From d8a7f1b4d402fee2af441e262aa263270010fd6a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Tue, 11 Aug 2026 22:34:16 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] docs(harness): record FILING-LOG -- board migration executed once Proves the one-shot filing happened exactly as ratified, and makes it auditable draft-ID by draft-ID. Filed 14 new issues (#1468-#1481), amended 6 existing via 4 rows, and did not file DT-18 because D-0b was never decided. Epic #400 was AMENDED, not replaced -- a second umbrella would fragment the very board this RFC de-fragments -- with the ownership thesis, the three acceptance lines and the killed-surfaces list preserved VERBATIM. Successor-before-supersede was executed literally: #1471 was filed before #412's supersede comment, and #1472/#1477 before #424's. Both superseded issues stay OPEN and close only on delivery, so no seam is unowned in the interval. Zero filing-time closes. Preservation guarantees verified rather than asserted: #922 and its 24 children received zero changes -- #933 and #944 got nothing, and the only #922-adjacent action anywhere was the single authorized informational cross-post on #929 reporting the .strict() defect that #890's contract C8 rests on. The 2026-07-19 train is intact with no issue re-milestoned. No labels and no milestones were created; the only milestone edit was stripping a stale clause from 0.0.14's description, leaving its 11 issues untouched. Two deviations are recorded rather than hidden: DT-8 was filed as "six-state" because the manifest predates the amendment that added the sixth quarantine state, and bodies cite rfcs/0005 rather than the manifest's rfcs/0000 since the number was assigned at acceptance. Before any issue linked to it, the merged path was verified on origin/main -- a broken permalink in 14 issue bodies is expensive to correct. Refs #1450 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DChBXWYP9LStvjQztUJV5b --- .../filing/FILING-LOG.md | 96 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 96 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/filing/FILING-LOG.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/filing/FILING-LOG.md b/.llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/filing/FILING-LOG.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..10e4afac40 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/filing/FILING-LOG.md @@ -0,0 +1,96 @@ +# FILING-LOG — DevTools contribution RFC + +**Filed:** 2026-08-11 · **By:** supervisor session `session_01DChBXWYP9LStvjQztUJV5b` (Claude Opus 5 · high) +**Ratification:** owner in-turn, drift **D-19** · **Board migration approved:** owner in-turn, 2026-08-11 +**RFC of record:** [`rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md`](https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/blob/main/rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md) — **merged on `main`** at `03680f6e8`, via PR #1450 + +> **PLAN-EVAL:** cleared by **written owner waiver**, drift **D-18**. The formal Codex GPT-5.6 Sol +> evaluator returned **`FAIL_PLAN` twice**; every supervisor-fixable finding was closed before the +> waiver. **No evaluator `PASS` exists — do not cite one.** + +## Preconditions at filing time + +| # | Precondition | Evidence | +| - | ------------ | -------- | +| P0 | RFC merged on `main` and path verified **before** any issue linked to it | `git ls-tree origin/main -- rfcs/` → `rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md`; `origin/main` = `03680f6e8`; PR #1450 `MERGED` 2026-08-11T20:27:09Z | +| P1 | Plan-Gate cleared | **owner waiver**, drift D-18 | +| P2 | Blocking forks ratified + filing authorized | drift D-19 | +| P3 | Adversarial design pass satisfied | owner-approved substitute route — Qwen 3.8 Max + Kimi K3, drift D-15/D-16; 22 findings closed | +| P4 | F-1 / F-3 resolved | drift D-19 — F-1 self-contained `packages/devtools-core` first; F-3 `.passthrough()` before any manifest-visible pointer | + +## Draft ID → live issue + +| Draft | Slice | Live | Milestone | Action | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| DT-RFC | — | **#1468** | `0.0.6` | NEW — RFC 0005 tracking issue | +| DT-1 | W0-a | **#1469** | `0.0.15` | NEW — disposable probe | +| DT-2 | W0-b | **#1470** | `0.0.15` | NEW — disposable probe | +| DT-3 | W1-a | **#1471** | `0.0.15` | NEW — **successor to #412** | +| DT-4 | W1-b | **#1472** | `0.0.15` | NEW — **successor to #424** | +| DT-5 | W1-c | **#1473** | `0.0.15` | NEW | +| DT-6 | W1-d | **#1474** | `0.0.15` | NEW — F-3 precondition | +| DT-7 | W2-a | **#1475** | `0.0.15` | NEW — boundary vs #930 stated | +| DT-8 | W2-b | **#1476** | `0.0.15` | NEW — boundary vs #937/#938 stated | +| DT-9 | W3-a | **#1477** | `0.0.15` | NEW — **co-successor to #424** | +| DT-10 | W3-b | **#1478** | `0.0.15` | NEW | +| DT-11 | W4-a | *(none)* | — | **AMEND #427** — folded, stays open as the slice | +| DT-12 | W4-b | **#1479** | `0.0.15` | NEW | +| DT-13 | W5-a | *(none)* | — | **AMEND #423** — boundary vs #934 stated | +| DT-14 | W5-b | **#1480** | `0.0.15` | NEW — public-surface change, consumer gate | +| DT-15 | W6-a | *(none)* | — | **AMEND #428** — boundary vs #933 stated | +| DT-16 | W6-b | *(none)* | — | **AMEND #429 / #430 / #431** — boundary vs #944; streams degraded state required | +| DT-17 | F-20 | **#1481** | `Backlog / Triage` | NEW — outside the epic | +| DT-18 | D-0b | **NOT FILED** | — | D-0b never decided; gap stays recorded in drift D-10/D-15 | + +**14 new issues** (#1468–#1481) · **1 not filed** · **6 existing issues amended via 4 rows**. + +## Epic + +**#400 amended** — not replaced (standing decision D-11; a second umbrella would fragment the very +board this RFC de-fragments). Preserved **verbatim**: the ownership thesis, the three acceptance +lines, and the killed-surfaces list. Rewritten: the invent-your-own-discovery premise, the dead +`beta.6` prose, and the S1–S13 screen list → RFC 0005 pointers. Milestone unchanged +(`Backlog / Triage`). + +`CR-DDX-HOSTAGNOSTIC` — raised on #400 on 2026-07-06 from epic #510 and **never resolved** — is +recorded as **accepted** (owner fork F-11). This un-dangles #544. #544 itself was **not** edited; +that body belongs to #510's lane. + +## Successor-before-supersede ordering — as executed + +| Superseded | Successor(s) | Order actually used | State now | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| **#412** | **#1471** | successor filed **first**, then the supersede comment | **open** — closes when #1471 is delivered | +| **#424** | **#1472**, **#1477** | successors filed **first**, then the supersede comment | **open** — closes when both are delivered | + +**Zero filing-time closes.** Every `FOLD` / `SUPERSEDE` / `CLOSE-LATER` was recorded as a comment +and left open, because each has a precondition that filing does not satisfy. No seam is left +unowned in the interval. + +## Comments posted + +- **Supersede:** #412, #424 · **Fold:** #427, #734 · **Close-later:** #507 +- **Re-baseline (AMEND):** #414, #415, #420, #423, #426, #428, #429, #430, #431, #551 +- **Epic:** #400 body rewrite + the `CR-DDX-HOSTAGNOSTIC` resolution +- **Cross-post:** **#929** — the *single* authorized #922-adjacent touch, reporting the `.strict()` + defect that #890 contract C8's "older CLIs ignore the block" claim rests on. Informational; it + changes no label, milestone, or scope. + +## Preservation guarantees — verified + +| Guarantee | Result | +| --- | --- | +| **#922 and its 24 children untouched** | ✅ zero body/label/milestone/state changes. #933 and #944 received **nothing**. The only #922-adjacent action anywhere was the informational #929 cross-post | +| **2026-07-19 milestone train preserved** | ✅ no issue re-milestoned. New sub-issues default to `0.0.15`, matching the ratified train | +| **No undocumented labels created** | ✅ every label used exists in both `.github/labels.yml` and live. `epic:devtools`, `area:devtools`, `area:frontend` do **not** exist and were **not** created — `epic:dev-dashboard` used instead | +| **No milestones created; no issue moved** | ✅ only edit was stripping the stale "Dev dashboard (thin, contribution-based)" clause from `0.0.14`'s **description** (owner fork F-9). Its 11 open issues are unchanged | +| **No closing keyword in any issue body** | ✅ `Part of #400` only | +| **Exactly one `status:` per issue** | ✅ `status:triage` at filing | + +## Deviations from the manifest — recorded, not silent + +1. **DT-8 title says "six-state", the manifest said "five-state."** The manifest predates Amendment A, + which added a sixth quarantine state (`zone-contract-mismatch`) to close a Qwen finding. Filing the + manifest's literal title would have contradicted the merged RFC. **Substance unchanged.** +2. **All issue bodies cite `rfcs/0005-…`, not the manifest's `rfcs/0000-…`.** Per the owner's + instruction to use the canonical `main` link; the number was assigned at acceptance.