi`. The later HTTP 200 is unattributed and cannot satisfy D5. Qualified F1(b) is selected without refuting the seam. | | 2026-08-03 | S1 | Fable review | First review requested six evidence/wording corrections; the same Codex thread amended them without rerunning Aspire. Native Fable re-review approved all dispositions and found no new blocker. | | 2026-08-03 | S1 | rescope recommendation | Product fix remains outside this PR. Only DB-backed P2 is blocked; no-DB P2 and P3 remain independently runnable after supervisor authorization. Exact owned teardown and hygiene checks passed. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | baseline | Re-inventoried two foreign AppHosts, six foreign/unproven containers, port 43127, and Aspire MCP processes read-only. No foreign or unproven resource was mutated. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | no-DB measurement | Fresh local-source `--db none` scaffold produced an attributed healthy 3657-byte OpenAPI 3.1.1 spec with three dotted operationIds, no refs, no non-2xx responses/common envelope, and no truncation-limit exceedance. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | DB carry-forward | Did not rerun or modify SQLite. Carried the attributed P1 missing-`--allow-ffi` failure forward and explicitly excluded the ambiguous P1 HTTP 200. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | teardown/verdict | Exact owned AppHost stopped; zero owned processes, port listeners, or containers survived. P2 is explicit `FAIL` because D7 requires both branches; #1128 acceptance remains open. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | Fable review | First review found an incomplete keyword allowlist. The same Codex thread retained the raw spec and made all keys auditable offline; native Fable re-review approved all M1/m1–m3 dispositions. | ## Decisions @@ -111,6 +116,9 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | Service overlay's two additional-read files absent | minor | yes | | First evaluator canary did not inherit documented file credential | minor, resolved | yes | | P1 generated SQLite runtime lacks `--allow-ffi` | significant | yes | +| P2 detached-start controlling-session behavior | minor | yes | +| P2 split fetch/measurement command | minor | yes | +| Resumed Codex thread reports low effort | minor | yes | ## Gate Results @@ -119,8 +127,8 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | | ------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ------- | ------------------------------------------------------------- | | Plan artifact format | scoped run formatter | PASS | All owned run Markdown checked after PLAN-EVAL output. | -| Experiment check/lint/fmt | scoped wrappers under `/proofs` | PASS | One TypeScript file selected; zero check/lint/fmt findings. | -| No lint ignores | owned-source scan | PASS | No lint-ignore directive in the P1 experiment. | +| Experiment check/lint/fmt | scoped wrappers under `/proofs` | PASS | Two TypeScript files selected; zero check/lint/fmt findings. | +| No lint ignores | owned-source scan | PASS | No lint-ignore directive in either P1 or P2 experiment. | | Lock/scope audit | raw status + root lock hash | PASS | Only run artifacts changed; root lock hash remained unchanged. | ### Fitness Gates @@ -128,17 +136,17 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | | ---------------------- | ------- | ------------------------- | ---------------- | | Archetype F-* | N/A | No package/plugin surface | Proof-only run. | -| Service contract check | NOT_RUN | P2 live spec evidence | After Plan-Gate. | +| Service contract check | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | No-DB measured; required DB branch remains failed/blocked. | | Service runtime health | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` | Generated users process exits without `--allow-ffi`. | | Trace/log review | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` | Failure and ambiguous HTTP observation preserved. | -| Consumer check | NOT_RUN | P2 projector evidence | After Plan-Gate. | +| Consumer check | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json` | No-DB complete; D7 requires the unavailable DB measurement. | ### Runtime Gates | Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | | ----------------------- | ------- | ---------------------- | ------------------------------------- | | P1 lifecycle | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-*` | Explicit P1 `FAIL`; qualified/revisitable F1(b). | -| P2 DB/no-DB measurement | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | DB half product-blocked; no-DB half remains runnable. | +| P2 DB/no-DB measurement | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | No-DB measured; DB half unavailable, so D7/D12 maps combined P2 to FAIL. | | P3 auth fixture | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P3-*` | Independent of the permission defect. | | Resource leak check | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json` | No owned survivors; foreign entries untouched. | @@ -146,8 +154,8 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | Consumer | Result | Evidence | Notes | | ----------------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------------------------------- | -| Generated DB scaffold spec | NOT_RUN | P2 evidence | Must be live, not source-inferred. | -| Generated no-DB scaffold spec | NOT_RUN | P2 evidence | Must be live, not source-inferred. | +| Generated DB scaffold spec | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json` | Live measurement blocked by attributed permission defect. | +| Generated no-DB scaffold spec | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json` | Attributed live spec measured against D7/D8. | ## Handoff Notes @@ -155,5 +163,6 @@ logic into a product template in this run. P1 `FAIL` and causally qualified/revisitable F1(b) are ready for supervisor decision-record sync. - The later HTTP 200 has no captured listener owner or precise timing and remains ambiguous; it is not pass evidence. -- No-DB P2 and P3 may proceed independently; DB-backed P2 requires an explicit failed-proof record - or a separately authorized scratch-only workaround, never a product/template edit in this PR. +- S2 passed separate Fable re-review. Its combined P2 verdict remains explicit `FAIL`; #1128 stays + open because the required DB measurement is absent, while the no-DB evidence is sound. +- P3 may proceed independently. Do not add a #1128 closing keyword or check its acceptance box. From 5c041bdfdb5c569d46355ef7338b8b3b82c15fad Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Tue, 4 Aug 2026 00:00:19 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 7/9] test(openapi-mcp): prove auth-guarded spec behavior --- .../briefs/S3-fable-review.md | 32 ++++ .../briefs/S3-implement.md | 44 ++++++ .../codex-thread-ids.md | 19 +++ .../context-pack.md | 40 ++--- .../drift.md | 27 ++++ .../proofs/P3-verdict.md | 39 +++++ .../proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json | 75 ++++++++++ .../reviews/S3-fable.md | 87 +++++++++++ .../worklog.md | 140 ++++++++++-------- 9 files changed, 423 insertions(+), 80 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S3-fable-review.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S3-implement.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P3-verdict.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S3-fable.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S3-fable-review.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S3-fable-review.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..6acd806bb4 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S3-fable-review.md @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +use harness + +# S3 Fable review — P3 auth-guarded spec fixture and wording + +You are the separate opposite-family slice reviewer. Work only in +`/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-p3b-impl`. Do not edit implementation/evidence files, delegate, +commit, push, or contact GitHub. A read-only rerun of the single focused test is permitted; do not +start Aspire, scaffold an app, or touch shared resources. + +Read plan D9/D10 and the skip-as-FAIL rule, `plan-eval.md`, issue #1129 and RFC #1123 §4 Wave 0, the +existing fixture source, and the stable S3 diff. Review at minimum: + +- `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` +- `proofs/P3-verdict.md` +- `proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json` +- `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, and `drift.md` + +Adversarially verify that the selected fixture really performs all three requests against one live +auth-guarded `/api/openapi.json` service; asserts the exact 401 and 403 JSON envelopes; asserts the +authorized 200 without claiming an unasserted success-body shape; and was actually executed with the +recorded focused command and exit-zero result. Check repository-head, fixture-blob, assertion line, +runtime-version, and normalization claims where independently possible. + +Confirm the ratified `spec_unavailable` wording is byte-for-byte the D9 text, is justified by the +measured 401/403/200 behavior, and does not weaken auth or imply authenticated-spec support exists. +Check scope/lock hygiene: S3 may add only run artifacts, must not edit product/test source, must not +add lint ignores, and must not represent a skipped branch as PASS. + +Write exactly one artifact at `reviews/S3-fable.md`; first line exactly `APPROVED` or +`CHANGES_REQUESTED`. Rank findings by severity with concrete required actions. State separately +whether #1129's acceptance box may truthfully be checked after the reviewed artifacts are committed. +This is advisory slice review, not IMPL-EVAL. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S3-implement.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S3-implement.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0d74cde9b2 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/S3-implement.md @@ -0,0 +1,44 @@ +use harness + +# S3 implementation — P3 auth-guarded spec fixture + +## SKILL + +Read and follow `.agents/skills/netscript-harness`, `.agents/skills/netscript-pr`, +`.agents/skills/netscript-cli`, `.agents/skills/netscript-doctrine`, +`.agents/skills/netscript-tools`, and `.agents/skills/rtk` before acting. + +## Assignment + +You are a fresh tracked Codex implementation session at the required `gpt-5.6-sol` / medium route. +Work only in `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-p3b-impl`. Read the required repo skills, current run +artifacts, approved S1/S2 Fable re-reviews, issue #1129, RFC §4, and plan D9/D10/D11/D12 before +acting. + +Execute S3 only and stop for supervisor/Fable review. Do not commit, push, edit GitHub, modify the +seed RFC, run an AppHost/scaffold, or change any product/template/test source. Preserve all reviewed +S1/S2 evidence. + +Required proof: + +1. Re-run the focused existing auth fixture in + `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` using the smallest repository-valid + targeted command. Do not edit the fixture. Record the actual exercised auth-guarded spec-route + behavior and the observed 401 missing-credential, 403 missing-scope, and 200 authorized response + envelopes/statuses. A copied source expectation without an executed passing fixture is FAIL. +2. Write normalized committed evidence under `proofs/evidence/` with command, exit code, versions, + timestamp, exact test names/counts, statuses/envelope shapes, and enough attribution to prove the + fixture executed. Omit credentials and volatile unrelated noise. +3. Write `proofs/P3-verdict.md` with exactly `PASS` or `FAIL`; any skipped/missing branch is FAIL. + Ratify this exact wording if and only if the evidence supports it: + + `spec_unavailable: OpenAPI document could not be fetched. The spec route may require authentication; allow anonymous access to the OpenAPI route (for NetScript auth, add /api/openapi.json to auth.authn.allowAnonymous) or provide a reachable public spec URL.` + +4. Explain how the observed 401/403 cases map to the generic MCP-facing wording without claiming the + later production feature is implemented. Do not weaken auth or add a product envelope. +5. Run scoped check/lint/fmt wrappers for any owned TypeScript (if none, record N/A truthfully), the + targeted fixture command, no-lint-ignore/scope/lock checks, and update worklog/context/drift. + Leave a stable uncommitted S3 diff and stop. + +Do not claim #1129 acceptance or issue an IMPL-EVAL disposition; the supervisor and separate Fable +review decide sign-off. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/codex-thread-ids.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/codex-thread-ids.md index 6eecaecf1d..83d98f0a30 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/codex-thread-ids.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/codex-thread-ids.md @@ -22,3 +22,22 @@ deno task agentic:codex-resume --thread-id 019fc95d-ce57-7893-98b3-36977bec0cf1 Initial identity was written by `.llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts`; the supervisor copied this credential-free route record into the PR worktree. + +## omb-wave0-p3b — Codex P3 implementation thread + +- **Thread / session id:** `019fc996-3a80-7171-b6a8-1ae9c248f113` +- **Rollout:** + `/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/03/rollout-2026-08-03T23-44-53-019fc996-3a80-7171-b6a8-1ae9c248f113.jsonl` +- **Worktree:** `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-p3b-impl` +- **Branch:** `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs-p3b-impl` @ `5b0ba26b5` (NO upstream by design). +- **Push rule:** no push; the supervisor integrates reviewed drafts into + `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs`. +- **Requested route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=medium +- **Observed route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=medium +- **Route verdict:** matched +- **Runtime:** approval=never · sandbox=dangerFullAccess +- **Brief (staged):** `/home/codex/omb-wave0-p3b-brief.md` + +This is a separate sender-owned implementation worktree because the suite correctly refused a new +sender in the earlier implementation worktree. The stale-path P3 turn is recorded only in +`drift.md`; it produced no evidence. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md index 89028173d5..113c8e3751 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md @@ -19,7 +19,10 @@ allocated values and a complete manifest, but the generated SQLite users process captured, so that observation is ambiguous and cannot satisfy D5. Separate Fable re-review approved the amended evidence and causal qualifier. S2 is also complete and separately re-reviewed: the attributed no-DB live spec was measured, but the required DB branch remains unavailable, so the -combined P2 verdict is explicit `FAIL`. P3 has not begun. +combined P2 verdict is explicit `FAIL`. S3 executed the focused existing auth fixture and produced a +separately Fable-approved P3 `PASS`: all 401/403/200 branches ran, the exact error envelopes and +authorized status are normalized in evidence, and the exact D9 wording is ratified without a +production-feature claim. ## Completed @@ -34,17 +37,18 @@ combined P2 verdict is explicit `FAIL`. P3 has not begun. - S2 fresh no-DB scaffold measurement with exact attribution/teardown, committed raw-spec input, complete/auditable keyword inventory, explicit combined P2 `FAIL`, and separate Fable approval after one amendment cycle. +- S3 focused auth fixture execution and normalized evidence: exit 0, one selected test passed, zero + failed, all required request branches exercised, and separate Fable approval. ## In Progress -- Supervisor integration and PR reporting for the approved S2 artifact set. +- Supervisor verification and integration of the approved S3 artifact set. ## Next Steps -1. Commit/push reviewed S2 and report its explicit partial-progress FAIL on #1128 without checking - acceptance or adding a closing keyword. -2. Launch P3 on the required medium-effort implementation route, preserving the one-sender rule. -3. Run separate Fable review after P3, then final hygiene and Qwen IMPL-EVAL. +1. Run supervisor verification, scoped final hygiene, and commit/push S3. +2. Sync #1129 acceptance and PR closing semantics while keeping #1128 open. +3. Run the final leak/review-thread gates and separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL. ## Key Decisions @@ -59,25 +63,26 @@ combined P2 verdict is explicit `FAIL`. P3 has not begun. ## Files Changed -| Path | Status | Notes | -| ------------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------------------------- | -| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | modified/new | Harness records plus reviewed S1/S2 proof artifacts. | +| Path | Status | Notes | +| ------------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ---------------------------------- | +| `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` | modified/new | Reviewed S1/S2/S3 proof artifacts. | ## Gates -| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | -| ---------------- | ----------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | -| Plan-Gate | PASS | Separate Qwen verdict in `plan-eval.md`. | -| Static | PASS | Scoped S1 check/lint/fmt and scope audit. | -| Runtime | P1 FAIL; P2 FAIL | P2 no-DB measured; DB branch remains unavailable. | -| Resource hygiene | PASS | No owned survivors; foreign resources untouched. | +| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | +| ---------------- | ---------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- | +| Plan-Gate | PASS | Separate Qwen verdict in `plan-eval.md`. | +| Static | PASS / S3 TS N/A | S1/S2 scoped checks preserved; S3 owns no TypeScript. | +| Runtime | P1 FAIL; P2 FAIL | P2 no-DB measured; DB branch remains unavailable. | +| P3 fixture | PASS | Focused test passed; Fable independently reran it. | +| Resource hygiene | PASS | No owned survivors; foreign resources untouched. | ## Open Questions - P1 is resolved as explicit `FAIL` / qualified F1(b), with separate Fable approval. - P2 is resolved as explicit combined `FAIL`, with sound no-DB measurements and separate Fable approval; #1128 acceptance remains open because DB measurements are absent. -- P3 remains runnable and not started. +- P3 is resolved as `PASS` with separate Fable approval; supervisor integration remains. - Evaluator credential availability is resolved: the parser-backed live canary passed with tools, reasoning, and streaming supported. @@ -85,7 +90,8 @@ combined P2 verdict is explicit `FAIL`. P3 has not begun. - Drift: supervisor route override, stale overlay read paths, resolved evaluator credential inheritance, the significant generated `--allow-ffi` permission defect, S2 command/runtime - deviations, and resumed-thread effort reporting are recorded in `drift.md`. + deviations, resumed-thread effort reporting, and the isolated P3 launch recovery are recorded in + `drift.md`. - Debt: none. ## Commits diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md index 0a5625b92d..e9832cc77a 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/drift.md @@ -179,3 +179,30 @@ Drift is append-only. through the agentic suite before authorizing new implementation work. - **Evidence:** supervisor turn command records; `reviews/S2-fable.md` and `reviews/S2-fable-rereview.md`. + +## 2026-08-03 — First P3 launch carried a stale worktree path + +- **What:** The first fresh P3 medium-effort launch used a brief whose absolute worktree path still + named the earlier S1/S2 implementation worktree. +- **Source:** Supervisor staging error in `/home/codex/omb-wave0-p3-brief.md`; launched thread + `019fc994-8d03-7ff3-94b4-8361e3dedff9`. +- **Expected:** A fresh sender-owned worktree and a brief naming that same worktree. +- **Actual:** The turn performed only read-only discovery against the stale path. The supervisor + interrupted it before any test, fixture, evidence edit, or other mutation. +- **Severity:** minor and contained; no proof evidence derives from this turn. +- **Action:** Treat the turn as invalid and preserve its identity here. Do not resume it. +- **Evidence:** supervisor launch/interrupt transcript; no P3 artifact cites this thread. + +## 2026-08-03 — P3 recovered in an isolated sender-owned worktree + +- **What:** P3 was relaunched through the agentic suite in a second no-upstream worktree with a + corrected brief and the required `gpt-5.6-sol`/medium route. +- **Source:** Sender-ownership fail-closed behavior plus the contained stale-path launch above. +- **Expected:** One valid medium-effort Codex sender owns the P3 implementation worktree. +- **Actual:** Thread `019fc996-3a80-7171-b6a8-1ae9c248f113` in + `/home/codex/repos/ns005-proofs-p3b-impl` produced the reviewed P3 draft; no other sender wrote + there. +- **Severity:** minor, resolved orchestration drift. +- **Action:** Integrate only the P3b artifacts after Fable review; retain both valid implementation + thread identities in `codex-thread-ids.md`. +- **Evidence:** `briefs/S3-implement.md`, `reviews/S3-fable.md`, and thread record. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P3-verdict.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P3-verdict.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..71a9746b8d --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/P3-verdict.md @@ -0,0 +1,39 @@ +# P3 verdict — auth-guarded spec fixture + +## Verdict + +`PASS` + +The existing focused fixture executed against the current branch and passed all three required +branches in one live `preset-auth` service lifecycle: missing credentials returned the exact 401 +JSON envelope, a credential missing `docs:read` returned the exact 403 JSON envelope, and a +credential carrying `docs:read` reached `/api/openapi.json` with status 200. Nothing was skipped. + +The authorized branch proves reachability when the configured policy permits the request. The +fixture asserts only its 200 status, so this verdict does not add an unsupported claim about the +success-body shape. + +## Ratified wording + +`spec_unavailable: OpenAPI document could not be fetched. The spec route may require authentication; allow anonymous access to the OpenAPI route (for NetScript auth, add /api/openapi.json to auth.authn.allowAnonymous) or provide a reachable public spec URL.` + +The 401 case maps to the generic phrase “may require authentication”: a credential-free fetch can be +rejected before the document is returned. The 403 case shows the narrower authorization form of the +same operator-visible symptom: an authenticated request can still be denied when the configured +matcher covers the spec route and the principal lacks its required scope. The authorized 200 case +shows that the route itself remains reachable when policy permits it. Therefore the guidance names +two configuration-level remedies for a credential-free MCP spec fetch—exempt the NetScript spec +route or supply a reachable public spec URL—without weakening auth, adding a new product envelope, +or implying authenticated-spec support exists in the later production feature. + +## Evidence + +- Fixture command: + `deno test --allow-all --frozen packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts --filter 'defineService auth option enforces 401, 403, and 200'` +- Result: exit 0; `1 passed`, `0 failed`, `1 filtered out`; selected test 46 ms, runner 53 ms. +- Normalized record: `proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json`. +- Fixture attribution: repository head `5b0ba26b5bd4be87288d981cdb951c978618ca6e`, fixture blob + `090f1b73803a6ffddaed494885f0c1d56152d7a7`, assertions at lines 60–78. + +This implementation verdict does not claim #1129 acceptance and does not issue an IMPL-EVAL +disposition. It stops for separate supervisor/Fable review. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..e1bdc62e2e --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "proof": "P3", + "capturedAt": "2026-08-03T21:47:20Z", + "versions": { + "deno": "2.9.3", + "v8": "14.9.207.2-rusty", + "typescript": "6.0.3", + "servicePackage": "0.0.4" + }, + "attribution": { + "repositoryHead": "5b0ba26b5bd4be87288d981cdb951c978618ca6e", + "fixture": "packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts", + "fixtureGitBlob": "090f1b73803a6ffddaed494885f0c1d56152d7a7", + "testName": "defineService auth option enforces 401, 403, and 200", + "assertionLines": { + "missingCredential": "60-64", + "missingScope": "69-73", + "authorized": "78" + } + }, + "execution": { + "command": "deno test --allow-all --frozen packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts --filter 'defineService auth option enforces 401, 403, and 200'", + "exitCode": 0, + "selectedTests": 1, + "passed": 1, + "failed": 0, + "filteredOut": 1, + "runnerDurationMs": 53, + "selectedTestDurationMs": 46, + "runnerResult": "ok | 1 passed | 0 failed | 1 filtered out", + "runtimeAttribution": [ + "preset-auth service listening", + "three HTTP request-start events", + "service shutdown completed" + ] + }, + "observedContract": [ + { + "case": "missing credential", + "request": "GET /api/openapi.json without credentials", + "status": 401, + "envelope": { + "error": "UNAUTHORIZED", + "message": "missing-credential" + }, + "proof": "The selected passing test fetched the route and required both the status and exact parsed JSON envelope." + }, + { + "case": "missing required scope", + "request": "GET /api/openapi.json with a credential lacking docs:read", + "status": 403, + "envelope": { + "error": "FORBIDDEN", + "message": "authz.missing-scope:docs:read" + }, + "proof": "The selected passing test fetched the route and required both the status and exact parsed JSON envelope." + }, + { + "case": "authorized", + "request": "GET /api/openapi.json with the required docs:read scope", + "status": 200, + "envelope": null, + "envelopeQualification": "The existing fixture asserts the authorized status only; it does not parse or assert the success body, so this proof makes no additional success-envelope claim.", + "proof": "The selected passing test fetched the route and required status 200." + } + ], + "normalization": { + "credentialsIncluded": false, + "absoluteForeignPathsIncluded": false, + "volatileLogTimestampsIncluded": false, + "unrelatedRuntimeNoiseIncluded": false, + "note": "Credential values and per-request logger timestamps were intentionally omitted; stable runner attribution and exact asserted response contracts were retained." + } +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S3-fable.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S3-fable.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..f8bf3bc462 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/reviews/S3-fable.md @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ +APPROVED + +# S3 Fable review — P3 auth-guarded spec fixture and wording + +- Reviewer: separate opposite-family Claude (Fable 5) session, advisory slice review (not + IMPL-EVAL), 2026-08-03. +- Scope reviewed: `packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` (read-only), + `proofs/P3-verdict.md`, `proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json`, `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, + `drift.md`, `briefs/S3-implement.md`, plan D9/D10/D11/D12, `plan-eval.md`, seed RFC §4 Wave 0 / §2 + D6 / OMB-3, and the full stable uncommitted S3 diff. + +## Independent verification performed + +1. **Fixture really performs all three requests against one live auth-guarded service.** Read the + fixture source: one `defineService` lifecycle named `preset-auth` with a static-credential + authenticator and a scope authorizer matching `/api`; three sequential `fetch`es of + `/api/openapi.json` (no credential; `Bearer write` lacking `docs:read`; `Bearer read` carrying + it), then `running.stop()` in `finally`. No branch is conditional or skippable; a skipped branch + is structurally impossible in this test, so skip-as-FAIL (RFC §4 S-17) cannot be silently + violated. +2. **Exact envelope assertions.** Lines 60–64 assert status 401 and the exact parsed JSON + `{error: 'UNAUTHORIZED', message: 'missing-credential'}`; lines 69–73 assert status 403 and + `{error: 'FORBIDDEN', message: 'authz.missing-scope:docs:read'}`; line 78 asserts the authorized + status 200 only. The fixture never parses the 200 body, and both the verdict and the evidence + file explicitly qualify that no success-body shape is claimed. Matches the brief's bar. +3. **Read-only rerun.** + `deno test --allow-all --frozen packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts --filter 'defineService auth option enforces 401, 403, and 200'` + → exit 0, `ok | 1 passed | 0 failed | 1 filtered out`. Runtime log showed `Service listening`, + exactly three `HTTP request started` events (deny, deny, allow decisions), and + `Service shutdown completed` — corroborating the evidence file's `runtimeAttribution` and the + recorded exit-zero result. +4. **Attribution claims.** `git rev-parse HEAD` = `5b0ba26b5bd4be87288d981cdb951c978618ca6e` and + `git hash-object` on the fixture = `090f1b73803a6ffddaed494885f0c1d56152d7a7` — both match the + evidence exactly. `deno --version` = deno 2.9.3 / v8 14.9.207.2-rusty / typescript 6.0.3 — + matches the recorded versions. +5. **Wording byte-for-byte.** SHA-256 over the extracted `spec_unavailable: …` sentence is identical + (`65c0c97b…e6904d`) in plan D9, `briefs/S3-implement.md`, and `proofs/P3-verdict.md`. The + ratified text is byte-for-byte the D9 text. +6. **Wording justification and auth posture.** The measured behavior supports every clause: 401 + grounds "may require authentication"; 403 shows the authorization variant of the same + operator-visible symptom; 200 shows the route is reachable when policy permits. The remedies are + operator configuration choices (anonymous exemption of the spec route, or a public spec URL), + consistent with seed RFC §2 D6/[P3] (`spec_unavailable (401)` naming the likely authz-matcher + cause and the fix). Nothing in the verdict weakens auth, adds a product envelope, or implies + authenticated-spec support exists — the verdict explicitly defers that to the later Wave 4 + feature and issues no IMPL-EVAL disposition or #1129 acceptance claim. +7. **Scope/lock hygiene.** `git status --porcelain` shows the S3 diff touches only run artifacts: + modified `codex-thread-ids.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `worklog.md`; new `briefs/S3-*`, + `proofs/P3-verdict.md`, `proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json`. No product/test/template source, + no `deno.lock`, no lint-ignore directives anywhere in the diff, no credentials in the evidence + (normalization block checks out). Reviewed S1/S2 evidence is preserved untouched. + +## Findings (ranked by severity) + +No blocking or major findings. Three minor items, none of which gates sign-off: + +- **m1 (minor, worklog/record hygiene):** The S3 diff rewrites `codex-thread-ids.md` in place, + replacing the S1/S2 thread record (`019fc95d-…`, worktree `ns005-proofs-impl`) with the new P3b + thread record (`019fc996-…`). The prior record survives in git history (committed at `7f62ff71d`), + so attribution is recoverable, but the file now reads as if only one implementation thread + existed. **Required action (non-blocking):** before or at the sign-off commit, either restore the + file as an append-style record listing both threads, or add one line noting the P3b record + supersedes the committed S1/S2 record. +- **m2 (minor, evidence precision):** `assertionLines.authorized` is recorded as `"75-78"`, but + lines 75–77 are the fetch; the single authorized assertion is line 78. The 401/403 ranges are + exact. **Required action (non-blocking):** optionally tighten to `"78"` or rename the field's + intent in a future schema; no correction is required for P3's validity. +- **m3 (minor, formatting):** The rewritten `codex-thread-ids.md` lacks a trailing newline and was + outside the S3 fmt gate's stated scope (P3 MD/JSON only). **Required action (non-blocking):** let + the S4 hygiene pass or the supervisor's sign-off formatting sweep pick it up. + +Informational, no action: the new thread record replaces the S1/S2 "no push" line with an +explicit-refspec push rule. No push occurred (the S3 diff is uncommitted and the branch has no +upstream), and commit/push authority remains with the supervisor per D11, so this is a record of the +supervisor's integration path, not a brief violation. + +## #1129 acceptance statement + +Separately from the findings above: **yes — #1129's acceptance box may truthfully be checked after +the reviewed S3 artifacts are committed** (and per the close-gate convention, mirrored/pushed). +OMB-3's deliverable is exactly "auth-guarded spec fixture + `spec_unavailable` envelope wording → +`proofs/P3-verdict.md`": the committed-to-be P3 verdict is an explicit `PASS` backed by an executed, +independently re-run, exit-zero fixture covering all three branches with exact 401/403 envelopes and +an authorized 200, and the ratified wording is byte-identical to the locked D9 text. No branch was +skipped, so skip-as-FAIL is satisfied. Checking the box must happen from the supervisor's session +after commit — not from the implementation session — and does not imply the Wave 4 production +`spec_unavailable` emission exists. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md index a944512d07..355a81da2b 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -49,13 +49,13 @@ ### Commit Slices -| # | Slice | Gate | Files | -| -- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| S0 | Lock plan/design and formal PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen `plan-eval.md=PASS`; format run Markdown | `plan.md`, `research.md`, `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `implement.md`, `briefs/plan-eval.md`, `plan-eval.md` | +| # | Slice | Gate | Files | +| -- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| S0 | Lock plan/design and formal PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen `plan-eval.md=PASS`; format run Markdown | `plan.md`, `research.md`, `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `implement.md`, `briefs/plan-eval.md`, `plan-eval.md` | | S1 | Prove/refute post-allocation endpoint manifest and arbitrate F1 | Owned Aspire status + manifest/describe/live-request agreement + log review + verified teardown; separate Fable review | `proofs/P1-verdict.md`, `proofs/experiments/p1-*`, `proofs/evidence/P1-*`, run logs/context; seed `rfc.md` §9 is supervisor-applied after review | -| S2 | Measure DB and no-DB live spec fidelity/size | Measurement script check/lint/fmt + two normalized evidence files + schema/error/keyword completeness review + verified teardown; separate Fable review | `proofs/P2-verdict.md`, `proofs/experiments/p2-*`, `proofs/evidence/P2-*`, run logs/context | -| S3 | Prove auth-guarded spec behavior and ratify wording | Targeted existing auth test + response evidence + wording review; separate Fable review | `proofs/P3-verdict.md`, `proofs/evidence/P3-*`, run logs/context | -| S4 | Final hygiene and evaluation | Scoped wrappers, no lint ignores, lock/scope audit, leak check, review-thread gate, separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL | `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `evaluate.md`, PR metadata/comments | +| S2 | Measure DB and no-DB live spec fidelity/size | Measurement script check/lint/fmt + two normalized evidence files + schema/error/keyword completeness review + verified teardown; separate Fable review | `proofs/P2-verdict.md`, `proofs/experiments/p2-*`, `proofs/evidence/P2-*`, run logs/context | +| S3 | Prove auth-guarded spec behavior and ratify wording | Targeted existing auth test + response evidence + wording review; separate Fable review | `proofs/P3-verdict.md`, `proofs/evidence/P3-*`, run logs/context | +| S4 | Final hygiene and evaluation | Scoped wrappers, no lint ignores, lock/scope audit, leak check, review-thread gate, separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL | `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, `drift.md`, `evaluate.md`, PR metadata/comments | ### Deferred Scope @@ -73,29 +73,34 @@ logic into a product template in this run. ## Progress Log -| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | -| ---------- | --------- | ---------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | PR | Committed/pushed harness bootstrap and opened draft PR #1182 with required milestone/taxonomy; closing keywords remain withheld. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | design | Locked D1–D12, proof schemas, serialized runtime method, gate set, commit slices, and skip-as-FAIL rule. No experiment files created. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | First canonical live canary reported `auth_required` because the shell lacked an exported key. The documented OpenRouter env file is present; retry will use its assignment parser and isolated child environment without exposing the value. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | Parser-backed retry passed on Qwen 3.7 Max/high: credential available and tools/reasoning/streaming supported. No secret entered logs or files. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The model guard denied Qwen's attempted delegation to default child `claude-opus-5` (exit 78); no closed request reached OpenRouter and no verdict was written. Brief tightened to require single-session evaluation. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The generic agent adapter's 30-second bound expired before the first full evaluator turn could write an artifact. A fresh single-session retry used a 240-second orchestration bound without changing provider/model/guard policy. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | implementation handoff | Launcher dry-run failed closed because `use harness` followed the brief title instead of occupying line 1. Reordered the activation line; no implementation process was started. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | implementation launch | One tracked Codex `gpt-5.6-sol`/medium thread launched in a dedicated no-upstream worktree after one-sender safety rejected the supervisor-owned PR worktree. Child has draft-only authority and must stop after each slice. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | experiment setup | Scaffolded the owned local-source SQLite fixture, restored Aspire SDK modules, and ran the documented DB init/generate/seed steps serially. Root `deno.lock` hash remained unchanged. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | allocation callback | `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` + `getValueAsync()` atomically emitted a complete identity-bound manifest for `users` at `http://localhost:3001`. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | runtime verdict | P1 is explicit `FAIL`: Aspire described `users` as `Finished` / exit 1 because generated permissions omit `--allow-ffi`. The later HTTP 200 is unattributed and cannot satisfy D5. Qualified F1(b) is selected without refuting the seam. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | Fable review | First review requested six evidence/wording corrections; the same Codex thread amended them without rerunning Aspire. Native Fable re-review approved all dispositions and found no new blocker. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | rescope recommendation | Product fix remains outside this PR. Only DB-backed P2 is blocked; no-DB P2 and P3 remain independently runnable after supervisor authorization. Exact owned teardown and hygiene checks passed. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | baseline | Re-inventoried two foreign AppHosts, six foreign/unproven containers, port 43127, and Aspire MCP processes read-only. No foreign or unproven resource was mutated. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | no-DB measurement | Fresh local-source `--db none` scaffold produced an attributed healthy 3657-byte OpenAPI 3.1.1 spec with three dotted operationIds, no refs, no non-2xx responses/common envelope, and no truncation-limit exceedance. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | DB carry-forward | Did not rerun or modify SQLite. Carried the attributed P1 missing-`--allow-ffi` failure forward and explicitly excluded the ambiguous P1 HTTP 200. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | teardown/verdict | Exact owned AppHost stopped; zero owned processes, port listeners, or containers survived. P2 is explicit `FAIL` because D7 requires both branches; #1128 acceptance remains open. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | Fable review | First review found an incomplete keyword allowlist. The same Codex thread retained the raw spec and made all keys auditable offline; native Fable re-review approved all M1/m1–m3 dispositions. | +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| ---------- | --------- | ----------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | PR | Committed/pushed harness bootstrap and opened draft PR #1182 with required milestone/taxonomy; closing keywords remain withheld. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | design | Locked D1–D12, proof schemas, serialized runtime method, gate set, commit slices, and skip-as-FAIL rule. No experiment files created. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | First canonical live canary reported `auth_required` because the shell lacked an exported key. The documented OpenRouter env file is present; retry will use its assignment parser and isolated child environment without exposing the value. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | Parser-backed retry passed on Qwen 3.7 Max/high: credential available and tools/reasoning/streaming supported. No secret entered logs or files. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The model guard denied Qwen's attempted delegation to default child `claude-opus-5` (exit 78); no closed request reached OpenRouter and no verdict was written. Brief tightened to require single-session evaluation. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The generic agent adapter's 30-second bound expired before the first full evaluator turn could write an artifact. A fresh single-session retry used a 240-second orchestration bound without changing provider/model/guard policy. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | implementation handoff | Launcher dry-run failed closed because `use harness` followed the brief title instead of occupying line 1. Reordered the activation line; no implementation process was started. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | implementation launch | One tracked Codex `gpt-5.6-sol`/medium thread launched in a dedicated no-upstream worktree after one-sender safety rejected the supervisor-owned PR worktree. Child has draft-only authority and must stop after each slice. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | experiment setup | Scaffolded the owned local-source SQLite fixture, restored Aspire SDK modules, and ran the documented DB init/generate/seed steps serially. Root `deno.lock` hash remained unchanged. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | allocation callback | `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` + `getValueAsync()` atomically emitted a complete identity-bound manifest for `users` at `http://localhost:3001`. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | runtime verdict | P1 is explicit `FAIL`: Aspire described `users` as `Finished` / exit 1 because generated permissions omit `--allow-ffi`. The later HTTP 200 is unattributed and cannot satisfy D5. Qualified F1(b) is selected without refuting the seam. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | Fable review | First review requested six evidence/wording corrections; the same Codex thread amended them without rerunning Aspire. Native Fable re-review approved all dispositions and found no new blocker. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | rescope recommendation | Product fix remains outside this PR. Only DB-backed P2 is blocked; no-DB P2 and P3 remain independently runnable after supervisor authorization. Exact owned teardown and hygiene checks passed. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | baseline | Re-inventoried two foreign AppHosts, six foreign/unproven containers, port 43127, and Aspire MCP processes read-only. No foreign or unproven resource was mutated. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | no-DB measurement | Fresh local-source `--db none` scaffold produced an attributed healthy 3657-byte OpenAPI 3.1.1 spec with three dotted operationIds, no refs, no non-2xx responses/common envelope, and no truncation-limit exceedance. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | DB carry-forward | Did not rerun or modify SQLite. Carried the attributed P1 missing-`--allow-ffi` failure forward and explicitly excluded the ambiguous P1 HTTP 200. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | teardown/verdict | Exact owned AppHost stopped; zero owned processes, port listeners, or containers survived. P2 is explicit `FAIL` because D7 requires both branches; #1128 acceptance remains open. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | Fable review | First review found an incomplete keyword allowlist. The same Codex thread retained the raw spec and made all keys auditable offline; native Fable re-review approved all M1/m1–m3 dispositions. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | fixture execution | Focused existing `defineService auth option enforces 401, 403, and 200` fixture passed: exit 0; one selected test passed, zero failed, one unrelated test filtered out. The run exercised all three requests in one live `preset-auth` lifecycle. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | response evidence | Passing exact assertions prove 401 `{error: UNAUTHORIZED, message: missing-credential}`, 403 `{error: FORBIDDEN, message: authz.missing-scope:docs:read}`, and authorized status 200. The fixture does not assert the 200 body, so no success-envelope shape is claimed. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | verdict/wording | P3 is explicit `PASS`; the exact D9 `spec_unavailable` text is ratified. Mapping is configuration guidance only and does not claim the later MCP-facing production feature is implemented. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | Fable review | Native Fable independently reran the focused fixture, verified attribution and byte-identical D9 wording, and returned `APPROVED`; minor thread-record and assertion-line hygiene was folded into supervisor integration. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | supervisor verification | Supervisor reran the focused fixture (exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed), matched the D9 sentence exactly, parsed the normalized evidence, confirmed no package/plugin/lock/seed-RFC diff, and completed the nine-file scoped formatting sweep. | ## Decisions @@ -110,59 +115,68 @@ logic into a product template in this run. ## Drift -| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | -| ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------- | ------------------ | -| User-addressed Codex supervisor route | minor | yes | -| Service overlay's two additional-read files absent | minor | yes | -| First evaluator canary did not inherit documented file credential | minor, resolved | yes | -| P1 generated SQLite runtime lacks `--allow-ffi` | significant | yes | -| P2 detached-start controlling-session behavior | minor | yes | -| P2 split fetch/measurement command | minor | yes | -| Resumed Codex thread reports low effort | minor | yes | +| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | +| ----------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | ------------------ | +| User-addressed Codex supervisor route | minor | yes | +| Service overlay's two additional-read files absent | minor | yes | +| First evaluator canary did not inherit documented file credential | minor, resolved | yes | +| P1 generated SQLite runtime lacks `--allow-ffi` | significant | yes | +| P2 detached-start controlling-session behavior | minor | yes | +| P2 split fetch/measurement command | minor | yes | +| Resumed Codex thread reports low effort | minor | yes | +| First P3 brief carried a stale implementation-worktree path | minor, contained | yes | +| P3 relaunched in an isolated sender-owned worktree | minor, resolved | yes | ## Gate Results ### Static Gates -| Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | -| ------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ------- | ------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Plan artifact format | scoped run formatter | PASS | All owned run Markdown checked after PLAN-EVAL output. | -| Experiment check/lint/fmt | scoped wrappers under `/proofs` | PASS | Two TypeScript files selected; zero check/lint/fmt findings. | -| No lint ignores | owned-source scan | PASS | No lint-ignore directive in either P1 or P2 experiment. | -| Lock/scope audit | raw status + root lock hash | PASS | Only run artifacts changed; root lock hash remained unchanged. | +| Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | +| ------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Plan artifact format | scoped run formatter | PASS | All owned run Markdown checked after PLAN-EVAL output. | +| Experiment check/lint/fmt | scoped wrappers under `/proofs` | PASS | Two TypeScript files selected; zero check/lint/fmt findings. | +| No lint ignores | owned-source scan | PASS | No lint-ignore directive in either P1 or P2 experiment. | +| Lock/scope audit | `git diff --exit-code HEAD -- deno.lock packages plugins ` | PASS | No lock/product/template/test/seed-RFC diff; lock SHA-256 remains `c031d4f7…cf91b24`. | +| S3 TypeScript wrappers | scoped check/lint/fmt wrappers | N/A | S3 owns no TypeScript; the existing fixture was executed but not edited. | +| S3 artifact format | scoped fmt wrapper over touched S3/run records | PASS | Supervisor sweep: 9 selected files; 0 findings after formatting. | +| S3 no lint ignores | owned proof TypeScript scan | PASS | No `deno-lint-ignore` directive found; S1/S2 source left unchanged. | +| S3 diff integrity | `git diff --check` | PASS | Exit 0; no whitespace errors. | +| S3 fixture | `deno test --allow-all --frozen … --filter …` | PASS | Exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed, 1 filtered out. | ### Fitness Gates -| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| ---------------------- | ------- | ------------------------- | ---------------- | -| Archetype F-* | N/A | No package/plugin surface | Proof-only run. | -| Service contract check | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | No-DB measured; required DB branch remains failed/blocked. | -| Service runtime health | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` | Generated users process exits without `--allow-ffi`. | -| Trace/log review | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` | Failure and ambiguous HTTP observation preserved. | -| Consumer check | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json` | No-DB complete; D7 requires the unavailable DB measurement. | +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ---------------------- | ------ | --------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | +| Archetype F-* | N/A | No package/plugin surface | Proof-only run. | +| Service contract check | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | No-DB measured; required DB branch remains failed/blocked. | +| Service runtime health | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` | Generated users process exits without `--allow-ffi`. | +| Trace/log review | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json` | Failure and ambiguous HTTP observation preserved. | +| Consumer check | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json` | No-DB complete; D7 requires the unavailable DB measurement. | ### Runtime Gates -| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| ----------------------- | ------- | ---------------------- | ------------------------------------- | -| P1 lifecycle | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-*` | Explicit P1 `FAIL`; qualified/revisitable F1(b). | -| P2 DB/no-DB measurement | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | No-DB measured; DB half unavailable, so D7/D12 maps combined P2 to FAIL. | -| P3 auth fixture | NOT_RUN | `proofs/evidence/P3-*` | Independent of the permission defect. | -| Resource leak check | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json` | No owned survivors; foreign entries untouched. | +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ----------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| P1 lifecycle | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-*` | Explicit P1 `FAIL`; qualified/revisitable F1(b). | +| P2 DB/no-DB measurement | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-*` | No-DB measured; DB half unavailable, so D7/D12 maps combined P2 to FAIL. | +| P3 auth fixture | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P3-auth-fixture.json` | All 401/403/200 branches executed; exact error envelopes and authorized status recorded. | +| Resource leak check | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P1-resource-hygiene.json` | No owned survivors; foreign entries untouched. | ### Consumer Gates -| Consumer | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| ----------------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------------------------------- | +| Consumer | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ----------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------- | | Generated DB scaffold spec | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json` | Live measurement blocked by attributed permission defect. | -| Generated no-DB scaffold spec | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json` | Attributed live spec measured against D7/D8. | +| Generated no-DB scaffold spec | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json` | Attributed live spec measured against D7/D8. | ## Handoff Notes -- S1 passed separate Fable re-review after the Codex lane resolved M1–M3 and m1–m3; the explicit - P1 `FAIL` and causally qualified/revisitable F1(b) are ready for supervisor decision-record sync. +- S1 passed separate Fable re-review after the Codex lane resolved M1–M3 and m1–m3; the explicit P1 + `FAIL` and causally qualified/revisitable F1(b) are ready for supervisor decision-record sync. - The later HTTP 200 has no captured listener owner or precise timing and remains ambiguous; it is not pass evidence. - S2 passed separate Fable re-review. Its combined P2 verdict remains explicit `FAIL`; #1128 stays open because the required DB measurement is absent, while the no-DB evidence is sound. -- P3 may proceed independently. Do not add a #1128 closing keyword or check its acceptance box. +- S3 passed separate Fable review. Its P3 `PASS` and exact D9 wording are ready for supervisor + sign-off; this does not claim the later production feature. +- Keep #1128 open and omit its closing keyword because its required DB measurement is absent. From 65ea2304a53c9a0d2c5d88e5b99dbe839e8c4642 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Tue, 4 Aug 2026 00:04:45 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 8/9] chore(harness): record final hygiene gates --- .../context-pack.md | 16 +++++++++------- .../worklog.md | 5 +++++ 2 files changed, 14 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md index 113c8e3751..1e7e794977 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md @@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ | -------------- | -------------------------------------- | | Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | | Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | -| Current phase | implementation | +| Current phase | evaluating | | Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | | Scope overlays | service | @@ -42,13 +42,13 @@ production-feature claim. ## In Progress -- Supervisor verification and integration of the approved S3 artifact set. +- Separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL after final hygiene gates passed. ## Next Steps -1. Run supervisor verification, scoped final hygiene, and commit/push S3. -2. Sync #1129 acceptance and PR closing semantics while keeping #1128 open. -3. Run the final leak/review-thread gates and separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL. +1. Run separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL and integrate its verdict without supervisor reinterpretation. +2. Synchronize the PR checklist/status with the formal verdict. +3. Keep #1128 open unless its missing DB-backed acceptance evidence is supplied in a future slice. ## Key Decisions @@ -75,14 +75,16 @@ production-feature claim. | Static | PASS / S3 TS N/A | S1/S2 scoped checks preserved; S3 owns no TypeScript. | | Runtime | P1 FAIL; P2 FAIL | P2 no-DB measured; DB branch remains unavailable. | | P3 fixture | PASS | Focused test passed; Fable independently reran it. | -| Resource hygiene | PASS | No owned survivors; foreign resources untouched. | +| Resource hygiene | PASS | Final leak check found zero run-owned survivors. | +| Review threads | PASS | 0 threads; 0 unanswered on PR #1182. | ## Open Questions - P1 is resolved as explicit `FAIL` / qualified F1(b), with separate Fable approval. - P2 is resolved as explicit combined `FAIL`, with sound no-DB measurements and separate Fable approval; #1128 acceptance remains open because DB measurements are absent. -- P3 is resolved as `PASS` with separate Fable approval; supervisor integration remains. +- P3 is resolved as `PASS`, separately Fable-approved, committed, and synchronized to #1129. +- Final leak and review-thread gates pass; formal IMPL-EVAL is the remaining merge-readiness gate. - Evaluator credential availability is resolved: the parser-backed live canary passed with tools, reasoning, and streaming supported. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md index 355a81da2b..c3e5d1a1d7 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -101,6 +101,9 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | 2026-08-03 | S3 | verdict/wording | P3 is explicit `PASS`; the exact D9 `spec_unavailable` text is ratified. Mapping is configuration guidance only and does not claim the later MCP-facing production feature is implemented. | | 2026-08-03 | S3 | Fable review | Native Fable independently reran the focused fixture, verified attribution and byte-identical D9 wording, and returned `APPROVED`; minor thread-record and assertion-line hygiene was folded into supervisor integration. | | 2026-08-03 | S3 | supervisor verification | Supervisor reran the focused fixture (exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed), matched the D9 sentence exactly, parsed the normalized evidence, confirmed no package/plugin/lock/seed-RFC diff, and completed the nine-file scoped formatting sweep. | +| 2026-08-03 | S4 | leak check | Final `agentic:leak-check` with the run dir, PR worktree, and declared experiment scratch root found zero run-owned survivors. It reported one foreign AppHost, three foreign containers, and one unproven container; all were left untouched. | +| 2026-08-03 | S4 | review-thread gate | `agentic:review-threads` passed for PR #1182: 0 threads, 0 unanswered. | +| 2026-08-03 | S4 | GitHub close-gate | #1129 acceptance checked and linked after commit `5c041bdfd`; PR now carries `Closes #1127` and `Closes #1129`. #1128 remains open and has no closing keyword because its DB-backed acceptance evidence is absent. | ## Decisions @@ -142,6 +145,8 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | S3 no lint ignores | owned proof TypeScript scan | PASS | No `deno-lint-ignore` directive found; S1/S2 source left unchanged. | | S3 diff integrity | `git diff --check` | PASS | Exit 0; no whitespace errors. | | S3 fixture | `deno test --allow-all --frozen … --filter …` | PASS | Exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed, 1 filtered out. | +| Final leak check | `agentic:leak-check` with run/worktree/owned-root | PASS | Zero owned survivors; foreign/unproven resources reported and untouched. | +| PR review-thread gate | `agentic:review-threads` for PR #1182 | PASS | 0 threads; 0 unanswered. | ### Fitness Gates From 24ebdc515e97faac1abf60de9e44fb4193fadcf7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Tue, 4 Aug 2026 00:15:00 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 9/9] chore(harness): record wave-0 evaluation pass --- .llm/2026-08-04-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs.md | 40 ++++ .../briefs/impl-eval.md | 56 +++++ .../context-pack.md | 15 +- .../evaluate.md | 217 ++++++++++++++++++ .../worklog.md | 69 +++--- 5 files changed, 360 insertions(+), 37 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .llm/2026-08-04-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/impl-eval.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/evaluate.md diff --git a/.llm/2026-08-04-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs.md b/.llm/2026-08-04-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..a224fc035d --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/2026-08-04-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs.md @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +# 2026-08-04 — OpenAPI→MCP Wave-0 proofs + +Run dir: `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/` · Branch `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` +· draft PR [#1182](https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1182) + +## What the proofs established + +P1 found a usable Aspire post-allocation callback seam: `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` plus +`getValueAsync()` emitted a complete, identity-bound endpoint manifest with the allocated port. The +full proof still correctly failed because the generated SQLite service exited without `--allow-ffi`, +and a later HTTP 200 could not be attributed to that owned process. The qualified, revisitable +arbitration is F1(b): productize a disposable startup-side writer after the generated runtime +permission defect is fixed. + +P2 measured a real, attributed no-database scaffold: a 3657-byte OpenAPI 3.1.1 document with three +dotted operation IDs, 73/89/88-byte discovery rows, no references, no non-2xx/common error envelope, +and no observed truncation-limit exceedance. Its combined verdict is FAIL because the required +DB-backed branch could not produce an attributable live spec; #1128 therefore remains open without a +closing keyword. + +P3 independently confirmed the auth-guarded spec route's exact 401 and 403 envelopes plus an +authorized 200, and ratified the locked `spec_unavailable` guidance without implying authenticated +spec support exists in the future production feature. + +## Two things worth remembering + +1. A proof slice can finish successfully with an empirical FAIL. The formal Qwen IMPL-EVAL passed + this run because all required verdict artifacts were truthful and evidence-backed; it did not + reinterpret a failed runtime or missing branch as a product PASS. + +2. Ownership evidence is part of the result. An HTTP response without captured listener ownership + and ordering cannot rescue a failed owned process. Likewise, shared-host leak checks must name + specific owned roots and leave foreign or unproven AppHosts and containers untouched. + +## Deliberately not done + +- No package/plugin public-surface or generated-template productization. +- No workaround for the generated SQLite `--allow-ffi` defect. +- No closing keyword for #1128 while its DB-backed acceptance evidence is absent. +- No `deno task e2e:cli`; merge-readiness E2E remains the orchestrator's decision. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/impl-eval.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/impl-eval.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..c5b7da8817 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/briefs/impl-eval.md @@ -0,0 +1,56 @@ +use harness + +# IMPL-EVAL brief — OMB wave-0 proofs + +## SKILL + +Read and follow `.agents/skills/netscript-harness`, `.agents/skills/netscript-pr`, +`.agents/skills/netscript-tools`, `.agents/skills/netscript-cli`, and +`.agents/skills/netscript-doctrine`. This is a formal evaluator turn, not implementation. + +You are the separate OPEN-model Qwen IMPL-EVAL session for `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0`, +PR #1182 at head `65ea2304a`. Follow `.llm/harness/evaluator/protocol.md` and +`verdict-definitions.md` exactly. Read the run-loop, proof-only N/A archetype decision, service +overlay, research, locked plan, PLAN-EVAL, implement brief, worklog, context pack, drift, debt +registry, all three proof verdicts/evidence sets, all Fable reviews, the draft-PR commit +list/comments/body, and issue acceptance state for #1127–#1129. + +Evaluate the approved deliverable as a proof/measurement run: P1 and P2 explicitly report FAIL +experiments, while P3 reports PASS. Independently decide whether honest committed FAIL verdicts +satisfy this run's proof-artifact scope or whether the missing DB-backed P2 measurement requires a +formal failure/rescope disposition. Do not inherit the implementation lane's recommendation and do +not convert a skipped/missing proof branch into PASS. + +At minimum, verify: + +- Plan-Gate and Design checkpoint preceded implementation; commit slices and per-slice reviews match + the locked plan. +- `proofs/P1-verdict.md`, `P2-verdict.md`, and `P3-verdict.md` exist at the RFC-designated run path + and their claims are supported by normalized evidence. +- P1's F1 outcome and RFC/epic synchronization are precise, including the callback-seam versus + owned-runtime-coherence distinction. +- P2's no-DB operationId/size/error/keyword/truncation measurements are reproducible, the raw spec + hash/byte size agree, the DB branch is not laundered, and #1128 remains open without a closing + keyword. +- P3's exact 401/403 envelopes, authorized 200, and byte-identical D9 wording are supported; no + production authenticated-spec capability is implied. +- Scoped check/lint/fmt evidence, no-lint-ignore, lock/scope hygiene, serialized-resource teardown, + final leak check, and review-thread gate meet the approved gate set. Do not run + `deno task e2e:cli`; the user explicitly excluded it. +- Close-gate semantics are truthful: only #1127 and #1129 carry closing keywords and their issue + acceptance boxes have linked committed evidence; #1128 is explicitly partial/open. +- No `packages/**` or `plugins/**` public surface, doctrine debt, seed RFC file, or `deno.lock` was + changed by this PR. +- Every implementation/evaluation/side-fix brief carries its required `## SKILL` chapter. Treat the + native Fable review prompts as advisory review briefs and check them under the same rule. + +You may run minimal read-only or non-mutating validation commands, including the focused P3 test and +scoped proof-experiment wrappers. Do not start Aspire, scaffold, modify product/evidence/plan files, +commit, push, edit GitHub, invoke Agent/Task, spawn a subagent, or delegate any work. Perform the +complete evaluation in this single session; the evaluator model guard will terminate any child model +request. + +Write only `.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/evaluate.md` using +`.llm/harness/templates/evaluate.md`. Emit exactly one formal verdict: `PASS`, `FAIL_FIX`, +`FAIL_RESCOPE`, or `FAIL_DEBT`, with evidence for every row and explicit issue/PR readiness +consequences. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md index 1e7e794977..a84269e24a 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/context-pack.md @@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ | -------------- | -------------------------------------- | | Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | | Branch | `test/openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs` | -| Current phase | evaluating | +| Current phase | complete | | Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | | Scope overlays | service | @@ -42,13 +42,13 @@ production-feature claim. ## In Progress -- Separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL after final hygiene gates passed. +- None. The run is complete; PR disposition remains with the orchestrator. ## Next Steps -1. Run separate Qwen IMPL-EVAL and integrate its verdict without supervisor reinterpretation. -2. Synchronize the PR checklist/status with the formal verdict. -3. Keep #1128 open unless its missing DB-backed acceptance evidence is supplied in a future slice. +1. Orchestrator decides whether to take draft PR #1182 out of draft and merge the proof artifacts. +2. Keep #1128 open unless its missing DB-backed acceptance evidence is supplied in a future slice. +3. Product remediation for the generated SQLite `--allow-ffi` defect remains outside this PR. ## Key Decisions @@ -77,6 +77,7 @@ production-feature claim. | P3 fixture | PASS | Focused test passed; Fable independently reran it. | | Resource hygiene | PASS | Final leak check found zero run-owned survivors. | | Review threads | PASS | 0 threads; 0 unanswered on PR #1182. | +| IMPL-EVAL | PASS | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high `evaluate.md`. | ## Open Questions @@ -84,7 +85,9 @@ production-feature claim. - P2 is resolved as explicit combined `FAIL`, with sound no-DB measurements and separate Fable approval; #1128 acceptance remains open because DB measurements are absent. - P3 is resolved as `PASS`, separately Fable-approved, committed, and synchronized to #1129. -- Final leak and review-thread gates pass; formal IMPL-EVAL is the remaining merge-readiness gate. +- Final leak and review-thread gates pass; formal IMPL-EVAL is `PASS`. +- The evaluator accepted honest P1/P2 FAIL verdicts as complete proof outputs while preserving #1128 + as open partial work. - Evaluator credential availability is resolved: the parser-backed live canary passed with tools, reasoning, and streaming supported. diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/evaluate.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/evaluate.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2c1b2f34f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/evaluate.md @@ -0,0 +1,217 @@ +# Evaluation: OMB wave-0 proofs + +## Metadata + +| Field | Value | +| -------------- | -------------------------------------------- | +| Run ID | `test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0` | +| Target | Wave-0 proof / measurement artifacts | +| Archetype | N/A — proof/measurement slice | +| Scope overlays | service | +| Evaluator | Qwen 3.7 Max / high · IMPL-EVAL · 2026-08-04 | + +## Process Verification + +| Check | Result | Evidence | +| -------------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Plan-Gate passed before implementation | PASS | `plan-eval.md` verdict `PASS` committed at `1fc6e3935`; first implementation slice `a9a28c4d1` came after | +| Design section exists in worklog | PASS | `worklog.md` `## Design` section with public surface, domain vocabulary, ports, constants, commit slices, deferred scope, and contributor path | +| Commit slices match design plan | PASS | 5 slices (S0–S4) in design; 8 commits trace matches ordered plan: bootstrap `b0be3673e`, plan lock `1fc6e3935`, P1 `a9a28c4d1`, P2 `5b0ba26b5`, P3 `5c041bdfd`, hygiene `65ea2304a` | +| Each slice has a passing gate | PASS | S0: scoped fmt PASS; S1: scoped check/lint/fmt PASS + Fable re-review APPROVED; S2: same + Fable re-review APPROVED; S3: fixture PASS + Fable APPROVED; S4: leak check + review-thread gate PASS | +| No speculative seams (unused files) | PASS | Two committed experiment files (`p1-post-allocation-manifest.ts`, `p2-measure-live-spec.ts`) each directly produce a committed evidence file | +| Constants used for finite vocabularies | PASS | Design checkpoint names `ProofStatus`, `F1Outcome`, `EndpointManifest`, `P2Measurement`, `SpecUnavailableEnvelope`; experiments use them without hardcoded string literals for domain values | + +## Static Gates + +| Gate | Command or check | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ---------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Narrow typecheck | `run-deno-check.ts --root /proofs --ext ts,tsx` | PASS | `filesSelected: 2`, `totalOccurrences: 0`, `exitCode: 0` | Two experiment files; zero type errors | +| Slice typecheck | same | PASS | same | | +| Format | `run-deno-fmt.ts --root --ext ts,tsx,md` | PASS* | 32 files selected; 9 Markdown line-length findings in briefs/reviews | Briefs/reviews have pre-existing long-line drift; verdict files and experiment source clean | +| Lint | `run-deno-lint.ts --root /proofs --ext ts,tsx` | PASS | `filesSelected: 2`, `totalOccurrences: 0`, `exitCode: 0` | Zero lint findings | +| Doc lint | N/A | N/A | No package/plugin docs changed | | +| Publish dry-run | N/A | N/A | No published surface changed | | +| Link/path check | Evidence files cross-referenced from verdicts | PASS | All 9 evidence files exist at committed paths; verdicts cite them by name | P3 fixture blob, repo head, and assertion lines independently verified | +| No lint ignores | `deno-lint-ignore` scan in `/proofs/experiments/` | PASS | Zero hits in both experiment files | | +| Lock/scope | `git diff --exit-code HEAD -- deno.lock packages/ plugins/` | PASS | exit 0; no diff | Lock SHA unchanged at `264f029ec…` | + +## Fitness Gates + +| Gate | Function | Result | Evidence | Violations | +| ---- | ---------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------- | +| F-1 | File-size lint | PASS | Two experiment files; no oversize artifact | none | +| F-2 | Helper-reinvention scan | PASS | Experiments use `fetch`, `URL`, Web Crypto, Deno fs directly | none | +| F-3 | Layering check | N/A | No package source | | +| F-4 | Inheritance audit | N/A | No package source | | +| F-5 | Public surface audit | N/A | No published surface | | +| F-6 | JSR publishability gate | N/A | No package/plugin export change | | +| F-7 | Doc-score gate | N/A | No package docs | | +| F-8 | Workspace `lib` override | N/A | No tsconfig change | | +| F-9 | Permission declaration | PASS | Experiment permissions match plan validation rows | none | +| F-10 | Test-shape audit | N/A | No new test file; existing fixture executed, not edited | | +| F-11 | Forbidden-folder lint | PASS | All artifacts under authorized `proofs/` paths | none | +| F-12 | Naming-convention lint | PASS | Files named by proof and purpose | none | +| F-13 | Saga and runtime invariants | N/A | No saga/runtime change | | +| F-14 | Console-log lint | N/A | No product source | | +| F-15 | Re-export-of-upstream lint | N/A | No package export | | +| F-16 | Folder-cardinality lint | PASS | `proofs/experiments/` (2 files), `proofs/evidence/` (9 files) | none | +| F-17 | Abstract-derived co-location | N/A | No abstract types | | +| F-18 | Sub-barrel lint | N/A | No barrel exports | | +| F-19 | Scoped source gate runners | PASS | Scoped check/lint/fmt wrappers used | none | + +## Runtime Gates + +| Gate | Validation | Result | Evidence | +| -------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| P1 lifecycle | Owned SQLite scaffold + allocation callback + description + teardown | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P1-runtime.json`: `users` Finished/exit 1; missing `--allow-ffi`; ambiguous HTTP 200 not reused | +| P2 no-DB measurement | Fresh `--db none` scaffold + live spec fetch + measurement | PASS | `proofs/evidence/P2-no-db.json`: 3657 bytes, 3 dotted operationIds, no truncation exceedance, complete keyword inventory | +| P2 DB measurement | Carried from P1 failure | FAIL | `proofs/evidence/P2-db-failure.json`: explicit FAIL, no rerun/wrap/reuse | +| P3 auth fixture | Focused existing test rerun (evaluator-independent) | PASS | `deno test … --filter …` exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed, 1 filtered out; lines 60, 69, 78 verified | +| Resource leak check | `agentic:leak-check` with run/worktree/owned-root | PASS | Zero run-owned survivors; foreign entries untouched | + +## Consumer Gates + +| Consumer | Validation | Result | Evidence | +| ----------------------------- | --------------------------------------------- | ------ | ---------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Generated DB scaffold spec | Measurement of live SQLite scaffold spec | FAIL | `P2-db-failure.json`: product permission defect blocks live spec | +| Generated no-DB scaffold spec | Measurement of live `--db none` scaffold spec | PASS | `P2-no-db.json`: attributed, hash-verified, complete | + +## Anti-Pattern Check + +| AP | Status | Evidence | Notes | +| ----- | ------ | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | +| AP-1 | CLEAR | Two experiment files; largest evidence file is 3657 bytes | No oversize artifact | +| AP-2 | CLEAR | Experiments use `fetch`, `URL`, `crypto.subtle`, `Deno.readFile` directly | No abstract helper layer | +| AP-3 | N/A | No package source | | +| AP-4 | N/A | No package source | | +| AP-5 | N/A | No barrel exports | | +| AP-6 | N/A | No published surface | | +| AP-7 | N/A | No plugin | | +| AP-8 | N/A | No package source | | +| AP-9 | N/A | No service registry | | +| AP-10 | CLEAR | P1/P2 explicit FAIL verdicts; skipped/incomplete mapped to FAIL; no silent fallback | D10 normalization applied | +| AP-11 | N/A | No saga | | +| AP-12 | N/A | No trigger | | +| AP-13 | N/A | No worker | | +| AP-14 | N/A | No stream | | +| AP-15 | N/A | No CLI command | | +| AP-16 | N/A | No scaffold template | | +| AP-17 | N/A | No Aspire resource | | +| AP-18 | N/A | No AI surface | | +| AP-19 | N/A | No docs change | | +| AP-20 | CLEAR | P1 manifest binds projectRoot + runId + service identity + allocated port; P3 attribution has repo head + fixture blob + assertion lines | Runtime coupling is explicit and auditable | +| AP-21 | N/A | No generated plugin registry | | +| AP-22 | N/A | No DB schema | | +| AP-23 | N/A | No migration | | +| AP-24 | N/A | No seed data | | +| AP-25 | N/A | No configuration surface | | + +## Arch-Debt Delta + +| Metric | Count | Evidence | +| --------------------- | ----- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| New entries | 0 | No doctrine debt from proof/measurement artifacts | +| Resolved entries | 0 | No existing debt entry was touched | +| Deepened violations | 0 | No package/plugin source changed | +| Unrecorded violations | 0 | Product defect (`--allow-ffi`) is a rescope to #1133, not debt in this run | + +## Findings + +| Severity | Finding | Evidence | Required action | +| -------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | +| low | 6 of 11 committed briefs lack the required `## SKILL` chapter (S1-fable-rereview, S2-fable-review, S2-fable-rereview, S2-no-db-rescope, S2-review-fixes, S3-fable-review) | `grep -L "## SKILL" briefs/*.md` returned 6 files; the protocol requires every implementation/evaluation/side-fix brief to carry it | Document for future runs; not blocking for this verdict | +| low | Format check reports 9 Markdown line-length findings in briefs/review files (not in verdict or evidence files) | `run-deno-fmt.ts` findings in `briefs/S1-fable-rereview.md` et al. | Pre-existing drift; not blocking for proof artifacts | +| info | Seed RFC §9 was modified (additive P1 verdict record + `` update) per plan scope | `git diff origin/main..HEAD -- .llm/runs/plan-openapi-mcp-plugin--seed/rfc.md`; plan §Scope explicitly authorizes it | No action needed; additive decision record | + +## Proof Verdict Assessment + +### P1 — Post-allocation endpoint manifest + +The committed `P1-verdict.md` says explicit `FAIL` and selects qualified F1(b). Evidence supports +this: + +- **Allocation callback worked**: manifest at `P1-runtime.json` has complete service identity, + non-zero port 3001, loopback-name host, atomic write marker. +- **Owned-run coherence failed**: Aspire described `users` as `Finished`/exit 1 with + `Unhealthy: endpoint not responding in the 200 range`. The service log shows + `NotCapable: Requires ffi access to the libsql native module`. +- **Ambiguous HTTP 200 correctly excluded**: `attributedToOwnedService: false`, + `listenerOwnershipEstablished: false`, `describeFetchOrderingPreciselyTimestamped: false`. The + evidence records three candidate explanations and explicitly states this is not pass evidence. +- **F1(b) selection is truthful**: The seam itself produced correct values; the generated runtime's + permission defect prevented coherence. F1(b) is causally qualified and revisitable. +- **Teardown verified**: zero owned processes, zero port listeners, zero containers remaining. + +The P1 FAIL verdict is honest, evidence-backed, and satisfies the plan's proof-artifact scope. A +FAIL that discovers a real product defect is a successful proof. + +### P2 — Live spec fidelity and size + +The committed `P2-verdict.md` says explicit `FAIL` because D7 requires both DB and no-DB scaffolds. + +- **No-DB branch PASS (independently)**: 3657-byte OpenAPI 3.1.1 document; three dotted + operationIds; 73/89/88-byte discovery rows; all views measured in source and locally dereferenced + form; no local/external/unresolved refs; no non-2xx responses; no common error envelope inferred + (correctly, for this template); complete keyword inventory with context-blind limitation stated. +- **Raw spec hash verified**: file is 3657 bytes, sha256 `8f8cf105…` matches `P2-no-db.json` + `sourceSpec.sha256` claim exactly. +- **Truncation comparison correct**: `maxArrayLength: 5` vs `maxItems: 50`; `maxStringLength: 34` vs + `maxStringLength: 2000`; `wholeResultByteCeiling: null` correctly reported. +- **DB branch correctly carried forward**: `P2-db-failure.json` references `P1-runtime.json`, + classifies as `generated-runtime-permission-defect`, records `--allow-ffi` missing. The + unattributed P1 HTTP 200 was explicitly not reused. +- **Combined FAIL is the only truthful D7/D12 verdict**: a blocked required branch maps to FAIL, not + partial PASS or NOT_RUN. +- **#1128 acceptance correctly unchecked**: the issue body's gate box remains `[ ]`. + +The P2 FAIL verdict is honest. The no-DB measurement is sound, reproducible evidence. The DB branch +is not laundered. The combined verdict correctly fails. + +### P3 — Auth-guarded spec fixture + +The committed `P3-verdict.md` says `PASS`. + +- **Fixture independently re-executed by this evaluator**: + `deno test --allow-all --frozen packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts --filter 'defineService auth option enforces 401, 403, and 200'` + → exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed, 1 filtered out. +- **Assertion lines verified at source**: line 60 (`assertEquals(unauthenticated.status, 401)`), + lines 61–64 (exact `{error: UNAUTHORIZED, message: missing-credential}` envelope), line 69 + (`assertEquals(forbidden.status, 403)`), lines 70–73 (exact + `{error: FORBIDDEN, message: authz.missing-scope:docs:read}` envelope), line 78 + (`assertEquals(allowed.status, 200)`). +- **D9 wording byte-identical**: the plan's D9 `spec_unavailable` text appears verbatim in the P3 + verdict. +- **No production-feature claim**: the verdict explicitly states the mapping is configuration + guidance and does not claim authenticated-spec support exists. +- **Fixture not edited**: + `git diff origin/main..HEAD -- packages/service/tests/auth/define-service-auth_test.ts` is empty. + +The P3 PASS verdict is honest and fully supported. + +## Close-Gate Verification + +| Issue | Closing keyword in PR body | Acceptance box checked | Linked evidence | Verdict | +| ----- | -------------------------- | ---------------------- | ------------------------------ | ------- | +| #1127 | `Closes #1127` | yes | commit `a9a28c4d1`, P1 verdict | PASS | +| #1128 | none (explicitly withheld) | no | no-DB partial evidence only | PASS | +| #1129 | `Closes #1129` | yes | commit `5c041bdfd`, P3 verdict | PASS | + +The close-gate semantics are truthful. Only #1127 and #1129 carry closing keywords, and both have +linked committed evidence with checked acceptance boxes. #1128 is explicitly partial/open — its +acceptance box remains unchecked and no closing keyword is present. This is the correct behavior for +a proof run whose required DB measurement is unavailable. + +## Lessons for Promotion + +| Lesson | Pattern | Applies to | Confidence | +| ------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------- | ---------- | +| Proof FAIL as product-discovery | Honest FAIL verdicts in proof runs expose product defects that trigger rescope to later waves | proof/measurement | high | +| Serialized owned-runtime method | Shared-host constraint requires exact owned-PID/port capture and verified teardown between scaffolds | service / Aspire | high | +| Brief SKILL chapter discipline | Advisory review briefs need the same SKILL chapter as implementation/evaluation briefs | all harness runs | medium | + +## Verdict + +| Field | Value | +| --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Verdict | `PASS` | +| Rationale | The approved deliverable — three empirical, committed Wave-0 verdict files — is complete and truthful. P1 and P2 are explicit FAIL verdicts supported by measured evidence; P3 is PASS supported by an independently re-executed fixture. The plan explicitly encoded FAIL as a valid, informative proof result, and the honest FAIL verdicts correctly discover a product defect (`--allow-ffi` permission) that triggers rescope to #1133. The close-gate is truthful: #1127 and #1129 carry closing keywords with linked evidence; #1128 correctly remains open. Static gates pass for touched TypeScript; no lint ignores were added; no package, plugin, lock, or seed-RFC normative surface was changed (the seed RFC update is an additive decision record per plan scope). Resource hygiene and review-thread gates pass. Two low-severity procedural findings (missing SKILL chapters in 6 advisory briefs, pre-existing Markdown line-length drift) are documented but not blocking. The proof run delivered exactly what it was scoped to deliver: honest, evidence-backed verdicts that correctly distinguish measured results from blocked branches without laundering. | diff --git a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md index c3e5d1a1d7..b389d4df1e 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/test-openapi-mcp-wave0-proofs--wave0/worklog.md @@ -73,37 +73,39 @@ logic into a product template in this run. ## Progress Log -| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | -| ---------- | --------- | ----------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | -| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | PR | Committed/pushed harness bootstrap and opened draft PR #1182 with required milestone/taxonomy; closing keywords remain withheld. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | design | Locked D1–D12, proof schemas, serialized runtime method, gate set, commit slices, and skip-as-FAIL rule. No experiment files created. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | First canonical live canary reported `auth_required` because the shell lacked an exported key. The documented OpenRouter env file is present; retry will use its assignment parser and isolated child environment without exposing the value. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | Parser-backed retry passed on Qwen 3.7 Max/high: credential available and tools/reasoning/streaming supported. No secret entered logs or files. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The model guard denied Qwen's attempted delegation to default child `claude-opus-5` (exit 78); no closed request reached OpenRouter and no verdict was written. Brief tightened to require single-session evaluation. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The generic agent adapter's 30-second bound expired before the first full evaluator turn could write an artifact. A fresh single-session retry used a 240-second orchestration bound without changing provider/model/guard policy. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | -| 2026-08-03 | S0 | implementation handoff | Launcher dry-run failed closed because `use harness` followed the brief title instead of occupying line 1. Reordered the activation line; no implementation process was started. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | implementation launch | One tracked Codex `gpt-5.6-sol`/medium thread launched in a dedicated no-upstream worktree after one-sender safety rejected the supervisor-owned PR worktree. Child has draft-only authority and must stop after each slice. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | experiment setup | Scaffolded the owned local-source SQLite fixture, restored Aspire SDK modules, and ran the documented DB init/generate/seed steps serially. Root `deno.lock` hash remained unchanged. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | allocation callback | `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` + `getValueAsync()` atomically emitted a complete identity-bound manifest for `users` at `http://localhost:3001`. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | runtime verdict | P1 is explicit `FAIL`: Aspire described `users` as `Finished` / exit 1 because generated permissions omit `--allow-ffi`. The later HTTP 200 is unattributed and cannot satisfy D5. Qualified F1(b) is selected without refuting the seam. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | Fable review | First review requested six evidence/wording corrections; the same Codex thread amended them without rerunning Aspire. Native Fable re-review approved all dispositions and found no new blocker. | -| 2026-08-03 | S1 | rescope recommendation | Product fix remains outside this PR. Only DB-backed P2 is blocked; no-DB P2 and P3 remain independently runnable after supervisor authorization. Exact owned teardown and hygiene checks passed. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | baseline | Re-inventoried two foreign AppHosts, six foreign/unproven containers, port 43127, and Aspire MCP processes read-only. No foreign or unproven resource was mutated. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | no-DB measurement | Fresh local-source `--db none` scaffold produced an attributed healthy 3657-byte OpenAPI 3.1.1 spec with three dotted operationIds, no refs, no non-2xx responses/common envelope, and no truncation-limit exceedance. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | DB carry-forward | Did not rerun or modify SQLite. Carried the attributed P1 missing-`--allow-ffi` failure forward and explicitly excluded the ambiguous P1 HTTP 200. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | teardown/verdict | Exact owned AppHost stopped; zero owned processes, port listeners, or containers survived. P2 is explicit `FAIL` because D7 requires both branches; #1128 acceptance remains open. | -| 2026-08-03 | S2 | Fable review | First review found an incomplete keyword allowlist. The same Codex thread retained the raw spec and made all keys auditable offline; native Fable re-review approved all M1/m1–m3 dispositions. | -| 2026-08-03 | S3 | fixture execution | Focused existing `defineService auth option enforces 401, 403, and 200` fixture passed: exit 0; one selected test passed, zero failed, one unrelated test filtered out. The run exercised all three requests in one live `preset-auth` lifecycle. | -| 2026-08-03 | S3 | response evidence | Passing exact assertions prove 401 `{error: UNAUTHORIZED, message: missing-credential}`, 403 `{error: FORBIDDEN, message: authz.missing-scope:docs:read}`, and authorized status 200. The fixture does not assert the 200 body, so no success-envelope shape is claimed. | -| 2026-08-03 | S3 | verdict/wording | P3 is explicit `PASS`; the exact D9 `spec_unavailable` text is ratified. Mapping is configuration guidance only and does not claim the later MCP-facing production feature is implemented. | -| 2026-08-03 | S3 | Fable review | Native Fable independently reran the focused fixture, verified attribution and byte-identical D9 wording, and returned `APPROVED`; minor thread-record and assertion-line hygiene was folded into supervisor integration. | -| 2026-08-03 | S3 | supervisor verification | Supervisor reran the focused fixture (exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed), matched the D9 sentence exactly, parsed the normalized evidence, confirmed no package/plugin/lock/seed-RFC diff, and completed the nine-file scoped formatting sweep. | -| 2026-08-03 | S4 | leak check | Final `agentic:leak-check` with the run dir, PR worktree, and declared experiment scratch root found zero run-owned survivors. It reported one foreign AppHost, three foreign containers, and one unproven container; all were left untouched. | -| 2026-08-03 | S4 | review-thread gate | `agentic:review-threads` passed for PR #1182: 0 threads, 0 unanswered. | -| 2026-08-03 | S4 | GitHub close-gate | #1129 acceptance checked and linked after commit `5c041bdfd`; PR now carries `Closes #1127` and `Closes #1129`. #1128 remains open and has no closing keyword because its DB-backed acceptance evidence is absent. | +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| ---------- | --------- | ----------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | research | Read #1127–#1129, epic #1126, RFC #1123 §§4/9, named skills, doctrine boundary, canonical discovery/projection designs, and current Aspire eventing docs. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | environment | Verified clean current-main baseline; inventoried foreign AppHosts/containers without mutation. | +| 2026-08-03 | bootstrap | PR | Committed/pushed harness bootstrap and opened draft PR #1182 with required milestone/taxonomy; closing keywords remain withheld. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | design | Locked D1–D12, proof schemas, serialized runtime method, gate set, commit slices, and skip-as-FAIL rule. No experiment files created. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | First canonical live canary reported `auth_required` because the shell lacked an exported key. The documented OpenRouter env file is present; retry will use its assignment parser and isolated child environment without exposing the value. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | evaluator preflight | Parser-backed retry passed on Qwen 3.7 Max/high: credential available and tools/reasoning/streaming supported. No secret entered logs or files. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The model guard denied Qwen's attempted delegation to default child `claude-opus-5` (exit 78); no closed request reached OpenRouter and no verdict was written. Brief tightened to require single-session evaluation. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL retry | The generic agent adapter's 30-second bound expired before the first full evaluator turn could write an artifact. A fresh single-session retry used a 240-second orchestration bound without changing provider/model/guard policy. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | PLAN-EVAL | Separate Qwen 3.7 Max/high session wrote `plan-eval.md` with `PASS` after rechecking source, RFC §4/§9, D1–D12, the open-decision sweep, all 5 commit slices, service gates, deferred scope, and JSR N/A. | +| 2026-08-03 | S0 | implementation handoff | Launcher dry-run failed closed because `use harness` followed the brief title instead of occupying line 1. Reordered the activation line; no implementation process was started. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | implementation launch | One tracked Codex `gpt-5.6-sol`/medium thread launched in a dedicated no-upstream worktree after one-sender safety rejected the supervisor-owned PR worktree. Child has draft-only authority and must stop after each slice. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | experiment setup | Scaffolded the owned local-source SQLite fixture, restored Aspire SDK modules, and ran the documented DB init/generate/seed steps serially. Root `deno.lock` hash remained unchanged. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | allocation callback | `onResourceEndpointsAllocated` + `getValueAsync()` atomically emitted a complete identity-bound manifest for `users` at `http://localhost:3001`. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | runtime verdict | P1 is explicit `FAIL`: Aspire described `users` as `Finished` / exit 1 because generated permissions omit `--allow-ffi`. The later HTTP 200 is unattributed and cannot satisfy D5. Qualified F1(b) is selected without refuting the seam. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | Fable review | First review requested six evidence/wording corrections; the same Codex thread amended them without rerunning Aspire. Native Fable re-review approved all dispositions and found no new blocker. | +| 2026-08-03 | S1 | rescope recommendation | Product fix remains outside this PR. Only DB-backed P2 is blocked; no-DB P2 and P3 remain independently runnable after supervisor authorization. Exact owned teardown and hygiene checks passed. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | baseline | Re-inventoried two foreign AppHosts, six foreign/unproven containers, port 43127, and Aspire MCP processes read-only. No foreign or unproven resource was mutated. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | no-DB measurement | Fresh local-source `--db none` scaffold produced an attributed healthy 3657-byte OpenAPI 3.1.1 spec with three dotted operationIds, no refs, no non-2xx responses/common envelope, and no truncation-limit exceedance. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | DB carry-forward | Did not rerun or modify SQLite. Carried the attributed P1 missing-`--allow-ffi` failure forward and explicitly excluded the ambiguous P1 HTTP 200. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | teardown/verdict | Exact owned AppHost stopped; zero owned processes, port listeners, or containers survived. P2 is explicit `FAIL` because D7 requires both branches; #1128 acceptance remains open. | +| 2026-08-03 | S2 | Fable review | First review found an incomplete keyword allowlist. The same Codex thread retained the raw spec and made all keys auditable offline; native Fable re-review approved all M1/m1–m3 dispositions. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | fixture execution | Focused existing `defineService auth option enforces 401, 403, and 200` fixture passed: exit 0; one selected test passed, zero failed, one unrelated test filtered out. The run exercised all three requests in one live `preset-auth` lifecycle. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | response evidence | Passing exact assertions prove 401 `{error: UNAUTHORIZED, message: missing-credential}`, 403 `{error: FORBIDDEN, message: authz.missing-scope:docs:read}`, and authorized status 200. The fixture does not assert the 200 body, so no success-envelope shape is claimed. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | verdict/wording | P3 is explicit `PASS`; the exact D9 `spec_unavailable` text is ratified. Mapping is configuration guidance only and does not claim the later MCP-facing production feature is implemented. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | Fable review | Native Fable independently reran the focused fixture, verified attribution and byte-identical D9 wording, and returned `APPROVED`; minor thread-record and assertion-line hygiene was folded into supervisor integration. | +| 2026-08-03 | S3 | supervisor verification | Supervisor reran the focused fixture (exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed), matched the D9 sentence exactly, parsed the normalized evidence, confirmed no package/plugin/lock/seed-RFC diff, and completed the nine-file scoped formatting sweep. | +| 2026-08-03 | S4 | leak check | Final `agentic:leak-check` with the run dir, PR worktree, and declared experiment scratch root found zero run-owned survivors. It reported one foreign AppHost, three foreign containers, and one unproven container; all were left untouched. | +| 2026-08-03 | S4 | review-thread gate | `agentic:review-threads` passed for PR #1182: 0 threads, 0 unanswered. | +| 2026-08-03 | S4 | GitHub close-gate | #1129 acceptance checked and linked after commit `5c041bdfd`; PR now carries `Closes #1127` and `Closes #1129`. #1128 remains open and has no closing keyword because its DB-backed acceptance evidence is absent. | +| 2026-08-04 | S4 | IMPL-EVAL | Separate OpenRouter Qwen 3.7 Max/high session `b69b5ff5-1fd6-4668-82c9-db4f47fd2921` returned formal `PASS`. It independently reran scoped check/lint and P3, verified proof evidence and close-gate semantics, and ruled the honest P1/P2 FAIL verdicts complete for the proof-artifact scope. | +| 2026-08-04 | S4 | evaluator findings | `evaluate.md` records two non-blocking low findings: six historical advisory briefs lack `## SKILL`, and nine historical brief/review Markdown files have formatting drift. They remain documented rather than rewriting reviewed prompt/output history after evaluation. | ## Decisions @@ -147,6 +149,7 @@ logic into a product template in this run. | S3 fixture | `deno test --allow-all --frozen … --filter …` | PASS | Exit 0; 1 passed, 0 failed, 1 filtered out. | | Final leak check | `agentic:leak-check` with run/worktree/owned-root | PASS | Zero owned survivors; foreign/unproven resources reported and untouched. | | PR review-thread gate | `agentic:review-threads` for PR #1182 | PASS | 0 threads; 0 unanswered. | +| Formal IMPL-EVAL | Qwen 3.7 Max/high via guarded `claude-openrouter` / `claude-print` | PASS | Separate session; evaluator independently reran scoped gates and wrote `evaluate.md`. | ### Fitness Gates @@ -185,3 +188,7 @@ logic into a product template in this run. - S3 passed separate Fable review. Its P3 `PASS` and exact D9 wording are ready for supervisor sign-off; this does not claim the later production feature. - Keep #1128 open and omit its closing keyword because its required DB measurement is absent. +- Formal IMPL-EVAL is `PASS`: truthful FAIL verdicts are complete proof outputs and do not make the + underlying failed product behavior pass. +- PR #1182 remains draft for the orchestrator's merge/readiness decision; all requested local gates + are complete and `deno task e2e:cli` was not run.