diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/harness-evidence-closure-gap.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/harness-evidence-closure-gap.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..10084c8e30 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/harness-evidence-closure-gap.md @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +use harness + +# #1644 acceptance-guidance completion + +Resume the existing `harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling` implementer in the same Codex thread. +The coordinator interrupted the packaging turn before any commit because final reconciliation found +one exact acceptance gap. Preserve and inspect the current uncommitted packaging artifacts; do not +discard valid work blindly. + +## SKILL + +Re-read and follow: + +- `.agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-tools/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-deno-toolchain/SKILL.md` + +Coordinator control head `33626b1f4` amends the binding leaf contract. Exactly one additional edit +surface is now authorized: `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md`. Live #1621 explicitly requires +the skill to state plainly that only markdown checkboxes are close-gated and that a plain-bullet +Acceptance section has no mirrorable targets and therefore takes no `acceptance-evidence` block. +Add that concise operator guidance in the existing machine-convention section. Do not edit any +other new product, workflow, tool, or test surface. + +Record the coordinator amendment and supersession of the earlier read-only decision in leaf +drift/worklog/context. Update draft PR #1644 so S3 and its matching Definition-of-Done row become +truthful only after the guidance commit exists. Preserve the implementation and Tier-A results. + +Treat the already-generated final receipts at `b21424c44` as pre-guidance evidence, not the final +immutable set. Commit the acceptance-complete guidance and run-artifact updates first. Then run +exactly one final structured `check`, `test`, and `quality-job` cycle at that acceptance-complete +implementation head. Package those receipts in one evidence-only commit and push by explicit +refspec. It is expected that receipt `actualGitHead` identifies the validated parent implementation +head while the final branch tip is the evidence-only packaging commit; record that relationship +explicitly. Do not create an infinite receipt/self-reference loop and do not rerun the gates merely +because the receipt-only commit changes HEAD. + +Stop at the formal IMPL-EVAL handoff. Do not launch Claude, Fable, OpenRouter, DeepSeek, Minimax, or +any substitute evaluator. The formal opposite-family gate is held until the native allowance reset +at Saturday 2026-08-15 00:00 Europe/Zurich. Do not merge, publish, mark ready, or alter central +cluster state. Return the exact implementation head, evidence head, receipt outcomes/durations, +remote reconciliation, and `BLOCKED: awaiting native opposite-family IMPL-EVAL after reset`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/README.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d1617fd22f --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +# Native reset-gate dispatch + +This directory is the coordinator-owned source of truth for the six formal gates parked until +Saturday 2026-08-15 00:00 Europe/Zurich. `dispatch.json` fixes the order, exact remote source heads, +worktrees, routes, and output artifacts. + +Rules: + +- Do not launch any entry before `launchAfter`. +- The Codex milestone coordinator remains the only active coordinator before the reset. +- Dispatch exactly one evaluator at a time and reconcile its result before starting the next. +- Use the exact per-entry native Claude Opus 5 route in `dispatch.json`: low effort for bounded + genuinely easy review and medium for the retained substantive gates. +- Do not launch Fable mechanically. Fable 5 is available only after the coordinator records a + genuinely architectural PLAN question or exceptional complex implementation-review need and amends + the entry. OpenRouter, DeepSeek, Minimax, AGY, and silent substitutions remain unauthorized. +- Start `/remote-control` in every native evaluator session and record its session, bridge, PID, and + cwd in the verdict artifact so the owner can see the lane. +- Resolve the PR and remote branch independently. A mismatch with `sourceHead` is a hard refusal, + not permission to evaluate a nearby commit. +- Evaluators write verdict evidence only. They do not implement, merge, publish, change labels, + update central state, or take an expensive-gate lease. +- The coordinator verifies the verdict commit, updates the leaf head/phase, renders status, and + validates cluster state before any next transition. + +The order deliberately clears the harness-tooling IMPL-EVAL first, then the second ready-to-merge +fix, before opening four plan-gated implementation queues. Each retained gate has a specific +existing hold, invalid/advisory prior gate, or complexity record; this is not a mechanical PLAN-EVAL +quota for later work. All six leaves are Wave 0 and the central dependency DAG contains no edge +between them. Broad source/CI/hold reconciliation is shared in the coordinator record, but harness +law still requires one fresh evaluator session per retained formal gate. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/comparison-docs-programme.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/comparison-docs-programme.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..659fd0792a --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/comparison-docs-programme.md @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ +use harness + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md`, the full `netscript-harness`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, +`netscript-doctrine`, `netscript-deno-toolchain`, and docs-relevant project skills. Then read the +PLAN-EVAL protocol, plan gate, verdict definitions, central leaf contract, complete run, live issue +#1551, PR #1652, and coordinator scope comments. + +Act only as fresh formal PLAN-EVAL cycle 1. The reset boundary has passed. Use the owner-authorized +native Claude Opus 5 **low** route and immediately enable `/remote-control`; record session ID, +bridge ID, PID, cwd, requested route, and observed route. No silent substitute; Fable 5 remains +unassigned and requires a coordinator amendment recording genuine architectural or exceptional +implementation-review necessity. + +Worktree `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs-comparison`; branch `docs/comparison-docs-programme`; +immutable base `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`; exact remote PR/source head +`d35cbca30872d1f55118d63437638e93270c2ac3`. Fetch and independently resolve PR and branch; refuse +any mismatch. + +Independently judge all Plan-Gate rows, the 0.0.7-sized slice of the 17-deliverable programme, +methodology/navigation scope, immutable evidence manifest and measurement procedure, deferred case +study/migration roadmap, source/claim freshness, terminology, locked decisions, risks, explicit +deferrals, and exact docs/check/test gate set. Check that evidence paths can prove claims without +turning future comparisons into untracked scope. Do not author docs or implement. + +Write `plan-eval.md` with exactly `PASS` or `FAIL_PLAN`. Commit only it, push explicitly to the +existing branch, and post one structured PR comment with verdict, evaluated head, evaluator commit, +and remote-control identity. Keep PR #1652 draft at `status:plan-eval`; do not implement, merge, +publish, relabel, or mutate central state. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..b6266cdeb9 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "milestone": "0.0.7", + "launchAfter": "2026-08-15T00:00:00+02:00", + "timezone": "Europe/Zurich", + "concurrency": 4, + "concurrencyScope": "per-topic-orchestrator", + "perOrchestratorConcurrency": 1, + "ownerOverride": { + "recordedAt": "2026-08-14T22:41:15.000Z", + "coordinator": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "topicOrchestrators": "native Claude Opus 5 / high with Remote Control", + "implementationLeaves": "daemon-attached WSL Codex GPT-5.6-SOL with effort matched to documented complexity", + "evaluationDefault": "native Claude Opus 5 / low through high; low only for genuinely easy bounded review", + "planEvalPolicy": "open only for an existing formal hold, unresolved architectural decision, or demonstrated complexity", + "fablePolicy": "reserve Fable 5 for recorded genuinely architectural PLAN questions or exceptional complex implementation review", + "costPolicy": "right-size effort, deduplicate shared review inputs, preserve every required independent evidence contract", + "queuePolicy": "serialize within each topic orchestrator; docs, internals, fixes, and features may each run one evaluator concurrently", + "supersedes": "the 2026-08-14T22:13:00.000Z Sonnet route matrix and the pre-reset blanket Fable matrix" + }, + "routePolicy": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "remoteControlRequired": true, + "freshSessionPerGate": true, + "oppositeFamilyRequired": true, + "substitutesAllowed": false, + "fablePolicy": "not pre-dispatched; coordinator amendment must record genuine architectural or exceptional implementation-review necessity", + "forbiddenProviders": ["openrouter", "opencode", "antigravity"] + }, + "entries": [ + { + "order": 1, + "leafId": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "pr": 1644, + "branch": "fix/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-harness-evidence", + "sourceHead": "4d9fb196765cbf1a6bc7eaa7c18ec82b237ab89f", + "implementationParent": "634b257ea1afcedb2d7f1da486d8c9e9432a2a86", + "runDir": ".llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "brief": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling.md", + "output": "evaluate.md", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "Claude Opus 5", + "cliModel": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "rationale": "substantive cross-tooling implementation review; Opus medium matches its documented complexity" + } + }, + { + "order": 2, + "leafId": "legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "pr": 1643, + "branch": "fix/legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "sourceHead": "e6ba15ec6414c0a42b1f9870791131162ea71c36", + "runDir": ".llm/runs/fix-legacy-port-pin-sweep--0.0.7-wave0", + "brief": "legacy-port-pin-sweep.md", + "output": "evaluate.md", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "Claude Opus 5", + "cliModel": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "low", + "rationale": "genuinely easy bounded implementation review with complete Tier-A and gate evidence; Opus low is sufficient" + } + }, + { + "order": 3, + "leafId": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "pr": 1651, + "branch": "docs/rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features-1502", + "sourceHead": "12276e6d86403ed1340ef79a963e87d401d643e9", + "runDir": ".llm/runs/docs-rfc-plugin-cli-contribution--1502", + "brief": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution.md", + "output": "plan-eval.md", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "Claude Opus 5", + "cliModel": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "rationale": "existing formal architectural hold requires substantive independent reasoning; Opus medium is sufficient for this evidence contract" + } + }, + { + "order": 4, + "leafId": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "pr": 1653, + "branch": "chore/quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-quality-rail", + "sourceHead": "09dfb092dccf7f843b9270295047d674a8187362", + "runDir": ".llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "brief": "quality-scan-allowance-rail.md", + "output": "plan-eval.md", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "Claude Opus 5", + "cliModel": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "rationale": "substantive coupled ownership and fail-closed quality-policy PLAN-EVAL" + } + }, + { + "order": 5, + "leafId": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "pr": 1654, + "branch": "fix/scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "sourceHead": "5b3c6fcf21b0b4947a770d8e67ea5cc8082724d5", + "runDir": ".llm/runs/fix-scaffold-generated-output-correctness--0.0.7-wave0", + "brief": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness.md", + "output": "plan-eval.md", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "Claude Opus 5", + "cliModel": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "rationale": "substantive grouped generator/runtime boundary PLAN-EVAL without running the expensive gate" + } + }, + { + "order": 6, + "leafId": "comparison-docs-programme", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "pr": 1652, + "branch": "docs/comparison-docs-programme", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs-comparison", + "sourceHead": "d35cbca30872d1f55118d63437638e93270c2ac3", + "runDir": ".llm/runs/docs-comparison-docs-programme--1551", + "brief": "comparison-docs-programme.md", + "output": "plan-eval.md", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "Claude Opus 5", + "cliModel": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "low", + "rationale": "genuinely easy bounded docs-only PLAN-EVAL with immutable evidence and no product implementation; Opus low is sufficient" + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..993519e52b --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling.md @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +use harness + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md`, `.agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md`, +`.agents/skills/netscript-tools/SKILL.md`, `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md`, +`.agents/skills/openhands-handoff/SKILL.md`, and `.agents/skills/netscript-deno-toolchain/SKILL.md` +completely. Then read the harness evaluator protocol, verdict definitions, lane policy, +agent-handoff rules, `6-cli-tooling` profile, the whole leaf run directory, live issues +#1561/#1563/#1621, PR #1644, and its structured comments. + +Act only as the fresh separate formal IMPL-EVAL. The reset boundary has passed. Use the +owner-authorized native Claude Opus 5 **medium** route and immediately enable `/remote-control`; +record session ID, bridge ID, PID, cwd, requested route, and observed route. No silent substitute; +Fable 5 remains unassigned and requires a coordinator amendment recording genuine architectural or +exceptional implementation-review necessity. + +Repository `rickylabs/netscript`; worktree `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-harness-evidence`; +branch `fix/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling`; immutable base +`01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`; exact remote PR/source head +`4d9fb196765cbf1a6bc7eaa7c18ec82b237ab89f`; acceptance-complete implementation parent +`634b257ea1afcedb2d7f1da486d8c9e9432a2a86`. Fetch and independently resolve the PR and branch. +Refuse if either source head differs. Receipts intentionally attest the implementation parent; +verify both SHAs and do not demand evidence-child self-reference. + +Evaluate the complete authorized diff and all evidence independently, including empty evidence, +block attribution, zero-checkbox ordering/guidance, dry-run failure, exact wrapped verdict tokens, +fenced/template exclusions, provenance states, workflow matchers, lock hygiene, and markdown-only +close-gate semantics. Verify the only binding gates are `check`, `test`, and `quality-job`. Run only +small independent checks needed for confidence. Do not implement or take an expensive gate. + +Write the run's `evaluate.md` from the harness template with exactly one verdict: `PASS`, +`FAIL_FIX`, `FAIL_RESCOPE`, or `FAIL_DEBT`. Commit only that artifact and push explicitly to the +existing branch. Post one structured PR comment with phase, verdict, evaluated source and parent, +evaluator commit, and remote-control identity. Keep the PR draft at `status:impl`; do not merge, +publish, relabel, or mutate central state. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/legacy-port-pin-sweep.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/legacy-port-pin-sweep.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..69ca78f29b --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/legacy-port-pin-sweep.md @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +use harness + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md` and the full `netscript-harness`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, +`netscript-cli`, `netscript-doctrine`, `netscript-deno-toolchain`, `jsr-audit`, `aspire`, and `rtk` +project skills. Then read the IMPL-EVAL protocol/verdict definitions, complete leaf run, live issue +#1243, PR #1643, coordinator scope comments, full diff, Tier-A review, and receipts. + +Act only as the fresh separate formal IMPL-EVAL. The reset boundary has passed. Use the +owner-authorized native Claude Opus 5 **low** route and immediately enable `/remote-control`; record +session ID, bridge ID, PID, cwd, requested route, and observed route. No silent substitute; Fable 5 +remains unassigned and requires a coordinator amendment recording genuine architectural or +exceptional implementation-review necessity. + +Worktree `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-legacy-port-pin-sweep`; branch +`fix/legacy-port-pin-sweep`; immutable base `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`; exact remote +PR/source head `e6ba15ec6414c0a42b1f9870791131162ea71c36`. Fetch and resolve both PR and branch +independently; refuse any mismatch. This exact head supersedes the stale `af3dca0f5` value in the +older leaf-local `evaluate-prompt.md`. + +Independently verify the auth command has no silent localhost:4437 default, requires explicit +`--stream-url`, fails before the session adapter when omitted, and gives actionable Aspire endpoint +discovery guidance. Verify manifest/copy port fields remain coordinator-classified compatibility +metadata, broad formatting remains mechanically isolated, lock/JSR/publish evidence is honest, and +there is no hidden behavioral or scope drift. Run only the smallest non-expensive checks needed; do +not run scaffold.runtime, Aspire, Docker, or publish and do not implement. + +Write `evaluate.md` with exactly one harness verdict: `PASS`, `FAIL_FIX`, `FAIL_RESCOPE`, or +`FAIL_DEBT`. Commit only it and push explicitly to the existing branch. Post one structured PR +comment with phase, verdict, evaluated head, evaluator commit, and remote-control identity. Keep PR +#1643 draft at `status:impl`; do not merge, publish, relabel, or mutate central state. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/quality-scan-allowance-rail.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/quality-scan-allowance-rail.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..01d7a448aa --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/quality-scan-allowance-rail.md @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +use harness + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md`, the full `netscript-harness`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, +`netscript-deno-toolchain`, `netscript-doctrine`, `jsr-audit`, and relevant quality-scan skills. +Then read the PLAN-EVAL protocol, plan gate, verdict definitions, central leaf contract, complete +run, issues #1378/#1545, PR #1653, issue #1655, and coordinator resolution comments. + +Act only as fresh formal PLAN-EVAL cycle 2. The reset boundary has passed. Use the owner-authorized +native Claude Opus 5 **medium** route and immediately enable `/remote-control`; record session ID, +bridge ID, PID, cwd, requested route, and observed route. No silent substitute; Fable 5 remains +unassigned and requires a coordinator amendment recording genuine architectural or exceptional +implementation-review necessity. + +Worktree `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-quality-rail`; branch `chore/quality-scan-allowance-rail`; +immutable base `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`; exact remote PR/source head +`09dfb092dccf7f843b9270295047d674a8187362`. Fetch and independently resolve PR and branch; refuse +any mismatch. Evaluate the repaired head, not advisory head `c573beda...`. Preserve the existing +advisory `plan-eval.md` as `plan-eval-cycle-1-advisory.md`, then write the new canonical +`plan-eval.md`. + +Independently judge all Plan-Gate rows and specifically verify the seven-record ownership decision, +exact authorized scanner-test/consumer/generated-asset/debt surfaces, strict Workers no-increase +baseline owned by #1655, measured budget, issue prose, RED-first proof, generated-asset freshness, +full JSR audit plan, and honest gate map. Do not implement. + +The new artifact must contain exactly `PASS` or `FAIL_PLAN`. Commit only the history rename and new +verdict artifact, push explicitly to the existing branch, and post one structured PR comment with +cycle, verdict, evaluated head, evaluator commit, and remote-control identity. Keep PR #1653 draft +at `status:plan-eval`; do not implement, merge, publish, relabel, or mutate central state. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/rfc-plugin-cli-contribution.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/rfc-plugin-cli-contribution.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..721ae0c851 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/rfc-plugin-cli-contribution.md @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ +use harness + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md`, the full `netscript-harness`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, +`netscript-doctrine`, `netscript-deno-toolchain`, `jsr-audit`, and docs/RFC-relevant project skills. +Then read the PLAN-EVAL protocol, plan gate, verdict definitions, central leaf contract, complete +run, live issue #1502, PR #1651, and coordinator repair comments. + +Act only as fresh PLAN-EVAL cycle 2. The reset boundary has passed. Use the owner-authorized native +Claude Opus 5 **medium** route and immediately enable `/remote-control`; record session ID, bridge +ID, PID, cwd, requested route, and observed route. No silent substitute; Fable 5 remains unassigned +and requires a coordinator amendment recording genuine architectural or exceptional +implementation-review necessity. + +Worktree `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features-1502`; branch `docs/rfc-plugin-cli-contribution`; +immutable base `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`; exact remote PR/source head +`12276e6d86403ed1340ef79a963e87d401d643e9`. Fetch and independently resolve PR and branch; refuse +any mismatch. Evaluate the repaired current plan, not cycle-1 head `a02f969...`. Preserve the prior +`plan-eval.md` as `plan-eval-cycle-1.md`, then write the new canonical `plan-eval.md`. + +Independently judge research currency, locked decisions, open-decision sweep, slice sizes, risks, +deferred scope, exact gate set, contract resolution, docs terminology, all Archetype-4 fitness +gates, and JSR applicability. Confirm the coordinator-authorized docs-only contract amendment and +closing-keyword disposition are explicit and sufficient. Do not write the RFC or implement. + +The new artifact must contain exactly `PASS` or `FAIL_PLAN`. Commit only the history rename and new +verdict artifact, push explicitly to the existing branch, and post one structured PR comment with +cycle, verdict, evaluated head, evaluator commit, and remote-control identity. Keep PR #1651 draft +at `status:plan-eval`; do not implement, merge, publish, relabel, or mutate central state. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/scaffold-generated-output-correctness.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/scaffold-generated-output-correctness.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..5457079c02 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/reset-gates/scaffold-generated-output-correctness.md @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +use harness + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md`, the full `netscript-harness`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, +`netscript-deno-toolchain`, `netscript-doctrine`, `jsr-audit`, `aspire`, and scaffold-relevant +project skills. Then read the PLAN-EVAL protocol, plan gate, verdict definitions, central leaf +contract, complete run, issues #1262/#1263/#1588, PR #1654, and coordinator amendments. + +Act only as fresh formal PLAN-EVAL cycle 2, the final permitted plan cycle. Cycle 1 returned +`FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit `13008abf83734884f7fcfc71e6d6d9facb24bcbf`; the original Codex +plan-author thread repaired only the run artifacts and pushed the immutable source below. The reset +boundary has passed. Use the owner-authorized +native Claude Opus 5 **medium** route and immediately enable `/remote-control`; record session ID, +bridge ID, PID, cwd, requested route, and observed route. No silent substitute; Fable 5 remains +unassigned and requires a coordinator amendment recording genuine architectural or exceptional +implementation-review necessity. + +Worktree `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-scaffold-generated-output-correctness`; branch +`fix/scaffold-generated-output-correctness`; immutable base +`01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`; exact remote PR/source head +`5b3c6fcf21b0b4947a770d8e67ea5cc8082724d5`. Fetch and independently resolve PR and branch; refuse +any mismatch. + +Independently judge all Plan-Gate rows: truthful model-aware seed, defined missing-row behavior with +OpenAPI projection preserved, selected-provider-only connection parsing, authorized boundary +amendment, RED-first paths, ordered slices, risks, deferrals, receipt strategy, and the single +serialized scaffold.runtime lease planned only after cheaper gates. Check JSR/publish applicability +against the contract. Do not implement or run the expensive verdict. + +Re-test the three cycle-1 findings rather than trusting the repair summary: the open-decision sweep +must resolve memory-router scope and the direct-call empty-schema generator contract; every slice +must name `proves -> gate -> files`, including `generate-engine-mod.ts` where selected-provider +emission is implemented; and #1262 acceptance item 3 must be explicitly inspected or deferred. +Confirm the worklog's live phase wording is `status:plan-eval` and that the repair adds no product +file or unstated boundary. + +Preserve the cycle-1 verdict as `plan-eval-cycle-1.md`, then write the cycle-2 result to +`plan-eval.md` with exactly `PASS` or `FAIL_PLAN`. Commit only those evaluator artifacts, push +explicitly to the existing branch, and post one structured PR comment with verdict, evaluated head, +evaluator commit, and remote-control identity. Keep PR #1654 draft at `status:plan-eval`; do not +implement, merge, publish, relabel, or mutate central state. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-claude-reset-common.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-claude-reset-common.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..b6d1aa94a2 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-claude-reset-common.md @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +# Claude topic-supervisor reset contract + +The owner correction at the 2026-08-15 Europe/Zurich reset supersedes the pre-reset Codex topic +fallback. Codex remains `codex-root-0.0.7`, the sole milestone coordinator and sole merge/release +authority. Exactly four Claude topic orchestrators supervise the preserved `docs`, `internals`, +`fixes`, and `features` worktrees. + +Before acting, read the coordinator run's `supervisor.md`, `worklog.md`, `context-pack.md`, +`drift.md`, `milestone-cluster-state.json`, `leaf-contracts.json`, `milestone-leaf-plan.json`, and +`briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json`, then the complete topic-local run and live leaf PR state. + +Control laws: + +- Supervise only. Do not implement product/docs/tooling changes in the topic worktree. +- Preserve the historical Codex topic thread, branch, worktree, child threads, PRs, and harness + evidence. The old controller is parked; never resume it as a topic controller. +- One topic branch maps to one topic worktree and one active controller. Do not create a rival + supervisor or a second implementation session in a leaf worktree. +- Implementation stays in daemon-attached WSL Codex leaves launched/steered through the agentic + suite. Request GPT-5.6-SOL low for mechanical work, medium by default, and high only after + recording concrete complexity evidence. +- Do not blindly resume a leaf. Re-establish its exact local/remote/PR head, hold, formal gate, + current CI, resource lease, and idle/parked thread state first. Resume the same eligible Codex + thread; never create a rival. +- Formal evaluators are fresh sessions separate from the Codex generator. Use only the exact native + Claude Opus 5 route and effort in `briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json`, one evaluator globally at a + time. Do not create PLAN-EVAL mechanically; require an existing formal hold or documented + architectural/complexity justification. Fable 5 needs a coordinator amendment recording the + genuinely architectural PLAN question or exceptional implementation-review complexity; no + OpenRouter/DeepSeek/Minimax/AGY substitution. +- Topic Tier-A review may consolidate shared lane context, but it does not replace PLAN-EVAL or + IMPL-EVAL. Evaluators write verdict evidence only. +- Do not merge, publish, mark ready, relabel, close issues, change milestone scope, mutate the + coordinator's cluster state, or acquire the release-writer lease. +- Keep Remote Control attached and owner-visible. Record Claude session ID, non-empty + `bridgeSessionId`, PID, exact cwd, requested model/effort, observed process argv/model evidence, + and Remote Control URL/state in the topic journal. + +First turn: reconcile only. Do not launch a leaf or evaluator until the coordinator explicitly +grants that leaf/gate. Update and commit the topic-local supervisor/worklog/context/drift record, +push the exact topic branch by explicit refspec, and return a compact lane status/identity table to +the coordinator. If a fact differs from the central dispatch set, stop and report drift. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-docs/claude-supervisor-reset.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-docs/claude-supervisor-reset.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..f30aadeccb --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-docs/claude-supervisor-reset.md @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +use harness + +# 0.0.7 docs Claude topic supervisor + +You are `topic-docs-0.0.7`, one of exactly four topic orchestrators under Codex coordinator +`codex-root-0.0.7`. + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md` and the complete `netscript-harness`, `agent-milestone-orchestrator`, +`claude-manager`, `codex-wsl-remote`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, and `netscript-doctrine` +project skills. Read the absolute common contract: +`/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-claude-reset-common.md`. + +Exact lane identity: + +- worktree: `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs` +- branch: `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-docs` +- topic run: `.llm/runs/orchestrator-release-0.0.7-docs--topic` +- preserved parked Codex topic thread: `019ffcc0-e19b-71d1-95ce-8c72559eb026` +- leaf: `comparison-docs-programme`, PR #1652, exact head `d35cbca30872d1f55118d63437638e93270c2ac3` +- formal hold: fresh PLAN-EVAL cycle 1, reset dispatch order 6; do not resume implementation + +Requested supervisor route is native Claude Opus 5 at high effort. Reconcile and journal only on the +first turn. Do not launch #1652's evaluator before the coordinator grants dispatch order 6. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-docs/implement.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-docs/implement.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..c714dde9a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-docs/implement.md @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +use harness + +# 0.0.7 docs topic orchestrator + +You are `topic-docs-0.0.7`, one of exactly four topic orchestrators under the milestone coordinator. Work from `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs` on `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-docs`, whose immutable dispatch base is `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`. + +## SKILL + +Read and follow these skills completely before acting: + +- `.agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/agent-milestone-orchestrator/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-tools/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-doctrine/SKILL.md` + +Also read the canonical approved coordination artifacts in `/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/`: `context-pack.md`, `plan.md`, `milestone-leaf-plan.json`, `leaf-contracts.json`, `milestone-dependency-dag.json`, `milestone-cluster-state.json`, `worklog.md`, `supervisor.md`, and `drift.md`. PLAN-EVAL approved immutable plan head `331f7c664`; coordinator control head at dispatch is `5330285f65242eff639cfc5c7ed68a80740de910`. + +## Authority and lane + +Own only the docs lane: issue #1551. The coordinator is the sole merge and release authority. You must not merge, publish, alter milestone scope, mutate central cluster state, or touch any user-owned worktree. Leaf PRs target `main` directly and remain draft until coordinator review. Never publish locally. + +Wave 0 has one bounded leaf, `comparison-docs-programme` (#1551): ship only the methodology page, one case study, and a migration placeholder; create follow-up issues for the remaining deliverables as the approved contract requires. This is a real leaf, not permission to complete all 17 deliverables. + +## Execution contract + +Act as a topic orchestrator, not the leaf implementer. Create a fresh leaf worktree/branch from the current live `origin/main`, with no upstream, and a leaf run directory. Launch it only through the Deno agentic suite with a brief beginning `use harness` and a `## SKILL` chapter. Observe the lane WIP limit of two implementers plus one evaluator. Record worktree, branch, thread id, requested/observed route, draft PR, head SHA, and exact resume/steering command. + +The leaf must inspect the live issue, use structured NetScript checks/reports, commit in reviewable slices, push by explicit refspec, and open a draft PR against `main` with acceptance evidence. Use PLAN-EVAL N/A only if the implementation is fully locked/mechanical; otherwise run the bounded plan gate. Require substantive Tier-A review and a separate opposite-family IMPL-EVAL before requesting merge. Do not run irrelevant expensive gates. + +Any Claude supervisor/orchestrator session you introduce must be native Claude Remote Control (`/remote-control`, launched through the supported native/hybrid surface), with matching PID/cwd and non-empty `bridgeSessionId` recorded. A custom-endpoint/OpenRouter Claude session is not Remote Control and must never be described as mobile-visible. + +Start now: reconcile live `main` and issue state, launch the ready wave-zero leaf, and keep supervising it. Report progress in your topic run artifacts and return a compact identity/status table to the coordinator; never claim merge authority. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-features/claude-supervisor-reset.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-features/claude-supervisor-reset.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..f051e715cd --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-features/claude-supervisor-reset.md @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +use harness + +# 0.0.7 features Claude topic supervisor + +You are `topic-features-0.0.7`, one of exactly four topic orchestrators under Codex coordinator +`codex-root-0.0.7`. + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md` and the complete `netscript-harness`, `agent-milestone-orchestrator`, +`claude-manager`, `codex-wsl-remote`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, `netscript-deno-toolchain`, +`netscript-cli`, and `netscript-doctrine` project skills. Read the absolute common contract: +`/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-claude-reset-common.md`. + +Exact lane identity: + +- worktree: `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features` +- branch: `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-features` +- topic run: `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-features--orchestration` +- preserved parked Codex topic thread: `019ffcc0-e1d2-7850-a308-354b670c6f3d` +- leaf: `rfc-plugin-cli-contribution`, PR #1651, exact head + `12276e6d86403ed1340ef79a963e87d401d643e9` +- formal hold: fresh PLAN-EVAL cycle 2, reset dispatch order 3; no RFC authoring yet + +Requested supervisor route is native Claude Opus 5 at high effort. Reconcile and journal only on the +first turn. Do not launch #1651's evaluator or resume RFC authoring before the coordinator grants +dispatch order 3. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-features/implement.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-features/implement.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..24048bf912 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-features/implement.md @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +use harness + +# 0.0.7 features topic orchestrator + +You are `topic-features-0.0.7`, one of exactly four topic orchestrators under the milestone coordinator. Work from `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features` on `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-features`, whose immutable dispatch base is `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`. + +## SKILL + +Read and follow these skills completely before acting: + +- `.agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/agent-milestone-orchestrator/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-tools/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-cli/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-doctrine/SKILL.md` + +Also read the canonical approved coordination artifacts in `/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/`: `context-pack.md`, `plan.md`, `milestone-leaf-plan.json`, `leaf-contracts.json`, `milestone-dependency-dag.json`, `milestone-cluster-state.json`, `worklog.md`, `supervisor.md`, and `drift.md`. PLAN-EVAL approved immutable plan head `331f7c664`; coordinator control head at dispatch is `5330285f65242eff639cfc5c7ed68a80740de910`. + +## Authority and lane + +Own only the features lane: #1293, #1348, #1349, #1352, #1354, #1355, #1360, #1451, #1452, #1455, #1458, #1466, #1467, #1502, #1590, #1591, #1592. The coordinator is the sole merge and release authority. You must not merge, publish, alter milestone scope, mutate central cluster state, or touch any user-owned worktree. Leaf PRs target `main` directly and remain draft until coordinator review. Never publish locally. + +Wave 0 contains the coordinator-only `rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board` checkpoint (#1348) and one implementation leaf, `rfc-plugin-cli-contribution` (#1502). Do not create a PR to close #1348 and do not close it early; verify the ratification record, then launch only #1502. That leaf is an RFC document plus its own PLAN-EVAL and proposes a later implementation epic; it does not implement the CLI seam now. + +## Execution contract + +Act as a topic orchestrator, not the leaf implementer. Create a fresh #1502 leaf worktree/branch from current live `origin/main`, no upstream, and a leaf run directory. Launch only through the Deno agentic suite with a brief beginning `use harness` and containing `## SKILL`. Observe the two-implementer/one-evaluator lane ceiling. Record worktree, branch, thread id, requested/observed route, draft PR, head SHA, and exact resume/steering command. + +The leaf must inspect live issue/RFC doctrine, use structured NetScript checks and preserve JSON receipts, commit in reviewable slices, push by explicit refspec, and open a draft PR against `main` with acceptance evidence. #1502 requires its bounded PLAN-EVAL; do not mark it N/A. Require substantive Tier-A review and a separate opposite-family IMPL-EVAL before requesting merge. Run `quality:gate` and JSR audit only where applicable. Do not overlap the global expensive gate. + +Any Claude supervisor/orchestrator session you introduce must be native Claude Remote Control (`/remote-control`, launched through the supported native/hybrid surface), with matching PID/cwd and non-empty `bridgeSessionId` recorded. A custom-endpoint/OpenRouter Claude session is not Remote Control and must never be described as mobile-visible. + +Start now: reconcile live `main`, verify the #1348 coordinator checkpoint without closing it, launch the ready #1502 leaf, and keep supervising it. Report progress in topic run artifacts and return a compact identity/status table to the coordinator; never claim merge authority. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-fixes/claude-supervisor-reset.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-fixes/claude-supervisor-reset.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..07590b4879 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-fixes/claude-supervisor-reset.md @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +use harness + +# 0.0.7 fixes Claude topic supervisor + +You are `topic-fixes-0.0.7`, one of exactly four topic orchestrators under Codex coordinator +`codex-root-0.0.7`. + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md` and the complete `netscript-harness`, `agent-milestone-orchestrator`, +`claude-manager`, `codex-wsl-remote`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, `netscript-cli`, +`netscript-deno-toolchain`, and `aspire` project skills. Read the absolute common contract: +`/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-claude-reset-common.md`. + +Exact lane identity: + +- worktree: `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-fixes` +- branch: `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-fixes` +- topic run: `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-fixes--orchestration` +- preserved parked Codex topic thread: `019ffcc0-e1ae-7b70-b3b8-8804ebd6f773` +- leaf #1643: `legacy-port-pin-sweep`, exact head `e6ba15ec6414c0a42b1f9870791131162ea71c36`, fresh + IMPL-EVAL, dispatch order 2 +- leaf #1654: `scaffold-generated-output-correctness`, exact head + `14d8b38b4db7ba0635cbbcac2f8cd8903bee0ec9`, fresh PLAN-EVAL cycle 1, dispatch order 5 +- no scaffold/Aspire/Docker lease is active + +Requested supervisor route is native Claude Opus 5 at high effort. Reconcile and journal only on the +first turn. Do not launch either evaluator or resume either leaf until the coordinator grants its +serial dispatch order. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-fixes/implement.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-fixes/implement.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..bd59390c70 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-fixes/implement.md @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +use harness + +# 0.0.7 fixes topic orchestrator + +You are `topic-fixes-0.0.7`, one of exactly four topic orchestrators under the milestone coordinator. Work from `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-fixes` on `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-fixes`, whose immutable dispatch base is `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`. + +## SKILL + +Read and follow these skills completely before acting: + +- `.agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/agent-milestone-orchestrator/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-tools/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-cli/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/aspire/SKILL.md` + +Also read the canonical approved coordination artifacts in `/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/`: `context-pack.md`, `plan.md`, `milestone-leaf-plan.json`, `leaf-contracts.json`, `milestone-dependency-dag.json`, `milestone-cluster-state.json`, `worklog.md`, `supervisor.md`, and `drift.md`. PLAN-EVAL approved immutable plan head `331f7c664`; coordinator control head at dispatch is `5330285f65242eff639cfc5c7ed68a80740de910`. + +## Authority and lane + +Own only the fixes lane: #1093, #1112, #1243, #1249, #1262, #1263, #1350, #1351, #1353, #1357, #1358, #1448, #1461, #1462, #1481, #1543, #1544, #1588, #1598, #1609, #1610, #1616, #1619, #1620, #1623, #1637. The coordinator is the sole merge and release authority. You must not merge, publish, alter milestone scope, mutate central cluster state, or touch any user-owned worktree. Leaf PRs target `main` directly and remain draft until coordinator review. Never publish locally. + +Wave 0 has exactly two ready leaves: `legacy-port-pin-sweep` (#1243) and `scaffold-generated-output-correctness` (#1262 + #1263 + #1588). The latter shares one `scaffold.runtime` verdict and must stay grouped. + +## Execution contract + +Act as a topic orchestrator, not either leaf implementer. Create fresh leaf worktrees/branches from current live `origin/main`, no upstream, and leaf run directories. Launch only through the Deno agentic suite with briefs beginning `use harness` and containing `## SKILL`. Run no more than the two allowed implementers concurrently and no more than one evaluator. Record worktree, branch, thread id, requested/observed route, draft PR, head SHA, and exact resume/steering command for each. + +Every leaf must inspect live issues, reproduce the defect or record the approved fallback, use the structured NetScript Deno check/test/quality reporters and preserve JSON receipts, commit in reviewable slices, push by explicit refspec, and open a draft PR against `main` with acceptance evidence. Use PLAN-EVAL N/A only for locked/mechanical work; otherwise run the bounded plan gate. Require substantive Tier-A review and a separate opposite-family IMPL-EVAL before requesting merge. Serialize scaffold/runtime/Aspire/Docker work under the one global expensive-gate lease and run `quality:gate`/JSR audit where the contract requires them. Clean any AppHost or container created by a leaf. + +Any Claude supervisor/orchestrator session you introduce must be native Claude Remote Control (`/remote-control`, launched through the supported native/hybrid surface), with matching PID/cwd and non-empty `bridgeSessionId` recorded. A custom-endpoint/OpenRouter Claude session is not Remote Control and must never be described as mobile-visible. + +Start now: reconcile live `main` and issue state, launch both ready wave-zero leaves within WIP, and keep supervising them. Report progress in topic run artifacts and return a compact identity/status table to the coordinator; never claim merge authority. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-internals/claude-supervisor-reset.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-internals/claude-supervisor-reset.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9786ebf5c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-internals/claude-supervisor-reset.md @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +use harness + +# 0.0.7 internals Claude topic supervisor + +You are `topic-internals-0.0.7`, one of exactly four topic orchestrators under Codex coordinator +`codex-root-0.0.7`. + +## SKILL + +Read `AGENTS.md` and the complete `netscript-harness`, `agent-milestone-orchestrator`, +`claude-manager`, `codex-wsl-remote`, `netscript-tools`, `netscript-pr`, `netscript-deno-toolchain`, +and `netscript-doctrine` project skills. Read the absolute common contract: +`/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-claude-reset-common.md`. + +Exact lane identity: + +- worktree: `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-internals` +- branch: `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-internals` +- topic run: `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration` +- preserved parked Codex topic thread: `019ffcc0-e1b5-74f0-96eb-cdeb298d6b17` +- leaf #1644: `harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling`, exact head + `4d9fb196765cbf1a6bc7eaa7c18ec82b237ab89f`, fresh IMPL-EVAL, dispatch order 1 +- leaf #1653: `quality-scan-allowance-rail`, exact head `09dfb092dccf7f843b9270295047d674a8187362`, + fresh PLAN-EVAL cycle 2, dispatch order 4 + +Requested supervisor route is native Claude Opus 5 at high effort. Reconcile and journal only on the +first turn. Prepare the order-1 handoff, but do not launch its Opus 5/medium evaluator until the +coordinator grants the singleton evaluator lease after your attachment receipt. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-internals/implement.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-internals/implement.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..471fb31262 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/briefs/topic-internals/implement.md @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +use harness + +# 0.0.7 internals topic orchestrator + +You are `topic-internals-0.0.7`, one of exactly four topic orchestrators under the milestone coordinator. Work from `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-internals` on `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-internals`, whose immutable dispatch base is `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`. + +## SKILL + +Read and follow these skills completely before acting: + +- `.agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/agent-milestone-orchestrator/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-tools/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-deno-toolchain/SKILL.md` + +Also read the canonical approved coordination artifacts in `/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/`: `context-pack.md`, `plan.md`, `milestone-leaf-plan.json`, `leaf-contracts.json`, `milestone-dependency-dag.json`, `milestone-cluster-state.json`, `worklog.md`, `supervisor.md`, and `drift.md`. PLAN-EVAL approved immutable plan head `331f7c664`; coordinator control head at dispatch is `5330285f65242eff639cfc5c7ed68a80740de910`. + +## Authority and lane + +Own only the internals lane: #1296, #1378, #1429, #1533, #1542, #1545, #1557, #1561, #1563, #1601, #1604, #1611, #1613, #1618, #1621, #1622. The coordinator is the sole merge and release authority. You must not merge, publish, alter milestone scope, mutate central cluster state, or touch any user-owned worktree. Leaf PRs target `main` directly and remain draft until coordinator review. Never publish locally. + +Wave 0 has exactly two ready leaves: `quality-scan-allowance-rail` (#1378 + #1545, inseparable because registration must precede enforcement) and `harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling` (#1561 + #1563 + #1621). Keep these boundaries exact. + +## Execution contract + +Act as a topic orchestrator, not either leaf implementer. Create fresh leaf worktrees/branches from current live `origin/main`, no upstream, and leaf run directories. Launch only through the Deno agentic suite with briefs beginning `use harness` and containing `## SKILL`. Run no more than the two allowed implementers concurrently and no more than one evaluator. Record worktree, branch, thread id, requested/observed route, draft PR, head SHA, and exact resume/steering command for each. + +Every leaf must inspect live issues, use the structured NetScript Deno check/test/quality reporters and preserve their JSON receipts, commit in reviewable slices, push by explicit refspec, and open a draft PR against `main` with acceptance evidence. Use PLAN-EVAL N/A only for locked/mechanical work; otherwise run the bounded plan gate. Require substantive Tier-A review and a separate opposite-family IMPL-EVAL before requesting merge. Run `quality:gate` and JSR audit only where the leaf contract marks them applicable. Do not overlap the one global expensive gate. + +Any Claude supervisor/orchestrator session you introduce must be native Claude Remote Control (`/remote-control`, launched through the supported native/hybrid surface), with matching PID/cwd and non-empty `bridgeSessionId` recorded. A custom-endpoint/OpenRouter Claude session is not Remote Control and must never be described as mobile-visible. + +Start now: reconcile live `main` and issue state, launch both ready wave-zero leaves within WIP, and keep supervising them. Report progress in topic run artifacts and return a compact identity/status table to the coordinator; never claim merge authority. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/context-pack.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8b62afbe4f --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/context-pack.md @@ -0,0 +1,840 @@ +# Context pack — release 0.0.7 + +Read, in order: + +1. `.llm/harness/workflow/milestone-run.md` +2. `.llm/harness/workflow/canary-cadence.md` +3. `.llm/harness/workflow/run-loop.md` +4. `.llm/harness/workflow/lane-policy.md` +5. `.agents/skills/agent-milestone-orchestrator/SKILL.md` +6. This run's `research.md`, `plan.md`, `worklog.md`, `step0-synthesis.md`, the four milestone + control JSON artifacts, `milestone-leaf-plan.json`, and `leaf-contracts.json`. + +Baseline identity is `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`. Treat GitHub live state as mutable +after the snapshot; any issue or `main` drift must be recorded before dispatch or merge. + +Step 0 is approved at 64 inspected targets / 60 active issues, 43 leaves, and nine dispatch waves. +#1564 is closed-fixed; there is no implementation wave-zero barrier. PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 approved +dispatch at plan head `331f7c664`; `leaf-contracts.json` is binding input for every leaf. + +Reset authority at `2026-08-15T00:00:00+02:00`: `codex-root-0.0.7` remains sole milestone +coordinator in Codex session `019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd`; its canonical transcript is +`/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/13/rollout-2026-08-13T12-20-27-019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd.jsonl`. +Resume that exact session rather than creating a rival coordinator. Its binding route is GPT-5.6-SOL +at **high** effort, never max, through the Codex app-server Remote Control socket +`unix:///home/codex/.codex/app-server-control/app-server-control.sock`. The current proof is resume +PID `2452378` with explicit `-m gpt-5.6-sol -c model_reasoning_effort=high` and app-server PID +`5027` with `--remote-control`; the two interrupted `max` turn contexts are non-authoritative +history. Topic supervision is native Claude Opus 5/high only. Preserve the four active Claude Remote +Control supervisors as-is; a coordinator transport repair never authorizes their relaunch or +mutation. Claude supervisors do not implement; WSL Codex Sol leaves use effort matched to the +harness's per-slice complexity record. + +Read `briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json` after the central state. It supersedes both the pre-reset +six-Fable route and the rejected Sonnet-low matrix. The six retained holds have specific existing +issue/complexity justification; future PLAN-EVAL is conditional rather than mechanical. Formal gates +stay fresh, separate, and opposite-family. Their queues are serial **within each topic +orchestrator**, while one evaluator in each of docs, internals, fixes, and features may run +concurrently. The cluster-wide expensive-gate limit remains reserved for shared resource-heavy +E2E/Aspire work. Opus 5 low through high is the normal adversarial/evaluation route. Fable 5 is +reserved for a recorded genuinely architectural PLAN question or an exceptionally complex +implementation/review. No paused leaf resumes merely because the clock reset; its exact head, hold, +lane-local evaluator lease, CI, and formal gate must be re-established first. + +All four historical Codex topic controllers are now durably parked: docs had no live session; +internals/fixes/features returned `TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED`, are idle, and left clean worktrees. The +rejected Sonnet-low replacement canaries also exited with `TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED_MODEL_FLOOR` and +dispatched no leaf or evaluator. The real replacements are now active through native Claude 2.1.233 +with explicit `--model claude-opus-5`, `--effort high`, `--remote-control`, the exact initial brief, +and bypass permissions. Their exact session/PID/bridge/URL/topic-head receipts live in +`milestone-cluster-state.json` and their topic journals. The hybrid wrapper is not needed unless a +later task explicitly authorizes its alternate-worker delegation surface. + +Live checkpoint advanced at `2026-08-14T23:54:29Z`: `main` is now +`0b3ed5d5a6aea451318f120988c25dfa3993a2ab` after coordinator merges of #1644 and #1643. Reset orders +1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 are terminal `PASS`; orders 3/4/5/6 have been returned to their preserved Codex +implementation threads through the existing Claude topic supervisors. Fixes order 5 first returned +`FAIL_PLAN` cycle 1, was repaired at `5b3c6fcf2` by the original Codex plan-author thread, then +passed fresh PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 at evaluator commit `b8fc5eb53` in session `06451c1e-…`. PR #1654 is +draft at `status:impl`; only its preserved Codex thread `019ffcca-8be0-…` is authorized to +implement. Reset orders 1 and 2 are merged. Continue to serialize only inside each topic +orchestrator; never introduce a cluster-wide evaluator wait, and keep the separate shared-resource +`expensiveGates` mutex empty until a genuine E2E/Aspire gate needs it. + +Completion supervision resumed at `2026-08-15T03:46:43Z`. The live continuation point is no longer +the reset-gate table above: docs S2 is active after exact pinned-input provisioning; internals #1653 +is in fresh Opus 5/high IMPL-EVAL session `430d5f91-…`; features #1651's session `2a8cf0a6-…` ended +conditional `PASS` at `0e302ad3a`, but owner comment `5300440887` supersedes readiness and requires +the active delegated RFC-0003 duplicate/overlap audit; fixes #1654 repaired Tier-A finding T-1 at +`ebad68c80`, and now holds the singleton slice-6 `scaffold.runtime` lease granted only after empty +Aspire/Docker/central-lease preflight. Keep the coordinator turn active through those terminal +results and subsequent merge-readiness decisions. A supervisor's parked checkpoint is never itself a +reason to yield. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T05:06:31Z` checkpoint, not the stale paragraph above. +#1653 cycle 2 passed at `70177e808`; current-head CI and close-gate passed, it merged as +`473e8d75b`, and #1378/#1545 closed `COMPLETED` with terminal labels. Internals has advanced its +next serial leaf, `quality-scan-root-coverage` (#1542), to harness bootstrap/research/plan. #1654's +clean retry reached one terminal `suite-end`, 89/0/0, and cleanup receipt proves empty Aspire, +Docker, custom-network, volume, and leak-survivor state; head `0b2cf5e7c` is in Tier-A review and +the shared lease is complete. #1652 must first rewrite issue comments `5265826161` and `5265971722` +in place from authoritative EIS-Chat `5191de83`, with recalculated feature/effort estimates. The +comments predate the material route improvements already contained in that pin; no newer product +head exists, and `834a2b36` differs only by harness evidence. #1651 is not duplicate overall but +remains owner-blocked: wait for option 1 keep-and-narrow, option 2 remove/defer C6, or option 3 +close-as-duplicate. Do not infer the verdict. All topic controllers and leaf threads remain the +preserved originals; serialization is per topic, not cluster-wide. + +Resume from the newer `2026-08-15T05:16:27Z` checkpoint. #1652's two canonical issue-comment +replacements are complete and approved S3 is running on the original Codex author thread from +`54e1c3bff`. #1654 passed Tier-A at `f178ac663`; its one formal native Fable 5/medium IMPL-EVAL is +attached as session `19f1be7b-db7d-47c0-b0f1-7cfca302d44a`, bridge +`session_01Qs22iAtnVYh2fLb26ABvja`, with no expensive-gate authority. Internals has opened draft +#1656 for #1542 at bootstrap head `5dc2d2148` and is still research/plan-only. Preserve #1651's +owner hold and all four original Opus 5/high Remote Control topic supervisors. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T05:52:01Z` checkpoint. Main is `da574111a` after #1654 +shipped with green post-merge CI/Pages/code-quality; #1262/#1263/#1588 are closed completed and the +host is empty. Docs #1652 is in one bounded F1–F5 repair on its original Codex author thread after +formal IMPL-EVAL cycle 1 `FAIL_FIX` at `e95f48380`; authorize cycle 2 only after the repaired head +receives fresh independent Tier-A. Internals #1656 passed PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 at `3b95a004f` and is +implementing its approved three-file plan on the original Codex thread; the earlier Fable attempt +was zero-token route drift, not a cycle. Fixes #1358 is implementing and must request the singleton +lease before `fresh-browser`. #1651 remains draft and unchanged until the owner explicitly selects 1 +keep-and-narrow, 2 remove/defer C6, or 3 close-as-duplicate. Preserve all four topic supervisor +session IDs and Remote Control bridges; serialization remains per topic, while Aspire/Docker/E2E +alone share the global expensive-gate mutex. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T06:07:53Z` checkpoint. Docs #1652 repaired formal cycle-1 +findings at `c7ce58a19`, passed hardened supervisor Tier-A at `3aedb4cce`, and has one fresh Opus +5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 authorized against that immutable head. Internals #1656 is +functionally green at `dbbedde34` but must record its three justified JSON field-name clarifications +in `drift.md` and obtain slice-1 sign-off before S2. Fixes #1657 holds the singleton `fresh-browser` +lease at `4a3c40321`; only Playwright/Chromium is in scope and cleanup plus empty Aspire/Docker are +mandatory before the lease completes. #1651 remains unchanged and draft pending the owner's explicit +1/2/3 disposition. Do not serialize these topic-local actions across lanes. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T06:19:11Z` checkpoint. Docs #1652 cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL is +still working in the fresh native Opus 5/medium Remote Control session `4ed649d5-…` against clean +source `c7ce58a19`; do not repair, ready, merge, or start the next docs leaf before its terminal +verdict. Internals #1656 S1 is signed off at `a258bcc8c`; S2 is running on its preserved Codex +thread and has local commits through `a7e9ee0d5`, but the PR is not yet pushed beyond the S1 head, +so await the author's explicit stop and supervisor Tier-A. Fixes #1657's singleton browser lease is +terminal PASS with evidence head `c792327c9`; Aspire, Docker containers, volumes, and browser +survivors are empty, and fixes Tier-A is running. #1651 remains an unchanged draft awaiting owner +choice 1 keep-and-narrow, 2 remove/defer C6, or 3 close as duplicate. Only the shared runtime mutex +is cluster-wide; all evaluator and implementation serialization remains per topic. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T06:24:17Z` checkpoint. Docs #1652 formal cycle 2 is +terminal `PASS` at `71cc5a02c`; the preserved Codex author is correcting only evaluator N1–N3, then +the docs supervisor performs one topic Tier-A and stops. Never launch cycle 3. Internals #1656 S2 is +signed off at `4ae309d57`; final S3 is run-artifact-only and active on the preserved author thread, +after which coordinator may grant one fresh IMPL-EVAL. Fixes #1657 Tier-A found T-3 at `5fe600235`: +CLI design-template-only changes bypassed the Fresh UI drift CI. The coordinator amended the +contract at `c5e06661b` with exactly the Fresh UI workflow, classifier, and classifier test; +repair/re-review is active, without another browser/Aspire/Docker pass. #1651 is unchanged and draft +pending explicit owner option 1/2/3. Runtime mutex is free; serialization is per topic. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T06:54:51Z` checkpoint. Docs #1652 is still on its +original Codex author thread after head `d4a0a8340`: current-head CI exposed the deterministic +`agent-docs.generated.ts` cascade from the refreshed prose bundle. The contract is amended by that +one generated file plus run artifacts; obtain fresh opposite-family Tier-A and current-head CI, but +never launch formal cycle 3. Internals #1656 formal IMPL-EVAL cycle 1 passed at evaluator commit +`addba1ab9` for immutable source `2c4881fd7`; the preserved topic supervisor owns body/issue +truthfulness, `impl-eval:skip`-before-ready ordering, and current-head CI, then stops before merge. +Its `.llm/**` lint-exclusion finding is a separate follow-up, not a rescope. Fixes #1657 formal +cycle 1 returned `FAIL_FIX` at `a46b83831`: the source template had 66 entries but the shipped +`embedded.generated.ts` still had 50. Scope is amended by exactly that generated barrel; allow one +same-author repair, fresh Tier-A, and one final Opus 5/medium Remote Control cycle 2, with no +browser, Aspire, Docker, scaffold, or E2E rerun. #1651 remains frozen pending explicit owner choice +1/2/3. Runtime remains empty and the expensive-gate mutex free; serialization is only per topic. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T07:12:16Z` checkpoint. Main is +`7737d8903bb2925c3fcefbda362168fe297eebd4` after #1656 merged from exact source `b80794470`; #1542 +is closed completed and both PR/issue carry `status:shipped`. Internals has advanced its next serial +leaf, draft PR #1658 `openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal` (#1611+#1613), on preserved Codex thread +`01a00443-…` at immutable base `7737d8903` and bootstrap `ca2266ecb`; its current authority ends +after research/plan. The L-2 mixed lint-batch exclusion false-green is a separate later tooling +leaf, not a fold-in or workaround. Fixes #1657 passed fresh Tier-A at `3d7819203`; its single final +Opus 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 is running in session `1df19d27-…` over that exact +local=remote=PR head. Docs #1652 is at final cascade head `a465836b4`; all four freshness gates pass +and its supervisor is waiting on fresh Tier-A plus terminal exact-head Actions, with formal cycle 3 +forbidden. Features #1651 remains untouched and owner-blocked on choice 1 keep-and-narrow C6, 2 +remove/defer C6, or 3 close as duplicate. Main CI has no failure at checkpoint but core `ci` is +still in progress. Agentic runtime is `no_change`; Aspire, Docker containers, and volumes are empty. +Preserve all four native topic supervisors and enforce serialization per topic only. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T07:25:00Z` checkpoint. Docs #1652 merged from +`a465836b4` as main `e090f894ff3682405a36e4f896ffd2cc16f9a1f8`; #1551 closed completed and the docs +lane has no residual bound 0.0.7 leaf. Internals #1658 stopped at research head `670e37bea` because +its original frozen contract excluded the real CLI producer and regression tests. The coordinator +replaced it with the exact eight-path mutation envelope recorded in `leaf-contracts.json`; +`.github/workflows/openhands-phase-eval.yml` is read-only precedent. Formal mode is explicit +`--phase plan|impl`, PR-only, verdict-bound, and uses a live CLI-resolved head; non-formal mode +stays tuple-free. Refusals are one sanitized non-recursive pre-spend reply, and lookup retry is 5×1s +with an attributable fail-closed exhaustion result. Resume the same Codex author only to rewrite the +plan, then run one fresh opposite-family PLAN-EVAL because the claim/spend and workflow-permission +boundary is architectural. Fixes #1657 cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL remains active at `3d7819203`. Features +#1651 stays frozen on owner choice 1/2/3. Main CI is running without a failure at this checkpoint; +Aspire and Docker remain empty. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T07:40:16Z` owner-verdict checkpoint. The owner chose +option 1 for features #1651: keep the distinct plugin CLI RFC and narrow C6. Release the lane hold +and resume only the preserved original Codex author. C6 owns the generic contribution workspace-plan +executor, preview/apply safety, common stage/check/commit/rollback, and generic doctor states. RFC +0003/#1490 exclusively owns command-store provider/Prisma/schema/migration/bridge/database and +business-command semantics. The adapter maps the RFC-0003 domain plan into the shared executor; C6 +must not parse Prisma or own migrations, and RFC 0003 must not build a second generic CLI mount or +workspace transaction engine. The planner must return the same canonical plan in preview and apply. +Correct the PR-body receipt attribution and cache-hit note, rerun the six contracted gates at the +amended content head, obtain fresh opposite-family Tier-A, and run one bounded final IMPL-EVAL; no +new PLAN-EVAL or open loop. Keep the PR draft until coordinator readiness. Internals #1658 is at +repaired plan `cea999d18` awaiting its authorized Opus 5/medium PLAN-EVAL. Fixes #1657 is removing +only the three redundant T-3 CI deltas before fresh Tier-A. Docs remains terminal. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T07:48:51Z` checkpoint. Features #1651 is no longer +held: topic checkpoint `1bfc1cfcd` is clean/pushed and the preserved original Codex author +`019ffcc5-…` is performing the one bounded keep-and-narrow amendment from immutable starting head +`0e302ad3a`. It must preserve the plugin CLI architecture, narrow only C6/RFC-0003 ownership, +correct receipt provenance, run six exact-head gates, then stop for fresh Tier-A and one focused +IMPL-EVAL. Internals #1658 repaired plan `cea999d18` passed topic Tier-A and is under its single +fresh native Opus 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL in session `7d544aec-…`, bridge +`session_01N9zhX5ZDUvvrBxcwoAYBCm`; implementation remains forbidden before `PASS`. Fixes #1657's +formal cycle 2 passed and its bounded cleanup is clean/pushed at `a891c6520`; the redundant three CI +paths equal main and fresh cleanup Tier-A is next, with no cycle 3 or runtime rerun. Docs remains +terminal. Serialization is per topic; the expensive runtime mutex is free. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T08:04:33Z` checkpoint. Features #1651 completed the +owner amendment at content `67e12f021` and evidence `d45a92ba7`; local=remote=PR, all six contracted +receipts pass at the content head, the check provenance/body defects are corrected, and comment +`5301282095` is posted. Fresh Tier-A and one bounded final IMPL-EVAL remain; keep draft/status:impl. +Internals #1658 formal PLAN-EVAL passed at evaluator head `e15d78588`, comment `5301255122`; topic +checkpoint `d5ade932b` carries N1–N5 and the preserved original Codex author is implementing S1 with +a supervisor watcher armed. Stop at each slice for Tier-A, and do not dispatch OpenHands or runtime +gates. Fixes #1657 cleanup Tier-A artifact `21403902b` requested only three PR-body truthfulness +edits; same-author body correction and one focused fresh recheck are active, with cycle-2 product +PASS unchanged and no gate rerun. Docs is terminal and the runtime mutex remains free. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T08:31:20Z` checkpoint. Fixes #1657 shipped as main +`6917c656e`; #1358 is closed with 7/7 acceptance boxes and shipped lifecycle labels. Features #1651 +then shipped as current main `284dda90a`; the owner keep-and-narrow boundary passed final bounded +IMPL-EVAL at `ec69100c8`, the owner disposition is answered in comment `5301349600`, and #1502 is +closed with 5/5 boxes and shipped labels. Both temporary `impl-eval:skip` labels were removed. +Internals #1658 S1 passed topic Tier-A at `6f725ad3b` after load-bearing root test 4,138/0; the same +Codex author is implementing S2 at `28a8a9184` and must stop again for Tier-A before S3. Features +and fixes supervisors were steered in place to reconcile the merges and advance only their own +frozen queues; fixes must preserve the #1348→#1350 prerequisite. Combined-main CI is active without +a failure. Runtime mutex remains free; no Aspire/Docker/browser gate is active. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T08:45:30Z` checkpoint. Exact current main remains +`284dda90a17a13a7e5e8e9834e5411b58887131b`, and combined-main workflow `31874580034` is terminal +success. Docs is active again under the owner's post-freeze #1659 replacement: draft #1660 at +`0b67ef39e` is on the original Codex author thread and repairing four Tier-A findings before a fresh +topic re-review. Internals #1658 S2 passed at `0886c2427`; S3 implementation is local at `d7fdbb1d9` +and must stop for Tier-A before S4. Fixes #1661 correctly stopped artifact-only at `1d4533462`; +topic ruling `af53757e6` expands exactly five `packages/ai/**` paths and fixes the additive public +status/cancellable-close contract before resuming the same author. Features #1293 is +research/plan-only; preserve and wire the already-published `onConnectionError` option, and run one +opposite-family PLAN-EVAL only if the clean returned plan remains decision-heavy after topic review. +Aspire and Docker remain empty. Keep the four native Opus 5/high supervisors and enforce +serialization only inside each topic. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T09:08:30Z` checkpoint. Main remains +`284dda90a17a13a7e5e8e9834e5411b58887131b`. Docs #1660 is ready at exact head `e35824d41` after a +fresh exclusive-owner Tier-A PASS and all eight #1659 boxes; merge only after its current readiness +CI is terminal green, then close/lifecycle-normalize #1659 and remove `impl-eval:skip`. The disclosed +stash incident is fully recovered at exact object `7eb4ed16d…`; no data loss occurred. Internals +#1658 has S3 signed off at `d3d31b3d0` and S4 local at `9b71e1bd2`, still before its required +receipt/push/Tier-A stop. Fixes #1661 is implementing amendment 2 through pushed `099067c6b`, with +both published transport wrappers and a Fresh cross-package check now binding. Features #1293 +PLAN-EVAL passed at `7780ba49e`; the evaluator job's terminal metadata stayed stale, so the +coordinator verified the final response directly and woke the existing features supervisor to amend +the plan and resume the original Codex author. Do not launch a duplicate evaluator. Preserve all +four native Opus 5/high Remote Control supervisors, serialize only inside each topic, and keep the +runtime mutex free unless a real resource-heavy gate requests it. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T09:28:54Z` checkpoint. Current main is +`729386c567bfbd0b8c7f86a4ed09348f0a8a4ad8`: docs #1660 is merged, #1659 is closed 8/8 and shipped, +Pages push run `31876977060` passed, and both `/comparisons/frontend/` and +`/comparisons/backend/` are live with HTTP 200. The readiness failure was a stale exact-corpus +snapshot, repaired at `615786c1a` into stable named invariants and freshly Tier-A reviewed in comment +`5301575337`; never revert it to total-count pinning. Internals #1658 has final S5 evidence at +`704c067e8` with all three receipts green and is in final Tier-A. Fixes #1661 is Tier-A PASS at +`e3c74d7aa`; one fresh opposite-family IMPL-EVAL lease is granted and launching. Features #1293 is +implementing S1 after the verified plan amendment `feb8b0355`. Preserve the original author threads, +all four native Opus 5/high Remote Control supervisors, per-topic serialization, and the free +expensive-gate mutex. + +#1661's active evaluator is Fable 5/medium Remote Control session `cb917802-ee26-4b89-86b9-0eee33c7de1b` +with bridge `session_01Kwmr8XjoznnQsHUnkmfcnV`, exact source `e3c74d7aa`. Its route/identity/lease +were recorded before mutation at fixes topic head `57680baf3`; do not launch a duplicate. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T09:41:25Z` checkpoint. Docs is exhausted and parked at +topic `0ca4c489f`. Internals #1658 has final Tier-A PASS at `f46d84630` and exactly one active native +Opus 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL, session `740d2a3a-1677-459c-a6b1-a39398649d1a`, bridge +`cse_01NVeBmZE7SwH3Nvu3ep51zV`. Its preceding Fable probe `e58c5f01` was a zero-token, +pre-inference availability failure and is not an evaluation cycle. Fixes #1661 cycle 1 is terminal +`FAIL_FIX` at evaluator commit `8d6b4726c`; Tier-A was withdrawn at `1bdb09e13`, and the original +Codex author is performing the bounded registration-signal lifetime repair before fresh Tier-A and +IMPL-EVAL cycle 2. Features #1293 S1 is accepted at `49fda0b77`; S2 is active with an intentionally +dirty implementation tree. Preserve every existing author thread and all four native topic +supervisors. Serialize within each topic only; no cluster-wide serialization and no duplicate gate. + +Newer exact transition at `2026-08-15T09:53:39Z`: #1661's repair is Tier-A PASS at `df0534416`, and +fresh cycle-2 evaluator `eb7149da-1689-44af-970e-ddd6e78022fa` / Fable 5 medium / Remote Control is +active on that immutable head, bridge `cse_01CaAEKsH35CP2QgfNUVdXK1`. Features #1293 S2 is Tier-A +PASS at `47ad48c9d`; S3 content `3dee41263` is running exact-head structured receipts. Internals' +Opus evaluator remains active independently. Do not serialize these three topics against each other. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T10:20:00Z` checkpoint. Main is +`05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b`: #1658 is merged and #1611/#1613 are closed with sole +`status:shipped`. Internals has released `package-gate-honesty` (#1604/#1618/#1622) on Codex +thread `01a004ec-…`, bootstrap/research/plan only; its eventual `scaffold.runtime` requires the +coordinator mutex. Fixes #1661 cycle-2 evaluation passed but exact-head CI found the optional +`@tanstack` computed-import invariant was regressed; the preserved original author is restoring it +in one file before fresh Tier-A and a proportionate fresh evaluator. Features #1662 IMPL-EVAL passed +at `f52aa471c`; it is non-draft/`status:ready-merge` with exact-head CI active, while #1293 stays +open and unchanged for the owner-worded concrete-class criterion plus docs #1112. Preserve every +topic supervisor and author thread, serialize only within topics, and keep the runtime mutex free +until a documented gate asks for it. + +Resume from the newer authoritative `2026-08-15T10:39:55Z` checkpoint. Main is +`3fc0f2f9221a8246f0d26a26189bafb2647be08a`: #1662 is merged/shipped, while #1293 remains open +with only boxes 2 and 3 checked. Features has released #1355/#1360 research/plan on original Codex +thread `01a004f9-…`, exact base `3fc0f2f92`; do not implement or run `scaffold.runtime` or +`fresh-browser` before plan review and a coordinator lease. Internals #1663 is at immutable plan +head `72d5aca66` under the sole real Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL `9078ecb6-…`; invalid +probe `bd8b4f90` and stopped Opus fallback `02d8d823` caused no mutation and consume no cycle. +Fixes #1661 is at Tier-A head `de8944011` after one-file computed-import repair `45aca4adc` and +root test 4152/0/19; fresh repair-delta evaluator `8a0ff845-…` is active. Preserve all native topic +supervisors and authors, serialize only within each topic, and keep the runtime mutex free. + +Newer gate disposition at `2026-08-15T10:46:30Z`: #1663 cycle 1 is `FAIL_PLAN` at `be2b18728`. +Coordinator rescope admits `.llm/tools/run-deno-{fmt,lint}.ts` plus their tests and at most one +narrow marker under the broken fixture; the malformed config is immutable, broad fixture skipping +is forbidden, both no-flag scoped commands and negative controls are binding. `scaffold.runtime` +is waived as matrix-`n/a`. The same Codex author repairs only the plan before cycle 2. #1661's +repair-delta evaluation is `PASS` at `f74695bc4`; await terminal exact-head CI and corrected PR +metadata, then coordinator merge/lifecycle normalization and only then release the next fixes leaf. + +Resume from the newer `2026-08-15T10:56:30Z` transition. Main is +`baf1cdf67a4e931af17b4772ddf6101f36152184`: #1661/#1448 are shipped and the fixes supervisor must +release `sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry` only after durable reconciliation. #1664 is draft at +clean head `6aea4a5ea`; PLAN-EVAL is required, but its author is first repairing the Tier-A evidence +class: `scaffold.runtime` is suite-owned release-gate evidence and never a catalog/run-gate receipt, +while `fresh-browser` is a catalog gate. Both remain lease-blocked and load-bearing after cheap +convergence. #1663 remains on the same Codex plan-repair turn after its marker prototype revealed a +second honest nested-config batching seam; accept only a proof that keeps healthy unmarked fixtures +selected and both real-source negative controls alive. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T11:03:30Z` transition. Main remains +`baf1cdf67a4e931af17b4772ddf6101f36152184`. #1664's repaired plan is immutable at +`7f20a34fee4e99ac17edb6ed4de06a3ec9c1934b`; fresh native Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL +`176aace4-b2a2-4b16-bdaa-9db687c7d132`, bridge `cse_01TiYhwUCkdyjziEpFP3kgaS`, is the sole active +features evaluator. Do not lease or run `scaffold.runtime` or `fresh-browser` before plan PASS, +implementation, cheap convergence, and a later explicit central grant. #1663's local-only +`71e803807` plan repair is rejected and unpushed because its 115-to-110 parent skip hid four healthy +files; remote remains `be2b18728`. Preserve the same Codex thread and accept only the corrected +115-to-114, healthy-selected, config-aware batching plan before fresh Tier-A and cycle 2. + +Resume from the newer `2026-08-15T11:09:30Z` transition. #1664 cycle 1 is terminal `FAIL_PLAN` at +`ed34105e2ef344a5b590bca6985810f45f89b0ca`, comment `5301947232`; the same Codex author is applying +the six plan-text findings, with direct `clientKey()` emission ruled and no SDK overload. #1663's +reviewed surface now includes exactly one twelfth path, +`packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`, formatting-only; actual product +mutation remains forbidden before Tier-A and cycle-2 PASS. Fixes has independently released +`sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry` on Sol/medium thread +`01a00516-2033-7ed3-936a-a616cee47447`, base main `baf1cdf67`, research/plan and draft-PR only. +Preserve all three authors and native topic supervisors; serialize only inside each topic. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T11:25:08Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67`. #1664 +cycle 2 is terminal `PASS` at `c53726c69`; its original Codex author may execute only the next +bounded implementation slice with C1-C3 carried, and both `scaffold.runtime` and `fresh-browser` +remain unleased. #1663 is immutable at `df1d7a96d`; Tier-A passed and the sole fresh Fable 5/medium +Remote Control cycle-2 evaluator is `517ac0e7`, bridge `cse_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn`; no product +mutation before PASS. #1665 is draft at `20e7aed41`; Tier-A is `FAIL_FIX` and the same author is +repairing the overflow-event ordering, rejected-report staging, and raw six-diagnostic doc-lint +baseline. Exactly four README/test proof paths plus `docs/site/web-layer/query-bridge.md` are +authorized; no unrelated SDK doc-lint remediation. Preserve all native topic supervisors and +original Codex authors; serialization is per topic only. + +Resume from the newer `2026-08-15T11:36:00Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67`. #1664 S1 is +Tier-A PASS at `5ac6efa30`, features checkpoint `6ea7a17fb`; the same author is running S2 only, +with the two pre-existing SDK `QueryClient` doc-lint diagnostics carried honestly and no expensive +gate lease. #1663 cycle 2 is `FAIL_PLAN` at `c415daad2`, comment `5302030430`; coordinator grants +exactly the generated CLI agent-tools barrel as path 13 plus asset freshness, removes the redundant +task-level doctor skip, and retains the root formatter exclusion. Plan repair only; another formal +failure escalates to the owner. #1665 has a first repair head `92bf26e11`; the same author is +reconciling the fifth docs path before fresh Tier-A. Preserve supervisors/authors and serialize only +inside each topic. + +Newer exact transition at `2026-08-15T11:44:15Z`: #1665's final repaired plan is clean/pushed at +`ee1b44c6d`, Tier-A PASS at fixes topic `318bd087c`. Its sole fresh native Fable 5/medium Remote +Control PLAN-EVAL is active as session `0287ccbe-2740-45ee-b378-33d1c1c59429`, bridge +`cse_01GaNTjv6oY6MaxnKHH1ZfrB`, on that immutable head. Do not implement before verdict. #1664 S2 +and #1663's bounded cycle-two repair remain active independently on their original Codex authors; +neither has an expensive gate lease. + +Resume from the newer `2026-08-15T11:51:00Z` transition. #1665 PLAN-EVAL is terminal PASS at +`cd5193b66`, comment `5302080198`; fixes topic is `7658df7e2` after correcting its own call-site +count, and the original Codex author is executing S1 only. #1663's repaired thirteen-path plan is +clean at `194e22a3d`, Tier-A PASS at `b2e0529be`, but implementation remains blocked at the genuine +owner boundary because both ordinary plan-evaluation cycles failed; a single exceptional final +PLAN-EVAL was recommended and requested. #1664 S2 remains active independently. No runtime lease. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T12:21:00Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67`. #1664 +S2 is Tier-A PASS at leaf `3669e9b87`, features topic `3eab955b1`, after two real FAIL_FIX rounds: +pre-write add-path contract validation and the stale `bridgeInvalidation` template assertion. The +same author is executing S3 only; neither `fresh-browser` nor `scaffold.runtime` is leased or +authorized. #1665 S1 is Tier-A PASS at `0e4e26c51`, fixes topic `f6f8f0fcb`; the same author is +executing S2 only with a real in-memory Deno KV RED/GREEN proof and awaited singleton teardown. +#1663 remains unchanged at its exceptional-final-evaluator owner boundary. Preserve all native +topic supervisors and original Codex authors; serialization remains per topic only. + +Resume from the newer `2026-08-15T12:36:26Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67`. #1664 S3 is +Tier-A PASS at leaf `1df8a5274`, features topic `c91c2084a`; full CLI 598/0, Fresh cheap gates, +asset freshness, both cache-age omission guards, and all earlier generator constraints were +independently rechecked. The same Sol/high author is now running S4 artifact-only convergence: +three per-member public/publish audit sets and the four immutable-head cheap receipts. Any red gate +must stop for attribution and scoped review. No runtime lease exists and `scaffold.runtime`, +`fresh-browser`, Aspire, Docker, S5, and evaluation remain forbidden. #1665 is independently +rerunning the full root check/test after tightening KV initialization inside the mandatory +`try/finally`; its earlier green receipts were correctly invalidated rather than reused. #1663 +remains at the genuine owner-only exceptional-evaluator boundary. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T15:12:31Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67` and +runtime ownership remains empty. #1665 implementation is complete through S3 at `9a26c107a`, fixes +Tier-A `aa4749da4`; its sole fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL is active as +`1fbb1c07-…`, bridge `cse_01JePyQuiERLe8GeWWKQp5wL`, and may change only `impl-eval.md`. #1664 S4 +cheap convergence is Tier-A PASS at evidence head `1c1f45820`, content head `32ea23f50`, topic +`84568f2ff`, with four renewed PASS receipts. Do not grant its S5 lease yet: coordinator finding F2 +proved the plan-required `payments` second-service, key-isolation, idempotent regeneration, and live +Rename/+1-refetch scaffold scenarios are absent. The preserved Sol/high author is recovering that +exact precondition under the features supervisor, after which all affected cheap gates and four +receipts must be renewed and independently reviewed. Fresh's controlled-clock browser prerequisite +is already present. #1663 remains at its owner-only exceptional evaluator boundary. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T15:25:00Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67`; runtime +ownership remains empty. #1665 formal IMPL-EVAL is terminal `PASS`: native Fable 5/medium Remote +Control job `1fbb1c07-…` evaluated product head `9a26c107a` and pushed only `impl-eval.md` as +`0fed4d7ff`, comment `5302881354`. All evidenced PR/issue acceptance boxes are reconciled, +`status:ready-merge` is applied, and the PR is non-draft at that exact head with required readiness +CI active. Merge only after current checks are terminal and truthful. #1664 F2 plan amendment +`4be440020` was committed and pushed before product edits; the original Sol/high author is building +the three shared scaffold/static gates, runtime-only CDP refetch gate, pure tests, and replacement +receipts. Fresh Tier-A is mandatory before any S5 lease. #1663 still requires the exact owner +decision on one exceptional third and final Fable 5/medium PLAN-EVAL at immutable `194e22a3d`; +independent work does not wait on it. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T15:34:28Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67`; Docker, +Aspire application ownership, and the singleton runtime lease remain empty. #1665's formal product +IMPL-EVAL PASS stands, but readiness run `31892668157` failed quality job `95031217843` because the +authorized query-bridge edit invalidated exactly two checked-in agent-docs bundle assets. Fixes topic +`ef396767a` authorizes only those assets plus run artifacts; the preserved Sol/medium author is +regenerating and verifying them, followed by fresh Tier-A and a focused fidelity delta evaluation. +#1664 pushed exact transport-split plan amendment `93fb5532d` before product head `787cfa928`, but +features topic `37372cbae` intercepted the wrong response-stage CDP resume and an unproven fixed-sleep +request baseline. The same Sol/high author is repairing additively and must renew all four receipts +before fresh Tier-A. No runtime lease or evaluator is permitted. #1663's owner-only decision is +unchanged; independent lanes continue. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T15:50:53Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67`; runtime +ownership is empty. #1665 two-asset corpus repair `7549d9fc0` passed fresh Tier-A `7fe2f433e` and +fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control delta evaluation `PASS` at artifact head `72d57229f`, but +readiness run `31893659579` / quality job `95033583015` exposed the next transitive dependency: +`check:assets-barrel` changes only `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-docs.generated.ts` because +it still embeds the old corpus. Fixes scope checkpoint `215aae4b2` authorizes that one path plus run +artifacts; same-author generation, fresh Tier-A, and a focused asset-chain delta verdict remain. +#1664 corrected head `2c8219968` is pushed and fresh receipts are active: deterministic Refresh- +driven completed/stable baseline, response-stage `Fetch.continueResponse`, and shared negative late- +initial-request proof. No runtime lease before fresh Tier-A. #1663 owner boundary is unchanged. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T15:57:31Z` transition. Main remains `baf1cdf67`. +#1664 evidence head `b14975af7` has four PASS/SUFFICIENT receipts and fresh features Tier-A PASS at +topic `63d190d4b`. The features lane owns the singleton S5 runtime lease on a clean host and must run +`scaffold.runtime` then `fresh-browser` serially with cleanup and audits; the PR stays draft and no +evaluator is authorized yet. #1665 link-3 author remains active. Fixes checkpoint `92ea9f829` proves +the branch-caused generated closure is exactly four paths and authorizes only +`packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts` after link 3 lands; no Tier-A/evaluator/readiness +before all links converge on one content head. #1652 had already recorded this exact cascade, and +the missed precedent is now explicit drift. #1663's owner-only decision is unchanged. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T16:03:00Z` transition. Runtime ownership is empty again. +#1664 `scaffold.runtime` at `b14975af7` passed six gates then failed the static generated-client +consumer with one missing canonical DB-Zod module and two real payments-input type mismatches; +cleanup is proven clean and `fresh-browser` is NOT_RUN. Features topic `d2e83f690` releases the +lease. F3 must be scoped/pushed before same-author mutation, cover all three diagnostics and the +false equal-tail assumption, then pass fresh Tier-A before requesting a new lease. #1665 link 3 is +clean/pushed at `27a64ea4c`; fixes topic `a9176278a` is serially dispatching the same original author +for only `packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts`. No fixes Tier-A/evaluator/readiness until +that fourth link lands. #1663's owner-only decision remains unchanged. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T16:14:20Z` transition. Runtime ownership remains empty. +#1665 is clean/pushed at final cascade head `9a2c74c41`; fixes Tier-A PASS checkpoint `cbd32230e` +independently proves all three freshness gates pass simultaneously and leave a clean generated tree. +Fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control evaluator `262ef8e1-…`, bridge +`cse_01E3QfD1wkvb1naZKS6m7bp2`, is active over only the full four-link asset-chain delta. Do not +resume readiness until its artifact-only terminal verdict. #1664 pushed dependency-isolation plan +amendment `c4a900adc` before creating the newly authorized internal primitive after generated-app +replay proved the parent probe cannot be imported through the app's import map. Same author remains +active on cheap tests and four receipts; no new lease before fresh features Tier-A. #1663's exact +owner-only decision remains unchanged. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T16:27:03Z` transition. Runtime ownership remains empty. +#1665's final four-link chain delta evaluator is terminal `PASS` at artifact-only head `ac274a464`, +comment `5303120561`, and fixes topic checkpoint `7a81326a6`; exact-head readiness has only +`check-test` active, so do not relabel or merge until it is terminal green and review threads are +rechecked. #1664 is clean/pushed at F3 product head `6e822a74b`, but its first fresh root-check +receipt is preserved `FAIL` with TS2322 `Timeout` versus `number` in unchanged +`verify-producer-reconnect.ts:268`. Stop all later receipts and expensive work. The same original +Sol/high author is proving before/after whether F3's `node:path` import contaminated the shared Deno +timer typings; if leaf-caused, a bounded amendment must be committed and pushed before repair and a +new receipt must use a distinct path. #1663 remains the only owner-only decision boundary. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T16:31:00Z` transition. Main is now +`3e8e146a4aedf8ee0afec15c83ddaefc171c71f9`: #1665 passed its last exact-head check, had zero review +threads, advanced to sole `status:ready-merge`, and squash-merged; all five linked issues closed. +The fixes supervisor is recording closure and may start only its next dependency-ready serial leaf. +#1664's failed check receipt and report are preserved/pushed at artifact head `3278cca34`; its +pre-F3 archive root check passed, so the new TS2322 is not a carried baseline. The same original +Sol/high author is bounded to remove the F3 Node path/type pollution, after an immutable amendment, +then prove the victim+probe in one batch before distinct replacement receipts and fresh Tier-A. No +lease, Aspire, Docker, browser, runtime gate, or evaluator is authorized. #1663 remains the only +owner-only decision boundary. + +Resume from the authoritative `2026-08-15T16:43:09Z` transition. Main is +`3e8e146a4aedf8ee0afec15c83ddaefc171c71f9`. #1665 and all five linked issues have sole +`status:shipped`; #1668 owns the unrelated stale MCP export corpus. Fixes topic `f9bb928ce` has one +research/plan-only #1461 author at base main, no evaluator or runtime lease. Internals topic +`f96e4f787` pushed #1666's coordinator scope amendment as `a3f6b87b5`; run fresh Tier-A over that +immutable head, then exactly one fresh separate native Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL. +#1663 remains parked at the owner-only exceptional-third-evaluator boundary and its stale active +cycle-2 lease record is corrected to terminal `FAIL_PLAN`; do not relaunch or mutate it. + +#1664 is clean/pushed at evidence head `8940e9266`, content head `193e665ba`. The Node-global repair +has fresh features Tier-A PASS at topic `c7ce2c3f6` and four replacement receipts are +PASS/SUFFICIENT while the original FAIL stays append-only. It owns the singleton active lease +`app-service-client-wiring-f3-runtime`: run suite-owned `scaffold.runtime` first, mandatory +Aspire/Docker cleanup plus empty-host audit; only on PASS run catalog-backed `fresh-browser` +serially, then browser/runtime cleanup and final audit. No evaluator before both runtime gates and +topic reconciliation. Coordinator route remains GPT-5.6-SOL/high through Codex Remote Control, +never max. Preserve every native Claude topic supervisor and the #1651 option-1 adapter boundary. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T16:49:14Z`: #1666 Tier-A PASS is pushed at topic `d5f5ea55a` and its +single authorized native Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL is active as job `68c31fcc`, bridge +`cse_01DcmCJnvESF3a4nVDvUR8u8`, source `a3f6b87b5`, artifact-only. #1461 opened draft PR #1669 at +plan head `7e5be1514`; before PLAN-EVAL, fixes Tier-A must reconcile the raw doc-lint count and amend +scope to include the second demonstrably false cache-refresh claim at +`docs/site/tutorials/live-dashboard/03-sdk-cache-first-query.md`. No product mutation yet. #1664 +continues to own the only runtime lease and is running scaffold first. + +Newer runtime truth `2026-08-15T16:53:06Z`: #1664 evidence head `e1dcb726b` records +`scaffold.runtime` FAIL (20/1/0) at `generated.service-client-contract`; fresh-browser is NOT_RUN and +the singleton lease is released after a verified empty Aspire/Docker/browser host. The leaf's probe +mistook the first reconciliation after plugin configuration changed for a same-input idempotency +rerun. Require an immutable F4 plan amendment before repair, then one allowed reconciliation plus a +second identical invocation that writes zero clients and zero helpers, fresh cheap receipts and +features Tier-A before any new lease. Preserve every prior FAIL and do not launch an evaluator. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T16:57:59Z`: no evaluator or expensive lease is active. #1666 cycle-1 +PLAN-EVAL is terminal `FAIL_PLAN` at `5d229e0f3`; leaf artifact head `cb91b225d`, topic +`818575d18`. SA-2 authorizes only three JSDoc import-line paths—Contracts transform helper to the +transform subpath, filter and pagination schemas to the query subpath—plus plan/run artifacts. The +plan must correct the false claim that docs-accuracy lacks CI enforcement, address N1-N5, pass fresh +Tier-A, then use one fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control cycle-2 evaluator. #1663 stays parked. +#1664 F4 is active on the original Sol/high author after exact consecutive-run/hash proof confirmed +the gate premise was false. #1461 is plan-only at `ebf8977c1`; its second docs-source amendment is +being delivered on the preserved author before Tier-A/evaluation. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T17:11:14Z`: #1664 is clean and immutable at evidence head +`6f813b0db`, content `7876aa109`; four exact-content-head receipts are PASS/SUFFICIENT and fresh +features Tier-A passed at topic `35f3a6975`. The singleton attempt-3 lease is active only for +suite-owned `scaffold.runtime`, followed by mandatory cleanup/audit; `fresh-browser` may run serially +only if scaffold passes, followed by final cleanup/audit. No evaluator yet. Unlike attempt 2, every +preflight artifact was committed before lease grant, so the leased head must not move. #1461 scope +amendment `eadd672d0` is plan-only but fixes Tier-A is `FAIL_FIX` at `9e9d02ebb`: repair the same +authorized page's five additional SWR narrative lines explicitly, re-review, then PLAN-EVAL only on +PASS. #1666 SA-2 plan repair continues on the preserved author under topic `071b2a812`; #1663 stays +at its owner-only boundary. Coordinator route remains GPT-5.6-SOL/high, never max; preserve native +Claude supervisors and #1651 option 1. + +Newer attachment checkpoint `2026-08-15T17:18:10Z`: #1666 plan-only SA-2 head `80046696e` passed +fresh Tier-A at internals topic `bb8c12f56`. Final ordinary PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 is active as fresh +native Fable 5/medium session `580832d7-53e8-4828-ad41-e2f9219c9340`, PID 379716, launched with +Remote Control and bound to that exact head. Bridge metadata is truthfully pending until emitted. +Do not begin the three JSDoc edits or any product work before a terminal PASS; a FAIL returns to the +owner boundary. #1664 runtime attempt 3 continues independently under its existing singleton lease. + +Newer runtime truth `2026-08-15T17:19:55Z`: #1664 attempt 3 is terminal `FAIL_FIX`, 32 passed / 1 +failed / 0 skipped at `generated.deno-fmt-check`; the repaired service-client contract passed. +Suite cleanup, run-owned teardown, and independent leak audit leave Aspire/Docker empty with zero +survivors, so the singleton lease is free. `fresh-browser` remains NOT_RUN. Preserve the raw log and +complete generated-format attribution before any amendment or retry; no product mutation is +authorized under the released lease. #1666 cycle-2 evaluator remains active independently. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T17:29:40Z`: #1461 repaired plan `23db20f30` passed fixes Tier-A at +`f71e860f9`; PLAN-EVAL job `01f0eda8`, bridge `cse_01SWnk7LwvoLaamvEwR5WLfX`, is active native +Fable 5/medium Remote Control. #1666 cycle-2's initial session was interrupted after verification +but before artifact/verdict; the same history is recovered as job `0e2d1e57`, bridge +`cse_01K6SbsotG5MyjyjTd11SrfK`, without consuming another cycle. #1664 evidence is pushed at +`09a771c8e`; do not accept its blanket baseline attribution until fresh features Tier-A classifies +all twelve unformatted generated paths, several of which are leaf-owned. No runtime lease is active. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T17:32:06Z`: #1666 final ordinary PLAN-EVAL passed at evaluator commit +`45c249b9c`, comment `5303401348`; internals `fd96c2075` dispatched only S1 to the preserved author. +Require fresh slice review before S2/S3. #1664 features Tier-A `0d0ba1b7a` rejects the blanket +baseline claim as leaf-caused, but must still correct its seven-helper count, measure the three +payments outputs against `c53726c69`, and identify a bounded repair that makes all twelve generated +outputs formatter-clean. No runtime retry, fresh-browser, or F5 product mutation is authorized yet. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T17:36:05Z`: #1669 PLAN-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at evaluator commit +`d555cc971`, comment `5303412171`; fixes topic `370ff6eba` dispatched S1 only to the preserved +Sol/medium author. Carry evaluator advisories A2/A3 in product/tests and A1/A4 into S2; require fresh +Tier-A before S2. #1664's corrected features record is `f5f75adc8`: all twelve format failures share +the post-init canonicalization gap. F5 is authorized only as a same-author plan amendment with exact +paths and formatted-against-formatted equality; a post-write-only call to current `formatOutput` +would regress proven F4 and is not authorized. No runtime lease or fresh-browser run is active. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T17:55:29Z`: #1666 S1 `678840603` passed fresh internals Tier-A at +`6c183ef16`; the preserved author is active on S2 only, with S3 held. #1664 F5 plan amendment +`3204ffa98` received honest Tier-A `FAIL_FIX` at features topic `c8d3acb92`; the same author is adding +three stdin/extension safety proofs and one composition-path justification before another plan +review, with no product mutation. #1669 pushed S1 head `e05a54145`, but coordinator rejected its +499-line result because it removed useful JSDoc/spacing solely to suppress F-1. The same author is +restoring that content and must reduce structurally inside the two-file scope or propose one exact +internal helper before any scope widening. No runtime lease, Aspire application, Docker container, +or browser gate is active. #1663 remains untouched at its owner-only third-evaluator boundary. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T18:00:45Z`: #1666 S2 is clean/pushed at `47ca22abe`; fresh internals +Tier-A is active and S3 stays held. #1664 plan repair `630185e2c` passed fresh features Tier-A at +topic `53f97644d`; the same original Sol/high author is implementing F5 under the reviewed +15-product/12-test ceiling, with fresh exact-head receipts and another Tier-A required before any +runtime retry. #1669's same-author anti-gaming correction is structurally consolidating duplicate +cache-entry reads with JSDoc restored; S2 remains held until commit/push and fresh fixes Tier-A. No +runtime lease exists. #1663 and accepted #1651 option-1 keep-and-narrow remain unchanged. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T18:07:44Z`: #1666 S2 `47ca22abe` passed fresh internals Tier-A at +`dbe72c50e`; final run-artifact-only S3 is active serially on the same author. #1669 transparent +structural repair `e100ea205` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `c01f32141`; same-author S2 dispatch is +being recovered and must stop for another Tier-A before IMPL-EVAL. #1664 F5 product implementation +continues independently inside the accepted 15-product/12-test ceiling. No runtime lease exists; +#1663 and #1651 option 1 remain unchanged. + +Delivery update `2026-08-15T18:11:19Z`: #1669 S2 is now verified active on the original author with +the exact two docs pages, one factory regression, four generated mirrors, and run artifacts. It must +stop for fresh fixes Tier-A before IMPL-EVAL; no runtime lease or out-of-scope tooling change exists. + +Newer stop `2026-08-15T18:17:33Z`: #1669 S2 exposed the pre-existing fresh-entry bug in +`preferFreshOnStale` and stopped before generation/commit. A plan-only amendment may add exactly +`cache-query.ts`, preserving expired precedence and applying the flag only when stale; the existing +factory regression remains the proof. Fresh fixes Tier-A precedes source mutation and S2 resume. No +additional test file, runtime lease, or final gate is authorized. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T18:25:53Z`: #1666 final Tier-A passed at `18eed10c9`; one artifact-only +Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL is launching over source `47ca22abe` and evidence +`d095c1260`. #1669 S2-A `ef3e43f06` passed fixes Tier-A `684c37d63` and the same author resumed the +one-line repair plus S2. #1664 F5 source `fda78ee43` / evidence `1263f655b` has four PASS/SUFFICIENT +receipts and is under final features Tier-A before any runtime lease. #1663 and #1651 option 1 are +unchanged. + +Newer checkpoint `2026-08-15T18:30:23Z`: #1664 final F5 Tier-A is `PASS` at features topic +`9a5521aa0`. A fresh Aspire-orchestration preflight found local/remote/PR all at immutable evidence +`1263f655b`, `aspire ps` empty, zero running Docker containers, no AppHost/DCP/application/browser +processes, no relevant listeners, and no competing lease. Attempt 4 now owns the singleton runtime +lease: `scaffold.runtime` first, mandatory cleanup/audit, then `fresh-browser` only on PASS and a +second cleanup/audit. #1666 IMPL-EVAL is active under native Fable 5/medium Remote Control session +`3882ca70-7857-46ca-aa24-8b1ae2664516`, bridge `cse_013RnnFDtHQhEbFhJCLbkEsD`, artifact-only over +implementation `47ca22abe` and evidence `d095c1260`. #1669 has applied exactly the approved predicate +correction while its two docs pages and query-factory test remain in the bounded S2 author turn. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T18:41:18Z`: #1666 cycle-1 IMPL-EVAL returned `FAIL_FIX` at +`4c09e9203`, comment `5303665087`, with exactly one test-quality defect. Three refusal tests can pass +for an unrelated NotFound or a masking OMITS result; the checker itself and every other re-derived +judgment hold. Internals topic `3c8db8178` returned only the authorized test path to the same original +Sol/medium author, requiring specific-cause assertions, four independent mutation reds, and all seven +receipts re-cut on one new head before fresh Tier-A and cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL. #1664 attempt-4 runtime +continues independently under its immutable lease; #1669 S2 continues independently. + +Newer stop `2026-08-15T18:48:52Z`: #1664 attempt-4 `scaffold.runtime` is terminal red at 69/1/0. +The previously failing generated format gate passed; `behavior.service-client-refetch` instead threw +when cleanup called `kill(SIGTERM)` on an already-terminated browser child. Raw log hash is +`b476da4ce039d03785e46669d51919b48c41fbae80ca41ca9188bcbb53e97f23`. Suite cleanup passed and an +independent Aspire/Docker/process/port audit is empty, so the lease is released and `fresh-browser` +is `NOT_RUN`. Preserve evidence and attribute before any repair; no retry or evaluator is authorized. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T19:03:12Z`: #1664 plan-only F6 is pushed at `36da13fa1` and undergoing +fresh features Tier-A; only the existing browser probe plus test may later change, with no attempt-5 +lease until implementation receipts and a second Tier-A pass. #1666 has discriminating test content +`423867017` and local evidence `010da98a2`; seven replacement receipts pass at the content head, the +initial scratch-contaminated root-test red is preserved, and internals owns push/comment, fresh +Tier-A, then cycle-2 Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL. #1669 S2 is clean/pushed at +`9aa54ae2d` over `eba0b0924`, comment `5303754598`, and fixes is performing fresh Tier-A before its +separate IMPL-EVAL. The runtime mutex is free. Explicit process auditing removed four stopped +attempt-4 `aspire-managed` utility children missed by `aspire ps`; Aspire, Docker, application, +browser, and port state is now empty. #1663 remains owner-only and #1651 option 1 is preserved. + +Follow-on `2026-08-15T19:05Z`: #1666 repair evidence `010da98a2` is now local == remote == PR with +comment `5303770640`; fresh internals Tier-A is active. #1664 F6 plan Tier-A passed at features topic +`f436df086`, releasing the same author for exactly two paths and four new binding receipts before a +second Tier-A. No runtime lease exists. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T19:08:30Z`: #1666 repair Tier-A passed at `0646f429f` and final +cycle-2 Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL job `7a3b4645` is active at +`session_01MDMbe68iYvjHBLuUGKZqBS` over `423867017`/`010da98a2`. #1669 final S2 Tier-A passed at +`a374977d8`; its Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL job `f40814ce` is active at +`session_01CMrdm9P2YwHxiNCT49C4Hf` over `eba0b0924`/`9aa54ae2d`. #1664's two-path repair continues +in parallel under its topic-local serial queue; the runtime mutex is free. + +Newer terminal `2026-08-15T19:14:29Z`: #1666 final cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL passed at `ee67d12b4`, comment +`5303804773`, over repaired content `423867017` and evidence `010da98a2`. The artifact correctly +binds all eight physical fix1 receipts to the repaired content head and treats the first test receipt +as preserved red. Two stale brief sentences named old `47ca22abe`, but the correct binding section +and the entire evaluator output use `423867017`, so the contradiction is recorded as non-impacting +brief drift. Internals is preparing coordinator readiness; no merge or issue-box edit has occurred. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T19:18:20Z`: #1666 is non-draft at `status:ready-merge`, unchanged head +`ee67d12b4`. All nine PR DoD boxes are current/checked; comment `5303825255` contains the sole five-row +#1296 acceptance mapping; the live dry-run passed before readiness. Current CI run `31903523137` is +active and must produce a real mirror mutation plus green close-gate/core visibility before merge. + +Newer rollback `2026-08-15T19:24:31Z`: #1666 is draft again with `status:impl`; its close-gate red +was a ready-label race and mutated no #1296 box, while quality found a real omitted agent-docs corpus +regeneration caused by the changed Fresh UI reference page. Internals owns a same-original-author, +plan-first exact cascade rescope, fresh Tier-A before generation, renewed exact-head receipts, a +second Tier-A, and a fresh delta IMPL-EVAL before readiness. #1664 is at evidence `4c7792f20` over +product `7fa29ad3e`: the first root-test receipt remains red because an ignored root-owned Postgres +temp tree was traversed. That exact tree is recoverably quarantined under +`/tmp/netscript-f6-quarantine.7kXcDX`; a distinct unchanged-head attempt 2 is active. Runtime leases +remain free; #1663 and #1651 option 1 are unchanged. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T19:31:02Z`: #1669 IMPL-EVAL is `PASS` at artifact-only `313cc08d5`, +comment `5303850473`, with no review threads and exact local/remote/PR equality. All eleven PR DoD +rows are current. Sole acceptance mapping comment `5303873817` covers all six live #1461 boxes; the +live mirror dry-run passed. `impl-eval:skip` and `status:ready-merge` were verified while draft before +the ready flip, avoiding #1666's label race. Exact-head CI run `31904125478` is active. Do not merge +or release the serial #1350 leaf until mirror/close-gate/required checks are terminal green. + +Newer lease `2026-08-15T19:39:00Z`: #1664 final F6 Tier-A passed at `a4224dbb1`; evidence +`a8a160285` is clean/pushed over product `7fa29ad3e`, with four selected PASS/SUFFICIENT receipts and +the environmental red preserved. Host preflight is empty after an explicit post-`aspire ps` audit. +Attempt 5 owns the singleton runtime lease: one `scaffold.runtime`, cleanup/audit, `fresh-browser` +only after PASS, then final cleanup/audit. Stop on any red; no retry or evaluator yet. + +Newer ship `2026-08-15T19:40:10Z`: #1669 merged as main `0ef48c2ec` after exact-head close-gate, +mirror, quality, check-test, and core visibility passed; #1461 is closed with six boxes checked and +both objects exactly `status:shipped`. Fixes may file the reviewed non-blocking docs follow-up and +release #1350 serially on fresh main. Keep #1348 open until all implementation children finish; its +ratified Stage-0 prerequisite is satisfied and does not block #1350. + +Newer dispatch `2026-08-15T19:44:30Z`: #1666 SA-3 plan `f98cfabac` passed fresh internals Tier-A; +the same author is generating exactly four approved corpus/publish outputs before a second Tier-A +and fresh delta IMPL-EVAL. Non-blocking docs debt is filed as #1670. #1350 is active plan-only in +`/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-typed-error` on exact main `0ef48c2ec`, Codex Sol/medium thread +`01a006f3-ae2d-7941-bd17-2ac71dd3d0f0`; keep #1348 open. + +Newer stop `2026-08-15T19:47:30Z`: #1664 attempt 5 is red at 69/1/0 because Chrome never exposed a +DevTools target; F6 teardown no longer masks the verdict. Raw log SHA is `ff349b40…e062b`. +`fresh-browser` is `NOT_RUN`; suite cleanup plus exact-PID orphan cleanup left Aspire, Docker, +application/browser/runtime processes and ports empty, so the lease is released. Same-author measured +attribution and a plan-only amendment precede mutation, Tier-A, or any later retry. + +Newer reconciliation `2026-08-15T19:57:21Z`: the #1669 evaluator lease record is terminal `PASS` +at artifact `313cc08d5`/comment `5303850473`, matching its already-terminal leaf and shipped GitHub +lifecycle. Cluster `currentMainSha` is corrected to live remote main `0ef48c2ec`. The remaining +Claude PID is a background spare, not an evaluator, and is preserved. No lane or runtime lease moved. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T20:17:10Z`: #1664 F7-C1 is corrected/pushed at `a2e9515f5`, Tier-A +PASS at features topic `8ec20d606`, and the same Sol/high author is implementing only the reviewed +probe/test paths before four cheap receipts and another Tier-A; no runtime lease or attempt 6. +#1666 recovery `b67414f4f` preserves the 4202/1/19 supervisor-hook red and records the sole +unchanged-head retry PASS at 4203/0/19; the exact hook event is recoverably quarantined outside the +repo with identical `d0251bc2…ab2` hashes, and second internals Tier-A is active. #1671 amended plan +`2fa2f71dc` passed fixes Tier-A at `6c9486004`; native Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL job +`50898ac7` is active at `session_015RuDy1h3UiCkLzo1PLk5Sc`. No product mutation before its PASS. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T20:23:15Z`: #1671 PLAN-EVAL passed at artifact-only `f76a3c45b`, +comment `5304059808`; S1 alone is active on the preserved Sol/medium author with both RED signatures, +contracts-exported schemas, retained type default, empty metadata slot, and no seventh path. #1666 +second Tier-A passed at `8933f58f2`; fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control delta IMPL-EVAL job +`f281b8cf` is active at `session_01UDGunAVYYPRC6KBNxEwZWA` over `46528ae4c`/`b67414f4f`, with +independent idempotence re-derivation load-bearing. No readiness or runtime lease. + + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T20:38:42Z`: #1666 delta IMPL-EVAL passed at `0d4c82d6e` / comment +`5304103041`, but current main creates a deterministic four-generated-output conflict via #1665. +The original Sol/medium author is integrating `0ef48c2ec` and rerunning the canonical cascade under +internals checkpoint `268544516`; fresh Tier-A and a fresh delta evaluator precede readiness. #1671 +S1 `dc034d680` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `7281cebac`; S2 only is active in `errors.ts`, +`service-client.ts`, and the doctest, with positive exact-union assertions and no metadata/docs scope. +#1664 F7 content `e45144db6` has focused 22/0 and exact-head check PASS; its 4236/1/19 root red is +environmental unreadable attempt-5 residue, preserved at evidence `885f352e7`. The run-owned tree is +recoverably quarantined at `/tmp/netscript-f7-quarantine.iXF6fb`; one exact-content test retry and +the remaining two cheap gates are active before fresh Tier-A. No runtime lease or readiness action. + + +Newer lease `2026-08-15T20:56:25Z`: #1664 F7 evidence `ed3f78e0d` passed fresh features Tier-A at +`4a65a2670`; four exact-content receipts are PASS/SUFFICIENT and the environmental red remains. +Preflight is empty after three older readable run workspaces moved recoverably to +`/tmp/netscript-preattempt6-quarantine.9mNpwE`. Attempt 6 holds the singleton runtime lease at topic +`ac1ec35cf`: run one scaffold.runtime with managed Chrome 151, audit, then fresh-browser only on PASS +plus clean audit; no retry/evaluator. #1671 S2 `ca7ade409` passed fixes Tier-A at `ac0b2c4c3`; S3 is +active on exactly the two docs pages, with S4, metadata, #1348, and #1466 untouched. #1666 merged-main +content `8c03d8629` has twelve exact-head PASS receipts and remains unpushed until its append-only +integration evidence is complete. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T21:03:30Z`: #1666 current-main refresh is now clean/pushed at evidence +`021c7ffc6` over merge content `8c03d8629`, with PR comment `5304205247`. Fresh internals Tier-A +passed at `6658ad9c0`; one native Fable 5/medium Remote Control integration-delta evaluator is active +as job `be3774eb`, bridge `cse_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV`. The prior `f281b8cf` lease is terminal +PASS and was reconciled from stale active state. Hold readiness, acceptance mirroring, close-gate, +and merge until the integration evaluator is terminal. #1664 attempt 6 and #1671 S3 remain active +independently; #1663 remains at the owner-only exceptional third-evaluator boundary. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T21:18:24Z`: #1666 integration-delta IMPL-EVAL passed at artifact-only +`05ac90d00`, comment `5304256350`, with native Fable 5/medium Remote Control proven at +`session_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV`; its lease is terminal. Readiness attempt 2 then passed live +acceptance mirroring and close-gate run `31908897973`, checking all five #1296 rows, but dedicated +changed-source run `31908898023` failed on two leaf-owned type-safety findings in +`check-exports-drift.ts`. #1666 is therefore draft again at `status:impl`, unmerged. The same original +Sol/medium author owns one focused repair; fresh internals Tier-A and a fresh delta evaluator precede +any later ready flip. #1664's bounded attempt 6 and #1671 S4 continue independently; #1663 remains +untouched at its owner-only exceptional evaluator boundary. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T21:31:49Z`: #1664 attempt 6 is terminal red at evidence `2385cdb72`, +comment `5304325367`: valid managed Chrome 151 selection, 69 PASS / 1 FAIL / 0 skipped, exit 143 at +the 900,030 ms `behavior.service-client-refetch` boundary, no output evidence, no retry, and +`fresh-browser` `NOT_RUN`. Raw log is `1bf8cb03…aaa0`; NDJSON is `ffab7e7f…e356`. Final independent +Aspire/Docker/process/port/residue audit is empty after exact cleanup of three stopped run-owned +helpers and recoverable quarantine of the unreadable generated project at +`/tmp/netscript-s5-a6-quarantine-20260815-4M9v8k`. Runtime lease is released. Fresh features Tier-A +must attribute the hang before any repair/retry/evaluator; #1666 repair and #1671 S4 remain active. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T21:36:48Z`: #1666 repair `e357938df` / comment `5304327917` removes +both quality findings without allowances or scanner weakening and passes fresh internals Tier-A at +`138ad7436`. The reviewer rejected its own repository-mode false green, then proved the exact +changed-files mode selected both repaired paths with zero findings. Fresh cycle-5 Fable 5/medium +Remote Control evaluator `dc433b8d` is active at bridge `cse_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC` / URL +`https://claude.ai/code/session_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC`; transport flags and bidirectional bridge +are proven. Readiness remains held. #1664 F8 attribution and #1671 S4 continue independently. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T21:42:53Z`: #1671 S3 `c7cba6d9b` passed fixes Tier-A at `580bd8ec0`. +S4 evidence `db8aadd95` / comment `5304357008` preserves its green matrix and exact authorized +15 +surface attribution but stops on real private-type doc-lint deltas: Contracts 9→11, SDK 3→13; later +JSR/specifier/export guards are `NOT_RUN`. Coordinator authorizes a plan-only S4-R amendment on the +same author within only `contract-primitives.ts`, `errors.ts`, `service-client.ts`, and existing run +artifacts, followed by fresh fixes Tier-A before product repair. #1666 cycle 5 and #1664 F8 continue. + +Newer transition `2026-08-15T21:54:00Z`: #1666 cycle-5 IMPL-EVAL passed at evaluator commit +`92988da30`, comment `5304391856`, Remote Control +`session_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC`. The final PR head is the same evaluator artifact commit; body, +review threads, acceptance mirror, and local close-gate are current and green. #1666 is non-draft at +`status:ready-merge` with exact-head CI `31910676720` plus changed-source quality `31910676700` +active. Do not merge until all current-head checks are terminal and truthful. + +Codex capacity is account-wide exhausted until `2026-08-20 05:31`, proven by fresh detached threads +`01a00766-…` (#1664) and `01a00767-…` (#1671); do not retry it. Continue the two executable +artifact-only routes: #1664 F8 provenance correction via fresh canonical Claude Opus 5/medium +`chore_code`, then fresh Minimax M3/high PLAN-EVAL; #1671 S4-R via fresh Claude Sonnet 5/high +`documentation_review`, then fresh Minimax PLAN-EVAL. Supervisors do not author or self-certify. +#1671 product repair waits for canonical Codex capacity; #1663 remains the sole owner-only exceptional +third-evaluator boundary. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/cut-trace.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/cut-trace.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..e30db930a6 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/cut-trace.md @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +# Cut trace — release 0.0.7 + +Publication has not started. This trace will record canary membership from actual first-parent +history, the exact canary-pinned production E2E, stable publication, and exact artifact-pinned +production E2E. + diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/drift.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/drift.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..57f094a0c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/drift.md @@ -0,0 +1,806 @@ +# Drift — release 0.0.7 + +| Time (UTC) | Drift | Disposition | +| -------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| 2026-08-13T21:12:00Z | #1453 cited a repository surface that never existed. | Moved to Backlog / Triage with public evidence. | +| 2026-08-13T21:12:00Z | #1249 and #1637 were outside the initial milestone snapshot. | Owner-ratified under `high-value-coherent`; #1249 has an explicit reproduction fallback. | +| 2026-08-13T21:27:00Z | #1306 and #1606 were stale-open observations. | Closed completed; #1377 post-merge checkbox synchronized. | +| 2026-08-13T22:42:00Z | #1564's provisional scope incorrectly treated safe three-dot consumers as unfixed. | Re-audited seven constructs; closed completed; removed barrier/leaf; 60 active, 43 leaves, nine waves. | +| 2026-08-13T22:42:00Z | #1360 was inventoried in fixes while its grouped leaf was in features. | Moved to features in inventory/state/contract. | +| 2026-08-13T22:42:00Z | First PLAN-EVAL used Claude Opus/high instead of Fable/medium. | Valid opposite-family verdict retained; route deviation recorded; same conversation gets the sole bounded re-review. | +| 2026-08-13T22:42:00Z | Evaluator write hook created a temporary worktree despite read-only intent. | Artifact captured; session stopped; worktree and temporary branch removed; no product mutation retained. | +| 2026-08-13T23:03:00Z | Fable reached the monthly spend limit after completing cycle-2 evidence collection but before verdict emission. | Same conversation, same cycle, and same evidence used the recorded Opus fallback for final synthesis; verdict `APPROVED`. | +| 2026-08-13T23:10:00Z | Canonical topic-orchestrator route is Claude Opus/high, but native Claude quota is nearly exhausted and Fable already hit the spend limit. | Use the documented same-role Codex Sol/high fallback for the four control sessions; implementations remain Codex-routed and opposite-family evaluation evidence is still mandatory per leaf. | +| 2026-08-13T23:32:00Z | #1561's structured non-zero validation report requires the mirror CLI and directly coupled tests omitted from the pre-dispatch file surface. | Coordinator authorized only the mirror CLI plus five named test peers; `netscript-pr` remains read-only skill guidance, and no unrelated product surface was admitted. | +| 2026-08-13T23:34:00Z | #1243 assumed the streams manifest/copy fields were ignored dead pins, but structured validation proved they remain required compatibility fields. | Preserve/classify those values; authorize only `auth-plugin-command_test.ts` beyond the original contract and finish the core stale silent-default fix with explicit URL/fail-loud guidance. | +| 2026-08-13T23:44:00Z | Native Claude showed 96% weekly use while the milestone control and #1651 PLAN-EVAL Remote Control sessions were active. | Owner stopped both sessions. Continue Codex work; defer any gate that genuinely requires fresh Claude-family capacity until the 2026-08-15 00:00 Europe/Zurich reset rather than substitute silently. | +| 2026-08-13T23:47:00Z | The grouped scaffold leaf proved #1263's OpenAPI-404 sub-symptom is already fixed and that #1262/#1588 require generator-level seams absent from the frozen surface. | Preserve the existing OpenAPI projection with regression coverage; authorize only the named Prisma-config, seed-generator, scaffolder, export, and focused test peers. PLAN-EVAL remains deferred to the Claude reset. | +| 2026-08-13T23:52:00Z | The internals topic launched a Claude-compatible OpenRouter evaluator after the owner had stopped Claude work; its `FAIL_PLAN` commit landed before interruption. | Stop the process, retain the findings only as advisory evidence, forbid any Claude/OpenRouter formal evaluator relaunch before the Saturday reset, and require a fresh formal PLAN-EVAL afterward. | +| 2026-08-13T23:53:00Z | #1653 PLAN-EVAL exposed a closing-owner paradox, three missing coupled surfaces, and 20 pre-existing Workers `private-type-ref` diagnostics. | Bind all seven allowances to existing durable owner #1276 T3; reconcile #1545 to seven; authorize the scanner test, consumer manifest, generated asset, and debt registry; create #1655 in 0.0.8 and accept only a strict no-increase baseline. | +| 2026-08-13T23:55:00Z | The docs topic treated a Minimax/OpenRouter advisory result as formal PLAN-EVAL PASS even though its own brief recorded that it was not opposite-family attestation, then started S1. | Interrupt the Codex S1 turn before any implementation commit, restore PR #1652 to `status:plan-eval`, preserve only the untracked evaluator artifact for audit, and defer implementation to a fresh formal gate after reset. | +| 2026-08-14T00:02:00Z | The docs topic automatically relaunched #1652 S1 twice more after the formal hold, recreating uncommitted docs/navigation changes and advisory transport evidence. | Stop the dedicated docs topic process group and watcher, revert only its unauthorized uncommitted patch via `apply_patch`, remove its temporary follower processes, verify the leaf clean at `d35cbca30`, and keep the docs lane offline until reset. | +| 2026-08-13T21:07:00Z | The fixes topic launched a DeepSeek/OpenRouter IMPL-EVAL for #1643 despite the native-opposite-family hold. | Stop it before verdict, remove the temporary JSONL transport artifact, amend the committed evaluator brief to require native Claude/Fable after reset, stop the fixes topic control, and retain the already valid Codex implementation plus Tier-A review. | +| 2026-08-13T21:17:00Z | #1644's authorized implementation passed its three final gates, but its contract still made `netscript-pr` read-only while #1621 explicitly required plain-bullet/no-evidence-block operator guidance. | Authorize that one exact skill file before immutable-head packaging; preserve all other boundaries and rerun the binding gates only after the acceptance-complete head exists. | +| 2026-08-14T22:12:38Z | The reset arrived after the temporary Codex topic-orchestrator fallback, while three preserved topic threads were stale and the docs controller was already offline. | Owner revoked the fallback. Preserve every thread/branch/worktree/child/PR artifact, durably park the old controller, then attach exactly one native Claude Sonnet 5/low Remote Control supervisor per topic. Never dual-own a topic worktree. | +| 2026-08-14T22:13:00Z | The pre-reset dispatch mechanically required six Fable 5/medium sessions, conflicting with the owner's cost/efficiency override. | Retain all six independent formal gates but right-size their fresh opposite-family routes to Sonnet 5 low/medium, serialize them, deduplicate shared review inputs, and reserve Fable for a concretely proven irreducible escalation only. | +| 2026-08-14T22:13:00Z | The hybrid delegation launcher inherits the user's Opus/high defaults and cannot express the corrected supervisor route. | Do not use that wrapper for these non-delegating topic sessions. The documented native Claude 2.1.231 CLI already accepts explicit model, effort, initial prompt, permissions, and Remote Control; use it directly and prove argv plus registry attachment. This avoids unrelated tooling scope. | +| 2026-08-14T22:18:41Z | Three legacy Codex topic rollouts were stale rather than terminal; starting Claude beside them would create ambiguous dual ownership. | Send one no-edit same-thread park instruction via the agentic suite, require exact `TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED`, verify `idle` and clean worktrees, and never resume those threads as topic controllers. Docs was already absent/offline. | +| 2026-08-14T22:25:56Z | The first reset matrix interpreted cost minimization as Sonnet 5/low topic supervision, below the owner's acceptable intelligence floor. | Park all four reconciliation-only Sonnet canaries before dispatch, preserve their journals, and restore the harness-prescribed native Claude Opus 5/high route for every topic orchestrator. | +| 2026-08-14T22:41:15Z | The reset discussion was temporarily routed through the database-RFC Codex session, and the active milestone coordinator reference was absent from its harness identity. | Transcript-verify `019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd` as the actual harness-generating coordinator, persist its JSONL and same-session resume command centrally, and steer only that existing thread. | +| 2026-08-14T22:41:15Z | The Sonnet correction draft expressed an overly rigid model-floor/capability-failure policy and risked mechanical PLAN-EVAL. | Use Opus 5 low–high for most independent adversarial and phase evaluation; open PLAN-EVAL only for an existing formal hold or demonstrated architectural complexity; reserve Fable 5 for recorded genuine architecture or exceptional complex implementation review. Preserve every harness evidence and separation invariant. | +| 2026-08-14T23:00:08Z | The reset briefs named native Claude 2.1.231 and central state still showed all four Opus replacements as `pending_attachment` after the installed CLI advanced to 2.1.233. | Prove the compatible 2.1.233 launch surface with a bounded Opus/high canary plus all four live argv/registry receipts; promote only after each topic pushed a clean reconcile-only checkpoint. Record exact volatile CLI evidence here rather than treating the patch-version literal as a routing contract. | + +## 2026-08-14T23:08:28Z — evaluator and coordinator transport reconciliation + +- Native Claude `--bg` ignored the coordinator's preallocated `--session-id` because background + dispatch owns fresh session allocation. The single launched evaluator remains authoritative as + background id `1afc9054`, session `1afc9054-cc28-48a8-9fc4-86ae2e3bb28d`; its route is proved by + job `respawnFlags` plus registry PID/cwd/bridge. No duplicate evaluator was launched. +- The interrupted standalone coordinator turn ran GPT-5.6-SOL at `max`, above the owner's authorized + effort, and left only order-1 attachment metadata dirty after pushing `aa02c21d3`. The canonical + session is now resumed through the Remote Control app-server at explicit GPT-5.6-SOL/high; `max` + is unauthorized. The exact dirty diff was reconciled to the live evaluator and all four Claude + topic supervisors were preserved unchanged. + +## 2026-08-14T23:13:20Z — evaluator serialization scope correction + +The reset dispatch incorrectly encoded `concurrency: 1` as a cluster-wide evaluator mutex. The owner +clarified that serialization is per topic orchestrator. The dispatch now allows four concurrent +evaluators total with a per-orchestrator cap of one; internals orders 1→4 and fixes orders 2→5 +remain ordered, while docs order 6 and features order 3 may run alongside them. Formal evaluator +leases no longer consume `expensiveGates`; that cluster-wide mutex remains reserved for shared +resource-heavy E2E/Aspire gates. + +No implementation drift is accepted. The plan repair changes orchestration evidence and public issue +contracts only; leaf implementation remains blocked until PLAN-EVAL approval. + +## 2026-08-15T03:46:43Z — coordinator inactivity after dispatch + +The coordinator yielded after releasing four topic lanes and did not supervise their subsequent +terminal checkpoints for more than two hours. All four topic supervisors eventually parked on work +that required coordinator authority, so useful progress stopped despite preserved healthy sessions. +This violated the milestone completion mandate. The correction is operational, not explanatory: +reconcile every lane at each checkpoint, clear coordinator-owned inputs/evaluator grants/leases +immediately, maintain per-topic concurrency, and stay active until merge/release terminality or a +genuine owner-only blocker. The current repair provisioned docs' pinned external input, launched the +two waiting IMPL-EVALs, and resumed fixes' bounded Tier-A repair without replacing any supervisor or +implementation thread. + +## 2026-08-15T04:39:17Z — post-evaluation owner holds and runtime interruption + +- **Significant / owner contract:** #1651 passed its planned evaluation before owner comment + `5300440887`, so that result cannot authorize readiness. The delegated overlap audit found a + narrower amendment boundary rather than a duplicate RFC. Preserve the RFC and the PR unchanged + until the owner selects one of the surfaced dispositions; no implicit recommendation is authority. +- **Significant / evidence baseline:** #1652's approved plan used EIS-Chat `5191de83`, but the owner + reports both examples materially improved and requires the two existing issue comments rewritten + in place. This is not an append-only status update. The docs lane must determine whether the newly + fetched immutable baseline stays within the locked evidence contract; open another PLAN-EVAL only + if it changes locked architecture or scope. +- **Operational / expensive gate:** #1654 attempt 1 produced a prefix of green gate events but no + suite verdict and left AppHost-owned stopped resources. It is classified `interrupted_no_verdict`, + never PASS/FAIL. Exact ownership evidence permitted scoped removal of three containers, their + empty Aspire network, and Garnet's anonymous volume. One retry is granted because the interruption + was transport/infrastructure, not a product verdict; no further retry is implicit. +- **Editorial evaluator loop:** #1653 cycle 1's only blocker was stale duplicated PR-body evidence; + the repair changed no code or committed content. A single fresh cycle 2 verifies the live body and + cycle-1 integrity. Further evaluator cycling requires a new substantive finding. + +## 2026-08-15T04:48:32Z — EIS-Chat evidence chronology correction + +- **Correction / evidence baseline:** no newer EIS-Chat product head exists. Current default master + and the immutable comparison input are both `5191de83`; the later-looking `834a2b36` branch delta + is harness evidence only. The two #1551 comments were written before material route changes that + are already ancestors of `5191de83`, so the stale surface is the public comment bodies rather than + the S2 pin. Recompute and replace both comments against `5191de83`; do not invent a later product + ref or open another PLAN-EVAL for this evidence/publication correction. + +## 2026-08-15T05:06:31Z — terminal runtime evidence and receipt-route gap + +- **Operational / terminal:** #1654 retry 2 reached one suite-owned terminal `suite-end` from the + unchanged approved command: raw exit 0, 89 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped. Exact postflight cleanup + proves no AppHost, container (including stopped), custom network, volume, or leak survivor. The + shared expensive-gate lease is complete rather than merely released on process exit. +- **Tooling gap / fail-closed:** `scaffold.runtime` has no allowlisted `run-gate.ts` catalog route + and `e2e:cli` has no standalone report flag. The author correctly refused to edit the catalog, + alter the fixed command, or fabricate a child receipt. This run preserves the suite-owned NDJSON + terminal record plus raw exit/head/timing in a committed receipt, exactly as its approved plan + allowed; the general durable-receipt gap still requires explicit tooling ownership before a later + milestone treats post-hoc transcription as the default. +- **Lifecycle / next queue:** #1653 merged only after cycle-2 `PASS`, direct acceptance validation, + current-head CI, close-gate, and zero review threads. Its issues and PR carry `status:shipped`. + Internals immediately advanced #1542; serialization remains per topic, not across the cluster. + +## 2026-08-15T05:16:27Z — exact-session steering and current evaluator route + +- **Transport trap / repaired before mutation:** native `claude --bg --resume ` allocated + new background session IDs instead of steering the two existing topic supervisors. The coordinator + stopped both duplicates immediately before either landed work, then used + `claude attach ` to deliver the grants directly to original supervisors `c7597d28` + and `fcf04b0f`. Their original PID/cwd/Remote Control bridges remained authoritative; no topic + worktree acquired dual ownership. +- **Route re-baseline:** current `lane-policy.md` binds Codex-authored formal IMPL-EVAL to fresh + native Fable 5/medium. #1654 therefore uses session `19f1be7b-db7d-47c0-b0f1-7cfca302d44a` and + registry bridge `session_01Qs22iAtnVYh2fLb26ABvja`, rather than copying the older Opus route from + prior reset leases. The evaluator source is the Tier-A sign-off head `f178ac663`, not the + pre-sign-off implementation head `0b2cf5e7c`. +- **No scope drift:** the completed #1551 rewrites satisfied the ordered prerequisite for S3; they + did not alter the evidence pin, equivalence contract, or approved docs boundary. Resuming the + original author thread is continuation, not a new plan cycle. + +## 2026-08-15T05:52:01Z — evaluator identity and evidence-integrity corrections + +- **Bridge identity:** #1656's evaluator artifact records the daemon/job alias + `cse_01BA2jJuyVsFhRJkVKoTMihe`, while the live bridge-status system event exposes the working + owner URL as `session_01BA2jJuyVsFhRJkVKoTMihe`. Central state records the `session_…` form and + retains the job artifact unchanged as historical evidence; no evaluator is relaunched for an + attachment-prefix discrepancy. +- **Cycle accounting:** the pre-cycle #1656 Fable attempt failed before inference with zero tokens, + no verdict, no artifact, and no repository mutation. It remains transport/model-unavailable drift + rather than PLAN-EVAL cycle 1. The subsequent Opus 5/medium PASS is the first formal cycle. +- **Docs gate value:** #1652's own cheap gates were all green while the independent evaluator found + two reproducibility defects in published claims. The correct response is one bounded same-plan + repair plus fresh Tier-A and formal re-evaluation; neither a new PLAN-EVAL nor a weakened evidence + definition is justified. +- **Host hygiene:** #1654's merge and main CI introduced no AppHost or container residue. The + coordinator preflight again observed `aspire ps --format Json` = `[]`, no Docker containers, and + no Docker volumes before leaving the global lease free for #1358's eventual browser boundary. + +## 2026-08-15T06:07:53Z — bounded review corrections and browser lease + +- **Docs / no plan drift:** #1652's F1–F5 repair changes evidence metadata, immutable references, + labels, matrix vocabulary, and truthful merge-facing state inside the approved contract. Hardened + Tier-A passed, so cycle 2 is a required fresh implementation evaluation, not another plan cycle. +- **Internals / significant but bounded:** #1656 implemented clearer output names + `publishableMembers`, `excludedNonPublishableMembers`, and `uncoveredPublishedMembers` instead of + the shorter plan names. The semantics are correct, but the locked-name movement must be explicit + in the leaf drift record before sign-off; no source rollback or scope expansion is authorized. +- **Expensive-gate lease:** #1657's `fresh-browser` command is a catalogued, CI-mirrored gate and + consumes the singleton lease even though it does not start Aspire or Docker. Empty host state was + re-proved before grant; the lease remains running until browser/runtime process cleanup and empty + Aspire/Docker postconditions are recorded. + +## 2026-08-15T06:19:11Z — corrected slice authority and closed browser ownership + +- **Internals / supervisor correction:** the S2 dispatch said only `deno.json` could change, while + the approved plan explicitly allowed `check-root-coverage_test.ts` when its live assertion needed + rebinding. The Codex author stopped without a commit and requested clarification. The preserved + supervisor corrected the brief from the approved plan, recorded the mistake, and resumed the same + thread; this is not a scope expansion or another evaluation cycle. +- **Fixes / lease closure:** #1657's browser receipt is terminal PASS and cleanup is independently + empty across actual Chromium/Playwright processes, Aspire, Docker containers, and volumes. The + expensive-gate record is complete before Tier-A begins, so no runtime ownership is carried into + review and the singleton mutex is free. +- **Features / unchanged owner contract:** surfacing the #1651 option 1/2/3 decision did not grant + authority. The PR, RFC, comments, labels, readiness, and merge state remain untouched until the + owner's explicit verdict. + +## 2026-08-15T06:24:17Z — terminal docs gate and accepted fixes contract amendment + +- **Docs / no evaluator loop:** cycle-2 `PASS` found only merge-readiness hygiene. The incorrect + digest appears in the PR body and run journals, not canonical published docs/comments; replace it + with directly reproducible byte-identity evidence alongside N2/N3, use topic Tier-A, and do not + spend a third formal evaluation cycle. +- **Fixes / significant contract amendment:** #1657's frozen four-file contract omitted the CI + trigger surfaces required to make its drift gate durable. T-3 proved a CLI catalog-template-only + diff could recreate the exact bug without running Fresh UI CI. The coordinator amended scope by + exactly `.github/workflows/fresh-ui-quality.yml`, `.github/scripts/ci-classify-changes.ts`, and + its test; weakening #1358, dropping its closing keyword, or deferring the known hole was rejected. +- **Internals / evidence denominator:** #1656 S3 must describe the applicable JSR audit as an empty + publishable-member denominator with a rescope tripwire, not claim a vacuous publishability pass. + This is final evidence truthfulness inside the approved run-artifact-only slice, not new scope. + +## 2026-08-15T06:54:51Z — shipped-artifact freshness and readiness trigger corrections + +- **Cross-leaf generated-asset blind spot:** two independent leaves changed authored inputs while + omitting the generated artifact consumed downstream. The docs prose bundle deterministically feeds + `agent-docs.generated.ts`; the Fresh UI registry template deterministically feeds + `embedded.generated.ts`. A green source-level/content gate is not proof that the shipped consumer + artifact is current. Any leaf touching `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/**` or a generator input + must select and bind `check:assets-barrel` and the narrow generator explaining its delta before + Tier-A. Queue a tooling improvement once the internals lane is free so this dependency is surfaced + automatically rather than relying on lane memory. +- **Evaluator-loop boundary:** #1652 already passed formal content evaluation cycle 2. Its current + failure is one deterministic representation of unchanged proven content, so fresh opposite-family + Tier-A plus current-head CI is sufficient; cycle 3 is forbidden. #1657 cycle 1 instead proved the + consumer-visible behavior false, so exactly one bounded same-author repair and cycle 2 are + justified after Tier-A. No further loop is implicit. +- **Ready-transition ordering:** when a native formal evaluator already supplied the binding PASS, + apply `impl-eval:skip` before converting a PR from draft to ready. Reversing that order can + dispatch a duplicate OpenHands evaluator; this occurred on #1652 and the duplicate was canceled + before mutation. +- **Lint evidence blind spot:** root `deno.json` excludes `.llm/**` from Deno lint. A mixed wrapper + batch can select new `.llm` tooling, have Deno silently drop it, and still exit 0 because other + files remain. #1656 independently linted its new files with the exact rules and found zero + defects, so this is non-blocking there; a dedicated tooling leaf must repair policy or disclose + downstream exclusion. +- **Host and transport:** Aspire and Docker remain empty; only existing topic supervisors were + attached via `claude attach`. Coordinator transport remains GPT-5.6-SOL/high through the Codex + app-server Remote Control socket, never max. Steering does not authorize replacing any native + Claude Opus 5/high topic supervisor. +- **L-2 disposition:** the `.llm/**` mixed-batch lint exclusion false-green is real and + pre-existing, but it is not part of #1656 or the contracted #1611+#1613 leaf. It is ordered after + the current internals wave-1 leaf as a dedicated issue/contract because the correct repair changes + repository- wide lint policy. No excluded-file workaround, manual receipt laundering, or fold-in + is allowed. +- **Main evidence boundary:** #1656 advanced main to `7737d8903`. Pages, code quality, and Fresh UI + quality were green at the checkpoint, while core `ci` remained in progress. Do not use the partial + workflow set as exact-main release evidence or a canary qualification; keep watching the exact + head until terminal. +- **#1658 significant contract drift:** the original contract named four paths but omitted the real + manual dispatch CLI and every directly affected regression suite; it also named the + already-correct automatic phase workflow as a mutation target. Research head `670e37bea` stopped + without widening. The corrected eight-path contract adds the producer and tests, removes the phase + workflow from the mutation envelope, and requires a new CLI integration test. This is an + authorized rescope, not opportunistic scope growth. +- **#1658 semantic lock:** formal manual evaluation is selected only by `--phase plan|impl`, is + PR-only and verdict-bound, and carries a CLI-resolved live head; non-formal work remains + tuple-free. The workflow may admit literal command candidates, but every denial reply must be + sanitized, marker-bearing, command-token-free, and exactly once so status/refusal comments cannot + recurse. Five one-second generation attempts match the automatic path; exhaustion becomes an + attributable denial rather than a paid dispatch or an unreported throw. +- **#1651 owner verdict / overlap disposition:** owner selected keep-and-narrow. The RFC is + distinct; only C6 overlaps RFC 0003/#1490. C6 retains generic CLI workspace-plan execution and + common doctor mechanics. RFC 0003/#1490 retains provider, Prisma schema/model/index, migration, + bridge, database-validation, receipt/audit/outbox, and transactional business-command semantics. + The adapter maps domain output to the common executor without reversing either ownership + direction. Preview must not influence plan construction. This substantive but bounded amendment + invalidates the pre-comment readiness claim and requires one fresh Tier-A plus one final focused + IMPL-EVAL, not a new PLAN-EVAL or an unbounded formal loop. + +## 2026-08-15T07:48:51Z — transport recovery and evidence corrections + +- **Features / transport, not scope drift:** the owner verdict was delivered to the existing + `19621a0b-…` native Opus 5/high Remote Control supervisor, which checkpointed `1bfc1cfcd` and + resumed the recorded Codex author `019ffcc5-…`. No replacement supervisor or author was created. + The amendment remains limited to the already-authorized C6/RFC-0003 boundary and provenance fix. +- **Fixes / false-positive CI expansion removed:** formal #1657 cycle 2 passed the product work but + proved the T-3 rationale false: root workspace discovery and required `check-test` already run the + drift test for both relevant surfaces, while the added Fresh UI job contained no test step. The + exact three redundant CI deltas are therefore restored to main at `a891c6520`; this is efficiency + cleanup, not withdrawal of the product verdict or a third formal cycle. +- **Fixes / browser evidence wording:** the inherited browser receipt proves the Fresh + form-navigation suite only; it never rendered the generated design gallery. #1358 consumer proof + rests on the decoded shipped barrel, source-template equality, rendered-section coverage + computation, and the symmetric root drift gate. No unleased runtime claim is retained. +- **Internals / required architectural gate:** #1658's repaired plan changes claim/spend atomicity + and workflow permissions, so one fresh PLAN-EVAL is warranted. The evaluator is independent Opus + 5/medium with active Remote Control, bound to `cea999d18`; this does not authorize implementation + until a terminal `PASS` is committed and pushed. + +## 2026-08-15T08:04:33Z — delivered-state watchers and merge-record truth + +- **Evaluator lifecycle:** #1658's evaluator delivered a committed/pushed/commented `PASS` but used + `state: blocked` with no terminal timestamp. A terminal-only watcher therefore missed it. The + coordinator reconciled the immutable verdict tuple directly, stopped the stale evaluator, and + resumed the existing topic supervisor. Future evaluator watches must accept a verified verdict + commit + exact head equality + structured comment as delivery evidence, then stop the session by + exact PID rather than waiting indefinitely or using a broad pattern. +- **#1658 carried implementation constraints:** S1-before-S4 is an API dependency, not live branch + spend protection; root `test` is the load-bearing gate for `.github`/`.llm` surfaces; refusal + vocabulary must avoid bare evaluator verdict tokens; all five reportable denial reasons need + explicit tests; and refusal posting must use `GITHUB_TOKEN` so the declared job permission is the + actual ceiling rather than an unconstrained PAT. +- **#1657 merge record:** the cleanup implementation is correct, but the live PR body remained stale + after the three CI files were restored to main. A body-only correction is required to mark the T-3 + slice and its validation superseded and to qualify `fresh-browser` as form-navigation only. This + is not product drift, a gate rerun, or a formal evaluator cycle. +- **#1651 evidence provenance closed:** the binding cached check receipt has empty stdout and must + not inherit cycle-1's 1,033-file/9-batch figures. The amended body now names the correct receipts, + content/evidence heads, and cached-hit semantics; fresh review must verify those live claims. + +## 2026-08-15T08:31:20Z — shipped boundaries and lifecycle normalization + +- **#1651 owner overlap gate closed:** keep-and-narrow is now merge truth, not a pending option. The + final evaluator found no substantive defect after independently checking RFC 0003's six owned + duties, the bidirectional adapter prohibitions, exact evidence sufficiency, and live #1490/#1363 + parentage. Two summary-table editorial omissions do not reopen the formal loop because normative + host/process and plan-vs-transaction ownership survives elsewhere in the RFC. +- **#1657 false-positive cleanup closed:** removing the redundant Fresh UI workflow/classifier + expansion did not withdraw the product proof. The final body recheck confirmed the merge-facing + record distinguishes static gallery proof from the form-navigation browser receipt; exact-head CI + then exercised root `check-test`, while desktop/scaffold/runtime lanes skipped by classification. +- **Lifecycle drift corrected:** merged #1643 and closed #1243 retained stale + `status:ready-merge`/`status:triage` labels. They were normalized to exactly `status:shipped` + after verifying the merge/close tuple and 3/3 issue boxes. This was bookkeeping repair, not + product or acceptance mutation. +- **Supervisor transport preserved:** post-merge grants were delivered by `claude attach` to the + existing feature/fix background IDs. No `--resume` duplicate, replacement bridge, or second topic + owner was created. + +## 2026-08-15T08:45:30Z — post-freeze docs intake and two public-contract corrections + +- **Docs #1659 is owner-directed post-freeze work:** the frozen inventory remains the audited + 60-issue milestone set, so central state records #1659 as `ownerDirectedIssueNumbers` rather than + silently rewriting intake/DAG ownership. It still uses the existing docs supervisor and original + Codex author and remains subject to the normal Tier-A/readiness/merge gates. +- **#1448 scope drift is real, not opportunistic expansion:** four acceptance requirements were + unreachable in the original three-file envelope. The exact five-file amendment stays wholly inside + `packages/ai/**`; it adds no export entry and no consumer work. Public status is synchronous and + I/O-free, uses `McpConnectionState`, retains last error per server, and close cancellation is an + additive options-bag contract. `pool.stop()` must settle per server so one failed close cannot + strand its peers. +- **#1293 filed premise is stale:** `onConnectionError` exists on the published options type and in + the example but is not called. Compatibility wins: wire the shipped hook with explicit semantics, + test it, and export the intended adapter surface; do not remove a public option without owner + authority. The stale reference page and #1112 example are reported to docs after the product leaf, + not folded across lane ownership. +- **Main CI is evidence, not release qualification:** run `31874580034` proves the merged + #1657/#1651 head is healthy and file classification skips unrelated jobs correctly. It does not + replace the final exact-main release gates/canary cadence, which remain pending after all + committed work ships. + +## 2026-08-15T09:08:30Z — worktree exclusivity and delivered-verdict recovery + +- **Docs supervisor contention:** the supervisor ran mutating docs generators/gates while the Codex + author still owned the same worktree, then used a bare `git stash drop` after a conflicted pop. + That removed another lane's shared-repository stash rather than the probe stash. The printed + object id allowed exact recovery with `git stash store`: object + `7eb4ed16d6944c1d1c904895bcb76b4361ad8a57`, original message and 20+/25− `deno.lock` delta are + intact. Final Tier-A evidence was regenerated under zero-author-process, clean local=remote + exclusive ownership. Rule: never run mutating verification in a live author worktree; never use + stash pop/apply/drop without an explicit ref re-read immediately before the operation. +- **#1293 terminal marker false negative:** Fable evaluator `75d9028e` committed and pushed a full + `PASS` at `7780ba49e` and displayed its terminal response, but `state.json` remained `working` + with no `firstTerminalAt`. A terminal-marker-only watcher therefore waited indefinitely. The + coordinator verified session output, immutable verdict artifact, local/remote equality, and exact + evaluator identity, then woke the existing features supervisor through `claude attach`. Delivery + evidence is the verified tuple, not the stale lifecycle marker; no duplicate evaluator is allowed. +- **#1661 second scope correction:** the first amendment omitted the two published composition + wrappers and assumed a required `readResource` port member would be safe. The topic supervisor + found the out-of-scope Fresh fake implementor before CI. Amendment 2 makes the broad port member + optional while requiring real abort behavior on the base and both published wrappers; the Fresh + package check is now a mandatory cross-package compatibility proof. + +## 2026-08-15T09:28:54Z — docs census false positive and merge-authority correction + +- **Stale census contract:** #1660 readiness CI failed because the docs snippet census test pinned + unrelated whole-corpus totals. New frontend/backend examples legitimately raised those values + while every safety property remained healthy. The repair asserts only the named contract: + TypeScript aliases exist and sum to `tsLike`; Tier-1/outside-floor and checked/exempt partitions + balance; floors/caps remain enforced; malformed stays zero. This turns future content growth from + noise into a skip-safe gate without weakening malformed or Tier-1 protection. +- **Tier-A durability gap:** the first repair verification was locally substantive but not durable; + coordinator inspection caught that the prior posted review still named `e35824d41`. The docs + supervisor posted a fresh exact-head review at `615786c1a` before merge. Local green output alone + does not discharge the harness review gate. +- **Merge authority:** the docs supervisor had stated it would merge after CI. The coordinator + corrected that role in-place: topic supervisors review, queue, and report; the coordinator alone + performs exact-head merge/lifecycle normalization. #1660 was merged only after the coordinator + independently reran review-thread and current-head PR gates. + +## 2026-08-15T09:41:25Z — lifetime defect and evaluator route recovery + +- **#1661 cancellation lifetime false green:** Tier-A verified that a signal was forwarded but did + not execute the lifetime contract. `registerMcpTools` captured its registration options inside + every registered call handler, while the README supplied `AbortSignal.timeout(1_500)` as a + startup bound and the test asserted the resulting post-timeout rejection. The formal evaluator's + before/after-deadline reproduction exposed the defect. New standing rule: cancellation plumbing + is not evidence of correct signal scope; lifetime contracts require a time-separated behavioral + test, and a test encoding the defect cannot make the gate green. +- **#1658 Fable availability failure:** probe `e58c5f01` failed before inference with null tokens, + no output artifact, and no repository mutation. It consumes zero formal cycles. The coordinator + explicitly amended the route to the internals lane's established native Opus 5/medium Remote + Control fallback, rather than silently substituting or relaunching Fable. Replacement identity + was recorded before evaluator mutation. +- **Autonomy interpretation:** a terminal `FAIL_FIX` inside an already-authorized surface does not + require another one-word coordinator grant. The fixes supervisor's pause was corrected using the + owner's standing full-autonomy mandate; only a genuine rescope or owner-only decision should stop + the bounded repair lifecycle. +- **Evaluator scope is lane-local:** the historical central singleton language was too broad for the + owner's clarified queue rule. One evaluator per topic remains binding, but a fixes evaluator may + run while an internals evaluator is active. The coordinator granted #1661 cycle 2 without pausing + #1658 and recorded both identities separately; no expensive runtime mutex was involved. + +## 2026-08-15T10:20:00Z — post-evaluation CI authority and runtime-gate foresight + +- **#1661 cross-package CI is a real correction, not flaky noise:** the focused AI evaluation passed + its contracted behavior, but the repository suite owns an additional packaging invariant in + `packages/cli`: optional TanStack MCP specifiers must be computed so generated projects, rather + than the static JSR graph, own resolution. A literal dynamic import violates that invariant. The + repair restores the computed form and expands focused evidence to the package that caught it; it + does not weaken or delete the assertion. +- **A formal PASS does not immunize later product mutation:** the #1661 repair changes source after + cycle 2, so readiness is withdrawn until a fresh Tier-A and a proportionate fresh evaluator attest + the repaired head. This is a new bounded cycle caused by new CI evidence, not an endless loop. +- **#1662 split-close is intentional:** the shipped product surface can merge after exact-head CI, + while #1293 stays open. Neither the issue's concrete-class wording nor its docs-owned #1112 + criterion is silently rewritten or falsely checked. +- **The next internals leaf declares an expensive gate before implementation:** `package-gate-honesty` + may plan `scaffold.runtime`, but cannot execute Aspire/Docker/Postgres without the coordinator's + cluster-wide mutex. The mutex is currently free; a future grant will be tied to a reviewed slice, + pre-gate head, and mandatory cleanup proof. + +## 2026-08-15T10:39:55Z — canonical model token and repair-delta authority + +- **Claude model aliases are not interchangeable:** the #1663 supervisor launched `fable-5` from + `/tmp` without Remote Control; it failed before inference with no artifact or mutation. It then + started an unauthorized Opus fallback, which the coordinator stopped before mutation. The known + working canonical token is `claude-fable-5`; the corrected exact-worktree Remote Control launch + is the sole evaluation cycle. Future supervisors must copy canonical tokens from a proven launch, + not abbreviate them. +- **A full product re-evaluation is not required for a bounded post-PASS repair:** #1661 cycle 2 + remains authoritative for the ten-file product contract. The one-file computed-import restoration + gets a fresh, proportionate formal evaluation over its actual CLI/publish blast radius plus the + previously failing root suite, avoiding both under-review and wasteful re-audit. +- **Split-close shipment must be represented as a split:** #1662 is merged, but #1293 remains open. + Central state records boxes 2/3 complete and boxes 1/4 open instead of collapsing the issue into + the PR's shipped state. + +- **Config exclusion is not wrapper selection:** #1663 proved root `exclude` cannot protect a Deno + command when the structured wrapper has already enumerated and passed files explicitly. For an + intentionally invalid nested config, the tool family needs one explicit, tested fixture-boundary + mechanism shared by fmt and lint; configuration prose alone is not evidence. The contract now + requires non-empty selection and real-source negative controls so the repair cannot become a + broad fixture false green. +- **Exact-head reruns inspect the full PR:** #1661's evaluator-only final commit caused another + repo-wide CI run because the PR still contains product changes. The classifier already maps + `.llm/runs/**` to no capabilities when that is the whole diff; it correctly did not pretend the + full PR was artifact-only. Redundant elapsed time is not sufficient reason to weaken exact-head + attestation. +- **Release gates are not static catalog gates:** #1664's plan treated the absent + `scaffold.runtime` catalog entry as missing plumbing. The absence is deliberate: the harness + owns it as a suite-run release-gate class. Its exact-head output and central cleanup lease are the + evidence; only `fresh-browser` receives a normal run-gate receipt. + +- **A narrow marker cannot license parent-family suppression:** #1663's first repaired-plan draft + made a marker inside `doctor/broken` suppress `doctor/healthy` as well. The arithmetic exposed the + false green: 115 to 110 equals one broken plus four healthy TS files. The accepted target is 114, + with healthy files named as selected. Nested valid configs are a batching concern, not permission + to remove unmarked files from a quality gate. +- **An unpushed local artifact commit is recoverable evidence, not an immutable verdict:** the + rejected #1663 plan existed only in local commit `71e803807`; product/config paths were untouched + and the remote PR head never moved. The coordinator preserved history, stopped the exact writer, + and resumed the same author thread with a corrective commit rather than force-pushing or replacing + the author. +- **Plan scenarios must prove effects, not method calls:** #1664's accepted repair requires the + invalidation gate to observe a second request and refreshed server value; spying on + `invalidateQueries` would pass against the existing defect. Hydration similarly compares old and + fresh timestamps under one controlled clock with different query-function counts. + +- **A legitimate finding must be fixed, not classified away:** once #1663 stopped hiding the healthy + fixture family, fmt exposed exactly one genuinely unformatted file. The correct rescope is one + formatting-only path with semantic equivalence proof; neither a broader marker nor a special + config flag is acceptable. Coverage stays 114 selected and all healthy files remain visible. +- **An identity helper is not automatically an API improvement:** #1664's proposed + `bridgeInvalidation(queryKey)` overload added no policy beyond `{ queryKey }`, left the unsafe + string form intact, and would have coupled new CLI output to SDK 0.0.7. Direct emission from the + already-published typed `clientKey()` surface is both narrower and compatible with 0.0.6-pinned + consumer apps. +- **Existing verbs need migration contracts when their owned output expands:** adding client-module + regeneration to `service generate` changes what a familiar Aspire-oriented command overwrites. + The plan must state owned paths and whether dry-run/force cover both halves before implementation; + naming deterministic output without that compatibility answer is incomplete. +- **Plan-only PRs now prove the skip classifier live:** #1663, #1664, and #1665 run-artifact-only + heads skipped check-test, quality, desktop, scaffold runtime/static, dependency, surface, and + close-gate work. This is the intended native skip case and is distinct from an evaluator-only + final commit on a PR whose complete diff still contains product code. +- **A promised span event needs a span-time seam:** #1665's first cardinality design normalizes and + mutates its budget before span creation while preserving a string-only helper signature, yet + promises a one-time event carrying the first overflow id. Tier-A must require an explicit + metadata/event handoff or an equivalent implementable design; prose cannot bridge ordering. +- **Optimized tool sources can have generated publish consumers:** #1663's lint wrapper is also a + `consumer-tools.json` asset embedded in `@netscript/cli`. Changing the source without regenerating + `agent-tools.generated.ts` would make asset freshness red and ship stale installed tooling. The + generated barrel is therefore an exact, regeneration-only thirteenth path, not an unrelated + expansion; the publish/hash behavior delta and freshness gate are binding evidence. +- **A task skip and a formatter boundary serve different purposes:** the task-level doctor-family + exclusion would keep healthy fixtures invisible after the child-only marker repair and must go. + The root formatter exclusion remains necessary to prevent root style from rewriting a fixture + that is intentionally judged under its nearest local/default formatting boundary. +- **Baseline red must stay named red:** #1664 S1 did not touch the two `QueryClient` private-type-ref + diagnostics, and they reproduce before the slice. The leaf records those exact failures as + pre-existing supplemental evidence; it neither calls the doc-lint invocation green nor silently + widens the feature slice to fix them. +- **Dynamic runtime identity needs a normalized documentation contract:** #1665 cannot quote a + per-install `import.meta.url` byte-for-byte as a fixed machine string. The accepted boundary uses + one `` token in the published single-line template, then normalizes only + the real URL segment in the focused provider test and compares every stable byte, including the + SDK prefix. This repairs the known page in place without inventing perpetual stale prose. +- **Evaluator census labels must match their own evidence:** #1665's Tier-A prose called the + namespace census twelve call sites while its table and the fresh evaluator correctly found eleven + calls plus the function definition. The topic artifact was corrected before implementation; the + mechanism, paths, and verdict were unchanged. +- **Two failed plan cycles create an owner boundary even after a sound repair:** #1663's second + evaluator exposed a real generated publish consumer and the repaired plan now passes fresh + Tier-A. The coordinator cannot silently invent cycle three; one exceptional final evaluator is an + explicit owner decision, while product mutation remains prohibited and independent lanes proceed. +- **Component atomicity does not compose through a mutating caller:** #1664's generator validated + all contracts before its own writes, but `addService` had already mutated appsettings, workspace, + and Aspire helpers. A true add-path zero-write test and shared preflight were required; a green + generator-only atomicity test could not prove the caller contract. +- **A proven product correction can make an old test the false positive:** after #1664 correctly + removed `bridgeInvalidation`, the full CLI suite—not the focused service suites—found a template + test still demanding that forbidden import. The assertion was repaired in the same slice to + prove exact import-set equality, absence, and literal order. A later slice label cannot justify + knowingly carrying a red suite or a stale already-disproven contract. +- **A gate command is not evidence that its planned scenario exists:** #1664 reached four cheap + PASS receipts and requested the runtime lease, but the accepted pre-lease contract required a + concrete second-service `payments` flow, cross-resource key isolation, idempotent regeneration, + and a live Rename with exactly one settled refetch. The branch only added a gate to the suite; + none of those assertions existed. Lease review must inspect scenario presence, not infer it from + suite membership or a future command name. +- **Structured formatter correctness can depend on batching as well as config:** the CLI format + proof needs an absolute neutral same-style config and a single 1000-file batch. The same config + with default batching produces non-zero `failedBatches` and zero findings. That result is a + fail-closed refusal, never a formatting pass; the original failed invocation remains append-only + evidence rather than being erased by the corrected proof. +- **Draft check sets are lifecycle placeholders, not product validation:** #1665 displayed two + successes and nineteen skipped checks while draft. The skip labels explain only intentionally + omitted scaffold/runtime families; draft state suppressed the required core jobs. Readiness must + be judged after verified acceptance reconciliation, lifecycle relabel, and a `ready_for_review` + event starts exact-head core CI. A zero-failure draft check set is never described as green. +- **Plan-before-code ordering needs an immutable remote boundary:** #1664's F2 recovery first + committed and explicitly pushed `4be440020` containing the bounded files, four gate scenarios, + pure-test contract, and superseded-receipt rules. Product edits began only afterward. A dirty + local plan next to product code would not prove the recovery was constrained before execution. +- **Generated documentation freshness follows source dependency, not human file category:** #1665 + changed an authorized `docs/site` page whose rendered counterpart is part of the checked-in agent + corpus. Docs accuracy passing does not imply corpus freshness; the canonical generator and its + exact two-asset diff are a required readiness consequence of that source edit. +- **A `+1` network assertion needs a proven quiet baseline:** a fixed delay before counting requests + lets a late initial request impersonate the expected refetch. The proof must first establish that + all observed initial requests completed and the count stayed stable across a confirmation window, + and a negative unit case must demonstrate rejection of the late-arrival sequence. +- **CDP continuation is stage-specific:** a request paused by Fetch at `requestStage: Response` must + resume with `Fetch.continueResponse`. Using `Fetch.continueRequest` can turn the first leased run + into an apparent infrastructure hang even though the defect is entirely in the unexecuted proof. +- **Generated dependencies can form a chain:** refreshing the canonical prose assets is insufficient + when a second checked-in artifact embeds them. `check:agent-docs-prose` may pass while + `check:assets-barrel` correctly fails; readiness must traverse corpus source → prose asset → CLI + embedded barrel rather than stopping at the first fresh node. +- **Hydrated data can make zero network requests:** a proof that merely waits for an observed list + request hangs when `initialData` remains fresh, while accepting stable zero lets a late request + impersonate mutation `+1`. Triggering Refresh establishes a deterministic completed baseline + before the mutation count begins. +- **Generated-asset closure must reuse prior dependency evidence:** shipped #1652 already proved the + exact Query Bridge cascade through prose assets, the CLI embedded barrel, and the MCP publish + asset. #1665 repeated two readiness failures because coordination stopped at each newly failing + gate instead of consulting that persisted closure. A docs-source change now requires a historical + cascade lookup plus exhaustive checked-in-mirror proof before readiness, not incremental CI + discovery one artifact at a time. +- **A real generated project can falsify a fully green fixture model:** #1664's cheap probe tests + shared one invented list input across users and payments and assumed equal key tails. The runtime + scaffold proved the services expose different real input contracts and that the users contract + also has a canonical DB-Zod generation predecessor. Gate plans must derive executable inputs and + prerequisites from generated artifacts, and Tier-A must reject fixture-only agreement when a + real-project gate is the stated proof. +- **A generated app cannot inherit the harness package's import map by assumption:** #1664's first + F3 draft imported the parent orchestration probe to reuse input derivation. Cheap replay against + the preserved generated project showed that this also imports monorepo-only dependencies the app + cannot resolve. Shared executable proof primitives used inside generated consumers must be + dependency-free (or live in an app-resolvable package), and that boundary must be exercised before + the expensive scaffold gate. The author pushed `c4a900adc` to name the isolated internal module + before creating it. +- **An unchanged diagnostic can still be made red by shared-batch type pollution:** #1664 F3's + first exact-head root-check receipt failed an old explicit `number` timer assignment only after + the proof code changed from `@std/path` to `node:path`. Node imports can introduce a different + timer return type into a Deno check batch; file ownership alone cannot establish non-causality. + Preserve the original failed receipt, prove the import/batch effect with an isolated before/after, + and require amendment-before-repair plus a distinct replacement receipt if the leaf caused it. +- **Lease records must follow terminal truth, not session attachment metadata:** #1663 cycle 2 had + already committed `FAIL_PLAN`, but central `evaluatorLeases` still said `active`. That stale bit + could falsely consume the lane evaluator limit or invite an unsafe resume. The record is now + terminal with the exact verdict commit/comment and the exceptional-third-cycle owner boundary. +- **Runtime retry authority belongs to the evidence head:** #1664's second runtime attempt is leased + at artifact head `8940e9266`, not merely product head `193e665ba`, so the preserved first FAIL, + replacement receipts, and Tier-A provenance are immutable inputs to the gate. The runtime probe + executes product content, but coordinator authorization binds the complete reviewed evidence tree. +- **Fail-closed gate semantics need durable negative tests:** #1666's tenth path is justified because + one-off terminal probes cannot fail a future CI run. Empty/malformed reasons, unknown coverage + modes, invented symbols, and omitted symbols must remain persistent assertions even though that + adds one test-only file to the originally frozen surface. +- **A corrected example must close its duplicate prose claims:** #1461's exact stale-loader snippet + lives in `services-sdk/sdk.md`, but the live-dashboard tutorial separately says a pure + `getCachedEntry` read refreshes stale data in the background. Regenerating the same four mirrors + while knowingly leaving that second false claim would preserve user-facing drift. The exact + tutorial source is a justified plan amendment, not a later cleanup. +- **Idempotency must hold inputs constant:** #1664's S5 gate ran `service generate` once before + installing plugins and again after plugin configuration had changed the Aspire model. Three helper + rewrites on the latter invocation are reconciliation, not evidence of non-idempotency. A valid + assertion permits that convergence run and requires zero writes only on the immediately following + identical invocation. Calling temporally separated, different-input runs “first” and “second” + creates an expensive false-positive gate. +- **Search breadth can invert CI truth:** #1666 research grepped only root tasks and workflow text + for the checker name, then concluded the drift check was unwired. The actual fail-closed path is + `ci.yml` docs-accuracy gate → catalog task → accuracy script → child drift checker. The missing + contract is discoverable naming/runbook visibility, not enforcement. Wiring audits must follow the + executable call graph before claiming absence. +- **Issue-wide example sweeps belong before scope freeze:** one known wrong Contracts import led the + #1666 plan to mark acceptance row 1 otherwise satisfied, but an exhaustive shipped-source sweep + found three more identical defects. When acceptance is phrased for a package family, planning must + enumerate the whole publish set, not stop at the issue's cited exemplar. +- **A corrected line must repair the surrounding teaching contract:** #1461's second authorized page + has one explicitly false `getCachedEntry` clause at line 100, but five earlier SWR statements make + the same demonstrated loader story misleading without being individually false. A docs plan must + give every nearby mechanism claim an explicit retain/correct disposition and explain the composed + narrative; fixing the quoted sentence alone is not sufficient acceptance. +- **Lease readiness is an immutable evidence state, not an intent:** #1664 attempt 3 was granted only + after all F4 receipts, the author report, and independent Tier-A were committed and pushed at + `6f813b0db`. No preflight artifact may be appended between this grant and execution. This makes the + exact authorized tree reproducible and prevents the attempt-2 grant/run head mismatch. +- **One baseline witness cannot classify a multi-file gate red:** #1664 attempt 3 found twelve + unformatted generated paths. Proving one unchanged Aspire helper fails at the pre-implementation + template does not classify leaf-owned users/payments client and payments service/contract outputs. + Attribution must enumerate every failing path against both source ownership and baseline before a + coordinator can authorize a repair or call the gate pre-existing. +- **Transport interruption before a verdict does not consume an evaluator cycle:** #1666 cycle 2 + finished re-derivation but received an interruption before writing an artifact. Resuming the same + evaluator history under a new Remote Control attachment preserves independence and cycle identity; + launching a new evaluator or counting a third cycle would misstate what happened. +- **A line-count gate must improve structure, not erase explanation:** #1669 briefly suppressed F-1 + by deleting useful private-method JSDoc and blank-line structure. The accepted correction restores + those explanations and removes real duplicated cache-entry lookup/span logic instead. Threshold + compliance is evidence only when the code becomes simpler to own, not when prose is sacrificed to + make `wc` smaller. +- **A named CI edge can be discoverability without duplicate enforcement:** #1666 already failed + closed through the aggregate docs-accuracy chain. Its S2 task and Pages label make that existing + policy independently runnable and visible; they must not cause the checker to execute twice in one + aggregate path or be described as enforcement that did not previously exist. +- **A named stale-only option needs a fresh-entry negative control:** #1669's docs regression found + that `preferFreshOnStale` was evaluated before the fresh-hit return, so the option forced network + work even for a fresh non-expired entry. Stale concurrency tests alone could not expose that + contract inversion. Policy-option acceptance must include the unaffected state as a zero-effect + control while preserving independent expired-entry precedence. +- **An allowlist should be checked against the pinned executable, not memory:** #1664's formatter + names 26 dialect tokens, including uncommon `xml`, `sql`, `vto`, and `njk`. A complete probe + against the pinned Deno accepted all 26 and rejected a non-member. That executable result closes + the contract question more reliably than assuming the help surface from recollection. +- **A retry lease must bind the reviewed evidence tree, not merely repaired source:** #1664 attempt + 4 is authorized only at evidence `1263f655b`, whose parent content is `fda78ee43` and whose four + binding receipts plus final Tier-A are already pushed. The clean-host preflight precedes the grant, + so any subsequent head movement invalidates the lease before runtime execution. +- **Nonzero is not proof of the named refusal:** #1666's committed policy tests initially asserted + only exit 1. A missing fixture could produce that exit after the reason/mode branch was removed, + and OMITS could preserve it after INVENTS was removed. Durable negative tests must assert the + specific cause and mutation-prove that removing only that branch makes the named test red. +- **A cleanup exception cannot stand in for the behavior verdict:** #1664's live refetch probe reached + a browser child that had already terminated, then failed while sending SIGTERM. The gate stays red, + but attribution must distinguish successful child completion, early failure, and idempotent cleanup + before treating this as evidence for or against the settled-refetch contract. +- **`aspire ps []` is not a complete host-cleanliness proof:** attempt 4 left four stopped + `aspire-managed nuget search` utility children whose AppHost/resource inventory was empty. The + coordinator must pair Aspire and Docker state with an explicit process/listener audit, remove only + exact attributable PIDs, then re-audit while preserving foreign `aspire mcp start` helpers. +- **A failed receipt can remain truthful beside its replacement:** #1666's first root-test receipt at + the repaired head failed because a temporary mutation archive itself contained forbidden command + strings. Removing the scratch input and writing a distinct `test-attempt2` PASS preserves both the + environmental failure and the clean-tree verdict; overwriting the first receipt would launder the + trail. +- **Termination idempotence must still fail precisely:** #1664 F6 does not permit a broad catch around + child teardown. The plan tolerates only Deno's exact already-terminated `TypeError`, still awaits + status and stderr drain, and requires unrelated kill and drain failures to propagate. +- **Brief templating must replace short and full immutable SHAs:** #1666's cycle-2 brief correctly + bound content `423867017` and evidence `010da98a2` in its table and repair section, but two copied + cycle-1 sentences still named short `47ca22abe` for receipt sufficiency because only the full SHA + was replaced. The evaluator independently used the repaired head throughout, so verdict impact is + none; future brief assembly must assert there is no contradictory stale source-head token before + dispatch. +- **A passing evaluator does not excuse a later generated-freshness red:** #1666's evaluator + correctly judged the declared source/evidence head, but ready CI then proved that the changed Fresh + UI reference page had not propagated into the tracked agent-docs corpus. Readiness was revoked; + generated closure must be verified and explicitly included before the next content head, followed + by fresh Tier-A and delta IMPL-EVAL. +- **Close-gate races and product reds require different recovery:** #1666's mirror saw the old label + and safely mutated nothing, so that same workflow may be rerun after readiness is restored. The + simultaneous corpus-freshness red is owned and cannot be retried away. Keep both classifications + explicit rather than treating an entire CI run as one failure class. +- **Ignored runtime debris can still poison repo-wide scanners:** #1664's root test traversed a + root-owned Postgres data directory under an ignored e2e temp tree and raised `PermissionDenied`. + Preserve the red receipt, recoverably quarantine only the proven unowned tree after Docker/process + audits, and use a distinct unchanged-head receipt for the environmental retry. +- **Apply readiness labels before the ready event and prove live visibility:** #1669 applied both + `status:ready-merge` and the attributed `impl-eval:skip` while still draft, fetched them back from + GitHub, and passed a live acceptance-mirror dry-run before `ready_for_review`. This ordering avoids + the label race observed on #1666 and keeps automatic phase evaluation from duplicating a completed + native evaluator. +- **Lifecycle probes may briefly create their own helper:** the #1664 attempt-5 preflight observed + `aspire ps []`, then caught the query's transient `aspire-managed nuget search` child in the same + instant. Lease decisions require a separate post-query process audit; that audit was empty. Do not + kill a healthy transient helper or mistake the command's own child for pre-existing runtime debt. +- **An open umbrella can contain a satisfied prerequisite:** #1348 explicitly remains open until its + implementation children ship, while its body simultaneously ratifies RFC 0001 Stage 0 and names + #1350 as the first child. Treating every open prerequisite node as blocked would deadlock the very + implementation sequence it defines; inspect the acceptance semantics, preserve the umbrella, and + release #1350 without falsely closing #1348. +- **Non-blocking does not mean forgotten:** #1669's evaluator found cross-page loader-shape + inconsistency and a warm-stale persistence-failure caveat without finding a false revalidation + claim or acceptance failure. Preserve PASS, avoid post-evaluation scope creep, and file one + explicitly non-blocking follow-up with both exact contracts rather than silently losing the debt. +- **A generated output can change only in provenance and still be a publish delta:** #1666's MCP + bounded prose selection excludes Fresh UI, so its prose bytes stay fixed, but the canonical publish + asset advances the corpus `sourceCommit`. The path is still an owned generated/published change and + belongs in scope, idempotence proof, JSR reasoning, and delta evaluation. +- **A red generator is not automatically part of the current cascade:** isolated #1666 controls + proved `gen:mcp-export-corpus` produces the same rewritten bytes at base and leaf while its check is + already red at base. Preserve and report that red; do not regenerate it merely because another MCP + generated asset legitimately changes. +- **Fixing cleanup can reveal the first real behavior verdict:** #1664 attempt 4 ended in teardown + before the refetch probe could report. F6 removed only that mask; attempt 5 then honestly failed on + DevTools target discovery. Treat this as new measured causality, not as failure of the teardown fix + or permission to retry unchanged. +- **Terminal leaf and evaluator-lease state must agree:** #1669's leaf, evaluator artifact, verdict + comment, CI, merge, and issue lifecycle were all terminal while its separate evaluator-lease entry + remained `active`. Reconcile the lease from those independent facts and distinguish a native Claude + background spare from a live evaluator before considering process cleanup. +- **Searching an allowlist is not searching the host:** #1664's probe found no Linux path in its six + candidates and fell through to Windows Chrome, but two managed Linux Chromium 151 binaries existed + and executed. Selection must validate runnability, provide a strict portable override, and retain + early status/stderr; an allowlist miss cannot be promoted into an environment-capability claim. +- **Supervisor prose can become scanner input:** #1666's ignored unscoped hook transcript captured a + supervisor explanation containing a prohibited command literal, so the repository scanner correctly + failed unchanged generated content. Preserve the red, quarantine the exact transcript recoverably + without weakening the scanner, hash before/after, and allow only one unchanged-head retry. +- **A checked umbrella item may conflict with its normative ownership header:** the first #1350 brief + copied a checked metadata sentence from #1348 but missed that the accepted amendment, target owner + comment, and live #1466 assign metadata vocabulary elsewhere. Formal planning must reconcile all live + authority surfaces before converting a checkbox into leaf ownership. + +- **A passed delta evaluator cannot resolve a later generated merge conflict by choosing a side:** + #1666 and main both legitimately advanced the same four publication outputs from different source + contributions. Preserve the PASS, integrate main, rerun the canonical cascade to include both + contributions, prove convergence, and re-evaluate only the integration delta. +- **Process/container cleanliness is not filesystem cleanliness:** #1664 attempt 5 left a foreign- + owned unreadable Postgres directory after its process and container audit passed. Every database- + starting run now needs an unreadable/foreign-owned residue sweep; quarantine run-owned residue + recoverably and preserve the scanner red rather than weakening traversal. +- **Compile suppression is transitional evidence, not a green acceptance proof:** #1671 S1 used two + `@ts-expect-error` markers to pin the S2 defect after recording the base RED. S2 must remove them + and replace them with positive exact-union and code-specific-data assertions before claiming the + error channel is preserved. + +- **A clean runtime preflight includes readable stale workspaces too:** unreadable residue is the + scanner hazard, but readable plugin-smoke trees still make lease ownership ambiguous. Move each + exact run-owned tree to recoverable quarantine before a new attempt; do not delete or use broad + cleanup. +- **A retry receipt can validate environmental causality without erasing the red:** #1664's two test + receipts have the same 4,256 total results; only the scanner failure flipped, from 4236/1/19 to + 4237/0/19 after quarantine. Preserve both, exclude the red only in the declared passing evidence + set, and require exact-head equality without a mismatch waiver. +- **A new evaluator must not stack on a stale terminal lease:** before registering #1666's + integration-delta evaluator, reconcile the earlier evaluator against its pushed artifact and live + verdict comment. Lane-local serialization is measured from live work plus terminal evidence, not + from an unreconciled `active` string in the control plane. +- **A broad quality PASS cannot overrule a narrower changed-source red:** #1666's core `quality` job + passed while the dedicated scanner correctly found an explicit `any` and unsafe cast in the leaf's + changed checker. Treat the narrower evidence as owned and blocking, revoke readiness, and repair the + code rather than rerunning or weakening the scanner. +- **Acceptance mirroring may precede a later independent CI red:** #1666's close-gate truthfully + checked all five #1296 boxes before the separate code-quality workflow failed. Preserve those + evidence-backed boxes and the open issue, return the PR to draft, and let `Closes #1296` close the + issue only after a fully green repaired head merges. +- **Valid browser selection does not prove browser behavior completion:** #1664 attempt 6 proved the + strict managed Chrome override and still hung until the suite's 900-second child boundary with no + refetch evidence. Preserve the red as an unattributed browser-probe timeout; do not regress to the + superseded target-discovery diagnosis or claim an application-refetch failure without evidence. +- **A green suite leak report does not replace the independent host audit:** Aspire and Docker were + already green when #1664's separate scan found three stopped run-owned helpers plus unreadable + database residue. Exact cleanup and recoverable quarantine were required before releasing the + runtime lease. +- **A scanner's green verdict is invalid when its mode omits the repaired path:** #1666 Tier-A first + saw `ok:true` in repository mode while the payload listed only package/plugin roots. Reading mode + and selected paths exposed the false green; only the corrected non-empty `changed-files` selection + over both `.llm/tools` files counts as repair evidence. +- **Pinned baseline-red counts still require base/head identity attribution:** #1671 correctly kept + raw doc-lint red, then proved its counts changed from Contracts 9→11 and SDK 3→13. A known-red gate + is not permission to absorb new leaf-owned findings; stop the matrix, preserve later gates as + NOT_RUN, and repair only after a bounded amendment and fresh review. +- **Supervisor verification must not write into an author-owned leaf:** the #1664 features Tier-A + audit regenerated the leaf leak report after the author commit. Its host result remains valid in + central state, but the bytes are supervisor-caused contamination and must be restored from the + author head before F8; future supervisor audits use supervisor-owned paths. +- **A thread-local quota probe cannot establish account scope:** both affected leaves used one fresh + detached Codex session after preserving the original sender. Threads `01a00766-…` and + `01a00767-…` failed before inference with `usageLimitExceeded`, `hasCredits:false`, and zero + balance, proving the boundary is account-wide until `2026-08-20 05:31`. Stop retries once that + evidence exists; distinguish executable canonical plan-artifact chores from product implementation + that truly has no in-plan fallback. +- **Quota fallback still preserves generator/evaluator separation:** #1664's provenance restoration + uses a fresh Claude Opus 5/medium `chore_code` generator and #1671's run-artifact-only amendment + uses a fresh Claude Sonnet 5/high `documentation_review` generator. Neither supervisor authors. + Each plan is then judged by a fresh Minimax M3/high PLAN-EVAL through the documented native-quota + fallback; no lane self-certifies and no outside-plan product implementation is inferred. +- **Readiness re-entry repeats all live preflights after any repair:** cycle-5 PASS did not inherit + the earlier readiness snapshot. #1666 refreshed the final body, review threads, acceptance mirror, + close-gate, status ordering, and exact-head CI at `92988da30`; the earlier broad green cannot stand + in for the new changed-source quality run. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/leaf-contracts.json b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/leaf-contracts.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..561c46602e --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/leaf-contracts.json @@ -0,0 +1,1497 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "capturedAt": "2026-08-13T22:42:00.000Z", + "baselineMainSha": "01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed", + "contracts": [ + { + "key": "rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board", + "issues": [ + 1348 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 0, + "executionKind": "coordinator-checkpoint", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "GitHub issues #1348-#1353", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": false, + "reason": "No publishable packages/** or plugins/** surface is in this leaf contract." + } + }, + { + "key": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "issues": [ + 1502 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 0, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/", + "packages/plugin/", + "rfcs/", + "rfcs/0003-command-composition-kit.md", + "rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-typed-error-channel", + "issues": [ + 1350 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 1, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "1-small-contract", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "docs/site/services-sdk/how-to/discover-services.md", + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md", + "packages/contracts/src/application/contract-primitives.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/client/errors.ts", + "packages/sdk/tests/readme-doctest_test.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-procedure-metadata", + "issues": [ + 1466 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 2, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "service", + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/aspire/config.ts", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-client-contribution-seam", + "issues": [ + 1349 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 3, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "service" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/client-link-factory.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/mod.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts", + "packages/service/src/builder/service-rpc.ts", + "packages/service/src/primitives/handlers.ts", + "packages/service/src/types.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-transport-policy-consolidation", + "issues": [ + 1351 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 4, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-auth-contribution-dogfood", + "issues": [ + 1352 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 4, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "service", + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/auth-kv-oauth/src/flow.ts", + "packages/plugin/src/config/domain/plugin-contributions.ts", + "packages/sdk/src", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts", + "packages/service/src/auth/static-credential-authenticator.ts", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-trace-ownership-proof", + "issues": [ + 1353 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 4, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-locale-contribution-proof", + "issues": [ + 1467 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 5, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": false, + "reason": "No publishable packages/** or plugins/** surface is in this leaf contract." + } + }, + { + "key": "plugin-discovery-contribution-references", + "issues": [ + 1093 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 5, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/plugin/src/config/domain/plugin-contributions.ts", + "packages/plugin/src/sdk/discovery/ast-extractor.ts", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "prisma-mysql-adapter-surface", + "issues": [ + 1293 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 1, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "2-integration", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/deno.json", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/adapter.ts", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/types.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "prisma-mysql-honest-example", + "issues": [ + 1112 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 2, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "2-integration", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "docs/site/reference/prisma-adapter-mysql/index.md", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/README.md", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/adapter.ts", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/mod.ts", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/types.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "issues": [ + 1243 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 0, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "5-plugin", + "overlays": [ + "service" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/skills.generated.ts", + "packages/cli/src/maintainer/features/sync/plugin/copy-official-plugin-test-support.ts", + "packages/cli/src/public/features/plugins/auth/auth-plugin-command.ts", + "packages/cli/src/public/features/plugins/auth/auth-plugin-command_test.ts", + "plugins/streams/scaffold.plugin.json" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "issues": [ + 1262, + 1263, + 1588 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 0, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/e2e", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/database/connection-helpers.ts.template", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/database/seed.ts.template", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/generated/database/generate-prisma-config-1.ts.template", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/routers/v1.memory.ts.template", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/routers/v1.ts.template", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/database/scaffolder.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/database/scaffolder_test.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/database-generators.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/generate-database-seed.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/generate-database-seed_test.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/generate-engine-mod.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/generate-prisma-config.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/generators_test.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "app-service-client-wiring", + "issues": [ + 1355, + 1360 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 1, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "2-integration", + "overlays": [ + "frontend" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/service/client-scaffolder.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/(_islands)/ServiceShowcaseLab.tsx.template", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/service-query.ts.template", + "packages/fresh", + "packages/fresh/src/application/query/hooks.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/query-client/key-bridge.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/query/query-factory.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime", + "arch-check", + "fresh-browser" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "ui-add-page-island-repair", + "issues": [ + 1357 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 2, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [ + "frontend" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts", + "packages/cli/src/public/features/ui/add/add-ui-command.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime", + "arch-check", + "fresh-browser" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "ui-resource-slice-generator", + "issues": [ + 1354 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 3, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [ + "frontend" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/service-query.ts.template", + "packages/cli/src/public/features/generate/generate-group.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime", + "arch-check", + "fresh-browser" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "issues": [ + 1358 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 1, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [ + "frontend" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/registry.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/(design)/design/(_shared)/registry.ts.template", + "packages/fresh-ui/registry.manifest.ts", + "packages/fresh-ui/tests/registry-doc-drift.test.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "fresh-browser" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "workers-job-policy-metadata", + "issues": [ + 1451 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 2, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "service" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/windows/runtime/runtime-config-overrides.ts", + "packages/config/src/", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/executor/multi-runtime-task-executor.ts", + "plugins/workers/services/src/generated-jobs_test.ts", + "plugins/workers/src/cli/registry-compiler.ts", + "plugins/workers/src/cli/runtime-registry-generator.ts", + "plugins/workers/src/runtime/generated-jobs.ts", + "plugins/workers/tests/cli/registry-compiler-golden_test.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "workers-job-payload-typing", + "issues": [ + 1455 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 4, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "service" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/registry-generator-fixture.ts", + "packages/plugin-triggers-core/src/builders/define-webhook.ts", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/contracts/v1/workers.contract-types.ts", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-definition.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "plugin-service-context-factory", + "issues": [ + 1452 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 6, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "5-plugin", + "overlays": [ + "service" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/embedded.generated.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/plugins/generate-plugin-service_test.ts", + "packages/plugin/src/sdk/", + "plugins/auth/services/src/main.ts", + "plugins/sagas/services/src/main.ts", + "plugins/workers/services/src/main.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "workers-execution-progress", + "issues": [ + 1592 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 6, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "3-runtime-behavior", + "overlays": [ + "service" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-context.ts", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-definition.ts", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/telemetry/job-tools.ts", + "plugins/workers/worker/job-runner-pool.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "issues": [ + 1448 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 3, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "2-integration", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/ai/src/mcp/adapters/tanstack-connector.ts", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/application/pool.ts", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/application/register-tools.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "ai-openai-responses-mapper", + "issues": [ + 1591 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 7, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "2-integration", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/ai", + "packages/ai/openai-compatible.ts", + "packages/ai/src/adapters/openai-compatible.adapter.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "fresh-ai-chat-response-options", + "issues": [ + 1458 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 8, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "3-runtime-behavior", + "overlays": [ + "frontend" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/fresh/src/runtime/ai/create-chat-connection.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "fresh-browser" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "fresh-client-navigation-coordinator", + "issues": [ + 1590 + ], + "lane": "features", + "wave": 7, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "frontend" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "external:EIS-Chat@5191de83f3da97559f21d8891c6c8afdf1cf473a", + "packages/fresh/deno.json", + "packages/fresh/src", + "packages/fresh/src/", + "packages/fresh/src/application/builders/define-page/navigation/", + "packages/fresh/src/application/defer/island.ts", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/enhancement.tsx", + "packages/fresh/tests/" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "fresh-browser" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair", + "issues": [ + 1249, + 1609, + 1610 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 7, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "frontend", + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/builders/define-partial.test.tsx", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/README.md", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/_internal/prop-types.ts", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/_internal/runtime-types.ts", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/enhancement.tsx", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/form.tsx", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/schema-adapter/zod-constraints.ts", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/_internal/contract-types.ts", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/mod.ts", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/types.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check", + "fresh-browser", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "issues": [ + 1598, + 1619, + 1620, + 1623, + 1637 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 3, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "3-runtime-behavior", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-provider.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/cache-store.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-cached-entry-swr", + "issues": [ + 1461 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 5, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "3-runtime-behavior", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "docs/sdk", + "docs/site/_site/capabilities/sdk/index.md", + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "sdk-browser-safe-entrypoints", + "issues": [ + 1462 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 6, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "3-runtime-behavior", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/sdk/deno.json", + "packages/sdk/mod.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/mod.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "scaffold-route-emission-and-gating", + "issues": [ + 1481, + 1616 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 6, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "4-dsl-builder", + "overlays": [ + "frontend", + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/scaffold/writers/app-route-seeds.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/scaffold/writers/write-app-files.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/(design)/design/", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/manifest.ts", + "packages/fresh/tests/fixtures/route-binding-browser/routes.ts", + "rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "scaffold.runtime", + "arch-check", + "fresh-browser", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "cross-package-dependency-declarations", + "issues": [ + 1543 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 7, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "2-integration", + "overlays": [ + "service" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/plugin-workers-core/deno.json", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/streams/producer.ts", + "plugins/triggers", + "plugins/triggers/deno.json", + "plugins/triggers/streams/producer.ts", + "plugins/workers/deno.json" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "cli-deploy-verb-surface", + "issues": [ + 1544 + ], + "lane": "fixes", + "wave": 8, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "2-integration", + "overlays": [ + "service" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/aspire/aspire-cloud-deploy-target.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/aspire/aspire-compose-deploy-target.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/domain/deploy/service-deploy-target.ts", + "packages/cli/src/public/features/deploy/target/target-deploy-command.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "arch-check" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "issues": [ + 1296 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 2, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [ + "frontend", + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".github/workflows", + ".llm/tools/docs/check-accuracy-and-discoverability.ts", + ".llm/tools/docs/check-exports-drift.ts", + "deno.json", + "docs/exports", + "docs/site/reference/fresh-ui/index.md", + "packages/contracts/src/application/contract-primitives.ts", + "packages/contracts/src/application/paginated-query.ts", + "packages/contracts/src/public/mod.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "quality-job", + "arch-check", + "fresh-browser", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "issues": [ + 1378, + 1545 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 0, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [ + "frontend", + "service", + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".llm/harness/debt/arch-debt.md", + ".llm/tools/consumer-tools.json", + ".llm/tools/quality/scan-code-quality.ts", + ".llm/tools/quality/scan-code-quality_test.ts", + "deno.json", + "docs/site", + "docs/site/**", + "docs/site/reference/triggers/index.md", + "packages/cli/src/public/features/root/public-command-dependencies.ts", + "packages/cli/src/public/public-api.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts", + "packages/fresh/src", + "plugins/workers/streams/producer.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "quality-job", + "arch-check", + "fresh-browser", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "quality-scan-root-coverage", + "issues": [ + 1542 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 1, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [ + "service", + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".llm/tools/fitness/check-doctrine.ts", + ".llm/tools/quality", + "deno.json", + "docs/site", + "packages/*", + "packages/cli/e2e", + "packages/cli/src", + "packages/plugin-streams-core", + "packages/plugin-workers-core", + "plugins/*" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "quality-job", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "leak-check-process-descendants", + "issues": [ + 1429 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 3, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "3-runtime-behavior", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".llm/tools/agentic/teardown/", + ".llm/tools/agentic/teardown/leak-check.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "quality-job" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": false, + "reason": "No publishable packages/** or plugins/** surface is in this leaf contract." + } + }, + { + "key": "jsdoc-example-compile-gate", + "issues": [ + 1533 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 3, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [ + "service", + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".llm/tools/docs/", + ".llm/tools/docs/check-snippets.ts", + "docs/site", + "packages/**", + "packages/sdk/**/*.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/desktop/mod.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/query-client/create-service-query-utils.ts", + "plugins/**" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "quality-job", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "fresh-defer-test-capability", + "issues": [ + 1557, + 1601 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 4, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "3-runtime-behavior", + "overlays": [ + "frontend" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".github/workflows/ci.yml", + "packages/cli", + "packages/fresh/tests", + "packages/fresh/tests/defer-island-client-bundle_test.ts", + "packages/fresh/tests/fixtures/defer-island-client/", + "packages/fresh/tests/form-navigation_browser.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "quality-job", + "fresh-browser" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "issues": [ + 1561, + 1563, + 1621 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 0, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md", + ".github/workflows/openhands-agent.yml", + ".llm/tools/agentic/lib/agentic-lib.ts", + ".llm/tools/agentic/lib/agentic-lib_test.ts", + ".llm/tools/agentic/openhands/phase-eval-workflow_test.ts", + ".llm/tools/validation/acceptance-evidence.ts", + ".llm/tools/validation/acceptance-evidence_test.ts", + ".llm/tools/validation/mirror-acceptance-evidence.ts", + ".llm/tools/validation/mirror-acceptance-evidence_test.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "quality-job" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": false, + "reason": "No publishable packages/** or plugins/** surface is in this leaf contract." + } + }, + { + "key": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "issues": [ + 1611, + 1613 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 1, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".github/scripts/openhands-comment-trigger.mjs", + ".github/scripts/openhands-comment-trigger.test.ts", + ".github/workflows/openhands-agent.yml", + ".llm/tools/agentic/lib/agentic-lib.ts", + ".llm/tools/agentic/lib/agentic-lib_test.ts", + ".llm/tools/agentic/openhands/dispatch-openhands.ts", + ".llm/tools/agentic/openhands/dispatch-openhands_test.ts", + ".llm/tools/agentic/openhands/phase-eval-workflow_test.ts" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "quality-job" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": false, + "reason": "No publishable packages/** or plugins/** surface is in this leaf contract." + } + }, + { + "key": "package-gate-honesty", + "issues": [ + 1604, + 1618, + 1622 + ], + "lane": "internals", + "wave": 2, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "6-cli-tooling", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + "deno.json", + "docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md", + "docs/site/quickstart.vto", + ".llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts", + ".llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts", + ".llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts", + ".llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts", + "packages/cli/", + "packages/*", + "packages/cli", + "packages/cli/", + "packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts", + "packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts", + "packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts", + "packages/mcp", + "packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json", + "packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "publish-dry-run", + "quality-job", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "coordinatorAmendment": { + "authorizedAt": "2026-08-15T10:45:30.000Z", + "reason": "PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 proved root deno.json exclusions cannot affect explicit-file formatter or linter argv; owner issue evidence requires both optimized wrappers to recover without hiding real source findings", + "surface": "both structured fmt/lint wrappers, their focused tests, and at most one explicit marker inside the deliberately malformed fixture subtree", + "negativeBoundary": "do not broadly skip tests/fixtures; broken/deno.json remains byte-for-byte malformed; both no-extra-flag scoped commands must select non-empty real source and real MCP source defects must still fail", + "scaffoldRuntime": "waived: the archetype matrix is n/a and the documented-stream semantic unit executes the changed consumer path end-to-end" + }, + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": true, + "risks": [ + "audit public exports and exact @netscript dependency pins for every touched publishable member", + "run isolated-declaration publish dry-run and reject runtime asset/import-meta reads" + ] + } + }, + { + "key": "comparison-docs-programme", + "issues": [ + 1551 + ], + "lane": "docs", + "wave": 0, + "executionKind": "implementation", + "archetype": "1-small-contract", + "overlays": [ + "docs" + ], + "fileSurfaces": [ + ".llm/tools/", + "docs/site", + "docs/site/", + "docs/site/reference/", + "external:EIS-Chat@5191de83f3da97559f21d8891c6c8afdf1cf473a" + ], + "provingGates": [ + "check", + "test", + "docs-source-format", + "docs-accuracy" + ], + "jsrAudit": { + "applicable": false, + "reason": "No publishable packages/** or plugins/** surface is in this leaf contract." + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-cluster-state.json b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-cluster-state.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..10f6c1a834 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-cluster-state.json @@ -0,0 +1,3336 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "milestone": "0.0.7", + "baselineMainSha": "01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed", + "currentMainSha": "0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb", + "coordinator": { + "agentId": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "sessionId": "019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd", + "predecessorSessionId": "019ff0c0-ca4b-7ea0-893b-e8ab1f4811ea", + "transcript": "/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/13/rollout-2026-08-13T12-20-27-019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd.jsonl", + "resumeCommand": "codex exec resume 019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd -- \"\"", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix", + "branch": "chore/release-0.0.7-orchestration", + "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", + "effort": "high", + "maxEffortAuthorized": false, + "transport": "codex-app-server-remote-control", + "remoteSocket": "unix:///home/codex/.codex/app-server-control/app-server-control.sock", + "appServerPid": 5027, + "attachedProcessPid": 2452378, + "verifiedAt": "2026-08-14T23:08:28.000Z" + }, + "limits": { + "activeImplementationSlicesPerLane": 2, + "activeEvaluatorsPerLane": 1, + "globalExpensiveGates": 1, + "releaseWriters": 1 + }, + "lanes": [ + { + "id": "docs", + "orchestratorAgentId": "topic-docs-0.0.7", + "controller": { + "runtime": "claude", + "state": "active", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs", + "branch": "orchestrator/release-0.0.7-docs", + "requestedModel": "claude-opus-5", + "requestedEffort": "high", + "remoteControlRequired": true, + "observedModel": "claude-opus-5", + "observedEffort": "high", + "backgroundAgentId": "fcf04b0f", + "sessionId": "fcf04b0f-3c2f-4844-9508-84c52ce8298c", + "pid": 23964, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01PLRauSHN1PnvrNF2ucefF6", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01PLRauSHN1PnvrNF2ucefF6", + "topicHeadSha": "5c4ccd8fec2b415b373c875c3b02a6f896fcdc3e", + "queueState": "exhausted_parked", + "attachmentVerifiedAt": "2026-08-14T23:00:08.000Z", + "legacyCodexThreadId": "019ffcc0-e19b-71d1-95ce-8c72559eb026", + "legacyState": "parked_offline" + }, + "issueNumbers": [ + 1551 + ] + }, + { + "id": "internals", + "orchestratorAgentId": "topic-internals-0.0.7", + "controller": { + "runtime": "claude", + "state": "active", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-internals", + "branch": "orchestrator/release-0.0.7-internals", + "requestedModel": "claude-opus-5", + "requestedEffort": "high", + "remoteControlRequired": true, + "observedModel": "claude-opus-5", + "observedEffort": "high", + "backgroundAgentId": "f7691917", + "sessionId": "f7691917-0be2-4bcd-8839-43d3fc809c34", + "pid": 23955, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01HqFtKQtyJcHBEn1MghQdFX", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01HqFtKQtyJcHBEn1MghQdFX", + "topicHeadSha": "abb015cb7a6c0e7c4dcda2589844fcfc2739b467", + "attachmentVerifiedAt": "2026-08-14T23:00:08.000Z", + "legacyCodexThreadId": "019ffcc0-e1b5-74f0-96eb-cdeb298d6b17", + "legacyState": "parked_idle" + }, + "issueNumbers": [ + 1296, + 1378, + 1429, + 1533, + 1542, + 1545, + 1557, + 1561, + 1563, + 1601, + 1604, + 1611, + 1613, + 1618, + 1621, + 1622 + ] + }, + { + "id": "fixes", + "orchestratorAgentId": "topic-fixes-0.0.7", + "controller": { + "runtime": "claude", + "state": "active", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-fixes", + "branch": "orchestrator/release-0.0.7-fixes", + "requestedModel": "claude-opus-5", + "requestedEffort": "high", + "remoteControlRequired": true, + "observedModel": "claude-opus-5", + "observedEffort": "high", + "backgroundAgentId": "c7597d28", + "sessionId": "c7597d28-6774-44c9-aa00-b8b40b776165", + "pid": 26724, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_014pCd2QWkCscgZpVdjcUPST", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_014pCd2QWkCscgZpVdjcUPST", + "topicHeadSha": "a374977d8a4ad7af68919afa508ec1107d7f4221", + "attachmentVerifiedAt": "2026-08-14T23:00:08.000Z", + "legacyCodexThreadId": "019ffcc0-e1ae-7b70-b3b8-8804ebd6f773", + "legacyState": "parked_idle" + }, + "issueNumbers": [ + 1093, + 1112, + 1243, + 1249, + 1262, + 1263, + 1350, + 1351, + 1353, + 1357, + 1358, + 1448, + 1461, + 1462, + 1481, + 1543, + 1544, + 1588, + 1598, + 1609, + 1610, + 1616, + 1619, + 1620, + 1623, + 1637 + ] + }, + { + "id": "features", + "orchestratorAgentId": "topic-features-0.0.7", + "controller": { + "runtime": "claude", + "state": "active", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features", + "branch": "orchestrator/release-0.0.7-features", + "requestedModel": "claude-opus-5", + "requestedEffort": "high", + "remoteControlRequired": true, + "observedModel": "claude-opus-5", + "observedEffort": "high", + "backgroundAgentId": "19621a0b", + "sessionId": "19621a0b-c6a0-47c6-b826-93c1634a6875", + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01LQBHX8KpA5aYtDraq46J8a", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01LQBHX8KpA5aYtDraq46J8a", + "topicHeadSha": "f436df086129f4e9f23afc5a4e0b1b7c996acdd5", + "attachmentVerifiedAt": "2026-08-14T23:00:08.000Z", + "legacyCodexThreadId": "019ffcc0-e1d2-7850-a308-354b670c6f3d", + "legacyState": "parked_idle" + }, + "issueNumbers": [ + 1293, + 1348, + 1349, + 1352, + 1354, + 1355, + 1360, + 1451, + 1452, + 1455, + 1458, + 1466, + 1467, + 1502, + 1590, + 1591, + 1592 + ] + } + ], + "watchers": [ + { + "agentId": "milestone-main-watcher-0.0.7", + "mutationAuthority": false + }, + { + "agentId": "milestone-ci-watcher-0.0.7", + "mutationAuthority": false + } + ], + "committedIssues": [ + { + "number": 1093, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1112, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1243, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1249, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1262, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1263, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1293, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1296, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1348, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1349, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1350, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1351, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1352, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1353, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1354, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1355, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1357, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1358, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1360, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1378, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1429, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1448, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1451, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1452, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1455, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1458, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1461, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1462, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1466, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1467, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1481, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1502, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1533, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1542, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1543, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1544, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1545, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1551, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1557, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1561, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1563, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1588, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1590, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1591, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1592, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1598, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1601, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1604, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1609, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1610, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1611, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1613, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1616, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1618, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1619, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1620, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1621, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1622, + "state": "open" + }, + { + "number": 1623, + "state": "closed" + }, + { + "number": 1637, + "state": "closed" + } + ], + "leaves": [ + { + "id": "comparison-docs-programme", + "lane": "docs", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "d35cbca30872d1f55118d63437638e93270c2ac3", + "currentPrHeadSha": "a465836b4cc1c40262a473de07b5744e70b20ead", + "prNumber": 1652, + "evaluatorCommitSha": "a790e91e26a4fb84636b4f3c57bd6444196b4ca9", + "evaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete_cycle_2", + "implementationEvaluationCycle": 2, + "implementationEvaluatedHeadSha": "15429cf8487cfe3504ae0443fd435d2a72d4528b", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "c6950ed9-7405-4f28-9464-1e1977f2979c", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "e95f4838038a27a0f209d2ce37c9f53bd4ed4299", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "issueNumbers": [1551], + "implementerAgentId": "019ffcc9-16c2-7573-b7f6-d627172408e8", + "evaluatorAgentId": "40a06314-b69a-4ca0-a4a0-1224c5e377ca", + "branch": "docs/comparison-docs-programme", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs-comparison", + "receiptRefs": [], + "ownerPriorityRewrite": { + "requestCommentId": 5300459514, + "targetCommentIds": [5265826161, 5265971722], + "oldEvidenceHead": "5191de83f3da97559f21d8891c6c8afdf1cf473a", + "authoritativeEvidenceHead": "5191de83f3da97559f21d8891c6c8afdf1cf473a", + "newerProductHeadExists": false, + "evidenceOnlyBranchHead": "834a2b36", + "commentChronologyConfirmed": true, + "state": "complete", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T05:07:09.377Z", + "requireInPlaceReplacement": true + }, + "s3State": "complete", + "s3GrantedAt": "2026-08-15T05:13:42.084Z", + "s3CompletedHeadSha": "15429cf8487cfe3504ae0443fd435d2a72d4528b", + "repairState": "complete", + "repairGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T05:48:07.224Z", + "repairCompletedHeadSha": "c7ce58a19494024c219e9970deeb3ece878232d6", + "repairCommits": [ + "43c702b973a71b539ec16e4b93f2c7a2c09d9ab6", + "c7ce58a19494024c219e9970deeb3ece878232d6" + ], + "repairCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1652#issuecomment-5300842325", + "repairTierAState": "PASS", + "repairTierACommitSha": "3aedb4ccefb230ef89939e93adaa243501286815", + "repairTierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1652#issuecomment-5300864119", + "nextImplementationEvaluationState": "complete_cycle_2", + "nextImplementationEvaluatedHeadSha": "c7ce58a19494024c219e9970deeb3ece878232d6", + "nextImplementationEvaluatorAgentId": "4ed649d5-9d62-4e24-a50a-081477607cee", + "nextImplementationEvaluatorPid": 145190, + "nextImplementationEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "session_013RN66nBipHogdecXX4uZ9G", + "nextImplementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "nextImplementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "71cc5a02cde091f862c9892464ea77cc962b3675", + "nextImplementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1652#issuecomment-5300916189", + "mergeReadinessCleanupState": "complete", + "derivedAssetRepairHeadSha": "a465836b4cc1c40262a473de07b5744e70b20ead", + "derivedAssetRepairPath": "packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts", + "derivedAssetCascadeHeads": [ + "d4a0a8340aa5fc2b61d9526845808c227c07f115", + "d24c3fa03197cfcf0adcc91eca08847d6a26bd8c", + "a465836b4cc1c40262a473de07b5744e70b20ead" + ], + "derivedAssetCascadePaths": [ + ".llm/assets/agent-docs/prose.json.gz", + ".llm/assets/agent-docs/provenance.json", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-docs.generated.ts", + "packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts" + ], + "derivedAssetRepairFormalCycle3": "not_authorized", + "readinessState": "complete", + "mergeCommitSha": "e090f894ff3682405a36e4f896ffd2cc16f9a1f8", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T07:21:13.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "closed_completed", + "mergeReadinessCleanupFindings": [ + "replace the non-reproducible normalized digest claim with directly reproducible byte-identical evidence", + "update the stale plan status", + "correct the methodology section citation and already-proven Tier-A checkbox" + ] + }, + { + "id": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "lane": "internals", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "09dfb092dccf7f843b9270295047d674a8187362", + "currentPrHeadSha": "70177e80821a916c83ffa72041c6bb24bbb6ccc8", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "c694cfb311d378f4796280649042c8c275c828ed", + "evaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationCycle": 2, + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "31c4cfa9-6610-4813-a4d2-482080fc562e", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "70177e80821a916c83ffa72041c6bb24bbb6ccc8", + "mergeCommitSha": "473e8d75b5281c93dc4729d99f3358a34f2bd687", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T05:04:49.000Z", + "issueNumbers": [1378, 1545], + "implementerAgentId": "019ffcc9-97d6-7602-bb7d-582ecc92b069", + "evaluatorAgentId": "b6c48f02-cb56-4dae-abfd-e46bdec05bd5", + "branch": "chore/quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-quality-rail", + "receiptRefs": [ + ".llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/quality-scan-allowance-rail/receipts/slice-4/check-binding.json", + ".llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/quality-scan-allowance-rail/receipts/slice-4/test-binding.json", + ".llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/quality-scan-allowance-rail/receipts/slice-4/quality-job.json" + ] + }, + { + "id": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "lane": "internals", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "4d9fb196765cbf1a6bc7eaa7c18ec82b237ab89f", + "currentPrHeadSha": "d6e6a6788cd38127f822d192f37557106dad4ebc", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "d6e6a6788cd38127f822d192f37557106dad4ebc", + "evaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "mergeCommitSha": "dd472102d05ea13ab7ac7654aeedb177fbae2eb8", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-14T23:27:02.000Z", + "issueNumbers": [1561, 1563, 1621], + "implementerAgentId": "019ffcc9-97ba-7770-a890-a1ebd80ec793", + "evaluatorAgentId": "1afc9054-cc28-48a8-9fc4-86ae2e3bb28d", + "branch": "fix/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-harness-evidence", + "receiptRefs": [ + ".llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling/receipts/final/check.receipt.json", + ".llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling/receipts/final/test.receipt.json", + ".llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling/receipts/final/quality-job.receipt.json" + ] + }, + { + "id": "legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "lane": "fixes", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "e6ba15ec6414c0a42b1f9870791131162ea71c36", + "currentPrHeadSha": "a949a6cd1777b0d05b1a3b45143de15951aa6dc2", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "a949a6cd1777b0d05b1a3b45143de15951aa6dc2", + "evaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "mergeCommitSha": "0b3ed5d5a6aea451318f120988c25dfa3993a2ab", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-14T23:39:37.000Z", + "issueNumbers": [1243], + "implementerAgentId": "019ffcca-8bdc-7fb3-98c5-df90e2ae3b1f", + "evaluatorAgentId": "8c47751a-6a30-4dab-b25c-dbafe9873455", + "branch": "fix/legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "lane": "fixes", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "5b3c6fcf21b0b4947a770d8e67ea5cc8082724d5", + "currentPrHeadSha": "7cfaf70cc5a42e74af4ae8b7be76d5a5cbf4fcc5", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "b8fc5eb53a530d337602f7dc377239651a57d428", + "evaluationCycle": 2, + "evaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "priorEvaluation": { + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHeadSha": "14d8b38b4db7ba0635cbbcac2f8cd8903bee0ec9", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "13008abf83734884f7fcfc71e6d6d9facb24bcbf", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN" + }, + "planRepairHeadSha": "5b3c6fcf21b0b4947a770d8e67ea5cc8082724d5", + "tierASignoffHeadSha": "f178ac663597a7b9cfd2e6a528026426d39d1173", + "tierAVerdict": "PASS_TO_IMPL_EVAL", + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "19f1be7b-db7d-47c0-b0f1-7cfca302d44a", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "70843d169d4e7f4c8f810d663a142cc66b7969ff", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "mergeCommitSha": "da574111af05a5cded74250128b196fcab870274", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T05:36:48.000Z", + "postMergeCi": { + "state": "success", + "ciRunId": 31867377599, + "docsRunId": 31867378176, + "codeQualityRunId": 31867377620, + "checkTestDuration": "8m54s", + "qualityDuration": "1m48s", + "warning": "actions/upload-artifact@v5 forced to Node.js 24 because Node.js 20 is deprecated" + }, + "issueNumbers": [1262, 1263, 1588], + "implementerAgentId": "019ffcca-8be0-74c2-bb0e-c82cf5ce3c85", + "evaluatorAgentId": "06451c1e-a9b8-47d2-8934-be2247ef5347", + "branch": "fix/scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "receiptRefs": [ + ".llm/runs/fix-scaffold-generated-output-correctness--0.0.7-wave0/receipts/scaffold-runtime.json", + ".llm/runs/fix-scaffold-generated-output-correctness--0.0.7-wave0/receipts/leak-check.json" + ], + "runtimeGate": { + "attempt": 2, + "state": "pass_cleanup_verified", + "outcome": "PASS", + "rawExitCode": 0, + "passed": 89, + "failed": 0, + "skipped": 0, + "durationMs": 602896, + "suiteEndedAt": "2026-08-15T04:53:51.303Z", + "cleanupVerifiedAt": "2026-08-15T04:55:26.483Z", + "aspirePostcondition": "empty", + "dockerPostcondition": "empty", + "leakSurvivors": 0, + "attempt1": { + "state": "interrupted_no_verdict", + "lastCompletedGate": "database.migration-artifacts", + "interruptedAtGate": "database.generate", + "cleanupVerifiedAt": "2026-08-15T04:34:58.220Z", + "aspirePostcondition": "empty", + "dockerPostcondition": "empty" + } + } + }, + { + "id": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "lane": "fixes", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "da574111af05a5cded74250128b196fcab870274", + "currentPrHeadSha": "b71c1ee723813dd384a6490f342360f9a434a89e", + "issueNumbers": [1358], + "implementerAgentId": "01a003f0-7821-7a10-a555-e619a9280479", + "branch": "fix/design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-design-registry-drift", + "prNumber": 1657, + "implementationState": "complete", + "implementationCompletedHeadSha": "4a3c40321ac1e58aa337e02afeaa95fbc553ce7f", + "freshBrowserGateState": "complete", + "freshBrowserLeaseId": "design-registry-catalog-drift-fresh-browser", + "freshBrowserGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T06:07:21.000Z", + "freshBrowserCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T06:13:10.000Z", + "freshBrowserVerdict": "PASS", + "freshBrowserEvidenceCommitSha": "c792327c99a54eb64f236d1676ee3a7c1d76efc2", + "freshBrowserCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5300887363", + "tierAState": "CHANGES_REQUESTED", + "tierAStartedAt": "2026-08-15T06:18:00.000Z", + "tierAReviewCommitSha": "5fe60023530d89b888a028d5269909636ac03b8a", + "tierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5300918179", + "tierAFinding": "T-3: Fresh UI drift CI does not trigger on CLI design-asset-only edits", + "contractAmendmentState": "authorized", + "contractAmendmentCommitSha": "c5e06661b1b957f64f86b8bd6aec8da7c3dd2064", + "contractAmendmentFiles": [ + ".github/workflows/fresh-ui-quality.yml", + ".github/scripts/ci-classify-changes.ts", + ".github/scripts/ci-classify-changes.test.ts", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/embedded.generated.ts" + ], + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete_cycle_1_fail_fix", + "implementationEvaluationCycle": 1, + "implementationEvaluatedHeadSha": "939e7311317365db7681de5e3c7c56a73412424e", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "04897102-bcd6-4918-8b72-dc0151035883", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "a46b83831fca037d8a8fa309da849200653c7730", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "implementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5301015059", + "repairScopeAmendmentHeadSha": "c3ccceeb13cd71895ea4ac3229f03a15472dac86", + "repairTierAState": "PASS", + "repairTierACommitSha": "3d7819203f59e68eb5b45f6871a03c41ca43cd2f", + "repairTierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5301086718", + "nextImplementationEvaluationState": "complete", + "nextImplementationEvaluationCycle": 2, + "nextImplementationEvaluatedHeadSha": "3d7819203f59e68eb5b45f6871a03c41ca43cd2f", + "nextImplementationEvaluatorAgentId": "1df19d27-ce81-4027-99ac-49f3b9ec26bc", + "nextImplementationEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "session_018WYHfqzFKKve37TL7hsPQD", + "nextImplementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "ed9ee76636db864031762c3a874db2e06e6353d3", + "nextImplementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "nextImplementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5301157020", + "nextImplementationEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T07:32:36.157Z", + "postEvaluationCleanupState": "complete", + "postEvaluationCleanupHeadSha": "a891c65203301ec96467f11d9fe3dcb77a09d5c8", + "postEvaluationCleanupCommits": [ + "695dd7b005f65071b8f749ed84eb60faa3cd0f73", + "a891c65203301ec96467f11d9fe3dcb77a09d5c8" + ], + "postEvaluationCleanupBoundary": "the three redundant T-3 CI deltas equal origin/main; core #1358 product work and prior formal PASS remain intact", + "postEvaluationCleanupTierAState": "CHANGES_REQUESTED", + "postEvaluationCleanupTierACommitSha": "21403902b502925dd97ea8cea4e129eb8c83e0df", + "postEvaluationCleanupTierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5301270096", + "postEvaluationCleanupTierAFinding": "live PR body still reports the reverted T-3 slice and its validation as current and fails to qualify fresh-browser as form-navigation-only evidence", + "postEvaluationBodyRepairState": "complete", + "postEvaluationBodyRecheckState": "PASS", + "postEvaluationBodyRecheckCommitSha": "b71c1ee723813dd384a6490f342360f9a434a89e", + "postEvaluationBodyRecheckCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5301330685", + "readinessState": "complete", + "mergeCommitSha": "6917c656eebdfda1ac65d509f6a5f55c93f38774", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T08:27:20.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "closed_completed", + "receiptRefs": [ + ".llm/runs/fix-design-registry-catalog-drift-gate--0.0.7-wave1/receipts/fresh-browser.json" + ] + }, + { + "id": "quality-scan-root-coverage", + "lane": "internals", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "473e8d75b5281c93dc4729d99f3358a34f2bd687", + "currentPrHeadSha": "b80794470cd175ad89d27c06a764ab1d032d3d9f", + "issueNumbers": [1542], + "implementerAgentId": "01a003d2-61ee-7ec0-8c74-075b3d631168", + "branch": "fix/quality-scan-root-coverage", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-quality-root-coverage", + "prNumber": 1656, + "planEvaluationState": "complete", + "planEvaluationCycle": 1, + "planEvaluatedHeadSha": "da76d9d8440a969f0715ca035ea6304bbf039efd", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "97ef1950-cda3-450e-9451-052a15015b3a", + "planEvaluatorCommitSha": "3b95a004fe8bc5c022c7a2601fafef9a1216be68", + "planEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationState": "complete", + "implementationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T05:48:07.224Z", + "slice1HeadSha": "dbbedde346f91341208875aee7b5108bd3805dc7", + "slice1TierAState": "PASS", + "slice1TierAFinding": "record the justified JSON output-field renames in drift.md; implementation behavior is substantively correct", + "slice1TierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1656#issuecomment-5300867545", + "slice1DriftRecordCommitSha": "179219b02d7901a534917ba1570bc91be1551036", + "slice1SignoffCommitSha": "a258bcc8c6365e12ee33b7e6a4657f52140f6308", + "slice1SignoffCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1656#issuecomment-5300880913", + "slice2HeadSha": "a7e9ee0d5c8c15bade0e1d5c656e77d9105ddbf2", + "slice2TierAState": "PASS", + "slice2SignoffCommitSha": "4ae309d5774676d710ba24f56119b028bc2c095c", + "slice2SignoffCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1656#issuecomment-5300918421", + "priorRouteFailure": { + "route": "native-claude/claude-fable-5/medium", + "classification": "transport_model_unavailable_zero_token", + "countedAsEvaluationCycle": false + }, + "slice3HeadSha": "0147e238fe9239ebb1da719137be2fbc66ad7bcd", + "slice3TierAState": "PASS", + "slice3SignoffCommitSha": "2c4881fd7b01c2c5dabb6e76009bb5412b2538b2", + "slice3SignoffCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1656#issuecomment-5300984832", + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete", + "implementationEvaluationCycle": 1, + "implementationEvaluatedHeadSha": "2c4881fd7b01c2c5dabb6e76009bb5412b2538b2", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "ee2825f2-a67f-4d65-8c7f-b1956f695ded", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "addba1ab977ed194dbce73deccfa94cac268e807", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1656#issuecomment-5301029660", + "readinessState": "complete", + "readinessFollowUp": "pre-existing .llm lint exclusion can silently omit tooling files from mixed lint batches", + "mergeCommitSha": "7737d8903bb2925c3fcefbda362168fe297eebd4", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T07:09:12.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "closed_completed", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "lane": "internals", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "7737d8903bb2925c3fcefbda362168fe297eebd4", + "currentPrHeadSha": "bf07062987088809133ccacd380be6b016b511ed", + "issueNumbers": [1611, 1613], + "implementerAgentId": "01a00443-abab-7261-8905-74ed71467929", + "branch": "fix/openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-openhands-dispatch", + "prNumber": 1658, + "bootstrapHeadSha": "ca2266ecb4fe0cdd8a47059b4bca39761840f3b3", + "researchHeadSha": "670e37beaa723f1b54218149a2485dd6b3e741e3", + "implementationState": "merged_and_lifecycle_normalized", + "planRepairHeadSha": "cea999d18ea2c2d4a6208fc209ce744d9be1d194", + "planRepairTierAState": "PASS", + "planRepairTierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301190104", + "planEvaluationState": "complete", + "planEvaluationCycle": 1, + "planEvaluatedHeadSha": "cea999d18ea2c2d4a6208fc209ce744d9be1d194", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "7d544aec-22cc-4656-8483-6d957dbfbfda", + "planEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "7d544aec", + "planEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "session_01N9zhX5ZDUvvrBxcwoAYBCm", + "planEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-opus-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "planEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T07:44:39.000Z", + "planEvaluatorCommitSha": "e15d78588503f4a83d6322be9039abe1f52190a1", + "planEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "planEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301255122", + "planEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T07:54:58.339Z", + "implementationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T07:59:47.000Z", + "implementationTopicCheckpointSha": "d5ade932be5bf541739e092a2eb4faf5a6668d20", + "slice1ImplementationHeadSha": "4aa04de34c83a47d96b65349b726fa190c491366", + "slice1EvidenceHeadSha": "f1567ce32806f30f80365d180e73e053eb7d8e05", + "slice1TierAState": "PASS", + "slice1TierASignoffHeadSha": "6f725ad3bf72f00cf1a439e3dad7acb6789dbb4c", + "slice1TierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301346790", + "slice1RootTest": "PASS: 4138 passed, 19 ignored, 0 failed", + "slice2ImplementationHeadSha": "28a8a9184201a7dc27532f057ddbe35e4e11215b", + "slice2EvidenceHeadSha": "5869cb46d5157fd4bd42ef2afaf357286a823506", + "slice2TierAState": "PASS", + "slice2TierASignoffHeadSha": "0886c2427fb78d26fd3aaa009f958ddf10895c76", + "slice2TierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301401476", + "slice3LocalImplementationHeadSha": "d7fdbb1d9e86e30100781ba420a4340b1a16abc6", + "slice3EvidenceHeadSha": "2e6a065d774dd21cc4f9913eacc291622d27bc76", + "slice3TierAState": "PASS", + "slice3TierASignoffHeadSha": "d3d31b3d071e1b0f6a0ef40013da2489775b08c1", + "slice3TierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301464449", + "slice4LocalImplementationHeadSha": "9b71e1bd29eb5eea5856d528973f85aa685b3172", + "slice4EvidenceHeadSha": "ab4b8185f545b4890f7fcbc0e00a114afecb4087", + "slice4TierAState": "PASS", + "slice4TierASignoffHeadSha": "ad19d0e201137865879db74d2819be980919d334", + "slice4TierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301555163", + "slice5CheckpointHeadSha": "1390d3ead1d7d4381ace3d9403f559f009895643", + "slice5EvidenceHeadSha": "704c067e8f09fb47a3973faa7277321cac34f9ef", + "slice5GateVerdicts": { + "check": "PASS", + "test": "PASS", + "quality-job": "PASS" + }, + "slice5TierAState": "PASS", + "slice5TierASignoffHeadSha": "f46d84630c54210a09ff4ed39537da1e66964a52", + "slice5TierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301628196", + "finalRootTest": "PASS: 4147 passed, 19 ignored, 0 failed in approximately 319 seconds", + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete", + "implementationEvaluationCycle": 1, + "implementationEvaluatedHeadSha": "f46d84630c54210a09ff4ed39537da1e66964a52", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "740d2a3a-1677-459c-a6b1-a39398649d1a", + "implementationEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "740d2a3a", + "implementationEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01NVeBmZE7SwH3Nvu3ep51zV", + "implementationEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-opus-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T09:38:04.000Z", + "implementationEvaluationStartedAt": "2026-08-15T09:40:04.876Z", + "implementationEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T09:54:05.000Z", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "8f62a61213df890101b6f7dfc07a042928f2d536", + "implementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301699397", + "postEvaluationDispositionHeadSha": "bf07062987088809133ccacd380be6b016b511ed", + "formalRoundTripDisposition": "the committed command-not-first-token production round-trip plus the separate formal producer-shape and phase-acceptance tests satisfy the literal criterion; a single combined formal case remains non-blocking follow-up", + "readinessState": "complete", + "readinessChecks": "21 terminal: 7 success, 14 policy skips, 0 failed, 0 active; 0 review threads; mergeState CLEAN", + "mergeCommitSha": "05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T10:13:45.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "1611 and 1613 closed; PR and both issues have sole status:shipped", + "fableAvailabilityProbe": { + "state": "failed_pre_inference_zero_cycle", + "agentId": "e58c5f01-8acc-4148-9fb6-74045e2bc5cd", + "backgroundAgentId": "e58c5f01", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01HKNQH5Ki5TVhTVKcsMtKVY", + "tokens": null, + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T09:38:46.599Z" + }, + "implementationCarriedNotes": [ + "S1-before-S4 is required by the API dependency, not live intermediate-branch spend safety", + "the root test receipt is the load-bearing gate for these dot-directory surfaces", + "refusal vocabulary must avoid bare evaluator verdict tokens", + "assert all five reportable denial reasons explicitly", + "post refusals with GITHUB_TOKEN so the declared issues:write job permission is the real ceiling" + ], + "contractAmendment": { + "state": "authorized", + "authorizedAt": "2026-08-15T07:25:00.000Z", + "formalCliMode": "explicit --phase plan|impl, PR-only, verdict contract required, CLI resolves live PR head before emitting phase/head", + "nonFormalCliMode": "no --phase, tuple-free, PR and issue dispatch remain supported", + "refusalPolicy": "literal command candidates reach trusted policy; denied attempts receive one sanitized marker-bearing reply before spend with no command token and no recursion", + "generationRetry": "manual path uses the existing five attempts at one-second intervals and returns an attributable fail-closed denial on exhaustion", + "readOnlySurfaces": [ + ".github/workflows/openhands-phase-eval.yml" + ], + "formalPlanEvaluationRequired": true + }, + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "package-gate-honesty", + "lane": "internals", + "phase": "planned", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b", + "currentPrHeadSha": "194e22a3d0aaefe68922ed7a378aafb651a72dff", + "issueNumbers": [1604, 1618, 1622], + "implementerAgentId": "01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5", + "implementerRoute": "openai / gpt-5.6-sol / medium / approval never / dangerFullAccess", + "branch": "fix/package-gate-honesty", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-package-gate", + "prNumber": 1663, + "bootstrapHeadSha": "25c29575c", + "planHeadSha": "df1d7a96d7fd4ecca0bd61710ba90ff67449da0b", + "implementationState": "cycle_2_repair_tier_a_pass_awaiting_owner_exceptional_final_plan_eval_no_product_mutation", + "dispatchTopicHeadSha": "b5f72901d0f30d56046c7f7241e09fb8cb3bfcad", + "expensiveGateContract": "scaffold.runtime is matrix n/a and coordinator-waived for this surface; no lease may be requested and no runtime gate is executed", + "planGate": "author must stop after bounded plan and report whether a fresh PLAN-EVAL is required", + "tierAPlanState": "PASS", + "tierAPlanHeadSha": "194e22a3d0aaefe68922ed7a378aafb651a72dff", + "tierAPlanTopicCheckpointSha": "b2e0529be", + "tierAPlanFinding": "PASS after cycle-2 repair: exact thirteen-path plan, generated CLI barrel/publish delta and freshness gate declared, task-level doctor skip removed, root formatter boundary retained, 114-file and negative-control invariants preserved", + "planEvaluationState": "owner_exception_required_for_one_final_cycle_after_two_failures", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "517ac0e7", + "planEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "517ac0e7", + "planEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn", + "planEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "planEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T11:24:31.000Z", + "planEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "df1d7a96d7fd4ecca0bd61710ba90ff67449da0b", + "planEvaluatorRemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn", + "planEvaluationCycle2": { + "state": "complete", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN", + "evaluatorAgentId": "517ac0e7-9951-40ec-ab48-d0175a6d7ebb", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "c415daad2af38690c6195b02c4e949bdc8c8ae6c", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1663#issuecomment-5302030430", + "blockingFinding": "run-deno-lint.ts is embedded into the published CLI consumer-tool bundle, so its planned change requires the generated agent-tools barrel and asset freshness gate" + }, + "planEvaluationCycle1": { + "state": "complete", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN", + "evaluatorAgentId": "9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_0176qkbF4eKUt7TxJiEPdTrk", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "be2b1872823cbbb07a393633fcccb684f753afc1", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1663#issuecomment-5301867229" + }, + "coordinatorContractAmendment": { + "authorizedAt": "2026-08-15T10:45:30.000Z", + "wrapperSurfaces": [ + ".llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts", + ".llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts", + ".llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts", + ".llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts" + ], + "markerAllowance": "at most one narrowly named marker inside packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken if the repaired plan proves marker-based subtree exclusion", + "formattingNormalizationPath": "packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts; formatting-only, no semantic/schema/config-value change, actual mutation forbidden before PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 PASS", + "negativeBoundary": "no broad tests/fixtures or parent-family skip; malformed deno.json stays byte-identical; fmt and lint no-extra-flag commands must select real files, retain doctor/healthy as selected, and retain real-source negative controls", + "scaffoldRuntimeDisposition": "waived_matrix_n_a_focused_semantic_unit_is_load_bearing", + "generatedAssetPath": "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts; exact thirteenth path, canonical regeneration only", + "assetGate": "check:assets-barrel/generated asset freshness is binding and the @netscript/cli publish/hash/installed-consumer behavior delta must be declared", + "rootTaskSkipDisposition": "remove the fmt:check task-level doctor exclusion so healthy fixtures remain visible; retain the root formatter exclusion that protects fixture-local default style", + "cycleEscalation": "a further formal FAIL_PLAN after this bounded repair is owner escalation" + }, + "rejectedPlanRepair": { + "localCommitSha": "71e803807bce3ed17cca0ec86925aadc6a378126", + "remoteState": "not_pushed_remote_still_be2b1872823cbbb07a393633fcccb684f753afc1", + "rejectedAt": "2026-08-15T11:00:09.503Z", + "reason": "a marker inside doctor/broken suppressed the entire doctor parent family, including four healthy unmarked fixture files, trading a visible crash for a silent false-positive exclusion", + "acceptanceNumber": "115 selected becomes exactly 114; only the marked broken subtree is omitted and all four doctor/healthy TypeScript files remain named as selected", + "secondSeam": "batch selected files by effective nearest Deno config inside the already-authorized fmt/lint wrappers so the healthy nested config is checked under its own valid boundary", + "recovery": "the exact active author PID was interrupted before push; local-only 71e803807 was safely amended into ccf256884 before its first remote push, so no remote history rewrite occurred; the same Codex thread was preserved and no product implementation occurred" + }, + "routeRecovery": { + "malformedProbe": "bd8b4f90 failed pre-inference from /tmp with model token fable-5 and no Remote Control; zero cycle and no mutation", + "stoppedFallback": "02d8d823 Opus fallback was stopped before repository mutation or verdict artifact", + "canonicalCorrection": "relaunched once with canonical token claude-fable-5, medium, Remote Control, and exact worktree" + }, + "nextSerialLeaf": "reference-export-drift-gate (#1296)", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "lane": "internals", + "phase": "implementing", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "baf1cdf67a4e931af17b4772ddf6101f36152184", + "currentPrHeadSha": "92988da30a4468f5ea77ea4e5a3e243469f92e52", + "issueNumbers": [1296], + "implementerAgentId": "01a005d2-7c9d-7dd1-b6fc-531b72dc14e4", + "implementerRoute": "openai / gpt-5.6-sol / medium / approval never / dangerFullAccess", + "branch": "fix/reference-export-drift-gate", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-reference-export", + "prNumber": 1666, + "implementationState": "quality_repair_cycle_5_pass_readiness_attempt_3_exact_head_ci_active", + "planHeadSha": "9d0b4bf128ba52fcd52091ba50590661d09470c1", + "scopeAmendmentHeadSha": "a3f6b87b599e778db950daf6ccaecd847c088d19", + "tierAPlanState": "PASS_SA2", + "tierAPlanHeadSha": "80046696e6b192c5448aba6b3b0b619faeabac21", + "tierAPlanTopicCheckpointSha": "bb8c12f56a693dd6d627e624edb8b8f00a257ca3", + "tierAPlanFinding": "SA-2 is plan-only and complete: nine-line inventory/four wrong-root examples, thirteen-path plus fourteenth refusal, corrected existing CI enforcement chain, N1-N5, four-file sequencing, and JSR prose-only delta all bound; fresh-browser waiver remains explicit", + "planEvaluationState": "complete_pass_cycle_2", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "0e2d1e57-c093-4d14-87fe-bab55fd8f020", + "planEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "0e2d1e57", + "planEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01K6SbsotG5MyjyjTd11SrfK", + "planEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "planEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "80046696e6b192c5448aba6b3b0b619faeabac21", + "planEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T17:15:29.000Z", + "planEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T17:29:51.000Z", + "planEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "planEvaluatorCommitSha": "45c249b9c16ee075435d11b827c94beca1f87ce2", + "planEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303401348", + "authorizedAdditionalSurface": [ + ".llm/tools/docs/check-exports-drift_test.ts" + ], + "scopeRuling": "the tenth path is test-only and must persist fail-closed coverage for empty or malformed reasons, unknown coverage modes, invented symbols, and omitted symbols; central leaf-contracts reconciliation remains coordinator-owned", + "cycle1RepairRuling": { + "authorizedAt": "2026-08-15T16:57:59.947Z", + "additionalJSDocOnlyPaths": [ + "packages/contracts/src/application/transform-helpers.ts", + "packages/contracts/schemas/filters.ts", + "packages/contracts/schemas/pagination.ts" + ], + "editBoundary": "only correct the @example import subpath: createTransformer from @netscript/contracts/transform; filter and pagination symbols from @netscript/contracts/query", + "wiringCorrection": "docs-accuracy is already fail-closed in non-draft CI through .github/workflows/ci.yml to the catalog task and checker spawn; the remaining row-5 gap is explicit named task/step/runbook discoverability, not enforcement absence", + "requiredPlanRepair": "SA-2 must reconcile the full Contracts import inventory, D8/live acceptance/deferrals/S1/path audit/JSR table/PR body, all evaluator N1-N5, and the four-file #1666-before-#1533 rationale before product mutation", + "cycle2Contract": "fresh Tier-A then one separate native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control PLAN-EVAL cycle 2, artifact-only; further FAIL stops for owner escalation" + }, + "freshBrowserDisposition": "N/A_WAIVED_NO_UI_SURFACE_NOT_RUN_PRESERVED", + "planEvaluatorContract": "after fresh Tier-A, exactly one separate native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 over the immutable amended head; evaluator is artifact-only", + "sequencing": "complete #1666 before #1533; defer L-2 lint exclusion ownership until #1663 is terminal", + "implementationSlices": { + "s1": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "6788406036b0ce294262b626b5b3cf0f450df403", + "topicCheckpointSha": "6c183ef16b550e0331a3f5c4401b54bf43e91648", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303486040", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A independently reproduced fail-closed policy refusals, 168 Fresh UI exports plus exactly seven documented non-exports, non-empty structured check/test/lint/fmt selections, docs source format and docs accuracy green, and the unchanged nine-finding Contracts doc-lint baseline red" + }, + "s2": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "47ca22abe94b9d2e54d3778edc8944094b227886", + "topicCheckpointSha": "dbe72c50e", + "scope": "named docs:exports-drift task, docs:accuracy fail-closed child invocation with output preservation, and one Pages workflow step from repository root behind the existing guard; no duplicate execution", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A independently reproduced named-task and aggregate raw exit 0, verified narrowed child permissions, fail-closed output surfacing, one invocation per path, guarded repo-root Pages wiring, and terminal green Pages build" + }, + "s3": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "sourceHeadSha": "47ca22abe94b9d2e54d3778edc8944094b227886", + "evidenceHeadSha": "d095c1260a2474f3ae16cd5b17f3bfcbbada9c94", + "topicCheckpointSha": "18eed10c9", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303605527", + "scope": "run-artifact-only exact-head check/test/quality/architecture/docs/publish receipts, focused drift proof, JSR audit, thirteen-path audit, and byte-identical deno.lock proof; baseline reds remain red", + "validation": "seven unique PASS receipts recompute SUFFICIENT at immutable source head; 4203/0 root tests, 2924-file check, honest Contracts 9 and Fresh UI 123 doc-lint reds, exact pins/JSR findings, ten changed implementation paths within thirteen, lock blob identical, all prohibited/runtime gates NOT_RUN" + } + }, + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete_fail_fix_cycle_1_bounded_test_repair_active", + "implementationEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "47ca22abe94b9d2e54d3778edc8944094b227886", + "implementationEvaluationEvidenceHeadSha": "d095c1260a2474f3ae16cd5b17f3bfcbbada9c94", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "3882ca70-7857-46ca-aa24-8b1ae2664516", + "implementationEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "3882ca70", + "implementationEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_013RnnFDtHQhEbFhJCLbkEsD", + "implementationEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T18:25:26.499Z", + "implementationEvaluationScope": "artifact-only verdict over immutable implementation 47ca22abe and evidence d095c1260; only impl-eval.md plus one structured PR comment; no product mutation, merge, ready flip, relabel, issue close, runtime lease, or repair", + "implementationEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T18:38:01.455Z", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "4c09e9203afee52b43c10dfa1246eb0473ad7e40", + "implementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303665087", + "implementationEvaluationFinding": "three of four committed refusal tests are non-discriminating: NotFound can substitute for reason/mode refusal and OMITS can mask INVENTS; checker behavior and all other acceptance rows independently hold", + "implementationRepairScope": "same original Sol/medium author; exactly .llm/tools/docs/check-exports-drift_test.ts plus existing run artifacts; assert specific refusal causes, use a real fixture directory, prevent OMITS masking INVENTS, mutation-prove all four tests red independently, then re-cut all seven receipts at one new immutable head and stop for fresh Tier-A", + "implementationRepairTopicCheckpointSha": "3c8db8178eb227e87c1ad72c8ccccdafb60c7a40", + "implementationRepairContentHeadSha": "4238670173271bca4281eba7db6c2030d046bc73", + "implementationRepairEvidenceHeadSha": "010da98a230503bb27b46eb0edc5e979929f7fb1", + "implementationRepairEvidenceState": "pushed_with_structured_comment_fresh_tier_a_active", + "implementationRepairCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303770640", + "implementationRepairReceipts": "seven replacement gate receipts bind gitHead == actualGitHead == 423867017 and exit 0; the initial root-test receipt remains append-only exit 1 because a temporary mutation archive contained forbidden command strings, and test-attempt2 is the clean-tree PASS replacement", + "implementationRepairTierAState": "PASS", + "implementationRepairTierATopicCheckpointSha": "0646f429fbea199f4b80075d62a79b3cb646283c", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2State": "complete_pass", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2SourceHeadSha": "4238670173271bca4281eba7db6c2030d046bc73", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2EvidenceHeadSha": "010da98a230503bb27b46eb0edc5e979929f7fb1", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2AgentId": "7a3b4645-5548-42e6-84fa-35c1f90158dd", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2BackgroundAgentId": "7a3b4645", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2RemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01MDMbe68iYvjHBLuUGKZqBS", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2Route": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2CompletedAt": "2026-08-15T19:12:52.602Z", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2Verdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2CommitSha": "ee67d12b4023b62241c2b2aeeec2f27f33b38747", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2CommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303804773", + "readinessState": "revoked_draft_status_impl_after_real_quality_red", + "readinessHeadSha": "ee67d12b4023b62241c2b2aeeec2f27f33b38747", + "readinessPreparedCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303815717", + "acceptanceEvidenceCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303825255", + "acceptanceMirrorDryRun": "PASS at live issue #1296 body f66987e42a7c88f7a1741cfb0fdc5f25f7189686d9c6b43a18e5f9ba4cd14037; five entries mapped; no mutation", + "closeGateCiRunId": 31903523137, + "closeGateCiRunUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/31903523137", + "closeGateCiDisposition": "close-gate failure was a ready-label/mirror race and is rerunnable only after the owned quality repair; the mirror made no #1296 mutation and all five boxes remain unchecked", + "readinessRollbackAt": "2026-08-15T19:23:00.000Z", + "readinessRollbackState": "PR returned to draft; status:ready-merge removed; status:impl restored; impl-eval:skip is present; no merge or issue mutation", + "postEvaluationQualityFinding": "real leaf-owned agent-docs corpus freshness failure: docs/site/reference/fresh-ui/index.md changed but prose.json.gz and provenance.json were stale; verify the generator-owned cascade into CLI/MCP publish mirrors before amendment approval", + "postEvaluationRecovery": "same original Sol/medium author must first push a plan-only exact-path generator-cascade rescope, receive fresh internals Tier-A, regenerate only verified owned mirrors, recut applicable exact-head receipts, receive a second Tier-A, then undergo a fresh delta IMPL-EVAL before readiness can be restored", + "sa3PlanAmendmentHeadSha": "f98cfabacb6ac362e8fcc8e56b180b55aa69c339", + "sa3PlanAmendmentCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303922392", + "sa3PlanTierAState": "PASS", + "sa3PlanTierAProof": "four exact generator-owned outputs verified in isolated base/head scratch; MCP export corpus excluded by byte-identical base/head pre-existing red; ceiling 17 with path 18 a rescope; CLI and MCP publish deltas plus idempotence/full recut set are explicit", + "sa3AuthorizedGeneratedPaths": [ + ".llm/assets/agent-docs/prose.json.gz", + ".llm/assets/agent-docs/provenance.json", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-docs.generated.ts", + "packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts" + ], + "sa3GenerationState": "canonical_generation_complete_recovery_evidence_pushed_second_tier_a_active", + "sa4GeneratedContentHeadSha": "46528ae4c71b3744f0af64bd749d01d831f70c89", + "sa4InitialEvidenceHeadSha": "440fa65cab115a167f8f8d06abffcaf8202d8096", + "sa4InitialEvidenceCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304008204", + "sa4InitialRootTest": "RED preserved append-only: 4202 passed, 1 failed, 19 ignored; forbidden-commands scanner found the internals supervisor's ignored unscoped hook transcript, not generated product", + "sa4Quarantine": { + "source": ".llm/tmp/claude/hooks/unscoped/events.jsonl", + "destination": "/home/codex/.claude/jobs/f7691917/quarantine/sa4-hooks-unscoped/events.jsonl", + "sha256Before": "d0251bc2f8c78814724cb2e6c2460102260a39aadb3a21551b81244efbaceab2", + "sha256After": "d0251bc2f8c78814724cb2e6c2460102260a39aadb3a21551b81244efbaceab2", + "recoverable": true, + "scannerChanged": false + }, + "sa4TestAttempt2": "PASS at unchanged content head 46528ae4c: 4203 passed, 0 failed, 19 ignored, duration 244980ms; original red retained", + "sa4RecoveryEvidenceHeadSha": "b67414f4f26d53f00fc50adf3a5787d3bffae077", + "sa4RecoveryCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304045867", + "sa4SecondTierAState": "PASS", + "sa4SecondTierATopicCheckpointSha": "8933f58f2b435652e317fc46ea77827a523a4710", + "sa4SecondTierAFinding": "generated cascade, receipt coherence, quarantine attribution, path ceiling, lock identity, publication selection, known reds, and NOT_RUN boundaries pass; idempotence carried from author evidence and explicitly assigned to delta evaluation for independent re-derivation", + "sa4DeltaEvaluationState": "complete_pass", + "sa4DeltaEvaluatorAgentId": "f281b8cf-f4bb-4125-a0ba-d79b6a8e11ad", + "sa4DeltaEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "f281b8cf", + "sa4DeltaEvaluatorPid": 793975, + "sa4DeltaEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "session_01UDGunAVYYPRC6KBNxEwZWA", + "sa4DeltaEvaluatorRemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01UDGunAVYYPRC6KBNxEwZWA", + "sa4DeltaEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "sa4DeltaEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T20:22:51.101Z", + "sa4DeltaEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T20:32:17.000Z", + "sa4DeltaEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "sa4DeltaEvaluatorCommitSha": "0d4c82d6e4bd327abd88eb8b80e7a7acd20ea4aa", + "sa4DeltaEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304103041", + "sa4DeltaEvaluationFinding": "all five #1296 acceptance rows independently pass; the four-output cascade is two-run idempotent with no fifth output; root red/pass receipts, quarantine attribution, 14-of-17 scope, lock identity, MCP bounded selection, baseline reds, and NOT_RUN boundaries are honest", + "postDeltaMainConflictState": "current main 0ef48c2ec advances the same four generated publication outputs through #1665, so GitHub reports CONFLICTING; read-only merge-tree found no hand-authored overlap outside those generator-owned outputs", + "postDeltaMainRefreshTopicCheckpointSha": "268544516", + "postDeltaMainRefreshState": "complete_pushed_fresh_tier_a_pass_integration_delta_eval_pass", + "postDeltaMainRefreshContract": "merge current main preserving history, resolve the four generated conflicts only through the canonical full generator cascade, prove both main and #1666 contributions plus two-run idempotence/no fifth output, recut exact-head receipts, then stop for fresh internals Tier-A and a fresh delta evaluator before readiness", + "postDeltaMainRefreshContentHeadSha": "8c03d862931b64573df9a4bac76ebf266e0ec175", + "postDeltaMainRefreshEvidenceHeadSha": "021c7ffc62cea5b0f6728ddb8ee377393a647f44", + "postDeltaMainRefreshCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304205247", + "postDeltaMainRefreshTierAState": "PASS", + "postDeltaMainRefreshTierATopicCheckpointSha": "6658ad9c060e37f02ff12c8f0525126f36f825c3", + "postDeltaMainRefreshProof": "history-preserving merge parents are prior evaluator 0d4c82d6e and current main 0ef48c2ec; exactly four generated conflicts were resolved by the canonical cascade; both source contributions coexist; two cascade cycles are idempotent with no fifth output; 12 exact-content-head receipts pass; 14-of-17 path scope and deno.lock identity hold", + "integrationDeltaEvaluationState": "complete_pass", + "integrationDeltaEvaluatorAgentId": "be3774eb-9bc8-4cd1-bcd8-9cc59fd2a0a8", + "integrationDeltaEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "be3774eb", + "integrationDeltaEvaluatorPid": 807626, + "integrationDeltaEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV", + "integrationDeltaEvaluatorRemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV", + "integrationDeltaEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "integrationDeltaEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T21:03:05.052Z", + "integrationDeltaEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T21:12:10.000Z", + "integrationDeltaEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "integrationDeltaEvaluatorCommitSha": "05ac90d00706d4bd9f3d93a59ab58bcdbfea5909", + "integrationDeltaEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304256350", + "integrationDeltaEvaluationFinding": "history-preserving union, exact four generated outputs, two-run convergence, twelve exact-content-head receipts, 14-of-17 scope, lock identity, prior reds, issue #1296 acceptance, and NOT_RUN boundaries independently pass; the older JSR audit timestamp is non-blocking because package configuration and exports are unchanged and publish-dry-run is head-bound", + "integrationDeltaEvaluationScope": "artifact-only judgment of the current-main integration delta at content 8c03d8629 with evidence 021c7ffc6; re-derive history preservation, exact four-output generated union, two-run convergence, receipt binding, scope/lock/known-red honesty, and NOT_RUN boundaries; no runtime, readiness, issue mutation, or merge", + "readinessAttempt2HeadSha": "05ac90d00706d4bd9f3d93a59ab58bcdbfea5909", + "readinessAttempt2Mirror": "live close-gate run 31908897973 passed and checked all five acceptance rows on open issue #1296", + "readinessAttempt2CloseGateRunUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/31908897973", + "readinessAttempt2QualityRunUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/31908898023", + "readinessAttempt2QualityFinding": "changed-source quality failed on explicit-any at check-exports-drift.ts:356 and unsafe-cast at line 372; both are leaf-owned", + "readinessAttempt2RollbackAt": "2026-08-15T21:18:24.000Z", + "readinessAttempt2RollbackState": "PR returned to draft; status:ready-merge removed; status:impl restored; acceptance boxes remain checked but issue stays open; no merge", + "postIntegrationQualityRepairContract": "same original Sol/medium author repairs only the two type-safety findings without allowances or scanner weakening, runs focused and changed-source gates, commits and pushes, then fresh internals Tier-A precedes a fresh delta evaluator/readiness", + "postIntegrationQualityRepairHeadSha": "e357938df82b2a87ccc69ac3217c165c16572930", + "postIntegrationQualityRepairCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304327917", + "postIntegrationQualityRepairProof": "exportsObj is an unknown boundary narrowed before enumeration; cast-free export-target union preserves string/default/missing/falsy behavior, deliberately maps target-level null to empty, fails closed on malformed top-level values, and adds discriminating coverage without allowance or scanner change; generated cascade and deno.lock are byte-identical", + "postIntegrationQualityRepairTierAState": "PASS", + "postIntegrationQualityRepairTierATopicCheckpointSha": "138ad7436acde576fcea9ff0c44c122320c176e1", + "postIntegrationQualityRepairTierAProof": "fresh internals review rejected its own mis-scoped repository-mode false green, then reproduced exact changed-files mode with a non-empty two-file selection and zero findings; focused and full gates pass and all evaluator/red history is intact", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5State": "complete_pass", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5SourceHeadSha": "e357938df82b2a87ccc69ac3217c165c16572930", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5AgentId": "dc433b8d-a72c-4d8f-ab50-b28a566d3968", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5BackgroundAgentId": "dc433b8d", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5BridgeSessionId": "cse_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5RemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5Route": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5GrantedAt": "2026-08-15T21:36:02.176Z", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5CompletedAt": "2026-08-15T21:50:06.393Z", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5Verdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5EvaluatorCommitSha": "92988da30a4468f5ea77ea4e5a3e243469f92e52", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5CommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304391856", + "implementationEvaluationCycle5Proof": "independent changed-files quality selected all nine changed source paths with zero findings; 12 focused tests and six targeted mutations pass; malformed top-level values fail closed; root check 2925 files and root test 4217/0/19 pass; the four publication outputs and deno.lock remain byte-identical to integration content", + "readinessAttempt3HeadSha": "92988da30a4468f5ea77ea4e5a3e243469f92e52", + "readinessAttempt3State": "ready_non_draft_exact_head_ci_active", + "readinessAttempt3Contract": "PR body rewritten to final repair/evaluator heads; zero unanswered review threads; live mirror dry-run and local close-gate PASS; status:ready-merge applied while draft with attributed impl-eval:skip retained; merge only after every exact-head check, including changed-source code-quality, is terminal green or an intentional policy skip", + "readinessAttempt3CommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304405717", + "readinessAttempt3CiRunId": 31910676720, + "readinessAttempt3QualityRunId": 31910676700, + "sa4NextGate": "wait for terminal truthful exact-head CI at 92988da30, then coordinator merge and shipped-label reconciliation only if zero current failures remain", + "expensiveGateContract": "no runtime lease; scaffold.runtime and fresh-browser are matrix n/a for this checker/docs/JSDoc/task/workflow-only leaf", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "comparison-vs-pages", + "lane": "docs", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "e090f894ff3682405a36e4f896ffd2cc16f9a1f8", + "currentPrHeadSha": "615786c1a93c39e7f6b9a1b40b5cee39b163ff8a", + "issueNumbers": [], + "ownerDirectedIssueNumbers": [ + 1659 + ], + "ownerDirectedPostFreeze": true, + "implementerAgentId": "01a0047a-aceb-7b53-9ba1-9191eedaaf1a", + "branch": "docs/comparison-vs-pages", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs-vs", + "prNumber": 1660, + "implementationState": "merged_and_published", + "slice1HeadSha": "efaa77b97b2ba02d356898cab967b0b48cf92547", + "slice2HeadSha": "34b4d69755e8cc57d3f05c9a36099a226160aeda", + "slice3HeadSha": "94568ab94f27c2167e2f6bfdd71bb80905857bb2", + "slice4HeadSha": "0b67ef39e25805d68056ea76978cb69c2968a36c", + "tierARepairHeadSha": "504de3f67f21e27b06695e9099fb6f752a827e9a", + "replacementGeneratedAssetsHeadSha": "e35824d413cafc8324291dd832f301a0be186163", + "censusInvariantRepairHeadSha": "615786c1a93c39e7f6b9a1b40b5cee39b163ff8a", + "tierAState": "PASS", + "tierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1660#issuecomment-5301575337", + "readinessState": "merged", + "formalImplementationEvaluation": "owner-authorized skip; independent Tier-A is the only review", + "mergeCommitSha": "729386c567bfbd0b8c7f86a4ed09348f0a8a4ad8", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T09:25:56.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "closed_8_of_8_status_shipped", + "pagesDeploymentRunId": 31876977060, + "pagesDeploymentState": "PASS", + "publishedUrls": [ + "https://rickylabs.github.io/netscript/comparisons/frontend/", + "https://rickylabs.github.io/netscript/comparisons/backend/" + ], + "reviewContentionIncident": { + "state": "fully_recovered", + "restoredStashSha": "7eb4ed16d6944c1d1c904895bcb76b4361ad8a57", + "dataLoss": false, + "freshExclusiveOwnerReview": true + }, + "tierAFindings": [ + "add honest backend architectural estimates", + "add a second backend argument proving same-contract imports without a generated client", + "verify the public baseContract chain with deno doc", + "type-check both central NetScript snippets with uncommitted scratch fixtures" + ], + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "lane": "fixes", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "284dda90a17a13a7e5e8e9834e5411b58887131b", + "currentPrHeadSha": "f74695bc4d0b916ed52ae922d96263f00c5ca6df", + "issueNumbers": [ + 1448 + ], + "implementerAgentId": "01a0048d-61b0-76a2-8117-5f8ce0466495", + "branch": "fix/ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-ai-mcp-pool", + "prNumber": 1661, + "implementationState": "merged_and_lifecycle_normalized", + "scopeBlockerHeadSha": "1d4533462a088ad902ac7dd71be88764463fcd5d", + "scopeRulingTopicHeadSha": "df20bb5a694ad95afd33ff5ca4f141a4199182f5", + "scopeRulingLeafArtifactSha": "6db182503b219d76c7db23f89c71ec9e467c2f40", + "amendedFiles": [ + "packages/ai/tests/mcp_test.ts", + "packages/ai/src/ports/mcp-transport.ts", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/adapters/base-transport.ts", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/adapters/stdio-transport.ts", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/adapters/streamable-http-transport.ts", + "packages/ai/mcp.ts", + "packages/ai/README.md" + ], + "amendment2Contract": "readResource remains optional on McpTransportPort for packages/fresh compatibility, but is required and abort-aware on BaseMcpTransport and both published wrappers; stop(options) forwards the signal through both wrappers; cross-package Fresh check is mandatory", + "publicContract": "additive synchronous I/O-free per-server snapshot keyed by serverId with McpConnectionState and last error; cancellable close takes a signal options bag; pool.stop settles per server", + "implementationHeadSha": "3a4bc66c4832baf8f209e47cc08c3a336e2ff100", + "tierAState": "PASS_AFTER_FIX_CYCLE_1", + "tierASignoffHeadSha": "e3c74d7aaf3b7734b5a44a5be248c01f004c21e5", + "tierACommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1661#issuecomment-5301585728", + "crossPackageFreshCheck": "PASS: 197 files, 0 failed batches", + "formalImplementationEvaluation": "cycle 1 complete with FAIL_FIX; bounded F-1 repair active on the preserved author thread", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "cb917802-ee26-4b89-86b9-0eee33c7de1b", + "implementationEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "cb917802", + "implementationEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "session_01Kwmr8XjoznnQsHUnkmfcnV", + "implementationEvaluatorSourceHeadSha": "e3c74d7aaf3b7734b5a44a5be248c01f004c21e5", + "implementationEvaluationCycle": 1, + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "8d6b4726cf6663ff3ca1a3c5f9a6fe1d20d300e9", + "tierAWithdrawalHeadSha": "1bdb09e1387583415928da0867ceb321d1e2e178", + "repairContract": "decouple the registration/discovery signal from later registered tool calls; prove calls succeed after registration abort while retaining discovery-abort coverage; align README startup-deadline guidance", + "repairRedHeadSha": "59eca06470932a4beb90d82ba8c4d3bd2eed17ae", + "repairGreenHeadSha": "e4944309361fe18efea20be8a3df364bb8754d82", + "repairTierASignoffHeadSha": "df05344166adaeb2b8e2f2f6ec741e1032d29045", + "repairTierAState": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2State": "complete", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2SourceHeadSha": "df05344166adaeb2b8e2f2f6ec741e1032d29045", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle2AgentId": "eb7149da-1689-44af-970e-ddd6e78022fa", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle2BackgroundAgentId": "eb7149da", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle2BridgeSessionId": "cse_01CaAEKsH35CP2QgfNUVdXK1", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle2Route": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2Verdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle2CommitSha": "4766b258f0d61108e4240720365b9ab078f6a111", + "implementationEvaluationCycle2CommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1661#issuecomment-5301708486", + "computedImportRepairHeadSha": "45aca4adcd35dd6a9b825db449284e400171a533", + "computedImportRepairTierASignoffHeadSha": "de89440119ba45822f0bdc8350838088a6f04140", + "computedImportRepairTierAState": "PASS", + "computedImportRepairRootTest": "PASS: 4152 passed, 19 ignored, 0 failed", + "implementationEvaluationCycle3State": "complete", + "implementationEvaluationCycle3SourceHeadSha": "de89440119ba45822f0bdc8350838088a6f04140", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle3AgentId": "8a0ff845-1d0a-43d6-ae3c-03b4158f7943", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle3BackgroundAgentId": "8a0ff845", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle3BridgeSessionId": "cse_013K3BZ2ydVkYzXt6vgcxTJX", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle3Route": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluationCycle3CompletedAt": "2026-08-15T10:44:56.894Z", + "implementationEvaluationCycle3Verdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluatorCycle3CommitSha": "f74695bc4d0b916ed52ae922d96263f00c5ca6df", + "implementationEvaluationCycle3CommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1661#issuecomment-5301873258", + "readinessState": "complete", + "readinessChecks": "21 terminal current-head checks: success or policy skip, zero failures/active; zero review threads; corrected PR body; MERGEABLE/CLEAN", + "mergeCommitSha": "baf1cdf67a4e931af17b4772ddf6101f36152184", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T10:54:05.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "#1448 closed; PR #1661 and issue #1448 both have sole status:shipped", + "ciFailure": { + "state": "resolved_repair_under_formal_evaluation", + "runId": 31878428521, + "testedHeadSha": "973fae54cc4d1ebc348abb5372b1d855cd8b3139", + "artifact": "ci-check-test-gate-receipts-31878428521-1", + "result": "4151 passed, 1 failed, 14 ignored", + "failingTest": "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/plugin/workspace-mutator_test.ts:261 — root-level scaffold runtime imports resolve in both package-source modes", + "cause": "literal optional @tanstack imports violated the computed-specifier packaging invariant", + "repairOwner": "preserved Codex author 01a0048d-61b0-76a2-8117-5f8ce0466495", + "repairBoundary": "restore both computed @tanstack specifiers in tanstack-connector.ts; keep the CLI assertion intact; fresh Tier-A and proportionate IMPL-EVAL required after push" + }, + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "lane": "fixes", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "baf1cdf67a4e931af17b4772ddf6101f36152184", + "currentPrHeadSha": "ac274a46489b9ab746e5be22ca71300ed94eaadb", + "issueNumbers": [1637, 1619, 1620, 1598, 1623], + "implementerAgentId": "01a00516-2033-7ed3-936a-a616cee47447", + "implementerRoute": "openai / gpt-5.6-sol / medium / approval never / dangerFullAccess", + "branch": "fix/sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-sdk-cache", + "prNumber": 1665, + "implementationState": "merged_after_all_product_and_generated_asset_evaluations_passed", + "dispatchTopicHeadSha": "7a81326a6", + "planGate": "research and contract decisions only; open one draft PR and stop before implementation; PLAN-EVAL is required", + "declaredSurface": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-provider.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/cache-store.ts" + ], + "authorizedAdditionalSurface": [ + "packages/sdk/README.md", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-provider_test.ts", + "packages/sdk/tests/cache/cache-telemetry_test.ts", + "packages/sdk/tests/cache/cache-query-kv-limit_test.ts", + "docs/site/web-layer/query-bridge.md" + ], + "scopeRuling": "the four acceptance/proof paths and the one exact published page quoting the changed diagnostic are granted; unrelated SDK doc-lint remediation is not added to this five-issue leaf; Tier-A must bind the existing named diagnostics as a strict zero-new-diagnostic baseline or reject the plan", + "tierAPlanState": "PASS_AFTER_FAIL_FIX_REPAIR", + "tierAPlanHeadSha": "ee1b44c6d401a9edb9c8690870ea2d9151f8f504", + "tierAPlanTopicCheckpointSha": "318bd087c", + "tierAPlanFindingState": "T-1 through T-4 closed: request-local span deferral, per-report invalidation staging, exact named red doc-lint baseline, and normalized published diagnostic quote inside the exact five-path grant", + "planRepairHeadSha": "92bf26e11a77121d899bfb3592b62b72a7503bec", + "finalPlanRepairHeadSha": "ee1b44c6d401a9edb9c8690870ea2d9151f8f504", + "planEvaluationState": "complete_pass", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "0287ccbe-2740-45ee-b378-33d1c1c59429", + "planEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "0287ccbe", + "planEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01GaNTjv6oY6MaxnKHH1ZfrB", + "planEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "planEvaluatorRemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01GaNTjv6oY6MaxnKHH1ZfrB", + "planEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "ee1b44c6d401a9edb9c8690870ea2d9151f8f504", + "planEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T11:42:12.000Z", + "planEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T11:47:45.000Z", + "planEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "planEvaluatorCommitSha": "cd5193b66175b981f32e8ca5abd8b41f913068c7", + "planEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5302080198", + "implementationSlices": { + "s1": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "0e4e26c51e9dcbac7dbd0e30eb5db19130e4d7d0", + "topicCheckpointSha": "f6f8f0fcb", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5302163687", + "scope": "fail-safe evidence validation and bounded namespace cardinality/prologue in three cache product files plus cache telemetry tests and SDK README", + "constraints": "partway invalidation rollback, normal data return on malformed evidence, request-local first overflow, composite no-admission until real operation, try/finally reset, internal helpers stay off cache/mod.ts", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A re-executed structured SDK check/lint/fmt with zero findings, cache tests 26/0, full SDK suite 65/0, and both raw doc-lint surfaces with exactly the six pinned red diagnostics and zero new or vanished findings" + }, + "s2": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "1cf76c6dd691378eddbbd9cd3c8a82d50c30fa2f", + "topicCheckpointSha": "cc86f480e", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5302265198", + "scope": "post-loader real Deno KV persistence-limit isolation in cache-query.ts plus the new cache-query-kv-limit_test.ts and run artifacts", + "constraints": "real in-memory Deno KV RED-before/GREEN-after, exact payload return and uncached miss, cache.write error evidence, awaited closeKv/resetKv teardown, lookup/queryFn/setCachedData remain fail-loud", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A independently reproduced the real pre-fix Deno KV rejection, focused 1/0 and SDK 66/0 green, exact fail-loud boundaries, awaited singleton teardown, root test 4203/0/19, and root check with zero diagnostics" + }, + "s3": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "9a26c107afa75bf1f38b78fe96c6df533b156c36", + "topicCheckpointSha": "aa4749da4", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5302765500", + "scope": "module-identity provider diagnostic, exact normalized Query Bridge quotation proof, and mandatory-evidence CacheStore JSDoc in four authorized paths plus run artifacts", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A reproduced SDK 66/0, provider 1/0, root 4203/0/19, uncached root check over 2925 files, exact six named red doc diagnostics, exact pins, quality, arch, SDK publish dry-run, and JSR audit; surface:diff 517 and F-DOCT-5 13-child findings reproduce at base and remain explicitly red" + } + }, + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete_pass", + "implementationEvaluationCycle": 1, + "implementationEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "9a26c107afa75bf1f38b78fe96c6df533b156c36", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "1fbb1c07-3b05-4d90-ab9c-c827c5aca2d5", + "implementationEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "1fbb1c07", + "implementationEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01JePyQuiERLe8GeWWKQp5wL", + "implementationEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluatorRemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01JePyQuiERLe8GeWWKQp5wL", + "implementationEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T15:09:24.269Z", + "implementationEvaluationStartedAt": "2026-08-15T15:10:18.519Z", + "implementationEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T15:21:12.696Z", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "0fed4d7ffb8c655a00846fbf545805bd2e184fb0", + "implementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5302881354", + "implementationEvaluationScope": "artifact-only impl-eval.md; evaluated product tree remains immutable at 9a26c107a", + "readinessState": "complete", + "readinessDisposition": "exact-head checks terminal green or intentionally skipped, review threads empty, sole lifecycle status advanced to ready-merge, and coordinator squash merge complete", + "mergeCommitSha": "3e8e146a4aedf8ee0afec15c83ddaefc171c71f9", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T16:29:46.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "PR #1665 shipped; issues #1598, #1619, #1620, #1623, and #1637 closed automatically from verified closing keywords", + "readinessRunId": 31892668157, + "readinessFailureJobId": 95031217843, + "readinessFailure": "quality failed at Agent docs corpus freshness because the authorized docs/site/web-layer/query-bridge.md edit feeds the checked-in agent-docs bundle; prose.json.gz and provenance.json are stale", + "postEvaluationRepair": { + "state": "exact_two_asset_repair_tier_a_and_delta_eval_pass_but_transitive_embedded_barrel_dependency_found_by_readiness", + "scopeAmendmentTopicCheckpointSha": "ef396767a", + "authorizedPaths": [ + ".llm/assets/agent-docs/prose.json.gz", + ".llm/assets/agent-docs/provenance.json" + ], + "tierAState": "PASS", + "tierATopicCheckpointSha": "7fe2f433e", + "repairHeadSha": "7549d9fc052e604212f12e617b05085a061f9e0b", + "deltaEvaluationState": "PASS", + "deltaEvaluatorAgentId": "08eb7184-7a14-4976-8421-1e4d5b13163a", + "deltaEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01Jc8aRcLQFVyVWKogq6SaFC", + "deltaEvaluatorCommitSha": "72d57229f28e3010c43d76fbecd3b3082680804f", + "deltaEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5302983190", + "unrelatedQueueFlakeIssue": 1667 + }, + "embeddedAgentDocsBarrelRepair": { + "state": "complete_exact_one_product_path_plus_run_artifacts", + "readinessRunId": 31893659579, + "readinessFailureJobId": 95033583015, + "failure": "Generated asset freshness runs check:assets-barrel; regeneration changes packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-docs.generated.ts from the old embedded corpus to the fresh prose asset", + "scopeAmendmentTopicCheckpointSha": "215aae4b2", + "authorizedPaths": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-docs.generated.ts" + ], + "repairHeadSha": "27a64ea4c122312e46ffc9602509c191bcd0dd71", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5303037805", + "requiredReview": "fresh fixes Tier-A plus one proportionate asset-chain fidelity delta evaluator before readiness resumes" + }, + "publishAssetsRepair": { + "state": "complete_exact_one_product_path_plus_run_artifacts_fresh_closure_tier_a_pass", + "scopeAmendmentTopicCheckpointSha": "92ea9f8298ce6a9cd448233a98d56b063ff14c53", + "authorizedPaths": [ + "packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts" + ], + "repairHeadSha": "9a2c74c41990c1e2a56c9714834fff97feb63466", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5303077056", + "tierAState": "PASS", + "tierATopicCheckpointSha": "cbd32230ec479c9abfd5e7ff075eca780c97e233", + "tierAProof": "check:agent-docs-prose, check:assets-barrel, and check:publish-assets all pass simultaneously at 9a2c74c41 and the detached proof tree remains clean after all three generators", + "finalDeltaEvaluationState": "PASS", + "finalDeltaEvaluatorAgentId": "262ef8e1-1907-4c83-a2cd-4af142b8a95a", + "finalDeltaEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01E3QfD1wkvb1naZKS6m7bp2", + "finalDeltaEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "finalDeltaEvaluatorCommitSha": "ac274a46489b9ab746e5be22ca71300ed94eaadb", + "finalDeltaEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1665#issuecomment-5303120561", + "finalDeltaEvaluationProof": "fresh evaluator independently reproduced simultaneous byte-exact freshness across the prose corpus, CLI barrel, and MCP publish asset; confirmed the same provenance payload, no fifth branch-caused mirror, authorized source-only movement, and all carried reds unchanged", + "generatorOrder": "gen:publish-assets must run only after the CLI agent-docs barrel repair lands because the publish generator consumes that barrel", + "closureProof": "exactly four branch-caused links; check:mcp-export-corpus is red at both branch and base and is unrelated; check:emitted-samples passes; no fifth checked-in mirror", + "historicalPrecedent": "PR #1652 already recorded the same four-path cascade; failure to reuse that known closure is a coordinator/process miss" + }, + "acceptanceState": "all 5 PR definition-of-done boxes and all 13 issue acceptance boxes on #1598/#1619/#1620/#1623 checked from verified evidence; #1637 defines no boxes", + "ciSkipSmoke": "plan/run-artifact-only PR #1665 skipped check-test, quality, desktop-native-linux, both scaffold runtimes, scaffold-static, deps-report, surface-diff, close-gate, and lane visibility checks as classified", + "crossPackageGateContract": "repo-root test or every asserting package gate must be named; package-local green is insufficient for SDK source/public-surface changes", + "expensiveGateContract": "no Aspire, Docker, or e2e:cli gate is currently load-bearing or authorized", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "sdk-cached-entry-swr", + "lane": "fixes", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "3e8e146a4aedf8ee0afec15c83ddaefc171c71f9", + "currentPrHeadSha": "9aa54ae2d4f53c705b0309ed472abf7bbccebe41", + "issueNumbers": [1461], + "implementerAgentId": "01a00646-82a9-7ec2-88e7-16dea98a58fa", + "implementerRoute": "openai / gpt-5.6-sol / medium / approval never / dangerFullAccess", + "branch": "fix/sdk-cached-entry-swr", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-cached-entry", + "prNumber": 1669, + "implementationState": "merged_and_issue_shipped", + "planHeadSha": "23db20f301d06ed1e4a9a65cbbf64349f89cb8c0", + "dispatchTopicHeadSha": "f9bb928cedeaf91174db4e70f877143028481232", + "planGate": "research and contract decisions only; resolve the stale docs paths, choose the supported API boundary, open one draft PR, and stop before implementation; PLAN-EVAL is required", + "scopeRuling": "authorize docs/site/tutorials/live-dashboard/03-sdk-cache-first-query.md as the exact second docs source because it repeats the same false getCachedEntry background-refresh claim; no third docs source; verify the existing four-mirror generated closure before implementation", + "tierAPlanState": "PASS_AFTER_T1", + "tierAPlanHeadSha": "23db20f301d06ed1e4a9a65cbbf64349f89cb8c0", + "tierAPlanTopicCheckpointSha": "f71e860f907d8cfad881d863f9e69489d3c106ea", + "tierAPlanFinding": "PASS: explicit dispositions cover tutorial lines 13, 15, 32, 75, 76, 80, 94, 100, and 107 plus both service-page claims; callable action and KV-only metadata read are separated page-wide; all prior concurrency, #1665, doc-lint, and four-mirror contracts remain intact", + "planEvaluationState": "complete_pass", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "01f0eda8-24fe-41b0-919e-7426579ab868", + "planEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "01f0eda8", + "planEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01SWnk7LwvoLaamvEwR5WLfX", + "planEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "planEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "23db20f301d06ed1e4a9a65cbbf64349f89cb8c0", + "planEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T17:23:00.000Z", + "planEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T17:34:00.000Z", + "planEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "planEvaluatorCommitSha": "d555cc9719fc81b7b5d6656471132c1a921fd5cf", + "planEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1669#issuecomment-5303412171", + "planEvaluationCorrection": "docs-accuracy does not bind the S2 page-level chapter-3 sentence; that acceptance remains manual Tier-A plus IMPL-EVAL evidence unless separately scoped tooling changes are authorized", + "implementationSlices": { + "s1": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass_after_transparent_repair", + "headSha": "e100ea205b16a8ed22dbdb6b587212a852d6c416", + "initialHeadSha": "e05a541455b657832474fea1bc1edfce5b685080", + "topicCheckpointSha": "c01f321411e0cba17e1ba6a861040921030df1f7", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1669#issuecomment-5303493013", + "repairCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1669#issuecomment-5303528330", + "authorizedSurface": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts", + "packages/sdk/tests/cache/cache-query_test.ts", + ".llm/runs/fix-sdk-cached-entry-swr--0.0.7-wave5/**" + ], + "constraints": "policy-aware persistence-complete in-flight ownership; background-owned write failure resolves fetched data to a foreground joiner; rejection only on fetch failure; deterministic sleep-free two-reader proof with exactly one refresh; useful JSDoc/structure restored and F-1 closed by one coherent shared cache-entry read path", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A executed 5/5 focused and 68/68 SDK tests, confirmed sleep-free A2/A3 proof, 497 documented lines with no F-1 and only pre-existing F-16, clean/pushed PR head, and honest append-only audit correction" + }, + "s2": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "sourceHeadSha": "eba0b092416831f5fada679a1c21247d065ca521", + "evidenceHeadSha": "9aa54ae2d4f53c705b0309ed472abf7bbccebe41", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1669#issuecomment-5303754598", + "scopeAmendmentHeadSha": "ef3e43f06c807356aeabfc172427239bcafd5144", + "scopeAmendmentTierATopicCheckpointSha": "684c37d63", + "scope": "two authorized docs sources, query-factory regression, exactly four generated mirrors, and run artifacts; page-level sentence is manual Tier-A plus IMPL-EVAL evidence rather than docs-accuracy proof", + "constraints": "apply all nine tutorial dispositions plus Services SDK claim, preserve callable-action SWR truth and A4 default-versus-preferFreshOnStale posture, regenerate the four-link cascade only, report pinned reds without repair, then stop for fresh Tier-A", + "blockingFinding": "executable factory proof shows pre-existing cache-query condition fetches fresh non-expired entries whenever preferFreshOnStale is true because the flag is evaluated before the fresh return", + "scopeAmendment": "plan-only first: add exactly packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts; preserve expired-entry precedence and make the flag block only when !isFresh; query-factory_test.ts is already authorized; no cache-query_test.ts or other source without a fresh necessity ruling; preserve dirty docs/test work and commit only amendment artifacts before mutation", + "resumeGate": "passed: exact five-artifact amendment, correct predicate and baseline attribution, factory-only proof sufficient, S1 A2/A3 and 497/no-F1 preserved; same author may make one predicate correction then continue S2", + "validation": "factory 6/0, SDK 69/0, root tests 4206/0/19, root check 2925 files/25 batches/0 failures, SDK check/lint/fmt, quality, architecture, docs source/accuracy, root and package publish dry-runs, JSR audit/specifiers, and all three committed-head generated freshness gates pass; three-plus-three doc-lint diagnostics and surface-diff major/524 remain honestly red; no runtime lease" + } + }, + "acceptanceFocus": "prove stale-while-revalidate with exactly one refresh for concurrent stale readers while carrying the four-link generated-doc asset cascade and known #1667/#1668 reds", + "implementationTierAState": "PASS", + "implementationTierATopicCheckpointSha": "a374977d8a4ad7af68919afa508ec1107d7f4221", + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete_pass_cycle_1", + "implementationEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "eba0b092416831f5fada679a1c21247d065ca521", + "implementationEvaluationEvidenceHeadSha": "9aa54ae2d4f53c705b0309ed472abf7bbccebe41", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "f40814ce-5b41-49ae-8cf2-e65014de01de", + "implementationEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "f40814ce", + "implementationEvaluatorRemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01CMrdm9P2YwHxiNCT49C4Hf", + "implementationEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T19:24:37.126Z", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "313cc08d572ea7db1764abf2efdcc11f7a63abde", + "implementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1669#issuecomment-5303850473", + "implementationEvaluationScopeResult": "artifact-only: exactly impl-eval.md added after evidence 9aa54ae2d; local, remote, and PR heads equal 313cc08d5; no review threads", + "readinessState": "complete_merged", + "readinessHeadSha": "313cc08d572ea7db1764abf2efdcc11f7a63abde", + "acceptanceEvidenceCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1669#issuecomment-5303873817", + "acceptanceMirrorDryRun": "PASS at live issue #1461 body 20b6370fdf3ed8491c30a052c75b6a6c33b529b4a278c8a39a6243847f47387e; six entries mapped; no mutation", + "readinessLabels": "status:ready-merge plus impl-eval:skip applied and verified live while draft before ready-for-review", + "closeGateCiRunId": 31904125478, + "closeGateCiRunUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/31904125478", + "closeGateCiResult": "PASS: mirror checked all six #1461 boxes; close-gate, quality, check-test, and core CI lane visibility terminal success", + "mergeCommitSha": "0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T19:39:50.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "#1461 closed at 2026-08-15T19:39:51Z with six of six boxes checked and exactly status:shipped; PR #1669 exactly status:shipped", + "advisoryDisposition": "non-blocking cross-page consistency and warm-stale persistence-failure docs caveat remain outside the evaluated scope; filed as Backlog/Triage issue #1670 from reviewed draft 70307f47c", + "advisoryFollowUpIssueUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1670", + "nextSerialLeaf": "sdk-typed-error-channel (#1350) active plan-only; #1348 remains open as implementation umbrella but its RFC Stage-0 prerequisite is satisfied", + "nextSerialDispatch": { + "issueNumber": 1350, + "branch": "fix/sdk-typed-error-channel", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-typed-error", + "baseHeadSha": "0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb", + "implementerAgentId": "01a006f3-ae2d-7941-bd17-2ac71dd3d0f0", + "implementerRoute": "openai / gpt-5.6-sol / medium / plan-only" + }, + "expensiveGateContract": "no runtime lease during research or planning", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "sdk-typed-error-channel", + "lane": "fixes", + "phase": "implementing", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb", + "currentPrHeadSha": "db8aadd9542c38a305efffbd7017c56d0abf4e01", + "issueNumbers": [1350], + "implementerAgentId": "01a006f3-ae2d-7941-bd17-2ac71dd3d0f0", + "implementerRoute": "openai / gpt-5.6-sol / medium / approval never / dangerFullAccess", + "branch": "fix/sdk-typed-error-channel", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-typed-error", + "prNumber": 1671, + "implementationState": "slice_4_stopped_on_leaf_owned_doc_lint_red_plan_maintenance_rerouted_after_account_wide_codex_quota", + "initialPlanHeadSha": "c7a6f3d32009cfe9344ab8ed613f1c54c205b07f", + "initialPlanCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1671#issuecomment-5303978621", + "scopeOwnershipRuling": "approve packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts as sixth path; deny packages/contracts/src/public/mod.ts and every NetScriptProcedureMeta definition/export; preserve the fourth generic as Record; seventh path requires rescope", + "scopeAmendmentHeadSha": "2fa2f71dc5b498c16221461439e53b9f5dc1d5d5", + "scopeAmendmentCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1671#issuecomment-5304017800", + "scopeAmendmentResult": "run-artifact-only six-file amendment; exact six product/test/docs paths, public/mod.ts conditional removed, six concrete error literals plus empty meta-slot acceptance, published breaking-change disclosure retained", + "planTierAState": "PASS", + "planTierATopicCheckpointSha": "6c94860042a9f3adc8b11b72775d6e01ef7fbac8", + "planEvaluationState": "complete_pass_cycle_1", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "50898ac7-6e79-4f31-ae18-694bb36b7c79", + "planEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "50898ac7", + "planEvaluatorPid": 636411, + "planEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "session_015RuDy1h3UiCkLzo1PLk5Sc", + "planEvaluatorRemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_015RuDy1h3UiCkLzo1PLk5Sc", + "planEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "planEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T20:12:35.647Z", + "planEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "2fa2f71dc5b498c16221461439e53b9f5dc1d5d5", + "planEvaluationFocus": "live #1348/#1350/#1466 ownership boundary, exact six-path sufficiency, TError end-to-end preservation, breaking published-contract honesty, real base RED, six literals, empty metadata slot, and two-page narrative completeness", + "planEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T20:19:58.223Z", + "planEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "planEvaluatorCommitSha": "f76a3c45bce42cab81c2b481d4abf03be1104bb0", + "planEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1671#issuecomment-5304059808", + "planEvaluationAdvisories": "record TS18046 plus TS2339 REDs; use exported contracts schemas without SDK zod mapping; retain SafeFailure default; track deferred bench debt without a seventh path; do not tick metadata boxes", + "implementationSlices": { + "s1": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "dc034d680b53c2845e9b82f73c6c709f2c51e2b3", + "topicCheckpointSha": "7281cebac293cf3648d4ac7d7c27c9f21cc84cf8", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1671#issuecomment-5304110615", + "authorizedPaths": [ + "packages/contracts/src/application/contract-primitives.ts", + "packages/sdk/tests/readme-doctest_test.ts" + ], + "constraints": "RED first with both TS18046 and TS2339; retain Record; no metadata vocabulary; no SDK zod mapping; no seventh path; commit/push/comment then stop for fresh Tier-A", + "validation": "one structured base RED captured TS18046 unknown and TS2339 never without rerun; exact six literal keys plus Record compile assertions; fresh Tier-A reran 105-file check with zero diagnostics, focused doctest 2/0, and Contracts plus SDK 77/0" + }, + "s2": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "ca7ade409be0cc0c064e75f5bfa1bd109e06d013", + "topicCheckpointSha": "ac0b2c4c3", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1671#issuecomment-5304171376", + "authorizedPaths": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/errors.ts", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts", + "packages/sdk/tests/readme-doctest_test.ts" + ], + "constraints": "preserve SafeFailure; convert both S1 @ts-expect-error markers to positive exact-union/data assertions; use public oRPC types; no SDK zod map, ambient redeclaration, seventh path, NetScriptProcedureMeta, docs, or runtime", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A verified all suppressions absent, exact six-code and code-specific-data assertions genuine, S1 RED wording preserved, 105-file check zero diagnostics, doctest 3/0, Contracts plus SDK 78/0, lint and format clean" + }, + "s3": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "c7cba6d9bd6aef1fbeb0e8e9778a5d979c8544bd", + "topicCheckpointSha": "580bd8ec0", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1671#issuecomment-5304248240", + "authorizedPaths": [ + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md", + "docs/site/services-sdk/how-to/discover-services.md" + ], + "constraints": "one compile-accurate defined/non-defined failure narrative using delivered public API; schema-derived code-specific data; no product/test change, metadata claim, seventh path, or final S4 gates", + "validation": "both pages name all six authoritative literals, branch literally on isSuccess and isDefined, terminate non-defined failures, show schema-derived code-specific data, and preserve compile/doctest/docs gates with lock and package bytes unchanged" + }, + "s4": { + "state": "stopped_leaf_owned_doc_lint_red_evidence_pushed", + "evidenceHeadSha": "db8aadd9542c38a305efffbd7017c56d0abf4e01", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1671#issuecomment-5304357008", + "greenSet": "uncached root check 2925 files; root test 4207/0/19; scoped lint/fmt 105 files; quality, architecture, docs source-format/accuracy, workspace publish and raw package publish all pass", + "surfaceDisposition": "raw surface:diff remains red; exact approved +15 signature delta only, no new exports/removals, and normalized base/head remainder both 972 with identical SHA-256 55744a8522197fbb450349ca7185631188c97add132c356e173259875ae9406c", + "blockingFinding": "raw doc-lint adds leaf-owned private-type references: Contracts 9 to 11 after three additions and one obsolete removal; SDK 3 to 13 with ten additions; JSR/specifier/export guards honestly NOT_RUN", + "repairPlanContract": "run-artifact-only plan amendment first through a fresh canonical documentation_review Claude Sonnet 5/high agent because Codex is account-quota blocked; correction ceiling is the already-authorized contract-primitives.ts, errors.ts, and service-client.ts plus existing run artifacts; no suppression, metadata, public/mod.ts, seventh path, test/docs/lock mutation, or runtime; fresh Minimax M3/high PLAN-EVAL follows via the native-quota fallback" + } + }, + "codexQuotaState": "account_wide_usage_limit_verified_by_fresh_thread_01a00767_2533_7273_a4c6_47cad0f85a6d_until_2026_08_20_05_31", + "s4rPlanMaintenanceRoute": "canonical documentation_review: fresh native Claude Sonnet 5/high in a dedicated detached exact-head worktree; run artifacts only; supervisor neither authors nor self-certifies", + "s4rPlanEvaluationRoute": "canonical native-quota PLAN-EVAL fallback: fresh Minimax M3/high over OpenRouter; generator session differs from evaluator session", + "productRepairCapacityBoundary": "the later three-product-file repair remains parked on canonical Codex implementation until the 2026-08-20 05:31 reset; no outside-plan product implementation authorized", + "nextGate": "complete the artifact-only S4-R amendment and fresh Minimax PLAN-EVAL; on PASS park at the canonical Codex product-repair capacity boundary", + "expensiveGateContract": "no runtime lease; no Aspire, Docker, e2e:cli, browser, or runtime gate during plan evaluation", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "prisma-mysql-adapter-surface", + "lane": "features", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "284dda90a17a13a7e5e8e9834e5411b58887131b", + "issueNumbers": [ + 1293 + ], + "implementerAgentId": "01a0048f-8d95-7682-a3ce-1c1926aba75c", + "branch": "feat/prisma-mysql-adapter-surface", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features-1293", + "currentPrHeadSha": "f52aa471c0b4e8fe44b7d0e231c69f58b52dc9bf", + "implementationState": "merged_product_split_close", + "prNumber": 1662, + "compatibilityDisposition": "preserve and wire the already-published PrismaMySqlOptions.onConnectionError hook; removal is not authorized", + "planEvaluationState": "complete", + "planEvaluatedHeadSha": "23c4d671b57282ddf2e5c3b834ac8e787d1dff09", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "75d9028e-0277-4b1c-bc2f-cefd0ce68dd7", + "planEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "75d9028e", + "planEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01T55opXUMc1mMKDZaA8bRf3", + "planEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "planEvaluatorCommitSha": "7780ba49e119377f2be39cac5ed110fc12758bfc", + "planEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "planEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T09:02:23.000Z", + "planAmendmentHeadSha": "feb8b0355215e7282b87787117dc5c244653250d", + "planAmendmentTierAState": "PASS", + "slice1InitialHeadSha": "ecb98cc88f9c86918ff535f7ada36b055df3e737", + "slice1TierAInitialState": "CHANGES_REQUESTED", + "slice1RepairHeadSha": "49fda0b77b4db4a91f1cb25e23b13e4bf1259699", + "slice1TierAState": "PASS", + "slice1Contract": "module-only concrete adapter seam, exact upstream-compatible query input type, bidirectional assignability guards, clean doc lint and unchanged eight-file publish set", + "slice2HeadSha": "47ad48c9dcfe408e5de150fdb3a65d0f2111ee1f", + "slice2TierAState": "PASS", + "slice2Contract": "closed connection-error classifier, single contained notifier choke point, raw executeScript rejection, identity-preserving callback containment, notify-and-preserve capability fallback", + "slice3ContentHeadSha": "3dee41263e5e34a9f59972edb43a345c8d4494c0", + "slice3State": "complete_exact_head_receipts_pass", + "finalEvidenceHeadSha": "d8d255bdc103eb120cc7b8835dfe3ce870017c32", + "finalTierAState": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationState": "complete", + "implementationEvaluationCycle": 1, + "implementationEvaluationSourceHeadSha": "d8d255bdc103eb120cc7b8835dfe3ce870017c32", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "e64f33f0-c88e-4fc7-9e79-63c01fed94db", + "implementationEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "e64f33f0", + "implementationEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01XrFMbPHpry6tL3v9ZmRsLK", + "implementationEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "implementationEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T10:11:15.000Z", + "implementationEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T10:16:31.000Z", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "f52aa471c0b4e8fe44b7d0e231c69f58b52dc9bf", + "implementationEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1662#issuecomment-5301776738", + "readinessState": "complete", + "readinessDisposition": "exact-head checks terminal green with zero review threads; coordinator merge complete", + "mergeCommitSha": "3fc0f2f9221a8246f0d26a26189bafb2647be08a", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T10:27:29.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "PR 1662 shipped; issue 1293 remains open with acceptance boxes 2 and 3 checked and boxes 1 and 4 open", + "planEvaluatorTerminalMetadata": "stale working state; terminal response and exact pushed verdict commit independently verified by coordinator", + "splitCloseContract": "product PR uses Part of #1293 and may merge on product gates while #1293 remains open; #1112 must rewrite and verify the docs example before box 4 and issue closure", + "docsFollowUp": "#1112 and the prisma-adapter-mysql reference remain docs-owned and are not part of this product leaf", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "app-service-client-wiring", + "lane": "features", + "phase": "implementing", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "3fc0f2f9221a8246f0d26a26189bafb2647be08a", + "currentPrHeadSha": "d8d5ee61924d0c3c7ed657ab96f610bc142cfd6a", + "issueNumbers": [1355, 1360], + "implementerAgentId": "01a004f9-f033-7592-a0bc-63927753fb43", + "implementerRoute": "openai / gpt-5.6-sol / high / approval never / dangerFullAccess", + "branch": "feat/app-service-client-wiring", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features-1355", + "prNumber": 1664, + "implementationState": "f8_plan_intermediate_provenance_correction_rerouted_after_account_wide_codex_quota", + "dispatchTopicHeadSha": "0d0ba1b7a404c847acba2daed40c69d282906f69", + "planGate": "author must open a draft PR at the first slice, produce research and plan, and stop before implementation", + "tierAPlanState": "PASS", + "tierAPlanRepairHeadSha": "f7225be98c01b38f86712c1df0782aec06e34445", + "tierAPlanTopicCheckpointSha": "cdfdda4a0", + "planEvaluationRequired": true, + "planEvaluationState": "complete_pass_cycle_2", + "planEvaluatorAgentId": "8c756943-11c8-45a2-84ab-8c8392898723", + "planEvaluatorBackgroundAgentId": "8c756943", + "planEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "cse_01UrhsQgBYpLZWHKAhCvESi6", + "planEvaluatorRoute": "native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control", + "planEvaluationGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T11:19:25.000Z", + "planEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T11:22:31.000Z", + "planEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "planEvaluatorCommitSha": "c53726c69b98a35bf293b89aeece12279f470be3", + "planEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5301997528", + "planEvaluatorRemoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01UrhsQgBYpLZWHKAhCvESi6", + "planEvaluationCycle1": { + "state": "complete", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN", + "evaluatorAgentId": "176aace4-b2a2-4b16-bdaa-9db687c7d132", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01TiYhwUCkdyjziEpFP3kgaS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "ed34105e2ef344a5b590bca6985810f45f89b0ca", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5301947232" + }, + "implementationConstraints": [ + "concrete SDK 0.0.6 emitted-expression and import allowlist proof; remove stale bridgeInvalidation import", + "document and error the atomic missing-contract failure, including service/path and an explicit Enabled:false service policy", + "mark generate-aspire_test.ts as new" + ], + "f5PlanAmendmentHeadSha": "3204ffa98a7e4db932515851145538fe899f381b", + "f5PlanAmendmentTierAState": "PASS_AFTER_A1", + "f5PlanAmendmentTierATopicCheckpointSha": "53f97644d4278bd794333260cf3d2f91d31e9af1", + "f5PlanRepairHeadSha": "630185e2cd391203f07bb3ba6a1eece80fed25ec", + "f5ContentHeadSha": "fda78ee438ea40888e5fb3870a78df70cabb8c82", + "f5EvidenceHeadSha": "1263f655b37d64a258619403398ca7117ea000d5", + "f5BindingReceiptState": "four_unique_pass_recomputed_sufficient_check_2944_files_test_4226_0_19_publish_dry_run_arch_check", + "f5FinalTierAState": "PASS", + "f5FinalTierATopicCheckpointSha": "9a5521aa084e482722e928a4720e389df306c84c", + "f5FinalTierAProof": "fresh review accepted 15 product and 11 test paths with zero outside the 27-path ceiling, reproduced the exact-12 generated fmt proof plus immediate byte-identical repeat, retained F4 and S2 atomicity, and independently checked timeout, EOF, zero-byte, extension, and all four pre-write canonicalization boundaries", + "f5AllowlistWatchTopicCheckpointSha": "bb538cd4f", + "f5PlanAmendmentSurface": "15 product plus 12 focused-test paths around an internal GeneratedSourceFormatterPort, ProcessPort stdin transport, four pre-write canonicalizing writer owners, and a cheap exact-12-path add/generate/full-fmt proof", + "f5PlanRepairRequired": "closed at 630185e2c: executable EOF-before-timeout/kill closure, supported zero-byte passthrough, extension allowlist refusal before content inspection, and services-group dependency projection are bound; product implementation released under unchanged 15-product/12-test ceiling", + "implementationSlices": { + "s1": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "5ac6efa308599eac9290977215af5c951fcf46ee", + "topicCheckpointSha": "6ea7a17fb", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5302026558", + "surfaceDelta": "none; JSDoc correction plus semantic TanStack partialMatchKey match/mismatch regression tests", + "validation": "focused SDK check and 2/2 tests pass; quality gate pass; two pre-existing QueryClient private-type-ref diagnostics carried as baseline" + }, + "s2": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass_after_two_fail_fix_rounds", + "headSha": "3669e9b8730dae3ef65b4dee02d5ce5770a467b7", + "topicCheckpointSha": "3eab955b1", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5302177061", + "scope": "CLI generator contract, emitted import allowlist and literal order, atomic missing-contract behavior, owned modules for Enabled:false, generated asset freshness", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A reproduced full CLI source suite 598/0 and asset freshness; C2 validates every existing manifest contract before renderService or any write; C1 exhaustively equals the two allowed SDK imports, forbids bridgeInvalidation, and orders direct clientKey invalidation after queries", + "failFixes": [ + "addService originally wrote appsettings/workspace/Aspire helpers before all-manifest contract validation; repaired with a shared preflight and zero-write add-path regression", + "route-templates_test.ts still demanded the removed bridgeInvalidation import; repaired in-slice with exhaustive import-set equality, forbidden-symbol, and literal-order assertions" + ] + }, + "s3": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass", + "headSha": "1df8a5274d2adc7657eb785a37266aa0f1f7540d", + "topicCheckpointSha": "c91c2084a", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5302233366", + "scope": "canonical cache-age hydration in both service showcase islands, generated omission coverage, public-wrapper browser fixture/task, CLI and Fresh package README notes, canonical embedded asset regeneration", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A reproduced the full CLI source suite at 598/0, Fresh check and non-browser tests green, asset regeneration clean, both island timestamp assertions present, all prior C1/add-path atomicity guards retained, and both expensive gates NOT_RUN" + }, + "s4": { + "state": "complete_tier_a_pass_after_two_attributed_stops_and_scoped_fix", + "contentHeadSha": "32ea23f501900ca4d7de603e00709e09f41be3dc", + "evidenceHeadSha": "1c1f458203cc458ff2c1fd20149c907998654f22", + "topicCheckpointSha": "84568f2ff", + "commentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5302773276", + "scope": "artifact-only formatting/lint/assets, exact-pin/export-map/doc/JSR audits for CLI/Fresh/SDK, three isolated publish dry-runs, and four immutable-head run-gate receipts", + "constraints": "no inline product repair; any red finding stops for attribution and a separately reviewed scope; receipts generated only by run-gate with explicit git head", + "validation": "fresh Tier-A verified the exact one-line order-sensitive suite-registry repair, focused 19/0, four distinct PASS/0 replacement receipts attesting gitHead == actualGitHead == 32ea23f50 without mismatch override, and independently recomputed SUFFICIENT; Fresh 45 and SDK 3 export-map baselines remain PRE_EXISTING_FAIL", + "attributedStops": [ + "root formatter exclusion and multi-batch interaction fail-closed with zero findings; corrected through explicit neutral config plus single 1000-file CLI batch without product mutation", + "binding test exposed a leaf-caused stale capability-suite expectation; topic review authorized the exact one-line order-sensitive expectation repair and all four receipts were replaced" + ] + }, + "s5": { + "state": "f6_plan_tier_a_pass_two_path_repair_active_same_author", + "finding": "accepted plan release condition 3 is unmet: no payments service add/generate/idempotency, users/payments key-isolation, or live Rename plus exactly-one settled refetch scenario exists in the scaffold.runtime suite", + "freshBrowserPrecondition": "present: controlled hydrationNow old-versus-fresh fixture and catalog-backed task wiring", + "f2PlanAmendmentHeadSha": "4be44002079a3a22a581810d12239f800175df12", + "f2PlanAmendmentState": "committed_and_explicitly_pushed_before_product_edits", + "f2TransportSplitAmendmentHeadSha": "93fb5532d1796fae8165c61ea86fe11e98092650", + "f2TransportSplitAmendmentState": "committed_and_explicitly_pushed_before_product_commit", + "f2InitialProductHeadSha": "787cfa928", + "f2InterceptionTopicCheckpointSha": "37372cbae", + "f2InterceptionFindings": "response-stage Fetch pause incorrectly resumes with Fetch.continueRequest; fixed 750ms baseline does not prove all initial list requests completed and remained stable, so a late initial request can satisfy +1 without a refetch", + "f2RequiredRepair": "same original author must use Fetch.continueResponse, prove a completed stable baseline across a confirmation window, add a rejecting late-initial-request unit case, renew affected cheap tests and all four receipts at the corrected head, then stop for fresh Tier-A", + "f2CorrectedProductHeadSha": "2c82199680e4b3cfc8e93d831acd5d160f0b5db9", + "f2CorrectedEvidenceHeadSha": "b14975af7657869dfb36f5e07d2ef393c1ef989c", + "f2HardRecoveryTopicCheckpointSha": "7385fac16", + "f2TierAState": "PASS", + "f2TierATopicCheckpointSha": "63d190d4be8ecbcc317971ea7a840e64d3553bae", + "f2CorrectedProof": "Refresh-driven deterministic list baseline; at least one request observed; all observed IDs completed and count stable across confirmation window; response-stage pause resumes with Fetch.continueResponse; shared primitive negative test rejects late initial request", + "f2ReceiptState": "four fresh exact-head receipts PASS and independently SUFFICIENT at b14975af7; all 787cfa928 receipts are superseded-only", + "f2PlanDesign": "three scaffold/static gates selected by scaffold.service and scaffold.runtime immediately after scaffold.init; one CDP settled-refetch behavior gate selected only by scaffold.runtime after live readiness; pure fail-capable unit assertions and four new exact-head binding receipts before fresh Tier-A", + "requiredRecovery": "amend an exact bounded CLI e2e gate/probe/test slice, implement on the original Sol/high author, rerun affected cheap tests and all four binding gates, and pass fresh Tier-A before any lease", + "leaseState": "released_after_terminal_scaffold_runtime_failure_and_clean_audit", + "leaseGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T15:56:55Z", + "leasePreflight": "leaf clean and local == remote; zero Docker containers; no Aspire application/AppHost/DCP, browser, relevant port, or other lease owner; idle Aspire MCP helpers are not application resources", + "scaffoldRuntimeResult": "FAILED passed=6 failed=1 skipped=0 at generated.service-client-contract; two new add/generate gates passed", + "scaffoldRuntimeFindings": "TS2307 missing database/postgres/schema/.generated/zod/crud.ts plus two TS2345 payments list input mismatches; current hardcoded shared input and equal-tail proof assumptions do not match the real users/payments contracts", + "cleanupResult": "cleanup.aspire-stop PASS; leak-check aspire/docker ok and survivors empty; zero containers and no AppHost/DCP; foreign Aspire MCP helpers untouched", + "f3RequiredScope": "amend before mutation; inspect canonical schema-generation lifecycle and real contracts; prove resource-prefix isolation with each service's own typed input; same original author; fresh Tier-A before a new lease", + "f3PlanAmendmentHeadSha": "fe88522dfc3e413b5a6a81796907fb3f35245b7a", + "f3CanonicalOrderAmendmentHeadSha": "2da92651947bfd07ab78f6d466cd552e79fadc9c", + "f3InputIsolationAmendmentHeadSha": "c4a900adc3b912d80ef7eab6b271f8aee532a5cc", + "f3InputIsolationFinding": "cheap generated-project replay proved that importing the parent orchestration probe drags monorepo import-map dependencies into the generated app; a dependency-free internal input primitive was added to scope and pushed before that new file is created", + "f3ProductHeadSha": "6e822a74b4de527a23da46f1c9c2f6ba6c94c72f", + "f3ProductProof": "dependency-free service-client input derivation from each generated contract, canonical DB codegen before the contract gate, 29 focused tests, five-file structured check/fmt/lint, quality scan, and preserved generated-project cheap replay all passed before receipt generation", + "f3FirstCheckReceiptArtifactHeadSha": "3278cca346d7a9ce10ab78089af9ba45282cef20", + "f3FirstCheckReceipt": ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/receipts/s4-f3-check.json", + "f3FirstCheckReceiptState": "FAIL_PRESERVED_EXIT_1", + "f3FirstCheckReceiptFinding": "root structured check failed at unchanged packages/cli/src/kernel/diagnostics/verify-producer-reconnect.ts:268 with TS2322 Type Timeout is not assignable to type number", + "f3ReceiptFence": "all remaining receipts and every runtime/evaluator action stopped until same-author isolated before/after attribution is terminal; the failed receipt is append-only evidence and must not be overwritten", + "f3LikelyCausality": "F3 replaced @std/path with node:path inside service-client-runtime-probe.ts; importing Node path can introduce Node timer globals into the shared Deno check batch, whereas the b14975af7 exact-head root-check receipt passed with @std/path", + "f3CausalityProofTopicCheckpointSha": "ca10ffaebf0735d926ebea4b26a0d3aac3bd3006", + "f3RepairProductHeadSha": "193e665ba0592273622253e3e9a1ebfc019b1be9", + "f3RepairEvidenceHeadSha": "8940e9266630a3cc5368153722747e45d30aec3b", + "f3Repair": "same author restored @std/path and a Deno-only custom walker, isolating the probe from Node timer globals without changing the F3 service-contract substance", + "f3ReplacementReceipts": "four distinct exact-head PASS/SUFFICIENT receipts at 193e665ba: root check 2937 files/25 batches/0 diagnostics, root test 4212/0/19, publish dry-run PASS, arch-check zero failures", + "f3RepairTierAState": "PASS", + "f3RepairTierATopicCheckpointSha": "c7ce2c3f6ba49fb3d56d5dd43722f5764a3abfae", + "f3RepairTierAProof": "fresh topic review independently reran the decisive one-batch check at exit 0 and verified exact receipt identity, scope, preserved FAIL trail, and clean immutable evidence head", + "s5RunHeadSha": "ab78eaa35c1753f9e8c526dbd234c7073758008b", + "s5EvidenceHeadSha": "e1dcb726b983dd10981f4fc8df5ea8c638686e77", + "s5RuntimeResult": "FAIL passed=20 failed=1 skipped=0 at generated.service-client-contract; post-plugin service generate wrote zero client modules, skipped two current clients, and wrote three Aspire helper files while the probe required zero helper writes", + "s5FailureClass": "leaf-caused proof-contract failure: the asserted zero-write run followed plugin installation that legitimately changes Aspire-helper inputs, so it is not yet a same-input idempotency rerun", + "s5Cleanup": "cleanup.aspire-stop PASS; run-owned teardown empty; independent final leak check Aspire ok, Docker ok, survivors empty; fresh-browser NOT_RUN", + "f4RequiredScope": "amend and push before mutation; distinguish reconciliation after plugin-input changes from a true consecutive same-input idempotency rerun, then prove the second identical invocation writes zero clients and zero Aspire helpers; preserve the FAIL and rerun cheap proofs/four receipts/fresh Tier-A before any new lease", + "f4DiagnosticProof": "after the failed invocation reconciled three helpers, two further consecutive identical service generate commands both exited 0 with zero clients written, two skipped, zero helpers written, and byte-identical complete helper SHA-256 manifests", + "f4PlanAmendmentHeadSha": "b40616a81e282dc7671cdeeb25eb49bf6946820e", + "f4ProductHeadSha": "7876aa10911c2eeea4aafb217d651b28a90bac2c", + "f4EvidenceHeadSha": "6f813b0db35df38dcd9dc7f1ea333e997399fac0", + "f4ReceiptState": "four distinct exact-content-head receipts PASS and independently SUFFICIENT: check 2937 files/25 batches/0 diagnostics; test 4213/0/19; publish dry-run PASS; arch-check zero failures", + "f4TierAState": "PASS", + "f4TierATopicCheckpointSha": "35f3a6975b1aaae20a384e5d655cc3483e0b2a56", + "f4TierAProof": "amendment preceded product repair; first post-plugin generate may converge, then an immediately identical generate must write zero clients/helpers and preserve SHA-256 path/byte identity; focused sequence and two negative cases passed 11/0; prior FAIL trail intact", + "attempt3RuntimeResult": "FAIL passed=32 failed=1 skipped=0 at generated.deno-fmt-check; repaired generated.service-client-contract passed; generated workspace fmt:check exited 1", + "attempt3Cleanup": "cleanup.aspire-stop PASS; run-owned teardown removed no AppHosts/containers/escalations; independent leak check Aspire ok, Docker ok, survivors empty", + "attempt3EvidenceHeadSha": "09a771c8e828f28bf26b387097bdb6a203b3bebe", + "attempt3EvidenceCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5303373489", + "attempt3AttributionReview": "author proved one unchanged Aspire helper is pre-existing, but the exact red contains twelve paths including leaf-owned payments/client outputs; fresh Tier-A must classify every path before any repair ruling", + "attempt3TierAState": "FAIL_FIX_LEAF_CAUSED", + "attempt3TierATopicCheckpointSha": "0d0ba1b7a404c847acba2daed40c69d282906f69", + "attempt3TierAProof": "exact twelve-path reproduction proves users/payments client modules from the leaf-modified client scaffolder are unformatted; seven unchanged Aspire helpers are baseline; three payments service/contract outputs remain to be measured at the pre-implementation head; blanket pre-existing attribution rejected", + "runtimeGates": "attempt 4 scaffold.runtime terminal FAIL at behavior.service-client-refetch after 69 passes; fresh-browser NOT_RUN; suite cleanup passed, independent host audit empty, singleton lease released; preserve raw evidence and attribute the already-terminated-child cleanup exception before any repair", + "attempt4LeaseState": "released_after_terminal_scaffold_runtime_failure_and_clean_audit", + "attempt4LeaseGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T18:30:23.000Z", + "attempt4PreGateHeadSha": "1263f655b37d64a258619403398ca7117ea000d5", + "attempt4ContentHeadSha": "fda78ee438ea40888e5fb3870a78df70cabb8c82", + "attempt4Preflight": "leaf clean and local == remote == PR; aspire ps []; zero Docker containers; zero AppHost/DCP/application/browser processes; zero relevant listening ports; zero competing runtime lease owners; idle Aspire MCP helpers preserved", + "attempt4RuntimeResult": "FAIL passed=69 failed=1 skipped=0 at behavior.service-client-refetch; collectBrowserRefetchEvidence called child.kill(SIGTERM) after the child had already terminated", + "attempt4RawLog": ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/reports/s5-attempt4-scaffold-runtime-20260815-2037.log", + "attempt4RawLogSha256": "b476da4ce039d03785e46669d51919b48c41fbae80ca41ca9188bcbb53e97f23", + "attempt4Cleanup": "suite cleanup.aspire-stop PASS; independent aspire ps []; Docker zero; no AppHost/DCP/application/browser process or relevant listener; four stopped aspire-managed nuget-search children from the suite were found by the explicit process audit, terminated by exact PID, and re-audited absent; foreign Aspire MCP helpers preserved", + "attempt4FreshBrowser": "NOT_RUN because scaffold.runtime failed", + "attempt4EvidenceHeadSha": "7df60832a8c804743442b66d2332fb75249e25a7", + "attempt4EvidenceCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5303720517", + "f6PlanAmendmentHeadSha": "36da13fa1e8ffcff5a9d9ce930634655675bbcda", + "f6PlanAmendmentCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5303765269", + "f6PlanTierAState": "PASS", + "f6PlanTierATopicCheckpointSha": "f436df086129f4e9f23afc5a4e0b1b7c996acdd5", + "f6RepairCeiling": "exactly the existing browser-probe and runtime-probe-test paths; named internal terminateBrowserProcess helper; tolerate only TypeError with exact already-terminated message; await status and drain; prove natural exit, active termination, unrelated-error propagation, drain rejection, and production delegation", + "f6ProductHeadSha": "7fa29ad3ed10ad903b9cbbd518111e6bf2754761", + "f6FirstEvidenceHeadSha": "4c7792f2094a0f2e2e4b23fa7ebde62f7eeb3205", + "f6FirstReceiptState": "check PASS; root test FAIL preserved at 4228 passed / 1 failed / 19 ignored because the repo scanner reached a root-owned ignored attempt-4 Postgres data directory", + "f6EnvironmentalDisposition": "the exact ignored tree .llm/tmp/cli-e2e/plugin-smoke-20260815-203755 was recoverably moved to /tmp/netscript-f6-quarantine.7kXcDX; Docker and owning processes were absent; the original red receipt remains append-only", + "f6FinalEvidenceHeadSha": "a8a160285d4f9bddb95a5dac6cfbde85e1265ebc", + "f6ReplacementReceiptState": "PASS and SUFFICIENT: check, test-attempt2 4229/0/19, publish-dry-run, and arch-check all bind unchanged product 7fa29ad3e; preserved test red is superseded-only with identical 4248 total results", + "f6FinalTierAState": "PASS", + "f6FinalTierATopicCheckpointSha": "a4224dbb1", + "attempt5LeaseState": "released_after_terminal_red_and_clean_audit", + "attempt5LeaseGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T19:39:00.000Z", + "attempt5EvidenceHeadSha": "a8a160285d4f9bddb95a5dac6cfbde85e1265ebc", + "attempt5Preflight": "leaf clean and local == remote == PR; aspire ps []; Docker zero; zero AppHost/DCP/application/browser/runtime processes and relevant listeners; transient aspire-managed nuget helper from ps query exited before the post-query audit", + "attempt5RuntimeResult": "FAIL passed=69 failed=1 skipped=0 at behavior.service-client-refetch: timed out waiting for Chrome DevTools target; F6 teardown no longer masks the behavior verdict", + "attempt5RawLog": ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/reports/s5-attempt5-scaffold-runtime-20260815-2139.log", + "attempt5RawLogSha256": "ff349b40f7f70341934e170df7c67d147c0ed983173b41871421755ad55e062b", + "attempt5FreshBrowser": "NOT_RUN because scaffold.runtime failed", + "attempt5Cleanup": "cleanup.aspire-stop PASS; Aspire [] and Docker zero; no AppHost/DCP/browser/runtime process or relevant listener; three stopped run-owned aspire-managed NuGet children 727834/727837/727843 verified under the attempt tree, removed by exact TERM/CONT, and independently re-audited absent", + "attempt5EvidenceCommitSha": "6204a71715ee63d1d4012693d07cfb5abbe4fa67", + "attempt5EvidenceCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5303965409", + "attempt5Next": "superseded by measured F7-C1 allowlist/selection attribution and reviewed two-path repair; no runtime retry before repaired content, four exact-head receipts, and second fresh Tier-A", + "f7InitialPlanHeadSha": "ff0ede99760cbd4b9fe67ab46e32ea1440baf0ea", + "f7InitialPlanDisposition": "superseded_unreviewed_false_environment_capability_premise", + "f7CausalCorrectionTopicCheckpointSha": "b89b527603db030b665fd95908e1cfc752cdf694", + "f7MeasuredCause": "managed Linux Chromium 151 exists and executes in Playwright caches; the probe ignores managed browsers, selects an unrunnable Windows PE without WSLInterop, discards early stderr/status, and reports a DevTools timeout; classification is allowlist/selection defect, not host capability gap", + "f7PlanAmendmentHeadSha": "a2e9515f5a430d53cff1e47d55d7916f3dc0db15", + "f7PlanAmendmentCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5304036438", + "f7PlanTierAState": "PASS", + "f7PlanTierATopicCheckpointSha": "8ec20d6065d1a3013cf5009e2883fb0992f11839", + "f7RepairCeiling": "exactly service-client-browser-probe.ts and service-client-runtime-probe_test.ts; strict NETSCRIPT_E2E_BROWSER_EXECUTABLE override with no fallback, runnable-version validation for override and built-ins, no versioned cache literals, bounded startup stderr/status diagnostics, and deterministic no-fallback proofs", + "f7ImplementationState": "product_pushed_environmental_test_red_recovery_active_no_runtime_lease", + "f7ProductHeadSha": "e45144db643f6bde85552a615812c8371e4ce792", + "f7FirstEvidenceHeadSha": "885f352e77439e1f846be1f99971c398f6865e75", + "f7FocusedProof": "22 passed / 0 failed including strict override/no fallback, managed Chromium version validation, early headless exit diagnostics, 32 KiB bounded drain, live-timeout cause preservation, and all F6 teardown cases", + "f7BindingCheck": "PASS at exact content head: 2944 files, 25 batches, zero diagnostics", + "f7BindingTestRed": "FAIL preserved at exact content head: 4236 passed / 1 failed / 19 ignored; unchanged forbidden-commands walker hit PermissionDenied under the retained attempt-5 Postgres data directory", + "f7EnvironmentalQuarantine": { + "source": ".llm/tmp/cli-e2e/plugin-smoke-20260815-213942", + "destination": "/tmp/netscript-f7-quarantine.iXF6fb/plugin-smoke-20260815-213942", + "recoverable": true, + "scannerChanged": false + }, + "f7RecoveryTopicCheckpointSha": "d81b99143", + "f7RecoveryState": "complete_pass_tier_a_pass", + "f7RecoveryContract": "preserve f7-test.json red; run f7-test-attempt2 from a clean exact-content checkout with gitHead == actualGitHead and no mismatch waiver; only on PASS run publish-dry-run then arch-check at the same content; attach evidence and stop for fresh Tier-A before runtime lease", + "f7FinalEvidenceHeadSha": "ed3f78e0d87784b1869166bd2574737c62fac0af", + "f7FinalEvidenceCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5304173729", + "f7ReplacementReceiptState": "PASS and SUFFICIENT at immutable content e45144db6: retained check; test-attempt2 4237/0/19 with total 4256; publish-dry-run; arch-check; original 4236/1/19 test red preserved and excluded as superseded evidence", + "f7FinalTierAState": "PASS", + "f7FinalTierATopicCheckpointSha": "4a65a2670", + "attempt6LeaseState": "released_after_terminal_red_clean_audit_and_pushed_evidence", + "attempt6LeaseGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T20:55:30.000Z", + "attempt6PreGateEvidenceHeadSha": "ed3f78e0d87784b1869166bd2574737c62fac0af", + "attempt6ContentHeadSha": "e45144db643f6bde85552a615812c8371e4ce792", + "attempt6TopicCheckpointSha": "ac1ec35cf", + "attempt6BrowserOverride": "/home/codex/.cache/ms-playwright/chromium-1234/chrome-linux64/chrome — Google Chrome for Testing 151.0.7922.34", + "attempt6Preflight": "leaf clean and local == remote == PR; aspire ps []; aspire stop no AppHost; Docker zero; no AppHost/DCP/browser/runtime process or relevant listener; no unreadable residue; three older readable plugin-smoke trees recoverably moved to /tmp/netscript-preattempt6-quarantine.9mNpwE", + "attempt6Contract": "one suite-owned scaffold.runtime with strict managed-browser override; cleanup and independent Aspire/Docker/process/port/residue audit; fresh-browser once only on scaffold PASS plus clean audit; final cleanup/audit; no retry or evaluator", + "attempt6RuntimeResult": "FAIL passed=69 failed=1 skipped=0 at behavior.service-client-refetch; managed Chrome was selected successfully, but the child returned no refetch evidence and exited 143 at the suite-owned 900030ms boundary", + "attempt6RawLog": ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/reports/s5-attempt6-scaffold-runtime-20260815-205715.log", + "attempt6RawLogSha256": "1bf8cb03aaa3be0ba900254abdaf3065aa9f7c8cae5989bac37ed396a919aaa0", + "attempt6NdjsonSha256": "ffab7e7f0b7764c7d2e0eca5873fa9d5cfee7c5f278743a8886e7bbba53de356", + "attempt6BrowserSelectionEvidence": ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/reports/s5-attempt6-browser-selection-20260815-205715.json; source NETSCRIPT_E2E_BROWSER_EXECUTABLE; Google Chrome for Testing 151.0.7922.34", + "attempt6FreshBrowser": "NOT_RUN because scaffold.runtime failed; no catalog receipt exists", + "attempt6Cleanup": "cleanup.aspire-stop and suite Docker cleanup passed; three stopped run-owned Aspire NuGet helpers exited after exact TERM plus CONT; generated project with its unreadable Postgres directory moved recoverably to /tmp/netscript-s5-a6-quarantine-20260815-4M9v8k; final Aspire, Docker, process, port, and unreadable-residue audits are empty", + "attempt6EvidenceHeadSha": "2385cdb72602c149c29cc637870ddca3db09e0cd", + "attempt6EvidenceCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5304325367", + "attempt6CompletedAt": "2026-08-15T21:30:55.000Z", + "attempt6Next": "F8 measured plan amendment exists; foreign supervisor-generated leak-report bytes must be restored append-only by a separate corrective owner before formal plan acceptance, product repair, or runtime attempt 7", + "f8PlanHeadSha": "d8d5ee61924d0c3c7ed657ab96f610bc142cfd6a", + "f8PlanCommentId": 5304365403, + "f8PlanFinding": "the 900-second ledger does not distinguish unbounded CDP connect from send, so deterministic separate reproductions must precede a bounded two-path product repair", + "f8ProvenanceFinding": "d8d5ee619 accidentally includes two leak-report lines generated by the features supervisor's host audit; F8 plan artifacts are otherwise plan-only and accepted as an intermediate head", + "f8ProvenanceRepairContract": "restore leak-report.md byte-identical to 2385cdb72 in a new append-only commit, rewrite comment 5304365403 in place to the corrected head, and prove only legitimate F8 plan artifacts remain", + "codexQuotaState": "account-wide usageLimitExceeded verified by fresh detached Sol/high thread 01a00766-3240-7dd0-91df-7e335142f0cb; reset 2026-08-20 05:31; no more Codex retries", + "f8CorrectiveRoute": "canonical chore_code: fresh separate native Claude Opus 5/medium agent in a dedicated detached exact-head worktree; supervisor neither authors nor self-certifies", + "f8PlanEvaluationRoute": "canonical native-quota PLAN-EVAL fallback: fresh Minimax M3/high over OpenRouter; terminal PASS required before the later product repair", + "attempt4Next": "superseded by attempt-5 terminal red and attribution recovery" + } + }, + "planDecisionBoundary": "cycle 1 ruled direct emitted { queryKey: Queries.list.clientKey() } with no SDK overload; repair must lock generator-owned output paths, existing service generate overwrite/dry-run/force compatibility, package README homes, post-mutation request-count proof, per-slice paths, and qualified citations", + "expensiveGateContract": "both gates are load-bearing after cheap convergence: scaffold.runtime uses its suite-owned release-gate command/evidence plus central lease (never run-gate catalog); fresh-browser uses the catalog receipt; run serially only after coordinator grant", + "receiptRefs": [] + }, + { + "id": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "lane": "features", + "phase": "merged", + "baseBranch": "main", + "headSha": "12276e6d86403ed1340ef79a963e87d401d643e9", + "currentPrHeadSha": "ec69100c89195adb776c4cef3724c8c3683c553c", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "3e0c8858b4a2552926d2965b62cbcc97a15c2935", + "evaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "implementationEvaluationVerdict": "PASS_CONDITIONAL", + "implementationEvaluatorAgentId": "2a8cf0a6-7529-4ca6-97ce-69edcca3f84d", + "implementationEvaluatorCommitSha": "0e302ad3a5915b7a820adcac0a9d5bdc2d7d0019", + "focusedAmendmentState": "complete", + "focusedAmendmentGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T07:47:32.000Z", + "focusedAmendmentTopicCheckpointSha": "1bfc1cfcdff6d39c75f7190d1b79750f55b966c0", + "focusedAmendmentContentHeadSha": "67e12f02165089ec7431b72d1294147477906282", + "focusedAmendmentEvidenceHeadSha": "d45a92ba70e78cc1ff42617ca15f6782f4ea8c21", + "focusedAmendmentCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1651#issuecomment-5301282095", + "focusedAmendmentGateVerdicts": { + "check": "PASS", + "test": "PASS", + "publish-dry-run": "PASS", + "arch-check": "PASS", + "docs-source-format": "PASS", + "docs-accuracy": "PASS" + }, + "focusedAmendmentPrBodyState": "corrected", + "focusedAmendmentTierAState": "ACCEPTED_WITH_FINDINGS_EDITORIAL_CLOSED", + "focusedAmendmentTierATopicCheckpointSha": "f7da0e6fbc02d2fa1e326f9b914200c86ace706c", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluationState": "complete", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluatedContentHeadSha": "67e12f02165089ec7431b72d1294147477906282", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluatedEvidenceHeadSha": "d45a92ba70e78cc1ff42617ca15f6782f4ea8c21", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluatorAgentId": "e8cd9765-9f6c-4418-bbc2-4a24f221f2d4", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluatorBridgeSessionId": "session_01Cwg2ukqsMkwpuca5xhzVaG", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluatorCommitSha": "ec69100c89195adb776c4cef3724c8c3683c553c", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluationVerdict": "PASS", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluationCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1651#issuecomment-5301336480", + "focusedAmendmentFinalEvaluationCompletedAt": "2026-08-15T08:18:27.000Z", + "ownerDispositionCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1651#issuecomment-5301349600", + "readinessState": "complete", + "mergeCommitSha": "284dda90a17a13a7e5e8e9834e5411b58887131b", + "mergedAt": "2026-08-15T08:28:46.000Z", + "issueCompletionState": "closed_completed", + "ownerMergeHold": { + "commentId": 5300440887, + "reason": "RFC 0003/#1490 overlap audit found #1651 distinct overall but C6 ownership and adapter boundaries require an owner disposition before amendment", + "state": "resolved_keep_and_narrow", + "auditVerdict": "AMENDMENT_AUTHORIZED", + "ownerVerdict": "keep-and-narrow", + "decidedAt": "2026-08-15T07:40:16.000Z", + "decisionOptions": [ + "keep-and-narrow", + "remove-or-defer-c6", + "close-as-duplicate" + ], + "amendmentBoundary": { + "pluginCliOwnership": "generic CLI contribution workspace-plan execution, preview/apply safety, common staging/check/commit/rollback, and contribution-level doctor states", + "rfc0003Ownership": "command-store domain planning, provider selection, Prisma schema and models, migration creation/application/refusal, generated command-store bridge and transaction-client types, database-specific validation, and business-command transaction semantics", + "adapterLaw": "RFC 0003/#1490 may produce a domain plan through the shared CLI executor but neither side reimplements the other's owned semantics", + "forbiddenCliClaims": "C6 does not parse Prisma schemas, choose provider SQL/indexes, own migration lifecycle, or define command-store receipts/audit/outbox behavior", + "forbiddenRfc0003Claims": "RFC 0003/#1490 does not define a second generic CLI plugin mount or workspace staging/rollback engine", + "doctorBoundary": "C6 reports generic registry/plan/journal health; RFC 0003/#1490 reports command-store schema/migration/bridge health", + "previewInvariant": "the planner returns the same canonical plan in preview and apply; preview affects only host execution and mutation", + "formalReview": "fresh opposite-family Tier-A followed by one bounded final IMPL-EVAL over the amendment and prior conditional body correction" + } + }, + "issueNumbers": [1502], + "implementerAgentId": "019ffcc5-d3e1-7c13-9815-e9956ec43683", + "evaluatorAgentId": "28cc8106-967b-4fb7-90f3-dd95054ae953", + "branch": "docs/rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "worktree": "/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features-1502", + "receiptRefs": [] + } + ], + "evaluatorLeases": [ + { + "id": "reset-gate-01-harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling-impl-eval", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "dispatchOrder": 1, + "sourceHead": "4d9fb196765cbf1a6bc7eaa7c18ec82b237ab89f", + "implementationParent": "634b257ea1afcedb2d7f1da486d8c9e9432a2a86", + "evaluatorAgentId": "1afc9054-cc28-48a8-9fc4-86ae2e3bb28d", + "backgroundAgentId": "1afc9054", + "pid": 2430432, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_011426qed3eW6SpmKxrMnzHN", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_011426qed3eW6SpmKxrMnzHN", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-14T23:04:51.000Z", + "attachedAt": "2026-08-14T23:06:32.000Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-14T23:14:56.438Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "d6e6a6788cd38127f822d192f37557106dad4ebc" + }, + { + "id": "reset-gate-02-legacy-port-pin-sweep-impl-eval", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "dispatchOrder": 2, + "sourceHead": "e6ba15ec6414c0a42b1f9870791131162ea71c36", + "evaluatorAgentId": "8c47751a-6a30-4dab-b25c-dbafe9873455", + "backgroundAgentId": "8c47751a", + "pid": 2450732, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01LmSFUzxkHGuH98fiDhgHxH", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01LmSFUzxkHGuH98fiDhgHxH", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "low", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-14T23:16:24.161Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-14T23:20:50.477Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "a949a6cd1777b0d05b1a3b45143de15951aa6dc2" + }, + { + "id": "reset-gate-03-rfc-plugin-cli-contribution-plan-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "dispatchOrder": 3, + "sourceHead": "12276e6d86403ed1340ef79a963e87d401d643e9", + "evaluatorAgentId": "28cc8106-967b-4fb7-90f3-dd95054ae953", + "backgroundAgentId": "28cc8106", + "pid": 2463708, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01D7t8efMh88nwR2PazUPkC1", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01D7t8efMh88nwR2PazUPkC1", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-14T23:17:07.633Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-14T23:24:37.813Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "3e0c8858b4a2552926d2965b62cbcc97a15c2935" + }, + { + "id": "reset-gate-04-quality-scan-allowance-rail-plan-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "dispatchOrder": 4, + "sourceHead": "09dfb092dccf7f843b9270295047d674a8187362", + "evaluatorAgentId": "b6c48f02-cb56-4dae-abfd-e46bdec05bd5", + "backgroundAgentId": "b6c48f02", + "pid": 2467808, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01Et9Y4vPf8i9ZMTwiqykvXr", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01Et9Y4vPf8i9ZMTwiqykvXr", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-14T23:18:58.036Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-14T23:24:44.178Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "c694cfb311d378f4796280649042c8c275c828ed" + }, + { + "id": "reset-gate-05-scaffold-generated-output-correctness-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "blocked", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "dispatchOrder": 5, + "sourceHead": "14d8b38b4db7ba0635cbbcac2f8cd8903bee0ec9", + "evaluatorAgentId": "bd703a7d-4757-4689-a603-5ca98f7d7323", + "backgroundAgentId": "bd703a7d", + "pid": 2470890, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_015wwEYoUsxCwzT3PQeSqi2A", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_015wwEYoUsxCwzT3PQeSqi2A", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-14T23:26:20.976Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-14T23:34:26.942Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "13008abf83734884f7fcfc71e6d6d9facb24bcbf" + }, + { + "id": "reset-gate-06-comparison-docs-programme-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "docs", + "leafId": "comparison-docs-programme", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "dispatchOrder": 6, + "sourceHead": "d35cbca30872d1f55118d63437638e93270c2ac3", + "evaluatorAgentId": "40a06314-b69a-4ca0-a4a0-1224c5e377ca", + "backgroundAgentId": "40a06314", + "pid": 2465471, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_0126JRYrbXqvoJwskcF31RwW", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_0126JRYrbXqvoJwskcF31RwW", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "low", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-14T23:18:01.067Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-14T23:29:49.147Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "a790e91e26a4fb84636b4f3c57bd6444196b4ca9" + }, + { + "id": "reset-gate-05-scaffold-generated-output-correctness-plan-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "dispatchOrder": 5, + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "5b3c6fcf21b0b4947a770d8e67ea5cc8082724d5", + "evaluatorAgentId": "06451c1e-a9b8-47d2-8934-be2247ef5347", + "backgroundAgentId": "06451c1e", + "pid": 2487919, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01AFoKjRXMVCaXUzJ9HqDvGt", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01AFoKjRXMVCaXUzJ9HqDvGt", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-14T23:48:25.792Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-14T23:54:29.079Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "b8fc5eb53a530d337602f7dc377239651a57d428" + }, + { + "id": "quality-scan-allowance-rail-impl-eval", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "sourceHead": "2d5e4f5ae15345d80c21c8c4da03f1667d3889bb", + "evaluatorAgentId": "430d5f91-a073-4f4f-991a-8a7eefc7ddb3", + "backgroundAgentId": "430d5f91", + "pid": 2546333, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01NFwTgbof8vAYdg9wex15fM", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01NFwTgbof8vAYdg9wex15fM", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "high", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T03:50:49.028Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T04:08:43.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "84bbcf9a185a1bc29072f1feecc1b7d08f3f18b2" + }, + { + "id": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution-impl-eval", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "sourceHead": "04d431028c1fe455dc18c05e3fa0779e7b593046", + "evaluatorAgentId": "2a8cf0a6-7529-4ca6-97ce-69edcca3f84d", + "backgroundAgentId": "2a8cf0a6", + "pid": 2718910, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01Y48WxcCgzUAWfJmGmhBykc", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01Y48WxcCgzUAWfJmGmhBykc", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "high", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T03:50:58.194Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T04:05:30.689Z", + "verdict": "PASS_CONDITIONAL", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "0e302ad3a5915b7a820adcac0a9d5bdc2d7d0019" + }, + { + "id": "quality-scan-allowance-rail-impl-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "84bbcf9a185a1bc29072f1feecc1b7d08f3f18b2", + "evaluatorAgentId": "31c4cfa9-6610-4813-a4d2-482080fc562e", + "backgroundAgentId": "31c4cfa9", + "pid": 24563, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01A8dNQhZgaysPzhnEDm2MrA", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01A8dNQhZgaysPzhnEDm2MrA", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "high", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T04:38:08.778Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T04:54:02.899Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "70177e80821a916c83ffa72041c6bb24bbb6ccc8" + }, + { + "id": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness-impl-eval", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "f178ac663597a7b9cfd2e6a528026426d39d1173", + "evaluatorAgentId": "19f1be7b-db7d-47c0-b0f1-7cfca302d44a", + "backgroundAgentId": "19f1be7b", + "pid": 105686, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01Qs22iAtnVYh2fLb26ABvja", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01Qs22iAtnVYh2fLb26ABvja", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T05:14:52.510Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T05:21:53.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "70843d169d4e7f4c8f810d663a142cc66b7969ff", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1654#issuecomment-5300713042" + }, + { + "id": "comparison-docs-programme-impl-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "docs", + "leafId": "comparison-docs-programme", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "15429cf8487cfe3504ae0443fd435d2a72d4528b", + "evaluatorAgentId": "c6950ed9-7405-4f28-9464-1e1977f2979c", + "backgroundAgentId": "c6950ed9", + "pid": 138125, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01QjkTyGWr2HSHrLLVLdfhCR", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01QjkTyGWr2HSHrLLVLdfhCR", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T05:38:37.962Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T05:46:49.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "e95f4838038a27a0f209d2ce37c9f53bd4ed4299", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1652#issuecomment-5300794391" + }, + { + "id": "quality-scan-root-coverage-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "quality-scan-root-coverage", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "da76d9d8440a969f0715ca035ea6304bbf039efd", + "evaluatorAgentId": "97ef1950-cda3-450e-9451-052a15015b3a", + "backgroundAgentId": "97ef1950", + "pid": 145718, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01BA2jJuyVsFhRJkVKoTMihe", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01BA2jJuyVsFhRJkVKoTMihe", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T05:39:01.786Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T05:47:21.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "3b95a004fe8bc5c022c7a2601fafef9a1216be68", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1656#issuecomment-5300796497" + }, + { + "id": "comparison-docs-programme-impl-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "docs", + "leafId": "comparison-docs-programme", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "c7ce58a19494024c219e9970deeb3ece878232d6", + "evaluatorAgentId": "4ed649d5-9d62-4e24-a50a-081477607cee", + "backgroundAgentId": "4ed649d5", + "pid": 145190, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_013RN66nBipHogdecXX4uZ9G", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_013RN66nBipHogdecXX4uZ9G", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T06:10:11.000Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T06:21:47.551Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "71cc5a02cde091f862c9892464ea77cc962b3675", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1652#issuecomment-5300916189" + }, + { + "id": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate-impl-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "939e7311317365db7681de5e3c7c56a73412424e", + "evaluatorAgentId": "04897102-bcd6-4918-8b72-dc0151035883", + "backgroundAgentId": "04897102", + "pid": 202494, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01GbqPgckdxHEZzXzNu7DKNp", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01GbqPgckdxHEZzXzNu7DKNp", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T06:36:29.000Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T06:48:56.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "a46b83831fca037d8a8fa309da849200653c7730", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5301015059" + }, + { + "id": "quality-scan-root-coverage-impl-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "quality-scan-root-coverage", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "2c4881fd7b01c2c5dabb6e76009bb5412b2538b2", + "evaluatorAgentId": "ee2825f2-a67f-4d65-8c7f-b1956f695ded", + "backgroundAgentId": "ee2825f2", + "pid": 258234, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01CiPTc5FQJLqr1JLGZZD3Hx", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01CiPTc5FQJLqr1JLGZZD3Hx", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T06:43:00.000Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T06:53:06.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "addba1ab977ed194dbce73deccfa94cac268e807", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1656#issuecomment-5301029660" + }, + { + "id": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate-impl-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "3d7819203f59e68eb5b45f6871a03c41ca43cd2f", + "evaluatorAgentId": "1df19d27-ce81-4027-99ac-49f3b9ec26bc", + "backgroundAgentId": "1df19d27", + "bridgeSessionId": "session_018WYHfqzFKKve37TL7hsPQD", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_018WYHfqzFKKve37TL7hsPQD", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T07:10:00.000Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T07:32:36.157Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "ed9ee76636db864031762c3a874db2e06e6353d3", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1657#issuecomment-5301157020" + }, + { + "id": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "cea999d18ea2c2d4a6208fc209ce744d9be1d194", + "evaluatorAgentId": "7d544aec-22cc-4656-8483-6d957dbfbfda", + "backgroundAgentId": "7d544aec", + "pid": 347868, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01N9zhX5ZDUvvrBxcwoAYBCm", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01N9zhX5ZDUvvrBxcwoAYBCm", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T07:44:39.000Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T07:54:58.339Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "e15d78588503f4a83d6322be9039abe1f52190a1", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301255122" + }, + { + "id": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation-impl-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "e3c74d7aaf3b7734b5a44a5be248c01f004c21e5", + "evaluatorAgentId": "cb917802-ee26-4b89-86b9-0eee33c7de1b", + "backgroundAgentId": "cb917802", + "pid": 520689, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01Kwmr8XjoznnQsHUnkmfcnV", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01Kwmr8XjoznnQsHUnkmfcnV", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T09:28:00.000Z", + "attachedAt": "2026-08-15T09:28:23.000Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T09:35:59.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "8d6b4726cf6663ff3ca1a3c5f9a6fe1d20d300e9" + }, + { + "id": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal-impl-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "f46d84630c54210a09ff4ed39537da1e66964a52", + "evaluatorAgentId": "740d2a3a-1677-459c-a6b1-a39398649d1a", + "backgroundAgentId": "740d2a3a", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01NVeBmZE7SwH3Nvu3ep51zV", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01NVeBmZE7SwH3Nvu3ep51zV", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-opus-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T09:38:04.000Z", + "startedAt": "2026-08-15T09:40:04.876Z", + "routeResolution": "Fable availability probe e58c5f01 failed before inference with zero tokens and no mutation; this Opus fallback is cycle 1", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T09:54:05.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "8f62a61213df890101b6f7dfc07a042928f2d536", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1658#issuecomment-5301699397" + }, + { + "id": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation-impl-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "df05344166adaeb2b8e2f2f6ec741e1032d29045", + "evaluatorAgentId": "eb7149da-1689-44af-970e-ddd6e78022fa", + "backgroundAgentId": "eb7149da", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01CaAEKsH35CP2QgfNUVdXK1", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01CaAEKsH35CP2QgfNUVdXK1", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T09:52:40.000Z", + "startedAt": "2026-08-15T09:52:52.080Z", + "evaluationFocus": "independently re-prove cycle-1 F-1 is closed by the RED-to-GREEN registration-signal lifetime repair", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T09:57:01.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "4766b258f0d61108e4240720365b9ab078f6a111", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1661#issuecomment-5301708486" + }, + { + "id": "prisma-mysql-adapter-surface-impl-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "prisma-mysql-adapter-surface", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "d8d255bdc103eb120cc7b8835dfe3ce870017c32", + "evaluatorAgentId": "e64f33f0-c88e-4fc7-9e79-63c01fed94db", + "backgroundAgentId": "e64f33f0", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01XrFMbPHpry6tL3v9ZmRsLK", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01XrFMbPHpry6tL3v9ZmRsLK", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T10:11:15.000Z", + "startedAt": "2026-08-15T10:11:25.517Z", + "evaluationFocus": "R1-R3 compliance, public query-contract compatibility, notifier boundary behavior, split-close truthfulness, exact-head receipts, raw D7 evidence, and scope hygiene", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T10:16:31.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "f52aa471c0b4e8fe44b7d0e231c69f58b52dc9bf", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1662#issuecomment-5301776738" + }, + { + "id": "package-gate-honesty-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "package-gate-honesty", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff", + "evaluatorAgentId": "9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be", + "backgroundAgentId": "9078ecb6", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_0176qkbF4eKUt7TxJiEPdTrk", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T10:35:39.952Z", + "evaluationFocus": "six-path scope boundary, supported config exclusion, import.meta package roots, non-tautological score-gap mutation tests, honest two-member JSR evidence, runtime-gate necessity, and slice/checklist reconciliation", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T10:43:00.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "be2b1872823cbbb07a393633fcccb684f753afc1", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1663#issuecomment-5301867229" + }, + { + "id": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation-repair-delta-impl-eval-cycle-3", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 3, + "sourceHead": "de89440119ba45822f0bdc8350838088a6f04140", + "evaluatorAgentId": "8a0ff845-1d0a-43d6-ae3c-03b4158f7943", + "backgroundAgentId": "8a0ff845", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_013K3BZ2ydVkYzXt6vgcxTJX", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T10:36:12.512Z", + "evaluationFocus": "proportionate one-file computed-import repair delta and its CLI/publish blast radius; cycle-2 product verdict remains otherwise authoritative", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T10:44:56.894Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "f74695bc4d0b916ed52ae922d96263f00c5ca6df", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1661#issuecomment-5301873258" + }, + { + "id": "app-service-client-wiring-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "app-service-client-wiring", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "7f20a34fee4e99ac17edb6ed4de06a3ec9c1934b", + "evaluatorAgentId": "176aace4-b2a2-4b16-bdaa-9db687c7d132", + "backgroundAgentId": "176aace4", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01TiYhwUCkdyjziEpFP3kgaS", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01TiYhwUCkdyjziEpFP3kgaS", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T11:02:50.000Z", + "startedAt": "2026-08-15T11:03:18.527Z", + "evaluationFocus": "public SDK/generator boundary, backwards compatibility, exact multi-service query-key isolation, mutation-triggered refetch observability, hydration timestamp behavior, release-gate evidence classes, and expensive-gate lease preconditions", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T11:08:17.776Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "ed34105e2ef344a5b590bca6985810f45f89b0ca", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5301947232" + }, + { + "id": "app-service-client-wiring-plan-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "app-service-client-wiring", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "f7225be98c01b38f86712c1df0782aec06e34445", + "evaluatorAgentId": "8c756943-11c8-45a2-84ab-8c8392898723", + "backgroundAgentId": "8c756943", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01UrhsQgBYpLZWHKAhCvESi6", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01UrhsQgBYpLZWHKAhCvESi6", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T11:19:25.000Z", + "evaluationFocus": "cycle-1 ruling discharge, owned output paths, SDK 0.0.6 compatibility, whole-command generation behavior, migration docs, falsifiable request-count and hydration proofs, and gate-class integrity", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T11:22:31.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "c53726c69b98a35bf293b89aeece12279f470be3", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5301997528" + }, + { + "id": "package-gate-honesty-plan-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "package-gate-honesty", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "df1d7a96d7fd4ecca0bd61710ba90ff67449da0b", + "evaluatorAgentId": "517ac0e7", + "backgroundAgentId": "517ac0e7", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T11:24:31.000Z", + "evaluationFocus": "12-path plan feasibility, child-only marker and nearest-config batching, exact 114-file selection, named healthy-file coverage, prototype-only formatting equivalence, negative controls, and matrix-n/a runtime disposition", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T11:33:42.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "c415daad2af38690c6195b02c4e949bdc8c8ae6c", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1663#issuecomment-5302030430", + "ownerBoundary": "two ordinary PLAN-EVAL failures exhausted; one exceptional third and final fresh native claude-fable-5 / medium / Remote Control PLAN-EVAL requires explicit owner authorization" + }, + { + "id": "reference-export-drift-gate-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "a3f6b87b599e778db950daf6ccaecd847c088d19", + "evaluatorAgentId": "68c31fcc-f93b-496f-8c0b-10e6736dded7", + "backgroundAgentId": "68c31fcc", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01DcmCJnvESF3a4nVDvUR8u8", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01DcmCJnvESF3a4nVDvUR8u8", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T16:46:12.000Z", + "evaluationFocus": "SA-1 tenth-path durable refusal coverage, truthful coverage accounting, generated reference/docs build chain, public SDK and workflow wiring, explicit browser waiver risk, #1666-before-#1533 sequencing, and strict artifact-only scope", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T16:52:58.569Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_PLAN", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "5d229e0f399fdafa4e9b8194d0ce8e57c158e5e2", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303254623", + "blockingFinding": "three additional shipped Contracts JSDoc examples import symbols from the non-exporting root; plan incorrectly claimed issue #1296 row 1 was otherwise satisfied" + }, + { + "id": "reference-export-drift-gate-plan-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "80046696e6b192c5448aba6b3b0b619faeabac21", + "evaluatorAgentId": "0e2d1e57-c093-4d14-87fe-bab55fd8f020", + "backgroundAgentId": "0e2d1e57", + "pid": 397181, + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01K6SbsotG5MyjyjTd11SrfK", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01K6SbsotG5MyjyjTd11SrfK", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "remoteControlProof": "initial session 580832d7-53e8-4828-ad41-e2f9219c9340 completed verification then received Request interrupted by user before artifact; same history resumed without a verdict as job 0e2d1e57, session 0e2d1e57-c093-4d14-87fe-bab55fd8f020, PID 397181, bridge cse_01K6SbsotG5MyjyjTd11SrfK, Fable 5/medium/Remote Control", + "transportInterruption": { + "interruptedSessionId": "580832d7-53e8-4828-ad41-e2f9219c9340", + "interruptedPid": 379716, + "state": "recovered_same_evaluator_history_no_verdict_no_cycle_consumed" + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T17:15:29.000Z", + "evaluationFocus": "SA-2 full shipped Contracts import inventory, honest Closes #1296, thirteen-path/fourteenth-refusal discipline, injectable fail-closed policy seam, honest residual-red behavior, per-package coverage visibility, corrected existing CI enforcement/discoverability boundary, Pages/root task mechanics, and JSR prose-only proportionality", + "finalOrdinaryCycle": true, + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T17:29:51.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "45c249b9c16ee075435d11b827c94beca1f87ce2", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303401348" + }, + { + "id": "sdk-cached-entry-swr-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "sdk-cached-entry-swr", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "23db20f301d06ed1e4a9a65cbbf64349f89cb8c0", + "evaluatorAgentId": "01f0eda8-24fe-41b0-919e-7426579ab868", + "backgroundAgentId": "01f0eda8", + "pid": 391331, + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01SWnk7LwvoLaamvEwR5WLfX", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01SWnk7LwvoLaamvEwR5WLfX", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T17:23:00.000Z", + "evaluationFocus": "no-new-public-API remedy, callable-action then KV-metadata composition, persistence-complete policy-aware single-flight, deterministic two-overlapping-reader proof, #1665 fail-safe preservation, exact two-page published claim dispositions, and four-mirror generated cascade closure", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T17:34:00.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "d555cc9719fc81b7b5d6656471132c1a921fd5cf", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1669#issuecomment-5303412171" + }, + { + "id": "reference-export-drift-gate-impl-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "47ca22abe94b9d2e54d3778edc8944094b227886", + "evidenceHead": "d095c1260a2474f3ae16cd5b17f3bfcbbada9c94", + "evaluatorAgentId": "3882ca70-7857-46ca-aa24-8b1ae2664516", + "backgroundAgentId": "3882ca70", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_013RnnFDtHQhEbFhJCLbkEsD", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_013RnnFDtHQhEbFhJCLbkEsD", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T18:25:26.499Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T18:38:01.455Z", + "evaluationFocus": "issue 1296 acceptance, durable fail-closed refusal coverage, truthful per-package accounting, Contracts/Fresh UI reference truth, single-execution discoverability wiring, JSR/pins/baseline reds, scope/lock, seven-receipt sufficiency, and NOT_RUN waiver honesty", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "4c09e9203afee52b43c10dfa1246eb0473ad7e40", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303665087", + "blockingFinding": "three refusal tests pass for an unrelated NotFound or masked OMITS cause; repair is test-only on an already-authorized path and all other re-derived judgments hold" + }, + { + "id": "reference-export-drift-gate-impl-eval-cycle-2", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 2, + "sourceHead": "4238670173271bca4281eba7db6c2030d046bc73", + "evidenceHead": "010da98a230503bb27b46eb0edc5e979929f7fb1", + "evaluatorAgentId": "7a3b4645-5548-42e6-84fa-35c1f90158dd", + "backgroundAgentId": "7a3b4645", + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01MDMbe68iYvjHBLuUGKZqBS", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01MDMbe68iYvjHBLuUGKZqBS", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T19:06:43.295Z", + "evaluationFocus": "cycle-1 refusal-test finding discharge, four independent mutation reds, replacement receipt integrity including preserved scratch-contaminated red, and complete re-derivation of issue 1296 acceptance, scope, lock, baseline reds, CI discoverability, and NOT_RUN waiver", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T19:12:52.602Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "ee67d12b4023b62241c2b2aeeec2f27f33b38747", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5303804773", + "briefCorrection": "two stale short-SHA sentences named the cycle-1 receipt head 47ca22abe, contradicting the correct cycle-2 binding section; the evaluator independently used 423867017 throughout its artifact and verdict, so the stale text had no impact" + }, + { + "id": "sdk-cached-entry-swr-impl-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "sdk-cached-entry-swr", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "eba0b092416831f5fada679a1c21247d065ca521", + "evidenceHead": "9aa54ae2d4f53c705b0309ed472abf7bbccebe41", + "evaluatorAgentId": "f40814ce-5b41-49ae-8cf2-e65014de01de", + "backgroundAgentId": "f40814ce", + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01CMrdm9P2YwHxiNCT49C4Hf", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01CMrdm9P2YwHxiNCT49C4Hf", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T19:07:12.951Z", + "evaluationFocus": "S1 persistence-complete policy-aware single-flight, S2 stale-only fresh preference, deterministic overlap proofs, exact two-page published wording and A1/A4 manual evidence, four-mirror generated closure, honest baseline reds, receipt sufficiency, and no-new-public-API boundary", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T19:24:37.126Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "313cc08d572ea7db1764abf2efdcc11f7a63abde", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1669#issuecomment-5303850473" + }, + { + "id": "sdk-typed-error-channel-plan-eval-cycle-1", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "sdk-typed-error-channel", + "phase": "plan-eval", + "cycle": 1, + "sourceHead": "2fa2f71dc5b498c16221461439e53b9f5dc1d5d5", + "evaluatorAgentId": "50898ac7-6e79-4f31-ae18-694bb36b7c79", + "backgroundAgentId": "50898ac7", + "pid": 636411, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_015RuDy1h3UiCkLzo1PLk5Sc", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_015RuDy1h3UiCkLzo1PLk5Sc", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T20:12:35.647Z", + "evaluationFocus": "live ownership boundary, exact six-path sufficiency, breaking published contract, base RED, six literal errors, empty metadata slot, docs completeness, and absence of product mutation", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T20:19:58.223Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "f76a3c45bce42cab81c2b481d4abf03be1104bb0", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1671#issuecomment-5304059808" + }, + { + "id": "reference-export-drift-gate-delta-impl-eval", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 3, + "sourceHead": "46528ae4c71b3744f0af64bd749d01d831f70c89", + "evidenceHead": "b67414f4f26d53f00fc50adf3a5787d3bffae077", + "evaluatorAgentId": "f281b8cf-f4bb-4125-a0ba-d79b6a8e11ad", + "backgroundAgentId": "f281b8cf", + "pid": 793975, + "bridgeSessionId": "session_01UDGunAVYYPRC6KBNxEwZWA", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01UDGunAVYYPRC6KBNxEwZWA", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T20:22:51.101Z", + "evaluationFocus": "fresh delta re-derivation of four-output cascade and idempotence, both root-test receipts and quarantine attribution, 17-path ceiling, lock identity, CLI/MCP publication selection, known reds, issue 1296 acceptance, and NOT_RUN boundaries", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T20:32:17.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "0d4c82d6e4bd327abd88eb8b80e7a7acd20ea4aa", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304103041" + }, + { + "id": "reference-export-drift-gate-integration-delta-impl-eval", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 4, + "sourceHead": "8c03d862931b64573df9a4bac76ebf266e0ec175", + "evidenceHead": "021c7ffc62cea5b0f6728ddb8ee377393a647f44", + "evaluatorAgentId": "be3774eb-9bc8-4cd1-bcd8-9cc59fd2a0a8", + "backgroundAgentId": "be3774eb", + "pid": 807626, + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T21:03:05.052Z", + "evaluationFocus": "current-main integration delta only: history-preserving merge, exact four-output generated union from #1665 plus #1666, two-run convergence/no fifth output, 12 exact-content-head receipts, 14-of-17 scope, lock identity, prior known reds, and NOT_RUN boundaries", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T21:12:10.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "05ac90d00706d4bd9f3d93a59ab58bcdbfea5909", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304256350", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV" + }, + { + "id": "reference-export-drift-gate-quality-repair-delta-impl-eval", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "internals", + "leafId": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "phase": "impl-eval", + "cycle": 5, + "sourceHead": "e357938df82b2a87ccc69ac3217c165c16572930", + "evaluatorAgentId": "dc433b8d-a72c-4d8f-ab50-b28a566d3968", + "backgroundAgentId": "dc433b8d", + "bridgeSessionId": "cse_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC", + "remoteControlUrl": "https://claude.ai/code/session_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC", + "route": { + "provider": "native-claude", + "model": "claude-fable-5", + "effort": "medium", + "remoteControlRequired": true + }, + "transportProof": "bridgeOutboundOnly false; respawn flags include --remote-control, --effort medium, and --model claude-fable-5", + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T21:36:02.176Z", + "evaluationFocus": "post-cycle-4 type-safety repair delta plus preservation of accepted integration truth: exact changed-file scan, discriminating malformed-shape behavior, no scanner weakening, unchanged generator cascade and lock, append-only prior evidence, and issue #1296 acceptance", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T21:50:06.393Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "evaluatorCommitSha": "92988da30a4468f5ea77ea4e5a3e243469f92e52", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1666#issuecomment-5304391856" + } + ], + "expensiveGates": [ + { + "id": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness-runtime", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "gateId": "scaffold.runtime", + "preGateHead": "ebad68c80bc9079ba835901eb2245a1a31ab7b62", + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T04:02:33.167Z", + "scope": "one isolated scaffold.runtime verdict covering issues 1262, 1263, and 1588; Aspire/Docker cleanup mandatory", + "attempt": 2, + "retryGrantedAt": "2026-08-15T04:38:12.147Z", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T04:55:26.483Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "receiptRefs": [ + ".llm/runs/fix-scaffold-generated-output-correctness--0.0.7-wave0/receipts/scaffold-runtime.json", + ".llm/runs/fix-scaffold-generated-output-correctness--0.0.7-wave0/receipts/leak-check.json" + ], + "attempt1": { + "state": "interrupted_no_verdict", + "lastCompletedGate": "database.migration-artifacts", + "interruptedAtGate": "database.generate", + "cleanup": "complete" + } + }, + { + "id": "design-registry-catalog-drift-fresh-browser", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "fixes", + "leafId": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "gateId": "fresh-browser", + "preGateHead": "4a3c40321ac1e58aa337e02afeaa95fbc553ce7f", + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T06:07:21.000Z", + "scope": "one contract-approved Playwright/Chromium fresh-browser pass for PR #1657; no Aspire, Docker, or Postgres; stray browser/runtime cleanup and empty-host recheck mandatory", + "attempt": 1, + "command": "deno run --allow-read --allow-write --allow-run --allow-env .llm/tools/gates/run-gate.ts --gate fresh-browser --id fresh-browser-1657 --cwd packages/fresh --output .llm/runs/fix-design-registry-catalog-drift-gate--0.0.7-wave1/receipts/fresh-browser.json", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T06:13:10.000Z", + "verdict": "PASS", + "receiptRefs": [ + ".llm/runs/fix-design-registry-catalog-drift-gate--0.0.7-wave1/receipts/fresh-browser.json" + ], + "cleanup": { + "chromiumPlaywrightSurvivors": 0, + "aspirePostcondition": "empty", + "dockerPostcondition": "empty", + "playwrightInstallNeeded": false, + "lockfilesChanged": false + } + }, + { + "id": "app-service-client-wiring-f3-runtime", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "app-service-client-wiring", + "gateId": "scaffold.runtime_then_fresh-browser", + "preGateHead": "8940e9266630a3cc5368153722747e45d30aec3b", + "contentHead": "193e665ba0592273622253e3e9a1ebfc019b1be9", + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T16:43:09.204Z", + "attempt": 2, + "scope": "run scaffold.runtime first through the suite-owned release command and preserve its receipt; mandatory Aspire/Docker cleanup and clean inter-gate audit; only on PASS run fresh-browser serially through the catalog receipt, then browser/runtime cleanup and a final empty-host audit", + "runHead": "ab78eaa35c1753f9e8c526dbd234c7073758008b", + "evidenceHead": "e1dcb726b983dd10981f4fc8df5ea8c638686e77", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T16:53:06.441Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "summary": "scaffold.runtime 20 passed / 1 failed / 0 skipped; generated.service-client-contract rejected three post-plugin Aspire-helper writes; fresh-browser NOT_RUN", + "receiptRefs": [ + ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/reports/s5-scaffold-runtime-20260815-184907.log", + ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/reports/s5-runtime-failure.md", + ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/leak-report.md" + ], + "cleanup": { + "aspirePostcondition": "ok_empty", + "dockerPostcondition": "ok_empty", + "survivors": 0, + "freshBrowser": "NOT_RUN" + } + }, + { + "id": "app-service-client-wiring-f4-runtime", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "app-service-client-wiring", + "gateId": "scaffold.runtime_then_fresh-browser", + "preGateHead": "6f813b0db35df38dcd9dc7f1ea333e997399fac0", + "contentHead": "7876aa10911c2eeea4aafb217d651b28a90bac2c", + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T17:11:14.000Z", + "attempt": 3, + "scope": "run suite-owned scaffold.runtime first at the immutable final evidence head; preserve the exact raw result; mandatory Aspire/Docker cleanup and clean inter-gate audit; only on PASS run catalog-backed fresh-browser serially, then browser/runtime cleanup and a final empty-host audit; no evaluator until both gates and topic reconciliation are terminal", + "preflight": { + "leafState": "clean_local_remote_pr_equal", + "dockerContainers": 0, + "aspireApplicationProcesses": 0, + "relevantListeningPorts": 0, + "otherLeaseOwners": 0, + "idleAspireMcpHelpers": "foreign_tooling_preserved" + }, + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T17:19:05.522Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "summary": "scaffold.runtime passed 32 gates then failed generated.deno-fmt-check; repaired service-client contract passed; fresh-browser NOT_RUN", + "cleanup": { + "aspirePostcondition": "ok_empty", + "dockerPostcondition": "ok_empty", + "survivors": 0, + "freshBrowser": "NOT_RUN" + } + }, + { + "id": "app-service-client-wiring-f5-runtime", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "app-service-client-wiring", + "gateId": "scaffold.runtime_then_fresh-browser", + "preGateHead": "1263f655b37d64a258619403398ca7117ea000d5", + "contentHead": "fda78ee438ea40888e5fb3870a78df70cabb8c82", + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T18:30:23.000Z", + "attempt": 4, + "scope": "run suite-owned scaffold.runtime first at immutable evidence head 1263f655b; preserve exact raw result; mandatory Aspire/Docker cleanup and clean inter-gate audit; only on PASS run catalog-backed fresh-browser serially, then browser/runtime cleanup and final empty-host audit; no evaluator until both gates and topic reconciliation are terminal", + "preflight": { + "leafState": "clean_local_remote_pr_equal", + "dockerContainers": 0, + "aspireApplicationProcesses": 0, + "relevantListeningPorts": 0, + "otherLeaseOwners": 0, + "idleAspireMcpHelpers": "foreign_tooling_preserved" + }, + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T18:48:52.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "summary": "scaffold.runtime passed 69 gates and failed behavior.service-client-refetch because cleanup killed an already-terminated child; fresh-browser NOT_RUN", + "receiptRefs": [ + ".llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/reports/s5-attempt4-scaffold-runtime-20260815-2037.log" + ], + "rawLogSha256": "b476da4ce039d03785e46669d51919b48c41fbae80ca41ca9188bcbb53e97f23", + "cleanup": { + "aspirePostcondition": "ok_empty", + "dockerPostcondition": "ok_empty", + "survivors": 0, + "freshBrowser": "NOT_RUN" + } + }, + { + "id": "app-service-client-wiring-f6-runtime", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "app-service-client-wiring", + "gateId": "scaffold.runtime_then_fresh-browser", + "preGateHead": "a8a160285d4f9bddb95a5dac6cfbde85e1265ebc", + "contentHead": "7fa29ad3ed10ad903b9cbbd518111e6bf2754761", + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T19:39:00.000Z", + "attempt": 5, + "scope": "run suite-owned scaffold.runtime once; mandatory cleanup/audit; fresh-browser only on PASS; no retry or evaluator", + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T19:47:30.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "summary": "scaffold.runtime passed 69 gates and failed behavior.service-client-refetch on DevTools target timeout; fresh-browser NOT_RUN", + "rawLogSha256": "ff349b40f7f70341934e170df7c67d147c0ed983173b41871421755ad55e062b", + "cleanup": { + "aspirePostcondition": "ok_empty", + "dockerPostcondition": "ok_empty", + "survivors": 0, + "freshBrowser": "NOT_RUN" + } + }, + { + "id": "app-service-client-wiring-f7-runtime", + "state": "complete", + "lane": "features", + "leafId": "app-service-client-wiring", + "gateId": "scaffold.runtime_then_fresh-browser", + "preGateHead": "ed3f78e0d87784b1869166bd2574737c62fac0af", + "contentHead": "e45144db643f6bde85552a615812c8371e4ce792", + "leaseOwner": "codex-root-0.0.7", + "grantedAt": "2026-08-15T20:55:30.000Z", + "attempt": 6, + "scope": "run suite-owned scaffold.runtime once with strict managed Chrome override; mandatory cleanup and independent Aspire/Docker/process/port/residue audit; only on PASS and clean audit run catalog fresh-browser once, then final cleanup/audit; no retry or evaluator", + "browserOverride": "/home/codex/.cache/ms-playwright/chromium-1234/chrome-linux64/chrome", + "preflight": { + "leafState": "clean_local_remote_pr_equal", + "dockerContainers": 0, + "aspireApplicationProcesses": 0, + "relevantListeningPorts": 0, + "unreadableResidue": 0, + "otherLeaseOwners": 0, + "staleReadableResidue": "three exact run-owned trees moved recoverably to /tmp/netscript-preattempt6-quarantine.9mNpwE" + }, + "completedAt": "2026-08-15T21:30:55.000Z", + "verdict": "FAIL_FIX", + "summary": "scaffold.runtime passed 69 and failed behavior.service-client-refetch at 900030ms / exit 143 after valid managed-Chrome selection; fresh-browser NOT_RUN", + "evidenceHead": "2385cdb72602c149c29cc637870ddca3db09e0cd", + "verdictCommentUrl": "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1664#issuecomment-5304325367", + "cleanup": { + "aspirePostcondition": "ok_empty", + "dockerPostcondition": "ok_empty", + "processPostcondition": "ok_empty_after_three_exact_run_owned_helpers_exited", + "portPostcondition": "ok_empty", + "unreadableResiduePostcondition": "ok_empty_after_recoverable_quarantine", + "quarantine": "/tmp/netscript-s5-a6-quarantine-20260815-4M9v8k", + "freshBrowser": "NOT_RUN" + } + } + ], + "canaryCheckpoints": [ + { + "id": "checkpoint-foundations", + "rationale": "Publish only after CI correctness and shared SDK/tooling foundations form a coherent, independently green main checkpoint.", + "state": "planned" + }, + { + "id": "checkpoint-feature-complete", + "rationale": "Publish the exact feature-complete main candidate before stable release qualification.", + "state": "planned" + } + ], + "exactMainEvidence": { + "gitHead": "baf1cdf67a4e931af17b4772ddf6101f36152184", + "surface": "repository", + "expectedGateIds": [ + "arch-check", + "canary-e2e-cli-prod", + "canary-oidc-publish", + "check", + "publish-dry-run", + "publish-readiness", + "quality-job", + "scaffold.runtime", + "stable-e2e-cli-prod", + "stable-oidc-publish", + "test" + ], + "receipts": [] + }, + "existingReleaseLease": false, + "releaseWriters": [], + "releaseCaptain": { + "state": "inactive", + "agentId": null, + "leaseId": null, + "contentSha": null, + "evidence": [] + }, + "updatedAt": "2026-08-15T21:42:53.000Z" +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-dependency-dag.json b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-dependency-dag.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8174c01584 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-dependency-dag.json @@ -0,0 +1,728 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "milestone": "0.0.7", + "baselineMainSha": "01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed", + "nodes": [ + { + "id": "issue:1093", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1093, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "[sdk-client S8] fix(plugin-core): let third-party plugin factories participate in discovery" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1112", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1112, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "docs(database): make the MySQL Prisma adapter example honest and executable" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1243", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1243, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "auth: session list --stream-url default pins localhost:4437 which no longer exists post-#1211" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1249", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1249, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(fresh/form): controlProps() is not element-assignable, and Zod 4 constraint derivation misses numbers and regex" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1262", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1262, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "scaffold: db seed is a placebo — SELECT 1 plus a success banner, no rows seeded" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1263", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1263, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "service: generated by-id handler returns 500 {defined:false} for a missing row instead of a defined 404" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1293", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1293, + "lane": "features", + "title": "prisma-adapter-mysql: adapter class is unexported and has no connection-error hook" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1296", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1296, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "fix(docs/exports): repair contracts and Fresh UI reference drift, then wire the regeneration gate" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1348", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1348, + "lane": "features", + "title": "Epic: Typed SDK client contributions — credentials, transport policy, metadata, and cache-safe extensions" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1349", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1349, + "lane": "features", + "title": "[sdk-client S3] feat(sdk): expose the typed oRPC client-contribution seam" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1350", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1350, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "[sdk-client S1] fix(sdk): preserve contract errors through safe() and isDefinedError" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1351", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1351, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "[sdk-client S4] refactor(sdk): centralize HTTP method and GET-cache policy" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1352", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1352, + "lane": "features", + "title": "[sdk-client S5] feat(sdk/auth): prove typed credential contributions end to end" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1353", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1353, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "[sdk-client S6] feat(sdk): express trace propagation as a general contribution" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1354", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1354, + "lane": "features", + "title": "feat(cli): no verb generates a resource route slice — the typed contract, cache-first loader and withResource page must be hand-copied from init" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1355", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1355, + "lane": "features", + "title": "feat(cli): app-side client/query wiring is a one-shot template with hardcoded names, colliding 'service' cache keys and a no-op invalidation" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1357", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1357, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(cli): ui:add page --island emits a useSignal counter and an empty queryLoaders object instead of the advertised data-screen triad" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1358", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1358, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(scaffold): the generated /design/components gallery lists 50 of 66 registry items — the whole AI collection is invisible and no gate compares them" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1360", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1360, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(scaffold): the canonical island never passes initialDataUpdatedAt, so the loader's cachedAt is computed, displayed and discarded" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1378", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1378, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "chore(quality): `quality:scan` cannot see an `any` in an exported type, an unbudgeted allowance, or a docs snippet" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1429", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1429, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "fix(agentic): leak-check cannot see orphaned Aspire process descendants, so it reports clean through a real leak" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1448", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1448, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(ai/mcp): make pool startup failure-isolated and propagate cancellation" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1451", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1451, + "lane": "features", + "title": "feat(plugin-workers): generated registry cannot consume project job policy metadata" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1452", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1452, + "lane": "features", + "title": "feat(plugin): publish reusable PluginServiceContext host factory" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1455", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1455, + "lane": "features", + "title": "workers: preserve job payload type through definition, registry, and enqueue" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1458", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1458, + "lane": "features", + "title": "feat(fresh/ai): expose awaited durable chat response completion" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1461", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1461, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "docs/sdk: getCachedEntry cache-first loader example never revalidates stale entries" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1462", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1462, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "bug(sdk): importing defineServices in a browser auto-registers the server KV cache provider" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1466", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1466, + "lane": "features", + "title": "[sdk-client S2] feat(sdk): define NetScriptProcedureMeta without erasing contract errors" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1467", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1467, + "lane": "features", + "title": "[sdk-client S7] feat(sdk): ship locale as the non-auth contribution proof" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1481", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1481, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(fresh-ui): /design ships ungated — the defect class RFC 0005 guards against" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1502", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1502, + "lane": "features", + "title": "RFC: Plugin CLI command contribution architecture — one typed mount and generation seam" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1533", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1533, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "test(docs): nothing compiles JSDoc `@example` blocks" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1542", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1542, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "fix(tooling): quality:gate roots omit published packages, so a green gate is not proof they were scanned" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1543", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1543, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "chore(deps): plugin-workers-core and plugins/triggers import plugin-streams-core without declaring it" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1544", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1544, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(cli): `emit` is advertised by three deploy adapters but never routed" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1545", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1545, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "chore(quality): register the pre-existing quality-allow population so #1378's linked-issue rule can land without a day-one red gate" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1551", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1551, + "lane": "docs", + "title": "docs(positioning): establish \"NetScript vs …\" and \"Migrate from …\" comparison framework" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1557", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1557, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "test(fresh): no capability to assert the deferred coordinator reaches the client bundle" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1561", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1561, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "fix(tooling): acceptance-evidence mirror throws on an empty entry list instead of reporting it" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1563", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1563, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "fix(agentic): verdict extractor records NONE when the token is a markdown heading" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1588", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1588, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(scaffold): omit unreachable provider URL parsers from SQLite workspaces" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1590", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1590, + "lane": "features", + "title": "Fresh partial navigation needs last-intent ordering and remount-safe region identity" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1591", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1591, + "lane": "features", + "title": "AI provider adapter needs a typed OpenAI Responses mapper" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1592", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1592, + "lane": "features", + "title": "Workers durable execution stream should publish typed progress" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1598", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1598, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "SDK cache-provider throw should name its module identity when two SDK instances are loaded" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1601", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1601, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "test(fresh): defer-island client-bundle test resolves npm:vite over the network, making the package verdict environment-dependent" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1604", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1604, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "test(cli): the prescribed `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` is always red" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1609", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1609, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(fresh): managed form silently drops navigation:'document' when mode:'client'" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1610", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1610, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(fresh): route-pattern path inference makes unknown params never instead of a compile error" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1611", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1611, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "agentic: formal evaluator dispatch helper must emit phase/head and acquire the existing claim" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1613", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1613, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "agentic: report refused OpenHands commands to their author and align generation retry across dispatch paths" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1616", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1616, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "test(cli): the scaffold emits no dynamic route, so no gate exercises dynamic route binding end to end" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1618", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1618, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "tooling: deno fmt cannot verify packages/mcp — a deliberately malformed test fixture aborts config parsing" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1619", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1619, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(sdk): cache telemetry evidence validation throws into the data path" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1620", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1620, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(sdk): cache namespace cardinality is unbounded because operationId is caller-supplied free text" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1621", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1621, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "tooling: acceptance-evidence blocks fail opaquely when the target issue has no checkbox boxes" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1622", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1622, + "lane": "internals", + "title": "mcp: the guidance closeScoreGap constant is pinned by no test — a 10x change passes green" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1623", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1623, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "docs(sdk): CacheStore.get JSDoc documents a return shape that no longer type-checks" + }, + { + "id": "issue:1637", + "kind": "issue", + "issueNumber": 1637, + "lane": "fixes", + "title": "fix(sdk): cache write limits must not fail successful query results" + } + ], + "edges": [ + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1350", + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": [ + "RFC 0001 Stage 0 (#1348) must accept the RFC and align #1349-#1353 bodies before Stage 1a implements; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1273-1274." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1466", + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 1b owner is \"selected in Stage 0; do not file in this run\"; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1275." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1349", + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 2 scope at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1276 differs from the filed #1349 acceptance in four places; Stage 0 owns the realignment." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1351", + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 3 at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1277 reassigns the deprecate-no-op-options scope and makes the oRPC family move a separate decision." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1352", + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 4 at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1278 adds scaffold choice and bans the cookie carve-out the issue still records." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1353", + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 5 at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1279 reverses the filed acceptance from \"ship a trace contribution\" to \"prove the transport owns trace injection\"." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1467", + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 6 is \"new child after RFC acceptance\"; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1280." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1093", + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 7 at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1281 defines the generic-discovery exit condition the issue body predates." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1350", + "to": "issue:1466", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 1b must initialize NetScriptProcedureMeta \"without re-erasing Stage 1a types\"; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1275." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1466", + "to": "issue:1349", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "The normative SdkClientProcedureDescriptor consumed by every contribution embeds Readonly; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:410-413." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1466", + "to": "issue:1352", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "#1352 acceptance reads procedure policy metadata, which #1466 defines." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1351", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": [ + "#1351 Boundaries: \"If #1349 lands first, this issue must additionally prove no contribution can reach the method decision.\"" + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1352", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "#1352 is the first dogfood consumer of the contribution chain #1349 creates; #1352 Summary." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1353", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "Stage 5 proves a property of the seam Stage 2 builds; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1276,1279." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1467", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "#1467 ships a contribution through the chain #1349 exposes." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1093", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": [ + "The RFC-added sdkClients-collection half of Stage 7 cannot land until the contribution seam exists; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1156-1160." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1352", + "to": "issue:1467", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": [ + "#1467 is the non-auth counterpart proof and reuses the auth dogfood composition order; both edit the same SDK docs page." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1243", + "to": "issue:1352", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": [ + "#1352 swaps the first-party CLI off raw fetch at the same call sites whose default URL #1243 repairs (auth-plugin-command.ts:87)." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1293", + "to": "issue:1112", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "#1112 own text: \"Until this lands, #1112 example must document only what ships today\"; #1293 opening paragraph." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1355", + "to": "issue:1357", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "#1357 emission target is the app-side client/query wiring #1355 regenerates." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1355", + "to": "issue:1354", + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": [ + "#1354 resource slice consumes the client/query wiring #1355 owns." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1357", + "to": "issue:1354", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": [ + "The new verb should generate against a repaired ui:add emission, not codify the broken one." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1378", + "to": "issue:1542", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": [ + "Widening quality:gate roots to published packages is only safe once the scanner is export-aware and allowances are registered." + ] + }, + { + "from": "issue:1451", + "to": "issue:1455", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": [ + "#1455 registry payload map consumes the generated-registry metadata plumbing #1451 introduces." + ] + } + ], + "waves": [ + { + "index": 0, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1243", + "issue:1262", + "issue:1263", + "issue:1348", + "issue:1378", + "issue:1502", + "issue:1545", + "issue:1551", + "issue:1561", + "issue:1563", + "issue:1588", + "issue:1621" + ] + }, + { + "index": 1, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1293", + "issue:1350", + "issue:1355", + "issue:1358", + "issue:1360", + "issue:1542", + "issue:1611", + "issue:1613" + ] + }, + { + "index": 2, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1112", + "issue:1296", + "issue:1357", + "issue:1451", + "issue:1466", + "issue:1604", + "issue:1618", + "issue:1622" + ] + }, + { + "index": 3, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1349", + "issue:1354", + "issue:1429", + "issue:1448", + "issue:1533", + "issue:1598", + "issue:1619", + "issue:1620", + "issue:1623", + "issue:1637" + ] + }, + { + "index": 4, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1351", + "issue:1352", + "issue:1353", + "issue:1455", + "issue:1557", + "issue:1601" + ] + }, + { + "index": 5, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1093", + "issue:1461", + "issue:1467" + ] + }, + { + "index": 6, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1452", + "issue:1462", + "issue:1481", + "issue:1592", + "issue:1616" + ] + }, + { + "index": 7, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1249", + "issue:1543", + "issue:1590", + "issue:1591", + "issue:1609", + "issue:1610" + ] + }, + { + "index": 8, + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1458", + "issue:1544" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-intake.json b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-intake.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..bfc5132e2f --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-intake.json @@ -0,0 +1,734 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "repo": "rickylabs/netscript", + "milestone": "0.0.7", + "capturedAt": "2026-08-13T21:12:00.000Z", + "baselineMainSha": "01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed", + "ownerRatifiedAt": "2026-08-13T21:12:00.000Z", + "sources": { + "targetMilestone": true, + "unmilestoned": true, + "backlog": true, + "laterMilestones": true + }, + "candidates": [ + { + "number": 928, + "source": "laterMilestone", + "decision": "defer", + "reason": "Referenced by #1348 as a future dialect that 0.0.7 should precede, not as an implementation prerequisite.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/928", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1348" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 934, + "source": "laterMilestone", + "decision": "defer", + "reason": "Referenced by #1348 as a future consumer whose policy shape must not be pre-empted, not as an implementation prerequisite.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/934", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1348" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1093, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1093" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1112, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1112" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1175, + "source": "backlog", + "decision": "defer", + "reason": "Replacing the fixed JSR propagation sleep can shorten releases but does not invalidate current publication evidence; keep outside the implementation critical path.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1175", + ".llm/tools/release/" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1243, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1243" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1249, + "source": "backlog", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "High-value coherent public Fresh form correctness work on the same managed-form surface as #1609; both halves require red-first reproduction.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1249", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1249#issuecomment-5285236885" + ], + "ownerRatified": true, + "admissionPredicate": "high-value-coherent", + "targetMilestone": "0.0.7", + "movedAt": "2026-08-13T21:12:00.000Z" + }, + { + "number": 1262, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1262" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1263, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1263" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1273, + "source": "backlog", + "decision": "defer", + "reason": "PostgreSQL-tier narrowing is useful compute optimization, but normal PR E2E is already release/manual/explicit-opt-in and this is not a correctness prerequisite for 0.0.7.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1273", + ".github/workflows/e2e-cli.yml:88-104" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1293, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1293" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1296, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1296" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1306, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1306" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1348, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1348" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1349, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1349" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1350, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1350" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1351, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1351" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1352, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1352" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1353, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1353" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1354, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1354" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1355, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1355" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1357, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1357" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1358, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1358" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1360, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1360" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1378, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1378" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1384, + "source": "laterMilestone", + "decision": "defer", + "reason": "The complete security fix depends on #1383 and the issue explicitly forbids owning that seam; a credential-only carve-out would not satisfy its principal/ownership acceptance and would be a partial workaround. Keep the full fix in 0.0.8.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1384", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1383" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1385, + "source": "laterMilestone", + "decision": "defer", + "reason": "A real P0 auth defect, but it is a contract-breaking auth transport slice outside the milestone's explicit typed-extension scope; preserve its already-scheduled 0.0.8 ownership rather than mixing auth topology into this foundation cut.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1385" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1429, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1429" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1448, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1448" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1451, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1451" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1452, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1452" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1453, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Included in the frozen target sweep, then dispositioned out after independent verification showed the cited surface has never existed in this repository.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1453", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1453#issuecomment-5285235764" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1455, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1455" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1458, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1458" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1461, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1461" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1462, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1462" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1466, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1466" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1467, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1467" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1481, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1481" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1502, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1502" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1533, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1533" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1542, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1542" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1543, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1543" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1544, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1544" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1545, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1545" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1551, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1551" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1557, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1557" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1561, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1561" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1563, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1563" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1564, + "source": "backlog", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Release-critical CI correctness prerequisite explicitly admitted during the owner's pre-0.0.7 false-positive audit.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1564", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1564#issuecomment-5284900986" + ], + "ownerRatified": true, + "admissionPredicate": "release-critical", + "targetMilestone": "0.0.7", + "movedAt": "2026-08-13T18:38:26.000Z" + }, + { + "number": 1588, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1588" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1590, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1590" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1591, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1591" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1592, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1592" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1598, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1598" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1601, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1601" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1604, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1604" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1606, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1606" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1609, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1609" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1610, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1610" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1611, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1611" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1613, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1613" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1616, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1616" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1618, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1618" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1619, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1619" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1620, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1620" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1621, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1621" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1622, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1622" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1623, + "source": "targetMilestone", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "Present in the owner-scheduled 0.0.7 milestone at the frozen baseline sweep.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1623" + ], + "ownerRatified": true + }, + { + "number": 1637, + "source": "unmilestoned", + "decision": "include", + "reason": "High-value coherent consumer-visible false outage on the exact SDK cache leaf already containing #1598/#1619/#1620/#1623.", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1637", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1637#issuecomment-5285236378" + ], + "ownerRatified": true, + "admissionPredicate": "high-value-coherent", + "targetMilestone": "0.0.7", + "movedAt": "2026-08-13T21:12:00.000Z" + } + ] +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-inventory.json b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-inventory.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..7d6efae9ba --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-inventory.json @@ -0,0 +1,817 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "repo": "rickylabs/netscript", + "milestone": "0.0.7", + "capturedAt": "2026-08-13T21:12:00.000Z", + "baselineMainSha": "01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed", + "ownerRatifiedAt": "2026-08-13T21:12:00.000Z", + "targetIssueCount": 64, + "issues": [ + { + "number": 1093, + "title": "[sdk-client S8] fix(plugin-core): let third-party plugin factories participate in discovery", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/plugin/src/sdk/discovery/ast-extractor.ts:4-8 — CONTRIBUTION_BUILDERS still hardcodes { defineJob: jobs }, { defineSaga: sagas }, { defineWebhook: triggers } in the core", + "packages/plugin/src/config/domain/plugin-contributions.ts:12-41 — no seam through which a plugin declares its own factory axis; :14-16 doctorChecks is a closed 'auth-backend' literal union", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1156-1160 — '#1093 must collect these references without official-plugin switches, reject duplicate ids or mismatched imported descriptors, and expose them to generators' (new obligation added by the merged RFC)", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1281 Stage 7 assigns generic discovery to #1093", + "Timeline: no merged PR references #1093; the nearest merged neighbour PR #1316 (fix(plugins): declare linking through shared core seam) closed a different issue (#1189) and left ast-extractor.ts:4-8 intact" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1112, + "title": "docs(database): make the MySQL Prisma adapter example honest and executable", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/README.md:7,13,20 still claims 'Deno's native MySQL client' / 'Deno-native driver' — this file is the JSR landing page (jsr-package-settings.json defaults readmeSource: 'readme')", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/mod.ts:6-8 module JSDoc repeats the same false 'Deno's native mysql driver' claim above the @example", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/adapter.ts:26 imports type { Pool, PoolConnection, PoolOptions } from 'mysql2/promise' — the real dependency", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/types.ts:39 declares onConnectionError; grep across the package finds it referenced only in examples/basic-usage.ts:39 and never in src/adapter.ts — a live accepted-but-unused option (acceptance row 4)", + "docs/site/reference/prisma-adapter-mysql/index.md:8,14,16-17 IS already honest about mysql2, pooling ownership and timeout — that half was repaired by PR #1292, so only the package-local prose plus source rows remain" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1243, + "title": "auth: session list --stream-url default pins localhost:4437 which no longer exists post-#1211", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/public/features/plugins/auth/auth-plugin-command.ts:87 still sets `default: 'http://localhost:4437/auth/sessions'` on --stream-url", + "plugins/streams/scaffold.plugin.json:54-55 still carries servicePort 4437 / backgroundPort 4437 — the dead manifest values the issue asks to sweep", + "packages/cli/src/maintainer/features/sync/plugin/copy-official-plugin-test-support.ts:108-109 also hardcodes 4437 for both ports", + "#1211 (randomize default listener ports) is MERGED in 0.0.5, so the premise that 4437 is no longer bound by new scaffolds holds", + "The 4437 squatting failure class is documented in the repo's own aspire skill text (packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/skills.generated.ts), which describes a foreign process answering on 4437 healthily" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1249, + "title": "fix(fresh/form): controlProps() is not element-assignable, and Zod 4 constraint derivation misses numbers and regex", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1249", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1249#issuecomment-5285236885", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/_internal/prop-types.ts:166", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/schema-adapter/zod-constraints.ts:163-198" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1262, + "title": "scaffold: db seed is a placebo — SELECT 1 plus a success banner, no rows seeded", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/database/seed.ts.template:13-14 is verbatim `await client.$queryRaw\\`SELECT 1\\`;` followed by `console.log('✅ Database seed completed.')` — unchanged on baseline", + "It is the only seed asset in the tree (`find packages/cli/src/kernel/assets -iname '*seed*'` returns exactly this one file), so every engine gets the placebo", + "No test references the seed script's row-writing behaviour (no seed assertions found under packages/cli/e2e)", + "Timeline shows only #1250/#1256 (the Zod-4 coercion fix) cross-referencing it — nothing that touched the seed" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1263, + "title": "service: generated by-id handler returns 500 {defined:false} for a missing row instead of a defined 404", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/routers/v1.ts.template:59 still throws a bare `new Error(\\`{{modelName}} ${input.id} not found\\`)` in the getById handler — not a defined oRPC error", + "Same defect in the memory variant: packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/routers/v1.memory.ts.template:56", + "Repo-wide grep for `.errors(`, `NOT_FOUND`, or `ORPCError` across packages/cli/src/kernel/assets (excluding generated) returns ZERO hits — no scaffolded contract defines a 404, so the OpenAPI projection cannot document one", + "update/delete handlers rely on Prisma's own throw (v1.ts.template update/delete use where:{id} with no not-found branch), so they share the class", + "Timeline shows only #1250/#1256 and later related issues; no merged PR addressed the defined-error gap" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1293, + "title": "prisma-adapter-mysql: adapter class is unexported and has no connection-error hook", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/adapter.ts:319 declares `class PrismaMySqlAdapter extends MySqlQueryable` with no `export` keyword; src/mod.ts exports only PrismaMySqlAdapterFactory/PrismaMySql (adapter.ts:742 aliases them) — the class is still unexported", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/types.ts:39 `onConnectionError?: (err: Error) => void` exists in the options type but no src/ file reads it — the hook is declared, not implemented or tested", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/adapter.ts:544,546 already carry explicit annotations (`readonly provider: 'mysql' = 'mysql'`, `readonly adapterName: string`), so the slow-types row is largely satisfied on baseline", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/deno.json exports only '.' -> './mod.ts', so any new export must go through src/mod.ts" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1296, + "title": "fix(docs/exports): repair contracts and Fresh UI reference drift, then wire the regeneration gate", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "The cited file is a false lead: packages/contracts/src/application/contract-primitives.ts:72,112,144 import baseContract/BaseContractRoute/BaseContractOutputRoute from '@netscript/contracts', and all three ARE root exports (packages/contracts/src/public/mod.ts:2-6) — those examples are correct", + "Real instances of the same defect: packages/contracts/src/application/paginated-query.ts:6 imports paginatedQuery, schemas/pagination.ts:6 imports PaginationInputSchema/createPaginatedOutput, schemas/filters.ts:6 imports FilterConditionSchema/buildPrismaWhere, and src/application/transform-helpers.ts:6 imports createTransformer — all from the root, while none of those symbols appear in src/public/mod.ts (they live on ./query and ./transform)", + ".llm/tools/docs/check-exports-drift.ts:13-21 lists fresh-ui with `checkSymbols: false` and `excludedSymbols: []` — symbol-level drift for docs/site/reference/fresh-ui/index.md is not checked and there is no machine-readable intentional-omission mechanism in use", + "Wiring is partly done: .llm/tools/docs/check-accuracy-and-discoverability.ts:293 spawns check-exports-drift.ts, and deno.json:85,90 expose it via docs:accuracy/docs:maintenance — but no .github/workflows job runs those tasks (only pages.yml:145 runs docs:snippets)", + "#1108 (the parent of the fresh-ui rows) was closed NOT_PLANNED on 2026-08-11, so those rows genuinely have no other owner" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1306, + "title": "fix(aspire): 'the dashboard is the authority' is unusable for an agent — aspire start detaches in a non-TTY and prints no login token", + "disposition": "close-fixed", + "lane": null, + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1306", + "aspire ps --help: --format Json and --non-interactive", + "aspire describe --help: resource state via --format Json", + ".agents/skills/aspire/SKILL.md:30-41", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/skills.generated.ts" + ], + "reason": "Aspire CLI 13.4.6 now exposes machine-readable AppHost/resource inventory and NetScript already teaches the exact agent path in both repository and generated skills." + }, + { + "number": 1348, + "title": "Epic: Typed SDK client contributions — credentials, transport policy, metadata, and cache-safe extensions", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1 exists on baseline — RFC text published, so acceptance box 1 is satisfied", + "PR #1390 'RFC: Typed SDK client contributions' MERGED 2026-08-11T20:15:51Z; its body states 'RFC tracking issue: #1348 (reference only; this draft does not close it)'", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1555-1599 — 11 unresolved questions still open (incl. Q6 metadata ownership), so ratification acceptance is incomplete", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1273 Stage 0 row assigns #1348 'align #1349–#1353 bodies before implementation' — not yet done (bodies still contradict the RFC)", + "gh issue list --label epic:sdk-client-contrib: all 8 children (#1349-#1353,#1466,#1467,#1093) still OPEN" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1349, + "title": "[sdk-client S3] feat(sdk): expose the typed oRPC client-contribution seam", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts:203-222 — CreateServiceClientOptions is still the closed nine-field record; no headers/fetch/interceptors/plugins/link/context parameter", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts:129-155 — ServiceClientContext is still a concrete interface; ServiceClientMethod at :167 carries no context or error generic", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:82,83-101,102-126 — method, headers and plugins are still inline literals inside the link", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/mod.ts:7 still advertises 'the transport seam' while ClientLinkPort/ClientLinkCallOptions (packages/sdk/src/ports/client-link-factory.ts:8-26, doc'd 'Internal … seam') are absent from its export list", + "packages/service/src/builder/service-rpc.ts:57 still calls createRPCHandler(router, { serviceName, debug }) while packages/service/src/primitives/handlers.ts:44 declares `plugins`; packages/service/src/types.ts:221 still `init?(options: unknown, router: unknown)`" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1350, + "title": "[sdk-client S1] fix(sdk): preserve contract errors through safe() and isDefinedError", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/errors.ts:75-77 — `isDefinedError(error: T): error is Extract` still lacks the upstream error generic", + "packages/sdk/src/client/errors.ts:86-92 — `safe(promise: PromiseLike)`, no TError; SafeResult at :49", + "packages/contracts/src/application/contract-primitives.ts:81 — `export const baseContract: ReturnType = oc.errors(commonErrorMap);` still erases the six literal codes", + "packages/sdk/tests/readme-doctest_test.ts:36-37 — still `declare function safe(...)` / `declare function isDefinedError(...)` instead of importing the real exports", + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md:198 and docs/site/services-sdk/how-to/discover-services.md:147,224 still ship the `isDefinedError(error) -> error.code` pattern" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1351, + "title": "[sdk-client S4] refactor(sdk): centralize HTTP method and GET-cache policy", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:82 — `method: inferRPCMethodFromContractRouter(contract)` still applied inline; no owned policy function exists (grep inferRPCMethodFromContractRouter/StrictGetMethodPlugin/fallbackMethod returns only this file)", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:109 — `filter: ({ request }) => request.method === 'GET'` still re-derives the method decision from the wire", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:110-125 — the 'force-cache' group condition is still an independent literal keyed off context?.cache", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:103-108 — ClientRetryPlugin default still frozen at retry: 0", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1277 Stage 3 assigns this issue the v1-family version decision, one fetch/retry/dedupe/trace path, header-safe dedupe, and deprecating the no-op options" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1352, + "title": "[sdk-client S5] feat(sdk/auth): prove typed credential contributions end to end", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/service/src/auth/static-credential-authenticator.ts reads Authorization/x-api-key while grep 'Authorization' packages/sdk/src returns no match — the client still cannot send a credential", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:83-101 — client header authorship is still only Content-Type + optional traceparent/tracestate", + "grep -rn 'authClient' packages plugins → no such symbol on baseline (only oauthClient in packages/auth-kv-oauth/src/flow.ts:169)", + "packages/plugin/src/config/domain/plugin-contributions.ts:12-41 — still no client/sdkClients contribution group; :14-16 `doctorChecks?: readonly 'auth-backend'[]` is the closed-literal precedent the issue warns against", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1278 Stage 4 keeps this issue as the auth dogfood (auth-core bearer factory, access metadata, redaction, cache partition/direct-only, manifest reference, docs, scaffold choice)" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1353, + "title": "[sdk-client S6] feat(sdk): express trace propagation as a general contribution", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:87-98 — trace-header authorship is still hard-coded in the link behind the propagateTraceContext boolean", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts:149-155 — ServiceClientContext.traceHeaders is still the per-call override; grep traceContextContribution → no such symbol on baseline", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1476-1481 §'Rejected: trace propagation as the non-auth contribution' — the merged RFC REJECTS this issue's headline deliverable", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1279 Stage 5 — 'Re-scope from “trace contribution” to prove the transport retains the only final trace injection and rejects contributor ownership of trace headers'", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:870-871,886-887 — traceparent/tracestate are reserved SDK-owned headers unavailable to contributions" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1354, + "title": "feat(cli): no verb generates a resource route slice — the typed contract, cache-first loader and withResource page must be hand-copied from init", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts:15-45 is still the entire page generator: three files, no withResource, no loader, no contract sidecar", + "packages/cli/src/public/features/generate/generate-group.ts:19-27 registers only `aspire`, `runtime-schemas`, `plugins` — no slice/route generator exists", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts:60-62 writeGeneratedFiles hard-refuses on any existing file; no --force/--dry-run reaches it from add-ui-command.ts:61-67", + "Reference slice still exists only as init assets: packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/service-query.ts.template and (_islands)/ServiceShowcaseLab.tsx.template", + "Timeline shows no merged PR touching this issue; only open peers #1355/#1357/#1360 cross-reference it" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1355, + "title": "feat(cli): app-side client/query wiring is a one-shot template with hardcoded names, colliding 'service' cache keys and a no-op invalidation", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/service-query.ts.template:22-27 still literally does `createQueryFactories({ service: { … } }).service` — resource key is the literal 'service' for every service", + "Same template :11-14 builds bridgeInvalidation({{serviceName|camelCase}}RouterName, 'list') → keys ['users','list'], while packages/sdk/src/query/query-factory.ts:218 passes the OBJECT KEY ('service') as resource → the invalidation is a no-op", + "packages/sdk/src/query-client/key-bridge.ts:32-37 confirms bridgeInvalidation returns { queryKey: [resource, action] } with no factory linkage", + "Dead call sites confirmed: assets/app/routes/examples/(_islands)/ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template:93 (onSettled) and :135 ('Invalidate list cache' button)", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/service/client-scaffolder.ts:38-49 is still a single renderTemplateAssetSync — one template, one shot, no per-service naming" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1357, + "title": "fix(cli): ui:add page --island emits a useSignal counter and an empty queryLoaders object instead of the advertised data-screen triad", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts:37 still emits `export const queryLoaders = {} as const;` and :35 emits signalIslandTemplate (useSignal counter, :66-68)", + "web-scaffold.ts:51-54 — `ui:add island --query` still emits `
Name
`: no useQuery, no key, no factory", + "web-scaffold.ts:20+:30 — route id is still a hand-derived dotted string with an inline createRouteReference, not router.ts/appRoutes", + "Contradicted description still live at packages/cli/src/public/features/ui/add/add-ui-command.ts:26-28 ('Scaffold the Fresh page + island + query-loader triad for a data screen')", + "add-ui-command.ts:61-67 never forwards `--force` to scaffoldUiPage/scaffoldUiIsland, and there is no --dry-run flag at all" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1358, + "title": "fix(scaffold): the generated /design/components gallery lists 50 of 66 registry items — the whole AI collection is invisible and no gate compares them", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/(design)/design/(_shared)/registry.ts.template:28 still declares `total: 50` and :1-4 self-describes as a hand-copied snapshot", + "Live manifest item count is 66: `grep -c '^ kind: ' packages/fresh-ui/registry.manifest.ts` → 66", + "AI/chart items absent from the snapshot but present in the manifest: grep for model-selector|prompt-input|donut|dropzone|citation-chip|mcp-ui-widget returns 0 hits in the template, and hits at packages/fresh-ui/registry.manifest.ts:451,495,561,583", + "The only drift test remains packages/fresh-ui/tests/registry-doc-drift.test.ts:4-19, which compares registry.ts JSDoc COLLECTION NAMES only and never reads the CLI snapshot", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/registry.ts imports freshUiRegistryManifest — the CLI resolves against the live manifest, so ui:add can install items the gallery denies" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1360, + "title": "fix(scaffold): the canonical island never passes initialDataUpdatedAt, so the loader's cachedAt is computed, displayed and discarded", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "Repo-wide grep for `initialDataUpdatedAt` under packages/cli/src returns ZERO hits; all hits are in packages/fresh (query-types.ts:136, hooks.ts:128,138-140, and two tests)", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/(_islands)/ServiceShowcaseLab.tsx.template:54-57 passes queryKey + initialData: props.initialList with no initialDataUpdatedAt; :148 uses props.cachedAt only as a display stat", + "Memory variant identical: ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template:60 initialData, :119 cachedAt as a label only", + "The seam is live and tested in the framework — packages/fresh/src/application/query/hooks.ts:138-140 maps the option to `{ updatedAt }` and initial-data.test.tsx:15 exercises it — so only the scaffold is unwired", + "Timeline shows no merged PR; only open peers #1354/#1357 cross-reference it" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1378, + "title": "chore(quality): `quality:scan` cannot see an `any` in an exported type, an unbudgeted allowance, or a docs snippet", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "Still regex-only, export-blind: `.llm/tools/quality/scan-code-quality.ts:69` `if (!commentOnly && /(?:<|:\\s*)any.../.test(line)) return 'explicit-any'` — no notion of `export`.", + "Allowances still unlinked: `scan-code-quality.ts:207` matches `/\\/\\/\\s*quality-allow:\\s*(.+)$/` and accepts any non-empty free text; no `#` requirement anywhere in the file.", + "Already landed (boxes 3,4,5,7): `scan-code-quality.ts:119` scans `docs/site/**` `.md` fences; `:124` keeps `-soundness_test.ts` in scope; `deno.json:50-51` wires `--root docs/site --max-allow 7` and `--max-allow 8`.", + "PR #1596 (merged 2026-08-12) body: \"Export reachability and live issue-state verification remain explicitly deferred to #1378 for 0.0.7\"; it referenced #1378 without closing it.", + "`docs/site/reference/triggers/index.md` (205 lines) contains no `any[]` at baseline — acceptance box 7 is discharged." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1429, + "title": "fix(agentic): leak-check cannot see orphaned Aspire process descendants, so it reports clean through a real leak", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "`.llm/tools/agentic/teardown/leak-check.ts` has zero matches for `ppid|PPID|pgrep|/proc|process` — it has no process-descendant observation at all.", + "Its resource model is containers + AppHosts only: `leak-check.ts:42`, `:68`, `:74`, `:106` all branch on `resource.kind === 'apphost'` or `registry.containers`.", + "Timeline cross-references for #1429 are only issues #1227 and #1169 (both closed), no merged PR touching leak-check.", + "`.llm/tools/agentic/teardown/` contains ownership.ts, ports.ts, probes.ts, run-resources.ts — no process enumerator module." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1448, + "title": "fix(ai/mcp): make pool startup failure-isolated and propagate cancellation", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/ai/src/mcp/application/pool.ts:154-173 — #collectTools iterates transports in a `for...of` with `await list(transport)`, so one never-settling or rejecting server blocks/aborts the whole pool; connect/reconnect/listTools (:107, :115, :122) all route through it", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/adapters/tanstack-connector.ts:80 and :89 — listTools/callTool only call options.signal?.throwIfAborted() before awaiting client.tools()/client.callTool(name, args); no signal is passed into the pending TanStack work", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/application/register-tools.ts:14-17 — registerMcpTools(registry, transport) accepts no caller signal, and :36 hardcodes `{ signal: undefined }` on every tool call", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/application/pool.ts:88 — the pool exposes only an aggregate `state`; there is no per-server status/degraded-lifecycle read", + "gh api issues/1448/timeline — the only cross-reference is rickylabs/eis-chat#159 (consumer adapter), not a netscript fix" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1451, + "title": "feat(plugin-workers): generated registry cannot consume project job policy metadata", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "plugins/workers/src/cli/runtime-registry-generator.ts:325-340 — createJobDefinition still hardcodes topic 'default', timeout 300000, maxRetries 3, retryDelay 1000, maxConcurrency 1, priority 50, persist true and a fixed tags expression", + "plugins/workers/src/cli/registry-compiler.ts:78 — the compiler path emits the same `timeout: 300000` literal", + "plugins/workers/tests/cli/registry-compiler-golden_test.ts:68 and plugins/workers/services/src/generated-jobs_test.ts:22 — golden tests pin the generic 300000ms timeout, so no project-metadata seam is exercised", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/executor/multi-runtime-task-executor.ts:66 — the executor default is likewise `options.defaults?.timeout ?? 300000`", + "gh api issues/1451/timeline — the only cross-reference is issue #1455 (open), no fix PR" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1452, + "title": "feat(plugin): publish reusable PluginServiceContext host factory", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/embedded.generated.ts:177 — the scaffold still embeds a full ~100-line LazyPluginKv class plus db/contracts/logger/env composition in the generated createPluginServiceContext", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/plugins/generate-plugin-service_test.ts:82 — the test asserts the generator emits `export function createPluginServiceContext(` into consumer code, pinning the duplicate-per-consumer shape", + "plugins/workers/services/src/main.ts:88-89, plugins/sagas/services/src/main.ts:139-140 and plugins/auth/services/src/main.ts:124-127 all load the host factory via NETSCRIPT_PLUGIN_SERVICE_BOOTSTRAP_MODULE, so no published factory exists to import", + "packages/plugin/src/sdk/ contains only discovery/walker/registry-emitter modules — no host-context factory", + "gh api issues/1452/timeline — no cross-references at all" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1453, + "title": "fix(agentic): migration LOC worktree snapshot crashes on unstaged deletions", + "disposition": "move", + "lane": null, + "evidence": [ + "`tools/migration-loc/` does not exist at baseline: `find . -iname '*migration-loc*'` returns nothing outside `.llm/tmp` hook logs and the 0.0.7 inventory JSONs.", + "`git log --all -- tools/migration-loc` is empty — the path has never existed in this repository's history.", + "`grep -rn readTrackedFile --include=*.ts .` returns no match; the cited `tools/migration-loc/git.ts:78` frame has no counterpart here.", + "The only `-S'migration-loc'` history hits (05e5fbac2, 9f1d0244a) are false positives on the string `migration-lock` in `rfcs/0000-database-architecture.md`.", + "No scaffold template emits it: `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/**` has no migration-loc generator.", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1453#issuecomment-5285235764" + ], + "reason": "The entire cited surface is absent from the repo and its full history, so the acceptance is unsatisfiable in a 0.0.7 slice against this codebase; needs re-scoping or relocation to the owning repo first." + }, + { + "number": 1455, + "title": "workers: preserve job payload type through definition, registry, and enqueue", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/plugin-triggers-core/src/builders/define-webhook.ts:79-81 — `enqueueJob(job: JobDefinition, ...)` still infers the payload independently of the job definition", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/contracts/v1/workers.contract-types.ts:32-36 — JobTriggerInput still exposes `payload?: Record`", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/registry-generator-fixture.ts:37 — generated registries still emit `new Map>([`", + "Partially superseded upstream: packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-definition.ts:153-163 and builders/job-builder.ts:241 already return JobDefinition, so the builder-side erasure the issue describes is already gone", + "gh api issues/1455/timeline — only cross-reference is rickylabs/eis-chat#168 (consumer repo), no netscript fix PR" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1458, + "title": "feat(fresh/ai): expose awaited durable chat response completion", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/runtime/ai/create-chat-connection.ts:234-264 — NetScriptChatResponseOptions exposes target/streamPath/source/newMessages/request/authorize/toResponse and no mode or waitUntil", + "packages/fresh/src/runtime/ai/create-chat-connection.ts:255-263 — `toResponse` is documented as a test/adapter seam defaulting to toDurableChatSessionResponse, which is exactly the escape hatch consumers are forced to use", + "packages/fresh/src/runtime/ai/create-chat-connection.ts:461 — `const toResponse = options.toResponse ?? defaultToResponse;` with no completion-mode forwarding", + "gh timeline for #1458: only a 0.0.7 milestone event; no PR has referenced it" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1461, + "title": "docs/sdk: getCachedEntry cache-first loader example never revalidates stale entries", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:385-410 — getCachedEntry() reads this.store.get(), records telemetry and returns toCachedEntry(); it never reads staleTime, calls queryFn, or schedules a refresh", + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md:188 — the published example still carries `if (entry) return entry; // serve cached; SDK reloads stale in the background`", + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md:138 — getCachedEntry is still described as 'the SWR primitive a layer loader uses to decide stale-reload'", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:256-300 — revalidateInBackground never touches this.inflightRequests, confirming the issue's concurrent-duplicate-refresh note (dedupe exists only in fetchAndCacheOnce at :210-217)", + "docs/site/_site/capabilities/sdk/index.md:143 — the same false comment is in the built site output" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1462, + "title": "bug(sdk): importing defineServices in a browser auto-registers the server KV cache provider", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/mod.ts:46 — `export * from './src/cache/mod.ts'` still re-exports the cache module from the SDK root alongside defineServices (mod.ts:55)", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/mod.ts:22 — top-level `setCacheProvider(cacheQuery)` executes on any import of that module; the module JSDoc (:11-12) only warns browsers to avoid it", + "packages/sdk/deno.json:6-19 exports map has no ./presets or other browser-safe defineServices subpath — exactly the published-surface gap the issue reports", + "packages/sdk/mod.ts:24-25 documents the auto-registration as intended behaviour, so the fix must also update the root module contract", + "gh timeline for #1462: only a 0.0.7 milestone event — no PR has touched it" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1466, + "title": "[sdk-client S2] feat(sdk): define NetScriptProcedureMeta without erasing contract errors", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "grep -rnE '\\$meta<|\\.meta\\(|NetScriptProcedureMeta' packages plugins --include=*.ts → only Zod `.meta({` in packages/aspire/config.ts; no oRPC procedure metadata and no NetScriptProcedureMeta symbol exists on baseline", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1275 Stage 1b — 'Initialize/export NetScriptProcedureMeta without re-erasing Stage 1a types … an explicit dependent child owns this before auth dogfood'", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:410-413 — `SdkClientProcedureDescriptor.meta: Readonly` is a field of the normative public contribution contract", + "Issue body 'Part of #1348. Implements RFC 0001 stage 1b.' — filed after PR #1390 merged, so it IS the Stage-0-selected 1b owner", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1347 §'Procedure metadata' defines the shape this issue must export" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1467, + "title": "[sdk-client S7] feat(sdk): ship locale as the non-auth contribution proof", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "grep -rn 'SdkClientContribution' packages plugins → no match on baseline; no locale contribution exists", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1280 Stage 6 'Non-auth proof — new child after RFC acceptance. Ship/test locale contribution, partitioned keys, header conflicts, and generated use.' — #1467 is that child (body: 'Implements RFC 0001 stage 6')", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1480-1481 — 'Locale proves generality without duplicating credential semantics or violating trace ownership' (locale, not trace, is the ratified non-auth proof)", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:879 — `accept-language` is explicitly permitted for contributions", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:441-452 — SdkClientResponseCache partition/direct-only law this issue must exercise" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1481, + "title": "fix(fresh-ui): /design ships ungated — the defect class RFC 0005 guards against", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/(design)/design/ ships _layout, index, tokens, components, composition templates plus (_components)/(_islands)/(_shared) — grep for MODE|development|import.meta.env across that directory returns zero matches, so no mode gate exists", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/scaffold/writers/write-app-files.ts:95-99 and :139-143 create the (design) group unconditionally; :257-263 write the route templates with no opt-in flag", + "gh timeline for #1481: milestoned to Backlog/Triage then 0.0.7; cross-referenced from merged PRs #1450/#1523 and open #1522 (DevTools RFC artifacts) — none touched the gate", + "RFC authority rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md is merged on main, so the dual-exclusion posture the acceptance must match is already ratified" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1502, + "title": "RFC: Plugin CLI command contribution architecture — one typed mount and generation seam", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "No such RFC exists: rfcs/ contains only 0000-template, 0001-sdk-client-contributions, 0002-runtime-versioned-automation, 0003-command-composition-kit, 0004-deterministic-first-hybrid-mcp-doc-retrieval, 0005-devtools-contribution", + "rfcs/0003-command-composition-kit.md:1-20 is 'Production command composition kit' (transactional business commands, single store) — confirms it does not cover CLI extension, as the issue states", + "rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md:1-8 is Accepted with tracking issue #1465, so the DevTools consumer named in the sequencing section exists and would consume this seam", + "The consumer children are filed and parked downstream: #904, #905, #906, #907, #908 are all OPEN in milestone 0.0.11 ('Host: CLI mount-children contribution contract', async bootstrap, doctor-checks-as-data, manifest triad, plugin CLI children)", + "Labelled priority:p0 + status:research + epic:cli-contrib and self-declared '0.0.7 foundation' — nothing in-repo supersedes it" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1533, + "title": "test(docs): nothing compiles JSDoc `@example` blocks", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "No JSDoc example gate exists: .llm/tools/docs/check-snippets.ts:42-43 resolves its root to docs/site (or a fixture's docs/site) only — packages/** and plugins/** JSDoc are outside its scope", + "The tool inventory under .llm/tools/docs/ (snippet-extractor.ts, snippet-compiler.ts, snippet-policy.ts, check-snippets.ts) contains no @example/JSDoc extractor", + "Negative-test fixture #1 is currently clean: grep for 'api-clients' across packages/sdk/**/*.ts returns nothing (file is packages/sdk/src/query-client/create-service-query-utils.ts), so the gate must reintroduce it deliberately", + "Negative-test fixture #2 is also clean: packages/sdk/src/desktop/mod.ts:11-12 now imports '@my-app/contracts', not a relative app path", + "Prerequisite #1374 is CLOSED (milestone 0.0.6) and its snippet machinery is checked in, so the sequencing constraint is already satisfied" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1542, + "title": "fix(tooling): quality:gate roots omit published packages, so a green gate is not proof they were scanned", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "`deno.json:52` `quality:gate` = `quality:scan && arch:check`, and `deno.json:50` `quality:scan` roots are still `packages/cli/src`, `plugins`, `docs/site` — `packages/plugin-streams-core`, `packages/plugin-workers-core`, and `packages/cli/e2e` are outside them.", + "The `arch:check` half is now fixed: `deno.json:163` uses `--all-roots`, and `.llm/tools/fitness/check-doctrine.ts:27-43` `discoverDoctrineRoots()` enumerates every `packages/*` and `plugins/*` carrying a named `deno.json`.", + "That arch half landed in `e391f3aec` \"fix(quality): make quality gate coverage informative (#1570)\", merged 2026-08-12T14:31 — after #1542 was filed (2026-08-12T09:11) but closing #1403, not #1542.", + "Acceptance box 3 is arguably already met: the scanner emits `scanned` in its JSON result (`scan-code-quality.ts` main block, `result.scanned`).", + "No test pins root coverage: no reference to `discoverDoctrineRoots` from any file under `.llm/tools/quality`." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1543, + "title": "chore(deps): plugin-workers-core and plugins/triggers import plugin-streams-core without declaring it", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "grep for '@netscript/plugin-streams-core' across the three manifests returns only plugins/workers/deno.json:26 — packages/plugin-workers-core/deno.json and plugins/triggers/deno.json still do not declare it", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/streams/producer.ts:1 imports { createDurableStream } from '@netscript/plugin-streams-core'", + "plugins/triggers/streams/producer.ts:7 imports { createDurableStream } from '@netscript/plugin-streams-core'", + "plugins/workers/deno.json:26 pins it as jsr:@netscript/plugin-streams-core@0.0.6, establishing the declaration pattern the other two diverge from" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1544, + "title": "fix(cli): `emit` is advertised by three deploy adapters but never routed", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/public/features/deploy/target/target-deploy-command.ts:15-23 ROUTED_OPERATIONS = ['plan','up','down','status','logs','rollback','secrets'] — 'emit' absent", + "Same file:26-35 OPERATION_DESCRIPTIONS still carries `emit: 'Emit deployment artifacts'`, and :58-59 generates subcommands only from ROUTED_OPERATIONS ∩ adapter.operations, so emit can never become a command", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/aspire/aspire-compose-deploy-target.ts:66 advertises 'emit' and :97 implements it (`return this.#publish('emit', request)`)", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/aspire/aspire-cloud-deploy-target.ts:125 advertises ['plan','emit','up','down']; packages/cli/src/kernel/domain/deploy/service-deploy-target.ts:24,107 advertise and implement it too", + "Existing tests lock the advertised sets (deploy-target-port_test.ts:198-199,210) but none asserts routability — the invariant the issue asks for is genuinely missing" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1545, + "title": "chore(quality): register the pre-existing quality-allow population so #1378's linked-issue rule can land without a day-one red gate", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "No allowance carries an issue id at baseline: all 7 live sites read `// quality-allow: ` — `packages/cli/src/public/public-api.ts:135,136,158,275,276`, `packages/cli/src/public/features/root/public-command-dependencies.ts:363`, `plugins/workers/streams/producer.ts:52`.", + "The population is 7, not the 8 the issue tabulates: `grep -rn 'quality-allow' packages/fresh/src` returns nothing, so table row 7 (`route-support.ts:96`) no longer exists at baseline.", + "`--max-allow` is already wired: `deno.json:50` `--max-allow 7`, `deno.json:51` `--max-allow 8` — so acceptance box 2 as written (8 for both) is stale relative to the tree.", + "The scanner still has no registration concept: `scan-code-quality.ts:207` accepts any non-empty reason, so box 1's 'reports them as registered rather than as findings' has no mechanism.", + "PR #1596 referenced #1545 without closing it and deferred live issue-state verification to 0.0.7." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1551, + "title": "docs(positioning): establish \"NetScript vs …\" and \"Migrate from …\" comparison framework", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "docs", + "evidence": [ + "No comparison surface exists yet: docs/site has no comparisons/ directory and docs/site/reference/ contains only per-package pages", + "The named case-study artifact is not in this repository — there is no apps/ directory, so `apps/dashboard/routes/project/[project]/channel/[channel]/session/[session]/index.tsx` cannot be read or reproduced from this worktree", + "#1550 (framework-owned request-aware cache-seed primitive, referenced by the case study) is CLOSED, so the 'label the current helper as application-owned' caveat may already be stale", + "Issue body itself scopes 17 deliverable checkboxes including LSP cold/warm p50/p95 benchmarks, paired human/agent navigation studies, and runtime measurement — none of which is a documentation authoring task" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1557, + "title": "test(fresh): no capability to assert the deferred coordinator reaches the client bundle", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/tests/form-navigation_browser.ts:212 drives `playwright-cli` and .github/workflows/ci.yml:252-265 installs @playwright/cli and runs the fresh-browser gate — the issue's premise 'no browser driver in repo test infrastructure' is STALE as of 1ed78f508 (#1602)", + "packages/fresh/tests/defer-island-client-bundle_test.ts:38-60 already builds a client bundle and asserts the defer island entry plus the 'partial-miss' policy string — criterion 1 is largely met for a FIXTURE, not for a scaffolded app", + "Criteria 2 and 3 remain unmet: nothing asserts a request to a configured /partials/** endpoint from a client navigation, and nothing asserts a named boundary swaps exactly once (grep of packages/fresh/tests shows only form-navigation_browser.ts and the bundle test)", + "gh timeline for #1557: cross-referenced from closed #1459 and merged PRs #1555/#1558 (the runtime fix), never from a test-capability PR" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1561, + "title": "fix(tooling): acceptance-evidence mirror throws on an empty entry list instead of reporting it", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "Defect present verbatim: `.llm/tools/validation/acceptance-evidence.ts:255` `if (!field) throw new Error(\\`Invalid acceptance-evidence YAML line: ${line}\\`);`.", + "The skip guard only tolerates the bare key: `acceptance-evidence.ts:251` `if (!line || line === 'entries:') continue;` — the literal `entries: []` is neither empty nor equal to `'entries:'`.", + "The field regex `^-?\\s*(issue|box|box-index|evidence):\\s*(.*)$` (`:254`) cannot match `entries: []`, so the throw is guaranteed, not conditional." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1563, + "title": "fix(agentic): verdict extractor records NONE when the token is a markdown heading", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "Shell tier 2 cannot match a heading: `.github/workflows/openhands-agent.yml:874` `grep -E '^[[:space:]]*(Verdict:?[[:space:]]*)?OPENHANDS_VERDICT:...'` after `sed -E 's/[*`]+//g'` — the strip removes `*` and backtick only, never `#`.", + "Shell tier 1 is strictly anchored: `openhands-agent.yml:870` `grep -E '^OPENHANDS_VERDICT:...'`.", + "The JS twin has the same hole: `openhands-agent.yml:~1176-1182` `verdictOf()` matches `/^OPENHANDS_VERDICT:.../` then `line.replace(/[*`]+/g,'').match(/^[ \\t]*(?:Verdict:?[ \\t]*)?OPENHANDS_VERDICT:.../)`.", + "The library extractor is equally blind: `.llm/tools/agentic/lib/agentic-lib.ts:892` prefix class is `[\\s>*`_]*` — `#` is not a member.", + "No test covers the heading form: `agentic-lib_test.ts:655,739` cover the bare line and the `**Verdict: OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS**` bold form only." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1564, + "title": "fix(ci): pull_request.base.sha is stale on long-lived PRs, so every gate that computes a range from it silently inspects the wrong changeset", + "disposition": "close-fixed", + "lane": null, + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1564", + "Fresh seven-construct workflow audit at 01e0960: every changed-file consumer uses three-dot merge-base semantics.", + "The remaining git show BASE_SHA:deno.json calls are conservative tasks-only applicability comparisons, not changed-file ranges.", + "The only affected two-dot code-quality construct and its red-first stale/foreign fixture were completed by #1403.", + "Closed COMPLETED during PLAN-EVAL remediation on 2026-08-13." + ], + "reason": "The only unsafe two-dot changed-file consumer was already fixed by #1403; all remaining changed-file ranges use merge-base semantics and base-manifest reads deliberately fail toward running." + }, + { + "number": 1588, + "title": "fix(scaffold): omit unreachable provider URL parsers from SQLite workspaces", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/generated/database/generate-prisma-config-1.ts.template:35-51 emits normalizeDatabaseUrl with postgres/mysql/mssql branches while :27 types the provider as the literal '{{__slot4__}}' (= 'sqlite') and :36-38 short-circuits sqlite first — the branches are statically unreachable", + "Same template :53-134 carries normalizePostgresUrl, normalizeMysqlUrl, normalizeMssqlUrl, parseSqlServerEndpoint and parseConnectionParts for every engine", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/generate-engine-mod.ts:34 + :140-142 inline the full connection-helpers asset unconditionally (buildConnectionHelpers() takes no provider argument), so database//mod.ts gets all three normalizers too", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/database/connection-helpers.ts.template:12-21 is the shared switch that duplicates the prisma-config one", + "The only cross-reference is rickylabs/eis-chat#194 (closed, downstream consumer cleanup) — no netscript PR has touched this" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1590, + "title": "Fresh partial navigation needs last-intent ordering and remount-safe region identity", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/builders/define-page/navigation/ contains only context.ts/hooks.ts/link.tsx/mod.ts — href/link typing, no generation counter, no supersede/abort logic (grep for generation|supersede|inflight|abort in hooks.ts returns nothing)", + "packages/fresh/deno.json:7-22 export map has no client-navigation subpath; nearest client runtime is ./defer/island (packages/fresh/src/application/defer/island.ts)", + "grep -rln 'clientNav|replaceState' packages/fresh/src only hits form transport attributes (packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/enhancement.tsx:55) and route types, never a navigation coordinator", + "gh timeline for #1590: only a 0.0.7 milestone event, no cross-referenced PR — nothing has attempted this" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1591, + "title": "AI provider adapter needs a typed OpenAI Responses mapper", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/ai/src/adapters/openai-compatible.adapter.ts:39-51 — openAiCompatibleGenerationModelOptions only emits Chat Completions keys (flat `reasoning_effort`, `max_tokens`); no Responses variant exists", + "packages/ai/src/adapters/openai-compatible.adapter.ts:56 — OpenAiCompatibleApi already accepts 'responses', and packages/ai/openai-compatible.ts:49 passes it through, so the config surface admits a wire shape the mapper cannot produce", + "grep for max_output_tokens across packages/ai returns no hits — the Responses output-token key is absent from the repo", + "gh api issues/1591/timeline — no cross-references" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1592, + "title": "Workers durable execution stream should publish typed progress", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "evidence": [ + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-definition.ts:201-245 — ExecutionRecordShape has no progress or progressMessage field (id, concept, jobId, topic, status, triggeredBy, timestamps, exitCode, duration, error, result, workerId, attempt, maxAttempts, payload, correlationId, traceparent, tracestate only)", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-context.ts:11 — reportProgress?: (percent, message?) => void | Promise exists on the context", + "plugins/workers/worker/job-runner-pool.ts:61 — the runtime wires reportProgress and does not persist it into an execution record", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/telemetry/job-tools.ts:46 — the only consumer just forwards to ctx.reportProgress?.()", + "gh api issues/1592/timeline — no cross-references" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1598, + "title": "SDK cache-provider throw should name its module identity when two SDK instances are loaded", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-provider.ts:203-212 — getCacheProvider() throw text still has no import.meta.url and no two-instances hint", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-provider.ts:55 — `let _provider: CacheProvider | null = null` is still module-local, as the issue requires it stay", + "gh issue 1589 is CLOSED on milestone 0.0.6 — the build-time gate landed, leaving this runtime throw as the only signal for already-generated consumers", + "No cross-referenced PR on issue 1598 timeline (gh api issues/1598/timeline returned no cross-references)" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1601, + "title": "test(fresh): defer-island client-bundle test resolves npm:vite over the network, making the package verdict environment-dependent", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/tests/defer-island-client-bundle_test.ts:19-28 — still `args: ['run','--no-lock','-A','npm:vite@7.2.2','build',...]`, verbatim the cited defect", + "packages/fresh/tests/fixtures/defer-island-client/ contains only client.ts, main.ts, otel-api.ts, vite.config.ts — no locked vite resolution for the fixture", + "git log on that test shows only 5705aeb19 (#1558); no determinism follow-up landed", + "gh timeline for #1601: cross-referenced only from open issue #1604 (packages/cli test suite always red) — same 'prescribed package test task is not a trustworthy verdict' family" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1604, + "title": "test(cli): the prescribed `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` is always red", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:5 calls `Deno.readTextFile('docs/site/quickstart.vto')` — a bare repo-root-relative path, resolved against process cwd", + "packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:3,7 define DOC_PATH = 'docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md' and read it with Deno.readTextFile — same cwd dependence", + "packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:96-100 stats the script argument produced by service-env-gates.ts:59 (`${GATE_DIR}/configure-service-env.ts`), which is repo-root-relative", + "All three are reachable from the packages/cli test task, so the failure is in the base, not any branch — matching the issue's cbf6d5c27 observation", + "Same class as #1601 (OPEN, 0.0.7: environment-dependent package verdict), different mechanism" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1606, + "title": "verify(sdk): confirm the published @netscript/sdk JSR landing page shows the canonical query dialect", + "disposition": "close-fixed", + "lane": null, + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1606", + "https://jsr.io/@netscript/sdk", + "https://jsr.io/@netscript/sdk/meta.json" + ], + "reason": "The observational acceptance is satisfied: JSR reports 0.0.6 latest and the live SDK landing page renders the canonical query-dialect content." + }, + { + "number": 1609, + "title": "fix(fresh): managed form silently drops navigation:'document' when mode:'client'", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/enhancement.tsx:49 — `if (!strategy || strategy.mode === 'client') { return props; }` still early-returns before resolveFormNavigationProps is consulted (function is now applyCollectionStrategy at :42, issue cited the older name resolveFormEnhancementProps)", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/_internal/runtime-types.ts:89 — `FormCollectionStrategy extends Partial` still makes `{ mode: 'client', navigation: 'document' }` expressible", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/form.tsx:62 — `...resolveFormNavigationProps(strategy)` is still spread after `...props`, the C3 precedence", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/README.md:77-94 documents client/document strategies but states no precedence over caller-supplied raw f-client-nav props", + "git log -- packages/fresh/src/application/form/ shows 6aee2b414 (#1600) as the last change; no follow-up commit touched enhancement.tsx" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1610, + "title": "fix(fresh): route-pattern path inference makes unknown params never instead of a compile error", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/types.ts:14 — `export type EmptyRecord = Record` still exists and is the empty-pattern branch at types.ts:131-132 (`TPattern extends '' ? EmptyRecord`)", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/_internal/contract-types.ts:80 — the internal copy has the same `'' ? EmptyRecord` branch; contract-types.ts:170 also defaults `RouteReference`, so an unbound reference's unknown key is `never`", + "packages/fresh/src/application/builders/define-partial.test.tsx:272-274 — `OriginalPath['channel']` is asserted `IsNever` for pattern '/projects/[project]', i.e. the carrier admits an undeclared key rather than erroring", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/mod.ts:54 — createRouteReference returns RouteReference>, so parsePath (contract-types.ts:185) inherits that shape", + "gh timeline for #1610: only cross-referenced from PR #1602 (the eval that raised it); no fix PR, and git log on route/types.ts shows no commit after the beta.5 baseline" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1611, + "title": "agentic: formal evaluator dispatch helper must emit phase/head and acquire the existing claim", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "Producer confirmed silent on phase/head: `.llm/tools/agentic/lib/agentic-lib.ts:528-539` `buildOpenHandsComment` pushes only `model`, `provider`, `effort`, `output`, `iterations`.", + "Authorizer short-circuit confirmed: `.github/scripts/openhands-comment-trigger.mjs:61-63` reads `params.get('phase')`/`params.get('head')` then `if (!phase && !head) return decision;` — returns authorized without consulting the claim.", + "The claim path that is bypassed exists immediately below: `openhands-comment-trigger.mjs:64-67` `denied('incomplete-phase-claim')` / `denied('phase-claim-context-required')`.", + "No `phase=`/`head=` token appears anywhere in `agentic-lib.ts`'s DispatchOptions surface (`:515-521`)." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1613, + "title": "agentic: report refused OpenHands commands to their author and align generation retry across dispatch paths", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "N2 confirmed: `.github/workflows/openhands-agent.yml:249` `core.notice(\\`Manual comment policy: ${decision.reason}\\`)` and `:252` for the stale-evaluator case — no `createComment` on the denial path.", + "N3 confirmed: `.github/workflows/openhands-agent.yml:208` `throw new Error(\\`No labeled-event generation found for ${expectedStatus}.\\`)` with no surrounding retry.", + "The asymmetry is real: `.github/workflows/openhands-phase-eval.yml:302-315` wraps the identical lookup in `for (let attempt = 0; attempt < 5 && !generationEvent; attempt += 1)` with a 1s sleep at `:313`." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1616, + "title": "test(cli): the scaffold emits no dynamic route, so no gate exercises dynamic route binding end to end", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "grep -rnE \"createRouteReference\\('/[^']*\\[\" packages/cli/src returns nothing on baseline — no dynamic reference is emitted anywhere", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts:29 emits `createRouteReference('/${segment}', ...)`; packages/cli/src/kernel/application/scaffold/writers/app-route-seeds.ts:45-60 seeds only $route/dashboard/health static references", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/manifest.ts:154-156 maps a `[id]` segment to `$id` and :269 emits `createRouteReference(, )` — Reading B is achievable with no framework change, as the issue claims", + "packages/fresh/tests/fixtures/route-binding-browser/routes.ts exists as a hand-authored fixture (added by 1ed78f508, #1602), confirming the provenance gap the issue describes", + "gh timeline for #1616: cross-referenced only from merged PR #1602; no fix attempt" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1618, + "title": "tooling: deno fmt cannot verify packages/mcp — a deliberately malformed test fixture aborts config parsing", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "Hazard present: `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json` is exactly `{ \"workspace\": \"packages/*\" }` — a string where a WorkspaceConfig is required.", + "The root `fmt` config does not exclude it: `deno.json:206-210` excludes only `packages/cli/`, `**/.generated/`, `**/node_modules/`.", + "Only the whole-repo task compensates: `deno.json:140` `fmt:check` passes `--exclude \"^(packages/(cli)|packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/|...)\"`, so a scoped `--root packages/mcp` run (the issue's repro) carries no such exclusion.", + "That compensating exclusion is pre-existing, not a fix for this issue: it entered in `10162bfda` (#715), long before the issue was filed.", + "`.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` has no fixture-marker skip of its own — the exclusion is caller-supplied only." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1619, + "title": "fix(sdk): cache telemetry evidence validation throws into the data path", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts:164-180 — recordIncompleteTopology is still typed `never` and ends in `throw new TypeError('Cache provider returned missing or invalid topology evidence')`", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts:149 validateDescriptor + :120 createCacheSpanAttributes — validation still runs inside the attribute builder", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:88 — createCacheSpanAttributes(...) is still evaluated as an argument to withSpan, so a bad descriptor throws before any span opens (same at :267, :308, :364, :392, :421)", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts:72 SYSTEM_PATTERN /^[a-z0-9][a-z0-9._-]*$/ still bounds the id, confirming the issue's 'no shipped path triggers it' framing" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1620, + "title": "fix(sdk): cache namespace cardinality is unbounded because operationId is caller-supplied free text", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts:78-89 — normalizeCacheNamespace still only trims/lowercases/collapses/slices to CACHE_NAMESPACE_MAX_LENGTH; no distinct-value bound, no overflow collapse, no warning", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:86 and :389 — namespace derives directly from the caller-supplied options.operationId on every read path", + "Shares its edit surface with #1619 (both mutate packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts and both need a README contract paragraph) — grouped into one leaf" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1621, + "title": "tooling: acceptance-evidence blocks fail opaquely when the target issue has no checkbox boxes", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "Error text present unchanged: `.llm/tools/validation/acceptance-evidence.ts:132` `Issue #${issue}: no acceptance box matched ${compared}; add an entry for box ... using exact trimmed text or its current box-index.`", + "No zero-box special case: `validateEvidenceMapping` (`acceptance-evidence.ts:116-140`) computes `actionable = checkboxes.filter(...)` and iterates evidence entries, emitting one per-index error each; it never tests `actionable.length === 0`.", + "Only the exact-text variant is pinned by a test: `acceptance-evidence_test.ts:55` asserts the `exact box text \"changed\"` message; there is no zero-box test." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1622, + "title": "mcp: the guidance closeScoreGap constant is pinned by no test — a 10x change passes green", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "evidence": [ + "Constant present and unpinned: `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:42` `closeScoreGap: 0.5`, declared at `:29`, consumed at `:201` `leader.score - ranked[end]!.score <= GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap`.", + "The misleading fixture is unchanged: `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76` is the close-score test, `:81` seeds `rankedSection('pages/gamma','outside-leader-band',9.8)` and `:92` asserts `'pages/gamma#outside-leader-band'` last — gamma sorts last by slug either way.", + "No slug-early/score-outside case exists in that test file (no `zulu`/`alpha` boundary pair), so band membership never changes the observable order." + ] + }, + { + "number": 1623, + "title": "docs(sdk): CacheStore.get JSDoc documents a return shape that no longer type-checks", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/ports/cache-store.ts:63 — `@returns Entry with the value or `{ value: null }` on cache miss` is still present", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/cache-store.ts:38-43 — CacheStoreEntry still declares a required `report: CacheReadTopologyReport`, so `{ value: null }` cannot satisfy it", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/cache-store.ts:66-79 — set() JSDoc documents only key/value/options and never mentions the CacheWriteTopologyReport it returns" + ] + }, + { + "number": 1637, + "title": "fix(sdk): cache write limits must not fail successful query results", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "evidence": [ + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1637", + "https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1637#issuecomment-5285236378", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:234-248" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-leaf-plan.json b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-leaf-plan.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..17c8eb0f3a --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-leaf-plan.json @@ -0,0 +1,496 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "capturedAt": "2026-08-13T22:42:00.000Z", + "leafGroups": [ + { + "key": "rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1348 + ], + "wave": 0, + "rationale": "Coordinator checkpoint: RFC 0001 decisions and child Acceptance sections are locked. No implementation PR closes this tracking issue; the coordinator closes it after every child is verified.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1348 + ] + }, + { + "key": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1502 + ], + "wave": 0, + "rationale": "RFC document + PLAN-EVAL for the plugin CLI command contribution seam; proposes its own implementation epic.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-typed-error-channel", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1350 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "packages/sdk/src/client/errors.ts + packages/contracts contract-primitives.ts:81; RFC Stage 1a.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-procedure-metadata", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1466 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "NetScriptProcedureMeta vocabulary; RFC Stage 1b. Must not re-erase Stage 1a types.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-client-contribution-seam", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1349 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 2. Largest slice in the release; body contradicts the merged RFC in four places and must be realigned by Stage 0 first.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1349 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-transport-policy-consolidation", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1351 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 3. One owned transport-policy function; the oRPC family version move is a separate owner decision.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1351 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-auth-contribution-dogfood", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1352 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 4. Auth-core bearer factory + CLI transport swap; cookie transport explicitly out.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1352 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-trace-ownership-proof", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1353 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 5, re-scoped: prove the transport keeps the only final trace injection and rejects contributor ownership.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-locale-contribution-proof", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1467 + ], + "wave": 5, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 6 non-auth proof.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "plugin-discovery-contribution-references", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1093 + ], + "wave": 5, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 7. Filed half (move callee-to-axis to plugins) is one PR; the RFC-added sdkClients-collection half needs #1349 and is not in the issue body.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1093 + ] + }, + { + "key": "prisma-mysql-adapter-surface", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1293 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Export PrismaMySqlAdapter + design the connection-error hook as API; surface-diff gate applies.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "prisma-mysql-honest-example", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1112 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Rewrite the MySQL example against the surface #1293 ships. Blocked until then by the issue own text.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1243 + ], + "wave": 0, + "rationale": "Dead 4437 pins in the auth CLI, the streams manifest, and copy-official-plugin-test-support.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1262, + 1263, + 1588 + ], + "wave": 0, + "rationale": "Generated project output defects sharing one scaffold.runtime verdict: placebo seed, 500-instead-of-404 by-id handler, unreachable SQLite provider parsers.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "app-service-client-wiring", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1355, + 1360 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Grouped because both edit the same ServiceShowcaseLab template - separate PRs would collide.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1355 + ] + }, + { + "key": "ui-add-page-island-repair", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1357 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Repair ui:add page --island emission. Split from #1354 deliberately: repair and new verb need separate review.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1357 + ] + }, + { + "key": "ui-resource-slice-generator", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1354 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "New resource-slice generator verb. Large; the three optional flags are independently testable and are split candidates.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1354 + ] + }, + { + "key": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1358 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Gallery lists 50 of 66 registry items; add the comparison gate.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "workers-job-policy-metadata", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1451 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Use the existing typed netscript.config.ts workers.groups[].jobs[] seam; validate it once and feed both generated RegisterJobInput definitions and runtime handlers. No second manifest.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1451 + ] + }, + { + "key": "workers-job-payload-typing", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1455 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "Registry map + JobTriggerInput + enqueueJob binding. Issue stated baseline is stale: JobDefinition already carries TPayload.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1455 + ] + }, + { + "key": "plugin-service-context-factory", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1452 + ], + "wave": 6, + "rationale": "Publish the PluginServiceContext host factory and consume it from scaffold output.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1452 + ] + }, + { + "key": "workers-execution-progress", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1592 + ], + "wave": 6, + "rationale": "Typed progress on the published ExecutionRecord + durable stream; replay/coalescing needs its own design decision.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1592 + ] + }, + { + "key": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1448 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "Failure-isolated MCP pool startup + cancellation. Snapshot API and cancellation plumbing are independently shippable.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1448 + ] + }, + { + "key": "ai-openai-responses-mapper", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1591 + ], + "wave": 7, + "rationale": "Typed OpenAI Responses mapper on @netscript/ai.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "fresh-ai-chat-response-options", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1458 + ], + "wave": 8, + "rationale": "Awaited durable chat completion options on @netscript/fresh/ai.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "fresh-client-navigation-coordinator", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1590 + ], + "wave": 7, + "rationale": "Four bundled behaviours; only honest as one coordinator module, otherwise split.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1590 + ] + }, + { + "key": "fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1249, + 1609, + 1610 + ], + "wave": 7, + "rationale": "Both are packages/fresh typed-route/managed-form defects on one surface.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1598, + 1619, + 1620, + 1623, + 1637 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "Four small packages/sdk cache-surface repairs sharing one review; grouped to avoid four micro-PRs. #1637 joins here if admitted.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-cached-entry-swr", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1461 + ], + "wave": 5, + "rationale": "Remedy undecided (doc correction vs new queryEntry API); the choice moves the lane.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1461 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-browser-safe-entrypoints", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1462 + ], + "wave": 6, + "rationale": "Export/side-effect restructure; the bundle-content assertion needs a gate that does not exist yet.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1462 + ] + }, + { + "key": "scaffold-route-emission-and-gating", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1481, + 1616 + ], + "wave": 6, + "rationale": "Both change what routes the scaffold emits and how the build gates them.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1616 + ] + }, + { + "key": "cross-package-dependency-declarations", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1543 + ], + "wave": 7, + "rationale": "Undeclared @netscript/plugin-streams-core imports in two published manifests. Small; may ride an adjacent workers PR.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "cli-deploy-verb-surface", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1544 + ], + "wave": 8, + "rationale": "Route or unadvertise `emit`. Product call, not a code call.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1296 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Machine-readable omissions + fresh-ui reference repair + maintainer runbook + gate wiring. Row 1 (contracts JSDoc subpath) is already satisfied on baseline.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1296 + ] + }, + { + "key": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1378, + 1545 + ], + "wave": 0, + "rationale": "MUST be one PR: #1545 registration must precede #1378 rule or the gate is red day one, while #1545 own test box needs that rule to exist.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1378, + 1545 + ] + }, + { + "key": "quality-scan-root-coverage", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1542 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Widen quality:gate roots to published packages. Sequenced after the allowance rail.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "leak-check-process-descendants", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1429 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "leak-check cannot see orphaned Aspire descendants, so it reports clean through a real leak.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "jsdoc-example-compile-gate", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1533 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "Compile JSDoc @example blocks so a published JSR reference cannot import a missing module.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "fresh-defer-test-capability", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1557, + 1601 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "Both are the deferred-coordinator client-bundle gate; #1601 determinism must be fixed before #1557 asserts on it.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1557 + ] + }, + { + "key": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1561, + 1563, + 1621 + ], + "wave": 0, + "rationale": "Three acceptance-evidence / verdict-extraction defects in the same tool family.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1611, + 1613 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Formal evaluator dispatch claim + refused-command reporting in one workflow surface.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "package-gate-honesty", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1604, + 1618, + 1622 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Three packages whose prescribed quality gate is dishonest (always-red cli tests, fmt aborted by a fixture, an unpinnable mcp constant).", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "comparison-docs-programme", + "lane": "docs", + "issues": [ + 1551 + ], + "wave": 0, + "rationale": "17 deliverables. Only methodology page + one case study + migration placeholder is a 0.0.7-sized leaf; the rest needs its own issues.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1551 + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-status.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-status.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..439eb85c22 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-status.md @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ + + + +# Milestone 0.0.7 cluster status + +- Updated: 2026-08-15T21:42:53.000Z +- Current main: `0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb` +- Release captain: inactive + +## Topic lanes + +| Lane | Orchestrator | Issues | Active implementation | Active evaluation | +| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | +| docs | topic-docs-0.0.7 | 1 | 0 | 0 | +| internals | topic-internals-0.0.7 | 16 | 1 | 0 | +| fixes | topic-fixes-0.0.7 | 26 | 1 | 0 | +| features | topic-features-0.0.7 | 17 | 1 | 0 | + +## Leaves + +| PR | Lane | Phase | Head | Blocker | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| #1652 | docs | merged | `d35cbca30872d1f55118d63437638e93270c2ac3` | — | +| — | internals | merged | `09dfb092dccf7f843b9270295047d674a8187362` | — | +| — | internals | merged | `4d9fb196765cbf1a6bc7eaa7c18ec82b237ab89f` | — | +| — | fixes | merged | `e6ba15ec6414c0a42b1f9870791131162ea71c36` | — | +| — | fixes | merged | `5b3c6fcf21b0b4947a770d8e67ea5cc8082724d5` | — | +| #1657 | fixes | merged | `da574111af05a5cded74250128b196fcab870274` | — | +| #1656 | internals | merged | `473e8d75b5281c93dc4729d99f3358a34f2bd687` | — | +| #1658 | internals | merged | `7737d8903bb2925c3fcefbda362168fe297eebd4` | — | +| #1663 | internals | planned | `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b` | — | +| #1666 | internals | implementing | `baf1cdf67a4e931af17b4772ddf6101f36152184` | — | +| #1660 | docs | merged | `e090f894ff3682405a36e4f896ffd2cc16f9a1f8` | — | +| #1661 | fixes | merged | `284dda90a17a13a7e5e8e9834e5411b58887131b` | — | +| #1665 | fixes | merged | `baf1cdf67a4e931af17b4772ddf6101f36152184` | — | +| #1669 | fixes | merged | `3e8e146a4aedf8ee0afec15c83ddaefc171c71f9` | — | +| #1671 | fixes | implementing | `0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb` | — | +| #1662 | features | merged | `284dda90a17a13a7e5e8e9834e5411b58887131b` | — | +| #1664 | features | implementing | `3fc0f2f9221a8246f0d26a26189bafb2647be08a` | — | +| — | features | merged | `12276e6d86403ed1340ef79a963e87d401d643e9` | — | + +## Release train + +- Global expensive gates running: 0 +- Canary checkpoints: 2 +- Release writer: — + diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval-brief.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval-brief.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..da57f231f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval-brief.md @@ -0,0 +1,117 @@ +use harness + +# Composed 0.0.7 milestone PLAN-EVAL brief + +Evaluate the committed 0.0.7 milestone wave plan at exact coordinator head +`a105d2ce28ef50b716ffc24e272594a556e0bd27`. This is the one composed PLAN-EVAL for the whole +milestone. It is a hard pre-implementation gate. Be adversarial, evidence-led, and decisive; do not +approve an unsound plan merely to begin implementation. + +## SKILL + +- `netscript-harness`: read `.agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md`, then enforce + `.llm/harness/evaluator/plan-protocol.md`, `.llm/harness/gates/plan-gate.md`, and + `.llm/harness/evaluator/verdict-definitions.md`. +- `agent-milestone-orchestrator`: read + `.agents/skills/agent-milestone-orchestrator/SKILL.md` and + `.llm/harness/workflow/milestone-run.md`. +- `netscript-doctrine`: use it for package/plugin public-surface and ownership judgements. +- `netscript-tools`: use structured/read-only repo and GitHub inspection where useful. +- `netscript-pr`: enforce lifecycle, issue-closure, and phase-comment vocabulary. +- `aspire`: only to audit the #1306 close-fixed disposition if its evidence is challenged; do not + start resources. + +Read every selected skill file completely before acting. Stay read-only except for writing the one +verdict artifact requested below. Do not edit source, other run artifacts, issue/PR state, labels, +branches, commits, or remote state. Do not start implementation or publish anything. + +## Canonical inputs + +Read these in order: + +1. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/research.md` +2. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.md` +3. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan.md` +4. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/worklog.md` +5. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-intake.json` +6. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-inventory.json` +7. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-dependency-dag.json` +8. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-cluster-state.json` +9. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-leaf-plan.json` +10. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/milestone-status.md` +11. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/supervisor.md` +12. `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/drift.md` + +The frozen baseline is `origin/main` commit `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`. +Independently confirm the evaluator is reading the requested coordinator head and that the plan was +re-baselined against that exact `main`. The current asserted shape is 64 inspected targets: 61 +active, one moved, two close-fixed; 44 leaves; four lanes; ten waves; 24 dependency edges; #1564 +alone in wave 0. Run the milestone validator and its tests if useful, but do not confuse schema +validity with plan quality. + +## Required adversarial audit + +Walk all eight Plan-Gate boxes explicitly and cite exact artifact locations. The standard +single-change wording around fewer than 30 commit slices does not literally fit a 61-issue +milestone: judge whether each individual leaf is bounded and whether the milestone's 44 leaf groups +are coherent, ordered, and supplied with enough contract/gate/file-surface information for their +supervisors. Treat an ambiguous leaf that would force implementation rework as a blocking open +decision. + +Also establish, with evidence: + +- Every active issue appears exactly once in inventory, DAG, lane ownership, and leaf coverage; + moved/closed-fixed issues appear nowhere in dispatchable work. +- #1564 is truly the sole first-merge barrier, and excluding already-fixed `code-quality.yml` + ownership under #1403 is correct. No other leaf may dispatch before that barrier merges and the + plan is re-baselined. +- #1306 is truthfully close-fixed by Aspire 13.4.6 plus the generated NetScript skill, and #1606 is + truthfully discharged by live JSR metadata/landing-page evidence—not merely hidden work. +- #1249 and #1637 meet the recorded `high-value-coherent` admission predicate. +- Leaving #1384/#1385 in 0.0.8 is consistent with release safety and does not hide a stable-cut + blocker; a credential-only partial workaround remains forbidden. +- The top-of-body amendments on #1348/#1349/#1351/#1352/#1353 make merged RFC 0001 unambiguous and + eliminate contradicted proposal text as an implementation input. +- The locked mechanisms for #1461 (existing cache-aware `query()`), #1620 (64-namespace runtime + cap and overflow), and #1621 (specific fail-closed zero-checkbox guidance) satisfy acceptance + without adding a competing public API, unenforceable typing, or a policy bypass. +- #1590's A→B→A/remount contract can be proven by a NetScript-owned black-box fixture while private + `rickylabs/eis-chat` remains read-only reference material at an immutable commit. +- #1551's one-PR, three-ordered-commit methodology/fixture/content plan is feasible, records raw + measurement inputs, labels unmeasured claims, and does not silently promise the optional 50-topic + backlog. +- Exactly four topic orchestrators, WIP at no more than two implementation leaves plus one evaluator + per lane, a single global expensive-gate slot, direct-to-main leaf PRs, coordinator-only merge + authority, one opposite-family IMPL-EVAL per leaf, and a singleton inactive release captain are + enforceable from the control artifacts. +- Canary checkpoints represent meaningful actual first-parent membership, not arbitrary cadence; + stable waits for terminal leaves, exact-main evidence, GitHub Actions OIDC publication, and + artifact-pinned production E2E. +- Provider quota and paid-transport verification are either already evidenced before dispatch or + are an explicit unresolved dispatch hard stop. Do not approve a plan that could dispatch without + those recorded checks. +- Package/plugin leaves have a defensible jsr-audit strategy and name public-surface/slow-type risk; + non-package leaves correctly mark that gate N/A rather than omitting it. +- The risk register, selected gates, deferred scope, and open-decision sweep cover all material + cross-lane collision and cut risks. Spot-check load-bearing claims against the tree and live + GitHub state where needed. + +## Output contract + +Write only +`.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval.md`, following +`.llm/harness/templates/plan-eval.md`. Include: + +1. requested and observed provider/model/effort/session identity and the exact evaluated head; +2. all eight checklist rows with `PASS`/`FAIL` and concrete citations; +3. the evaluator-run open-decision sweep; +4. severity-ranked findings with precise required fixes; +5. exactly one harness verdict: `PASS` or `FAIL_PLAN`. + +For the eventual PR comment vocabulary, begin the artifact with exactly one of: + +- `**[PHASE: PLAN-EVAL] [VERDICT: APPROVED]**` when and only when the harness verdict is `PASS`; +- `**[PHASE: PLAN-EVAL] [VERDICT: CHANGES_REQUESTED]**` when the harness verdict is `FAIL_PLAN`. + +Do not post the comment yourself. The coordinator will review and publish it. Do not invent evidence +or downgrade missing evidence to advice; any unchecked Plan-Gate box is `FAIL_PLAN`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval-cycle-2.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval-cycle-2.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..a080b6bd5d --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval-cycle-2.md @@ -0,0 +1,53 @@ +# PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 of 2 — release 0.0.7 + +**Verdict: APPROVED** + +- Evaluated plan head: `331f7c664` (`d2fe018be..331f7c664`). +- Evaluator: same opposite-family Claude conversation as cycle 1, + `2439b19d-5df7-4920-9fce-fa5831ec4fdf`. +- Route: Fable/medium completed the evidence pass, then hit its monthly spend limit before emitting + the verdict; the same conversation emitted the final synthesis through the recorded Opus/high + fallback. This was not a new evaluation cycle. +- Mutation: read-only; no file, issue, PR, branch, label, or worktree mutation by the evaluator. +- Harness verdict: `PASS` (`validate` `ok:true`; 15/15 tests). + +## Findings + +No blocking findings. Every F1–F11 required repair is verified. + +Non-blocking observations: + +1. The remaining `git show "$BASE_SHA:deno.json"` constructs are conservative applicability + classifiers rather than changed-file ranges. The CI watcher should investigate a surprising + old-base skip rather than dismiss it as noise. +2. Claude quota is constrained until the recorded reset. Implementation routes through WSL Codex; + per-leaf evaluation must preselect the recorded fallback rather than discover exhaustion + mid-wave. +3. Keep the two watcher `agentId` values synchronized between cluster state and supervisor records. + +## Evidence + +- #1564 is live `CLOSED/COMPLETED`, carries the seven-construct audit/correction, and is absent from + DAG nodes, waves, lanes, leaf plans, and contracts. #1403 fixed the only unsafe two-dot construct. +- `leaf-contracts.json` has 43 keys exactly matching the 43 leaf groups. Every contract has file + surfaces, archetype, overlays, proving gates, and either a JSR risk audit or a written N/A reason. + Contract issue coverage equals the 60 active issues exactly once. +- `plan.md` carries the risk register, collision ownership, open-decision sweep, immutable EIS-Chat + SHA, #1249 fallback, #1451 seam, and #1385 deferral distinction. +- #1360 is `features` in inventory, state, and contract; there are no lane mismatches. +- `exactMainEvidence.expectedGateIds` contains the repository gates plus canary/stable OIDC publish + and exact production-E2E identities. Stable requires the publish run's `version.txt` artifact; + local publication is prohibited. +- Quota, provider transport, routing deviation, dispositions, temporary evaluator-worktree cleanup, + watcher identities, and corrected lane counts are recorded in worklog/supervisor/drift. +- Inventory is 60 active plus three close-fixed and one moved; DAG is 60 nodes, nine waves, 24 + strictly earlier-to-later edges; live milestone issue numbers equal committed issue numbers. +- `deno task harness:milestone:validate` returned `{"ok":true}` and + `deno task harness:milestone:test` passed 15/15. + +## Dispatch decision + +**APPROVED — the four topic orchestrators may dispatch.** There is no wave-zero implementation +barrier. Wave-zero leaves may launch under the frozen WIP limits (at most two implementation leaves +and one evaluator per lane, one global expensive-gate slot), with `leaf-contracts.json` binding and +the coordinator holding sole merge authority. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..c53375a511 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan-eval.md @@ -0,0 +1,191 @@ +**[PHASE: PLAN-EVAL] [VERDICT: CHANGES_REQUESTED]** + +# PLAN-EVAL — release-0.0.7--orchestration (composed milestone wave plan) + +## Evaluator identity and evaluated head + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Phase | PLAN-EVAL (composed, whole-milestone), hard pre-implementation gate | +| Requested route | `formal_plan_evaluation` → native opposite-family. Plan author is `codex-root-0.0.7` (Codex family), so `lane-policy.md:45` binds **Claude · Anthropic · Fable 5 · medium** | +| Observed route | **Claude · Anthropic · Opus 5** · native first-party Claude Code session; effort not independently observable from inside the session | +| Route deviation | **Recorded, not hidden.** Family is correct (opposite-family Claude evaluating Codex-authored work — `lane-policy.md` invariant 1 satisfied, generator ≠ evaluator). Model is **not** the bound primary: `lane-policy.md:45` declares only Minimax M3 · high and AGY Gemini 3.6 Flash · high as fallbacks for this lane; Opus 5 is not among them. The coordinator must record this substitution in `supervisor.md`/`drift.md` per `lane-policy.md` § Selection and handoff rules, or re-run on Fable 5 · medium. | +| Evaluator session | `session_01Jn3vRjSJ14PAHcpkJhRbXQ`, host WSL2 Linux 6.18.33.2, checkout `/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix` | +| **Evaluated head** | **`a105d2ce28ef50b716ffc24e272594a556e0bd27`** ("chore: discharge stale 0.0.7 work") | +| Head verification | `git ls-tree` at that SHA lists all 18 run artifacts; `git diff a105d2ce2..6a2ef6861` = `plan-eval-brief.md` only (+117 lines), so the working-tree run artifacts read are byte-identical to the requested head | +| Baseline verification | `git rev-parse origin/main` = `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`; `git merge-base origin/main a105d2ce2` = the same SHA. The plan is baselined on that exact `main`, and all four control artifacts carry it as `baselineMainSha`. | +| Profile | `milestone-cluster` (`workflow/milestone-run.md`), coordinator run, four topic lanes | +| Surface / archetype | Whole-milestone: `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, `.github/workflows/**`, `.llm/tools/**`, docs. Package/plugin-dominant. | +| Scope overlays | None recorded in the run. `SCOPE-frontend` / `SCOPE-service` / `SCOPE-docs` are all in play across the 44 leaves and none is selected (see finding **F3**). | +| Boundaries observed | Read-only throughout. No source, issue, PR, label, branch, milestone, commit, remote or run artifact was mutated. No implementation, evaluator or publish lane dispatched. No Aspire/Docker resource started (`aspire --version` only). | + +## What I independently verified as sound + +Recorded first so the findings below are read as targeted, not as a rejection of the whole run. + +- **Structural integrity of the control plane is exact.** The active-issue set is byte-identical across `milestone-inventory.json` (61 `active` of 64), `milestone-dependency-dag.json` `nodes` (61) and `waves` (61), `milestone-cluster-state.json` `lanes` (61) and `committedIssues` (61), and `milestone-leaf-plan.json` `leafGroups` (61 across 44 leaves). Zero duplicates, zero omissions, zero extras in any of the five sets. `#1306`, `#1453` and `#1606` appear in **no** dispatchable structure. Lane assignment agrees across inventory / DAG / cluster-state for all 61. All 24 edges point strictly earlier-wave → later-wave; the DAG is acyclic; every leaf's `wave` equals its issues' DAG wave. +- **`plan.md` matches its own control artifacts exactly.** All 44 leaf-map rows and all ten wave rows reconcile against `milestone-leaf-plan.json` on key, lane, wave and issue set with zero mismatches. +- **The validator is green and does real work.** `deno task harness:milestone:validate` → `{"ok": true}`. It enforces `limits` exactly `{2,1,1,1}`, exactly four topic lanes, lane ownership == active inventory, `leaf.baseBranch === 'main'`, `mutationAuthority:false` on watchers, an `admissionPredicate` **and** `targetMilestone`/`movedAt` on every included external candidate, and non-empty `exactMainEvidence.expectedGateIds` at release-captain claim (`validate-milestone-cluster.ts:204-210,550-563`). +- **The Step 0 GitHub moves were actually performed, not merely recorded.** Live: `#1453` now carries milestone `Backlog / Triage`; `#1249` (was Backlog) and `#1637` (was unmilestoned) now carry `0.0.7`; `#1564` is open in `0.0.7`; `#1306`/`#1606` are `CLOSED/COMPLETED` at 2026-08-13T19:18Z. Live milestone 27's 61 open issues equal the frozen 61 active exactly. +- **The `#1403` exclusion is correct.** `#1403` is `CLOSED/COMPLETED` in milestone `0.0.6`; `.llm/tools/quality/changed-source-files.ts:14` uses three-dot `${base}...${head}` and `changed-source-files_test.ts` exists. `code-quality.yml:49` routes through it. Excluding it from `#1564` is right. +- **Three locked mechanisms satisfy the brief's constraints.** `#1461` enters through the existing cache-aware `query()` path and adds no competing public API. `#1620`'s 64-namespace runtime cardinality cap with a fixed `overflow` collapse and one bounded warning is runtime-enforceable, unlike the branded string / source-only lint it replaces (`packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts` is the real surface). `#1621` stays fail-closed, detects the zero-checkbox case before index matching, and neither no-ops nor widens issue-template policy. +- **Load-bearing findings spot-checked against the tree and hold.** `packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:234-248` does resolve `data`, then rethrow on a failing `store.set`, discarding the successful result — `#1637`'s premise is real. Aspire CLI **13.4.6** is installed, and `aspire ps/describe --format Json --non-interactive` are documented in both `.agents/skills/aspire/SKILL.md` and `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/skills.generated.ts`. `https://jsr.io/@netscript/sdk/meta.json` reports `latest: 0.0.6`, and the published `0.0.6` README contains **no** `lib/api-clients.ts` reference and names `createQueryFactories` as "the golden path". +- **Canary checkpoints are meaningful, not cadence-arbitrary.** Two checkpoints (`checkpoint-foundations`, `checkpoint-feature-complete`), each with a recorded rationale tied to a coherent green `main` state, and `plan.md:20` binds publication to *actual first-parent membership* rather than the dispatch plan — which is what `canary-cadence.md` requires. +- **The RFC 0001 top-of-body amendments are, as prose, excellent.** Each of `#1348/#1349/#1351/#1352/#1353` carries a dated `> [!IMPORTANT]` block that names the exact superseded claim and its replacement. They resolve all four contradictions the synthesis identified. Their defect is scope, not quality — see **F2**. + +## Checklist results + +| Plan-Gate item | Result | Evidence / location | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Research present and current | **FAIL** | `research.md` exists and the re-baselining requirement is met (baseline `01e0960` == `origin/main`; no carried-in plan; load-bearing findings spot-checked above). But the artifact is **not current**: `research.md:22-23` still asserts "62 active issues across `docs` (7), `internals` (17), `fixes` (20), and `features` (18)" and "The freeze remains provisional". The frozen truth is 61 active / docs 1 / internals 17 / fixes 27 / features 16 (`milestone-status.md:14-17`, `milestone-cluster-state.json` `lanes`). `context-pack.md:6` routes leaf supervisors to `research.md`, so they read superseded lane counts. → **F10** | +| Decisions locked | **FAIL** | Six remedies are locked with rationale at `plan.md:24-43` and three of them are strong (above). But (a) `#1451` — `step0-synthesis.md:178`: "**#1451 does not name its seam** and no candidate exists on baseline — design precedes the slice" — has no locked decision, and it sits in wave 3 with a `cross-epic-order` edge to `#1455` in wave 5; (b) the RFC decision at `plan.md:42-43` locks the *prose* but leaves the machine-checked *acceptance* surface contradicted (**F2**); (c) 24 of 61 active issues carry `splitRisk: true` in `step0-synthesis.json` and only six were dispositioned. | +| Open-decision sweep | **FAIL** | No such section exists anywhere in the run. `plan.md` has no list of still-open decisions, and nothing is marked "safe to defer" or "must resolve now" — the exact vocabulary `gates/plan-gate.md:23-25` requires. `step0-synthesis.json` carries **58** `openUncertainties`; `plan.md` addresses six. My own sweep (below) found rework-forcing items the plan did not flag, which `evaluator/plan-protocol.md:32-34` makes an automatic unchecked box. | +| Commit slices (< 30, gate + files each) | **FAIL** | Enumeration and ordering are excellent: 44 leaves, ten waves, exactly-once coverage, acyclic validated DAG, `plan.md` tables reconciling perfectly with `milestone-leaf-plan.json`. The 44 > 30 count is correctly judged per-leaf rather than literally, and each individual leaf is bounded. **But no leaf names the gate that proves it or the files it touches.** `milestone-leaf-plan.json` leaf schema is exactly `{issues, key, lane, rationale, splitCandidates, wave}` — `rationale` is prose, not a gate or a file surface. `gates/plan-gate.md:26-27` requires both. Also one leaf spans two lanes (**F7**). | +| Risk register | **FAIL** | Absent. There is no risk table, no mitigations, and no cross-lane collision analysis anywhere in the run dir. `gates/plan-gate.md:28` requires risks with mitigations. This matters concretely here: `step0-synthesis.md:117` records that `#1355`/`#1360` "both edit `ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template` and would collide as separate PRs" — that single collision was found and grouped, but with 7 leaves dispatching concurrently in wave 1 and 6 in each of waves 2–4, all direct-to-`main`, no artifact records which other leaves share a surface. | +| Gate set selected | **FAIL** | No gate set is chosen from `gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md` for any surface, and no scope overlay is selected. `plan.md` names gates only as "one global expensive-gate slot" (`plan.md:17`). The `milestone-run.md` pre-merge gate is inherited but never selected or bound per leaf. Concretely: `milestone-cluster-state.json` `exactMainEvidence.expectedGateIds` is `[]`, so no gate IDs are named for the exact-`main` sufficiency computation the stable cut depends on. → **F9** | +| Deferred scope explicit | **PASS** | `plan.md:114-121` states four deferrals with reasons: `#1306` close-fixed, `#1606` closed on live JSR evidence, `#1453` moved with public reason, `#1384`/`#1385` retained in `0.0.8`. `plan.md:41` explicitly declines to promise `#1551`'s optional 50-topic backlog, as the issue permits. `milestone-intake.json` records six `defer` decisions, all `ownerRatified: true` with reasons and linked evidence, including a distinct `#1385`-specific reason that `plan.md` itself omits (**F6** notes). | +| jsr-audit surface scan (pkg/plugin) | **FAIL** | Not `N/A` — this milestone is package/plugin-dominant (`@netscript/sdk`, `service`, `plugin`, `fresh`, `cli`, `plugin-workers-core`, `plugin-auth-core`, `ai`, `database` all have leaves). The `jsr-audit` rubric was **not** applied to the planned public surface, and **no** slow-type or public-surface risk is named in `plan.md` or any control artifact. `gates/plan-gate.md:32-34` requires the scan before slicing, and this is the milestone where it matters most: `#1349` alone turns on whether `createHttpClientLink`/`ClientLinkPort`/`ClientLinkCallOptions` become public, `#1462` is browser-safe entrypoints, `#1543` is cross-package dependency declarations, and `#1296`/`#1604`/`#1618`/`#1622` are export/reference/package-gate honesty. Non-package leaves are not marked `N/A` either — the box is simply absent. | + +**6 FAIL / 2 PASS.** Any unchecked box is `FAIL_PLAN` (`gates/plan-gate.md:19`). + +## Open-decision sweep (evaluator-run) + +Decisions the plan leaves open that would force rework if deferred. Each is an automatic unchecked box under `evaluator/plan-protocol.md:32-34`. + +1. **What `#1564` actually implements.** The single merge barrier for all 61 issues has an unverified residual scope (**F1**). Must resolve now — nothing else may dispatch behind it. +2. **How the SDK-chain leaves close their issues** given contradicted acceptance rows (**F2**). Must resolve now — it decides whether `#1349`/`#1351`/`#1353` are closable at all. +3. **`#1451`'s seam.** `step0-synthesis.md:178` states no candidate exists on baseline. Must resolve now — a wave-3 leaf whose design is undecided blocks `#1455` in wave 5. +4. **Whether `#1249`'s Zod-4 constraint half is a real defect.** Admitted on "both halves require red-first reproduction" with no recorded fallback if it does not reproduce (**F5**). Must resolve now, or the fallback must be recorded — this is the `#1024`/`#1061` mid-flight-split class. +5. **How `#1348` terminates.** Its own acceptance forbids closure by any implementation PR's closing keyword, and two of its boxes need owner answers (**F6**). Must resolve now — the milestone's definition of done requires every issue closed or moved. +6. **The immutable commits for `#1590` and `#1551`.** `plan.md:34-41` says "an immutable commit" and "a recorded immutable commit" of private `rickylabs/eis-chat`, but no SHA is recorded anywhere and no read access is evidenced. `step0-synthesis.md:179-180`: "If unreachable, `#1590`'s semantics are prose-only and `#1551` has no subject." Must resolve now — both leaves' proofs depend on it. +7. **The gate IDs the stable cut requires.** `expectedGateIds: []` (**F9**). Safe to defer only until release-captain activation, where the validator hard-fails — but deferring means no leaf knows which receipts it must produce, so in practice it must resolve before dispatch. +8. **Per-leaf gate and file surface.** Not a decision the plan flagged; it is the missing input every leaf supervisor needs. Must resolve now. + +Decisions I judge genuinely **safe to defer**: the two owner-undecided canary cadence questions (`agent-milestone-orchestrator` § When a canary goes out) — the run has two declared checkpoints and can follow the recorded decision when it is made; and `#1551`'s 50-topic backlog, explicitly follow-up. + +## Findings, severity-ranked + +### F1 — BLOCKING. The sole wave-0 merge barrier is scoped from a consumer audit that baseline `main` contradicts + +`plan.md:16` makes this the hardest invariant in the run: *"#1564 is the sole wave-0 merge barrier. No other implementation leaf may dispatch until its CI range fix is merged to `main` and its stale-base fixture is green."* All 43 other leaves and all 61 issues sit behind it. `step0-synthesis.md:174-176` already warned: *"#1564's blast radius is stated, not proven — four of five consumers are recorded as unaudited in the issue itself."* The coordinator settled the `#1403` boundary ([comment 5285276645](https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1564#issuecomment-5285276645)) but never performed the audit. I performed it against `a105d2ce2`: + +- `#1564`'s reproduction is a **two-dot** range: `git diff --name-only --diff-filter=ACMR cd24e1679 2a4102600 -- packages plugins` (issue body, "Reproduced on #1539"). +- Every consumer the boundary comment assigns to `#1564` already uses **three-dot** on baseline: `ci.yml:145`, `e2e-cli.yml:138`, `surface-diff.yml:56` all run `git diff --name-status -M "$BASE_SHA...$HEAD_SHA"`. All three checkout with `fetch-depth: 0` (`ci.yml:122`, `e2e-cli.yml:110`, `surface-diff.yml:33`), so the merge-base is computable. +- `git diff A...B` is `diff(merge_base(A,B), B)`. A stale-or-advanced `base.sha` still resolves to the PR's fork point, which is why three-dot **is** the fix `#1403` applied. + +Consequence: `#1564`'s "CI range fix" on its three assigned range consumers is plausibly an audit-and-justify outcome, not a code change — and its acceptance criterion 2, which demands the fixture be **"Proven red-first"**, then has no red case to prove on those workflows. That is precisely the `milestone-run.md` § Gate integrity "proof of firing" defect: a guard whose predicate can never be true, which 0.0.4 shipped twice. + +Separately, the genuinely stale-sensitive residual is a **different** step: `git show "$BASE_SHA:deno.json"` at `ci.yml:163` and `e2e-cli.yml:163` reads a file *at the recorded base commit*, which a stale base does corrupt. And **two consumers of the same input are absent from `#1564`'s table and from the boundary comment entirely**: `pages.yml:79,100` and `fresh-ui-quality.yml:62,83`, both carrying the identical `BASE_SHA` + `git show "$BASE_SHA:deno.json"` pattern. `#1564`'s acceptance criterion 1 says **"Every workflow computing a changed-file range from `pull_request.base.sha`"** — that box cannot be truthfully ticked against the scope the coordinator recorded. + +**Required fix.** Re-audit all seven `base.sha` consumers at `01e0960` and rewrite `#1564`'s consumer table and the boundary comment to state, per workflow and per line, which construct is affected (two-dot range, three-dot range, or `git show BASE_SHA:path`) and what the leaf will change. Add `pages.yml` and `fresh-ui-quality.yml` or state on the issue why they are excluded. Then re-state the red-first fixture against a construct that can actually go red. If the outcome is that no range fix is needed, say so and re-decide whether `#1564` is still a whole-milestone merge barrier or a wave-1 leaf — a barrier that gates 61 issues on an audit is a different plan. + +### F2 — BLOCKING. The RFC amendments leave contradicted acceptance checkboxes live, so SDK-chain leaves cannot close their issues + +`plan.md:42-43` locks: *"the top-of-body 0.0.7 amendments and merged RFC 0001 are normative; the superseded proposal text is never an implementation input."* The amendments say the older text is *"non-normative where [it] conflicts"*. That is sufficient for **prose**. It is not sufficient for the **acceptance checklists**, which were not edited and which are the machine-checked close criteria. Verified live: + +| Issue | Live acceptance row | The amendment says | +| --- | --- | --- | +| `#1349` | `- [ ] createHttpClientLink, ClientLinkPort and ClientLinkCallOptions are exported from their…` | must **not** publicly export any of the three | +| `#1349` | `- [ ] port and timeout are removed from the client and defineServices option records.` | must **keep** them accepted/deprecated rather than remove | +| `#1353` | `- [ ] traceContextContribution() ships as an SdkClientContribution declaring its header keys…` | *"Do **not** ship `traceContextContribution()`"* | +| `#1353` | `- [ ] createHttpClientLink contains no trace-header authorship; the contribution is the only…` | the transport *"remains the sole final author of trace headers"* | +| `#1353` | `- [ ] NEGATIVE: with the contribution removed from the chain, a request carries no traceparent…` | reversed by the above | +| `#1351` | `- [ ] deno task deps:latest shows the oRPC family at 1.14.15 and deno why @orpc/shared shows a…` | any dependency move is a *separate* decision targeting stable **v1.15.0** | + +`milestone-run.md` pre-merge gate check 2 requires **"zero unticked `- [ ]` on every issue the PR closes"**, and the honesty rule states a criterion that cannot be truthfully ticked **moves with its issue** and *"is never ticked to clear a gate."* Those two rules are now in direct collision for `#1349`, `#1351` and `#1353`: the leaf either ticks a box the amendment forbids implementing, or its close-gate stays red. That is the `#1024`/`#1061` mid-flight-split class arriving at merge time in waves 4–5, after the SDK chain has already consumed the critical path. + +**Required fix.** Before dispatch, rewrite the **Acceptance** sections of `#1349`, `#1351`, `#1352` and `#1353` to the amended scope — strike or restate each contradicted row in place, rather than leaving it under a superseding note. Any row that survives only as history must be moved out of the checklist. + +### F3 — BLOCKING. Five Plan-Gate boxes have no artifact at all + +Open-decision sweep, per-leaf gate + file surface, risk register, gate set selection, and the jsr-audit surface scan are each simply absent from the run dir, not merely thin. `gates/plan-gate.md:45` is explicit that absence of a script is not permission to omit a check, and `evaluator/plan-protocol.md:44-47` forbids downgrading missing evidence to advice. See the checklist rows for the per-box citation and consequence. + +**Required fix.** Add to `plan.md` (or a committed companion the leaf briefs reference): a risk register with mitigations, including a shared-surface collision table for concurrently dispatched leaves; the gate set selected from `gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md` per surface plus the scope overlays in play; a jsr-audit surface scan over the planned public surface naming slow-type and export risks per package leaf, with an explicit `N/A` + reason on non-package leaves; an open-decision sweep with each item marked "safe to defer" or "must resolve now"; and, per leaf, the proving gate and the file surface it touches — this is the field `milestone-leaf-plan.json`'s schema is missing and the field every leaf supervisor needs. + +### F4 — MAJOR. `#1606` was closed with an acceptance criterion that is false on live GitHub right now + +Its fourth criterion is `- [ ] #1377's [post-merge] row is ticked, referencing this issue.` I checked `#1377`: it is `CLOSED/COMPLETED` in milestone `0.0.6`, and its line 115 is still `- [ ] [post-merge] The published JSR landing page for @netscript/sdk shows the canonical dialect.` — unticked. The close comment on `#1606` does not mention that row. + +The other three criteria I verified as genuinely true (JSR `latest: 0.0.6`; the published `0.0.6` README contains no `lib/api-clients.ts` and leads its value bullets with `createQueryFactories` as "the golden path"; version and observation date recorded on the issue). So this is not hidden work — the observational discharge is real. It is an honesty-rule slip on one row, and it is cheap to fix. + +**Required fix.** Tick `#1377`'s `[post-merge]` row with a reference to `#1606`'s verification comment, or record on `#1606` why that row is being left for `#1377`'s own bookkeeping. Do not leave an issue closed `completed` with a criterion that reads false to anyone who checks. + +### F5 — MAJOR. `#1249`'s admission does not meet its recorded predicate + +`milestone-intake.json` records `admissionPredicate: "high-value-coherent"` for `#1249`. `milestone-run.md` step 0.2 defines that predicate as *"complete P1/feature scope that serves the release without displacing a critical prerequisite."* Live, `#1249` is `priority:p2`, `type:fix` — neither P1 nor feature scope. Nor is it "complete": `step0-synthesis.md:140` calls it *"**Weakest, and one supporting claim needs correcting**"*, shows the `min`/`max`/`multipleOf` claim rests on Zod 3 names read by Zod 4's `def.check`, calls it *"unconfirmed without executing a probe"*, and recommends *"Admit on the `controlProps` half only."* The intake admitted both halves with "both halves require red-first reproduction" and **no recorded fallback** if the second half does not reproduce. The leaf `fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair` then couples `#1249`'s close-gate to `#1609`/`#1610`. + +This is the opportunistic-scope-growth failure mode the predicate exists to prevent, and it is sharpened by the contrast with `#1637` — `priority:p1`, a consumer-visible false outage on published `@netscript/sdk@0.0.6-canary.3`, riding an existing leaf at near-zero cost — which meets the predicate cleanly and which I raise no objection to. + +**Required fix.** Either re-scope `#1249`'s admission to the `controlProps` half (as the synthesis recommended) and amend the issue accordingly, or record on the intake the explicit fallback: if the Zod-4 constraint half does not reproduce red-first, that half moves to `0.0.8` with a written reason rather than being ticked or silently dropped. + +### F6 — MAJOR. `#1348` has no closure path, and its leaf's work is largely already done + +`rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board` is a wave-1 leaf on the critical path — eight `rfc-prerequisite` edges fan out of `#1348` into waves 2–6. But its own acceptance says `- [ ] This issue is not closed by any implementation PR's closing keyword`, and `milestone-leaf-plan.json` agrees: *"Tracking issue - no implementation PR may carry a closing keyword on it."* Meanwhile the worklog records that Stage 0's substance — RFC ratification and the realignment of `#1349`–`#1353` — was already performed during Step 0 at 21:15Z. Two of its remaining boxes (`Q1 (cookie topology) and Q2 (PluginContributions group shape) are answered on this issue`) are owner decisions no agent can execute, and `step0-synthesis.md:166-169` records that RFC 0001 still lists **11 unresolved questions** at `:1555-1599` — *"the biggest unknown gating waves 3–6."* + +So the plan has a leaf that produces no mergeable PR, cannot be closed by one, has partly already executed, and depends on owner answers that are not scheduled — while the milestone's definition of done requires every issue closed with verified acceptance or moved with a written reason. + +**Required fix.** State `#1348`'s termination path in `plan.md`: who answers Q1/Q2 and when, which boxes Step 0 already discharged, and whether `#1348` closes at the feature-complete checkpoint or moves to `0.0.8` as an epic. If the RFC's 11 open questions gate waves 3–6, say which ones and schedule them. + +### F7 — MODERATE. One leaf spans two topic lanes + +`app-service-client-wiring` is `lane: features` and owns `#1355` (features) and `#1360` (**fixes**). `milestone-run.md` § Cluster control plane requires topic issue sets to be exclusive and a topic orchestrator to own *only* its allocated issues. The validator does not catch this: it checks lane ownership against inventory and leaf `lane` validity independently, never their agreement. The grouping itself is well-justified (`step0-synthesis.md:117` — both edit `ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template` and would collide as separate PRs), so the fix is bookkeeping, not re-clustering. + +**Required fix.** Move `#1360` to the `features` lane in inventory, DAG and cluster state, re-render and re-validate. Consider adding a leaf-lane/issue-lane agreement check to the validator so this class cannot recur silently. + +### F8 — MODERATE. The quota and paid-transport preflight is thin and pre-dates the re-freeze + +`milestone-run.md` stage B makes these procedural gates whose proof is *"the recorded check output (what was queried, when, result)"*, because both cost real time in 0.0.4 — a hard quota cap mid-delivery, and $7.43 billed to the wrong transport. `worklog.md:9` records at `18:43:18.739Z`: *"Claude first-party Max; Codex ChatGPT authenticated; `agentic:runtime doctor`: `no_change`, all components ready; routing state `[]`."* That evidences **authentication and runtime health**, not quota headroom and not transport billing. It was also taken against the provisional 62-issue plan, ~2h45m before the 64/61/44 re-freeze at `21:28:00Z`, for a milestone roughly 4× the 0.0.4 exemplar (`step0-synthesis.md:98`). + +**Required fix.** Re-run the preflight against the frozen plan and record the actual numbers: remaining quota per provider lane with reset windows, and an explicit confirmation of which transport each lane bills to. A record that cannot distinguish "have headroom" from "am authenticated" does not discharge a gate whose negative case is exhaustion mid-delivery. + +### F9 — MODERATE. The stable-cut conditions are under-specified and the sufficiency computation is unpopulated + +`plan.md:20` says only *"Stable waits for all committed issues/leaves to be terminal and exact-`main` evidence to be sufficient."* It does not name **GitHub Actions OIDC publication** or **artifact-pinned production E2E**, both of which `milestone-run.md` § Definition of done and `netscript-release` require. `milestone-cluster-state.json` has `exactMainEvidence.expectedGateIds: []` and `receipts: []`, and `releaseCaptain.evidence: []`. The validator does hard-fail on empty `expectedGateIds` — but only once the captain leaves `inactive` (`validate-milestone-cluster.ts:530-532,550-551`), so today nothing names the gates, and no leaf knows which receipts it is expected to produce. + +**Required fix.** Populate `expectedGateIds` with the gate identities the exact-`main` cut will require, and state the OIDC-publication and artifact-pinned production-E2E conditions in `plan.md:20` rather than relying on inheritance. + +### F10 — LOW. `research.md` is stale and `drift.md` contradicts the frozen state + +`research.md:22-23` asserts a provisional 62-issue / 4-lane split that the freeze superseded, and says the freeze *"remains provisional"*. `drift.md` reads in full: *"No accepted drift. Step 0 is in progress and no scope has frozen."* — while scope is frozen, `#1453` was moved, two issues were closed-fixed, lane allocation was rebalanced (docs 2→1, features 17→16, fixes 25→27), and two external candidates were admitted. `netscript-harness` § Run Artifacts makes `drift.md` the append-only record of exactly these events, and `lane-policy.md` § Selection and handoff rules requires the selected lane and any override to be recorded in `supervisor.md` **and** `drift.md`. + +Relatedly, `supervisor.md` carries profile, run id, coordinator, branch, baseline and start time — but no model, session, host, checkout/worktree path, **lane table**, or **PLAN-EVAL decision**, all of which `lane-policy.md` § Supervisor identity and the `milestone-run.md` checklist require ("PLAN-EVAL decision for the wave plan recorded in `supervisor.md`"). + +**Required fix.** Update `research.md` to the frozen numbers; open `drift.md` with the Step 0 disposition events, the lane rebalance, and this evaluation's route substitution; complete `supervisor.md` with the lane table, identity fields, and the PLAN-EVAL decision. + +### F11 — LOW. Residual `#1306` scope is unrouted, and three bookkeeping slips + +- **`#1306`.** Its close is defensible: the four rows read as alternative remedies across three surfaces (`step0-synthesis.md:124`), and I verified rows 1 and 4 are genuinely satisfied by Aspire 13.4.6 plus both skill files. But rows 2 (`aspire start` non-TTY attached-or-documented contract) and 3 (dashboard login token to stdout when no TTY) were **not** satisfied — the close comment argues they are moot rather than met. Per `milestone-run.md` § Cut-time checklist and the `#1090` pattern, the residual DX gap should be routed to a follow-up issue at the moment it is noticed, not left implicit in a close comment. +- **Four milestone issues are absent from the inventory** — `#1108`, `#1201`, `#1260`, `#1550`, all closed 2026-08-11/12, i.e. before the run. Step 0.4 says inventory *every* resulting target-milestone issue. The omission is harmless but undocumented; state that the inventory covers issues open at `baselineMainSha`. +- **No watchers.** `milestone-cluster-state.json` `watchers: []`, while stage A's contract names read-only watchers as part of cluster bootstrap. +- **Stale counts in committed artifacts.** `milestone-leaf-plan.json`'s `#1564` rationale still says *"With 45 leaves merging direct-to-main"*; the frozen count is 44. + +## Verdict + +`FAIL_PLAN` + +Six of eight Plan-Gate boxes are unchecked, and the evaluator-run sweep found eight open decisions the plan did not flag, at least six of which force rework if deferred. Two findings are independently blocking on their merits: the milestone's single merge barrier is scoped from a consumer audit that baseline `main` contradicts (**F1**), and the RFC realignment left the machine-checked acceptance surface in a state where three SDK-chain leaves cannot close their issues without violating either the close-gate or the honesty rule (**F2**). + +This is not a weak plan. Its control plane is the most internally consistent I have audited in this repository — five independent structures agreeing exactly on 61 issues, a validated acyclic DAG, GitHub moves actually performed rather than merely recorded, and three genuinely well-chosen locked mechanisms. The gap is that the run produced a **dispatch schedule** and stopped short of the **plan** the Plan-Gate asks for: the risk, gate, surface and open-decision work that turns a schedule into something 44 leaf supervisors can execute without rediscovering the same decisions. That is the cheap fix happening before the expensive one, which is what this gate exists for. + +### Required fixes, in dispatch-blocking order + +1. **F1** — re-audit all seven `pull_request.base.sha` consumers at `01e0960`; restate `#1564`'s scope, consumer table and boundary comment per workflow and per construct; add or explicitly exclude `pages.yml` and `fresh-ui-quality.yml`; re-state the red-first fixture against a construct that can go red; re-decide whether `#1564` remains a whole-milestone barrier. +2. **F2** — rewrite the Acceptance sections of `#1349`, `#1351`, `#1352`, `#1353` to the amended scope, striking contradicted rows in place rather than superseding them by note. +3. **F3** — add the risk register (with a shared-surface collision table), the selected gate set and overlays, the jsr-audit surface scan with per-leaf `N/A` reasons, the open-decision sweep with defer/resolve-now markers, and per-leaf proving gate + file surface. +4. **F6** — state `#1348`'s termination path and schedule the RFC's open questions that gate waves 3–6. +5. **F5** — re-scope `#1249`'s admission or record its fallback. +6. **F9** — populate `expectedGateIds`; name OIDC publication and artifact-pinned production E2E in the stable-cut conditions. +7. **F8** — re-run the quota/transport preflight against the frozen plan and record actual numbers. +8. **F4**, **F7**, **F10**, **F11** — bookkeeping: `#1377`'s post-merge row; `#1360`'s lane; `research.md`, `drift.md`, `supervisor.md` currency; `#1306` residual routing; inventory scope note; watchers; the "45 leaves" string. + +Re-render and re-run `harness:milestone:validate` after 1, 5, 7 and the `#1360` lane move; the current `ok: true` does not survive an inventory or lane edit unexamined, and schema validity was never the question here. + +### Loop status + +This is `FAIL_PLAN` cycle **1 of 2**. A second `FAIL_PLAN` escalates to the owner with the unresolved items (`evaluator/plan-protocol.md:52-55`). + +## Notes + +- No implementation, evaluator or publish lane was dispatched, and no repository state was mutated. The coordinator owns publishing this as the PR phase comment. +- The route substitution in the identity table (Opus 5 where `lane-policy.md:45` binds Fable 5 · medium) is a recorded deviation, not an approved fallback. If the coordinator wants a route-clean verdict on the re-submitted plan, run cycle 2 on Fable 5 · medium; the opposite-family invariant is satisfied either way. +- `#1384`/`#1385` remaining in `0.0.8`: I judge this defensible and not a hidden stable-cut blocker. `#1384`'s reasoning is sound and the credential-only carve-out is correctly refused. `#1385` is a p0 that `step0-synthesis.md:139` says *"Needs nothing from #1383"*, and `plan.md:9-10` justifies only `#1384` — but `milestone-intake.json` carries a distinct, owner-ratified `#1385` reason (auth transport topology outside this milestone's typed-extension scope). Fold that reason into `plan.md` so the deferral does not read as covered by `#1384`'s argument. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2054794944 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/plan.md @@ -0,0 +1,171 @@ +# Plan — release 0.0.7 milestone cluster + +## Frozen scope and gate + +The owner-ratified inventory contains **64 target issues**: **60 active**, **one moved** (#1453, +whose cited surface has never existed in this repository), and **three closed-fixed** after live +verification (#1306, #1564, and #1606). Two external issues were admitted before freeze under +`high-value-coherent`: #1249 and #1637. The auth defects #1384/#1385 remain in 0.0.8; #1384 cannot +be correctly completed without #1383, and a partial credential-only workaround is explicitly +rejected. + +Exactly one composed `PLAN-EVAL` is required for this milestone plan. Mechanical leaves whose design is fully locked here may record leaf `PLAN-EVAL: N/A`; every implementation leaf still requires a separate-session, opposite-family `IMPL-EVAL` unless the owner records an attributed waiver. + +## Execution invariants + +1. **There is no synthetic implementation barrier.** #1564's seven-construct audit proved that all + changed-file consumers already use merge-base semantics and #1403 fixed the affected two-dot + construct, so #1564 is closed-fixed. PLAN-EVAL approval remains the sole dispatch barrier. +2. Exactly four topic orchestrators own `docs`, `internals`, `fixes`, and `features`. Each lane may run at most two implementation leaves and one evaluator; the cluster has one global expensive-gate slot. +3. Every leaf PR targets `main` directly, carries immutable-head structured receipts, and merges only after independent evaluation. The coordinator alone mutates cluster state and merges. +4. RFC 0001 is normative. #1348 realigns #1349–#1353 before SDK implementation; implementers must not follow contradicted/stale issue rows. +5. Canaries publish only from actual first-parent membership at the foundations and feature-complete checkpoints. Stable waits for all committed issues/leaves to be terminal and exact-`main` evidence to be sufficient. +6. Publication is GitHub Actions OIDC-only. Stable qualification requires the canary OIDC publish + and its exact-version E2E pair, then the stable OIDC publish and the production E2E run pinned to + the `version.txt` artifact from that exact publish workflow. Local publication is prohibited. + +## Decisions locked before dispatch + +- **#1461:** do not add a second public `queryEntry()` API. Correct the published loader to enter + through the existing cache-aware `query()` path, then read entry metadata; prove fresh/miss/stale + and concurrent-stale dedupe behavior with the executable example. +- **#1620:** use a runtime cardinality guard, not an unenforceable branded string or source-only + lint. Admit at most 64 distinct normalized telemetry namespaces per process, collapse later novel + values to one fixed `overflow` namespace, and emit one bounded warning that names the first + offender. Static shipped call sites remain unchanged. +- **#1621:** keep the acceptance mirror fail-closed, but detect the zero-checkbox case before index + matching and emit the specific removal-or-convert guidance. Update `netscript-pr`; do not make it + a no-op and do not widen issue-template policy in this leaf. +- **#1590:** the issue's A→B→A/region-remount behavior is the framework contract. The implementing + lane may read `rickylabs/eis-chat` at immutable commit + `5191de83f3da97559f21d8891c6c8afdf1cf473a` through existing GitHub access, but the + shipped proof is a NetScript-owned black-box fixture and does not copy consumer business code. +- **#1551:** one PR, three ordered commits: methodology/navigation; pinned Next.js-equivalence + fixture plus measurement scripts; comparison/migration pages and matrices. Read the private + EIS-Chat route at a recorded immutable commit, hold shared leaf presentation constant, publish + raw measurement inputs, and label every unmeasured statement inspected/inferred. The 50-topic + backlog remains follow-up work, as the issue explicitly permits. Its private EIS-Chat input is + pinned to `5191de83f3da97559f21d8891c6c8afdf1cf473a`. +- **#1349/#1351/#1352/#1353:** the top-of-body 0.0.7 amendments and merged RFC 0001 are normative; + the superseded proposal text is never an implementation input. +- **#1249:** run independent red-first probes for both filed defects. If the locked Zod-family probe + does not reproduce, move only that half visibly to 0.0.8 with its output and reason; never tick it + silently or broaden the fix. +- **#1451:** extend the existing typed `netscript.config.ts` `workers.groups[].jobs[]` seam and feed + the validated policy into the installed workers registry generator. Do not add a second manifest. +- **#1385:** remains independently deferred because cookie/CORS transport topology belongs to the + later auth pack; it is distinct from #1383's server-header propagation repair. + +## Leaf contracts, gates, and JSR audit + +`leaf-contracts.json` is dispatch input, not optional prose. Every one of the 43 leaves names its +expected file surfaces, smallest doctrine archetype, overlays, proving gates selected from the +archetype matrix, and either a publishable-member JSR audit or an explicit non-package N/A reason. +Implementers must update a contract before crossing its file boundary; the coordinator treats an +undeclared package/plugin touch as drift and pauses that leaf. + +## Risk register and collision ownership + +| Risk | Early signal | Containment / owner | +| --- | --- | --- | +| RFC/client semantics regress to stale issue prose | public link/callback/fetch or trace-contribution API appears | RFC 0001 plus rewritten Acceptance rows; SDK critical path remains serialized | +| Two leaves edit the same source seam | declared file surfaces overlap before dispatch | coordinator assigns one owner or orders leaves; no parallel overlapping mutations | +| JSR dry-run is green but published graph fails | asset/import-meta reads, stale exact pins, first-publish member | per-leaf JSR audit; release preflight; OIDC canary plus exact-version production E2E | +| Runtime leaves leak Aspire/Docker/process state | leak-check or final inventory reports owned resources | one global expensive gate; scoped teardown; final Aspire/Docker/WSL audit | +| Private consumer evidence drifts | EIS-Chat default branch moves | immutable SHA above; NetScript-owned black-box fixtures are the shipped proof | +| Canary quota/cadence is wasted | bookkeeping-only checkpoint or insufficient JSR quota | publish only meaningful first-parent checkpoints; fail closed before minting | + +| Collision surface | Owning leaves / order | +| --- | --- | +| SDK contribution, transport, auth, trace | `sdk-typed-error-channel` → `sdk-procedure-metadata` → `sdk-client-contribution-seam` → wave-4 SDK leaves | +| Service showcase scaffold | single grouped `app-service-client-wiring` leaf (#1355/#1360) | +| Fresh navigation/forms/routes | framework foundations before `fresh-client-navigation-coordinator` and `fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair` | +| Workers generated registry | `workers-job-policy-metadata` before `workers-job-payload-typing` | +| Harness evidence/quality gates | foundation tooling leaves precede package-gate honesty and release evidence collection | +| Docs/JSR landing surfaces | docs leaf consumes pinned inputs; JSR observation remains closed-fixed and release E2E is authoritative | + +## Open-decision sweep + +All dispatch-blocking owner decisions are resolved in the issue Acceptance sections: bearer-only +auth topology; generic optional `sdkClients` references; ceiling 16; application-supplied bearer; +outer logical-call composition; procedure metadata in #1350/#1466; explicit incoming-header +selection; whole-family oRPC v1.15.0; and coordinator-only #1348 closure. oRPC v2, cookie/session +transport, environment token convenience, and the comparison-docs 50-topic backlog are explicitly +safe-deferred and are not hidden 0.0.7 gates. + +## Dependency and dispatch waves + +| Wave | Leaf groups | Issues | +| ---: | --- | --- | +| 0 | rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board
rfc-plugin-cli-contribution
legacy-port-pin-sweep
scaffold-generated-output-correctness
quality-scan-allowance-rail
harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling
comparison-docs-programme | #1243, #1262, #1263, #1348, #1378, #1502, #1545, #1551, #1561, #1563, #1588, #1621 | +| 1 | sdk-typed-error-channel
prisma-mysql-adapter-surface
app-service-client-wiring
design-registry-catalog-drift-gate
quality-scan-root-coverage
openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal | #1293, #1350, #1355, #1358, #1360, #1542, #1611, #1613 | +| 2 | sdk-procedure-metadata
prisma-mysql-honest-example
ui-add-page-island-repair
workers-job-policy-metadata
reference-export-drift-gate
package-gate-honesty | #1112, #1296, #1357, #1451, #1466, #1604, #1618, #1622 | +| 3 | sdk-client-contribution-seam
ui-resource-slice-generator
ai-mcp-pool-isolation
sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry
leak-check-process-descendants
jsdoc-example-compile-gate | #1349, #1354, #1429, #1448, #1533, #1598, #1619, #1620, #1623, #1637 | +| 4 | sdk-transport-policy-consolidation
sdk-auth-contribution-dogfood
sdk-trace-ownership-proof
workers-job-payload-typing
fresh-defer-test-capability | #1351, #1352, #1353, #1455, #1557, #1601 | +| 5 | sdk-locale-contribution-proof
plugin-discovery-contribution-references
sdk-cached-entry-swr | #1093, #1461, #1467 | +| 6 | plugin-service-context-factory
workers-execution-progress
sdk-browser-safe-entrypoints
scaffold-route-emission-and-gating | #1452, #1462, #1481, #1592, #1616 | +| 7 | ai-openai-responses-mapper
fresh-client-navigation-coordinator
fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair
cross-package-dependency-declarations | #1249, #1543, #1590, #1591, #1609, #1610 | +| 8 | fresh-ai-chat-response-options
cli-deploy-verb-surface | #1458, #1544 | + +## Leaf map + +| Wave | Leaf | Lane | Issues | +| ---: | --- | --- | --- | +| 0 | `rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board` | features | #1348 | +| 0 | `rfc-plugin-cli-contribution` | features | #1502 | +| 1 | `sdk-typed-error-channel` | fixes | #1350 | +| 2 | `sdk-procedure-metadata` | features | #1466 | +| 3 | `sdk-client-contribution-seam` | features | #1349 | +| 4 | `sdk-transport-policy-consolidation` | fixes | #1351 | +| 4 | `sdk-auth-contribution-dogfood` | features | #1352 | +| 4 | `sdk-trace-ownership-proof` | fixes | #1353 | +| 5 | `sdk-locale-contribution-proof` | features | #1467 | +| 5 | `plugin-discovery-contribution-references` | fixes | #1093 | +| 1 | `prisma-mysql-adapter-surface` | features | #1293 | +| 2 | `prisma-mysql-honest-example` | fixes | #1112 | +| 0 | `legacy-port-pin-sweep` | fixes | #1243 | +| 0 | `scaffold-generated-output-correctness` | fixes | #1262, #1263, #1588 | +| 1 | `app-service-client-wiring` | features | #1355, #1360 | +| 2 | `ui-add-page-island-repair` | fixes | #1357 | +| 3 | `ui-resource-slice-generator` | features | #1354 | +| 1 | `design-registry-catalog-drift-gate` | fixes | #1358 | +| 2 | `workers-job-policy-metadata` | features | #1451 | +| 4 | `workers-job-payload-typing` | features | #1455 | +| 6 | `plugin-service-context-factory` | features | #1452 | +| 6 | `workers-execution-progress` | features | #1592 | +| 3 | `ai-mcp-pool-isolation` | fixes | #1448 | +| 7 | `ai-openai-responses-mapper` | features | #1591 | +| 8 | `fresh-ai-chat-response-options` | features | #1458 | +| 7 | `fresh-client-navigation-coordinator` | features | #1590 | +| 7 | `fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair` | fixes | #1249, #1609, #1610 | +| 3 | `sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry` | fixes | #1598, #1619, #1620, #1623, #1637 | +| 5 | `sdk-cached-entry-swr` | fixes | #1461 | +| 6 | `sdk-browser-safe-entrypoints` | fixes | #1462 | +| 6 | `scaffold-route-emission-and-gating` | fixes | #1481, #1616 | +| 7 | `cross-package-dependency-declarations` | fixes | #1543 | +| 8 | `cli-deploy-verb-surface` | fixes | #1544 | +| 2 | `reference-export-drift-gate` | internals | #1296 | +| 0 | `quality-scan-allowance-rail` | internals | #1378, #1545 | +| 1 | `quality-scan-root-coverage` | internals | #1542 | +| 3 | `leak-check-process-descendants` | internals | #1429 | +| 3 | `jsdoc-example-compile-gate` | internals | #1533 | +| 4 | `fresh-defer-test-capability` | internals | #1557, #1601 | +| 0 | `harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling` | internals | #1561, #1563, #1621 | +| 1 | `openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal` | internals | #1611, #1613 | +| 2 | `package-gate-honesty` | internals | #1604, #1618, #1622 | +| 0 | `comparison-docs-programme` | docs | #1551 | + +## Canary checkpoints + +- **Foundations:** after the shared SDK, quality, harness, and generator foundations are merged and + independently green; membership is derived from actual first-parent history. +- **Feature complete:** after every code leaf is merged, immediately before stable release qualification. + +## Deferred and observational work + +- #1306 is closed-fixed: Aspire 13.4.6 and the generated NetScript skill already expose the native + JSON inventory path the issue requested. +- #1564 is closed-fixed after the consumer-by-consumer audit; #1403 owns the completed red-first fix. +- #1606 is closed after live JSR registry and landing-page verification; it requires no code PR. +- #1453 was moved to Backlog / Triage with a public reason and evidence. +- #1384/#1385 remain owned by 0.0.8; this release will not ship a partial security workaround that fails their acceptance contract. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/pr-body.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/pr-body.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2aa74765cb --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/pr-body.md @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +## Summary + +Coordinate the complete 0.0.7 milestone through the milestone-cluster harness: freeze scope, +schedule four topic lanes, retain structured gate/evaluator evidence, publish meaningful canaries, +and cut stable only from exact-main green evidence. + +## Scope + +- Archetype / area: release orchestration and harness evidence +- Evidence-only coordinator PR; closes no product issue. +- Frozen intake: 64 inspected targets, 60 active, one moved, three closed-fixed, 43 leaves, + four topic lanes, and nine dependency waves. + +## Slices + +- [x] Step 0 owner-ratified inventory and dependency DAG repaired after PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 +- [x] Composed milestone plan independently approved at plan head `331f7c664` +- [ ] All leaf PRs independently evaluated and merged to `main` +- [ ] Coherent canary checkpoint(s) published and production-E2E proven +- [ ] Stable 0.0.7 publication and exact artifact-pinned production E2E proven + +## Validation + +- `deno task harness:milestone:render -- .llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration` — PASS +- `deno task harness:milestone:validate -- .llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration` — PASS (`ok: true`) +- `deno task harness:milestone:test` — PASS (15 tests) + +## Harness + +- Run dir: `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/` +- Phase: implementation dispatch + +## Drift / Debt + +- #1453 moved to Backlog / Triage because its cited surface has never existed in this repository. +- #1306 closed-fixed after Aspire 13.4.6 and the generated NetScript agent skill proved the + requested native JSON resource inventory path. +- #1606 closed after live JSR package metadata and landing-page verification. +- #1564 closed after a seven-construct audit proved #1403 already owned the only affected range. +- #1384/#1385 remain in 0.0.8; no partial credential-only workaround is accepted for #1384. + +## Definition of Done + +- [ ] Every frozen 0.0.7 issue is closed with evidence or explicitly moved with owner-ratified reason. +- [ ] Every merged leaf has current-head IMPL-EVAL PASS and required CI/gate receipts. +- [ ] Canary and stable publication evidence is pinned to exact content and artifact identities. +- [ ] WSL, Aspire, Docker, worktrees, and harness scratch are clean at handoff. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/receipts/README.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/receipts/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..239bfd2fbe --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/receipts/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +# Gate receipts + +Durable structured gate receipts for the milestone cluster are stored here. No gate has run yet. + diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/research.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/research.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8ee011d40f --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/research.md @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +# Research — release 0.0.7 + +## Baseline snapshot + +- `main`: `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed`. +- GitHub milestone `0.0.7` is milestone `#27`. The frozen post-audit execution set is 60 active + issues: docs 1, internals 16, fixes 26, features 17. The 64 inspected targets also contain one + moved issue (#1453) and three close-fixed issues (#1306, #1564, #1606). +- #1564 was provisionally admitted, then the composed plan review forced a seven-construct re-audit. + All live changed-file consumers use three-dot merge-base semantics, the affected code-quality + construct was already fixed by #1403, and remaining base-`deno.json` reads are conservative + applicability comparisons. #1564 is therefore closed-fixed, not a release barrier. +- The intake sweep includes the target milestone, unmilestoned issues, `Backlog / Triage`, and all + later open milestones. External scope is excluded by default unless it satisfies one admission + predicate and is owner-ratified before freeze. +- GitHub authentication passed through `deno task agentic:gh-token check`. +- No prior `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/` run existed on the baseline. + +## Step 0 status + +Issue bodies, acceptance gates, dependency references, and existing-main evidence are being +classified. No implementation or evaluator session may dispatch until the frozen intake, +inventory, dependency DAG, and cluster state render and validate successfully. + +The repaired structural Step 0 artifacts cover 60 active issues across `docs` (1), `internals` +(16), `fixes` (26), and `features` (17), grouped into 43 leaves and nine topological waves. #1360 +is assigned to features with its grouped scaffold leaf. The independent synthesis is retained as +historical input; PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 requested changes and one bounded re-review remains. + +The inventory is baseline-bounded. Issues #1108, #1201, #1260, and #1550 were already closed before +the baseline and are intentionally not active targets. Residual Aspire documentation from #1306 is +tracked outside this release by #1642. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis-brief.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis-brief.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3c9b060ac8 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis-brief.md @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +use harness + +# SKILL + +Read and follow these repository instructions before acting: + +- `.agents/skills/agent-milestone-orchestrator/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-tools/SKILL.md` +- `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` +- `.llm/harness/workflow/milestone-run.md` +- `.llm/harness/workflow/lane-policy.md` + +# Role + +You are a high-value Step 0 synthesis workflow for the 0.0.7 milestone coordinator. Use Claude +workflows/Ultracode only where it materially improves cross-issue classification. You are not an +implementer or evaluator, and you must not self-certify the eventual milestone plan. + +# Immutable context + +- Repository: `rickylabs/netscript` +- Worktree: `/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix` +- Branch: `chore/release-0.0.7-orchestration` +- Baseline main SHA: `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed` +- Target: GitHub milestone `0.0.7`, numeric id `27`, 61 open issues at capture. +- Coordinator PR: `#1641` (evidence-only draft; do not edit it). + +# Objective + +Independently audit the live 0.0.7 issue bodies and baseline repository to produce a compact, +evidence-linked recommendation for: + +1. each target issue's disposition (`active`, `move`, `close-fixed`, `close-duplicate`, or + `close-superseded`); +2. exactly one topic lane (`docs`, `internals`, `fixes`, `features`) for every active issue; +3. dependency edges using only `requires`, `rfc-prerequisite`, or `cross-epic-order`; +4. coherent implementation leaf groupings and topological waves; +5. any unmilestoned, Backlog, or later-milestone issue that is truly `release-critical`, + `dependency-required`, or `high-value-coherent` enough to propose for owner admission; +6. false-positive/stale issues that appear already fixed on the baseline, with a concrete file, + test, merged PR, or commit as proof. + +Treat issue labels and prose as hypotheses. Check acceptance boxes, related-issue references, +existing code/tests, and merged history. Prefer exclusion over scope creep for external issues. Do +not reduce scope merely because it is large: recommend moving a target issue only for a specific +coherence/dependency/release-boundary reason. + +# Authority and prohibitions + +- Read-only for product code, configuration, GitHub issues/PRs/labels/milestones, git branches, + worktrees, Docker, Aspire, and processes. +- Do not launch Codex, OpenHands, another Claude implementation session, tests, containers, or + Aspire. +- Do not commit, push, open/update PRs, or mutate GitHub. +- The only permitted writes are the two output artifacts below. Do not touch other run files. +- Do not claim owner ratification; clearly mark proposed moves/admissions that require it. + +# Output + +Write: + +- `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.md` — concise human decision record with + evidence and explicit uncertainties. +- `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.json` — machine-readable object with + arrays `targetIssues`, `externalCandidates`, `edges`, `waves`, and `leafGroups`. Every target + issue number must occur exactly once. Every non-active target disposition needs `reason` and a + non-empty `evidence` array. Every edge needs `from`, `to`, `kind`, and `evidence`. + +Finish by printing a one-paragraph summary including counts by disposition/lane and the exact two +paths written. Missing evidence must be surfaced as uncertainty, never fabricated. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.json b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..15bc4803a8 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.json @@ -0,0 +1,3256 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "artifact": "step0-synthesis", + "repo": "rickylabs/netscript", + "milestone": "0.0.7", + "milestoneId": 27, + "baselineMainSha": "01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed", + "worktreeHeadSha": "477511709b90bf7b5be92f3b0467bdf2a2a6aa6f", + "capturedAt": "2026-08-13T00:00:00.000Z", + "status": "recommendation-only", + "authority": { + "ownerRatified": false, + "githubMutationsPerformed": false, + "note": "Advisory synthesis. No issue, label, milestone, PR or branch was mutated. Every move and every admission below requires owner ratification and an actual GitHub milestone move before scope freeze." + }, + "counts": { + "targetIssues": 62, + "byDisposition": { + "active": 61, + "move": 1 + }, + "byLane": { + "fixes": 25, + "features": 17, + "internals": 17, + "docs": 2 + }, + "leafGroups": 46, + "waves": 10, + "edges": 24, + "externalProposedForAdmission": 4, + "externalExaminedAndExcluded": 31 + }, + "targetIssues": [ + { + "number": 1093, + "title": "[sdk-client S8] fix(plugin-core): let third-party plugin factories participate in discovery", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Repairs defective packages/plugin behaviour (third-party plugins silently undiscovered) and moves declarations into plugins/**; the doctrine guard test is a subordinate gate, not an internals-lane deliverable.", + "leafGroup": "plugin-discovery-contribution-references", + "wave": 6, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "The filed acceptance (move defineSaga/defineWebhook axes to plugins/sagas + plugins/triggers, third-party fixture test, config path-constant decision, doctrine guard) is one coherent PR — but RFC:1156-1160 adds a second, later deliverable (collect sdkClients references, reject duplicate ids, expose to generators) that cannot land until #1349 exists. Those two halves cannot truthfully ship in one PR at 0.0.7 sequencing.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/plugin/src/sdk/discovery/ast-extractor.ts:4-8 — CONTRIBUTION_BUILDERS still hardcodes { defineJob: jobs }, { defineSaga: sagas }, { defineWebhook: triggers } in the core", + "packages/plugin/src/config/domain/plugin-contributions.ts:12-41 — no seam through which a plugin declares its own factory axis; :14-16 doctorChecks is a closed 'auth-backend' literal union", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1156-1160 — '#1093 must collect these references without official-plugin switches, reject duplicate ids or mismatched imported descriptors, and expose them to generators' (new obligation added by the merged RFC)", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1281 Stage 7 assigns generic discovery to #1093", + "Timeline: no merged PR references #1093; the nearest merged neighbour PR #1316 (fix(plugins): declare linking through shared core seam) closed a different issue (#1189) and left ast-extractor.ts:4-8 intact" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The RFC-added sdkClients-collection obligation is not written into the issue body (body predates the RFC, last substantive text from 2026-08-03), so an implementer reading only the issue would ship half of Stage 7." + }, + { + "number": 1112, + "title": "docs(database): make the MySQL Prisma adapter example honest and executable", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Labelled type:docs, but acceptance rows 4-5 (audit accepted-but-unused options, add focused adapter tests) require packages/prisma-adapter-mysql source and test changes — this is NOT a docs-lane slice. The prose halves also live in packages/** files (README.md, src/mod.ts JSDoc), not docs/site.", + "leafGroup": "prisma-mysql-honest-example", + "wave": 3, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": "One PR can carry both if #1293's surface change lands in the same slice; separately, #1112 alone cannot truthfully tick its example row.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/README.md:7,13,20 still claims 'Deno's native MySQL client' / 'Deno-native driver' — this file is the JSR landing page (jsr-package-settings.json defaults readmeSource: 'readme')", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/mod.ts:6-8 module JSDoc repeats the same false 'Deno's native mysql driver' claim above the @example", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/adapter.ts:26 imports type { Pool, PoolConnection, PoolOptions } from 'mysql2/promise' — the real dependency", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/types.ts:39 declares onConnectionError; grep across the package finds it referenced only in examples/basic-usage.ts:39 and never in src/adapter.ts — a live accepted-but-unused option (acceptance row 4)", + "docs/site/reference/prisma-adapter-mysql/index.md:8,14,16-17 IS already honest about mysql2, pooling ownership and timeout — that half was repaired by PR #1292, so only the package-local prose plus source rows remain" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Did not run deno check/tests, so 'every advertised option has observable behavior' is verified only for onConnectionError; other PrismaMySqlOptions fields unaudited." + }, + { + "number": 1243, + "title": "auth: session list --stream-url default pins localhost:4437 which no longer exists post-#1211", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/public/features/plugins/auth/auth-plugin-command.ts:87 still sets `default: 'http://localhost:4437/auth/sessions'` on --stream-url", + "plugins/streams/scaffold.plugin.json:54-55 still carries servicePort 4437 / backgroundPort 4437 — the dead manifest values the issue asks to sweep", + "packages/cli/src/maintainer/features/sync/plugin/copy-official-plugin-test-support.ts:108-109 also hardcodes 4437 for both ports", + "#1211 (randomize default listener ports) is MERGED in 0.0.5, so the premise that 4437 is no longer bound by new scaffolds holds", + "The 4437 squatting failure class is documented in the repo's own aspire skill text (packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/skills.generated.ts), which describes a foreign process answering on 4437 healthily" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether an AppHost/appsettings discovery seam (as used by the #1206 aspire-cli adapter) is reachable from this command was not traced; the minimum acceptable fix (fail with a legacy-pin message) is unambiguous, the full resolution path is not." + }, + { + "number": 1262, + "title": "scaffold: db seed is a placebo — SELECT 1 plus a success banner, no rows seeded", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Generated database-workspace script emitted by packages/cli; runtime behaviour of scaffolded output.", + "leafGroup": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/database/seed.ts.template:13-14 is verbatim `await client.$queryRaw\\`SELECT 1\\`;` followed by `console.log('✅ Database seed completed.')` — unchanged on baseline", + "It is the only seed asset in the tree (`find packages/cli/src/kernel/assets -iname '*seed*'` returns exactly this one file), so every engine gets the placebo", + "No test references the seed script's row-writing behaviour (no seed assertions found under packages/cli/e2e)", + "Timeline shows only #1250/#1256 (the Zod-4 coercion fix) cross-referencing it — nothing that touched the seed" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Seeding 'at least one representative row per generated model' requires reading the generated Prisma schema (packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/database/schema.prisma.template) or the model metadata at scaffold time — I did not verify that a model list is already available to the template renderer, so the size could be larger than 'small'." + }, + { + "number": 1263, + "title": "service: generated by-id handler returns 500 {defined:false} for a missing row instead of a defined 404", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Generated service router + contract emitted by packages/cli; a runtime status-code defect in scaffolded output.", + "leafGroup": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/routers/v1.ts.template:59 still throws a bare `new Error(\\`{{modelName}} ${input.id} not found\\`)` in the getById handler — not a defined oRPC error", + "Same defect in the memory variant: packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/service/routers/v1.memory.ts.template:56", + "Repo-wide grep for `.errors(`, `NOT_FOUND`, or `ORPCError` across packages/cli/src/kernel/assets (excluding generated) returns ZERO hits — no scaffolded contract defines a 404, so the OpenAPI projection cannot document one", + "update/delete handlers rely on Prisma's own throw (v1.ts.template update/delete use where:{id} with no not-found branch), so they share the class", + "Timeline shows only #1250/#1256 and later related issues; no merged PR addressed the defined-error gap" + ], + "externalDependencies": [ + { + "issue": 1362, + "milestone": "0.0.8", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "note": "#1362 redesigns the generated service layering that #1263 patches. Not a blocker; order 0.0.7 then 0.0.8." + } + ], + "uncertainty": "Acceptance box 2 ('the OpenAPI projection documents the 404') needs the contract template to carry .errors({ NOT_FOUND }); I confirmed no such construct exists in the assets but did not verify that the scaffolded oRPC/OpenAPI projection renders defined errors automatically once declared." + }, + { + "number": 1293, + "title": "prisma-adapter-mysql: adapter class is unexported and has no connection-error hook", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Widens the published surface of @netscript/prisma-adapter-mysql (new export + new option contract) — surface-diff gate applies.", + "leafGroup": "prisma-mysql-adapter-surface", + "wave": 2, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/adapter.ts:319 declares `class PrismaMySqlAdapter extends MySqlQueryable` with no `export` keyword; src/mod.ts exports only PrismaMySqlAdapterFactory/PrismaMySql (adapter.ts:742 aliases them) — the class is still unexported", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/types.ts:39 `onConnectionError?: (err: Error) => void` exists in the options type but no src/ file reads it — the hook is declared, not implemented or tested", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/src/adapter.ts:544,546 already carry explicit annotations (`readonly provider: 'mysql' = 'mysql'`, `readonly adapterName: string`), so the slow-types row is largely satisfied on baseline", + "packages/prisma-adapter-mysql/deno.json exports only '.' -> './mod.ts', so any new export must go through src/mod.ts" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Did not run `deno doc --lint` or a surface diff; the slow-types row may already be green, which would shrink this issue to export + hook." + }, + { + "number": 1296, + "title": "fix(docs/exports): repair contracts and Fresh UI reference drift, then wire the regeneration gate", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": "Deliverable is the drift-gate machinery (.llm/tools/docs/check-exports-drift.ts: machine-readable omissions, symbol checking, runbook, verification-path wiring) plus JSDoc edits inside packages/contracts — not a pure docs-lane slice.", + "leafGroup": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "wave": 3, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Contracts JSDoc/subpath repair, fresh-ui reference regeneration, machine-readable omissions in the tool, and the maintainer runbook + CI wiring are three distinct surfaces; one PR truthfully ticking all five rows is unlikely.", + "evidence": [ + "The cited file is a false lead: packages/contracts/src/application/contract-primitives.ts:72,112,144 import baseContract/BaseContractRoute/BaseContractOutputRoute from '@netscript/contracts', and all three ARE root exports (packages/contracts/src/public/mod.ts:2-6) — those examples are correct", + "Real instances of the same defect: packages/contracts/src/application/paginated-query.ts:6 imports paginatedQuery, schemas/pagination.ts:6 imports PaginationInputSchema/createPaginatedOutput, schemas/filters.ts:6 imports FilterConditionSchema/buildPrismaWhere, and src/application/transform-helpers.ts:6 imports createTransformer — all from the root, while none of those symbols appear in src/public/mod.ts (they live on ./query and ./transform)", + ".llm/tools/docs/check-exports-drift.ts:13-21 lists fresh-ui with `checkSymbols: false` and `excludedSymbols: []` — symbol-level drift for docs/site/reference/fresh-ui/index.md is not checked and there is no machine-readable intentional-omission mechanism in use", + "Wiring is partly done: .llm/tools/docs/check-accuracy-and-discoverability.ts:293 spawns check-exports-drift.ts, and deno.json:85,90 expose it via docs:accuracy/docs:maintenance — but no .github/workflows job runs those tasks (only pages.yml:145 runs docs:snippets)", + "#1108 (the parent of the fresh-ui rows) was closed NOT_PLANNED on 2026-08-11, so those rows genuinely have no other owner" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Did not run check-exports-drift.ts, so whether the contracts reference inventory currently advertises non-exports (row 2) is unverified; the issue's own claim about contract-primitives.ts does not hold on baseline." + }, + { + "number": 1306, + "title": "fix(aspire): 'the dashboard is the authority' is unusable for an agent — aspire start detaches in a non-TTY and prints no login token", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "The deliverable is a new machine-readable resource-inventory capability (CLI verb and/or MCP tool), i.e. new public surface — not a repair of existing emission. Label is type:feature and matches.", + "leafGroup": "aspire-agent-resource-inventory", + "wave": 6, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "The four checkboxes are alternative remedies ('any one of these'), spanning three different surfaces (a CLI/JSON inventory verb, aspire start non-TTY contract, dashboard token emission, MCP tool). They cannot all be ticked by one PR and should not all be attempted; the scope decision must be made before assignment.", + "evidence": [ + "No inventory verb exists: packages/cli/src/public/features/ contains agent, config, contracts, db, deploy, generate, init, marketplace, plugins, root, services, ui — no aspire/status/resources group", + "The issue's 'check get_app_status first' question resolves NEGATIVE: packages/mcp/src/domain/tool-contracts.ts:175-179 declares its output as { status, counts, domains } — a health rollup, with no resolved endpoints, ports, or URLs", + "packages/mcp/src/application/tool-registry.ts:36 describes get_app_status only as 'Summarize NetScript app health', confirming it is not a resource inventory", + "No TTY/token handling anywhere near an aspire path: grep for isTerminal in packages/cli/src hits only init-command.ts:116, agent-mcp-command.ts:44, agent-group.ts:33, db-operation-command.ts:84", + "Timeline: only #1290 and the merged docs PR #1309 cross-reference it — the docs pass did not close the capability gap" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether the token/detach behaviour is fixable in NetScript at all is unverified — `aspire start` is upstream Aspire CLI (13.4.6), so checkboxes 2 and 3 may be upstream-only and reduce to documenting the detached contract. I could not verify runtime behaviour without launching Aspire, which is out of scope for this audit." + }, + { + "number": 1348, + "title": "Epic: Typed SDK client contributions — credentials, transport policy, metadata, and cache-safe extensions", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Tracking/ratification issue for RFC 0001; deliverable is board reconciliation + owner dispositions, not code. Must NOT carry a closing keyword on any implementation PR (its own acceptance says so).", + "leafGroup": "rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Umbrella: acceptance spans RFC publication (done), owner Q&A/FCP, cross-links on two external epics, and 'closes only when all implementation children merged'. No single PR can tick these; it is a tracking issue by design.", + "evidence": [ + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1 exists on baseline — RFC text published, so acceptance box 1 is satisfied", + "PR #1390 'RFC: Typed SDK client contributions' MERGED 2026-08-11T20:15:51Z; its body states 'RFC tracking issue: #1348 (reference only; this draft does not close it)'", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1555-1599 — 11 unresolved questions still open (incl. Q6 metadata ownership), so ratification acceptance is incomplete", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1273 Stage 0 row assigns #1348 'align #1349–#1353 bodies before implementation' — not yet done (bodies still contradict the RFC)", + "gh issue list --label epic:sdk-client-contrib: all 8 children (#1349-#1353,#1466,#1467,#1093) still OPEN" + ], + "externalDependencies": [ + { + "issue": 928, + "milestone": "0.0.9", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "note": "Coordination only. rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1290 states #928 and #934 \"are not prerequisites for the header seam\". Satisfiable by an issue comment recording divergences." + }, + { + "issue": 934, + "milestone": "0.0.9", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "note": "Same: #934 consumes the ratified metadata vocabulary later. #1348 body records both as milestone 0.0.7 - that board line is stale drift." + } + ], + "uncertainty": "Whether the owner has formally accepted/amended the envelope and answered Q1/Q2 is not visible in the repo — PR #1390 merged the text but the RFC still lists 11 open questions. Owner disposition status unverified." + }, + { + "number": 1349, + "title": "[sdk-client S3] feat(sdk): expose the typed oRPC client-contribution seam", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Widens the public surface of @netscript/sdk (context type parameter, contribution chain) and packages/service option records.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-client-contribution-seam", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Acceptance as filed cannot all be ticked and partly contradicts the ratified RFC: (a) it demands exporting createHttpClientLink/ClientLinkPort/ClientLinkCallOptions, but RFC:491-497 requires the adapter ports live under src/internal/client-contributions/ with NO public export and RFC:1289 keeps #451 'the sole future owner of custom links'; (b) it demands composing interceptors/adapterInterceptors/link plugins/fetch, but RFC:1276 says 'No upstream callback arrays' and RFC:434 limits the patch to `headers`; (c) it demands `port`/`timeout` be REMOVED, but RFC:1224 keeps them accepted-and-deprecated and RFC:1277 reassigns that to #1351; (d) the packages/service items (withRPC plugins forwarding, ServiceHandlerPlugin typing, deduplication) are a separate package and are absent from Stage 2's exit condition.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts:203-222 — CreateServiceClientOptions is still the closed nine-field record; no headers/fetch/interceptors/plugins/link/context parameter", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts:129-155 — ServiceClientContext is still a concrete interface; ServiceClientMethod at :167 carries no context or error generic", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:82,83-101,102-126 — method, headers and plugins are still inline literals inside the link", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/mod.ts:7 still advertises 'the transport seam' while ClientLinkPort/ClientLinkCallOptions (packages/sdk/src/ports/client-link-factory.ts:8-26, doc'd 'Internal … seam') are absent from its export list", + "packages/service/src/builder/service-rpc.ts:57 still calls createRPCHandler(router, { serviceName, debug }) while packages/service/src/primitives/handlers.ts:44 declares `plugins`; packages/service/src/types.ts:221 still `init?(options: unknown, router: unknown)`" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether the orchestrator wants the issue body rewritten to the ratified RFC scope before implementation (Stage 0's job on #1348) is undecided; implementing the body as written would violate the merged RFC." + }, + { + "number": 1350, + "title": "[sdk-client S1] fix(sdk): preserve contract errors through safe() and isDefinedError", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "type:fix + area:docs labels, but the deliverable is packages/sdk + packages/contracts source; docs snippets are only the proof, so this is NOT the docs lane.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-typed-error-channel", + "wave": 2, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/errors.ts:75-77 — `isDefinedError(error: T): error is Extract` still lacks the upstream error generic", + "packages/sdk/src/client/errors.ts:86-92 — `safe(promise: PromiseLike)`, no TError; SafeResult at :49", + "packages/contracts/src/application/contract-primitives.ts:81 — `export const baseContract: ReturnType = oc.errors(commonErrorMap);` still erases the six literal codes", + "packages/sdk/tests/readme-doctest_test.ts:36-37 — still `declare function safe(...)` / `declare function isDefinedError(...)` instead of importing the real exports", + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md:198 and docs/site/services-sdk/how-to/discover-services.md:147,224 still ship the `isDefinedError(error) -> error.code` pattern" + ], + "externalDependencies": [ + { + "issue": 1278, + "milestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "note": "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1274 keeps #1350 a type-soundness #1278 child. Not a blocker; #1278 is prose-only." + } + ], + "uncertainty": "I did not re-run the cited `deno check` probe (read-only mandate, no builds). Type-level failure is inferred from the signatures, not re-executed." + }, + { + "number": 1351, + "title": "[sdk-client S4] refactor(sdk): centralize HTTP method and GET-cache policy", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "packages/sdk source consolidation plus an oRPC dependency-family bump; adds no new public API (the policy function is package-internal), so it is neither docs nor internals nor a surface-widening feature.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-transport-policy-consolidation", + "wave": 5, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Bundles two independently gated things: a behaviour-preserving policy-function refactor, and an oRPC whole-family version move (deno.json:215-221 pins ^1.14.6; the issue asks for 1.14.15 while RFC:1277 says the target is a separately decided stable v1.15.0 whole-family lock). The RFC explicitly calls the version move a separate decision, and the scaffold.runtime E2E gate attaches only to the refactor half.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:82 — `method: inferRPCMethodFromContractRouter(contract)` still applied inline; no owned policy function exists (grep inferRPCMethodFromContractRouter/StrictGetMethodPlugin/fallbackMethod returns only this file)", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:109 — `filter: ({ request }) => request.method === 'GET'` still re-derives the method decision from the wire", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:110-125 — the 'force-cache' group condition is still an independent literal keyed off context?.cache", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:103-108 — ClientRetryPlugin default still frozen at retry: 0", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1277 Stage 3 assigns this issue the v1-family version decision, one fetch/retry/dedupe/trace path, header-safe dedupe, and deprecating the no-op options" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Target oRPC version is contradictory: issue acceptance says 1.14.15, ratified RFC:1277 says decide on stable v1.15.0. I did not run deps:latest (read-only), so the current registry stable is unverified." + }, + { + "number": 1352, + "title": "[sdk-client S5] feat(sdk/auth): prove typed credential contributions end to end", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "New public surface (credential contribution factory + authClient) in an auth plugin package plus a CLI transport swap; not docs despite the docs proof.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-auth-contribution-dogfood", + "wave": 5, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "One PR must ship a new plugin-side public export, swap the first-party CLI off raw fetch, add server-integration negative gates against a live authenticator, and rewrite three docs pages — SDK gates and CLI gates are separate verdicts, and RFC:1278 adds 'scaffold choice' on top of the filed acceptance.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/service/src/auth/static-credential-authenticator.ts reads Authorization/x-api-key while grep 'Authorization' packages/sdk/src returns no match — the client still cannot send a credential", + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:83-101 — client header authorship is still only Content-Type + optional traceparent/tracestate", + "grep -rn 'authClient' packages plugins → no such symbol on baseline (only oauthClient in packages/auth-kv-oauth/src/flow.ts:169)", + "packages/plugin/src/config/domain/plugin-contributions.ts:12-41 — still no client/sdkClients contribution group; :14-16 `doctorChecks?: readonly 'auth-backend'[]` is the closed-literal precedent the issue warns against", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1278 Stage 4 keeps this issue as the auth dogfood (auth-core bearer factory, access metadata, redaction, cache partition/direct-only, manifest reference, docs, scaffold choice)" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Module placement diverges: issue says `@netscript/plugin-auth/sdk`, RFC:1168 example imports `@netscript/plugin-auth-core/sdk`. Also the issue's cookie-topology carve-out is now moot (RFC bans cookie), unrecorded on the issue." + }, + { + "number": 1353, + "title": "[sdk-client S6] feat(sdk): express trace propagation as a general contribution", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Filed as a public-surface addition (traceContextContribution export). NOTE: under the merged RFC this becomes a transport-ownership guard slice with no new export — see uncertainty; if rescoped it is closer to a fixes-lane hardening slice.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-trace-ownership-proof", + "wave": 5, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/client/http-client-link.ts:87-98 — trace-header authorship is still hard-coded in the link behind the propagateTraceContext boolean", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/service-client.ts:149-155 — ServiceClientContext.traceHeaders is still the per-call override; grep traceContextContribution → no such symbol on baseline", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1476-1481 §'Rejected: trace propagation as the non-auth contribution' — the merged RFC REJECTS this issue's headline deliverable", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1279 Stage 5 — 'Re-scope from “trace contribution” to prove the transport retains the only final trace injection and rejects contributor ownership of trace headers'", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:870-871,886-887 — traceparent/tracestate are reserved SDK-owned headers unavailable to contributions" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "HARD CONFLICT: the issue body's acceptance ('traceContextContribution() ships as an SdkClientContribution'; 'createHttpClientLink contains no trace-header authorship') is the exact alternative the merged RFC rejects (rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1476-1481) and reverses (Stage 5, :1279). The issue is still real work but its acceptance list must be rewritten before any implementer reads it; implementing as written would violate ratified RFC 0001. Whether the owner has recorded that rescope on the issue is unverified (issue updated before the RFC merge)." + }, + { + "number": 1354, + "title": "feat(cli): no verb generates a resource route slice — the typed contract, cache-first loader and withResource page must be hand-copied from init", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "New public CLI verb + widened generator surface in packages/cli; not a repair of an existing command (that is #1357).", + "leafGroup": "ui-resource-slice-generator", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Core slice + --form + --partial + --stream + four negative golden tests + a scaffold.runtime E2E extension cannot all be truthfully ticked in one PR; the three optional flags are independently testable by the issue's own wording.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts:15-45 is still the entire page generator: three files, no withResource, no loader, no contract sidecar", + "packages/cli/src/public/features/generate/generate-group.ts:19-27 registers only `aspire`, `runtime-schemas`, `plugins` — no slice/route generator exists", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts:60-62 writeGeneratedFiles hard-refuses on any existing file; no --force/--dry-run reaches it from add-ui-command.ts:61-67", + "Reference slice still exists only as init assets: packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/service-query.ts.template and (_islands)/ServiceShowcaseLab.tsx.template", + "Timeline shows no merged PR touching this issue; only open peers #1355/#1357/#1360 cross-reference it" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The RFC-A (#1348, 0.0.7 epic) contribution-inclusion clause is explicitly NOT a blocker per the issue body, so I recorded no rfc-prerequisite edge — but if the orchestrator wants that clause in scope it becomes one. I did not verify the research/ audit files cited (research/repo-audit/*.md are not present in this worktree)." + }, + { + "number": 1355, + "title": "feat(cli): app-side client/query wiring is a one-shot template with hardcoded names, colliding 'service' cache keys and a no-op invalidation", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Deliverable is a new `generate`-family verb regenerating apps//lib/.ts; it also fixes two runtime-correctness defects inside the emitted code, but the acceptance is generator-shaped.", + "leafGroup": "app-service-client-wiring", + "wave": 2, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "The issue itself says 'the owner may split them out as a separate p0 fix' for the 'service' key collision and the dead invalidation; those are shippable independently of the new generator verb, and the two-service E2E fixture is a third distinct deliverable.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/service-query.ts.template:22-27 still literally does `createQueryFactories({ service: { … } }).service` — resource key is the literal 'service' for every service", + "Same template :11-14 builds bridgeInvalidation({{serviceName|camelCase}}RouterName, 'list') → keys ['users','list'], while packages/sdk/src/query/query-factory.ts:218 passes the OBJECT KEY ('service') as resource → the invalidation is a no-op", + "packages/sdk/src/query-client/key-bridge.ts:32-37 confirms bridgeInvalidation returns { queryKey: [resource, action] } with no factory linkage", + "Dead call sites confirmed: assets/app/routes/examples/(_islands)/ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template:93 (onSettled) and :135 ('Invalidate list cache' button)", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/service/client-scaffolder.ts:38-49 is still a single renderTemplateAssetSync — one template, one shot, no per-service naming" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Note: the template moved from the path the issue cites (packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/lib/example-service.ts.template no longer exists) to assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/service-query.ts.template — the defect is identical, but every line cite in the issue body is stale. RFC #1348 gates only the optional contribution clause per the body, so no edge recorded." + }, + { + "number": 1357, + "title": "fix(cli): ui:add page --island emits a useSignal counter and an empty queryLoaders object instead of the advertised data-screen triad", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Repairs defective generator output in packages/cli — the emitted files, not new surface.", + "leafGroup": "ui-add-page-island-repair", + "wave": 3, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Acceptance mixes an emission rewrite, a cross-command island-placement convention decision (routes//(_islands)/ vs top-level islands/), a --help-vs-emission assertion, and an E2E gate change; the convention decision is a separate call from the emission fix.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts:37 still emits `export const queryLoaders = {} as const;` and :35 emits signalIslandTemplate (useSignal counter, :66-68)", + "web-scaffold.ts:51-54 — `ui:add island --query` still emits `
Name
`: no useQuery, no key, no factory", + "web-scaffold.ts:20+:30 — route id is still a hand-derived dotted string with an inline createRouteReference, not router.ts/appRoutes", + "Contradicted description still live at packages/cli/src/public/features/ui/add/add-ui-command.ts:26-28 ('Scaffold the Fresh page + island + query-loader triad for a data screen')", + "add-ui-command.ts:61-67 never forwards `--force` to scaffoldUiPage/scaffoldUiIsland, and there is no --dry-run flag at all" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "One acceptance box is ALREADY satisfied on baseline: packages/cli/src/public/features/ui/add/add-ui-input.ts:1-11 declares projectRoot, app, registryRoot, theme, force, route, island, query — the 'UiAddCommandInput declares route/island/query/app' box needs no work. The rest of the issue is unaffected." + }, + { + "number": 1358, + "title": "fix(scaffold): the generated /design/components gallery lists 50 of 66 registry items — the whole AI collection is invisible and no gate compares them", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Repairs generated scaffold output (CLI design assets) plus a drift gate; the gate is a means, the defective emission is the deliverable.", + "leafGroup": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "wave": 2, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/(design)/design/(_shared)/registry.ts.template:28 still declares `total: 50` and :1-4 self-describes as a hand-copied snapshot", + "Live manifest item count is 66: `grep -c '^ kind: ' packages/fresh-ui/registry.manifest.ts` → 66", + "AI/chart items absent from the snapshot but present in the manifest: grep for model-selector|prompt-input|donut|dropzone|citation-chip|mcp-ui-widget returns 0 hits in the template, and hits at packages/fresh-ui/registry.manifest.ts:451,495,561,583", + "The only drift test remains packages/fresh-ui/tests/registry-doc-drift.test.ts:4-19, which compares registry.ts JSDoc COLLECTION NAMES only and never reads the CLI snapshot", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/registry.ts imports freshUiRegistryManifest — the CLI resolves against the live manifest, so ui:add can install items the gallery denies" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "I counted manifest items by grepping top-level `kind:` (66) rather than evaluating the module, since executing deno was out of scope; the 8-collection claim is unverified beyond the single `collections:` array at registry.manifest.ts:1356." + }, + { + "number": 1360, + "title": "fix(scaffold): the canonical island never passes initialDataUpdatedAt, so the loader's cachedAt is computed, displayed and discarded", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Scaffold asset templates only; issue explicitly excludes any packages/fresh source change.", + "leafGroup": "app-service-client-wiring", + "wave": 2, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "Repo-wide grep for `initialDataUpdatedAt` under packages/cli/src returns ZERO hits; all hits are in packages/fresh (query-types.ts:136, hooks.ts:128,138-140, and two tests)", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/examples/(_islands)/ServiceShowcaseLab.tsx.template:54-57 passes queryKey + initialData: props.initialList with no initialDataUpdatedAt; :148 uses props.cachedAt only as a display stat", + "Memory variant identical: ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template:60 initialData, :119 cachedAt as a label only", + "The seam is live and tested in the framework — packages/fresh/src/application/query/hooks.ts:138-140 maps the option to `{ updatedAt }` and initial-data.test.tsx:15 exercises it — so only the scaffold is unwired", + "Timeline shows no merged PR; only open peers #1354/#1357 cross-reference it" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "File overlap risk with #1355: that issue's acceptance also edits ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template (the invalidation call sites at :93 and :135). If both land in the same wave, sequence them or merge the two template edits into one PR to avoid a conflict. The 'migration note' acceptance box is docs prose and may need a docs-lane co-landing." + }, + { + "number": 1378, + "title": "chore(quality): `quality:scan` cannot see an `any` in an exported type, an unbudgeted allowance, or a docs snippet", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": "Labelled area:docs/area:packages, but the deliverable is the .llm/tools/quality scanner plus deno.json gate wiring; the docs-corpus half (typed triggers reference) already landed in PR #1596, so no packages/** or docs prose work remains.", + "leafGroup": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Three independent mechanisms remain (export-reachability severity via `deno doc --json`, live open+milestoned issue-state verification of allowance links, and the budget ratchet), and boxes 3/5/7 are already ticked by PR #1596 while box 6 was partly delivered as the same-diff predicate. One PR can plausibly carry export-awareness OR issue-state verification, not both plus the #1545 registration, without overrunning.", + "evidence": [ + "Still regex-only, export-blind: `.llm/tools/quality/scan-code-quality.ts:69` `if (!commentOnly && /(?:<|:\\s*)any.../.test(line)) return 'explicit-any'` — no notion of `export`.", + "Allowances still unlinked: `scan-code-quality.ts:207` matches `/\\/\\/\\s*quality-allow:\\s*(.+)$/` and accepts any non-empty free text; no `#` requirement anywhere in the file.", + "Already landed (boxes 3,4,5,7): `scan-code-quality.ts:119` scans `docs/site/**` `.md` fences; `:124` keeps `-soundness_test.ts` in scope; `deno.json:50-51` wires `--root docs/site --max-allow 7` and `--max-allow 8`.", + "PR #1596 (merged 2026-08-12) body: \"Export reachability and live issue-state verification remain explicitly deferred to #1378 for 0.0.7\"; it referenced #1378 without closing it.", + "`docs/site/reference/triggers/index.md` (205 lines) contains no `any[]` at baseline — acceptance box 7 is discharged." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Not verified whether `deno doc --json` over each package `exports` map is fast enough to run inside the PR gate; no executed measurement (read-only audit, no task runs allowed)." + }, + { + "number": 1429, + "title": "fix(agentic): leak-check cannot see orphaned Aspire process descendants, so it reports clean through a real leak", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "leak-check-process-descendants", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "`.llm/tools/agentic/teardown/leak-check.ts` has zero matches for `ppid|PPID|pgrep|/proc|process` — it has no process-descendant observation at all.", + "Its resource model is containers + AppHosts only: `leak-check.ts:42`, `:68`, `:74`, `:106` all branch on `resource.kind === 'apphost'` or `registry.containers`.", + "Timeline cross-references for #1429 are only issues #1227 and #1169 (both closed), no merged PR touching leak-check.", + "`.llm/tools/agentic/teardown/` contains ownership.ts, ports.ts, probes.ts, run-resources.ts — no process enumerator module." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Could not reproduce the leak (running Aspire/e2e is prohibited here); the three-condition reclaim rule the issue prescribes is unimplemented, and I could not verify whether Deno can enumerate PPID/cwd portably on Windows without a new dependency." + }, + { + "number": 1448, + "title": "fix(ai/mcp): make pool startup failure-isolated and propagate cancellation", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Repairs defective runtime behaviour in packages/ai, though the 'immediate snapshot of ready clients plus per-server status' box also widens the published McpTransportPool surface.", + "leafGroup": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Nine acceptance boxes across three layers: per-server settlement + degraded state in pool.ts, cancellation through five connector operations, late-success client closure, registerMcpTools signature change, per-server retry, a new status-snapshot API, and documentation — the snapshot API and the cancellation plumbing are independently shippable.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/ai/src/mcp/application/pool.ts:154-173 — #collectTools iterates transports in a `for...of` with `await list(transport)`, so one never-settling or rejecting server blocks/aborts the whole pool; connect/reconnect/listTools (:107, :115, :122) all route through it", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/adapters/tanstack-connector.ts:80 and :89 — listTools/callTool only call options.signal?.throwIfAborted() before awaiting client.tools()/client.callTool(name, args); no signal is passed into the pending TanStack work", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/application/register-tools.ts:14-17 — registerMcpTools(registry, transport) accepts no caller signal, and :36 hardcodes `{ signal: undefined }` on every tool call", + "packages/ai/src/mcp/application/pool.ts:88 — the pool exposes only an aggregate `state`; there is no per-server status/degraded-lifecycle read", + "gh api issues/1448/timeline — the only cross-reference is rickylabs/eis-chat#159 (consumer adapter), not a netscript fix" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": null + }, + { + "number": 1451, + "title": "feat(plugin-workers): generated registry cannot consume project job policy metadata", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "New project-metadata seam consumed by workers-api and startCombinedProcess(); type:feat is correct.", + "leafGroup": "workers-job-policy-metadata", + "wave": 3, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Three acceptance bullets each land in a different layer: a config/manifest seam, generator plumbing for eight metadata fields including Deno permissions, and a scaffold/runtime integration test proving effective definitions — the integration test in particular pulls in the expensive scaffold.runtime surface.", + "evidence": [ + "plugins/workers/src/cli/runtime-registry-generator.ts:325-340 — createJobDefinition still hardcodes topic 'default', timeout 300000, maxRetries 3, retryDelay 1000, maxConcurrency 1, priority 50, persist true and a fixed tags expression", + "plugins/workers/src/cli/registry-compiler.ts:78 — the compiler path emits the same `timeout: 300000` literal", + "plugins/workers/tests/cli/registry-compiler-golden_test.ts:68 and plugins/workers/services/src/generated-jobs_test.ts:22 — golden tests pin the generic 300000ms timeout, so no project-metadata seam is exercised", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/executor/multi-runtime-task-executor.ts:66 — the executor default is likewise `options.defaults?.timeout ?? 300000`", + "gh api issues/1451/timeline — the only cross-reference is issue #1455 (open), no fix PR" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The issue does not name the seam (workers plugin config file vs. netscript.config vs. job-definition module), and no candidate exists on baseline." + }, + { + "number": 1452, + "title": "feat(plugin): publish reusable PluginServiceContext host factory", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Publishes new surface on @netscript/plugin and changes CLI scaffold output to consume it.", + "leafGroup": "plugin-service-context-factory", + "wave": 7, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Publishing the factory in @netscript/plugin, keeping DB/env override points, changing CLI scaffold emission, and a generated-consumer boot test across workers/auth/sagas are separable; the boot test alone is a scaffold-runtime-class gate.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/embedded.generated.ts:177 — the scaffold still embeds a full ~100-line LazyPluginKv class plus db/contracts/logger/env composition in the generated createPluginServiceContext", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/plugins/generate-plugin-service_test.ts:82 — the test asserts the generator emits `export function createPluginServiceContext(` into consumer code, pinning the duplicate-per-consumer shape", + "plugins/workers/services/src/main.ts:88-89, plugins/sagas/services/src/main.ts:139-140 and plugins/auth/services/src/main.ts:124-127 all load the host factory via NETSCRIPT_PLUGIN_SERVICE_BOOTSTRAP_MODULE, so no published factory exists to import", + "packages/plugin/src/sdk/ contains only discovery/walker/registry-emitter modules — no host-context factory", + "gh api issues/1452/timeline — no cross-references at all" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": null + }, + { + "number": 1453, + "title": "fix(agentic): migration LOC worktree snapshot crashes on unstaged deletions", + "disposition": "move", + "lane": null, + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": null, + "wave": null, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "`tools/migration-loc/` does not exist at baseline: `find . -iname '*migration-loc*'` returns nothing outside `.llm/tmp` hook logs and the 0.0.7 inventory JSONs.", + "`git log --all -- tools/migration-loc` is empty — the path has never existed in this repository's history.", + "`grep -rn readTrackedFile --include=*.ts .` returns no match; the cited `tools/migration-loc/git.ts:78` frame has no counterpart here.", + "The only `-S'migration-loc'` history hits (05e5fbac2, 9f1d0244a) are false positives on the string `migration-lock` in `rfcs/0000-database-architecture.md`.", + "No scaffold template emits it: `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/**` has no migration-loc generator." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The defect is probably real in whatever repo owns `tools/migration-loc` (the issue quotes a concrete Windows/Deno 2.9.5 stack trace), but nothing in this worktree can be changed to satisfy its acceptance. Move is on the release-boundary ground that no 0.0.7 slice here can tick a single box — not on size or priority.", + "reason": "The entire cited surface is absent from the repo and its full history, so the acceptance is unsatisfiable in a 0.0.7 slice against this codebase; needs re-scoping or relocation to the owning repo first.", + "moveTarget": "Backlog / Triage", + "requiresOwnerRatification": true + }, + { + "number": 1455, + "title": "workers: preserve job payload type through definition, registry, and enqueue", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Widens published types on @netscript/plugin-workers-core, @netscript/plugin-triggers-core and generated registries.", + "leafGroup": "workers-job-payload-typing", + "wave": 5, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Spans four packages (plugin-workers-core types, plugin-triggers-core enqueueJob, workers contract JobTriggerInput, CLI registry generator) plus a job-ID→payload map export and shared runtime validation; one PR cannot truthfully tick all five 'Expected' bullets.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/plugin-triggers-core/src/builders/define-webhook.ts:79-81 — `enqueueJob(job: JobDefinition, ...)` still infers the payload independently of the job definition", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/contracts/v1/workers.contract-types.ts:32-36 — JobTriggerInput still exposes `payload?: Record`", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/registry-generator-fixture.ts:37 — generated registries still emit `new Map>([`", + "Partially superseded upstream: packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-definition.ts:153-163 and builders/job-builder.ts:241 already return JobDefinition, so the builder-side erasure the issue describes is already gone", + "gh api issues/1455/timeline — only cross-reference is rickylabs/eis-chat#168 (consumer repo), no netscript fix PR" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The issue's stated baseline (build() returns JobDefinition with no payload) is stale — payload params already exist on the type. The remaining scope is the registry map, JobTriggerInput, and enqueueJob binding; the issue body should be re-scoped before implementation." + }, + { + "number": 1458, + "title": "feat(fresh/ai): expose awaited durable chat response completion", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Adds new public options (mode/waitUntil) to an exported @netscript/fresh/ai interface — widened public surface, features lane.", + "leafGroup": "fresh-ai-chat-response-options", + "wave": 9, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/runtime/ai/create-chat-connection.ts:234-264 — NetScriptChatResponseOptions exposes target/streamPath/source/newMessages/request/authorize/toResponse and no mode or waitUntil", + "packages/fresh/src/runtime/ai/create-chat-connection.ts:255-263 — `toResponse` is documented as a test/adapter seam defaulting to toDurableChatSessionResponse, which is exactly the escape hatch consumers are forced to use", + "packages/fresh/src/runtime/ai/create-chat-connection.ts:461 — `const toResponse = options.toResponse ?? defaultToResponse;` with no completion-mode forwarding", + "gh timeline for #1458: only a 0.0.7 milestone event; no PR has referenced it" + ], + "externalDependencies": [ + { + "issue": 950, + "milestone": "0.0.10", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "note": "Adjacency note in the issue body (\"Related to #238 and #950\"), not a dependency." + } + ], + "uncertainty": "I did not read the upstream transport's toDurableChatSessionResponse signature, so whether it already accepts mode/waitUntil (making this pure forwarding) or needs a transport change in plugins/ai is unverified — that determines whether this stays a one-package change." + }, + { + "number": 1461, + "title": "docs/sdk: getCachedEntry cache-first loader example never revalidates stale entries", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Labelled type:docs, but the acceptance checklist demands runtime behaviour (zero upstream calls when fresh, SWR on stale, exactly one refresh under concurrency, refreshed cachedAt) — that is packages/sdk source, NOT the docs lane. This is the exact trap that produced the bad 0.0.4 docs-lane PR.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-cached-entry-swr", + "wave": 6, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "The issue offers two mutually exclusive remedies (correct the docs vs. add a revalidating queryEntry() API) but the six acceptance boxes only hold under the second; the inflight-dedupe fix in revalidateInBackground is a third, separable change to cache-query.ts.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:385-410 — getCachedEntry() reads this.store.get(), records telemetry and returns toCachedEntry(); it never reads staleTime, calls queryFn, or schedules a refresh", + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md:188 — the published example still carries `if (entry) return entry; // serve cached; SDK reloads stale in the background`", + "docs/site/services-sdk/sdk.md:138 — getCachedEntry is still described as 'the SWR primitive a layer loader uses to decide stale-reload'", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:256-300 — revalidateInBackground never touches this.inflightRequests, confirming the issue's concurrent-duplicate-refresh note (dedupe exists only in fetchAndCacheOnce at :210-217)", + "docs/site/_site/capabilities/sdk/index.md:143 — the same false comment is in the built site output" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether the intended outcome is a doc correction or a new published queryEntry() API is undecided in the issue; that choice moves it between fixes and features." + }, + { + "number": 1462, + "title": "bug(sdk): importing defineServices in a browser auto-registers the server KV cache provider", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Primary deliverable repairs defective runtime/build behaviour in packages/sdk, but the fix widens the published export map (a browser-safe defineServices subpath) — treat the export-surface change with a publish-surface/jsr-audit review even though the lane is fixes.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-browser-safe-entrypoints", + "wave": 7, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Acceptance mixes three deliverables: (a) an SDK export/side-effect restructure, (b) making browser queryOptions().queryFn() use an injected typed client, and (c) 'production client chunks contain no server KV adapter', which needs a bundle-inspection gate that does not exist in this repo today (nothing under packages/cli/e2e asserts on built chunk contents). (c) plus 'defineFreshApp/server bootstrap still registers the provider explicitly' also reaches packages/fresh, i.e. a second package.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/mod.ts:46 — `export * from './src/cache/mod.ts'` still re-exports the cache module from the SDK root alongside defineServices (mod.ts:55)", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/mod.ts:22 — top-level `setCacheProvider(cacheQuery)` executes on any import of that module; the module JSDoc (:11-12) only warns browsers to avoid it", + "packages/sdk/deno.json:6-19 exports map has no ./presets or other browser-safe defineServices subpath — exactly the published-surface gap the issue reports", + "packages/sdk/mod.ts:24-25 documents the auto-registration as intended behaviour, so the fix must also update the root module contract", + "gh timeline for #1462: only a 0.0.7 milestone event — no PR has touched it" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "I did not trace query-factory.ts / KvCacheStore.resolve() line-by-line, so the exact seam where hasCacheProvider() flips the code path is taken from the issue body. Whether removing the root re-export is a breaking change for existing 0.0.6 consumers is unassessed." + }, + { + "number": 1466, + "title": "[sdk-client S2] feat(sdk): define NetScriptProcedureMeta without erasing contract errors", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "New public NetScript-owned type vocabulary exported from packages/sdk + packages/contracts — widened public surface.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-procedure-metadata", + "wave": 3, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "grep -rnE '\\$meta<|\\.meta\\(|NetScriptProcedureMeta' packages plugins --include=*.ts → only Zod `.meta({` in packages/aspire/config.ts; no oRPC procedure metadata and no NetScriptProcedureMeta symbol exists on baseline", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1275 Stage 1b — 'Initialize/export NetScriptProcedureMeta without re-erasing Stage 1a types … an explicit dependent child owns this before auth dogfood'", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:410-413 — `SdkClientProcedureDescriptor.meta: Readonly` is a field of the normative public contribution contract", + "Issue body 'Part of #1348. Implements RFC 0001 stage 1b.' — filed after PR #1390 merged, so it IS the Stage-0-selected 1b owner", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1347 §'Procedure metadata' defines the shape this issue must export" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Issue body is a terse post-RFC stub (6 acceptance lines) with no file citations; the concrete surface must be read out of RFC §'Procedure metadata' (rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:347-398) rather than the issue." + }, + { + "number": 1467, + "title": "[sdk-client S7] feat(sdk): ship locale as the non-auth contribution proof", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Ships a new contribution export plus generated-client type propagation — public surface.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-locale-contribution-proof", + "wave": 6, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "grep -rn 'SdkClientContribution' packages plugins → no match on baseline; no locale contribution exists", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1280 Stage 6 'Non-auth proof — new child after RFC acceptance. Ship/test locale contribution, partitioned keys, header conflicts, and generated use.' — #1467 is that child (body: 'Implements RFC 0001 stage 6')", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1480-1481 — 'Locale proves generality without duplicating credential semantics or violating trace ownership' (locale, not trace, is the ratified non-auth proof)", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:879 — `accept-language` is explicitly permitted for contributions", + "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:441-452 — SdkClientResponseCache partition/direct-only law this issue must exercise" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Terse post-RFC stub with no file citations; concrete acceptance (composition order, retries, cancellation, cache keys, redaction) must be read from rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:830-946 and :1089-1133. Docs acceptance ('auth and non-auth examples') overlaps #1352's docs deliverable — possible PR collision on the same SDK docs page." + }, + { + "number": 1481, + "title": "fix(fresh-ui): /design ships ungated — the defect class RFC 0005 guards against", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Labelled area:fresh-ui, but the code to change is packages/cli scaffold assets (the (design) route group) plus an e2e production-build assertion — CLI/scaffold output repair, so the fixes lane, not docs and not fresh-ui source.", + "leafGroup": "scaffold-route-emission-and-gating", + "wave": 7, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/routes/(design)/design/ ships _layout, index, tokens, components, composition templates plus (_components)/(_islands)/(_shared) — grep for MODE|development|import.meta.env across that directory returns zero matches, so no mode gate exists", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/scaffold/writers/write-app-files.ts:95-99 and :139-143 create the (design) group unconditionally; :257-263 write the route templates with no opt-in flag", + "gh timeline for #1481: milestoned to Backlog/Triage then 0.0.7; cross-referenced from merged PRs #1450/#1523 and open #1522 (DevTools RFC artifacts) — none touched the gate", + "RFC authority rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md is merged on main, so the dual-exclusion posture the acceptance must match is already ratified" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The issue's own non-gating note says it was never established whether /design is intended to reach production users; that product decision gates the mechanism choice (structural exclusion vs runtime refusal vs opt-in flag) and is not answered anywhere I could read. Also unverified: whether the scaffolded Vite build even has a mechanism to exclude a route group from the build graph." + }, + { + "number": 1502, + "title": "RFC: Plugin CLI command contribution architecture — one typed mount and generation seam", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Labelled type:docs but it is RFC ratification of a new public extension seam — features lane per the acceptance ('public contracts, ownership, lifecycle, failures, security, compatibility' + implementation epic proposal), not the docs lane.", + "leafGroup": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": "Single RFC document + PLAN-EVAL; the 'implementation epic and PR-sized children proposed' row means filing issues, which one PR can accompany.", + "evidence": [ + "No such RFC exists: rfcs/ contains only 0000-template, 0001-sdk-client-contributions, 0002-runtime-versioned-automation, 0003-command-composition-kit, 0004-deterministic-first-hybrid-mcp-doc-retrieval, 0005-devtools-contribution", + "rfcs/0003-command-composition-kit.md:1-20 is 'Production command composition kit' (transactional business commands, single store) — confirms it does not cover CLI extension, as the issue states", + "rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md:1-8 is Accepted with tracking issue #1465, so the DevTools consumer named in the sequencing section exists and would consume this seam", + "The consumer children are filed and parked downstream: #904, #905, #906, #907, #908 are all OPEN in milestone 0.0.11 ('Host: CLI mount-children contribution contract', async bootstrap, doctor-checks-as-data, manifest triad, plugin CLI children)", + "Labelled priority:p0 + status:research + epic:cli-contrib and self-declared '0.0.7 foundation' — nothing in-repo supersedes it" + ], + "externalDependencies": [ + { + "issue": 904, + "milestone": "0.0.11", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "note": "#1502 Required decisions name #904-#908 as candidates for migration/supersession. Read-only inventory obligation; the deploy consumers must consume the accepted seam later." + }, + { + "issue": 908, + "milestone": "0.0.11", + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "note": "Same as #904." + } + ], + "uncertainty": "Whether #904-#908 should be superseded outright or re-scoped as consumers of the new seam is a decision for the RFC; not determinable from code." + }, + { + "number": 1533, + "title": "test(docs): nothing compiles JSDoc `@example` blocks", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "jsdoc-example-compile-gate", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "No JSDoc example gate exists: .llm/tools/docs/check-snippets.ts:42-43 resolves its root to docs/site (or a fixture's docs/site) only — packages/** and plugins/** JSDoc are outside its scope", + "The tool inventory under .llm/tools/docs/ (snippet-extractor.ts, snippet-compiler.ts, snippet-policy.ts, check-snippets.ts) contains no @example/JSDoc extractor", + "Negative-test fixture #1 is currently clean: grep for 'api-clients' across packages/sdk/**/*.ts returns nothing (file is packages/sdk/src/query-client/create-service-query-utils.ts), so the gate must reintroduce it deliberately", + "Negative-test fixture #2 is also clean: packages/sdk/src/desktop/mod.ts:11-12 now imports '@my-app/contracts', not a relative app path", + "Prerequisite #1374 is CLOSED (milestone 0.0.6) and its snippet machinery is checked in, so the sequencing constraint is already satisfied" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Did not execute doc:lint or the snippet gate; the claim that deno doc --lint ignores example bodies is taken from the issue's recorded evidence, not re-run here." + }, + { + "number": 1542, + "title": "fix(tooling): quality:gate roots omit published packages, so a green gate is not proof they were scanned", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "quality-scan-root-coverage", + "wave": 2, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "`deno.json:52` `quality:gate` = `quality:scan && arch:check`, and `deno.json:50` `quality:scan` roots are still `packages/cli/src`, `plugins`, `docs/site` — `packages/plugin-streams-core`, `packages/plugin-workers-core`, and `packages/cli/e2e` are outside them.", + "The `arch:check` half is now fixed: `deno.json:163` uses `--all-roots`, and `.llm/tools/fitness/check-doctrine.ts:27-43` `discoverDoctrineRoots()` enumerates every `packages/*` and `plugins/*` carrying a named `deno.json`.", + "That arch half landed in `e391f3aec` \"fix(quality): make quality gate coverage informative (#1570)\", merged 2026-08-12T14:31 — after #1542 was filed (2026-08-12T09:11) but closing #1403, not #1542.", + "Acceptance box 3 is arguably already met: the scanner emits `scanned` in its JSON result (`scan-code-quality.ts` main block, `result.scanned`).", + "No test pins root coverage: no reference to `discoverDoctrineRoots` from any file under `.llm/tools/quality`." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether widening `quality:scan` to all published packages leaves the gate green is unverified — running `quality:scan:repo` was out of scope for this read-only audit; PR #1570's triage note records one still-actionable A8 finding at `packages/plugin-streams-core/src/application/durable-stream-producer-supervisor.ts:501`." + }, + { + "number": 1543, + "title": "chore(deps): plugin-workers-core and plugins/triggers import plugin-streams-core without declaring it", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Edits packages/plugin-workers-core/deno.json and plugins/triggers/deno.json — published-artifact manifests, not repo tooling. The optional third row (a check on undeclared cross-package imports) is the only internals-flavoured part.", + "leafGroup": "cross-package-dependency-declarations", + "wave": 8, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "grep for '@netscript/plugin-streams-core' across the three manifests returns only plugins/workers/deno.json:26 — packages/plugin-workers-core/deno.json and plugins/triggers/deno.json still do not declare it", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/streams/producer.ts:1 imports { createDurableStream } from '@netscript/plugin-streams-core'", + "plugins/triggers/streams/producer.ts:7 imports { createDurableStream } from '@netscript/plugin-streams-core'", + "plugins/workers/deno.json:26 pins it as jsr:@netscript/plugin-streams-core@0.0.6, establishing the declaration pattern the other two diverge from" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Could not run `deno task publish:dry-run` (read-only audit), so whether publish rejects, warns, or silently accepts the undeclared import — the issue's own first acceptance row — remains unknown. If it silently accepts, the issue downgrades to consistency and may be closable on that evidence." + }, + { + "number": 1544, + "title": "fix(cli): `emit` is advertised by three deploy adapters but never routed", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "cli-deploy-verb-surface", + "wave": 9, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/public/features/deploy/target/target-deploy-command.ts:15-23 ROUTED_OPERATIONS = ['plan','up','down','status','logs','rollback','secrets'] — 'emit' absent", + "Same file:26-35 OPERATION_DESCRIPTIONS still carries `emit: 'Emit deployment artifacts'`, and :58-59 generates subcommands only from ROUTED_OPERATIONS ∩ adapter.operations, so emit can never become a command", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/aspire/aspire-compose-deploy-target.ts:66 advertises 'emit' and :97 implements it (`return this.#publish('emit', request)`)", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/aspire/aspire-cloud-deploy-target.ts:125 advertises ['plan','emit','up','down']; packages/cli/src/kernel/domain/deploy/service-deploy-target.ts:24,107 advertise and implement it too", + "Existing tests lock the advertised sets (deploy-target-port_test.ts:198-199,210) but none asserts routability — the invariant the issue asks for is genuinely missing" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The route-vs-unadvertise decision is a product call not resolvable from code; note `plan`'s description already reads 'Emit or preflight deployment artifacts', which favours unadvertising." + }, + { + "number": 1545, + "title": "chore(quality): register the pre-existing quality-allow population so #1378's linked-issue rule can land without a day-one red gate", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": "Edits comment text inside packages/** and plugins/** but changes no runtime behaviour or public surface; the deliverable is the quality-rail register plus deno.json budget wiring, so it is internals, not fixes.", + "leafGroup": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Mutually dependent with #1378: #1545's registration must precede #1378's rule to avoid a red gate, while #1545's own test box needs that rule to exist. Neither can tick all boxes alone — they should land as one PR under this leaf group, or #1545 ships comment edits only and its test box moves to the #1378 PR.", + "evidence": [ + "No allowance carries an issue id at baseline: all 7 live sites read `// quality-allow: ` — `packages/cli/src/public/public-api.ts:135,136,158,275,276`, `packages/cli/src/public/features/root/public-command-dependencies.ts:363`, `plugins/workers/streams/producer.ts:52`.", + "The population is 7, not the 8 the issue tabulates: `grep -rn 'quality-allow' packages/fresh/src` returns nothing, so table row 7 (`route-support.ts:96`) no longer exists at baseline.", + "`--max-allow` is already wired: `deno.json:50` `--max-allow 7`, `deno.json:51` `--max-allow 8` — so acceptance box 2 as written (8 for both) is stale relative to the tree.", + "The scanner still has no registration concept: `scan-code-quality.ts:207` accepts any non-empty reason, so box 1's 'reports them as registered rather than as findings' has no mechanism.", + "PR #1596 referenced #1545 without closing it and deferred live issue-state verification to 0.0.7." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether the packages/fresh allowance was removed by a real type fix or by code deletion — I did not trace the commit that dropped it, so the 8-vs-7 delta's cause is unverified." + }, + { + "number": 1551, + "title": "docs(positioning): establish \"NetScript vs …\" and \"Migrate from …\" comparison framework", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "docs", + "laneRationale": "Pure prose/site content under docs/site; the deliverables list touches no packages/** or plugins/** source. It does require building a comparison Next.js implementation, which belongs outside the framework tree.", + "leafGroup": "comparison-docs-programme", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "17 deliverables spanning IA + methodology page + a full Next.js re-implementation + LSP benchmark harness + agent-leverage experiments cannot be ticked by one PR. Only 'methodology page + NetScript vs Next.js case study + migration roadmap placeholder' is a 0.0.7-sized leaf; the LSP/agent/runtime measurement deliverables need their own issues. Also note the case-study source lives in an external repo (EIS-Chat), so the evidence base must be imported or the case study re-based on an in-repo route.", + "evidence": [ + "No comparison surface exists yet: docs/site has no comparisons/ directory and docs/site/reference/ contains only per-package pages", + "The named case-study artifact is not in this repository — there is no apps/ directory, so `apps/dashboard/routes/project/[project]/channel/[channel]/session/[session]/index.tsx` cannot be read or reproduced from this worktree", + "#1550 (framework-owned request-aware cache-seed primitive, referenced by the case study) is CLOSED, so the 'label the current helper as application-owned' caveat may already be stale", + "Issue body itself scopes 17 deliverable checkboxes including LSP cold/warm p50/p95 benchmarks, paired human/agent navigation studies, and runtime measurement — none of which is a documentation authoring task" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether the EIS-Chat dashboard route is accessible to the implementing lane at all is unverified; if not, the first case study has no subject." + }, + { + "number": 1557, + "title": "test(fresh): no capability to assert the deferred coordinator reaches the client bundle", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": "Labelled type:test; the deliverable is a regression gate plus a recorded CI-cost decision, with no packages/** runtime change — internals.", + "leafGroup": "fresh-defer-test-capability", + "wave": 5, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Criterion 1 as worded ('for a scaffolded app') is a packages/cli e2e deliverable, while criteria 2-3 (client navigation into a cache-miss deferred layer, boundary swaps exactly once) fit the existing packages/fresh playwright gate. Those are two gates in two packages; one PR cannot truthfully tick both unless criterion 1 is re-scoped to the existing fixture.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/tests/form-navigation_browser.ts:212 drives `playwright-cli` and .github/workflows/ci.yml:252-265 installs @playwright/cli and runs the fresh-browser gate — the issue's premise 'no browser driver in repo test infrastructure' is STALE as of 1ed78f508 (#1602)", + "packages/fresh/tests/defer-island-client-bundle_test.ts:38-60 already builds a client bundle and asserts the defer island entry plus the 'partial-miss' policy string — criterion 1 is largely met for a FIXTURE, not for a scaffolded app", + "Criteria 2 and 3 remain unmet: nothing asserts a request to a configured /partials/** endpoint from a client navigation, and nothing asserts a named boundary swaps exactly once (grep of packages/fresh/tests shows only form-navigation_browser.ts and the bundle test)", + "gh timeline for #1557: cross-referenced from closed #1459 and merged PRs #1555/#1558 (the runtime fix), never from a test-capability PR" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The issue body must be re-baselined before work starts — its 'What is missing today' section predates the playwright gate. Whether the deferred-layer scenario can reuse the existing route-binding-browser fixture harness, or needs a new scaffolded fixture, is unverified." + }, + { + "number": 1561, + "title": "fix(tooling): acceptance-evidence mirror throws on an empty entry list instead of reporting it", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "Defect present verbatim: `.llm/tools/validation/acceptance-evidence.ts:255` `if (!field) throw new Error(\\`Invalid acceptance-evidence YAML line: ${line}\\`);`.", + "The skip guard only tolerates the bare key: `acceptance-evidence.ts:251` `if (!line || line === 'entries:') continue;` — the literal `entries: []` is neither empty nor equal to `'entries:'`.", + "The field regex `^-?\\s*(issue|box|box-index|evidence):\\s*(.*)$` (`:254`) cannot match `entries: []`, so the throw is guaranteed, not conditional." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Acceptance box 3 also requires a `netscript-pr` skill statement; I did not check whether `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` already covers the empty/omitted-block case." + }, + { + "number": 1563, + "title": "fix(agentic): verdict extractor records NONE when the token is a markdown heading", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "Shell tier 2 cannot match a heading: `.github/workflows/openhands-agent.yml:874` `grep -E '^[[:space:]]*(Verdict:?[[:space:]]*)?OPENHANDS_VERDICT:...'` after `sed -E 's/[*`]+//g'` — the strip removes `*` and backtick only, never `#`.", + "Shell tier 1 is strictly anchored: `openhands-agent.yml:870` `grep -E '^OPENHANDS_VERDICT:...'`.", + "The JS twin has the same hole: `openhands-agent.yml:~1176-1182` `verdictOf()` matches `/^OPENHANDS_VERDICT:.../` then `line.replace(/[*`]+/g,'').match(/^[ \\t]*(?:Verdict:?[ \\t]*)?OPENHANDS_VERDICT:.../)`.", + "The library extractor is equally blind: `.llm/tools/agentic/lib/agentic-lib.ts:892` prefix class is `[\\s>*`_]*` — `#` is not a member.", + "No test covers the heading form: `agentic-lib_test.ts:655,739` cover the bare line and the `**Verdict: OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS**` bold form only." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Acceptance box 2 (distinguish 'agent emitted no verdict' from 'could not be parsed') needs a new `verdict_source` value; I did not audit every consumer of that marker field for the added enum case." + }, + { + "number": 1564, + "title": "fix(ci): pull_request.base.sha is stale on long-lived PRs, so every gate that computes a range from it silently inspects the wrong changeset", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": "CI workflow range computation (.github/workflows/*.yml); no packages/** or plugins/** runtime change. Internals lane.", + "leafGroup": "ci-diff-range-base-sha-barrier", + "wave": 0, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Four unaudited consumers (ci.yml:135,153; e2e-cli.yml:128,158; surface-diff.yml:47) plus the audited code-quality.yml:39 which #1403 separately owns. The surface-diff consumer is a correctness question, not only a coverage one, and may warrant its own review.", + "evidence": [ + "Reproduced on PR #1539: base.sha cd24e1679 was hours stale; `git diff --name-only --diff-filter=ACMR cd24e1679 2a4102600 -- packages plugins` returned 9 files, ZERO of them in #1539 own diff (all from already-merged #1526/#1528/#1534/#1535/#1536).", + "The gate reported success having inspected zero lines of the PR under review, while a new `as unknown as` sat in .llm/tools/release/github-release.ts throughout.", + "Consumers audited on main: code-quality.yml:39 (affected, owned by #1403); ci.yml:135,153, e2e-cli.yml:128,158, surface-diff.yml:47 (unaudited, same input); openhands-phase-eval.yml:126 already fixed by #1552 by resolving heads/${pr.base.ref} instead.", + "gh issue view 1564: state=OPEN, milestone=0.0.7, labels type:fix,area:tooling,status:triage,priority:p1, updated 2026-08-13T18:38:26Z." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Four of the five consumers are recorded as unaudited in the issue itself; the blast radius beyond code-quality.yml:39 is stated, not proven. Boundary with #1403 (which hardens exactly one consumer) must be settled before dispatch so the two do not collide on code-quality.yml." + }, + { + "number": 1588, + "title": "fix(scaffold): omit unreachable provider URL parsers from SQLite workspaces", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Generated database workspace output from packages/cli templates.", + "leafGroup": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/generated/database/generate-prisma-config-1.ts.template:35-51 emits normalizeDatabaseUrl with postgres/mysql/mssql branches while :27 types the provider as the literal '{{__slot4__}}' (= 'sqlite') and :36-38 short-circuits sqlite first — the branches are statically unreachable", + "Same template :53-134 carries normalizePostgresUrl, normalizeMysqlUrl, normalizeMssqlUrl, parseSqlServerEndpoint and parseConnectionParts for every engine", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/generate-engine-mod.ts:34 + :140-142 inline the full connection-helpers asset unconditionally (buildConnectionHelpers() takes no provider argument), so database//mod.ts gets all three normalizers too", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/database/connection-helpers.ts.template:12-21 is the shared switch that duplicates the prisma-config one", + "The only cross-reference is rickylabs/eis-chat#194 (closed, downstream consumer cleanup) — no netscript PR has touched this" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The issue's expected output uses SQLITE_URI with a plain fallback; generate-prisma-config.ts:28-31 already derives `_URI` and a `file:./.db` fallback, so the trim is mechanical — but I could not confirm by scaffolding (running init was out of scope), only by reading the two generators." + }, + { + "number": 1590, + "title": "Fresh partial navigation needs last-intent ordering and remount-safe region identity", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Net-new framework surface in packages/fresh (client navigation coordinator + subscription API), not a repair of an existing behaviour — labelled type:feat and matches the features lane.", + "leafGroup": "fresh-client-navigation-coordinator", + "wave": 8, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Four independent behaviours are bundled: navigation-generation ordering, abort-safe drain (Vite overlay avoidance), remount-safe dynamic region identity via keyed partial comment boundaries, and a public route-subscription API. Each has its own test shape; the removal condition (EIS deleting apps/dashboard/lib/client-nav.ts) requires all of them, so one PR cannot honestly tick the set unless it is scoped as a single coordinator module.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/builders/define-page/navigation/ contains only context.ts/hooks.ts/link.tsx/mod.ts — href/link typing, no generation counter, no supersede/abort logic (grep for generation|supersede|inflight|abort in hooks.ts returns nothing)", + "packages/fresh/deno.json:7-22 export map has no client-navigation subpath; nearest client runtime is ./defer/island (packages/fresh/src/application/defer/island.ts)", + "grep -rln 'clientNav|replaceState' packages/fresh/src only hits form transport attributes (packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/enhancement.tsx:55) and route types, never a navigation coordinator", + "gh timeline for #1590: only a 0.0.7 milestone event, no cross-referenced PR — nothing has attempted this" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The consumer module apps/dashboard/lib/client-nav.ts lives in the EIS repo and is not readable here, so the exact semantics to absorb are taken from the issue body only. Whether Fresh 2.3.3 upstream has since changed ordering behaviour was not checked." + }, + { + "number": 1591, + "title": "AI provider adapter needs a typed OpenAI Responses mapper", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "New published typed adapter/mapper on @netscript/ai; type:feat is correct.", + "leafGroup": "ai-openai-responses-mapper", + "wave": 8, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/ai/src/adapters/openai-compatible.adapter.ts:39-51 — openAiCompatibleGenerationModelOptions only emits Chat Completions keys (flat `reasoning_effort`, `max_tokens`); no Responses variant exists", + "packages/ai/src/adapters/openai-compatible.adapter.ts:56 — OpenAiCompatibleApi already accepts 'responses', and packages/ai/openai-compatible.ts:49 passes it through, so the config surface admits a wire shape the mapper cannot produce", + "grep for max_output_tokens across packages/ai returns no hits — the Responses output-token key is absent from the repo", + "gh api issues/1591/timeline — no cross-references" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether the retry/no-replay-after-output behaviour the issue asks to preserve is exercised by existing tests is unverified — I did not read tanstack-chat-client.ts." + }, + { + "number": 1592, + "title": "Workers durable execution stream should publish typed progress", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "features", + "laneRationale": "Extends the canonical published ExecutionRecord schema and adds stream events — widened public contract surface.", + "leafGroup": "workers-execution-progress", + "wave": 7, + "sizeHint": "large", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "Schema extension, persistence in the execution record, publication on the durable /workers/executions stream, and documented ordering/coalescing/replay semantics are four distinct layers; the replay/coalescing contract in particular needs its own design decision.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-definition.ts:201-245 — ExecutionRecordShape has no progress or progressMessage field (id, concept, jobId, topic, status, triggeredBy, timestamps, exitCode, duration, error, result, workerId, attempt, maxAttempts, payload, correlationId, traceparent, tracestate only)", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/domain/job-context.ts:11 — reportProgress?: (percent, message?) => void | Promise exists on the context", + "plugins/workers/worker/job-runner-pool.ts:61 — the runtime wires reportProgress and does not persist it into an execution record", + "packages/plugin-workers-core/src/telemetry/job-tools.ts:46 — the only consumer just forwards to ctx.reportProgress?.()", + "gh api issues/1592/timeline — no cross-references" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": null + }, + { + "number": 1598, + "title": "SDK cache-provider throw should name its module identity when two SDK instances are loaded", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "type:fix and correct: edits packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-provider.ts source plus a test; the message is published surface.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-provider.ts:203-212 — getCacheProvider() throw text still has no import.meta.url and no two-instances hint", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-provider.ts:55 — `let _provider: CacheProvider | null = null` is still module-local, as the issue requires it stay", + "gh issue 1589 is CLOSED on milestone 0.0.6 — the build-time gate landed, leaving this runtime throw as the only signal for already-generated consumers", + "No cross-referenced PR on issue 1598 timeline (gh api issues/1598/timeline returned no cross-references)" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Exact wording is an API-adjacent decision; no existing test asserts the message text, so the new test file is unspecified." + }, + { + "number": 1601, + "title": "test(fresh): defer-island client-bundle test resolves npm:vite over the network, making the package verdict environment-dependent", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": "Labelled type:test; deliverable is test-harness determinism (fixture build resolution / gate setup), no packages/** runtime source change — internals, not fixes.", + "leafGroup": "fresh-defer-test-capability", + "wave": 5, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/tests/defer-island-client-bundle_test.ts:19-28 — still `args: ['run','--no-lock','-A','npm:vite@7.2.2','build',...]`, verbatim the cited defect", + "packages/fresh/tests/fixtures/defer-island-client/ contains only client.ts, main.ts, otel-api.ts, vite.config.ts — no locked vite resolution for the fixture", + "git log on that test shows only 5705aeb19 (#1558); no determinism follow-up landed", + "gh timeline for #1601: cross-referenced only from open issue #1604 (packages/cli test suite always red) — same 'prescribed package test task is not a trustworthy verdict' family" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether the fix should pin vite through packages/fresh/deno.json imports or pre-provision it in gate setup is undecided in the issue; the catalog law (catalog: is npm-only) may constrain the option chosen. Related open issue #1604 covers the same determinism class for packages/cli and may want the same convention." + }, + { + "number": 1604, + "title": "test(cli): the prescribed `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` is always red", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": "Test-infrastructure capability (making a prescribed package gate honest); the files live under packages/cli/e2e but no runtime/product behaviour changes.", + "leafGroup": "package-gate-honesty", + "wave": 3, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:5 calls `Deno.readTextFile('docs/site/quickstart.vto')` — a bare repo-root-relative path, resolved against process cwd", + "packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:3,7 define DOC_PATH = 'docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md' and read it with Deno.readTextFile — same cwd dependence", + "packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:96-100 stats the script argument produced by service-env-gates.ts:59 (`${GATE_DIR}/configure-service-env.ts`), which is repo-root-relative", + "All three are reachable from the packages/cli test task, so the failure is in the base, not any branch — matching the issue's cbf6d5c27 observation", + "Same class as #1601 (OPEN, 0.0.7: environment-dependent package verdict), different mechanism" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Did not run the suite (read-only audit), so the exact failing count (3) and that no fourth cwd-sensitive test exists is unverified — a repo-wide audit of bare relative Deno.readTextFile/stat calls under packages/cli should be part of the fix." + }, + { + "number": 1606, + "title": "verify(sdk): confirm the published @netscript/sdk JSR landing page shows the canonical query dialect", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "docs", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "sdk-jsr-landing-verification", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "Source work is confirmed merged: packages/sdk/README.md:30 leads with 'createQueryFactories is the golden path'; grep finds no 'api-clients' reference in the file", + "packages/sdk/README.md:103,216-217 demote createServiceQueryUtils to the narrower ./query-client helper, matching the intended dialect", + "jsr-package-settings.json (repo root) sets defaults.readmeSource: 'readme', so packages/sdk/README.md is indeed the JSR landing page source", + "The README fix (db1d79c68, PR #1541) is an ancestor of the 0.0.6 cut c63dcc669 (`git merge-base --is-ancestor` = true), so if @netscript/sdk@0.0.6 published, the observation may already be makeable without waiting for a 0.0.7 publish", + "packages/sdk/deno.json:3 version is 0.0.6" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Observational by construction — cannot be closed by a PR. Did not fetch jsr.io, so whether @netscript/sdk@0.0.6 is actually published and how the page renders is unverified; the issue may be dischargeable immediately rather than after a 0.0.7 publish." + }, + { + "number": 1609, + "title": "fix(fresh): managed form silently drops navigation:'document' when mode:'client'", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair", + "wave": 8, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/enhancement.tsx:49 — `if (!strategy || strategy.mode === 'client') { return props; }` still early-returns before resolveFormNavigationProps is consulted (function is now applyCollectionStrategy at :42, issue cited the older name resolveFormEnhancementProps)", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/_internal/runtime-types.ts:89 — `FormCollectionStrategy extends Partial` still makes `{ mode: 'client', navigation: 'document' }` expressible", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/components/form.tsx:62 — `...resolveFormNavigationProps(strategy)` is still spread after `...props`, the C3 precedence", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/README.md:77-94 documents client/document strategies but states no precedence over caller-supplied raw f-client-nav props", + "git log -- packages/fresh/src/application/form/ shows 6aee2b414 (#1600) as the last change; no follow-up commit touched enhancement.tsx" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": null + }, + { + "number": 1610, + "title": "fix(fresh): route-pattern path inference makes unknown params never instead of a compile error", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair", + "wave": 8, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/types.ts:14 — `export type EmptyRecord = Record` still exists and is the empty-pattern branch at types.ts:131-132 (`TPattern extends '' ? EmptyRecord`)", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/_internal/contract-types.ts:80 — the internal copy has the same `'' ? EmptyRecord` branch; contract-types.ts:170 also defaults `RouteReference`, so an unbound reference's unknown key is `never`", + "packages/fresh/src/application/builders/define-partial.test.tsx:272-274 — `OriginalPath['channel']` is asserted `IsNever` for pattern '/projects/[project]', i.e. the carrier admits an undeclared key rather than erroring", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/mod.ts:54 — createRouteReference returns RouteReference>, so parsePath (contract-types.ts:185) inherits that shape", + "gh timeline for #1610: only cross-referenced from PR #1602 (the eval that raised it); no fix PR, and git log on route/types.ts shows no commit after the beta.5 baseline" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "I could not reproduce the exact `path.channel` compile-pass by type-checking (running deno check is outside my read-only remit). By reading alone, the #178 `EmptySegment = {}` fix (types.ts:17-24, contract.test.ts:238-260) removes the index signature for STATIC segments, so `{} & {project:string}` should already error on an unknown key; yet define-partial.test.tsx:274 indexes `['channel']` and is expected to type-check, which implies an index signature survives somewhere on that path. The residual EmptyRecord instances I can point to concretely are the empty-pattern branch and the default TPath. Whoever takes this must first re-run the issue's repro and record which construction actually yields `never`." + }, + { + "number": 1611, + "title": "agentic: formal evaluator dispatch helper must emit phase/head and acquire the existing claim", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "wave": 2, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "Producer confirmed silent on phase/head: `.llm/tools/agentic/lib/agentic-lib.ts:528-539` `buildOpenHandsComment` pushes only `model`, `provider`, `effort`, `output`, `iterations`.", + "Authorizer short-circuit confirmed: `.github/scripts/openhands-comment-trigger.mjs:61-63` reads `params.get('phase')`/`params.get('head')` then `if (!phase && !head) return decision;` — returns authorized without consulting the claim.", + "The claim path that is bypassed exists immediately below: `openhands-comment-trigger.mjs:64-67` `denied('incomplete-phase-claim')` / `denied('phase-claim-context-required')`.", + "No `phase=`/`head=` token appears anywhere in `agentic-lib.ts`'s DispatchOptions surface (`:515-521`)." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Acceptance box 2 demands an executed refusal test under a real claimed tuple; I could not run it (no test execution permitted), so only the code-level gap is proven here." + }, + { + "number": 1613, + "title": "agentic: report refused OpenHands commands to their author and align generation retry across dispatch paths", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "wave": 2, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "N2 confirmed: `.github/workflows/openhands-agent.yml:249` `core.notice(\\`Manual comment policy: ${decision.reason}\\`)` and `:252` for the stale-evaluator case — no `createComment` on the denial path.", + "N3 confirmed: `.github/workflows/openhands-agent.yml:208` `throw new Error(\\`No labeled-event generation found for ${expectedStatus}.\\`)` with no surrounding retry.", + "The asymmetry is real: `.github/workflows/openhands-phase-eval.yml:302-315` wraps the identical lookup in `for (let attempt = 0; attempt < 5 && !generationEvent; attempt += 1)` with a 1s sleep at `:313`." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The N2 reply must not recursively dispatch; I did not verify which exact prefix the production predicate treats as a command first token, so the safe reply shape is unconfirmed." + }, + { + "number": 1616, + "title": "test(cli): the scaffold emits no dynamic route, so no gate exercises dynamic route binding end to end", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Labelled type:test, but acceptance box 1 requires the CLI scaffold to EMIT a dynamic page route — that is packages/cli scaffold output source, so it is not the internals test lane.", + "leafGroup": "scaffold-route-emission-and-gating", + "wave": 7, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": true, + "splitNote": "The body itself separates Reading B (drive the existing browser test from real manifest.ts generator output — packages/fresh only, cheap) from Reading A (scaffold emits a dynamic example page and scaffold.runtime exercises it — packages/cli assets + embedded.generated.ts + e2e). Acceptance box 1 is Reading A, box 2/3 are satisfiable at either level; one PR doing both spans two packages and the expensive scaffold.runtime gate.", + "evidence": [ + "grep -rnE \"createRouteReference\\('/[^']*\\[\" packages/cli/src returns nothing on baseline — no dynamic reference is emitted anywhere", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/application/ui/web-scaffold.ts:29 emits `createRouteReference('/${segment}', ...)`; packages/cli/src/kernel/application/scaffold/writers/app-route-seeds.ts:45-60 seeds only $route/dashboard/health static references", + "packages/fresh/src/application/route/manifest.ts:154-156 maps a `[id]` segment to `$id` and :269 emits `createRouteReference(, )` — Reading B is achievable with no framework change, as the issue claims", + "packages/fresh/tests/fixtures/route-binding-browser/routes.ts exists as a hand-authored fixture (added by 1ed78f508, #1602), confirming the provenance gap the issue describes", + "gh timeline for #1616: cross-referenced only from merged PR #1602; no fix attempt" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Whether adding a permanent /examples/orders/[id] page to every scaffolded project is wanted product-wise is not settled in the issue; the narrower generator-shape assertion is offered as an alternative." + }, + { + "number": 1618, + "title": "tooling: deno fmt cannot verify packages/mcp — a deliberately malformed test fixture aborts config parsing", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "package-gate-honesty", + "wave": 3, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "Hazard present: `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json` is exactly `{ \"workspace\": \"packages/*\" }` — a string where a WorkspaceConfig is required.", + "The root `fmt` config does not exclude it: `deno.json:206-210` excludes only `packages/cli/`, `**/.generated/`, `**/node_modules/`.", + "Only the whole-repo task compensates: `deno.json:140` `fmt:check` passes `--exclude \"^(packages/(cli)|packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/|...)\"`, so a scoped `--root packages/mcp` run (the issue's repro) carries no such exclusion.", + "That compensating exclusion is pre-existing, not a fix for this issue: it entered in `10162bfda` (#715), long before the issue was filed.", + "`.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` has no fixture-marker skip of its own — the exclusion is caller-supplied only." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "I could not execute the wrapper to confirm the exit-1 reproduction or the negative control (test/build runs prohibited); whether `--exclude` alone stops deno's *config discovery* rather than only file selection is therefore unproven, which is precisely what option 1 vs option 3 in the issue turns on." + }, + { + "number": 1619, + "title": "fix(sdk): cache telemetry evidence validation throws into the data path", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Runtime contract change in packages/sdk/src/cache plus a README paragraph; the README line alone does not make it docs lane.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts:164-180 — recordIncompleteTopology is still typed `never` and ends in `throw new TypeError('Cache provider returned missing or invalid topology evidence')`", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts:149 validateDescriptor + :120 createCacheSpanAttributes — validation still runs inside the attribute builder", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:88 — createCacheSpanAttributes(...) is still evaluated as an argument to withSpan, so a bad descriptor throws before any span opens (same at :267, :308, :364, :392, :421)", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts:72 SYSTEM_PATTERN /^[a-z0-9][a-z0-9._-]*$/ still bounds the id, confirming the issue's 'no shipped path triggers it' framing" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The issue cites cache-telemetry_test.ts:237 as pinning fail-loud, but no packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry_test.ts exists on baseline (only cache-provider_test.ts) — the pinning test's location is unverified." + }, + { + "number": 1620, + "title": "fix(sdk): cache namespace cardinality is unbounded because operationId is caller-supplied free text", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Option 2 (runtime bound) is a fix in packages/sdk/src/cache; option 1 (branded operationId) would change the published QueryParams type and would be a features-lane change — the chosen option decides the lane.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "medium", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts:78-89 — normalizeCacheNamespace still only trims/lowercases/collapses/slices to CACHE_NAMESPACE_MAX_LENGTH; no distinct-value bound, no overflow collapse, no warning", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:86 and :389 — namespace derives directly from the caller-supplied options.operationId on every read path", + "Shares its edit surface with #1619 (both mutate packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry.ts and both need a README contract paragraph) — grouped into one leaf" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "Which of the three proposed mechanisms is intended is undecided in the issue; option 1 changes published types and would flip the lane to features." + }, + { + "number": 1621, + "title": "tooling: acceptance-evidence blocks fail opaquely when the target issue has no checkbox boxes", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": null, + "leafGroup": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "wave": 1, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "Error text present unchanged: `.llm/tools/validation/acceptance-evidence.ts:132` `Issue #${issue}: no acceptance box matched ${compared}; add an entry for box ... using exact trimmed text or its current box-index.`", + "No zero-box special case: `validateEvidenceMapping` (`acceptance-evidence.ts:116-140`) computes `actionable = checkboxes.filter(...)` and iterates evidence entries, emitting one per-index error each; it never tests `actionable.length === 0`.", + "Only the exact-text variant is pinned by a test: `acceptance-evidence_test.ts:55` asserts the `exact box text \"changed\"` message; there is no zero-box test." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The issue offers three mutually exclusive remedies (actionable message / documented no-op / checkbox issue templates) and does not choose; option 3 changes what close-gate enforces repo-wide and would not fit this leaf." + }, + { + "number": 1622, + "title": "mcp: the guidance closeScoreGap constant is pinned by no test — a 10x change passes green", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "internals", + "laneRationale": "Touches packages/mcp only under tests/; the deliverable is a guard that can fire, i.e. test-infrastructure capability, not a runtime repair — behaviour today is correct by the issue's own statement.", + "leafGroup": "package-gate-honesty", + "wave": 3, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "Constant present and unpinned: `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:42` `closeScoreGap: 0.5`, declared at `:29`, consumed at `:201` `leader.score - ranked[end]!.score <= GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap`.", + "The misleading fixture is unchanged: `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76` is the close-score test, `:81` seeds `rankedSection('pages/gamma','outside-leader-band',9.8)` and `:92` asserts `'pages/gamma#outside-leader-band'` last — gamma sorts last by slug either way.", + "No slug-early/score-outside case exists in that test file (no `zulu`/`alpha` boundary pair), so band membership never changes the observable order." + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "I did not execute the mutation experiment (setting the constant to 5) that the issue reports, so the '8 fixtures still pass' claim is taken from the issue's evaluator, not independently reproduced here." + }, + { + "number": 1623, + "title": "docs(sdk): CacheStore.get JSDoc documents a return shape that no longer type-checks", + "disposition": "active", + "lane": "fixes", + "laneRationale": "Labelled type:docs but the deliverable edits JSDoc INSIDE packages/sdk/src/ports/*.ts — framework source files. NOT the docs lane (docs lane must touch no packages/**); the docs orchestrator cannot own this.", + "leafGroup": "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "wave": 4, + "sizeHint": "small", + "splitRisk": false, + "splitNote": null, + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/ports/cache-store.ts:63 — `@returns Entry with the value or `{ value: null }` on cache miss` is still present", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/cache-store.ts:38-43 — CacheStoreEntry still declares a required `report: CacheReadTopologyReport`, so `{ value: null }` cannot satisfy it", + "packages/sdk/src/ports/cache-store.ts:66-79 — set() JSDoc documents only key/value/options and never mentions the CacheWriteTopologyReport it returns" + ], + "externalDependencies": [], + "uncertainty": "The third acceptance box is an open-ended sweep of packages/sdk/src/ports/** — I read cache-store.ts only, so the number of other superseded doc comments is unverified." + } + ], + "externalCandidates": [ + { + "number": 1249, + "title": "fix(fresh/form): controlProps() is not element-assignable, and Zod 4 constraint derivation misses numbers and regex", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "high-value-coherent", + "recommendation": "propose-admission", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "PROPOSAL for owner ratification, not a decision. Both defects are still real on baseline and both are type-soundness failures on a public surface, which is the stated 0.0.7 theme (\"typed extension and generation foundation\"): the canonical documented spread `` does not type-check against Preact's JSX role type, which is why @netscript/fresh-ui has to ship re-narrowing helpers. It shares the @netscript/fresh managed-form surface with already-admitted #1609, so a single leaf PR can carry both at near-zero marginal cost. It is p2 rather than p1 — that is the main argument against, and the reason this is offered as a proposal rather than an assertion.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/_internal/prop-types.ts:166 — `readonly role?: string;` still widens role beyond JSX's Signalish, reproducing the TS2322 in the issue", + "packages/fresh/src/application/form/schema-adapter/zod-constraints.ts:88,116,135 — switch handles only 'min_length'/'max_length'/'string_format'; no 'greater_than', 'less_than' or 'multiple_of' case, so number min/max/step never land", + "0.0.7 already owns the sibling form defect #1609 (managed form drops navigation:'document' when mode:'client') on the same package surface" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": true, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1384, + "title": "fix(auth): `POST /api/v1/auth/signout` revokes any session id an unauthenticated caller supplies", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "release-critical", + "recommendation": "propose-admission", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "PROPOSAL ONLY — owner ratification required. Verified live on baseline: `signout` takes `sessionId` from the request body and calls `revokeSession(sessionId)` with no principal check anywhere in the function, and the service that owns identity is itself built with no auth configuration. `@netscript/plugin-auth` is a published package name, so 0.0.7 would ship an unauthenticated (and, via `everywhere:true`, global) session-revocation hole. ADMISSION CONDITION: must be scoped to the credential-only-resolution carve-out — drop/ignore caller-supplied `input.sessionId` and resolve identity from `backend.interactive.getSessionId(request)` — which is self-contained in the handler + contract. The full issue as written declares itself \"blocked until #1383 lands\"; #1383 is NOT proposed and admitting it would drag the entire 0.0.8 auth pack. If the owner will not accept the carve-out scoping, this stays in 0.0.8.", + "evidence": [ + "plugins/auth/services/src/routers/v1-handlers.ts:188-234 — `signout(input, context)` resolves `input.sessionId ?? backend.interactive?.getSessionId(...)` then `await backend.sessions.revokeSession(sessionId)`; no principal check in the function body", + "plugins/auth/services/src/main.ts:70-83 — `createPluginService(router, { name:'auth', ..., middleware:[withAuthRequest], ... })`; no auth/authn/authz key, so no middleware populates a principal", + "plugins/auth/deno.json:\"name\": \"@netscript/plugin-auth\" — the defect is on a published package, not an internal-only surface", + "packages/plugin-auth-core/src/contracts/v1/auth.contract.ts:449-452 — `signout` route declares only method/path/input/output; the contract itself invites the caller-supplied id", + "#1384 Boundaries: \"Do not add the PluginServiceConfig.auth seam here — #1383 owns it; this issue consumes it and is blocked until it lands\" — the dependency that forces the carve-out scoping" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": true, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1385, + "title": "fix(auth): oRPC `signin`/`callback` discard the backend `Set-Cookie`, so the interactive browser flow can never establish a session", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "release-critical", + "recommendation": "propose-admission", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "PROPOSAL ONLY — owner ratification required, and weaker than #1384. Verified on baseline: none of the five auth v1 routes declares `outputStructure: 'detailed'`, and `signin`/`callback` keep only the `Location` value from the backend `Response`, so the only interactive backend NetScript ships cannot complete a browser sign-in through its own published API. Fits the release's \"existing docs/public-surface fixes\" clause, and the fix is contract-breaking (`outputStructure` on three routes), which is cheapest to land in a foundation release rather than after 0.0.7 hardens the SDK/contract seams. It needs NOTHING from #1383 — it is server-side header propagation only, so it is admissible atomically. Exclude it if the owner prefers to keep every auth-shaped change behind the 0.0.8 auth pack; the theme's deferral of \"auth consumers\" is arguably about consumers (#942, #1352 cookie scope), not about a broken published route.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/plugin-auth-core/src/contracts/v1/auth.contract.ts:437-461 — read directly: signin/callback/signout/session/me are all bare `.route().input().output()`; no `outputStructure: 'detailed'` on any of the five", + "plugins/auth/services/src/routers/v1-handlers.ts:95-107 — `signin` calls `interactive.signIn(...)` then keeps only `responseLocation(response)`; the `Response` (and its Set-Cookie) is discarded", + "plugins/auth/services/src/routers/v1-handlers.ts:160-169 — `callback` builds `{completed, sessionId, redirectTo, subject}` from `result` and discards `result.response`; the session id is returned in the JSON body instead", + "#1352 Target contract §5 — \"Cookie/session transport does not land here\" (bearer + x-api-key only), so no 0.0.7 SDK issue covers or conflicts with this fix", + "#1385 Boundaries reference only #1384/#1386/#1352/#942 as separate owners — none is a hard code prerequisite, so this is atomically landable without #1383" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": true, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1637, + "title": "fix(sdk): cache write limits must not fail successful query results", + "currentMilestone": "NONE", + "admissionPredicate": "high-value-coherent", + "recommendation": "propose-admission", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "PROPOSAL for owner ratification, not a decision. Filed today (2026-08-13) against the shipped @netscript/sdk@0.0.6-canary.3 by a live consumer (EIS-Chat); the defect is confirmed on baseline. It lands in exactly the SDK cache-path cluster 0.0.7 already owns (#1619 telemetry validation throwing into the data path, #1598 provider-throw identity, #1620 namespace cardinality, #1623 CacheStore.get JSDoc) and shares their principle: a cache-layer failure must degrade, not destroy a successful source read. No open issue duplicates it. Owner may reasonably upgrade the predicate to release-critical — it is a consumer-visible false-outage regression on the published canary — but it carries no p0 label, so I do not assert that on my own authority. Scope is one function plus a test; it can ride the same PR as #1619.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:237-248 — fetchAndCache awaits this.store.set(...) inside try/catch and rethrows after recordCacheProviderError, discarding the already-resolved `data`", + "packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:234 — `const data = await promise;` resolves before the cache write, so the source query has already succeeded when the write throws", + "gh issue list --search 'in:title cache' --state open returns no other open issue covering store.set write failure (only #1619/#1620/#1598/#1461/#1351, all already in 0.0.7)", + "Issue body names Deno KV's 65,536-byte value limit and the observed version @netscript/sdk@0.0.6-canary.3" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": true, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 175, + "title": "Service logs spurious \"MySQL is NOT reachable\" ERR under --db sqlite", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Tempting because it sits squarely in the SQLite-scaffold + MySQL-fix theme alongside #1588 and #1112, but the defect is already repaired on baseline, with the fix citing this issue number in a code comment. Recommend close-fixed, not admission.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/service/src/diagnostics/database-connectivity.ts:244-263 — resolveProbeEngine() returns 'skip' for sqlite and any unrecognized provider", + "packages/service/src/diagnostics/database-connectivity.ts:142-150 — skip branch logs at info and returns, with an inline comment naming (#175)" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 238, + "title": "epic: NetScript AI Stack — first-class AI runtime, chat & plugin seams (anchor #219)", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "p1 epic whose theme touches 0.0.7's #1591 (typed OpenAI Responses mapper) and #1458 (awaited durable chat completion), which is why it is tempting as an rfc-prerequisite. But it is explicitly research-complete/no-implementation, its five-home split (packages/ai, fresh/ai, fresh-ui ai registry, plugin-ai-core, plugins/ai) already exists in the tree, and #1591's own body states a self-contained removal condition that does not reference this epic. Ratifying an epic of this size is scope creep against the stated ship order.", + "evidence": [ + "#238 body: 'Status: architectural research complete (no implementation yet)'", + "#1591 body contains no reference to #238 and states its own removal condition ('EIS Chat can remove its generationOptions OpenAI branch when the native adapter covers the exact Responses wire')", + "The milestone description defers dependent auth/deploy/DevTools consumers; an AI-stack epic ratification is the same class of later work" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 767, + "title": "quality(docs): docs:readme:check is a dead gate — checker/template/house-style three-way divergence", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "internals", + "rationale": "Examined because it was flagged as referenced by 0.0.7 content. It is p3 CI-gate hygiene with no dependency on, or from, any 0.0.7 issue, and its own body records that it was deliberately kept out of a prior milestone close-out. Off-theme for a typed-extension release.", + "evidence": [ + "Issue labels: priority:p3, type:chore, wave:v1", + "Body: 'Deliberately not scoped into beta.10 — the milestone is being closed out ahead of the dashboard prototype'", + "Body: the checker is 'not wired into any CI workflow', so nothing regresses by deferring it" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 863, + "title": "scaffold: `netscript db init` can block indefinitely on an Unhealthy-but-Running Postgres resource (clean-machine quickstart flake)", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "p1 quickstart hang with no workaround, adjacent to in-milestone #1306 (aspire start agent usability) and #1262 (db seed placebo). Excluded because two of its three acceptance boxes require reproducing and root-causing an Aspire Postgres health-probe false negative on a clean machine — not tickable inside this milestone's WIP. If the owner wants it, admit only a narrowed version (bound db init's wait with an actionable timeout naming the unhealthy resource); the probe root-cause box should stay behind.", + "evidence": [ + "Issue acceptance boxes 2 and 3 require reproducing the Running/Unhealthy Postgres probe and a clean-machine quickstart end-to-end run", + "Evidence cited is a 0.0.4-era run trail (.llm/runs/beta11-cli--orchestrator/...), not re-verified on the 0.0.7 baseline — unverified whether it still reproduces" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 864, + "title": "cli: `deploy list --json` advertises an `emit` operation that no target command tree ships", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Same defect as #1544, which is already in 0.0.7 (\"`emit` is advertised and implemented by three deploy adapters but never routed, so `deploy list` reports a command that does not exist\"). Recommend the owner close #864 as a duplicate of #1544 rather than admit it — this is a Step 0 cleanup item, not scope.", + "evidence": [ + "#1544 (milestone 0.0.7) and #864 describe the identical deploy list-vs-command-tree parity defect", + "#864 evidence is from @netscript/cli@0.0.1-beta.10, materially older than #1544" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 904, + "title": "[deploy-plugin DPB-12] Host: CLI mount-children contribution contract", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.11", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "ANSWERS THE ASSIGNED QUESTION: #904 is a candidate for SUPERSESSION by #1502, not a prerequisite of it. #1502's Required decisions list \"Migration/supersession of deploy-specific proposals such as #904–#908\" and its Sequencing states deploy-plugin command children in 0.0.11 must consume the accepted seam rather than establish competing APIs. Admitting #904 would invert the ordering and let deploy ship the competing mount API the RFC exists to prevent. #1502 only needs to READ #904/#908 during its inventory acceptance box — a read-only obligation.", + "evidence": [ + "#1502 Required decisions: \"Migration/supersession of deploy-specific proposals such as #904–#908\"", + "#1502 Sequencing: \"This RFC is a 0.0.7 foundation. Deploy-plugin command children in 0.0.11 and DevTools command generation in 0.0.15 must consume its accepted seam rather than establish competing APIs\"", + "#1502 Acceptance: \"Current CLI/plugin seams and every existing consumer proposal are inventoried\" — inventory is a read, not a dependency", + "0.0.7 milestone description: \"Dependent auth, deploy, and DevTools consumers remain later\"" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 908, + "title": "[deploy-plugin DPB-16] Plugin CLI children: target add/remove, capabilities, cells apply, eight-op router", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.11", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "Same finding as #904: a downstream deploy consumer explicitly named for migration/supersession by #1502, and explicitly deferred by the milestone description. Not a prerequisite. Its eight-op router is precisely the kind of deploy-specific competing API #1502 is meant to replace.", + "evidence": [ + "#1502 Required decisions: \"Migration/supersession of deploy-specific proposals such as #904–#908\"", + "#1502 Sequencing: deploy-plugin command children in 0.0.11 \"must consume its accepted seam\"", + "No open 0.0.7 issue body references #908 outside that #1502 supersession line (grep across all 62 bodies)" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 928, + "title": "[frontend-contrib S6] @netscript/plugin-frontend-core contracts/v1", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.9", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "ANSWERS THE ASSIGNED QUESTION: #928 is coordination, not a prerequisite. #1348 treats it as a deliberately separate contribution dialect and asks only that the two envelopes share a version field, a conflict key, and a failure taxonomy. The one acceptance box that names it — \"reviewed against #928's contribution contract and the divergences are recorded on both issues\" — is satisfiable against #928's already-written contract text via an issue comment; no #928 code needs to exist. DRIFT: #1348's body states #928 is milestone `0.0.7`, but it is actually 0.0.9 under epic #922 — the RFC's board line is stale and should be corrected on the issue.", + "evidence": [ + "#1348 Boundaries: \"Do not duplicate #928 … it owns the frontend contribution contract; this RFC only asks that the two envelopes share a version field, a conflict key, and a failure taxonomy\"", + "#1348 Acceptance: \"The envelope is reviewed against #928's contribution contract and the divergences are recorded on both issues\" — a documentation obligation, not a code dependency", + "#1349 Boundaries: \"Do not duplicate #928 / #934 (frontend contribution contracts, deny-by-default …)\"", + "gh issue list milestone check: #928 is milestone 0.0.9, contradicting #1348:37 which records it as `0.0.7`" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 934, + "title": "[frontend-contrib S12] Generated deny-by-default procedure gateway", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.9", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "ANSWERS THE ASSIGNED QUESTION: #934 is a downstream CONSUMER of the metadata type, not a prerequisite. #1348 ratifies `NetScriptProcedureMeta.policy` so #934 does not invent a competing policy shape later; the acceptance obligation is that \"#934 is notified on its issue before it reaches implementation\" — a comment, satisfiable with zero #934 code. Same stale-milestone drift as #928 (#1348 records 0.0.7; actual is 0.0.9).", + "evidence": [ + "#1348 Summary: ratify the envelope \"before #934 invents its own policy shape\" — ordering is 0.0.7 → 0.0.9, not the reverse", + "#1348 Acceptance: \"#934 is notified on its issue before it reaches implementation\"", + "#1348 Boundaries: \"Do not duplicate #934 … it owns the gateway; this RFC owns only the metadata type it will read\"", + "gh issue list milestone check: #934 is milestone 0.0.9, contradicting #1348:37" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 950, + "title": "[AI-stack hardening] production agent lifecycle, completion policy, MCP routing, and conformance", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.10", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "Tempting because 0.0.7 carries AI-surface work (#1591 typed OpenAI Responses mapper, #1458 awaited durable chat completion, #1448 MCP pool isolation), but the only link is #1458's \"Related to #238 and production lifecycle hardening #950\" — an adjacency note, not a dependency. #950 is a whole 0.0.10 epic; admitting it displaces the milestone.", + "evidence": [ + "b_1458 body line 17: \"Related to #238 and production lifecycle hardening #950\" — the sole reference, phrased as related, not required", + "Cross-reference sweep of all 62 open 0.0.7 bodies: no other mention of #950" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1085, + "title": "fix(agentic): launch-codex-slice dies on SIGTERM and takes the Codex turn with it", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "internals", + "rationale": "Tempting because it threatens this very milestone's execution and coheres with 0.0.7's internals lane (#1611, #1613, #1429, #1453). Excluded because the sharpest box — refusals exiting 0 — is already satisfied on baseline, leaving only detachment defaults and diagnostic wording. Small residual, and the operational workaround (never timeout-wrap a launch; recover via agentic:codex-resume) is already established doctrine.", + "evidence": [ + ".llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts:390 and :408 — duplicate_sender_risk refusals now Deno.exit(4), satisfying the non-zero-exit acceptance box", + ".llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts:422-428 — the Codex child is still spawned attached with piped stdout, so the detachment box is unverified but plausibly still open" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1090, + "title": "verify(wave-five): does the shipped agent surface actually change agent behaviour?", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "internals", + "rationale": "Referenced by 0.0.7's #1357 and carries p1, but it is a measurement of agent behaviour against a *published* release, which by its own reasoning cannot be run against a branch. It blocks no 0.0.7 issue and no PR can tick its boxes. It belongs to a post-canary measurement window, not to the milestone's implementation scope.", + "evidence": [ + "#1090 body: 'A measured agent run is only meaningful against the published release. Run against a branch, it would grade a build no user can install'", + "#1090 body: 'Three 0.0.4 issues carry acceptance criteria that no pull request can satisfy'", + "It has already been relocated twice (0.0.4 → 0.0.5 → Backlog) without landing" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1175, + "title": "fix(ci): replace the fixed 120s JSR-propagation sleep with a version-named poll that reports what it waited for", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "internals", + "rationale": "The only pool item that touches the release cut itself (canary → stable publish path), which makes it tempting for a milestone that ends in a publish. Excluded as p3 quality-of-evidence work: the fixed sleep is slow and uninformative, not incorrect, so it cannot block the 0.0.7 cut.", + "evidence": [ + "Issue labels: priority:p3, type:fix, area:tooling", + "Title/body scope is replacing a fixed 120s sleep with a poll — a latency and diagnostics improvement, not a correctness gate" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1245, + "title": "fix(fresh/query): island query types reject the package's own documented patterns", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Referenced by 0.0.7's #1355 and #1360 and therefore a plausible dependency-required admission — but all three cited defects are repaired on baseline, so it blocks nothing. Recommend the owner close it as fixed rather than admit it. Note specifically that #1360 (island never passes initialDataUpdatedAt) is NOT blocked: the option exists on the type today, so the scaffold fix can land unaided.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/query/query-types.ts:136 — `initialDataUpdatedAt?: number;` present on IslandQueryOptions (defect 1 repaired)", + "packages/fresh/src/application/query/query-types.ts:52,54 — `isFetching` and `isRefetching` present on the island query result (defect 3 repaired)", + "packages/sdk/src/query-client/query-client-factory.ts:44-46 — createNetScriptQueryClient() returns `QueryClient`, not the narrower QueryClientPort (defect 2 repaired)", + "grep for 'as unknown as IslandQueryClient' and 'TS2551' across docs/ returns no hits — the documented concession is gone" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [ + 1355, + 1360 + ], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1246, + "title": "windows: project-local node_modules/.deno materialization is incomplete — scaffolded frontend cannot start", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Real on baseline (the scaffold still emits the npm:vite dev task), and it is a p1 first-run blocker on Windows — the most tempting exclusion here. Excluded because the root cause is @babel/core CJS resolution under Deno's npm compat layer, i.e. likely upstream, and the acceptance demands a new Windows CI lane. That is an unbounded platform investigation that would displace the RFC 0001 S1-S8 prerequisites the milestone ships first.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/scaffold/fresh-adapter.ts:139 — dev task is still `deno run -A npm:vite --configLoader native`", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/templates/app/generate-app-deno-json.ts:123 — same invocation in the app deno.json generator", + "Issue acceptance box 3 requires a Windows CI lane covering init → aspire start → frontend serving" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1255, + "title": "fix(fresh): page.layer.delivery span attribute reports 'blocking' for deferring regions", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Still real on baseline and adjacent to 0.0.7's deferred-coordinator work (#1557, #1601), which makes it a plausible free rider. Excluded on value: p3 telemetry-accuracy only, no user-facing behaviour change, and it does not share acceptance with any admitted issue.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/fresh/src/application/builders/define-page/runtime/mod.tsx:133 — `'page.layer.delivery': descriptor.config.delivery ?? 'blocking'`, so a layer deferring via a promise-returning loader is still labelled blocking", + "Labelled priority:p3; evidence is a 0.0.6-era docs run trail, not re-executed" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1259, + "title": "fix(cli): generated service aggregate health check fails on sqlite/libSQL — and intermittently on postgres", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Coherent with in-milestone #1588 (SQLite scaffold cleanup), but the primary root cause is already gone: the emitted health check no longer uses the tagged $queryRaw form the libSQL adapter rejects. What remains is a vestigial identical-branch ternary and re-including behavior.service-health in the sqlite e2e tier — cleanup, not a release concern.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/embedded.generated.ts:155 — generated healthCheck calls `$queryRawUnsafe('{{__slot14__}}')`, not the tagged template form", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/database/generate-engine-mod.ts:35 — `const healthQuery = provider.engine === 'sqlite' ? 'SELECT 1' : 'SELECT 1';` vestigial ternary still present", + "grep for 'service-health' in packages/cli/e2e/suites/scaffold/*.ts returns no hits, so the claimed sqlite-tier exclusion could not be located — unverified" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1276, + "title": "epic(quality): ratify and eliminate unsound types — no as-unknown-as, no arbitrary any, no conceded TS errors", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "p1 and thematically magnetic for a \"typed foundation\" release, but it is a six-tranche umbrella spanning 56 as-unknown-as sites, 8 lint suppressions and a new CI gate. Admitting it would import a repo-wide program that displaces the RFC 0001 ship order. Its most valuable pieces are already represented in 0.0.7 by #1378 (quality:scan cannot see an `any` in an exported type), #1545 (quality-allow population) and #1296 (contracts/Fresh UI reference drift).", + "evidence": [ + "Issue body defines tranches T1-T6, including a new fail-closed CI gate covering docs snippets", + "T2 of this epic is #1245 + #1249; #1245 is already repaired on baseline (see this sweep's #1245 entry)", + "0.0.7 already carries #1378, #1545 and #1296 covering the gate-capability and reference-drift portions" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1278, + "title": "Type soundness ratification: eliminate unsound and arbitrary types across the public surface and the docs", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "Sibling umbrella to #1276 with overlapping inventory (its item A is already ticked and its query-bridge exemplar is repaired on baseline). Referenced by 0.0.7's #1348 as motivation, not as a prerequisite — #1348 does not block on it. Same scope-creep objection as #1276; the two should probably be merged during Step 0 cleanup rather than admitted.", + "evidence": [ + "#1348 body references #1278 among a dozen context refs; nothing in #1348's acceptance depends on #1278 landing", + "#1278's headline exemplar (query-bridge as-unknown-as + TS2551/TS2345) no longer reproduces — createNetScriptQueryClient returns QueryClient (packages/sdk/src/query-client/query-client-factory.ts:46)", + "Inventory sections B and C span packages/cli, packages/fresh, plugins/workers plus a new lint gate — multi-PR by construction" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1320, + "title": "deps: collapse to a single Zod instance — blocked on @ag-ui/core hard ^3 and kvdex", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "internals", + "rationale": "Genuinely relevant to typed foundations (a split Zod identity is what produced #1249/#1250), but the issue is labelled status:blocked and its own body documents that neither route is available: @ag-ui/core@0.0.52 hard-pins zod ^3.22.4 and kvdex 3.6.7 is the latest release. Admitting a blocked issue would create an unclosable row.", + "evidence": [ + "Issue labels include status:blocked; body lists three unmet watch signals", + "Body: '@ag-ui/core@0.0.52 hard-depends on zod: ^3.22.4 — no || ^4'", + "Body: 'jsr:@olli/kvdex@3.6.7 also materialises Zod 3, and 3.6.7 is the latest release'" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1335, + "title": "Epic: Scaffold conformance — generated surfaces match current docs, exports and idiomatic usage", + "currentMilestone": "Backlog / Triage", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "internals", + "rationale": "Referenced by 0.0.7's #1354, #1355 and #1358, so it looks like a dependency — but the direction is the reverse: this umbrella waits on those issues, it does not gate them. Its own acceptance demands a machine-readable inventory of every scaffold variant plus a published-canary conformance smoke and a measured unfamiliar-agent run. That is a release program, not a 0.0.7 row.", + "evidence": [ + "#1335 body: 'Current specialized issues (#1328 and frontend modernization) land before their rows are marked complete here'", + "#1335 body closes with 'This is an umbrella. No implementation PR should close it directly.'", + "#1354/#1355/#1358 reference #1335 as their parent umbrella, not as a prerequisite" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1362, + "title": "fix(scaffold/service): generated services have no internal layering — the v1 router template teaches ORM-in-handler and `deno task test` fails on an empty tree", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "The most tempting non-auth candidate: it targets the same generated-service surface as 0.0.7's #1262/#1263 and one sliver is verifiably real on baseline (a freshly scaffolded service's `deno task test` runs `deno test -A src/` against a tree with no test module). But as scoped it is a consumer-facing folder-vocabulary redesign across the scaffolder, templates, add-handler, and docs — large, and it would displace the SDK/CLI seam work. NOTE FOR OWNER: the `test` task sliver alone is a small carve-out that could ride the existing 0.0.7 scaffold cluster if desired; I am not proposing the issue as written.", + "evidence": [ + "packages/cli/src/kernel/templates/service/generate-service-deno-json.ts:65 — `test: 'deno test -A src/'`, read on baseline; the scaffolder creates no test module", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/service/scaffolder.ts:39-49 — only serviceDir/src/routers are created; no domain/application/ports/adapters/tests directories", + "#1362 Target contract: a seven-row collapsible folder vocabulary plus generator and docs changes — multi-day scope" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1365, + "title": "fix(sagas): publish receipts are discardable and the publisher silently falls back to 127.0.0.1:8092", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Genuinely P0 and well-evidenced, but it belongs to the 0.0.8 runtime-plugins cluster (#1366/#1367/#1369/#1370/#979) and touches sagas/workers runtime, not the typed-extension/generation surfaces 0.0.7 is named for; admitting one member of that cluster without the others leaves the composed silent-drop chain only half repaired.", + "evidence": [ + "#1365 evidence: plugins/sagas/src/runtime/saga-publisher.ts:295-307 fallback plus plugins/workers/src/cli/official-sample-configuration.ts:393-403 discarded receipt", + "#1365 lists adjacent open issues #1326/#1329/#1325/#979 — the defect is composed across the sagas/streams/triggers cluster, all outside 0.0.7" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1366, + "title": "fix(plugins): every declareHealthChecks returns only the API resource", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Aspire/plugin health-surface defect with no overlap with any 0.0.7 issue and no 0.0.7 issue blocking on it; part of the 0.0.8 runtime-plugins cluster.", + "evidence": [ + "Cross-reference sweep of all 62 open 0.0.7 issue bodies: no reference to #1366" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1367, + "title": "fix(streams): STREAMS_DATA_DIR is set by nothing the framework generates, so \"durable streams\" is always in-memory", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Real durability defect but confined to plugins/streams + Aspire generation; no 0.0.7 issue references or depends on it.", + "evidence": [ + "Cross-reference sweep of all 62 open 0.0.7 issue bodies: no reference to #1367" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1372, + "title": "test(e2e): the merge-readiness gate probes API health only — background children and streams go unverified", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "internals", + "rationale": "Tempting as release-hygiene, but it verifies the 0.0.8 runtime-plugin behaviours (#1365/#1366/#1367), not 0.0.7 content; the 0.0.7 gate work is already covered by #1616/#1604/#1601/#1557.", + "evidence": [ + "#1372 title scope: background children, streams, saga compensation state — all 0.0.8 subjects", + "0.0.7 already carries #1616, #1604, #1601, #1557 as its test-capability slices" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1382, + "title": "fix(scaffold): the generated service ships `/api` unprotected and a framework test codifies public API routes as correct", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Tempting because it is P0 and touches the same scaffold templates as 0.0.7's correction cluster, but its Target contract requires #1383's seam plus a new authenticator, and it changes `defineService` to error on a missing `auth` option — a breaking public-surface redesign larger than any 0.0.7 scaffold slice.", + "evidence": [ + "#1382 Target contract §2: \"netscript service add emits the opt-in form by default: an authenticator wired from @netscript/plugin-auth's remote session-verifying AuthenticatorPort (#1383)\"", + "packages/cli/src/kernel/adapters/service/scaffolder.ts:39-49 — the scaffolder creates only serviceDir/src/routers; the auth wiring it would need has no generation site today" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1383, + "title": "fix(plugin): `createPluginService` has no auth seam, so every first-party plugin API is unguardable by construction", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "The enabler for the whole 0.0.8 auth pack (#1382/#1384/#1386/#1387/#1388 all consume it) and it needs a remote session-verifying AuthenticatorPort that does not exist in the repo; admitting it imports five more issues and displaces the SDK/CLI seam work the milestone is named for.", + "evidence": [ + "#1383 evidence: `grep -rn 'withAuthn|withAuthz' packages plugins` outside packages/service returns zero matches; five first-party plugin services listed as unguarded callers", + "#1383 evidence: the only AuthenticatorPort implementations are static-credential, trusted-header, kv-oauth, workos, better-auth — no remote session verifier exists to wire" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1386, + "title": "fix(service): the default CORS policy is `origin: '*'`, which makes credentialed browser calls impossible", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "fixes", + "rationale": "Coupled to the browser cookie-topology decision that #1352 explicitly defers to the auth pack; landing a CORS default change without that decision would pre-commit the topology 0.0.7 chose not to decide.", + "evidence": [ + "#1352 Target contract §5: cookie/session transport excluded because the cross-origin + `__Host-` + `origin:'*'` combination is proven unworkable — \"the topology decision is the auth pack's\"", + "#1385 Boundaries: \"Do not change the CORS default or decide the browser topology — #1386 owns both\"" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1387, + "title": "feat(service): handlers receive `principal` as an untyped bag entry and no procedure can declare a policy", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "features", + "rationale": "Would define a procedure policy shape concurrently with #1348/#1466, which are ratifying `NetScriptProcedureMeta.policy` as the single policy shape in 0.0.7; admitting it invites exactly the duplicate-dialect outcome the RFC exists to prevent. Correct order is 0.0.7 ratifies, 0.0.8 consumes.", + "evidence": [ + "#1348 Acceptance: \"`NetScriptProcedureMeta.policy` is ratified as the single policy shape\"; Summary: ratify \"before #934 invents its own policy shape\"", + "0.0.7 already carries #1466 [sdk-client S2] `feat(sdk): define NetScriptProcedureMeta without erasing contract errors`" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + }, + { + "number": 1388, + "title": "test(e2e): the scaffold runtime auth gate proves only that an unauthenticated request succeeds", + "currentMilestone": "0.0.8", + "admissionPredicate": "none", + "recommendation": "exclude", + "suggestedLane": "internals", + "rationale": "A verification issue whose subject (a guarded generated service) does not exist until #1382/#1383 land; it cannot be truthfully closed inside 0.0.7.", + "evidence": [ + "#1382/#1383 remain in 0.0.8 and are not proposed for admission; the gate has nothing to assert against on baseline" + ], + "blocksTargetIssues": [], + "ownerRatificationRequired": false, + "decidedByThisRun": false + } + ], + "edges": [ + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1350", + "fromIssue": 1348, + "toIssue": 1350, + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": "RFC 0001 Stage 0 (#1348) must accept the RFC and align #1349-#1353 bodies before Stage 1a implements; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1273-1274." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1466", + "fromIssue": 1348, + "toIssue": 1466, + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": "Stage 1b owner is \"selected in Stage 0; do not file in this run\"; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1275." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1349", + "fromIssue": 1348, + "toIssue": 1349, + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": "Stage 2 scope at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1276 differs from the filed #1349 acceptance in four places; Stage 0 owns the realignment." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1351", + "fromIssue": 1348, + "toIssue": 1351, + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": "Stage 3 at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1277 reassigns the deprecate-no-op-options scope and makes the oRPC family move a separate decision." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1352", + "fromIssue": 1348, + "toIssue": 1352, + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": "Stage 4 at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1278 adds scaffold choice and bans the cookie carve-out the issue still records." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1353", + "fromIssue": 1348, + "toIssue": 1353, + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": "Stage 5 at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1279 reverses the filed acceptance from \"ship a trace contribution\" to \"prove the transport owns trace injection\"." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1467", + "fromIssue": 1348, + "toIssue": 1467, + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": "Stage 6 is \"new child after RFC acceptance\"; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1280." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1348", + "to": "issue:1093", + "fromIssue": 1348, + "toIssue": 1093, + "kind": "rfc-prerequisite", + "evidence": "Stage 7 at rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1281 defines the generic-discovery exit condition the issue body predates." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1350", + "to": "issue:1466", + "fromIssue": 1350, + "toIssue": 1466, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "Stage 1b must initialize NetScriptProcedureMeta \"without re-erasing Stage 1a types\"; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1275." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1466", + "to": "issue:1349", + "fromIssue": 1466, + "toIssue": 1349, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "The normative SdkClientProcedureDescriptor consumed by every contribution embeds Readonly; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:410-413." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1466", + "to": "issue:1352", + "fromIssue": 1466, + "toIssue": 1352, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "#1352 acceptance reads procedure policy metadata, which #1466 defines." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1351", + "fromIssue": 1349, + "toIssue": 1351, + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": "#1351 Boundaries: \"If #1349 lands first, this issue must additionally prove no contribution can reach the method decision.\"" + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1352", + "fromIssue": 1349, + "toIssue": 1352, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "#1352 is the first dogfood consumer of the contribution chain #1349 creates; #1352 Summary." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1353", + "fromIssue": 1349, + "toIssue": 1353, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "Stage 5 proves a property of the seam Stage 2 builds; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1276,1279." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1467", + "fromIssue": 1349, + "toIssue": 1467, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "#1467 ships a contribution through the chain #1349 exposes." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1349", + "to": "issue:1093", + "fromIssue": 1349, + "toIssue": 1093, + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": "The RFC-added sdkClients-collection half of Stage 7 cannot land until the contribution seam exists; rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1156-1160." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1352", + "to": "issue:1467", + "fromIssue": 1352, + "toIssue": 1467, + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": "#1467 is the non-auth counterpart proof and reuses the auth dogfood composition order; both edit the same SDK docs page." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1243", + "to": "issue:1352", + "fromIssue": 1243, + "toIssue": 1352, + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": "#1352 swaps the first-party CLI off raw fetch at the same call sites whose default URL #1243 repairs (auth-plugin-command.ts:87)." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1293", + "to": "issue:1112", + "fromIssue": 1293, + "toIssue": 1112, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "#1112 own text: \"Until this lands, #1112 example must document only what ships today\"; #1293 opening paragraph." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1355", + "to": "issue:1357", + "fromIssue": 1355, + "toIssue": 1357, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "#1357 emission target is the app-side client/query wiring #1355 regenerates." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1355", + "to": "issue:1354", + "fromIssue": 1355, + "toIssue": 1354, + "kind": "requires", + "evidence": "#1354 resource slice consumes the client/query wiring #1355 owns." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1357", + "to": "issue:1354", + "fromIssue": 1357, + "toIssue": 1354, + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": "The new verb should generate against a repaired ui:add emission, not codify the broken one." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1378", + "to": "issue:1542", + "fromIssue": 1378, + "toIssue": 1542, + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": "Widening quality:gate roots to published packages is only safe once the scanner is export-aware and allowances are registered." + }, + { + "from": "issue:1451", + "to": "issue:1455", + "fromIssue": 1451, + "toIssue": 1455, + "kind": "cross-epic-order", + "evidence": "#1455 registry payload map consumes the generated-registry metadata plumbing #1451 introduces." + } + ], + "waves": [ + { + "index": 0, + "mergeBarrier": true, + "leafGroups": [ + "ci-diff-range-base-sha-barrier" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1564" + ], + "issues": [ + 1564 + ] + }, + { + "index": 1, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board", + "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "comparison-docs-programme", + "sdk-jsr-landing-verification" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1243", + "issue:1262", + "issue:1263", + "issue:1348", + "issue:1378", + "issue:1502", + "issue:1545", + "issue:1551", + "issue:1561", + "issue:1563", + "issue:1588", + "issue:1606", + "issue:1621" + ], + "issues": [ + 1243, + 1262, + 1263, + 1348, + 1378, + 1502, + 1545, + 1551, + 1561, + 1563, + 1588, + 1606, + 1621 + ] + }, + { + "index": 2, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "prisma-mysql-adapter-surface", + "app-service-client-wiring", + "sdk-typed-error-channel", + "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "quality-scan-root-coverage", + "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1293", + "issue:1350", + "issue:1355", + "issue:1358", + "issue:1360", + "issue:1542", + "issue:1611", + "issue:1613" + ], + "issues": [ + 1293, + 1350, + 1355, + 1358, + 1360, + 1542, + 1611, + 1613 + ] + }, + { + "index": 3, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "sdk-procedure-metadata", + "workers-job-policy-metadata", + "prisma-mysql-honest-example", + "ui-add-page-island-repair", + "reference-export-drift-gate", + "package-gate-honesty" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1112", + "issue:1296", + "issue:1357", + "issue:1451", + "issue:1466", + "issue:1604", + "issue:1618", + "issue:1622" + ], + "issues": [ + 1112, + 1296, + 1357, + 1451, + 1466, + 1604, + 1618, + 1622 + ] + }, + { + "index": 4, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "sdk-client-contribution-seam", + "ui-resource-slice-generator", + "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "leak-check-process-descendants", + "jsdoc-example-compile-gate" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1349", + "issue:1354", + "issue:1429", + "issue:1448", + "issue:1533", + "issue:1598", + "issue:1619", + "issue:1620", + "issue:1623" + ], + "issues": [ + 1349, + 1354, + 1429, + 1448, + 1533, + 1598, + 1619, + 1620, + 1623 + ] + }, + { + "index": 5, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "sdk-auth-contribution-dogfood", + "workers-job-payload-typing", + "sdk-transport-policy-consolidation", + "sdk-trace-ownership-proof", + "fresh-defer-test-capability" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1351", + "issue:1352", + "issue:1353", + "issue:1455", + "issue:1557", + "issue:1601" + ], + "issues": [ + 1351, + 1352, + 1353, + 1455, + 1557, + 1601 + ] + }, + { + "index": 6, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "sdk-locale-contribution-proof", + "aspire-agent-resource-inventory", + "plugin-discovery-contribution-references", + "sdk-cached-entry-swr" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1093", + "issue:1306", + "issue:1461", + "issue:1467" + ], + "issues": [ + 1093, + 1306, + 1461, + 1467 + ] + }, + { + "index": 7, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "plugin-service-context-factory", + "workers-execution-progress", + "sdk-browser-safe-entrypoints", + "scaffold-route-emission-and-gating" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1452", + "issue:1462", + "issue:1481", + "issue:1592", + "issue:1616" + ], + "issues": [ + 1452, + 1462, + 1481, + 1592, + 1616 + ] + }, + { + "index": 8, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "fresh-client-navigation-coordinator", + "ai-openai-responses-mapper", + "fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair", + "cross-package-dependency-declarations" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1543", + "issue:1590", + "issue:1591", + "issue:1609", + "issue:1610" + ], + "issues": [ + 1543, + 1590, + 1591, + 1609, + 1610 + ] + }, + { + "index": 9, + "mergeBarrier": false, + "leafGroups": [ + "fresh-ai-chat-response-options", + "cli-deploy-verb-surface" + ], + "nodeIds": [ + "issue:1458", + "issue:1544" + ], + "issues": [ + 1458, + 1544 + ] + } + ], + "leafGroups": [ + { + "key": "ci-diff-range-base-sha-barrier", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1564 + ], + "wave": 0, + "rationale": "MERGE BARRIER. Every pre-merge gate that computes a diff range from pull_request.base.sha can report success having scanned zero lines of the PR under review, and degrades with PR age. With 45 leaves merging direct-to-main across ten waves, pre-merge gate checks 3 (no new ignore/cast in the diff) and 6 (changed-file audit on docs-lane PRs) are unreliable until this lands. It must merge before any other leaf in the milestone.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1564 + ] + }, + { + "key": "rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1348 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "RFC 0001 Stage 0: owner ratification, FCP questions, and realignment of #1349-#1353 bodies to the merged RFC. Tracking issue - no implementation PR may carry a closing keyword on it.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1348 + ] + }, + { + "key": "rfc-plugin-cli-contribution", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1502 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "RFC document + PLAN-EVAL for the plugin CLI command contribution seam; proposes its own implementation epic.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-typed-error-channel", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1350 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "packages/sdk/src/client/errors.ts + packages/contracts contract-primitives.ts:81; RFC Stage 1a.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-procedure-metadata", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1466 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "NetScriptProcedureMeta vocabulary; RFC Stage 1b. Must not re-erase Stage 1a types.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-client-contribution-seam", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1349 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 2. Largest slice in the release; body contradicts the merged RFC in four places and must be realigned by Stage 0 first.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1349 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-transport-policy-consolidation", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1351 + ], + "wave": 5, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 3. One owned transport-policy function; the oRPC family version move is a separate owner decision.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1351 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-auth-contribution-dogfood", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1352 + ], + "wave": 5, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 4. Auth-core bearer factory + CLI transport swap; cookie transport explicitly out.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1352 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-trace-ownership-proof", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1353 + ], + "wave": 5, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 5, re-scoped: prove the transport keeps the only final trace injection and rejects contributor ownership.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-locale-contribution-proof", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1467 + ], + "wave": 6, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 6 non-auth proof.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "plugin-discovery-contribution-references", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1093 + ], + "wave": 6, + "rationale": "RFC Stage 7. Filed half (move callee-to-axis to plugins) is one PR; the RFC-added sdkClients-collection half needs #1349 and is not in the issue body.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1093 + ] + }, + { + "key": "prisma-mysql-adapter-surface", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1293 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Export PrismaMySqlAdapter + design the connection-error hook as API; surface-diff gate applies.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "prisma-mysql-honest-example", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1112 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "Rewrite the MySQL example against the surface #1293 ships. Blocked until then by the issue own text.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "legacy-port-pin-sweep", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1243 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Dead 4437 pins in the auth CLI, the streams manifest, and copy-official-plugin-test-support.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "scaffold-generated-output-correctness", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1262, + 1263, + 1588 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Generated project output defects sharing one scaffold.runtime verdict: placebo seed, 500-instead-of-404 by-id handler, unreachable SQLite provider parsers.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "app-service-client-wiring", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1355, + 1360 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Grouped because both edit the same ServiceShowcaseLab template - separate PRs would collide.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1355 + ] + }, + { + "key": "ui-add-page-island-repair", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1357 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "Repair ui:add page --island emission. Split from #1354 deliberately: repair and new verb need separate review.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1357 + ] + }, + { + "key": "ui-resource-slice-generator", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1354 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "New resource-slice generator verb. Large; the three optional flags are independently testable and are split candidates.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1354 + ] + }, + { + "key": "design-registry-catalog-drift-gate", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1358 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Gallery lists 50 of 66 registry items; add the comparison gate.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "aspire-agent-resource-inventory", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1306 + ], + "wave": 6, + "rationale": "Four acceptance rows are ALTERNATIVE remedies; scope must be chosen before assignment.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1306 + ] + }, + { + "key": "workers-job-policy-metadata", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1451 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "Project job-policy seam consumed by the generated registry. The seam is unnamed in the issue and has no baseline candidate.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1451 + ] + }, + { + "key": "workers-job-payload-typing", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1455 + ], + "wave": 5, + "rationale": "Registry map + JobTriggerInput + enqueueJob binding. Issue stated baseline is stale: JobDefinition already carries TPayload.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1455 + ] + }, + { + "key": "plugin-service-context-factory", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1452 + ], + "wave": 7, + "rationale": "Publish the PluginServiceContext host factory and consume it from scaffold output.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1452 + ] + }, + { + "key": "workers-execution-progress", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1592 + ], + "wave": 7, + "rationale": "Typed progress on the published ExecutionRecord + durable stream; replay/coalescing needs its own design decision.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1592 + ] + }, + { + "key": "ai-mcp-pool-isolation", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1448 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "Failure-isolated MCP pool startup + cancellation. Snapshot API and cancellation plumbing are independently shippable.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1448 + ] + }, + { + "key": "ai-openai-responses-mapper", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1591 + ], + "wave": 8, + "rationale": "Typed OpenAI Responses mapper on @netscript/ai.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "fresh-ai-chat-response-options", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1458 + ], + "wave": 9, + "rationale": "Awaited durable chat completion options on @netscript/fresh/ai.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "fresh-client-navigation-coordinator", + "lane": "features", + "issues": [ + 1590 + ], + "wave": 8, + "rationale": "Four bundled behaviours; only honest as one coordinator module, otherwise split.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1590 + ] + }, + { + "key": "fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1609, + 1610 + ], + "wave": 8, + "rationale": "Both are packages/fresh typed-route/managed-form defects on one surface.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1598, + 1619, + 1620, + 1623 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "Four small packages/sdk cache-surface repairs sharing one review; grouped to avoid four micro-PRs. #1637 joins here if admitted.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-cached-entry-swr", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1461 + ], + "wave": 6, + "rationale": "Remedy undecided (doc correction vs new queryEntry API); the choice moves the lane.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1461 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-browser-safe-entrypoints", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1462 + ], + "wave": 7, + "rationale": "Export/side-effect restructure; the bundle-content assertion needs a gate that does not exist yet.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1462 + ] + }, + { + "key": "scaffold-route-emission-and-gating", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1481, + 1616 + ], + "wave": 7, + "rationale": "Both change what routes the scaffold emits and how the build gates them.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1616 + ] + }, + { + "key": "cross-package-dependency-declarations", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1543 + ], + "wave": 8, + "rationale": "Undeclared @netscript/plugin-streams-core imports in two published manifests. Small; may ride an adjacent workers PR.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "cli-deploy-verb-surface", + "lane": "fixes", + "issues": [ + 1544 + ], + "wave": 9, + "rationale": "Route or unadvertise `emit`. Product call, not a code call.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "reference-export-drift-gate", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1296 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "Machine-readable omissions + fresh-ui reference repair + maintainer runbook + gate wiring. Row 1 (contracts JSDoc subpath) is already satisfied on baseline.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1296 + ] + }, + { + "key": "quality-scan-allowance-rail", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1378, + 1545 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "MUST be one PR: #1545 registration must precede #1378 rule or the gate is red day one, while #1545 own test box needs that rule to exist.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1378, + 1545 + ] + }, + { + "key": "quality-scan-root-coverage", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1542 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Widen quality:gate roots to published packages. Sequenced after the allowance rail.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "leak-check-process-descendants", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1429 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "leak-check cannot see orphaned Aspire descendants, so it reports clean through a real leak.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "jsdoc-example-compile-gate", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1533 + ], + "wave": 4, + "rationale": "Compile JSDoc @example blocks so a published JSR reference cannot import a missing module.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "fresh-defer-test-capability", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1557, + 1601 + ], + "wave": 5, + "rationale": "Both are the deferred-coordinator client-bundle gate; #1601 determinism must be fixed before #1557 asserts on it.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1557 + ] + }, + { + "key": "harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1561, + 1563, + 1621 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Three acceptance-evidence / verdict-extraction defects in the same tool family.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1611, + 1613 + ], + "wave": 2, + "rationale": "Formal evaluator dispatch claim + refused-command reporting in one workflow surface.", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "package-gate-honesty", + "lane": "internals", + "issues": [ + 1604, + 1618, + 1622 + ], + "wave": 3, + "rationale": "Three packages whose prescribed quality gate is dishonest (always-red cli tests, fmt aborted by a fixture, an unpinnable mcp constant).", + "splitCandidates": [] + }, + { + "key": "comparison-docs-programme", + "lane": "docs", + "issues": [ + 1551 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "17 deliverables. Only methodology page + one case study + migration placeholder is a 0.0.7-sized leaf; the rest needs its own issues.", + "splitCandidates": [ + 1551 + ] + }, + { + "key": "sdk-jsr-landing-verification", + "lane": "docs", + "issues": [ + 1606 + ], + "wave": 1, + "rationale": "Observational: closes by a recorded observation of the published JSR page, never by a PR.", + "splitCandidates": [] + } + ], + "externalDependenciesSatisfied": [ + { + "for": 1533, + "issue": 1374, + "note": "\"#1374 owns fenced code blocks under docs/site/** and lands first\" - #1374 is CLOSED in 0.0.6, so the predecessor is already satisfied." + }, + { + "for": 1622, + "issue": 1615, + "note": "#1615 CLOSED in 0.0.6." + }, + { + "for": 1611, + "issue": 1594, + "note": "#1594 CLOSED in 0.0.6." + }, + { + "for": 1598, + "issue": 1589, + "note": "#1589 CLOSED in 0.0.6." + }, + { + "for": 1429, + "issue": 1333, + "note": "#1333 CLOSED in 0.0.5." + } + ], + "staleOrFalsePositiveFindings": [ + { + "issue": 1296, + "scope": "partial", + "claim": "Acceptance row 1: \"packages/contracts JSDoc examples import from the root where the documented symbols live on the /query subpath.\"", + "finding": "Already satisfied on baseline. baseContract, BaseContractRoute, BaseContractOutputRoute and OffsetPaginationQuerySchema are all re-exported from the root via packages/contracts/src/public/mod.ts:2-6,65, and the JSDoc examples at contract-primitives.ts:72,112,144 import from the root correctly. The other four rows remain live." + }, + { + "issue": 1357, + "scope": "partial", + "claim": "Acceptance box: \"UiAddCommandInput declares route/island/query/app.\"", + "finding": "Already satisfied on baseline: packages/cli/src/public/features/ui/add/add-ui-input.ts:1-11 declares projectRoot, app, registryRoot, theme, force, route, island, query. The emission defect the issue exists for is unaffected." + }, + { + "issue": 1455, + "scope": "stale-premise", + "claim": "Stated baseline: \"build() returns JobDefinition with no payload.\"", + "finding": "Stale. packages/plugin-workers-core/src/builders/job-builder.ts:80 already returns JobDefinition. The live scope is the registry job-id-to-payload map, JobTriggerInput, and the enqueueJob binding; the body should be re-scoped before dispatch." + }, + { + "issue": 1355, + "scope": "stale-citations", + "claim": "Every file:line citation in the body.", + "finding": "The cited template packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/lib/example-service.ts.template no longer exists; the equivalent now lives at assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/. The defect is identical, the citations are not." + }, + { + "issue": 1619, + "scope": "stale-citation", + "claim": "\"cache-telemetry_test.ts:237 pins fail-loud behaviour.\"", + "finding": "No packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry_test.ts exists on baseline (only cache-provider_test.ts). The pinning test location is unverified." + }, + { + "issue": 1349, + "scope": "contradicted-by-rfc", + "claim": "Acceptance rows demanding public export of createHttpClientLink/ClientLinkPort/ClientLinkCallOptions, composition of upstream interceptor/plugin arrays, and removal of port/timeout.", + "finding": "All three contradict the merged RFC 0001: :491-497 keeps the adapter ports private under src/internal/client-contributions/, :1276 says \"No upstream callback arrays\", :1224 keeps port/timeout accepted-and-deprecated and :1277 reassigns that to #1351. Implementing the body as written would violate ratified doctrine." + }, + { + "issue": 1353, + "scope": "contradicted-by-rfc", + "claim": "Acceptance: \"traceContextContribution() ships as an SdkClientContribution\" and \"createHttpClientLink contains no trace-header authorship\".", + "finding": "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1279 reverses this into \"prove the transport retains the only final trace injection and rejects contributor ownership of trace headers\", and :1476-1481 records the contribution form as the rejected alternative. Body must be rewritten before any implementer reads it." + }, + { + "issue": 1352, + "scope": "contradicted-by-rfc", + "claim": "Cookie-topology carve-out; module path @netscript/plugin-auth/sdk.", + "finding": "The RFC bans cookie transport for this stage, making the carve-out moot, and its example imports @netscript/plugin-auth-core/sdk (:1168). Divergence unrecorded on the issue." + }, + { + "issue": 1351, + "scope": "contradicted-by-rfc", + "claim": "Acceptance: \"deps:latest shows the oRPC family at 1.14.15\".", + "finding": "rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1277 makes the whole-family version move a separate owner decision targeting stable v1.15.0, not 1.14.15." + } + ], + "openUncertainties": [ + { + "issue": 1093, + "uncertainty": "The RFC-added sdkClients-collection obligation is not written into the issue body (body predates the RFC, last substantive text from 2026-08-03), so an implementer reading only the issue would ship half of Stage 7." + }, + { + "issue": 1112, + "uncertainty": "Did not run deno check/tests, so 'every advertised option has observable behavior' is verified only for onConnectionError; other PrismaMySqlOptions fields unaudited." + }, + { + "issue": 1243, + "uncertainty": "Whether an AppHost/appsettings discovery seam (as used by the #1206 aspire-cli adapter) is reachable from this command was not traced; the minimum acceptable fix (fail with a legacy-pin message) is unambiguous, the full resolution path is not." + }, + { + "issue": 1262, + "uncertainty": "Seeding 'at least one representative row per generated model' requires reading the generated Prisma schema (packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/database/schema.prisma.template) or the model metadata at scaffold time — I did not verify that a model list is already available to the template renderer, so the size could be larger than 'small'." + }, + { + "issue": 1263, + "uncertainty": "Acceptance box 2 ('the OpenAPI projection documents the 404') needs the contract template to carry .errors({ NOT_FOUND }); I confirmed no such construct exists in the assets but did not verify that the scaffolded oRPC/OpenAPI projection renders defined errors automatically once declared." + }, + { + "issue": 1293, + "uncertainty": "Did not run `deno doc --lint` or a surface diff; the slow-types row may already be green, which would shrink this issue to export + hook." + }, + { + "issue": 1296, + "uncertainty": "Did not run check-exports-drift.ts, so whether the contracts reference inventory currently advertises non-exports (row 2) is unverified; the issue's own claim about contract-primitives.ts does not hold on baseline." + }, + { + "issue": 1306, + "uncertainty": "Whether the token/detach behaviour is fixable in NetScript at all is unverified — `aspire start` is upstream Aspire CLI (13.4.6), so checkboxes 2 and 3 may be upstream-only and reduce to documenting the detached contract. I could not verify runtime behaviour without launching Aspire, which is out of scope for this audit." + }, + { + "issue": 1348, + "uncertainty": "Whether the owner has formally accepted/amended the envelope and answered Q1/Q2 is not visible in the repo — PR #1390 merged the text but the RFC still lists 11 open questions. Owner disposition status unverified." + }, + { + "issue": 1349, + "uncertainty": "Whether the orchestrator wants the issue body rewritten to the ratified RFC scope before implementation (Stage 0's job on #1348) is undecided; implementing the body as written would violate the merged RFC." + }, + { + "issue": 1350, + "uncertainty": "I did not re-run the cited `deno check` probe (read-only mandate, no builds). Type-level failure is inferred from the signatures, not re-executed." + }, + { + "issue": 1351, + "uncertainty": "Target oRPC version is contradictory: issue acceptance says 1.14.15, ratified RFC:1277 says decide on stable v1.15.0. I did not run deps:latest (read-only), so the current registry stable is unverified." + }, + { + "issue": 1352, + "uncertainty": "Module placement diverges: issue says `@netscript/plugin-auth/sdk`, RFC:1168 example imports `@netscript/plugin-auth-core/sdk`. Also the issue's cookie-topology carve-out is now moot (RFC bans cookie), unrecorded on the issue." + }, + { + "issue": 1353, + "uncertainty": "HARD CONFLICT: the issue body's acceptance ('traceContextContribution() ships as an SdkClientContribution'; 'createHttpClientLink contains no trace-header authorship') is the exact alternative the merged RFC rejects (rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:1476-1481) and reverses (Stage 5, :1279). The issue is still real work but its acceptance list must be rewritten before any implementer reads it; implementing as written would violate ratified RFC 0001. Whether the owner has recorded that rescope on the issue is unverified (issue updated before the RFC merge)." + }, + { + "issue": 1354, + "uncertainty": "The RFC-A (#1348, 0.0.7 epic) contribution-inclusion clause is explicitly NOT a blocker per the issue body, so I recorded no rfc-prerequisite edge — but if the orchestrator wants that clause in scope it becomes one. I did not verify the research/ audit files cited (research/repo-audit/*.md are not present in this worktree)." + }, + { + "issue": 1355, + "uncertainty": "Note: the template moved from the path the issue cites (packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/app/lib/example-service.ts.template no longer exists) to assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/service-query.ts.template — the defect is identical, but every line cite in the issue body is stale. RFC #1348 gates only the optional contribution clause per the body, so no edge recorded." + }, + { + "issue": 1357, + "uncertainty": "One acceptance box is ALREADY satisfied on baseline: packages/cli/src/public/features/ui/add/add-ui-input.ts:1-11 declares projectRoot, app, registryRoot, theme, force, route, island, query — the 'UiAddCommandInput declares route/island/query/app' box needs no work. The rest of the issue is unaffected." + }, + { + "issue": 1358, + "uncertainty": "I counted manifest items by grepping top-level `kind:` (66) rather than evaluating the module, since executing deno was out of scope; the 8-collection claim is unverified beyond the single `collections:` array at registry.manifest.ts:1356." + }, + { + "issue": 1360, + "uncertainty": "File overlap risk with #1355: that issue's acceptance also edits ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template (the invalidation call sites at :93 and :135). If both land in the same wave, sequence them or merge the two template edits into one PR to avoid a conflict. The 'migration note' acceptance box is docs prose and may need a docs-lane co-landing." + }, + { + "issue": 1378, + "uncertainty": "Not verified whether `deno doc --json` over each package `exports` map is fast enough to run inside the PR gate; no executed measurement (read-only audit, no task runs allowed)." + }, + { + "issue": 1429, + "uncertainty": "Could not reproduce the leak (running Aspire/e2e is prohibited here); the three-condition reclaim rule the issue prescribes is unimplemented, and I could not verify whether Deno can enumerate PPID/cwd portably on Windows without a new dependency." + }, + { + "issue": 1451, + "uncertainty": "The issue does not name the seam (workers plugin config file vs. netscript.config vs. job-definition module), and no candidate exists on baseline." + }, + { + "issue": 1453, + "uncertainty": "The defect is probably real in whatever repo owns `tools/migration-loc` (the issue quotes a concrete Windows/Deno 2.9.5 stack trace), but nothing in this worktree can be changed to satisfy its acceptance. Move is on the release-boundary ground that no 0.0.7 slice here can tick a single box — not on size or priority." + }, + { + "issue": 1455, + "uncertainty": "The issue's stated baseline (build() returns JobDefinition with no payload) is stale — payload params already exist on the type. The remaining scope is the registry map, JobTriggerInput, and enqueueJob binding; the issue body should be re-scoped before implementation." + }, + { + "issue": 1458, + "uncertainty": "I did not read the upstream transport's toDurableChatSessionResponse signature, so whether it already accepts mode/waitUntil (making this pure forwarding) or needs a transport change in plugins/ai is unverified — that determines whether this stays a one-package change." + }, + { + "issue": 1461, + "uncertainty": "Whether the intended outcome is a doc correction or a new published queryEntry() API is undecided in the issue; that choice moves it between fixes and features." + }, + { + "issue": 1462, + "uncertainty": "I did not trace query-factory.ts / KvCacheStore.resolve() line-by-line, so the exact seam where hasCacheProvider() flips the code path is taken from the issue body. Whether removing the root re-export is a breaking change for existing 0.0.6 consumers is unassessed." + }, + { + "issue": 1466, + "uncertainty": "Issue body is a terse post-RFC stub (6 acceptance lines) with no file citations; the concrete surface must be read out of RFC §'Procedure metadata' (rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:347-398) rather than the issue." + }, + { + "issue": 1467, + "uncertainty": "Terse post-RFC stub with no file citations; concrete acceptance (composition order, retries, cancellation, cache keys, redaction) must be read from rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md:830-946 and :1089-1133. Docs acceptance ('auth and non-auth examples') overlaps #1352's docs deliverable — possible PR collision on the same SDK docs page." + }, + { + "issue": 1481, + "uncertainty": "The issue's own non-gating note says it was never established whether /design is intended to reach production users; that product decision gates the mechanism choice (structural exclusion vs runtime refusal vs opt-in flag) and is not answered anywhere I could read. Also unverified: whether the scaffolded Vite build even has a mechanism to exclude a route group from the build graph." + }, + { + "issue": 1502, + "uncertainty": "Whether #904-#908 should be superseded outright or re-scoped as consumers of the new seam is a decision for the RFC; not determinable from code." + }, + { + "issue": 1533, + "uncertainty": "Did not execute doc:lint or the snippet gate; the claim that deno doc --lint ignores example bodies is taken from the issue's recorded evidence, not re-run here." + }, + { + "issue": 1542, + "uncertainty": "Whether widening `quality:scan` to all published packages leaves the gate green is unverified — running `quality:scan:repo` was out of scope for this read-only audit; PR #1570's triage note records one still-actionable A8 finding at `packages/plugin-streams-core/src/application/durable-stream-producer-supervisor.ts:501`." + }, + { + "issue": 1543, + "uncertainty": "Could not run `deno task publish:dry-run` (read-only audit), so whether publish rejects, warns, or silently accepts the undeclared import — the issue's own first acceptance row — remains unknown. If it silently accepts, the issue downgrades to consistency and may be closable on that evidence." + }, + { + "issue": 1544, + "uncertainty": "The route-vs-unadvertise decision is a product call not resolvable from code; note `plan`'s description already reads 'Emit or preflight deployment artifacts', which favours unadvertising." + }, + { + "issue": 1545, + "uncertainty": "Whether the packages/fresh allowance was removed by a real type fix or by code deletion — I did not trace the commit that dropped it, so the 8-vs-7 delta's cause is unverified." + }, + { + "issue": 1551, + "uncertainty": "Whether the EIS-Chat dashboard route is accessible to the implementing lane at all is unverified; if not, the first case study has no subject." + }, + { + "issue": 1557, + "uncertainty": "The issue body must be re-baselined before work starts — its 'What is missing today' section predates the playwright gate. Whether the deferred-layer scenario can reuse the existing route-binding-browser fixture harness, or needs a new scaffolded fixture, is unverified." + }, + { + "issue": 1561, + "uncertainty": "Acceptance box 3 also requires a `netscript-pr` skill statement; I did not check whether `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` already covers the empty/omitted-block case." + }, + { + "issue": 1563, + "uncertainty": "Acceptance box 2 (distinguish 'agent emitted no verdict' from 'could not be parsed') needs a new `verdict_source` value; I did not audit every consumer of that marker field for the added enum case." + }, + { + "issue": 1564, + "uncertainty": "Four of the five consumers are recorded as unaudited in the issue itself; the blast radius beyond code-quality.yml:39 is stated, not proven. Boundary with #1403 (which hardens exactly one consumer) must be settled before dispatch so the two do not collide on code-quality.yml." + }, + { + "issue": 1588, + "uncertainty": "The issue's expected output uses SQLITE_URI with a plain fallback; generate-prisma-config.ts:28-31 already derives `_URI` and a `file:./.db` fallback, so the trim is mechanical — but I could not confirm by scaffolding (running init was out of scope), only by reading the two generators." + }, + { + "issue": 1590, + "uncertainty": "The consumer module apps/dashboard/lib/client-nav.ts lives in the EIS repo and is not readable here, so the exact semantics to absorb are taken from the issue body only. Whether Fresh 2.3.3 upstream has since changed ordering behaviour was not checked." + }, + { + "issue": 1591, + "uncertainty": "Whether the retry/no-replay-after-output behaviour the issue asks to preserve is exercised by existing tests is unverified — I did not read tanstack-chat-client.ts." + }, + { + "issue": 1598, + "uncertainty": "Exact wording is an API-adjacent decision; no existing test asserts the message text, so the new test file is unspecified." + }, + { + "issue": 1601, + "uncertainty": "Whether the fix should pin vite through packages/fresh/deno.json imports or pre-provision it in gate setup is undecided in the issue; the catalog law (catalog: is npm-only) may constrain the option chosen. Related open issue #1604 covers the same determinism class for packages/cli and may want the same convention." + }, + { + "issue": 1604, + "uncertainty": "Did not run the suite (read-only audit), so the exact failing count (3) and that no fourth cwd-sensitive test exists is unverified — a repo-wide audit of bare relative Deno.readTextFile/stat calls under packages/cli should be part of the fix." + }, + { + "issue": 1606, + "uncertainty": "Observational by construction — cannot be closed by a PR. Did not fetch jsr.io, so whether @netscript/sdk@0.0.6 is actually published and how the page renders is unverified; the issue may be dischargeable immediately rather than after a 0.0.7 publish." + }, + { + "issue": 1610, + "uncertainty": "I could not reproduce the exact `path.channel` compile-pass by type-checking (running deno check is outside my read-only remit). By reading alone, the #178 `EmptySegment = {}` fix (types.ts:17-24, contract.test.ts:238-260) removes the index signature for STATIC segments, so `{} & {project:string}` should already error on an unknown key; yet define-partial.test.tsx:274 indexes `['channel']` and is expected to type-check, which implies an index signature survives somewhere on that path. The residual EmptyRecord instances I can point to concretely are the empty-pattern branch and the default TPath. Whoever takes this must first re-run the issue's repro and record which construction actually yields `never`." + }, + { + "issue": 1611, + "uncertainty": "Acceptance box 2 demands an executed refusal test under a real claimed tuple; I could not run it (no test execution permitted), so only the code-level gap is proven here." + }, + { + "issue": 1613, + "uncertainty": "The N2 reply must not recursively dispatch; I did not verify which exact prefix the production predicate treats as a command first token, so the safe reply shape is unconfirmed." + }, + { + "issue": 1616, + "uncertainty": "Whether adding a permanent /examples/orders/[id] page to every scaffolded project is wanted product-wise is not settled in the issue; the narrower generator-shape assertion is offered as an alternative." + }, + { + "issue": 1618, + "uncertainty": "I could not execute the wrapper to confirm the exit-1 reproduction or the negative control (test/build runs prohibited); whether `--exclude` alone stops deno's *config discovery* rather than only file selection is therefore unproven, which is precisely what option 1 vs option 3 in the issue turns on." + }, + { + "issue": 1619, + "uncertainty": "The issue cites cache-telemetry_test.ts:237 as pinning fail-loud, but no packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-telemetry_test.ts exists on baseline (only cache-provider_test.ts) — the pinning test's location is unverified." + }, + { + "issue": 1620, + "uncertainty": "Which of the three proposed mechanisms is intended is undecided in the issue; option 1 changes published types and would flip the lane to features." + }, + { + "issue": 1621, + "uncertainty": "The issue offers three mutually exclusive remedies (actionable message / documented no-op / checkbox issue templates) and does not choose; option 3 changes what close-gate enforces repo-wide and would not fit this leaf." + }, + { + "issue": 1622, + "uncertainty": "I did not execute the mutation experiment (setting the constant to 5) that the issue reports, so the '8 fixtures still pass' claim is taken from the issue's evaluator, not independently reproduced here." + }, + { + "issue": 1623, + "uncertainty": "The third acceptance box is an open-ended sweep of packages/sdk/src/ports/** — I read cache-store.ts only, so the number of other superseded doc comments is unverified." + } + ] +} diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9a20967b47 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/step0-synthesis.md @@ -0,0 +1,204 @@ +# Step 0 synthesis — milestone 0.0.7 + +| Field | Value | +| --------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Repo / milestone | `rickylabs/netscript` · milestone `0.0.7` (id `27`) | +| Baseline `main` | `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed` | +| Worktree HEAD | `477511709b90bf7b5be92f3b0467bdf2a2a6aa6f` (run artifacts only) | +| Target issues | **62**, each dispositioned exactly once | +| Status | **Recommendation only** — nothing ratified, nothing moved, no GitHub mutation | + +**Capture drift, recorded.** The brief pinned 61 open issues. **#1564** was moved into `0.0.7` at +`2026-08-13T18:38:26Z`, after that snapshot, and is included here on owner instruction — audited +directly, not carried over from the batch sweep. The milestone's own `open_issues` counter reads 63 +because GitHub counts PRs; the 63rd item is coordinator PR #1641, which the brief places off-limits. + +## Headline findings + +**1. #1564 is a merge barrier and must land before any other leaf.** +`github.event.pull_request.base.sha` is the base recorded *for the PR*, not the base branch tip, so +every gate computing `base.sha..head` enumerates other PRs' merged work as this PR's diff. +Reproduced on #1539: base `cd24e1679` was hours stale, the range returned **9 files, zero of them in +#1539's own diff**, and the gate reported success having inspected **zero lines of the PR under +review** while a new `as unknown as` sat in the actual diff untouched. It degrades with PR age, so +it is anti-correlated with risk. Consumers: `code-quality.yml:39` (affected, owned by #1403), +`ci.yml:135,153`, `e2e-cli.yml:128,158`, `surface-diff.yml:47` (all unaudited, same input); +`openhands-phase-eval.yml:126` is already fixed by #1552, which is the precedent pattern. + +This makes **pre-merge gate checks 3 and 6 unreliable** for the whole milestone — the exact +"pass is indistinguishable from did-not-run" class the gate-integrity rules name. With 46 leaves +merging direct-to-`main`, it is wave 0 alone. + +**2. RFC 0001 is merged and re-scopes five target issues.** +`rfcs/0001-sdk-client-contributions.md` (1611 lines, PR #1390, 2026-08-11) carries a normative stage +table at `:1273-1281`. Four bodies now contradict ratified doctrine: + +- **#1349** demands public export of `createHttpClientLink`/`ClientLinkPort`/`ClientLinkCallOptions` + — RFC `:491-497` keeps those ports **private** and `:1289` makes #451 "the sole future owner of + custom links"; it composes upstream interceptor arrays, which `:1276` forbids; it removes + `port`/`timeout`, which `:1224` keeps deprecated and `:1277` reassigns to #1351. +- **#1353** is reversed: its `traceContextContribution()` acceptance is the alternative `:1476-1481` + **rejects**; `:1279` re-scopes it to proving the transport owns trace injection. +- **#1351** targets oRPC `1.14.15`; `:1277` makes the family move a separate decision on `v1.15.0`. +- **#1352** keeps a cookie carve-out the RFC bans and cites the wrong module path (`:1168`). + +RFC `:1273` already assigns the fix to Stage 0 (#1348): *"align #1349–#1353 bodies before +implementation."* **That is a Step 0 deliverable.** Dispatching those bodies as written produces work +that fails IMPL-EVAL against ratified doctrine. + +**3. Nothing in 0.0.7 is blocked by anything outside it.** 134 external issues examined → **zero +`dependency-required` admissions**. Every outward reference is an exclusion boundary, never a +prerequisite; direction runs 0.0.7 → later (#1349 unblocks #451; #1502 supersedes #904–#908). RFC +`:1290` settles the open question: *"#928 and #934 … are **not prerequisites** for the header seam."* + +**4. #1453 cannot be worked in this repository.** It targets `tools/migration-loc/cli.ts`; that path +does not exist on baseline, `git log --all -- '*migration-loc*'` returns nothing, and no generator +emits it. No 0.0.7 slice can tick a single box. **`move`** on release-boundary grounds — not size. + +**5. The docs lane is nearly empty, and one of its two issues cannot be closed by a PR.** Five +issues labelled `type:docs`/`area:docs` (#1112, #1296, #1350, #1461, #1623) have acceptance +requiring `packages/**` source and were reassigned — the #1020 class that put framework source on a +docs PR in 0.0.4. #1606 is observational: it closes by recorded observation at a canary/cut +checkpoint, never by a merge. `@netscript/sdk@0.0.6` is already published, so it may be +dischargeable now. + +## Dispositions and lanes + +| Disposition | Count | | Lane | Count | +| ----------- | ----- | - | ---- | ----- | +| `active` | 61 | | `fixes` | 25 | +| `move` | 1 — #1453 → `Backlog / Triage` | | `features` | 17 | +| `close-fixed` / `-duplicate` / `-superseded` | 0 | | `internals` | 17 | +| | | | `docs` | 2 | + +**No issue is recommended for closure.** Six already-fixed hypotheses were tested; all six defects +are still present on baseline. Scope was not reduced for size — #1349, #1354, #1448, #1551, #1590, +#1592 are all large and all stay. Lane came from acceptance content, never the label: #1502 → +`features` (ratifies a public seam despite `type:docs`), #1616 → `fixes` (its box 1 needs generator +source despite `type:test`), #1353 → `fixes` (a coordinator override of the auditor's `features` +call: under the RFC re-scope it ships no new export). + +## Dependency structure + +24 edges, all `from` = prerequisite, all crossing to a strictly later wave, acyclic — asserted +programmatically at build time. Two conventions: + +- **External dependencies are not DAG nodes** (recorded per issue in `externalDependencies`) so the + DAG equals the frozen active inventory and validates. Five named predecessors — #1374, #1615, + #1594, #1589, #1333 — are **already closed** and recorded as satisfied. +- **Ordering inside one leaf is not an edge.** #1545→#1378, #1601→#1557, #1561→#1621, #1611→#1613 + are intra-PR sequencing, recorded on the leaf. + +Critical path, six deep: `#1348 → #1350 → #1466 → #1349 → {#1351, #1352, #1353, #1093} → #1467`. + +## Waves + +61 active issues → **46 leaf groups**, **10 waves**. Waves are dispatch batches sized to the WIP +bound (≤2 implementation leaves per topic), which is why there are ten rather than the seven the DAG +alone requires. This is ~4× the 0.0.4 exemplar (11 PRs, 42 issues) — a scale decision worth naming +now rather than discovering at wave 5. + +| Wave | Leaves | Issues | +| ---- | ------ | ------ | +| **0** | **ci-diff-range-base-sha-barrier — MERGE BARRIER, merges before every other leaf** | 1 | +| 1 | rfc-a-stage0-ratification-board · rfc-plugin-cli-contribution · legacy-port-pin-sweep · scaffold-generated-output-correctness · quality-scan-allowance-rail · harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling · comparison-docs-programme · sdk-jsr-landing-verification | 13 | +| 2 | prisma-mysql-adapter-surface · app-service-client-wiring · sdk-typed-error-channel · design-registry-catalog-drift-gate · quality-scan-root-coverage · openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal | 8 | +| 3 | sdk-procedure-metadata · workers-job-policy-metadata · prisma-mysql-honest-example · ui-add-page-island-repair · reference-export-drift-gate · package-gate-honesty | 8 | +| 4 | sdk-client-contribution-seam · ui-resource-slice-generator · ai-mcp-pool-isolation · sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry · leak-check-process-descendants · jsdoc-example-compile-gate | 9 | +| 5 | sdk-auth-contribution-dogfood · workers-job-payload-typing · sdk-transport-policy-consolidation · sdk-trace-ownership-proof · fresh-defer-test-capability | 6 | +| 6 | sdk-locale-contribution-proof · aspire-agent-resource-inventory · plugin-discovery-contribution-references · sdk-cached-entry-swr | 4 | +| 7 | plugin-service-context-factory · workers-execution-progress · sdk-browser-safe-entrypoints · scaffold-route-emission-and-gating | 5 | +| 8 | fresh-client-navigation-coordinator · ai-openai-responses-mapper · fresh-typed-route-and-form-repair · cross-package-dependency-declarations | 5 | +| 9 | fresh-ai-chat-response-options · cli-deploy-verb-surface | 2 | + +Groupings that were judgement calls: **scaffold-generated-output-correctness** {#1262,#1263,#1588} +shares one `scaffold.runtime` verdict, grouped to cut expensive-gate contention (two false failures +in 0.0.4); **app-service-client-wiring** {#1355,#1360} both edit +`ServiceShowcaseLab.memory.tsx.template` and would collide as separate PRs; +**quality-scan-allowance-rail** {#1378,#1545} *must* be one PR — #1545's registration must precede +#1378's rule or the gate is red day one, while #1545's own test box needs that rule to exist. +**#1354/#1357 and #1293/#1112 were deliberately split** (new verb vs repair; published-surface +change vs prose written against what shipped). + +**25 of 61 active issues carry `splitRisk: true`.** Six should be resolved before dispatch, not at +merge: **#1306** (four rows are *alternative* remedies across three surfaces), **#1551** (17 +deliverables incl. a full Next.js re-implementation), **#1349**, **#1590**, **#1461** and **#1620** +(each has two mutually exclusive remedies, and the choice moves the lane). This is the #1024/#1061 +class that split mid-flight in 0.0.4. + +## External candidates + +134 examined · **4 proposed** · 31 tempting-but-rejected recorded with reasons. Each proposal needs +**owner ratification *and* the actual milestone move before scope freeze** — recording without +moving is a failed Step 0. + +| Issue | Now | Predicate | Basis | Condition | +| ----- | --- | --------- | ----- | --------- | +| **#1637** | *(none)* | `high-value-coherent` | `packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts:234-248` — `data` resolves, then a failing `store.set` **rethrows and discards the successful result**. Filed 2026-08-13 by a live consumer against published `@netscript/sdk@0.0.6-canary.3`. | Has **no labels and no milestone**. Rides `sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry` at near-zero cost. Owner may upgrade to `release-critical` — it is a consumer-visible false outage on a published canary. | +| **#1384** | 0.0.8 | `release-critical` | `plugins/auth/services/src/routers/v1-handlers.ts:188-234` — `signout` revokes any `sessionId` an unauthenticated caller supplies; `main.ts:70-83` shows the auth service has no auth config. Ships on published `@netscript/plugin-auth`. | Admissible **only** scoped to the credential-only carve-out. As written it declares itself blocked on #1383, and admitting #1383 drags the whole 0.0.8 auth pack. Without the carve-out, decline. | +| **#1385** | 0.0.8 | `release-critical` | `auth.contract.ts:437-461` — none of the five auth v1 routes sets `outputStructure:'detailed'`; `v1-handlers.ts:95-107,160-169` discard the backend `Set-Cookie`. The only interactive backend shipped cannot complete a browser sign-in via its own published API. | Needs nothing from #1383. Contract-breaking, so cheaper in a foundation release. Decline if the auth deferral is read as covering defects, not just consumers — a legitimate call. | +| **#1249** | Backlog | `high-value-coherent` | `prop-types.ts:166` — `role?: string` widens past JSX's `Signalish`, so the documented `controlProps()` spread does not type-check. Shares #1609's surface. | **Weakest, and one supporting claim needs correcting.** The sweep reported "no `greater_than`/`less_than`/`multiple_of` case exists"; `zod-constraints.ts:163-181` *does* have `min`/`max`/`multipleOf` — but those are **Zod 3** names while `readCheckKind` (`:198`) reads Zod 4's `def.check`. Plausibly real for that reason; unconfirmed without executing a probe. Admit on the `controlProps` half only. | + +Notable exclusions: **#928/#934** (coordination, settled by RFC `:1290`), **#904/#908** (downstream +consumers #1502 names for supersession — admitting them inverts the ordering), the **0.0.8 auth +pack** (#1387 would define a competing procedure-policy shape concurrently with #1466 — the exact +outcome RFC 0001 exists to prevent), **#1362** (one sliver is verifiably real — a scaffolded +service's `deno task test` runs against a tree with no test module — but as scoped it is a +folder-vocabulary redesign), **#950** (a whole 0.0.10 epic; the only link is an "Related to" note). + +## Stale rows and false positives + +No issue is wholly stale; these rows are stale *within* live issues and must be corrected before the +owning issue is dispatched. + +| Issue | Row | Finding | +| ----- | --- | ------- | +| **#1296** | "contracts JSDoc imports the root where symbols live on `/query`" | **Already satisfied.** `baseContract`, `BaseContractRoute`, `BaseContractOutputRoute`, `OffsetPaginationQuerySchema` are all re-exported from the root (`src/public/mod.ts:2-6,65`) and the JSDoc at `contract-primitives.ts:72,112,144` imports correctly. Four rows remain live. | +| **#1357** | "`UiAddCommandInput` declares route/island/query/app" | **Already satisfied**: `add-ui-input.ts:1-11` declares all eight fields. The emission defect is unaffected. | +| **#1455** | "`build()` returns `JobDefinition` with no payload" | **Stale**: `job-builder.ts:80` already returns `JobDefinition`. Live scope is the registry payload map, `JobTriggerInput`, `enqueueJob`. | +| **#1355** | every `file:line` citation | **Stale**: the cited template moved to `assets/app/routes/examples/service/(_lib)/`. Same defect, wrong citations. | +| **#1619** | "`cache-telemetry_test.ts:237` pins fail-loud" | No such file on baseline (only `cache-provider_test.ts`). | +| **#1349/#1351/#1352/#1353** | multiple acceptance rows | **Contradicted by merged RFC 0001** — finding 2. | +| **#1348** | board line recording #928/#934 as `0.0.7` | Both are `0.0.9` under epic #922. Stale drift. | + +## Uncertainties + +- **Owner ratification of RFC 0001 is not visible from the repo.** PR #1390 merged the text, but the + RFC still lists **11 unresolved questions** at `:1555-1599`, including Q6 (metadata ownership) — + which is precisely what #1466's existence presumes was decided. This is the biggest unknown + gating waves 3–6. +- **No gate, test, build, or `deno` task was executed** (read-only brief). Every "still broken" + verdict rests on reading source at the cited lines, not a reproduction. Not re-run: #1350's + `deno check` probe, #1610's `never`-inference repro, #1618's `deno fmt` exit-1, #1622's constant + mutation, #1543's `publish:dry-run` behaviour (if publish silently accepts, #1543 downgrades). +- **#1564's blast radius is stated, not proven** — four of five consumers are recorded as unaudited + in the issue itself. Its boundary with **#1403**, which hardens exactly one consumer, must be + settled before dispatch or the two collide on `code-quality.yml`. +- **Three issues have an undecided remedy that moves them between lanes**: #1461, #1620, #1621. +- **#1451 does not name its seam** and no candidate exists on baseline — design precedes the slice. +- **#1590 and #1551 depend on artefacts outside this repo** (`apps/dashboard/lib/client-nav.ts`; + the EIS-Chat route). If unreachable, #1590's semantics are prose-only and #1551 has no subject. +- **#1306's remedies may be upstream-only** — `aspire start` is the Aspire CLI (13.4.6). +- **The external sweep searched outward from 0.0.7.** That catches every case where a 0.0.7 issue + knows it is blocked, but would miss a blocker documented only in the blocking issue's body. + Unread: #1464/#1503–#1512, #1363/#1482–#1488, #1364/#1366–#1372, #979. + +## What this run did not do + +Read-only throughout. No GitHub issue, label, milestone, PR, branch or comment was mutated; no +Codex, OpenHands or implementation session launched; no test, container or Aspire process started; +no commit or push. The only files written are this document and `step0-synthesis.json`. + +**Step 0 is therefore not complete.** It remains open on: + +1. Owner ratification of the 61/1 split and the #1453 move — **plus the actual GitHub move**. +2. Owner ratification of the four admission proposals — **plus the actual moves into `0.0.7` before + freeze**, and labels + milestone for #1637, which has neither. +3. **Realignment of #1349, #1351, #1352, #1353 to the merged RFC** (RFC `:1273` assigns this to + #1348). No SDK-chain leaf should dispatch before this. +4. Settling the **#1564 ↔ #1403** boundary before wave 0 dispatches. +5. Generating the four milestone JSON artifacts from this synthesis, then + `harness:milestone:render` and `harness:milestone:validate` — the dispatch gate, red until it + passes. +6. A separate-session **PLAN-EVAL** of the composed wave plan. This synthesis is a generator output + and **does not self-certify**. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/supervisor.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/supervisor.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..da046e56c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/supervisor.md @@ -0,0 +1,1005 @@ +# Supervisor identity — release 0.0.7 + +| Field | Value | +| ------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Profile | `milestone-cluster` | +| Run id | `release-0.0.7--orchestration` | +| Coordinator | `codex-root-0.0.7` | +| Coordinator Codex session | `019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd` | +| Coordinator transcript | `/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/13/rollout-2026-08-13T12-20-27-019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd.jsonl` | +| Same-session resume | `codex exec resume 019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd -- ""` | +| Recovery predecessor | `019ff0c0-ca4b-7ea0-893b-e8ab1f4811ea` (daily-assistant/recovery anchor, not the active milestone coordinator) | +| Coordinator worktree | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix` | +| Control branch | `chore/release-0.0.7-orchestration` | +| Harness | `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration` (`milestone-cluster`) | +| Baseline `main` | `01e0960494c95ce56eb35892c211a095eb13e6ed` | +| Target milestone | GitHub milestone `0.0.7` (`#27`) | +| Started | `2026-08-13T18:35:10.000Z` | +| Coordinator runtime | Codex via ChatGPT subscription; GPT-5.6-SOL at high effort (`max` is not authorized) | +| Coordinator transport | Remote Control app-server socket `unix:///home/codex/.codex/app-server-control/app-server-control.sock` | +| Coordinator attachment | resume PID `2452378`; app-server PID `5027` running with `--remote-control`; verified `2026-08-14T23:08:28Z` | +| PLAN-EVAL session | Claude `2439b19d-5df7-4920-9fce-fa5831ec4fdf`; opposite family | +| PLAN-EVAL cycle | 2 of 2: `APPROVED` at plan head `331f7c664` | + +The coordinator identity was recovered and transcript-verified at `2026-08-14T22:41:15Z` rather than +inferred from a child thread. Its `session_meta` identifies Codex Desktop/OpenAI, its persistent +goal names the 0.0.7 milestone coordinator mandate, it created this canonical harness run, and it +committed/pushed the coordinator checkpoints. Topic and implementation sessions remain excluded. +Resume this exact session; never create a replacement coordinator while it is recoverable. + +The owner-corrected coordinator route is **GPT-5.6-SOL / high, never max**. Two interrupted +standalone turn contexts at `2026-08-14T22:47:31Z` and `22:53:43Z` recorded `max`; they are +historical transport drift and confer no continuing authority. The active same-thread process is PID +`2452378`, launched through `codex resume --remote` with model `gpt-5.6-sol` and reasoning effort +`high`, against app-server PID `5027`, whose argv includes `app-server --remote-control`. The +app-server owns both the canonical rollout file and thread-writer lock for +`019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd`. This transport repair does not alter, relaunch, or reassign +any Claude topic supervisor. + +The coordinator is the sole merge authority. Exactly four topic orchestrators will own the `docs`, +`internals`, `fixes`, and `features` lanes after Step 0 validates. The release captain and writer +lease remain inactive until every committed issue is terminal and exact-`main` gates pass. + +| Lane | Orchestrator id | Active issues | Capacity | +| --------- | ----------------------- | ------------: | -------------------------------- | +| docs | `topic-docs-0.0.7` | 1 | two implementers + one evaluator | +| internals | `topic-internals-0.0.7` | 16 | two implementers + one evaluator | +| fixes | `topic-fixes-0.0.7` | 26 | two implementers + one evaluator | +| features | `topic-features-0.0.7` | 17 | two implementers + one evaluator | + +Read-only watchers are `milestone-main-watcher-0.0.7` and `milestone-ci-watcher-0.0.7`; both carry +`mutationAuthority:false`. The first evaluation was mistakenly routed to Claude Opus/high instead of +the canonical Fable/medium plan-evaluator route. The family separation was valid, but the route +deviation is recorded. Fable completed the cycle-2 evidence pass but hit its monthly spend limit; +the same conversation used the recorded Opus fallback for final synthesis and approved dispatch. + +Quota at the checkpoint: Codex primary window had 77% remaining (weekly reset 2026-08-20 05:31 +Europe/Zurich); Claude Max showed 6% all-model weekly remaining and 2% Fable weekly remaining (reset +2026-08-15 00:00), with its current-session window resetting 2026-08-13 23:10. Implementation +therefore routes through WSL Codex; Claude is reserved for the bounded opposite-family re-review. + +At dispatch, all four topic-control sessions use the documented Codex Sol/high route fallback +because native Claude capacity is insufficient for four persistent orchestrators. Their clean +control worktrees are `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-{docs,internals,fixes,features}` at exact +`main` `01e096049`; thread identities and steering commands are recorded after launch. + +| Lane | Topic thread | Worktree | Same-thread steering | +| --------- | -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | `019ffcc0-e19b-71d1-95ce-8c72559eb026` | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs` | `codex exec resume 019ffcc0-e19b-71d1-95ce-8c72559eb026 -- ""` | +| internals | `019ffcc0-e1b5-74f0-96eb-cdeb298d6b17` | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-internals` | `codex exec resume 019ffcc0-e1b5-74f0-96eb-cdeb298d6b17 -- ""` | +| fixes | `019ffcc0-e1ae-7b70-b3b8-8804ebd6f773` | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-fixes` | `codex exec resume 019ffcc0-e1ae-7b70-b3b8-8804ebd6f773 -- ""` | +| features | `019ffcc0-e1d2-7850-a308-354b670c6f3d` | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features` | `codex exec resume 019ffcc0-e1d2-7850-a308-354b670c6f3d -- ""` | + +All four sessions were launched attached through `agentic:launch-codex-slice`; live status reports +one working Sol/high agent at each exact worktree and no route or worktree ownership collision. + +Owner visibility invariant: every 0.0.7 session assigned a Claude supervisor/orchestrator role must +run with native Claude `/remote-control`. Attachment is proven only by the native session registry +matching PID and cwd and exposing a non-empty `bridgeSessionId`; custom-endpoint/OpenRouter Claude +sessions do not satisfy this invariant. The four active topic controls above are Codex daemon lanes, +so they use the corresponding daemon/thread visibility proof instead. + +The user-visible native Claude milestone control surface was attachment-proved with +`/remote-control` at `https://claude.ai/code/session_016HFNiTigGUb7ieFxqFDvJb`: PID `2163112`, cwd +`/home/codex/repos/netscript-547-lffix`, Claude session `6e65c618-c957-443a-b713-d0399a891463`, and +non-empty bridge id `session_016HFNiTigGUb7ieFxqFDvJb`. The owner then directed it stopped to +preserve the remaining 4% allowance; the process and registry record are gone. The four Codex topic +lanes remain the active supervisors. + +PR #1651 PLAN-EVAL separately uses a bounded native Claude Remote Control session at +`https://claude.ai/code/session_018f6pxZjiFPaYJF6AFLyLxn`: PID `2159276`, exact leaf cwd, Opus +5/medium fallback, and bridge id `session_018f6pxZjiFPaYJF6AFLyLxn`. It was interrupted before +verdict and cleanly exited on the same owner directive; no verdict or repository mutation survived. +Formal Claude-family gates may resume after the Saturday 2026-08-15 00:00 Europe/Zurich reset. + +After that owner directive, the internals topic briefly launched a Claude-compatible OpenRouter +PLAN-EVAL for #1653. It had already committed a `FAIL_PLAN` artifact before the coordinator's stop +signal reached it; the process then exited and no replacement was launched. Its three substantive +findings are retained as advisory planning evidence and resolved by coordinator decisions, but it +does not waive the fresh formal opposite-family PLAN-EVAL required after reset. Until that reset, +topic and leaf lanes must not launch native Claude, Claude-compatible OpenRouter, or substitute +formal evaluators; existing Codex sessions may continue research, implementation already backed by a +valid plan gate, and artifact-only housekeeping. + +The docs topic then attempted three automatic S1 resumes from the advisory #1652 result despite the +formal hold. The coordinator interrupted each leaf turn, stopped the dedicated docs topic process +group and watcher, removed the uncommitted/untracked S1 patch with `apply_patch`, and verified the +leaf worktree exactly clean at pushed plan head `d35cbca30`. The docs lane remains intentionally +offline until the Saturday gate; the other three Codex topic controls are unaffected. + +The fixes topic later attempted a DeepSeek/OpenRouter IMPL-EVAL for #1643. The coordinator stopped +that process before verdict, removed its temporary transport artifact, amended the evaluator brief +to require a fresh native Claude/Fable gate after reset, and stopped the fixes topic control to +prevent automatic relaunch. #1643's substantive Codex implementation and Tier-A review remain valid +at pushed head `e6ba15ec6`; #1654 remains plan-only at `14d8b38b4`. + +The internals tooling leaf #1644 completed its exact nine-surface implementation at `634b257ea`, +including the coordinator-authorized #1621 operator guidance. Substantive Tier-A review passed and +fresh structured check/test/quality receipts all passed at that implementation head. Evidence-only +child `4d9fb1967` packages the receipts and formal handoff without a self-referential gate rerun. +The draft remains `status:impl` and blocked only on native opposite-family IMPL-EVAL after reset. + +## 2026-08-15 reset transition + +The reset boundary arrived at `2026-08-15T00:00:00+02:00`. The owner revoked the temporary Codex +topic-orchestrator fallback while retaining Codex as milestone coordinator. The historical Codex +topic threads, branches, worktrees, leaf threads, PRs, and harness records remain evidence; they are +parked and must never be resumed as topic controllers while their Claude replacements own the lane. + +The pre-mutation recheck at `2026-08-14T22:12:38Z` found unchanged `main` `01e096049`, exactly 60 +open milestone issues, all seven milestone draft PRs at their recorded heads, zero current CI +failures or pending checks, clean coordinator/topic/leaf worktrees, no Docker containers, no +milestone resource lease, and no active milestone evaluator. The unrelated database-RFC Fable +session in `/home/codex/repos/netscript-db-rfc` is outside this cluster and is not touched. + +### Corrected topic control plane + +The owner rejected the Sonnet 5/low supervision canary as below the acceptable intelligence floor. +The canonical topic-orchestrator route is restored: native Claude Opus 5 at high effort. Every +replacement uses the same preserved topic branch/worktree, native Remote Control, and launcher +evidence; implementation remains delegated to WSL Codex with effort matched to documented task +complexity. + +| Lane | Preserved Codex topic thread | Pre-transition state | Claude requested route | Worktree / branch | Replacement identity | +| --------- | -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | `019ffcc0-e19b-71d1-95ce-8c72559eb026` | parked: prior controller absent/offline; clean worktree | native Claude · Opus 5 · high | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs` / `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-docs` | `fcf04b0f-…` · PID `2429469` · bridge `session_01PL…` · topic head `3e554349b` | +| internals | `019ffcc0-e1b5-74f0-96eb-cdeb298d6b17` | parked: `TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED`, idle, clean | native Claude · Opus 5 · high | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-internals` / `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-internals` | `f7691917-…` · PID `2429478` · bridge `session_01Hq…` (`cse_01Hq…` daemon alias) · topic head `98661da4f` | +| fixes | `019ffcc0-e1ae-7b70-b3b8-8804ebd6f773` | parked: `TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED`, idle, clean | native Claude · Opus 5 · high | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-fixes` / `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-fixes` | `c7597d28-…` · PID `2430399` · bridge `session_014p…` · topic head `1a5c3d5a9` | +| features | `019ffcc0-e1d2-7850-a308-354b670c6f3d` | parked: `TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED`, idle, clean | native Claude · Opus 5 · high | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features` / `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-features` | `19621a0b-…` · PID `2430404` · bridge `session_01LQ…` · topic head `fed3f8119` | + +No replacement is considered active until the previous controller is durably parked and the new +process has a Claude session ID, non-empty `bridgeSessionId`, PID, exact cwd, process-argv +model/effort evidence, and owner-visible Remote Control URL/state. Blank or inherited model settings +are forbidden; the documented native Claude CLI route must pass Opus 5, high effort, Remote Control, +and the initial brief explicitly. + +Parking proof was completed at `2026-08-14T22:18:41Z`. The three extant Codex threads received the +same no-edit same-thread parking instruction through `agentic:codex-resume`, returned exactly +`TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED`, reached `idle`, and left their worktrees clean at the preserved heads. +The docs topic had no live session or process and was already clean/offline. No topic controller, +leaf, evaluator, watcher, or resource process now owns any of the four topic worktrees. + +Four Sonnet 5/low replacement canaries were subsequently started only long enough to reconcile and +journal their lanes. After the owner's model-floor correction, each returned +`TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED_MODEL_FLOOR` and exited without launching an implementation leaf or formal +evaluator. They are historical evidence, not active controllers. + +At `2026-08-14T23:00:08Z`, all four native Opus 5/high replacements satisfied the attachment gate: +each has an exact Claude session ID, non-empty bridge ID, PID/cwd match, explicit process-argv model +and effort, owner-visible Remote Control URL, a clean pushed topic checkpoint, and no premature leaf +or evaluator dispatch. The central controller state is now `active`; each topic's serialized +formal-gate queue may begin at its first eligible entry. + +### Corrected evaluator matrix + +The six already-recorded formal holds remain independently required because their live issues, prior +invalid/advisory gates, or implementation complexity still justify them. This is not a standing +six-gate template: no additional PLAN-EVAL is opened unless an existing issue, unresolved +architectural decision, or demonstrated complexity makes it necessary. Shared adversarial review is +deduplicated without replacing required independent phase evidence. + +Each retained gate uses a fresh session separate from its Codex generator. Serialization is **per +topic orchestrator**: internals must finish order 1 before order 4, and fixes must finish order 2 +before order 5; docs order 6 and features order 3 may run alongside those lane-local queues. One +evaluator per topic remains binding. The cluster-wide expensive-gate limit applies only to shared +resource-heavy gates such as full E2E/Aspire work, not formal evaluator sessions. Native Claude Opus +5 is the normal opposite-family evaluator; effort ranges from low through high according to the +evidence contract. Fable 5 is not pre-dispatched. It is reserved for genuinely architectural PLAN +questions or the few exceptionally complex implementations/reviews that materially need its +additional intelligence, with model and effort plus the concrete necessity recorded before launch. +All generator/evaluator separation, opposite-family, immutable-head, and coordinator-only authority +laws remain binding. The exact current assignments and rationales live in +`briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json`. + +### Live reset-gate checkpoint — 2026-08-14T23:54:29Z + +| Order | Lane | PR | Gate | Result / current action | +| ----- | --------- | ----- | ----------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| 1 | internals | #1644 | IMPL-EVAL | `PASS`; merged by coordinator as `dd472102d`; #1561/#1563/#1621 closed completed | +| 2 | fixes | #1643 | IMPL-EVAL | `PASS`; merged by coordinator as `0b3ed5d5a`; #1243 closed completed | +| 3 | features | #1651 | PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 | `PASS` at `3e0c8858b`; preserved Codex thread `019ffcc5-…` authorized to implement | +| 4 | internals | #1653 | PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 | `PASS` at `c694cfb31`; preserved Codex thread `019ffcc9-97d6-…` authorized to implement | +| 5 | fixes | #1654 | PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 | `PASS` at `b8fc5eb53`; preserved Codex thread `019ffcca-8be0-…` authorized to implement | +| 6 | docs | #1652 | PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 | `PASS` at corrected evaluator commit `a790e91e2`; preserved Codex thread `019ffcc9-16c2-…` authorized to implement | + +The four PLAN-EVAL passes do not authorize replacement implementation sessions: each topic +supervisor must resume the recorded existing Codex leaf thread. `expensiveGates` is still empty. + +### Active completion checkpoint — 2026-08-15T03:50:58Z + +The coordinator must remain active through terminal lane handoffs; a topic checkpoint is not a +completion condition. The four topics continue concurrently, with serialization only inside each +topic: + +| Lane | Live action | +| --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| docs | S2 resumed on original Codex thread `019ffcc9-16c2-…` after coordinator provisioned exact immutable EIS-Chat input `5191de83` at `/home/codex/repos/eis-chat-007-input` | +| internals | #1653 fresh IMPL-EVAL running in Opus 5/high session `430d5f91-a073-…`, bridge `session_01NFwTgbof8vAYdg9wex15fM`, source `2d5e4f5ae` | +| fixes | T-1 bounded MSSQL regression repair resumed on original Codex thread `019ffcca-8be0-…`; slice 6 and its singleton lease remain pending | +| features | #1651 IMPL-EVAL ended conditional `PASS` at `0e302ad3a`; owner comment `5300440887` now holds merge/readiness pending a fresh delegated RFC-0003 duplicate/overlap audit | + +Neither formal evaluator consumes the global expensive-gate mutex. At `2026-08-15T04:02:33Z`, fixes +T-1 passed Tier-A at `ebad68c80`; a clean `aspire ps`/Docker/central-state preflight then granted +the one `scaffold.runtime`/Aspire/Docker lease to #1654. No other expensive gate may start until +that isolated pass is terminal and its mandatory cleanup is verified. + +### Active completion checkpoint — 2026-08-15T05:06:31Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | Rewrite #1551 comments `5265826161` and `5265971722` in place from authoritative EIS-Chat `5191de83`; the comments predate the route improvements already contained in that pin | Preserve original Codex thread; `834a2b36` is evidence-only, no invented newer product head, appended follow-up, ready flip, merge, or false PLAN-EVAL shortcut | +| internals | #1653 merged as `473e8d75b`; next serial leaf `quality-scan-root-coverage` (#1542) is dispatched for harness bootstrap/research/plan | Preserve the Opus 5/high topic supervisor; no concurrent `openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal` leaf inside this topic | +| fixes | #1654 runtime head `0b2cf5e7c` is under independent Tier-A review after 89/0/0 terminal PASS and exact cleanup | Shared expensive lease is complete; no IMPL-EVAL before the coordinator receives the Tier-A terminal checkpoint | +| features | Owner decision hold for #1651 after RFC 0003/#1490 overlap audit | Keep draft; no amendment, reply, resolution, readiness, or merge before explicit option 1/2/3 verdict | + +Coordinator transport remains GPT-5.6-SOL/high, never max. The resumed Claude controller PIDs may +change after an unattended-process interruption, but their session IDs, branches, worktrees, and +Remote Control bridges remain authoritative and must not be replaced. Continue supervising useful +work in the other topics while #1651 waits; the owner hold is lane-local, not a cluster stop. + +### Active completion checkpoint — 2026-08-15T05:52:01Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | #1652 formal cycle 1 is `FAIL_FIX`; original author thread repairs F1–F5, then fresh Tier-A | No cycle 2, ready flip, merge, or expensive gate before a new coordinator grant | +| internals | #1656 PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 is `PASS`; original author thread implements the approved three-file plan | Carry changed-file and denominator-boundary advisories; stop before IMPL-EVAL | +| fixes | #1654 shipped as `da574111a`; #1358 is the next serial leaf and is implementing | Stop before `fresh-browser` and request the singleton expensive-gate lease | +| features | #1651 is draft and owner-blocked on explicit option 1/2/3 | Do not amend, reply, resolve, ready, or merge before the verdict | + +Main post-merge CI, Pages, and code quality are green. Aspire and Docker are empty, and no expensive +lease is held. Formal evaluator serialization is independent per topic; only resource-heavy +Aspire/Docker/E2E uses the cluster-wide mutex. + +### Active completion checkpoint — 2026-08-15T06:07:53Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | #1652 repair Tier-A `PASS` at `c7ce58a19`; dispatching fresh IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 | One fresh Opus 5/medium evaluator only; no repair, readiness, merge, or next leaf inside the evaluation session | +| internals | #1656 S1 Tier-A requested one drift-only JSON field-name record at `dbbedde34` | Same author thread, F1 only, then supervisor sign-off; do not start S2 yet | +| fixes | #1657 one `fresh-browser` lease running at `4a3c40321` | Playwright/Chromium only; durable receipt and exact process/Aspire/Docker cleanup before Tier-A | +| features | #1651 remains draft and owner-blocked on explicit option 1/2/3 | Do not amend, reply, resolve, ready, or merge before the verdict | + +All checked PR heads equal their remote refs and current workflows have no failures. The singleton +runtime mutex is held only by #1657 until its browser receipt and cleanup are terminal. + +### Active completion checkpoint — 2026-08-15T06:19:11Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | #1652 fresh IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 working against `c7ce58a19` in session `4ed649d5-…` | Wait for one terminal verdict; a further failure escalates and does not begin another loop | +| internals | #1656 S2 author is finishing receipts after local evidence head `a7e9ee0d5` | No central completion claim, push assumption, or IMPL-EVAL before the author stops and Tier-A signs off | +| fixes | #1657 browser gate is terminal PASS at evidence head `c792327c9`; substantive Tier-A is running | No IMPL-EVAL, ready flip, merge, issue mutation, or next fixes leaf before the Tier-A verdict | +| features | #1651 remains draft and owner-blocked on explicit option 1/2/3 | Do not amend, reply, resolve, ready, or merge before the verdict | + +The singleton expensive-gate mutex is free: Aspire is empty, Docker has no containers or volumes, +and the browser gate left no Chromium/Playwright survivors. Topic serialization remains local to +each orchestrator; these three active gates run concurrently without cross-topic waiting. + +### Active completion checkpoint — 2026-08-15T06:24:17Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | #1652 IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`; original author fixes only N1–N3, then topic Tier-A | No formal cycle 3, canonical-comment edit, ready flip, merge, or next docs leaf | +| internals | #1656 S2 Tier-A `PASS`; final run-artifact-only S3 active | No product-path change or formal IMPL-EVAL before S3 topic sign-off | +| fixes | #1657 T-3 contract amendment recorded; original author repairs workflow/classifier/test | Exactly three new CI files; no browser rerun, Aspire, Docker, formal IMPL-EVAL, or next fixes leaf | +| features | #1651 remains draft and owner-blocked on explicit option 1/2/3 | Do not amend, reply, resolve, ready, or merge before the verdict | + +All three active workers are preserved original threads under the same four native Opus 5/high +Remote Control topic supervisors. The completed browser lease has no residual process or resource +ownership and the cluster-wide runtime mutex remains free. + +## Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T07:12:16Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | #1652 final generated-asset cascade at `a465836b4`; fresh Tier-A plus exact-head Actions running | No formal cycle 3, next docs leaf, or readiness claim before exact-head terminal green | +| internals | #1656 shipped as `7737d8903`; draft #1658 (#1611+#1613) research/plan active from bootstrap `ca2266ecb` on preserved Codex thread `01a00443-…` | No implementation or OpenHands dispatch before the plan gate; L-2 stays a later dedicated leaf | +| fixes | #1657 fresh Tier-A `PASS`; formal IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 running in native Opus 5/medium session `1df19d27-…` | One final formal cycle only; no browser/Aspire/Docker/E2E rerun | +| features | #1651 frozen on explicit owner option 1/2/3 | No amendment, reply, readiness, relabel, or merge before owner verdict | + +The topics do not wait on each other. Main is `7737d8903`; its post-merge core CI is watched while +the other topics perform work that does not depend on that terminal result. + +## Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T07:25:00Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | #1652 shipped as `e090f894f`; lane inventory has no residual 0.0.7 docs leaf | Preserve supervisor checkpoint; do not invent work outside the bound inventory | +| internals | #1658 research head `670e37bea`; central eight-path contract amendment authorized, same author repairs plan | No implementation before fresh opposite-family PLAN-EVAL `PASS`; phase workflow is read-only | +| fixes | #1657 final IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 remains active at immutable source `3d7819203` | This is the final formal cycle; no browser/Aspire/Docker/E2E rerun | +| features | #1651 owner-blocked on explicit option 1/2/3 | No amendment, reply, readiness, relabel, or merge before owner verdict | + +Main is `e090f894f`. Per-topic queues remain independent; only the runtime mutex is global. + +### Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T07:40:16Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | Inventory complete; #1652 shipped as `e090f894f` | Preserve terminal supervisor checkpoint; no invented docs leaf | +| internals | #1658 repaired plan `cea999d18` in Tier-A / authorized single PLAN-EVAL | No implementation before immutable-head `PASS`; no OpenHands dispatch | +| fixes | #1657 same-author three-file redundant-CI cleanup active | Fresh Tier-A only after exact cleanup proofs; no formal cycle 3 or browser/Aspire/Docker/E2E | +| features | Owner selected keep-and-narrow for #1651; focused C6 amendment authorized | Same Codex author, exact adapter boundary, six gates, fresh Tier-A, one final focused IMPL-EVAL; remain draft | + +Serialization remains per topic. The owner verdict releases only the features amendment hold; it +does not grant readiness, issue mutation, comment resolution, or merge authority. + +### Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T07:48:51Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | Inventory complete; #1652 shipped as `e090f894f` | Preserve the terminal topic checkpoint; do not invent a new docs leaf | +| internals | #1658 repaired-plan PLAN-EVAL is working in fresh Opus 5/medium Remote Control session `7d544aec-…` against immutable `cea999d18` | No implementation, OpenHands dispatch, or status transition before the formal plan verdict is `PASS` | +| fixes | #1657 post-evaluation cleanup is clean/pushed at `a891c6520`; fresh opposite-family Tier-A is the next gate | Preserve the cycle-2 `PASS`; no cycle 3, browser/Aspire/Docker/E2E rerun, readiness, or merge before cleanup review | +| features | #1651 focused keep-and-narrow amendment is running on preserved Codex thread `019ffcc5-…`; topic checkpoint `1bfc1cfcd` is clean/pushed | Keep draft/status:impl; six exact-head gates, fresh Tier-A, and one bounded final IMPL-EVAL remain mandatory | + +The recovered features lane reused the existing native Opus 5/high supervisor, Remote Control +bridge, and original Codex author; no replacement topic or author session was created. Evaluator and +author serialization is per topic, so these three gates continue concurrently. The expensive runtime +mutex remains unclaimed. + +### Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T08:04:33Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | Inventory complete; #1652 shipped as `e090f894f` | Preserve the terminal topic checkpoint | +| internals | #1658 PLAN-EVAL `PASS` at `e15d78588`; preserved author implementing S1 with watcher armed | Stop after each S1–S5 slice for topic Tier-A; no OpenHands dispatch, new PLAN-EVAL, or runtime gate | +| fixes | #1657 cleanup Tier-A found PR-body-only T-1/T-2/T-3; original author correcting the live body | Body-only, then one focused fresh recheck; preserve cycle-2 PASS and do not rerun product gates | +| features | #1651 content `67e12f021` and evidence `d45a92ba7` are clean/pushed; six gates and PR-body provenance are correct | Fresh Tier-A, then one bounded final IMPL-EVAL; remain draft/status:impl | + +The #1658 evaluator's delivered-but-blocked state was reconciled from its commit, exact head +equality, and PR comment before the stale session was explicitly stopped. The internals supervisor +checkpointed `d5ade932b` and armed an S1 watcher. Serial order remains local to each topic. + +### Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T08:31:20Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| docs | Inventory complete; #1652 remains shipped | Preserve terminal topic inventory | +| internals | #1658 S1 signed off at `6f725ad3b`; same author implementing S2 at `28a8a9184` | Structured check/test, then stop for fresh topic Tier-A; no S3, OpenHands dispatch, evaluator, or runtime gate before sign-off | +| fixes | #1657 shipped as `6917c656e`; supervisor reconciling the merge and frozen queue | Preserve #1348→#1350 prerequisite; do not invent a leaf if no eligible work remains | +| features | #1651 shipped as current main `284dda90a`; supervisor reconciling the merge and frozen queue | Preserve owner-approved RFC boundary and dispatch only the next eligible frozen leaf | + +The two shipped PRs have complete acceptance boxes, zero temporary evaluator-skip labels, and +`status:shipped`. Serial queues remain per topic. Combined-main CI is running without a failure and +the expensive runtime mutex is free. + +### Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T08:45:30Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| docs | Owner-directed post-freeze #1659 is draft PR #1660 at `0b67ef39e`; the original author is repairing four Tier-A findings | Same author only; re-run generated-asset freshness after the snippet/API/architecture repairs; no evaluator, ready flip, or merge before topic re-review | +| internals | #1658 S2 passed Tier-A at `0886c2427`; S3 implementation is local at `d7fdbb1d9` and producing structured receipts | No S4, OpenHands dispatch, formal evaluator, or runtime gate before pushed S3 evidence and topic sign-off | +| fixes | Draft #1661 stopped artifact-only at `1d4533462`; topic ruling `af53757e6` authorizes the exact five-file public-contract amendment | Resume only original thread `01a0048d-…`; keep the SDK-cache leaf queued until the next supervised stop; no expensive gate | +| features | #1293 original author is researching the shipped-but-unwired `onConnectionError` option | Preserve and wire the published option; one PLAN-EVAL is conditional on a clean decision-heavy plan plus topic review; docs-owned #1112 remains separate | + +Combined-main workflow `31874580034` is terminal `success` at `284dda90a`: classify, quality, and +check-test succeeded and unrelated deployment/runtime lanes skipped by policy. Aspire is empty; +Docker has no containers or volumes and only default networks. The post-freeze docs repair is +tracked explicitly without rewriting the frozen 60-issue inventory. Serialization remains per topic +orchestrator, not cluster-wide. + +### Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T09:08:30Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | #1660 exact head `e35824d41` passed fresh exclusive-owner Tier-A; ready CI running | Coordinator merges only after terminal exact-head green; then #1659/lifecycle reconciliation and temporary skip-label removal | +| internals | #1658 S3 signed off at `d3d31b3d0`; S4 local implementation `9b71e1bd2` is producing receipts | No S5, evaluator, provider spend, or runtime gate before S4 push/comment and fresh Tier-A | +| fixes | #1661 amendment 2 running on the original Codex thread, pushed through `099067c6b` | Published-wrapper cancellation and cross-package Fresh compatibility must pass before Tier-A; no expensive gate | +| features | #1293 PLAN-EVAL `PASS` at `7780ba49e`; existing supervisor reconciling the verdict and required plan amendment | Resume only the original author after plan amendment; no duplicate evaluator; #1112 remains a separate split-close follow-up | + +The #1293 evaluator's lifecycle metadata is stale but its delivered verdict tuple is independently +verified. The docs stash incident caused no data loss and its final review was rerun under clean +exclusive ownership. All four native Opus 5/high Remote Control topic supervisors remain preserved; +serial queues are local to each topic and the shared runtime mutex is free. + +## 2026-08-15T09:28:54Z lane handoff + +| Lane | Current state | Binding next action | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | #1660 merged as `729386c56`; #1659 closed/shipped; Pages and both published URLs verified | Reconcile topic artifacts, then dispatch the next eligible docs leaf or record queue exhaustion; no merge authority | +| internals | #1658 S5 pushed `704c067e8`; all final receipts PASS | Fresh Tier-A at the final content/evidence head, then request one formal IMPL-EVAL lease | +| fixes | #1661 Tier-A PASS/sign-off `e3c74d7aa`; canonical Fable 5/medium RC evaluator `cb917802-…` active | Accept only its immutable pushed verdict; keep next fixes leaf queued until terminal | +| features | #1293 amendment `feb8b0355` verified and S1 released | Complete S1 only, stop for Tier-A, then continue the planned serial slices | + +Serialization remains per lane, never across lanes. Coordinator retains sole merge/lifecycle +authority. Topic supervisors remain native Claude Opus 5/high with Remote Control enabled. + +## 2026-08-15T09:41:25Z lane handoff + +| Lane | Current state | Binding next action | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Assigned queue exhausted; merge/deploy reconciled at topic `0ca4c489f` | Stay preserved and parked; do not absorb fixes/internals/features allocations | +| internals | #1658 final Tier-A PASS `f46d84630`; Opus 5/medium RC evaluator `740d2a3a-…` active after zero-cycle Fable probe failure | Accept only an immutable exact-head verdict, then perform the lifecycle transition before releasing the next internals leaf | +| fixes | #1661 cycle 1 `FAIL_FIX` at `8d6b4726c`; original author repairing the registration-signal lifetime bug | Fresh Tier-A after pushed repair, then request a fresh formal IMPL-EVAL cycle 2; keep next leaf queued | +| features | #1293 S1 accepted at `49fda0b77`; S2 implementation active | Review S2 independently at its clean pushed stop, then continue the planned per-slice serial sequence | + +The central evaluator singleton remains lane-local: internals may evaluate while fixes and features +implement. No expensive runtime lease is held. Coordinator route remains GPT-5.6-SOL/high, never +max; all topic supervisors remain their existing native Claude Opus 5/high Remote Control sessions. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T09:53:39Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Gate boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| internals | #1658 Opus 5/medium IMPL-EVAL continues at `f46d84630` | Immutable evaluator verdict before lifecycle or next leaf | +| fixes | #1661 fresh Fable 5/medium IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 at `df0534416` after Tier-A PASS | Cycle-2 verdict must independently close F-1; next leaf remains queued | +| features | #1293 S3 content `3dee41263`; exact-head structured receipts running | Fresh final Tier-A only after clean pushed evidence head; no evaluator yet | +| docs | Exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | No cross-topic issue reassignment | + +Two formal evaluators are valid concurrently because they occupy different topic slots. The shared +Aspire/Docker/browser mutex is still free and all three active leaves avoid expensive runtime gates. + +## Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T10:20:00Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1658 shipped as main `05fc3132b`; `package-gate-honesty` (#1604/#1618/#1622) is in bootstrap/research/plan on preserved Codex thread `01a004ec-…` | Stop at the plan gate; `scaffold.runtime` needs the coordinator's cluster-wide mutex before any run | +| fixes | #1661 cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL passed, but exact-head CI exposed one real computed-import packaging regression; the original author is running the one-file RED→GREEN repair | Fresh Tier-A and a proportionate fresh formal evaluation are required after the product repair; no expensive gate | +| features | #1662 IMPL-EVAL passed at evaluator head `f52aa471c`; PR is non-draft/`status:ready-merge` with readiness CI active | #1293 stays open and its owner wording stays unchanged; merge only after current exact-head checks are terminal green | + +Main is `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b`. Per-topic queues remain independent. Docker, +Aspire application processes, Playwright, and Chromium are empty; the expensive-gate mutex is free. + +## Live checkpoint — 2026-08-15T10:39:55Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | Draft #1663 plan head `72d5aca66` is under fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL `9078ecb6-…` | No implementation or `scaffold.runtime` before the immutable verdict and topic reconciliation | +| fixes | #1661 repaired the computed-import CI regression at `45aca4adc`, passed full root test 4152/0/19, and is under repair-delta evaluator `8a0ff845-…` at `de8944011` | Merge only after the bounded verdict and current exact-head checks are terminal green | +| features | #1662 shipped as main `3fc0f2f92`; #1355/#1360 research/plan is active on preserved Codex author `01a004f9-…` | Stop at plan; no implementation, `scaffold.runtime`, or `fresh-browser` before review and a coordinator lease | + +The #1663 route incident is closed: malformed `fable-5` probe `bd8b4f90` failed pre-inference and +the premature Opus fallback `02d8d823` was stopped before mutation. The sole real cycle uses the +canonical `claude-fable-5` token from the exact worktree with Remote Control. Serialization remains +per topic, not across topics; the shared runtime mutex is free. + +### Formal-gate disposition — 2026-08-15T10:46:30Z + +#1663 PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 returned `FAIL_PLAN` at `be2b18728`: root `deno.json` exclusion cannot +affect the wrappers' explicit-file argv. Coordinator rescope now admits both structured fmt/lint +wrappers, their focused tests, and at most one narrow marker inside the broken fixture subtree. +The malformed config stays byte-identical, broad fixture skipping is forbidden, and +`scaffold.runtime` is waived as matrix-`n/a`; the same author is repairing the plan before cycle 2. + +#1661 repair-delta IMPL-EVAL returned `PASS` at `f74695bc4`; exact-head readiness CI is active. +Merge remains coordinator-only after terminal green and metadata reconciliation. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T10:56:30Z + +#1661 reached terminal exact-head green and was coordinator squash-merged as main `baf1cdf67`; +#1448 auto-closed and both surfaces have sole `status:shipped`. The fixes lane is reconciling before +releasing `sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry` from current main. + +Draft #1664 is at clean Phase-1 head `6aea4a5ea`. PLAN-EVAL is required. Tier-A requested one +repair: preserve `scaffold.runtime` as a suite-owned release gate rather than inventing a run-gate +catalog entry/receipt, and name the exact two-service/invalidation/hydration assertions. Both +expensive gates remain load-bearing after cheap convergence; no lease exists yet. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T12:21:00Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 repaired plan `194e22a3d` passed Tier-A at `b2e0529be`, but two ordinary PLAN-EVAL failures are consumed | No product mutation or exceptional final evaluator before the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 S1 passed Tier-A at `0e4e26c51` / topic `f6f8f0fcb`; same author executing S2 real-KV isolation | Stop after S2 for fresh Tier-A; no S3, evaluator, Aspire, Docker, or e2e | +| features | #1664 S2 passed Tier-A at `3669e9b87` / topic `3eab955b1`; same author executing S3 hydration/browser-fixture/docs | Stop after S3 for fresh Tier-A; both expensive gates remain unleased and NOT_RUN | + +S2 acceptance on #1664 required both call-graph review and the full CLI suite: the focused suites +were green while a stale template assertion still encoded the removed bridge import. The repaired +gate is now executable in all three dimensions: exact allowed import set, forbidden legacy symbol, +and direct invalidation literal order. Runtime ownership remains empty. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T15:12:31Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 S3 Tier-A `PASS` at `9a26c107a` / topic `aa4749da4`; fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL `1fbb1c07-…` is active | Verdict artifact only; no runtime gate, readiness, relabel, or product repair during evaluation | +| features | #1664 S4 Tier-A `PASS` at `1c1f45820` / topic `84568f2ff`, but pre-lease finding F2 is under bounded same-author recovery | No lease or expensive gate until the missing exact scaffold scenarios exist, cheap receipts are renewed, and fresh Tier-A passes | + +#1664's four cheap receipts are genuine and sufficient at content head `32ea23f50`, but cheap +convergence is not itself a runtime-lease grant. The accepted plan requires the `payments` second +service, key-isolation, idempotent regeneration, and live Rename/+1-refetch scenarios to exist +before lease acquisition; none exists at `1c1f45820`. The Fresh controlled-clock prerequisite does. +Serialization remains per topic. The singleton runtime mutex is free; Docker and Aspire application +ownership are empty. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T15:25:00Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 formal IMPL-EVAL `PASS` at evaluator head `0fed4d7ff`; acceptance reconciled and exact-head readiness CI active | Merge only after current required checks are terminal green; next fixes leaf stays queued until shipped lifecycle is terminal | +| features | #1664 F2 plan locked/pushed at `4be440020` before code; same original author implementing gates/probes/tests | No runtime lease, Aspire, Docker, `scaffold.runtime`, `fresh-browser`, or evaluator before renewed cheap receipts and fresh Tier-A | + +#1665's draft check set was vacuous and is not accepted as green; leaving draft at the evaluator +head is what starts the required product validation. #1664's plan placement in `scaffold-gates.ts` +is acceptable only if the final catalog proves the first three gates in both suites immediately +after init and the live refetch gate in runtime only after readiness. The singleton runtime mutex +remains free and serialization remains per topic. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T15:34:28Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 readiness quality failed on stale generated agent-docs assets; scope amendment `ef396767a`, same original author regenerating and verifying exactly two assets | Fresh fixes Tier-A and a proportionate source-to-generated delta evaluation are required before readiness resumes | +| features | #1664 plan split `93fb5532d` preceded product head `787cfa928`, but topic `37372cbae` intercepted two executable CDP proof defects | Same-author additive repair, renewed receipts, and fresh Tier-A before any runtime lease | + +#1665's formal product evaluation remains valid, but its exact-head readiness claim does not: the +authorized query-bridge source edit feeds the checked-in agent-docs bundle. The canonical generator +changed only `prose.json.gz` and `provenance.json`; bounded checks are active. #1664's first product +commit uses `Fetch.continueRequest` for a response-stage pause and snapshots its request baseline +after a fixed sleep. Those cannot prove a settled `+1` refetch. The same author is repairing the +committed head without rewriting history. Runtime ownership remains empty. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T15:50:53Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 corpus repair passed Tier-A and delta evaluation, but readiness exposed a second transitive generated dependency; scope checkpoint `215aae4b2` authorizes only the embedded CLI agent-docs barrel | Same-author generation, fresh Tier-A, and one focused asset-chain delta verdict before readiness | +| features | #1664 corrected probe head `2c8219968` is pushed; fresh four-receipt generation active | No runtime lease until current-head receipts and fresh Tier-A pass | + +#1665's exact corpus fidelity verdict remains valid for its two-asset scope, but quality run +`31893659579` / job `95033583015` fails `check:assets-barrel`: the CLI embedded agent-docs barrel +still contains the old corpus. #1664 now forces a Refresh-driven completed/stable list baseline, +uses `Fetch.continueResponse`, and tests the shared stability primitive against a late initial +request. Runtime ownership remains empty. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T15:57:31Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 link-3 author is active; exact four-link closure and link-4 scope amendment are pushed at `92ea9f829` | Finish link 3, then the same author regenerates only link 4; no Tier-A/evaluator/readiness until one closure head | +| features | #1664 fresh F2 Tier-A passed at evidence head `b14975af7` / topic `63d190d4b`; singleton S5 runtime lease granted | `scaffold.runtime` then `fresh-browser`, serially, with clean audit between and after; no evaluator yet | + +#1665's fourth branch-caused link is `packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts`; there is no +fifth checked-in mirror. The identical four-path cascade was already known from shipped #1652, so +not reusing it when #1665 changed Query Bridge docs is recorded as a coordinator/process miss. +#1664's lease preflight found zero Docker containers, Aspire application/AppHost/DCP or browser +processes, relevant ports, or competing lease owners; idle Aspire MCP helpers are not application +resources. The PR remains draft and labels remain unchanged. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T16:03:00Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 link 3 is clean/pushed at `27a64ea4c`; same-author link-4 dispatch is queued from topic `a9176278a` | Canonical `gen:publish-assets` only, hard stop on any extra path; no Tier-A/evaluator/readiness before it lands | +| features | #1664 `scaffold.runtime` failed honestly after 6 passes; cleanup is clean and lease released at topic `d2e83f690` | Amend F3 before mutation, same author repair, fresh Tier-A, then request a new lease; `fresh-browser` is NOT_RUN | + +#1664's runtime failure contains three independent compiler diagnostics: missing generated database +Zod output and two payments list-input mismatches. The original report characterized only the input +shape and was corrected before repair. F3 must use the real users/payments contracts, prove resource +prefix isolation without assuming identical input tails, and resolve the canonical schema-generation +precondition without inventing a fake generated module. #1665 remains serial: publish assets consume +the just-landed CLI barrel. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T16:14:20Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 final cascade head `9a2c74c41` passed fresh Tier-A at topic `cbd32230e`; fresh chain evaluator `262ef8e1-…` / bridge `cse_01E3Q…` is active | Evaluator artifact-only; no readiness/relabel/merge until terminal PASS and exact-head reconciliation | +| features | #1664 pushed F3 input-isolation amendment `c4a900adc` before the new module; same author continues cheap proof | Four new receipts and fresh Tier-A before any new runtime lease; `fresh-browser` remains NOT_RUN | + +The #1665 closure proof is simultaneous rather than historical: the three generators all pass and +leave the same detached tree clean. #1664's new internal module is a justified proof-transport split, +not a product-surface expansion: the generated app cannot resolve the parent probe's monorepo import +map, so only dependency-free input derivation moves. Runtime ownership remains empty. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T16:27:03Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 final chain evaluator `PASS` at artifact head `ac274a464`; exact-head readiness has only `check-test` active | Do not relabel or merge until that final check is terminal green and review threads are rechecked | +| features | #1664 F3 product head `6e822a74b` is clean/pushed, but the first new root-check receipt is preserved `FAIL` | Stop every later receipt, lease, runtime gate, and evaluator until same-author isolated causality is proven and any leaf-caused repair is amended before mutation | + +#1665's evaluator independently reproduced all three freshness gates in one clean detached tree, +matched the prose payload and provenance through both generated consumers, found no fifth mirror, +and preserved every named pre-existing red. #1664's first F3 binding receipt instead reports TS2322 +in the unchanged reconnect diagnostic. That does not establish non-causality: F3 replaced +`@std/path` with `node:path` in the shared check batch, while the prior exact-head receipt passed. +The original author is executing a before/after archive proof. Runtime ownership remains empty. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T16:31:00Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `0ca4c489f` | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1663 remains at the exceptional-final-PLAN-EVAL owner boundary on `194e22a3d` | No third evaluator or product mutation without the owner's explicit verdict | +| fixes | #1665 merged as `3e8e146a4`; topic supervisor reconciling closure then advancing its documented serial queue | Only one next dependency-ready leaf; preserve normal research/plan and evaluator gates | +| features | #1664 preserved the failed binding receipt at pushed artifact head `3278cca34`; same-author repair evidence is active | Amendment-before-mutation, distinct replacement receipts, fresh Tier-A, then a new lease request only after clean audit | + +#1665 exact-head `check-test` completed successfully, leaving no pending or failing check and no +review thread. The coordinator applied the sole `status:ready-merge` label and squash-merged the PR; +all five closing-keyword issues closed automatically. #1664's isolated pre-F3 archive check passed, +so the new shared-batch TS2322 cannot be classified as carried baseline. The features supervisor has +bounded the likely repair to removing Node path/type pollution while preserving every F3 contract. +Runtime ownership remains empty. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T16:43:09Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked | Do not invent post-freeze work | +| internals | #1666 scope amendment `a3f6b87b5` is pushed; fresh Tier-A is next | Then one Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL cycle 1; keep #1663 parked at its owner-only third-cycle boundary | +| fixes | #1461 Sol/medium author is researching and planning from main `3e8e146a4` | No product mutation before draft plan, fresh Tier-A, and required PLAN-EVAL; no runtime lease | +| features | #1664 repair evidence `8940e9266` and Tier-A topic `c7ce2c3f6` are PASS; singleton runtime lease is active | Run `scaffold.runtime`, clean/audit, then `fresh-browser` only on PASS, clean/audit again; no evaluator yet | + +#1664 local, remote, and PR heads are equal and the clean-host preflight found zero Docker, Aspire +application/AppHost/DCP, browser, relevant port, or competing lease owner. #1665 lifecycle is fully +normalized to shipped and #1668 owns its unrelated export-corpus follow-up. The coordinator remains +GPT-5.6-SOL/high over Codex Remote Control, never max; all existing native Claude topic supervisors +and #1651's accepted keep-and-narrow adapter boundary are preserved. + +At 16:49Z, #1666 advanced to one active formal PLAN-EVAL (`68c31fcc`, Fable 5/medium Remote +Control) after fresh Tier-A PASS at topic `d5f5ea55a`. #1461 is now draft PR #1669 at plan head +`7e5be1514`; fixes Tier-A must require a pre-implementation amendment for the duplicate false +live-dashboard cache-refresh claim and reconcile the doc-lint baseline before evaluator dispatch. + +At 16:53Z, #1664 `scaffold.runtime` stopped at 20/1/0 on the leaf's own false idempotency premise. +The host is empty, the lease is released, and fresh-browser remains NOT_RUN. Features must push an +F4 proof-contract amendment before same-author repair: allow post-plugin reconciliation, then demand +zero client/helper writes from the next identical invocation; renew cheap receipts and Tier-A before +requesting another runtime lease. No evaluator is authorized. + +At 16:58Z all singleton leases are free. #1666 cycle-1 PLAN-EVAL failed at `5d229e0f3`; SA-2 grants +three exact Contracts JSDoc import-line repairs and one fresh cycle-2 evaluator only after repaired +plan Tier-A. #1664 is in same-author F4 plan/proof repair after consecutive zero-write/hash evidence +proved the S5 idempotency assertion was positioned before convergence. #1461 remains plan-only while +its exact second tutorial source is added to scope. All three lanes remain independent and serial +within themselves; #1663 and docs stay parked. + +### Live transition — 2026-08-15T17:11:14Z + +| Lane | Current serial action | Hard boundary | +| --- | --- | --- | +| docs | Queue exhausted and parked at `5c4ccd8fe` | Do not invent work | +| internals | #1666 preserved author is repairing SA-2 plan-only at topic `071b2a812` | Fresh Tier-A, then exactly one cycle-2 Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL; #1663 untouched | +| fixes | #1461 amendment `eadd672d0` received Tier-A `FAIL_FIX` at topic `9e9d02ebb`; bounded T-1 plan repair is required | No PLAN-EVAL or product mutation before the same-page narrative has an explicit per-line disposition and fresh Tier-A passes | +| features | #1664 F4 evidence `6f813b0db` and topic Tier-A `35f3a6975` are PASS; immutable attempt-3 singleton runtime lease is active | Run `scaffold.runtime`, clean/audit, then `fresh-browser` only on PASS; clean/audit again; no evaluator yet | + +#1664 local, remote, and PR heads are equal and the preflight found zero Docker containers, Aspire +application processes, relevant listening ports, or competing lease owners. All preflight artifacts +were already committed before the lease, so the authorized evidence head cannot move as it did on +attempt 2. Coordinator remains GPT-5.6-SOL/high through Remote Control, never max. Native Claude +topic supervisors and #1651 option-1 keep-and-narrow architecture remain preserved. + +At 17:18Z, #1666 is in its final ordinary PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 after plan-only head `80046696e` passed +fresh internals Tier-A at topic `bb8c12f56`. The evaluator is a fresh native Fable 5/medium process, +session `580832d7-53e8-4828-ad41-e2f9219c9340`, PID 379716, launched with Remote Control over that +exact head. Its bridge attachment metadata is not yet emitted and is recorded as pending rather than +invented. This evaluator runs concurrently with #1664's leased runtime because serialization is per +orchestrator; neither lane may start a second evaluator/gate of its own. + +At 17:19Z, #1664 attempt 3 stopped honestly after 32 passes on one red: +`generated.deno-fmt-check` ran the generated workspace's `fmt:check` and exited 1. The repaired +`generated.service-client-contract` passed, so F4 is proven effective. Suite cleanup passed, +run-owned teardown found nothing, and independent leak-check reports Aspire/Docker ok with zero +survivors. The singleton lease is released; `fresh-browser` remains NOT_RUN. Preserve the raw log +and attribute the format drift before any amendment, repair, or retry. + +At 17:29Z, #1461 repaired plan head `23db20f30` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at topic `f71e860f9`; its +separate Fable 5/medium PLAN-EVAL is active as job `01f0eda8`, bridge +`cse_01SWnk7LwvoLaamvEwR5WLfX`, exact source head, Remote Control. #1666's initial cycle-2 transport +was interrupted after verification but before artifact or verdict; the same evaluator history was +recovered without consuming another cycle as job `0e2d1e57`, bridge +`cse_01K6SbsotG5MyjyjTd11SrfK`. Features is independently re-reviewing all twelve generated format +paths because the author proved only one helper baseline while several red paths are leaf-owned. + +At 17:32Z, #1666 cycle-2 PLAN-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at evaluator commit `45c249b9c`, comment +`5303401348`; internals topic `fd96c2075` has resumed the preserved Sol/medium author into S1 only, +with S2/S3 held for serial slice review. Features topic `0d0ba1b7a` correctly rejected #1664's +blanket attribution as leaf-caused because both generated client modules are unformatted, but its +durable count says six helpers while naming seven and its proposed out-of-scope baseline would keep +the gate red. Coordinator has returned it for exact count correction, baseline measurement of the +three payments paths, and a smallest all-twelve-output normalization seam before any F5 dispatch. + +At 17:36Z, #1669 PLAN-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at `d555cc971`, comment `5303412171`; fixes topic +`370ff6eba` dispatched S1 only to the preserved Sol/medium author, with S2 held for fresh Tier-A. +The evaluator's docs-accuracy refutation is accepted: the S2 page sentence is manual evidence unless +a separate tooling scope is granted. Features corrected #1664's inventory at topic `f5f75adc8` and +proved one post-init canonicalization gap. Coordinator authorized a focused plan amendment only and +rejected post-write-only formatting because it would regress F4 on the next identical invocation; +the amendment must name exact paths, canonicalize before equality/write, and stop for Tier-A. + +At 17:55Z, #1666 S1 `678840603` passed fresh internals Tier-A at `6c183ef16`; S2 alone is active on +the preserved author and S3 remains held. #1664 F5 plan `3204ffa98` received features Tier-A +`FAIL_FIX` at `c8d3acb92` for three missing transport-safety proofs and an unjustified composition +path; the same author is repairing plan artifacts only. #1669 behavior head `e05a54145` is pushed, +but its 499-line F-1 claim is rejected because it deleted useful JSDoc/spacing to hit the threshold. +The same author is restoring it and must reduce structurally within two files or return an exact +one-file helper proposal for scope ruling. No runtime lease exists; #1663 remains owner-only. + +At 18:00Z, #1666 S2 is clean/pushed at `47ca22abe`; fresh internals Tier-A is active and S3 remains +held. The three implementation paths expose the least-privilege named task, route `docs:accuracy` +through it, and add one guarded repo-root Pages step without widening triggers; the live Pages build +is still terminalizing. #1664's plan-only repair `630185e2c` passed fresh features Tier-A at topic +`53f97644d`; the same preserved Sol/high author is implementing the unchanged 15-product/12-test F5 +ceiling with four fresh binding receipts before another Tier-A. #1669's same-author structural +repair is active and has restored the useful JSDoc while consolidating duplicated cache-entry reads; +S2 remains held. No runtime lease exists, and #1663's owner-only boundary is unchanged. + +At 18:07Z, #1666 S2 is fresh Tier-A `PASS` at topic `dbe72c50e`; S3 is running its final +run-artifact-only evidence serially on exact source head `47ca22abe`. The live Pages classifier and +build are terminal green while unrelated runtime/desktop/core lanes skipped. #1669's transparent +repair head `e100ea205` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `c01f32141`: all documentation is restored, +the shared cache-entry reader is a coherent structural reduction, 5/5 focused and 68/68 SDK tests +pass, and no F-1 remains. S2 dispatch recovery is active on the same original author; no runtime +lease exists. #1664 F5 implementation continues independently inside its reviewed ceiling. + +At 18:11Z, #1669 S2 delivery is verified on the preserved author. Its exact final-slice surface is +the two approved docs pages, one query-factory regression, four generated mirrors, and run artifacts; +the docs-accuracy overclaim is forbidden and the tutorial sentence remains manual Tier-A plus +IMPL-EVAL evidence. The author must preserve all pinned baseline reds and stop for fresh review. + +At 18:17Z, #1669 S2 stopped before generation/commit on a real pre-existing SDK defect: the current +branch fetches a fresh entry whenever `preferFreshOnStale` is true, contradicting the option's +stale-only contract. Coordinator authorized a plan-only amendment adding exactly `cache-query.ts` +back to the correction surface. The repaired condition must preserve expired-entry precedence and +block only for stale entries; the already-authorized factory regression proves fresh/missing/two +overlapping stale cases. Fresh fixes Tier-A is required before mutation; no extra test file, mirror, +runtime lease, or gate is authorized yet. + +At 18:25Z, #1666 final Tier-A is `PASS` at internals topic `18eed10c9`; immutable source +`47ca22abe` plus evidence `d095c1260` are entering one fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control +IMPL-EVAL, artifact-only. #1669 plan-only S2-A `ef3e43f06` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `684c37d63`; +the same author is resumed for the one predicate repair and remaining S2. #1664 F5 content +`fda78ee43` plus evidence `1263f655b` have four unique PASS/SUFFICIENT receipts; final features +Tier-A is active before any runtime lease. The pinned Deno probe accepts all 26 formatter allowlist +members, and 15 product/11 test/zero outside-ceiling paths are touched. + +At 18:30Z, #1664 final F5 Tier-A is `PASS` at `9a5521aa0`. Coordinator preflight under the Aspire +orchestration contract found the leaf clean and local/remote/PR equal at `1263f655b`, `aspire ps []`, +zero Docker containers, zero AppHost/DCP/application/browser processes, zero relevant listeners, and +no competing runtime lease; foreign Aspire MCP helpers remain untouched. Attempt 4 now holds the +singleton runtime lease at immutable evidence `1263f655b` / content `fda78ee43`. Features must run +suite-owned `scaffold.runtime`, preserve the exact result, clean/audit, and run `fresh-browser` only +if scaffold passes, followed by final cleanup/audit; no evaluator yet. #1666's native Fable 5/medium +Remote Control IMPL-EVAL is active as `3882ca70`, bridge `cse_013RnnFDtHQhEbFhJCLbkEsD`. #1669's +author has applied the exact approved one-line predicate correction and remains bounded to S2. + +At 18:41Z, #1666 cycle-1 IMPL-EVAL is terminal `FAIL_FIX` at `4c09e9203`, comment `5303665087`. +The evaluator proved three of four refusal tests are non-discriminating: a missing fixture path can +stand in for reason/mode refusal, and OMITS can mask INVENTS. Checker behavior and all other ten +judgments hold. Internals topic `3c8db8178` recovered the same original Sol/medium author on exactly +the already-authorized test path. Require specific refusal-cause assertions, a real fixture, no +INVENTS/OMITS masking, four mutation reds, all seven receipts re-cut at one head, and fresh Tier-A +before one cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL. No product or workflow repair, runtime lease, or #1663 mutation. + +At 18:48Z, #1664 attempt-4 `scaffold.runtime` stopped red at 69 passed / 1 failed / 0 skipped. The +generated formatting gate that failed attempt 3 is now green. The sole red is +`behavior.service-client-refetch`: `collectBrowserRefetchEvidence` called `child.kill('SIGTERM')` +after the browser child had already terminated, producing a Deno `TypeError`. Preserve the raw log +at SHA-256 `b476da4ce039d03785e46669d51919b48c41fbae80ca41ca9188bcbb53e97f23`; do not infer the refetch +behavior from a cleanup exception. Suite cleanup passed and the independent host audit is empty. +Lease released, `fresh-browser` `NOT_RUN`; same-author plus fresh Tier-A attribution precedes scope. + +At 19:03Z, all three independent topic queues have concrete forward motion. #1664 pushed the F6 +plan-only amendment at `36da13fa1`, comment `5303765269`; fresh features Tier-A is active before the +same original Sol/high author may touch exactly the browser probe and its existing test. #1666 has +the discriminating test repair at content `423867017` and local evidence `010da98a2`; seven new +PASS receipts bind the content head, while the initial root-test red caused by a temporary mutation +archive remains append-only. Internals is driving explicit push/comment then fresh Tier-A and the +final ordinary IMPL-EVAL cycle. #1669 S2 is clean/pushed at evidence `9aa54ae2d` / content +`eba0b0924`, comment `5303754598`; fixes is independently re-running the fresh Tier-A proof before +IMPL-EVAL. The runtime mutex is free. A second host audit found and removed four stopped +`aspire-managed nuget search` children that `aspire ps []` did not expose; final Aspire, Docker, +application-process, browser, and port audits are empty. #1663 and #1651 option 1 remain unchanged. + +Follow-on at 19:05Z: #1666 evidence `010da98a2` is explicitly pushed with comment `5303770640` and +fresh internals Tier-A is active. #1664 F6 plan Tier-A passed at topic `f436df086`; the same original +Sol/high author is now implementing exactly the two reviewed paths and must stop after focused tests, +four exact-content-head binding receipts, explicit push/comment, and a second fresh Tier-A. No +runtime lease is active or requested. + +At 19:08Z, #1666 repair Tier-A is `PASS` at internals topic `0646f429f`; final ordinary cycle-2 +IMPL-EVAL is active as native Fable 5/medium Remote Control job `7a3b4645`, URL +`session_01MDMbe68iYvjHBLuUGKZqBS`, over content `423867017` plus evidence `010da98a2`. #1669 final +S2 Tier-A is `PASS` at fixes topic `a374977d8`; cycle-1 IMPL-EVAL is active on native Fable 5/medium +Remote Control job `f40814ce`, URL `session_01CMrdm9P2YwHxiNCT49C4Hf`, over content `eba0b0924` +plus evidence `9aa54ae2d`. #1664's same-author two-path repair remains independently active. Topic +serialization is local to each supervisor; the runtime mutex remains free. + +At 19:14Z, #1666 final cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at evaluator commit `ee67d12b4`, +comment `5303804773`. The evaluator independently mutation-proved all four refusals red, accepted the +seven selected PASS receipts plus preserved scratch-contaminated red, and re-derived the remaining +#1296 rows, scope, lock, discoverability, baseline reds, and browser waiver. The dispatch brief had +two stale short-SHA sentences naming `47ca22abe`, but its correct binding section named `423867017` +and the evaluator artifact/comment use `423867017` consistently; record the contradiction as +non-impacting brief drift. Internals is preparing coordinator-owned readiness/close-gate evidence; +no merge or issue-box mutation has occurred. + +At 19:18Z, coordinator close-gate preparation for #1666 is complete at unchanged evaluated head +`ee67d12b4`: PR body now has nine checked current DoD boxes, the sole machine-readable #1296 +acceptance mapping is comment `5303825255`, and the live mirror dry-run accepts all five entries. +The coordinator changed `status:impl` to `status:ready-merge` while draft, verified the dry-run, then +marked the PR ready for review. Current-head CI run `31903523137` and companion workflows are active; +the real mirror must mutate all five boxes and close-gate/core visibility must succeed before merge. + +At 19:24Z, #1666 readiness is revoked after current-head CI distinguished one orchestration race +from one real owned omission. The close-gate ran before the live `status:ready-merge` label was +visible, so it made no #1296 mutation and is rerunnable later; quality independently proved the +Fresh UI reference rewrite left the tracked agent-docs corpus stale. The coordinator returned #1666 +to draft/`status:impl`, removed `status:ready-merge`, preserved the cycle-2 PASS as pre-finding +evidence, and authorized only a same-author plan-first generator-cascade rescope, two fresh Tier-A +reviews, renewed exact-head receipts, and a delta IMPL-EVAL before readiness. #1664 meanwhile +preserved its first F6 root-test receipt red at evidence `4c7792f20`: 4228/1/19 was caused by the +scanner entering an ignored root-owned Postgres temp tree. The exact tree is recoverably quarantined +at `/tmp/netscript-f6-quarantine.7kXcDX`; attempt 2 must be distinct at unchanged product +`7fa29ad3e`. No runtime lease is active. #1663 and #1651 option 1 remain untouched. + +At 19:31Z, #1669 cycle-1 IMPL-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at artifact-only `313cc08d5`, comment +`5303850473`, with local/remote/PR equality and zero review threads. The coordinator made all eleven +PR DoD rows current, posted the sole six-box #1461 mapping in comment `5303873817`, applied +`impl-eval:skip` and `status:ready-merge` while draft, and verified the live mirror dry-run against +issue-body SHA-256 `20b6370fdf3ed8491c30a052c75b6a6c33b529b4a278c8a39a6243847f47387e`. +Only then was the PR marked ready. Exact-head CI run `31904125478` is active; merge and #1350 dispatch +remain blocked until the real mirror, close-gate, required core checks, and generated closure are +terminal green. This readiness action uses no runtime lease. + +At 19:39Z, #1664 F6 final Tier-A is `PASS` at topic `a4224dbb1`, pushed evidence `a8a160285` over +product `7fa29ad3e`. The preserved red and replacement root-test receipts have the identical 4248 +total results: exactly one failure became a pass, with no removed or skipped test. All four selected +receipts are PASS/SUFFICIENT. Coordinator preflight found local/remote/PR equality, a clean leaf, +`aspire ps []`, Docker zero, no application/browser/runtime process or relevant listener; the +query's transient `aspire-managed` helper exited before the post-query audit. Attempt 5 now owns the +singleton runtime lease: `scaffold.runtime` once, cleanup/audit, then `fresh-browser` only on PASS, +followed by final cleanup/audit. Any red stops; no evaluator or retry is authorized. + +At 19:40Z, #1669 exact-head CI is fully green: the live mirror checked all six #1461 boxes, and +close-gate, quality, check-test, and core visibility succeeded. With zero review threads and +mergeability CLEAN, the coordinator squash-merged evaluated head `313cc08d5` as main +`0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb`. #1461 closed automatically one second later; both PR +and issue are normalized to exactly `status:shipped`. The evaluator's cross-page and warm-stale +advisories do not invalidate #1461: the named external pages attach no false revalidation claim and +their layer policy can own background behavior. One precise Backlog/Triage follow-up is authorized +from fixes topic draft `70307f47c`. #1350 is released serially on new main. #1348 stays open until all +its implementation children finish, while its already-ratified Stage-0 prerequisite is satisfied. + +At 19:44Z, #1666 SA-3 is plan-only, clean, and pushed at `f98cfabac`, comment `5303922392`. +Fresh internals Tier-A is `PASS`: isolated base/head generation proves exactly four affected outputs, +the MCP export corpus is a byte-identical pre-existing red at both heads and is excluded, the live +ceiling is 17 paths, and CLI/MCP publish deltas plus the full idempotence/receipt recut are explicit. +The same original Sol/medium author is now running only the three canonical generators over the four +approved outputs; a second fresh Tier-A and delta IMPL-EVAL remain mandatory. Fixes filed the accepted +non-blocking docs follow-up as #1670, then launched #1350 plan-only on fresh main `0ef48c2ec` with +Codex thread `01a006f3-ae2d-7941-bd17-2ac71dd3d0f0`, Sol/medium. #1348 remains open and untouched. + +At 19:47Z, #1664 attempt 5 is terminal red at 69/1/0. F6 successfully removed the teardown mask; +the behavior gate now reports its own failure: Chrome never exposed a DevTools target before the +bounded wait expired. Raw log SHA-256 is +`ff349b40f7f70341934e170df7c67d147c0ed983173b41871421755ad55e062b`. Suite Aspire cleanup passed; +`fresh-browser` is `NOT_RUN`. The coordinator and features supervisor verified and removed only three +stopped run-owned `aspire-managed` children by exact PID, then re-audited Aspire, Docker, +application/browser/runtime processes, and relevant listeners empty. The lease is released. Preserve +the red and require measured same-author attribution plus a plan-only amendment and fresh Tier-A +before any mutation or retry; no evaluator is authorized. + +At 19:57Z, the coordinator reconciled a control-plane-only stale record after independently checking +the live #1669 evaluator artifact, verdict comment, shipped leaf lifecycle, and remote `main`. The +evaluator lease is terminal `PASS` at `313cc08d5` rather than active, and `currentMainSha` is the +actual shipped main `0ef48c2ec`. PID `391331` is only a native Claude background spare, not a live +evaluation, so it remains untouched. This repair changes no topic supervisor, leaf, PR, issue, gate, +or runtime lease. + +At 20:17Z, all three topic-local serial queues advanced independently. #1664 corrected the stale F7 +host premise at pushed plan head `a2e9515f5`, comment `5304036438`; features Tier-A passed at topic +`8ec20d606` and released the same Sol/high author for exactly two paths plus four cheap receipts, with +no runtime lease or attempt 6. #1666 pushed recovery evidence `b67414f4f`, comment `5304045867`: the +supervisor-owned ignored hook transcript is recoverably quarantined with identical SHA-256 +`d0251bc2…ab2`, and the sole unchanged-head retry passed 4203/0/19 while the 4202/1/19 red remains. +Fresh internals Tier-A is active. #1671 plan amendment `2fa2f71dc`, comment `5304017800`, passed fixes +Tier-A at topic `6c9486004`; its sole Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL is active in session +`session_015RuDy1h3UiCkLzo1PLk5Sc`. #1663 and #1651 option 1 remain untouched. + +Follow-on at 20:23Z: #1671 PLAN-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at artifact-only `f76a3c45b`, comment +`5304059808`, with route/session binding intact. Fixes released S1 only to the same Sol/medium author, +carrying both RED diagnostics and the no-seventh-path/no-metadata-vocabulary constraints. #1666 +second Tier-A passed at topic `8933f58f2`; because idempotence was the one explicitly carried claim, +the fresh delta evaluator must re-derive it. Exactly one Fable 5/medium Remote Control evaluator is +active as job `f281b8cf`, PID 793975, session `session_01UDGunAVYYPRC6KBNxEwZWA`, over content +`46528ae4c` and evidence `b67414f4f`. No readiness or runtime action is authorized. + + +At 20:38Z, all three topic-local queues advanced again. #1666 fresh delta IMPL-EVAL returned `PASS` +at `0d4c82d6e`, comment `5304103041`, after independently paying the full two-run Lume/generator +cost and re-deriving all five #1296 rows. GitHub nevertheless reports the branch conflicting with +current main `0ef48c2ec`; read-only merge-tree confines the overlap to the same four generated +publication outputs advanced by #1665. Internals checkpoint `268544516` released the original +Sol/medium author for a deterministic current-main cascade refresh, followed by fresh Tier-A and a +fresh delta evaluator before readiness. #1671 S1 is pushed at `dc034d680`, comment `5304110615`, and +fresh fixes Tier-A passed at `7281cebac`; S2 alone is active on the same Sol/medium author across +`errors.ts`, `service-client.ts`, and the doctest. #1664 product `e45144db6` passed 22 focused tests +and the exact-head check, then preserved a 4236/1/19 root-test red caused by unreadable attempt-5 +residue. Features recoverably quarantined it at `/tmp/netscript-f7-quarantine.iXF6fb`, recorded +checkpoint `d81b99143`, and released one exact-content test retry plus the remaining two cheap gates +on PASS. No runtime lease, attempt 6, readiness action, issue tick, or #1663/#1651 mutation exists. + + +At 20:56Z, #1664 F7 recovery is fully reviewed: evidence `ed3f78e0d`, comment `5304173729`, and +features Tier-A `4a65a2670` prove four exact-content PASS/SUFFICIENT receipts while preserving the +4236/1/19 environmental red. After Aspire/Docker/process/port/residue preflight, three older readable +run-owned workspaces were moved to recoverable quarantine `/tmp/netscript-preattempt6-quarantine.9mNpwE`. +Features checkpoint `ac1ec35cf` now holds the singleton attempt-6 lease: one `scaffold.runtime` with +the verified managed Chrome 151 override, cleanup/audit, then `fresh-browser` only on PASS and a clean +inter-gate audit. #1671 S2 `ca7ade409` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `ac0b2c4c3`; S3 alone is released +to the same author for the two docs pages, with S4 and metadata still held. #1666 current-main union +`8c03d8629` has twelve exact-head PASS receipts and is assembling append-only evidence before push. + +At 21:03Z, #1666's history-preserving current-main refresh is clean, pushed, and independently +Tier-A `PASS`. Content merge `8c03d8629` has parents `0d4c82d6e` and `0ef48c2ec`; artifact head +`021c7ffc6` and comment `5304205247` preserve exactly four generated conflicts, the combined #1665 +and #1666 corpus, two-run convergence with no fifth output, twelve exact-content-head PASS receipts, +14-of-17 scope, and byte-identical `deno.lock`. Internals checkpoint `6658ad9c0` launched one fresh +native Fable 5/medium Remote Control integration-delta evaluator as job `be3774eb`, bridge +`cse_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV`. The earlier `f281b8cf` lease is reconciled terminal `PASS` at +`0d4c82d6e`; it is not a second active evaluator. Readiness, issue mutation, close-gate, and merge +remain held. #1664 attempt 6 and #1671 S3 continue independently under their existing contracts. + +At 21:18Z, #1666's integration-delta evaluator is terminal `PASS` at `05ac90d00` / comment +`5304256350`; Remote Control was visible at +`https://claude.ai/code/session_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV`, and the evaluator lease is released. +Readiness attempt 2 passed the acceptance mirror and close-gate, checking all five open #1296 rows, +but dedicated changed-source CI `31908898023` found an explicit `any` and unsafe cast in the leaf's +checker. The coordinator revoked readiness immediately: #1666 is draft at sole `status:impl`, no +merge occurred, and broad quality's green does not override the focused red. Internals must use the +same original Sol/medium author for one type-safe repair without allowances or scanner weakening, +then perform fresh Tier-A and a fresh delta evaluator before readiness can be reconsidered. + +At 21:31Z, #1664 attempt 6 is terminal `FAIL_FIX` with evidence `2385cdb72` / comment +`5304325367`. The strict managed override selected Chrome for Testing 151 successfully, then +`scaffold.runtime` passed 69 gates and the refetch browser child produced no evidence before exit 143 +at 900,030 ms. `fresh-browser` is `NOT_RUN`; no retry occurred. Three stopped run-owned Aspire +helpers were cleaned exactly, the unreadable generated Postgres tree is preserved recoverably under +`/tmp/netscript-s5-a6-quarantine-20260815-4M9v8k`, and the final Aspire/Docker/process/port/residue +audit is empty. Release the singleton runtime lease. Features must now perform fresh Tier-A causal +classification before any repair amendment, retry, or evaluator. + +At 21:36Z, #1666's focused type-safety repair is clean/pushed at `e357938df`, comment `5304327917`, +and fresh internals Tier-A passed at `138ad7436`. The review rejected an initially mis-scoped +repository-mode scanner result, then proved exact changed-files mode selected both repaired files +and returned zero findings. One separate native Fable 5/medium Remote Control cycle-5 evaluator is +active as job `dc433b8d`, bridge `cse_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC`, URL +`https://claude.ai/code/session_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC`; argv and bidirectional bridge state are +proven. No readiness or merge before its terminal verdict. + +At 21:42Z, #1671 S4 stopped honestly at evidence `db8aadd95` / comment `5304357008`. S3 +`c7cba6d9b` had already passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `580bd8ec0`. The S4 green set is preserved and +surface-diff attributes only the approved +15 signature delta, but raw doc-lint adds leaf-owned +private references (Contracts 9→11, SDK 3→13); later JSR/specifier/export gates are `NOT_RUN`. +Coordinator authorizes same-author plan-only S4-R within exactly `contract-primitives.ts`, +`errors.ts`, and `service-client.ts`, then fresh fixes Tier-A before product repair. No suppression, +metadata, public barrel, seventh path, evaluator, or readiness action. + +At 21:54Z, #1666 cycle-5 IMPL-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at evaluator commit `92988da30`, comment +`5304391856`, native Fable 5/medium Remote Control +`https://claude.ai/code/session_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC`; its evaluator lease is released. The +coordinator repeated the live readiness preflights at the final head, rewrote the PR body, proved zero +review threads plus mirror/close-gate PASS, applied `status:ready-merge` while draft with +`impl-eval:skip` retained, and marked #1666 ready. CI `31910676720` and changed-source quality +`31910676700` are active; no merge until the exact-head set is terminal and truthful. + +Fresh detached sessions prove the OpenAI account has no remaining implementation credits until +`2026-08-20 05:31`; repeated Codex launch attempts are forbidden. The coordinator selected only +documented in-plan artifact routes: #1664 uses a fresh separate Claude Opus 5/medium `chore_code` +agent for the two-line F8 provenance correction, and #1671 uses a fresh separate Claude Sonnet 5/high +`documentation_review` agent for the run-artifact-only S4-R amendment. Both then use a fresh Minimax +M3/high PLAN-EVAL via the native-quota fallback. Topic supervisors remain reviewers/non-authors and +may not self-certify. #1671's later product repair remains on the canonical Codex route after reset; +no outside-plan product route is authorized. #1663's exceptional third-evaluator decision remains +owner-only and untouched. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-docs/codex-thread-ids.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-docs/codex-thread-ids.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..578c391d8f --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-docs/codex-thread-ids.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +# topic-docs-0.0.7 — Codex implementation thread +- **Thread / session id:** `019ffcc0-e19b-71d1-95ce-8c72559eb026` +- **Rollout:** `/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/13/rollout-2026-08-13T22-12-06-019ffcc0-e19b-71d1-95ce-8c72559eb026.jsonl` +- **Worktree:** `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-docs` +- **Branch:** `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-docs` @ `01e096049` (NO upstream by design). +- **Push rule:** explicit refspec only — `git push origin HEAD:refs/heads/orchestrator/release-0.0.7-docs`. +- **Requested route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high +- **Observed route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high +- **Route verdict:** matched +- **Runtime:** approval=never · sandbox=dangerFullAccess +- **Brief (staged):** `/home/codex/topic-docs-0.0.7-brief.md` +## Steering (same thread — never a second send-message-v2 at this worktree) +```bash +codex exec resume 019ffcc0-e19b-71d1-95ce-8c72559eb026 -- "" +``` +_Written by `.llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts`._ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-features/codex-thread-ids.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-features/codex-thread-ids.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..f7acb2b4f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-features/codex-thread-ids.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +# topic-features-0.0.7 — Codex implementation thread +- **Thread / session id:** `019ffcc0-e1d2-7850-a308-354b670c6f3d` +- **Rollout:** `/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/13/rollout-2026-08-13T22-12-07-019ffcc0-e1d2-7850-a308-354b670c6f3d.jsonl` +- **Worktree:** `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-features` +- **Branch:** `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-features` @ `01e096049` (NO upstream by design). +- **Push rule:** explicit refspec only — `git push origin HEAD:refs/heads/orchestrator/release-0.0.7-features`. +- **Requested route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high +- **Observed route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high +- **Route verdict:** matched +- **Runtime:** approval=never · sandbox=dangerFullAccess +- **Brief (staged):** `/home/codex/topic-features-0.0.7-brief.md` +## Steering (same thread — never a second send-message-v2 at this worktree) +```bash +codex exec resume 019ffcc0-e1d2-7850-a308-354b670c6f3d -- "" +``` +_Written by `.llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts`._ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-fixes/codex-thread-ids.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-fixes/codex-thread-ids.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..51caf49409 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-fixes/codex-thread-ids.md @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +# topic-fixes-0.0.7 — Codex implementation thread +- **Thread / session id:** `019ffcc0-e1ae-7b70-b3b8-8804ebd6f773` +- **Worktree:** `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-fixes` +- **Branch:** `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-fixes` @ `01e096049` (NO upstream by design). +- **Push rule:** explicit refspec only — `git push origin HEAD:refs/heads/orchestrator/release-0.0.7-fixes`. +- **Requested route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high +- **Observed route:** provider=pending · model=pending · effort=pending +- **Route verdict:** pending +- **Runtime:** approval=never · sandbox=dangerFullAccess +- **Brief (staged):** `/home/codex/topic-fixes-0.0.7-brief.md` +## Steering (same thread — never a second send-message-v2 at this worktree) +```bash +codex exec resume 019ffcc0-e1ae-7b70-b3b8-8804ebd6f773 -- "" +``` +_Written by `.llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts`._ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-internals/codex-thread-ids.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-internals/codex-thread-ids.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..958adcd88e --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/topic-internals/codex-thread-ids.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +# topic-internals-0.0.7 — Codex implementation thread +- **Thread / session id:** `019ffcc0-e1b5-74f0-96eb-cdeb298d6b17` +- **Rollout:** `/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/13/rollout-2026-08-13T22-12-06-019ffcc0-e1b5-74f0-96eb-cdeb298d6b17.jsonl` +- **Worktree:** `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-internals` +- **Branch:** `orchestrator/release-0.0.7-internals` @ `01e096049` (NO upstream by design). +- **Push rule:** explicit refspec only — `git push origin HEAD:refs/heads/orchestrator/release-0.0.7-internals`. +- **Requested route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high +- **Observed route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high +- **Route verdict:** matched +- **Runtime:** approval=never · sandbox=dangerFullAccess +- **Brief (staged):** `/home/codex/topic-internals-0.0.7-brief.md` +## Steering (same thread — never a second send-message-v2 at this worktree) +```bash +codex exec resume 019ffcc0-e1b5-74f0-96eb-cdeb298d6b17 -- "" +``` +_Written by `.llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts`._ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/worklog.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0ce40c17b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7--orchestration/worklog.md @@ -0,0 +1,1518 @@ +# Worklog — release 0.0.7 + +| Time (UTC) | Event | Evidence | +| ------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 2026-08-13T18:35:10.000Z | Coordinator run activated on a clean `main` baseline. | `git status`; `git rev-parse HEAD` | +| 2026-08-13T18:35:10.000Z | Live milestone surface captured; Step 0 hard dispatch gate remains closed. | GitHub milestone `#27`: 61 open issues; token check PASS | +| 2026-08-13T18:38:26.000Z | Admitted #1564 from Backlog as release-critical CI correctness scope. | Owner false-positive directive; [admission comment](https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1564#issuecomment-5284900986) | +| 2026-08-13T18:40:00.000Z | Provisional 62-issue inventory, four-lane ownership, and eight-wave DAG rendered and validated. | `harness:milestone:test`: 15 pass; `harness:milestone:validate`: `ok: true` | +| 2026-08-13T18:43:18.739Z | Provider/quota and paid-transport preflight passed. | Claude first-party Max; Codex ChatGPT authenticated; `agentic:runtime doctor`: `no_change`, all components ready; routing state `[]` | +| 2026-08-13T21:08:31.000Z | Bounded eight-surface synthesis completed; corrected live-snapshot drift and validated 62 unique initial targets with #1564 alone in wave 0. | `step0-synthesis.json`; `step0-synthesis.md`; Claude session `93ddfd19` stopped after artifact delivery | +| 2026-08-13T21:12:00.000Z | Scope freeze completed: #1453 moved on repository-boundary evidence; #1249 and #1637 admitted under `high-value-coherent`; #1384/#1385 retained in 0.0.8 to avoid partial auth workarounds. | Public issue disposition/admission comments; `milestone-intake.json` | +| 2026-08-13T21:15:00.000Z | RFC 0001 board reconciled and #1564/#1403 ownership boundary settled. | Top-of-body normative amendments on #1348/#1349/#1351/#1352/#1353; [ratification record](https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1348#issuecomment-5285273104); [CI boundary](https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/issues/1564#issuecomment-5285276645) | +| 2026-08-13T21:16:00.000Z | Canonical 64-target/63-active inventory, 46 leaves, and 10-wave DAG rendered and validated. | `harness:milestone:test`: 15 pass; `harness:milestone:validate`: `ok: true` | +| 2026-08-13T21:27:00.000Z | Discharged two live false positives before PLAN-EVAL: #1306 is fixed by Aspire 13.4.6 plus NetScript's generated agent skill; #1606's JSR observation is satisfied. | `aspire ps/describe --help`; `.agents/skills/aspire/SKILL.md`; `skills.generated.ts`; JSR package metadata and landing page; public close comments | +| 2026-08-13T21:28:00.000Z | Re-froze the plan at 64 targets / 61 active / 44 leaves and locked the six material remedy choices called out by synthesis. | `plan.md`; `milestone-leaf-plan.json`; four milestone control artifacts | +| 2026-08-13T22:05:00.000Z | Composed PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 returned `CHANGES_REQUESTED`; no implementation dispatched. | `plan-eval.md`; PR #1641 plan-eval comment; Claude session `2439b19d-5df7-4920-9fce-fa5831ec4fdf` | +| 2026-08-13T22:12:00.000Z | Captured paid-transport and quota evidence. | Codex ChatGPT: 77% primary remaining, weekly reset 2026-08-20 05:31 Europe/Zurich; Claude first-party Max: 6% all-model / 2% Fable weekly remaining, reset 2026-08-15 00:00 | +| 2026-08-13T22:35:00.000Z | Rewrote #1348–#1353 Acceptance contracts in place, locked #1249/#1451 decisions, synchronized #1377, and created residual Aspire docs issue #1642. | Live GitHub issue bodies and comments | +| 2026-08-13T22:42:00.000Z | Re-audited every #1564 construct; closed it completed because all live changed-file consumers are safe and #1403 already fixed the affected construct. Removed the false wave-zero barrier and moved #1360 to features. | #1564 correction comment; 60 active / 43 leaves / nine waves; lane counts 1/16/26/17 | +| 2026-08-13T22:48:00.000Z | Added per-leaf surfaces, archetypes, overlays, proving gates, JSR applicability, risk register, collision ownership, release evidence ids, two read-only watchers, and exact OIDC/artifact-pinned stable conditions. | `leaf-contracts.json`; repaired plan/state/DAG/inventory | +| 2026-08-13T23:03:00.000Z | PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 approved the repaired plan. Fable completed evidence collection, hit monthly spend before verdict text, and the same conversation emitted the final synthesis through the recorded Opus fallback. | `plan-eval-cycle-2.md`; evaluator session `2439b19d-5df7-4920-9fce-fa5831ec4fdf`; evaluated head `331f7c664` | +| 2026-08-13T23:08:44.000Z | Final dispatch recheck passed on unchanged `main`: milestone schema valid; Docker empty; Aspire has no AppHost/resources; coordinator PR merge state clean. | `origin/main` `01e096049`; validator `ok:true`; `docker ps/volume/network`; `aspire stop` + `aspire ps` | +| 2026-08-13T23:10:00.000Z | Materialized four clean topic-control worktrees and locked wave-zero dispatch briefs. | `netscript-007-{docs,internals,fixes,features}`; `briefs/topic-*/implement.md` | +| 2026-08-13T23:12:07.000Z | Activated exactly four attached topic orchestrators on the recorded Codex Sol/high fallback; all four route/worktree identities matched and began working. | `topic-{docs,internals,fixes,features}/codex-thread-ids.md`; `agentic:codex-status` | +| 2026-08-13T23:18:00.000Z | Locked the owner-requested visibility rule: every Claude orchestrator lane must use native `/remote-control` with registry attachment proof. | `agentic:smoke-claude-remote`: version/help/remote-control/agents surfaces all OK; topic briefs + supervisor invariant | +| 2026-08-13T23:25:00.000Z | Wave-zero dispatch reached its exact WIP shape: six attached implementation leaves (docs 1, internals 2, fixes 2, features 1), all based on exact `main` with no upstream and recorded daemon/thread identity. | `milestone-cluster-state.json`; per-leaf `codex-thread-ids.md`; `agentic:codex-status` | +| 2026-08-13T23:32:00.000Z | At the first completed-turn interception, authorized the narrow #1561 mirror-CLI/test extension and resumed the same #1644 implementation thread. #1643 separately proved two manifest values remain schema compatibility fields and narrowed to the silent CLI default plus focused tests. | PRs #1644/#1643; leaf research/drift; same-thread resume `019ffcc9-97ba-7770-a890-a1ebd80ec793` | +| 2026-08-13T23:34:00.000Z | Authorized #1643's narrow focused-test extension and classified the manifest/copy `4437` values as required compatibility metadata rather than mechanically removable dead pins. | Structured plugin validation; #1243/PR #1643 coordinator comments; `leaf-contracts.json` | +| 2026-08-13T23:41:00.000Z | Activated and registry-proved the user-visible native Claude `/remote-control` milestone surface, while preserving exactly four topic lanes; also launched #1651's bounded remote PLAN-EVAL fallback. | Bridge ids `session_016HFNiTigGUb7ieFxqFDvJb` and `session_018f6pxZjiFPaYJF6AFLyLxn`; matching PID/cwd registry records | +| 2026-08-13T23:44:00.000Z | Owner directed both newly created Claude sessions stopped and continuation on the existing Codex train. Both exited cleanly, registry records disappeared, and #1651 retained no evaluator mutation. | Claude resume ids `6e65c618-c957-443a-b713-d0399a891463` / `669d043a-a1e3-4e75-9366-a1ee94f965ba`; process/registry audit clean | +| 2026-08-13T23:47:00.000Z | Amended #1654's leaf contract with the exact generator/scaffolder/test seams required by reproduced #1262/#1588 behavior; classified #1263 OpenAPI projection as already fixed and preservation-only. | PR #1654 research/drift; focused reproduction receipts; `leaf-contracts.json` | +| 2026-08-13T23:52:00.000Z | Stopped the late #1653 Claude-compatible OpenRouter evaluator launched after the owner hold. It had already emitted `FAIL_PLAN`; the verdict is advisory only and no evaluator relaunch is allowed before reset. | OpenRouter session `977b0618-1b0c-4957-8369-698d3c5274c6`; evaluator commit `8a4709afe`; process audit | +| 2026-08-13T23:53:00.000Z | Resolved #1653's coordinator-owned blockers without implementation: #1276 T3 owns all seven allowances, #1545 now states the measured seven, #1655 owns the Workers 20-diagnostic repair in 0.0.8, and the exact coupled test/generated/debt surfaces are authorized. | #1276/#1545/#1655; `leaf-contracts.json`; `deno task doc:lint --root plugins/workers --pretty` | +| 2026-08-13T23:55:00.000Z | Corrected #1652's invalid gate transition: stopped the S1 Codex turn, restored `status:plan-eval`, and left the product/docs tree unmodified. | PR #1652 coordinator hold; worktree head `d35cbca30`; only untracked `plan-eval.md` remained | +| 2026-08-14T00:02:00.000Z | Fully stopped the non-compliant docs topic after two further automatic S1 resumes; reverted its uncommitted docs/navigation patch and removed temporary follower/schema/log processes. | Targeted docs topic process group; clean #1652 worktree at `d35cbca30`; no surviving `019ffcc0-e19b`/`019ffcc9-16c2` process | +| 2026-08-13T21:07:00.000Z | Parked all leaves that require a fresh opposite-family gate and kept only authorized Codex work running. Reconciled #1653's repaired plan, #1643's completed Tier-A handoff, and #1654's approved scope record to their pushed heads. | #1653 `09dfb092d`; #1643 `e6ba15ec6`; #1654 `14d8b38b4`; process audit found no milestone Claude/OpenRouter/Minimax/DeepSeek evaluator | +| 2026-08-13T21:14:00.000Z | Completed #1651's bounded same-thread Codex plan repair without RFC/product implementation and parked it for formal PLAN-EVAL cycle 2. | Clean pushed head `12276e6d8`; structured check/test/publish/architecture/docs/JSR receipts; PR #1651 PLAN-UPDATE | +| 2026-08-13T21:17:00.000Z | Reconciled #1644's final closure contract before packaging: #1621 explicitly requires one operator-guidance sentence, so the previously read-only `netscript-pr` skill became the ninth and final authorized surface. | Live #1621 acceptance; exact `.agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md` amendment; no other scope growth | +| 2026-08-13T21:35:00.000Z | Completed #1644's acceptance guidance, substantive S3 Tier-A review, and immutable structured evidence package; parked the draft leaf at its formal native IMPL-EVAL handoff. | Implementation `634b257ea`; evidence head `4d9fb1967`; check 2,919 files/0 diagnostics; test 4,109 pass/19 ignored/0 fail; quality-job PASS; handoff comment `5286647015` | +| 2026-08-13T21:47:00.000Z | Replaced stale/scattered evaluator handoffs with one coordinator-owned, serial, SHA-locked Saturday dispatch set. No evaluator was launched. | `briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json`; six activation-correct briefs; local/remote/PR/cluster-state validation PASS; native Claude/Fable 5 medium + `/remote-control`, no substitutes | +| 2026-08-14T22:12:38.000Z | Reset-boundary reconciliation completed before mutation. `main`, 60-issue milestone scope, seven draft PR heads, branches, and all clean worktrees match the recorded cluster; live PR checks have zero current failures/pending jobs; Docker and milestone resource leases are empty. | `git ls-remote`; GitHub milestone/PR reads; `agentic:pr-checks` for #1641/#1643/#1644/#1651–#1654; `agentic:codex-status`; process/container/port audit | +| 2026-08-14T22:13:00.000Z | Owner routing correction accepted: Codex remains coordinator; all four legacy Codex topic controllers are preserved but must be parked, then replaced one-for-one by native Claude Remote Control supervisors. | Owner instruction; `supervisor.md` corrected control-plane table; legacy topic threads/worktrees/branches retained | +| 2026-08-14T22:13:00.000Z | Rebuilt the formal-gate route matrix for cost and evidence quality. Six independent gates remain, but the obsolete six-Fable mandate is removed: Sonnet 5 low handles two mechanical gates, Sonnet 5 medium handles four substantive gates, all serial and fresh; Fable is escalation-only after concrete failure evidence and a recorded amendment. | `briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json`; six corrected briefs; owner-authorized route override | +| 2026-08-14T22:18:41.000Z | Parked every legacy Codex topic controller before Claude replacement. Internals/fixes/features returned exact `TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED` receipts and are idle; docs was already absent/offline. All four preserved topic worktrees remain clean at their recorded heads. | `agentic:codex-resume` same-thread receipts; `agentic:codex-status`; direct Git status; no topic controller process | +| 2026-08-14T22:20:00.000Z | Corrected the launch-path diagnosis without widening the coordinator PR into agentic-tool source. Native Claude 2.1.231 directly supports explicit `--model`, `--effort`, initial prompt, and `--remote-control`; the hybrid wrapper is needed only for alternate-worker delegation. | `claude --help`; `claude remote-control --help`; `claude --model claude-sonnet-5 --effort low --version`; `claude-manager` skill | +| 2026-08-14T22:25:56.000Z | Owner rejected Sonnet 5/low as below the topic-supervision floor. All four reconciliation-only canaries returned `TOPIC_CONTROLLER_PARKED_MODEL_FLOOR`, exited, and launched no leaf or evaluator; Opus 5/high replacements remain pending. | Topic journals and native process/registry audit; owner correction | +| 2026-08-14T22:41:15.000Z | Recovered and transcript-verified the actual milestone coordinator rather than a topic/leaf child, then persisted its exact same-session recovery reference. | Codex session `019ffaa3-32ae-7b02-92a5-d7ae146d8cbd`; canonical rollout JSONL; `session_meta`, persistent goal, run-creation, and commit/push events | +| 2026-08-14T22:41:15.000Z | Rebuilt the current route policy: topic orchestrators use native Opus 5/high; implementations remain WSL Codex Sol with documented per-slice effort; most adversarial/phase evaluation uses fresh Opus 5 low–high; PLAN-EVAL is conditional; Fable 5 is reserved for recorded genuine architecture or exceptional implementation-review complexity. | Owner amendment; central topic/reset briefs; `briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json`; cluster state | +| 2026-08-14T23:00:08.000Z | Attachment-proved exactly four native Opus 5/high Remote Control topic supervisors and reconciled every frozen leaf/PR head without mutation. All four pushed topic-only checkpoints; no leaf or evaluator launched early. | Claude sessions `fcf04b0f-…` / `f7691917-…` / `c7597d28-…` / `19621a0b-…`; four non-empty bridge IDs; topic heads `3e554349b` / `98661da4f` / `1a5c3d5a9` / `fed3f8119`; clean worktrees and exact remote refs | +| 2026-08-14T23:04:51.000Z | Granted the internals lane's evaluator lease to dispatch order 1: fresh native Opus 5/medium IMPL-EVAL for #1644 at immutable source `4d9fb1967` and implementation parent `634b257ea`. Internals order 4 remains queued behind it. | Actual evaluator session `1afc9054-cc28-48a8-9fc4-86ae2e3bb28d`; background id `1afc9054`; exact local/remote/PR head equality; `evaluatorLeases[0]`; reset-gate brief `harness-evidence-and-verdict-tooling.md` | +| 2026-08-14T23:08:28.000Z | Reconciled the interrupted standalone coordinator turn and the evaluator attachment before further dispatch. The coordinator remains the same session on GPT-5.6-SOL/high through the Remote Control app-server; `max` is forbidden. All four Claude topic supervisors were preserved without relaunch or mutation. | Coordinator PID `2452378`; app-server PID `5027`; rollout turn context; app-server rollout/lock file descriptors; evaluator PID `2430432`, bridge `session_011426qed3eW6SpmKxrMnzHN`, immutable head `4d9fb1967` | +| 2026-08-14T23:13:20.000Z | Owner corrected evaluator serialization scope: one evaluator at a time per topic orchestrator, with independent topic queues allowed to run concurrently. The global expensive-gate mutex is reserved for shared resource-heavy E2E/Aspire gates. | `briefs/reset-gates/dispatch.json`: concurrency 4, scope `per-topic-orchestrator`, per-orchestrator cap 1; cluster `activeEvaluatorsPerLane: 1`; formal lease moved from `expensiveGates` to `evaluatorLeases` | +| 2026-08-14T23:14:56.438Z | Internals reset-gate order 1 completed its fresh opposite-family IMPL-EVAL with `PASS`; the evaluator changed only the verdict artifact, pushed it, and the PR closure contract now records the independent pass. | Source `4d9fb1967`; native Opus 5/medium session `1afc9054-cc28-48a8-9fc4-86ae2e3bb28d`; evaluator commit `d6e6a6788`; focused 100/100 tests plus binding structured receipts PASS; PR #1644 ready and current CI gating | +| 2026-08-14T23:16:24.161Z | With lane-local serialization enforced, the fixes, features, docs, and then internals lanes independently acquired one formal evaluator each. Internals order 4 launched only after internals order 1 was terminal; fixes order 5 remained queued behind fixes order 2. | Orders 2/3/6/4 sessions `8c47751a-…`, `28cc8106-…`, `40a06314-…`, `b6c48f02-…`; all native Opus 5 at their approved low/medium effort with non-empty Remote Control bridges; `expensiveGates` remains empty | +| 2026-08-14T23:20:50.477Z | Fixes reset-gate order 2 completed its fresh opposite-family IMPL-EVAL with `PASS`; the evaluator independently reproduced the behavioral claims and pushed a verdict-only commit. The fixes lane is now eligible for its own next serial evaluator without waiting on any other topic. | Source `e6ba15ec6`; native Opus 5/low session `8c47751a-6a30-4dab-b25c-dbafe9873455`; evaluator commit `a949a6cd1`; focused auth tests 11/11 PASS; prior Tier-A PASS comment `5286347517` | +| 2026-08-14T23:24:44.178Z | Features order 3 and internals order 4 independently completed fresh PLAN-EVAL with `PASS`. Each topic supervisor was granted authority to journal the exact verdict and resume only its preserved Codex implementation thread; neither lane waits on the other. | #1651 source `12276e6d8`, evaluator `3e0c8858b`, session `28cc8106-…`; #1653 source `09dfb092d`, evaluator `c694cfb31`, session `b6c48f02-…`; both native Opus 5/medium Remote Control | +| 2026-08-14T23:26:20.976Z | After fixes order 2 became terminal, the same preserved fixes supervisor acquired its next lane-local lease and launched order 5 only: fresh PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 for #1654. | Source `14d8b38b4`; native Opus 5/medium session `bd703a7d-4757-4689-a603-5ca98f7d7323`; PID `2470890`; bridge `session_015wwEYoUsxCwzT3PQeSqi2A`; `expensiveGates` remains empty | +| 2026-08-14T23:27:02.000Z | Coordinator merged reset-gate order 1 PR #1644 after exact-head CI, close gate, mergeability, and thread-aware review checks all passed. The three closed issues were re-read live and `main` advanced to the squash commit. | PR #1644 MERGED; merge commit `dd472102d05ea13ab7ac7654aeedb177fbae2eb8`; #1561/#1563/#1621 CLOSED/COMPLETED; zero review threads; current `check-test`, quality, code-quality, close-gate, and visibility checks PASS | +| 2026-08-14T23:29:49.147Z | Docs order 6 completed corrected PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 with `PASS`. The same evaluator fixed only its recorded bridge identity, stopped terminally, and the preserved docs supervisor received authority to resume only the existing Codex implementation thread after removing verified empty untracked residue. | Source `d35cbca30`; final evaluator commit `a790e91e2`; native Opus 5/low session `40a06314-b69a-4ca0-a4a0-1224c5e377ca`; registry bridge `session_0126JRYrbXqvoJwskcF31RwW` | +| 2026-08-14T23:34:26.942Z | Fixes order 5 PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 returned `FAIL_PLAN` with three plan-text-only repairs. The fixes lane alone returned to Plan & Design on its original Codex author thread; no implementation or cycle-2 evaluator was authorized yet, and all other topic lanes continue. | Source `14d8b38b4`; evaluator commit `13008abf8`; native Opus 5/medium session `bd703a7d-4757-4689-a603-5ca98f7d7323`; required fixes: OD sweep/memory scope, per-slice gates/files, #1262 docs acceptance mapping | +| 2026-08-14T23:39:38.000Z | Coordinator closed the intentionally withheld #1643 closure contract and merged it after every gate passed. #1243 gained three checked evidence-bound acceptance rows; the PR gained `Closes #1243`; live mirroring was a no-op; the close gate, 8m06s check-test, quality, code-quality, visibility, OpenHands augmentation, and thread-aware review checks all passed. | PR #1643 MERGED; merge commit `0b3ed5d5a6aea451318f120988c25dfa3993a2ab`; #1243 CLOSED/COMPLETED; exact head `a949a6cd1`; local live close-gate provenance at `2026-08-14T23:39:21.538Z` | +| 2026-08-14T23:45:50.000Z | The original #1654 Codex plan-author thread completed the bounded cycle-1 repair and stopped at the cycle-2 handoff. Coordinator spot-check confirmed all three findings addressed without product mutation and pinned the repaired head into the final-cycle brief. | Clean pushed head `5b3c6fcf2`; structured PLAN update comment `5299255389`; OD-1b memory exclusion, OD-2 direct generator contract, per-slice proves/gate/files including `generate-engine-mod.ts`, #1262 docs inspection | +| 2026-08-14T23:48:32.194Z | Fixes order 5 acquired its final-cycle lane-local evaluator lease after the plan repair and updated binding brief were both pushed. A fresh native opposite-family session is evaluating the repaired immutable head; no implementation authority exists before terminal `PASS`. | Source `5b3c6fcf2`; native Opus 5/medium session `06451c1e-a9b8-47d2-8934-be2247ef5347`; PID `2487919`; bridge `session_01AFoKjRXMVCaXUzJ9HqDvGt`; `expensiveGates` remains empty | +| 2026-08-14T23:54:29.079Z | Fixes order 5 PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 completed `PASS` after independently re-deriving all three cycle-1 repairs. The evaluator preserved cycle 1 verbatim, changed only the two verdict artifacts, pushed the signed commit, and posted the structured verdict. The fixes lane alone advanced to implementation on its preserved Codex thread; other topic lanes continue independently. | Source `5b3c6fcf2`; evaluator `b8fc5eb53`; native Opus 5/medium session `06451c1e-a9b8-47d2-8934-be2247ef5347`; comment `5299298009`; PR #1654 draft at `status:impl`; no expensive-gate lease | +| 2026-08-15T03:46:43.000Z | Coordinator supervision resumed after an unacceptable idle interval. Live reconciliation found four coordinator-owned stops: docs lacked its pinned local external input, internals and features had completed implementation but lacked IMPL-EVAL grants, and fixes had a bounded Tier-A regression finding awaiting same-thread repair. No lane was allowed to remain parked merely because its supervisor had reported a checkpoint. | Four preserved topic supervisors remained attached but idle/blocked; Codex leaf heads `0a13c0162` / `2d5e4f5ae` / `cab6d1feb` / `04d431028`; central head and remote still `182ade71c` before reconciliation | +| 2026-08-15T03:50:49.028Z | Cleared all four handoffs without introducing cross-topic serialization. Materialized the exact pinned EIS-Chat input in a clean detached worktree and resumed docs S2 on its original Codex thread; dispatched fresh Opus 5/high Remote Control IMPL-EVAL sessions for internals #1653 and features #1651; returned fixes T-1 to its original Codex thread for bounded MSSQL regression restoration. | External input `/home/codex/repos/eis-chat-007-input@5191de83`; docs thread `019ffcc9-16c2-…`; fixes thread `019ffcca-8be0-…`; evaluators `430d5f91-a073-4f4f-991a-8a7eefc7ddb3` and `2a8cf0a6-7529-4ca6-97ce-69edcca3f84d`; `expensiveGates` remains empty | +| 2026-08-15T04:02:33.167Z | Fixes T-1 completed bounded repair and independent Tier-A PASS, closing the lost MSSQL loopback regression without product-source or lockfile change. After exact preflight proved zero running Aspire AppHosts, zero Docker containers, and no existing expensive lease, the coordinator granted the singleton slice-6 `scaffold.runtime` lease. | Fix-up head `ebad68c80`; focused gate 10/10, quality clean, architecture no FAIL, asset barrel clean; lease `scaffold-generated-output-correctness-runtime` covers one isolated shared verdict for #1262/#1263/#1588 with mandatory cleanup | +| 2026-08-15T04:05:30.689Z | Features #1651 IMPL-EVAL completed a conditional `PASS` and pushed its verdict commit. Before readiness, the owner added a higher-priority merge gate requiring an independent duplicate/overlap audit against recently merged RFC 0003. The evaluator started before that comment and therefore cannot discharge it. PR #1651 remains draft and held; a fresh delegated read-only audit is active. | Evaluator `2a8cf0a6-7529-4ca6-97ce-69edcca3f84d`, commit `0e302ad3a`; conditional medium finding is a PR-body check-receipt provenance correction; owner comment `5300440887`; delegated audit `/root/audit_rfc_1651_overlap` | + +## Current design checkpoint + +- Objective: complete and publish milestone `0.0.7` through the milestone-cluster profile. +- Frozen invariants: four topic orchestrators, leaf PRs target `main`, coordinator-only merge, one + expensive gate globally, inactive release captain until exact-main readiness. +- Step 0 repair and PLAN-EVAL are approved. Dispatch may begin after the final clean-environment + sweep and status transition to implementation. +- The reset sweep, controller parking, and four Opus 5/high Remote Control attachment proofs are + complete. Each topic's formal evaluator queue runs serially, while the four topics may evaluate in + parallel. Implementation stays on WSL Codex Sol with per-slice effort; evaluator selection follows + the owner-amended Opus-default/Fable-exception policy. + +## 2026-08-15T04:39:17Z — owner corrections and interrupted runtime reconciliation + +- Delegated audit of owner comment `5300440887` found #1651 distinct overall but materially + overlapping RFC 0003/#1490 at C6. PR #1651 remains draft under `BLOCK_PENDING_AMENDMENT`; the + owner has been shown three explicit dispositions and the features lane may not amend, reply, + resolve, mark ready, or merge before that verdict. +- Owner comment `5300459514` made the two canonical #1551 case-study comments (`5265826161`, + `5265971722`) the docs lane's first priority. The preserved docs supervisor and original Codex + thread must use authoritative EIS-Chat `5191de83`, recompute the surfaces and estimates, and + replace both comment bodies in place rather than append follow-ups. The comments predate material + route improvements already contained in the pin; `834a2b36` is evidence-only and no newer product + head exists. PR #1652 stays draft and partial. +- #1653 IMPL-EVAL cycle 1 returned `FAIL_FIX` only because superseded acceptance blocks remained in + the PR body. Internals reproduced the exact 9+5 errors, removed only the stale body blocks, and + proved exact 9/9 and 5/5 mappings. Fresh cycle 2 is running in native Opus 5/high Remote Control + session `31c4cfa9-6610-4813-a4d2-482080fc562e`, bridge `session_01A8dNQhZgaysPzhnEDm2MrA`, against + head `84bbcf9a1`. +- #1654's first `scaffold.runtime` attempt has no terminal verdict. Its structured log ends after + `database.migration-artifacts` passed and `database.generate` started. The orphan check proved + three exact run-owned exited containers; ownership-aware teardown removed PostgreSQL and Redis, + label/network correlation proved Garnet belonged to the same AppHost, and the coordinator removed + that exact container, empty Aspire network, and anonymous volume. `aspire ps` and `docker ps -a` + are empty. A single clean retry is authorized on the original Codex thread under the same global + lease; partial attempt-1 output is not acceptance evidence. + +## 2026-08-15T05:06:31Z — #1653 shipped, #1654 runtime terminal, next internals leaf active + +- #1653 IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 recorded `PASS` at evaluator commit `70177e808`; direct evidence mapping + was exact 9/9 and 5/5 with zero errors/warnings. The coordinator reconciled the PR body, applied + attributed `impl-eval:skip`, moved to `status:ready-merge`, and the live mirror checked all issue + acceptance boxes. Current-head check-test, quality, close-gate, code-quality, visibility, and + zero-thread review gates passed before squash merge `473e8d75b`. #1378 and #1545 closed + `COMPLETED`; PR and issues now carry `status:shipped`. +- Internals serial work continued immediately with frozen Wave-1 leaf `quality-scan-root-coverage` + (#1542), whose #1378 dependency is now satisfied. Its Opus 5/high topic supervisor is + bootstrapping research/plan through one Codex leaf thread; the sibling OpenHands leaf remains + queued rather than concurrent inside the topic. +- #1654 retry 2 reached terminal `suite-end`: raw exit 0, 89 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped, 602,896 + ms. Committed receipts at head `0b2cf5e7c` prove empty Aspire/Docker/network/volume state and zero + leak survivors. The fixes supervisor is independently executing Tier-A; no IMPL-EVAL has been + granted. + +## 2026-08-15T05:16:27Z — docs S3 resumed; #1654 formal evaluation attached; #1656 opened + +- The #1652 owner-priority rewrite is terminal: both #1551 comments are verified true in-place + replacements, privacy-clean, and consistent with unchanged product pin `5191de83`. The exact + preserved Codex author thread `019ffcc9-16c2-7573-b7f6-d627172408e8` resumed approved S3 from + clean local/remote/PR head `54e1c3bff`; no rival thread or new PLAN-EVAL was created. +- #1654 Tier-A passed at sign-off head `f178ac663`. Exactly one formal IMPL-EVAL is active in fresh + native Fable 5/medium session `19f1be7b-db7d-47c0-b0f1-7cfca302d44a`, Remote Control bridge + `session_01Qs22iAtnVYh2fLb26ABvja`, against that immutable local/remote/PR head. Its brief forbids + another expensive runtime/Aspire/Docker pass and binds the interrupted-attempt and cleanup audit. +- Internals opened draft PR #1656 for #1542 at bootstrap head `5dc2d2148`, with its sole Codex + thread still restricted to research/plan. A formal Plan-Gate remains pending; the sibling leaf is + not dispatched concurrently inside the internals topic. + +## 2026-08-15T05:52:01Z — #1654 shipped; docs repair and internals implementation active + +- PR #1654 passed formal IMPL-EVAL at evaluator commit `70843d169`, merged as + `da574111af05a5cded74250128b196fcab870274`, and closed #1262/#1263/#1588 as completed. Its + post-merge `ci` run `31867377599`, Pages run `31867378176`, and code-quality run `31867377620` all + passed. The only annotation is the non-failing Node.js 20 deprecation on + `actions/upload-artifact@v5`; no product or release gate failed. Main remains exactly `da574111a`. +- PR #1652 formal IMPL-EVAL cycle 1 returned `FAIL_FIX` at evaluator commit `e95f483803` after all + five proportional docs gates passed. The two blockers are evidence integrity, not architecture: a + Channel count labelled `Measured` without a published aggregate, and mutable branch URLs in + canonical comment `5265826161`. Three minor consistency defects accompany them. The original Codex + author thread `019ffcc9-16c2-7573-b7f6-d627172408e8` is running one bounded F1–F5 repair; no + second formal cycle is authorized before fresh Tier-A. +- PR #1656 formal PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 returned `PASS` at evaluator commit `3b95a004f`. The earlier + Fable launch remains a zero-token model-unavailable transport failure, not an evaluation cycle. + The original Codex implementation thread `01a003d2-61ee-7ec0-8c74-075b3d631168` is implementing + the approved three-file plan with both evaluator advisories carried explicitly and no expensive + gate. The live Remote Control bridge is `session_01BA2jJuyVsFhRJkVKoTMihe`; the job artifact's + `cse_…` alias is not the owner-visible URL form. +- Fixes advanced its next serial leaf, #1358, on original Codex thread + `01a003f0-7821-7a10-a555-e619a9280479`. It is bounded to the four contracted registry surfaces and + must stop before `fresh-browser` for a coordinator lease. Aspire and Docker were empty at this + checkpoint, so the global expensive-gate mutex is free. +- #1651 remains untouched and draft. Features is blocked only on the explicit owner option 1/2/3 + verdict; that lane-local hold does not serialize docs, internals, or fixes. + +## 2026-08-15T06:07:53Z — repaired docs re-evaluation and #1657 browser lease released + +- #1652's original Codex author completed the bounded F1–F5 repair at clean pushed head `c7ce58a19`. + The docs supervisor independently re-derived all five corrections, immutable-link reachability, + in-place comment chronology, evidence labels, and DoD state, then recorded hardened Tier-A `PASS` + at topic head `3aedb4cce` and comment `5300864119`. Exactly one fresh native Opus 5/medium Remote + Control IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 is now authorized against that immutable source; a further failure + escalates rather than loops. +- #1656 reached slice-1 head `dbbedde34`. Executed Tier-A found the implementation substantively + correct and the red-first/denominator/advisory evidence valid, but requested one drift-only + bookkeeping repair: record why three locked JSON field names were clarified. The original author + thread owns that bounded correction and must stop before S2 until supervisor sign-off. +- #1657 completed its non-browser implementation at clean pushed head `4a3c40321`. After an + independent empty Aspire/Docker/volume preflight and confirmation that the prior runtime lease is + terminal, the coordinator granted one catalogued `fresh-browser` pass. The lease is confined to + Playwright/Chromium and requires a durable receipt, stray-process cleanup, and empty-host + postcondition before Tier-A or any evaluator. + +## 2026-08-15T06:19:11Z — browser lease closed; three topic-local gates remain active + +- #1657's exactly-once `fresh-browser` gate passed at product head `4a3c40321`; evidence commit + `c792327c9` records 2 passed / 0 failed, exit 0, exact head ancestry, no lock change, and zero + browser survivors. Aspire, Docker containers, and Docker volumes are independently empty. The + shared lease is complete and fixes Tier-A is now substantively re-deriving the 66/66 catalog, + collection metadata, negative fixtures, template, publication, scope, and acceptance evidence. +- #1656 S1's drift-only finding is closed and signed off at `a258bcc8c`. S2 correctly stopped once + when the supervisor's paraphrased file boundary contradicted the approved plan; the supervisor + corrected its own brief without widening the plan and resumed the preserved Codex author thread. + Local commits `98360da7b`, `15d894740`, and `a7e9ee0d5` now exist, but the author is still running + final receipt checks and has not pushed or claimed Tier-A completion, so central state remains + `running_slice_2` at the live PR head. +- #1652's fresh cycle-2 evaluator remains working against immutable head `c7ce58a19` in native Opus + 5/medium Remote Control session `4ed649d5-9d62-4e24-a50a-081477607cee`. No competing docs author + or evaluator exists. #1651 remains draft and unchanged pending the owner's explicit option 1/2/3 + verdict; the hold does not block the other topic queues. + +## 2026-08-15T06:24:17Z — docs evaluation passes; final internals slice and fixes CI repair active + +- #1652's fresh cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL returned `PASS` at evaluator commit `71cc5a02c`. The evaluator + independently closed F1–F5 and ran the proportional docs/tool gates. Three non-blocking + merge-readiness journal defects remain: a normalized digest that does not reproduce despite + byte-identical regeneration, stale plan status, and two understatements. The original Codex author + owns one bounded cleanup followed by topic Tier-A; there is no cycle 3. +- #1656 S2 passed topic Tier-A at implementation head `a7e9ee0d5` and sign-off head `4ae309d57`. The + 29→0 coverage transition, unchanged 37/37/35 census, real changed-file argument forwarding, + structured negative fixture, permissions, budget, and scope were re-executed. The preserved author + is now running final run-artifact-only S3; no formal evaluator is authorized yet. +- #1657 Tier-A requested changes at review head `5fe600235`: CLI-only design-template edits did not + trigger the Fresh UI drift workflow or classifier, leaving #1358's close-gated durability claim + false. The coordinator chose the quality-preserving contract amendment, recorded at `c5e06661b`, + adding only the workflow, classifier, and classifier test. The original author owns this cheap CI + repair; the browser gate is not rerun and the runtime mutex remains free. + +## 2026-08-15T06:54:51Z — formal outcomes reconciled and bounded repairs dispatched + +- Reconciled three independent topic queues without imposing a cluster-wide evaluator wait. Docs + #1652 remains inside its already-proven content contract and is repairing one deterministic + transitive asset barrel after current-head CI exposed staleness; formal cycle 3 is explicitly not + authorized. Current leaf head is `d4a0a8340`; the only product target added to the cleanup is + `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-docs.generated.ts`. +- Internals #1656 completed formal IMPL-EVAL cycle 1 with `PASS` against immutable source + `2c4881fd7`, evaluator commit `addba1ab9`, comment `5301029660`, native Opus 5/medium Remote + Control session `ee2825f2-…`. It entered coordinator-controlled readiness. The pre-existing + `.llm/**` lint-exclusion blind spot is queued separately and does not rescope this leaf. +- Fixes #1657 completed formal cycle 1 with `FAIL_FIX` against `939e73113`, evaluator commit + `a46b83831`, comment `5301015059`: the authored 66-entry registry template was correct, but the + embedded artifact actually consumed by `netscript init` still shipped 50 entries. The contract was + amended at `c3ccceeb1` by exactly `embedded.generated.ts`; one same-author repair, fresh Tier-A, + and at most one cycle-2 formal evaluation are authorized. No browser/runtime rerun. +- Re-proved shared runtime hygiene: agentic runtime `no_change`, Aspire `[]`, Docker containers and + volumes empty. Existing supervisors were attached and steered in place, never relaunched. #1651 + remains unchanged and draft pending the explicit owner option 1/2/3 disposition. + +## 2026-08-15T07:12:16Z — #1656 shipped; all three unblocked topics advance independently + +- Merged internals PR #1656 by squash with exact-head protection at source `b80794470`; live main is + now `7737d8903bb2925c3fcefbda362168fe297eebd4`. Before merge, the source had 0 pending and 0 + failing checks, 0 review threads, and issue #1542 had 3/3 acceptance boxes checked. PR #1656 and + issue #1542 are now terminal `status:shipped`; the issue is `CLOSED/COMPLETED`. +- The preserved internals supervisor reconciled that merge and selected its next lane-local serial + leaf, `openhands-dispatch-claim-and-refusal` for #1611 + #1613, now draft PR #1658. The original + Codex route was launched at immutable main `7737d8903` in worktree + `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-openhands-dispatch`, thread `01a00443-…`, GPT-5.6-SOL/medium. It + bootstrapped cleanly at `ca2266ecb`; this turn is research/plan only and cannot implement or + dispatch OpenHands. +- The L-2 mixed-batch lint exclusion false-green is not folded into #1656 or the new leaf. It + remains a dedicated tooling candidate after the contracted OpenHands leaf because repairing it + changes repository-wide lint policy and needs its own issue/contract. +- Fixes #1657 reached fresh opposite-family Tier-A `PASS` at exact head `3d7819203`, then launched + its single authorized formal cycle-2 evaluator in native Opus 5/medium Remote Control session + `1df19d27-…`, bridge `session_018WYHfqzFKKve37TL7hsPQD`. Local, remote, and PR source heads were + equal at launch. No further formal loop is implicit. +- Docs #1652 reached the terminal deterministic asset-cascade head `a465836b4`; the three generated + layers are agent-doc prose/provenance, the CLI embedded agent-doc barrel, and the MCP publish + assets barrel. Its supervisor independently re-ran all four freshness gates successfully and is + waiting for exact-head Actions plus fresh Tier-A. Formal cycle 3 remains forbidden. +- Main post-merge workflows at `7737d8903` had no failures at this checkpoint: Pages, code quality, + and Fresh UI quality were successful; core `ci` remained in progress. Agentic runtime remained + `no_change`; Aspire, Docker containers, and Docker volumes remained empty. Serialization remains + per topic, with only the global runtime/expensive-gate mutex shared. + +## 2026-08-15T07:25:00Z — docs shipped; #1658 contract corrected at the research boundary + +- Docs PR #1652 merged from exact source `a465836b4` as main + `e090f894ff3682405a36e4f896ffd2cc16f9a1f8` after fresh Tier-A, 0 pending/0 failing checks, 0 + review threads, 21/21 PR boxes, and a clean mergeability result. Issue #1551 closed completed; + both PR and issue are `status:shipped`. The two canonical issue examples were independently + re-read as in-place replacements with no follow-up-update framing. The temporary `impl-eval:skip` + redispatch-suppression label was removed after merge so it cannot imply the earned cycle-2 + evaluation was waived. +- Internals draft #1658 stopped correctly at research head `670e37bea`: the frozen four-path + contract excluded the actual `dispatch-openhands.ts` producer and all required regression suites, + while including `openhands-phase-eval.yml`, whose retry behavior is already the correct reference. + No implementation or evaluator was launched against the invalid envelope. +- Coordinator amended the exact mutation contract to eight paths: the trusted trigger module and + test, manual workflow, dispatch builder and test, real dispatch CLI and a new CLI integration + test, plus the workflow contract regression test. The automatic phase workflow is read-only + precedent. +- Locked semantics: `--phase plan|impl` alone selects formal PR evaluation; formal mode is PR-only, + requires the verdict contract, and the CLI resolves the live PR head rather than accepting a + caller-supplied head. Without `--phase`, existing PR/issue dispatch remains tuple-free. Literal + command candidates reach the trusted predicate; a denial gets one sanitized marker-bearing reply + before spend that contains no command token and cannot recurse. Manual generation lookup adopts + the existing five attempts at one-second intervals and returns an attributable fail-closed denial + on exhaustion. +- A fresh opposite-family PLAN-EVAL is required after the original author rewrites the plan because + this leaf changes atomic claim/spend behavior, job write permission, event admission, and refusal + recursion. This is a necessary architectural gate, not a reflexive extra cycle. +- Exact-main workflows for `e090f894f` were active without a failure at this checkpoint. Fixes #1657 + final IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 remained active and independent. Aspire/Docker stayed empty. + +## 2026-08-15T07:40:16Z — owner selects keep-and-narrow for #1651 + +- The owner explicitly selected option 1 for PR #1651. The features-lane hold is released; the RFC + remains distinct and the preserved original Codex author may perform one focused RFC/journal/body + amendment under the existing native Opus 5/high Remote Control topic supervisor. +- C6 owns only the generic CLI contribution workspace-plan executor, preview/apply safety, + staging/check/commit/rollback, and contribution-level registry/plan/journal doctor states. RFC + 0003/#1490 exclusively owns command-store provider selection, Prisma schema/models/indexes, + migrations, generated bridge and transaction-client types, database validation, and transactional + business-command semantics. Their adapter may map the domain plan into the shared executor; + neither may reimplement the other's owned behavior. +- Preview is plan-invariant: the planner returns the same canonical plan for preview and apply, + while the host alone decides whether to mutate. This closes the evaluator's carried C6 observation + as part of the same amendment. +- The author must also correct the merge-facing check-receipt provenance claim and record the valid + input-cache hit. Re-run the six contracted gates at the amended content head, obtain fresh + opposite-family Tier-A, then exactly one bounded final IMPL-EVAL over the ownership amendment and + prior conditional finding. No PLAN-EVAL or open-ended evaluator cycle is authorized. +- #1651 remains draft. Reply to owner comment `5300440887`, ready transition, issue mutation, and + merge remain withheld until the amended head, review, receipts, and live checks are reconciled. + +## 2026-08-15T07:48:51Z — owner amendment dispatched; cleanup and plan-eval advance + +- Features supervisor `19621a0b-…` reconciled the owner verdict into clean pushed topic checkpoint + `1bfc1cfcdff6d39c75f7190d1b79750f55b966c0` and resumed only the preserved original Codex author + `019ffcc5-d3e1-7c13-9815-e9956ec43683`. The leaf remained clean at `0e302ad3a` when dispatched. + Its focused brief preserves the distinct plugin CLI architecture, narrows C6 to the shared + workspace-plan executor, corrects receipt provenance, and requires all six contracted gates. +- Internals #1658 repaired its plan on the original author thread and reached clean local=remote=PR + head `cea999d18ea2c2d4a6208fc209ce744d9be1d194`. Topic Tier-A passed in comment `5301190104`. One + fresh native `claude-opus-5`/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL is now working in session + `7d544aec-22cc-4656-8483-6d957dbfbfda`, bridge `session_01N9zhX5ZDUvvrBxcwoAYBCm`; its live + transcript and respawn flags independently confirm the requested route and immutable head. +- Fixes #1657 cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at evaluator commit `ed9ee7663` and comment + `5301157020`. The original author then removed the three redundant T-3 CI deltas, recorded the + rationale/browser-evidence corrections, and pushed proof head + `a891c65203301ec96467f11d9fe3dcb77a09d5c8`. The three paths now have an empty delta versus + `origin/main`; the core #1358 product changes and formal PASS remain intact. Fresh Tier-A is next. +- All topic heads recorded here were clean when sampled. No expensive gate was launched, and the + three topic-local queues continue independently rather than waiting on one another. + +## 2026-08-15T08:04:33Z — #1658 plan gate passes; #1651 amendment proven; #1657 body repair + +- #1658 formal PLAN-EVAL returned `PASS` against repaired plan `cea999d18`. Evaluator artifact head + `e15d78588503f4a83d6322be9039abe1f52190a1` is clean and equal across local, remote, and PR; + comment `5301255122` records the verdict. The evaluator stopped at a delivered `blocked` state + without a terminal timestamp, so the coordinator woke the existing topic supervisor, which + independently reconciled the artifact and then stopped the stale evaluator/watch. Topic checkpoint + `d5ade932b` carries notes N1–N5 and resumes only original author `01a00443-…` for S1. +- #1651 original author committed normative keep-and-narrow content at `67e12f021` and evidence at + `d45a92ba70e78cc1ff42617ca15f6782f4ea8c21`; local, remote, and PR heads are equal and the tree is + clean. All six exact-content-head receipts are `PASS`, and the PR body now attributes the cached + check accurately while preserving the historical cycle-1 figures only with their real receipt. + Structured amendment comment `5301282095` is posted; fresh opposite-family Tier-A is next. +- #1657 fresh cleanup Tier-A independently passed the product/revert proofs but returned + `CHANGES_REQUESTED` at artifact head `21403902b`, comment `5301270096`, because the live PR body + still described reverted T-3 code and left the form-navigation browser receipt unqualified. The + coordinator authorized only those merge-record text corrections on the preserved author thread, + followed by one focused fresh body recheck. Formal cycle-2 product `PASS` remains final. + +## 2026-08-15T08:31:20Z — owner amendment and design-registry fix shipped; #1658 S2 active + +- #1657's focused body recheck returned `PASS` at exact head `b71c1ee72`, comment `5301330685`. The + coordinator checked all seven #1358 acceptance boxes, applied the one-`status:` readiness + transition with `impl-eval:skip`, observed current-head CI terminal green with no unresolved + review threads, and squash-merged the protected head as main `6917c656e`. #1358 closed and both + issue and PR now carry `status:shipped`; the temporary skip label was removed. +- #1651's final bounded amendment IMPL-EVAL returned `PASS` with no substantive findings at + evaluator commit `ec69100c8`, comment `5301336480`. It independently re-read RFC 0003, recomputed + the exact six-receipt evidence set, resolved all 12 cited SHAs, and verified live + #1490-under-#1363 ownership. The coordinator answered owner comment `5300440887` in disposition + comment `5301349600`, checked all five #1502 boxes, completed readiness, then squash-merged the + exact head as current main `284dda90a`. #1502 and PR #1651 now carry `status:shipped` and the + temporary skip label is absent. +- #1658 S1 reached product head `4aa04de34`, evidence head `f1567ce32`, and supervisor sign-off + `6f725ad3b`. The load-bearing root test passed 4,138 with 19 ignored and zero failed; the + supervisor independently re-ran the 16 focused tests and verified the refusal body through the + production predicates. S2 is active on the preserved Codex author thread at local implementation + head `28a8a9184`, with only structured `check`/`test` receipts allowed before the next Tier-A + stop. +- Existing native features and fixes supervisors were steered through `claude attach`, preserving + their Remote Control bridges and sessions. Features is reconciling the shipped RFC and selecting + the next frozen leaf; fixes is reconciling #1657 and respecting #1350's open #1348 prerequisite. + Discovered legacy lifecycle drift was corrected: merged #1643 and closed #1243 now carry + `status:shipped` rather than stale ready/triage labels. +- Combined-main CI for `284dda90a` is running without a failure at this checkpoint. No runtime, + browser, Aspire, Docker, evaluator, or expensive-gate lease was launched for either merge. + +## 2026-08-15T08:45:30Z — four independent serial queues advance after combined-main green + +- Combined-main Actions run `31874580034` completed successfully at exact main `284dda90a`; the + repository classifier, quality job, and check-test passed, while unrelated deployment/runtime + lanes skipped natively. Aspire reported `[]`; Docker has no containers or volumes and only its + default networks. +- Owner-directed issue #1659 opened draft PR #1660 from the preserved docs author thread. Its four + implementation slices reached `0b67ef39e` with docs/freshness gates green, then topic Tier-A found + four concrete merge blockers: backend estimates, a second no-generated-client argument, public + `baseContract` verification, and compilation of both central NetScript snippets. The findings are + now running on that same thread; no rival was created. +- #1658 S2 product `28a8a9184`, evidence `5869cb46d`, and topic sign-off `0886c2427` are pushed with + comment `5301401476`. The same author landed local S3 product `d7fdbb1d9` and is producing the + structured exact-head receipt before another stop; S4 remains unauthorized until Tier-A. +- #1661 stopped correctly at artifact-only head `1d4533462` when the three-file frozen contract + could not satisfy #1448. Fixes supervisor ruling `af53757e6` authorizes exactly five additional + `packages/ai/**` paths, an additive synchronous per-server status snapshot, signal-bearing close, + and per-server `pool.stop()` settlement. The same author thread is the only implementation route. +- #1293 research proved the public `PrismaMySqlOptions.onConnectionError` option already shipped in + 0.0.6 but is never invoked. Coordinator disposition preserves and wires that API; deletion is not + authorized. A fresh PLAN-EVAL is conditionally granted only after a clean decision-heavy plan and + topic Tier-A, while #1112/reference prose remains docs-owned. + +## 2026-08-15T09:08:30Z — docs reaches readiness; #1293 PLAN-EVAL stall recovered + +- Docs #1660 repaired all four Tier-A findings at content `504de3f67`, refreshed the generated + cascade at exact head `e35824d41`, and then passed a fresh independent review under proven + exclusive worktree ownership. All eight #1659 acceptance boxes are checked with evidence; + readiness comment `5301508540` is posted and exact-head CI is running with no current failure. + The supervisor's earlier concurrent gate/stash error is fully disclosed: dropped stash object + `7eb4ed16d6944c1d1c904895bcb76b4361ad8a57` was restored exactly, no data was lost, and every + reported final gate was re-executed after the incident without contention. +- Internals #1658 S3 product `d7fdbb1d9`, evidence `2e6a065d7`, and supervisor sign-off + `d3d31b3d0` are complete. S4 has a local implementation commit `9b71e1bd2`; its branch remains + remote-pinned to the S3 sign-off while the author writes structured receipts and stops for + another Tier-A review. S5 and formal IMPL-EVAL remain unauthorized until that stop. +- Fixes #1661 amendment 2 is active after the topic proved the two published transport wrappers + were missing from the first correction and a required port member would break the Fresh package + test double. The same author has clean/pushed RED/product progression through `099067c6b`; + `readResource` is optional only on the broad port, required and abort-aware on the base plus both + published wrappers, and a cross-package Fresh check is mandatory before sign-off. +- Features #1293's fresh Fable 5/medium PLAN-EVAL returned `PASS` with binding rulings at pushed + commit `7780ba49e`. The job registry incorrectly remained `working`; the coordinator attached to + session `75d9028e`, verified its terminal response and exact remote head, and steered the existing + features supervisor to reconcile the verdict, record the stale-terminal drift, amend `plan.md`, + and resume only the original Codex author. No duplicate evaluator was launched. +- Serialization remains per topic. No runtime, browser, Aspire, Docker, OpenHands provider-spend, + or shared expensive-gate lease was started by this checkpoint. + +## 2026-08-15T09:28:54Z — docs ships after a stale-CI repair; three product lanes advance + +- Docs readiness CI at `e35824d41` found a false-positive exact corpus snapshot in + `snippet-extractor_test.ts`: the test name promised alias/floor protection, but unrelated new + TypeScript fences changed total corpus counts. The preserved author replaced those totals at + `615786c1a` with named invariants (`tsLike` partition, Tier-1 partition, checked/exempt partition, + monotonic floors/cap, zero malformed). Focused structured test passed 6/6; a fresh exclusive-owner + Tier-A PASS is durable in comment `5301575337`; docs content was not changed to satisfy the test. +- Exact-head PR gates then passed: review threads 0/0, structured current-head checks 21 with zero + current failures, repo check/test, quality, and docs build. Coordinator squash-merged #1660 at + `729386c56`; #1659 auto-closed with 8/8 boxes; issue and PR are `status:shipped`, and the temporary + `impl-eval:skip` label is removed. Main-push Pages run `31876977060` passed. Both comparison pages + return HTTP 200 with their expected frontend/backend titles. +- Internals #1658 finished S5 at `704c067e8` with final `check`, load-bearing `test`, and + `quality-job` receipts all PASS at checkpoint `1390d3ead`; the native topic supervisor is running + the final substantive Tier-A review before formal IMPL-EVAL. +- Fixes #1661 completed the twice-amended ten-file implementation at `3a4bc66c4`. Tier-A reran the + gate set, independently proved `packages/fresh` remains green (197 files, zero failed batches), + and signed off at `e3c74d7aa` / comment `5301585728`. The coordinator granted exactly one fresh + opposite-family formal IMPL-EVAL lease; the next fixes leaf stays queued until it is terminal. +- Features #1293 plan rulings are durably amended at `feb8b0355`; the supervisor verified every + amendment item and released S1 on the preserved Codex author. The owner-only acceptance-box-1 + wording edit remains unresolved but does not block the split-close product implementation. +- Fixes evaluator identity is recorded before evaluator mutation: fresh Fable 5/medium Remote + Control session `cb917802-ee26-4b89-86b9-0eee33c7de1b`, bridge + `session_01Kwmr8XjoznnQsHUnkmfcnV`, PID `520689`, exact source `e3c74d7aa`. This is the canonical + formal-IMPL-EVAL route for Codex-authored work, not an Opus override. + +## 2026-08-15T09:41:25Z — two formal-gate transitions and S1 acceptance + +- Docs supervisor independently reconciled #1660's merge and deployment, proved its assigned + allocation `[1551]` exhausted, and pushed parked topic checkpoint `0ca4c489f`. The supervisor + remains preserved; no unrelated docs-labelled issue was stolen from another topic allocation. +- Internals #1658 passed final Tier-A at exact head `f46d84630`: 4,147 tests passed, 19 ignored, + zero failed in about 319 seconds; sign-off comment `5301628196`. The first Fable availability + probe `e58c5f01` failed before inference with null tokens and no mutation, so it consumes zero + evaluation cycles. The established native Opus 5/medium Remote Control fallback is active as + evaluator `740d2a3a-1677-459c-a6b1-a39398649d1a`, bridge + `cse_01NVeBmZE7SwH3Nvu3ep51zV`, against immutable head `f46d84630`. +- Fixes #1661 IMPL-EVAL cycle 1 returned immutable pushed `FAIL_FIX` at `8d6b4726c`. Blocking F-1 + proves the registration startup signal was captured by every later registered tool call; the + documented 1.5-second startup deadline therefore poisoned the registry after 1.5 seconds, and + the old test encoded that defect. Tier-A PASS was withdrawn at `1bdb09e13`. Under the owner's + autonomous-continuation mandate, the same original Codex author is now running the bounded + three-file RED-to-GREEN repair; the next fixes leaf remains queued. +- Features #1293 S1 initially widened the public query input type and required a correctness-hiding + cast. Tier-A rejected it. The preserved author repaired the contract at `49fda0b77` with the exact + scalar union, correct optional/required fields, no cast, and bidirectional compile-time + assignability guards. S1 is accepted and S2 classifier/notifier wiring is active in the same + lane-local serial queue. + +## 2026-08-15T09:53:39Z — fixes cycle 2 and features S3 advance independently + +- Fixes #1661 completed its bounded RED-to-GREEN repair: regression head `59eca0647` reproduced the + post-registration-abort failure; `e49443093` decoupled call lifetime from discovery lifetime and + aligned the README. Fresh Tier-A ran the time-separated behavior itself and signed PASS at exact + head `df0534416`; topic checkpoint `a6cb21f02` is pushed. +- Per-topic evaluator serialization permits fixes and internals gates concurrently. The coordinator + granted #1661 IMPL-EVAL cycle 2 and recorded fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control evaluator + `eb7149da-1689-44af-970e-ddd6e78022fa`, bridge `cse_01CaAEKsH35CP2QgfNUVdXK1`, immutable + source `df0534416`, before any evaluator artifact mutation. The next fixes leaf remains queued. +- Features #1293 S2 passed independent Tier-A at `47ad48c9d`: predicate coverage, notifier + choke-point placement, duplicate-notification risk, raw `executeScript` rejection, callback + containment, primary-error identity, and capability fallback were all reviewed. Topic checkpoint + `38abbacaf` released S3. S3 content is pushed at `3dee41263`; exact-head structured final receipts + are running, so the leaf remains non-terminal and no formal evaluator is yet authorized. + +## 2026-08-15T10:20:00Z — one shipment, one CI repair, one readiness gate, one new plan + +- Independently verified #1658 at exact head `bf0706298`: 21 terminal checks (7 success, 14 policy + skips), zero failures/active jobs, zero review threads, and `mergeState=CLEAN`. Squash-merged it + as `05fc3132b`; #1611 and #1613 auto-closed. The PR and both issues now carry exactly + `status:shipped`, and `origin/main` contains the merge. +- The internals supervisor reconciled that terminal tuple at `9aabef2c9` and released its next + serial leaf, `package-gate-honesty` (#1604/#1618/#1622), on new preserved Codex author thread + `01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5`. Its current authority is bootstrap/research/plan only. +- #1661's Fable 5/medium cycle-2 evaluator passed at immutable commit `4766b258f`, comment + `5301708486`. Current exact-head Actions then failed one cross-package CLI packaging assertion + (4151 passed / 1 failed / 14 ignored): literal optional `@tanstack` imports had replaced the + required computed specifiers. The original Codex author is performing the bounded one-file + RED→GREEN restoration, with `packages/cli` and `packages/fresh` source kept read-only. +- #1662's fresh Fable 5/medium evaluator passed at `f52aa471c`, comment `5301776738`, after + independently rerunning and reading the R1–R3, query compatibility, notifier, receipt, D7, and + split-close evidence. The PR is now non-draft with sole `status:ready-merge`; #1293 remains open + at `status:impl`, with its wording unchanged. Exact-head `check-test` and `quality` are active. +- Runtime hygiene remains clean and the expensive-gate mutex is free. + +## 2026-08-15T10:39:55Z — feature shipment and two formal gates + +- #1662 reached terminal exact-head green with zero review threads and was coordinator squash-merged + as `3fc0f2f92`. The PR has sole `status:shipped`; #1293 deliberately remains open, with only + acceptance boxes 2 and 3 checked and owner-worded boxes 1 and 4 still open. +- Features released its next serial leaf, `app-service-client-wiring` (#1355/#1360), on preserved + Codex thread `01a004f9-f033-7592-a0bc-63927753fb43` from main `3fc0f2f92`. It is research/plan + only and must stop before implementation or either declared expensive gate. +- Internals #1663 stopped clean at plan head `72d5aca66`, covering exactly six proposed product/config + paths. Fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL `9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be`, + bridge `cse_0176qkbF4eKUt7TxJiEPdTrk`, is active on that immutable head. +- #1661 restored both optional TanStack computed specifiers in one file at `45aca4adc`; Tier-A + `de8944011` independently passed the previous CLI failure, package publish proof, and the full + repository suite (4152 passed, 0 failed, 19 ignored). Fresh proportionate evaluator + `8a0ff845-1d0a-43d6-ae3c-03b4158f7943`, bridge `cse_013K3BZ2ydVkYzXt6vgcxTJX`, is active. +- #1663's first probe used invalid token `fable-5` from `/tmp` without Remote Control and failed + before inference; a premature Opus fallback was stopped before repository mutation. The corrected + canonical `claude-fable-5` launch is the only formal cycle. + +## 2026-08-15T10:46:30Z — #1663 plan repair and #1661 readiness + +- #1663 cycle-1 PLAN-EVAL returned immutable `FAIL_PLAN` at `be2b18728`, comment `5301867229`. + Execution proved the proposed root exclusion cannot affect explicit file arguments, and also + established that `scaffold.runtime` adds no evidence for this surface. +- Coordinator expanded the leaf contract to both optimized fmt/lint wrappers, their focused tests, + and at most one explicit marker inside the broken fixture subtree. The repair must keep the + malformed config byte-identical, avoid broad fixture skipping, prove non-empty exact no-flag fmt + and lint passes, and retain real-source negative controls. The runtime gate is waived. Same author, + plan repair only, then fresh Tier-A and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2. +- #1661 repair-delta evaluator independently passed at `f74695bc4`, comment `5301873258`, after + reproducing 4152/0/19 and the publish invariant. Current exact-head CI is the only remaining + technical readiness gate; the fixes supervisor is updating the PR body in place before its tuple. + +## 2026-08-15T10:56:30Z — #1661 shipped and #1664 plan gated + +- Independently verified #1661 at exact head `f74695bc4`: current check-test 4152/0/19, quality and + all required contexts terminal green/policy-skipped, zero review threads, corrected PR body, + MERGEABLE/CLEAN. Transitioned it to sole `status:ready-merge`, re-resolved the tuple, and + coordinator squash-merged as main `baf1cdf67` at 10:54:05Z. #1448 auto-closed; PR and issue are + normalized to sole `status:shipped`. +- The final evaluator-only commit still reran full CI because classification correctly considers + the complete PR diff, not merely the last commit. That is exact-head attestation, not a path + classifier false positive, so no skip weakening is authorized. +- #1664 opened correctly at its first slice and stopped clean at `6aea4a5ea`. Coordinator requires + formal PLAN-EVAL and agrees both runtime gates are load-bearing only after cheap convergence. + Tier-A rejected the proposed `scaffold.runtime` catalog entry: it remains the separate + suite-owned release-gate class, while `fresh-browser` retains its normal run-gate receipt. The + same author is repairing this evidence class and making scenario assertions falsifiable. + +## 2026-08-15T11:03:30Z — #1664 formal plan gate and #1663 false-green interception + +- #1664's preserved author repaired the gate-class contract and exact scenarios at immutable head + `7f20a34fe`: `scaffold.runtime` remains suite-owned release-gate evidence, `fresh-browser` remains + the catalog receipt gate, multi-service key arrays are named, invalidation requires an observed + second network request plus server-confirmed DOM value, and hydration runs under one controlled + clock. Fresh Tier-A passed at features topic `b52641ece`. +- Granted and verified one native Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL on that exact head: + session `176aace4-b2a2-4b16-bdaa-9db687c7d132`, bridge + `cse_01TiYhwUCkdyjziEpFP3kgaS`. Neither expensive gate is leased or running. +- Intercepted #1663's unpushed repaired-plan commit `71e803807` because a marker under + `doctor/broken` suppressed the whole doctor family: 115 to 110 removed the one broken fixture TS + file plus all four healthy unmarked TS files. That is a false-positive exclusion, not a gate fix. +- The exact active author PID was stopped before push; remote #1663 remains `be2b18728`. The same + Codex thread is being resumed with the conjunctive 114-file contract: skip only the marked broken + subtree, preserve all healthy fixture selection, and group explicit argv by effective nearest + Deno config inside the already-authorized fmt/lint wrappers. No product implementation or twelfth + path is authorized. + +## 2026-08-15T11:09:30Z — two plan repairs and the next fixes leaf + +- #1664 cycle-1 PLAN-EVAL completed `FAIL_PLAN` at immutable evaluator commit `ed34105e2`, comment + `5301947232`. It ruled direct `{ queryKey: Queries.list.clientKey() }` emission with no SDK + overload, then required plan-text decisions for generator-owned paths, the existing + `service generate` overwrite/dry-run/force contract, package README homes, post-mutation request + counting, per-slice paths, and one qualified citation. The same Codex author is repairing only + plan artifacts; neither expensive gate ran. +- The #1663 114-file prototype exposed one legitimate fmt finding rather than another wrapper bug: + only `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` is genuinely unformatted; the other three healthy files + and all lint checks pass. Coordinator granted that exact twelfth path as formatting-only planned + surface, with actual mutation still blocked until fresh Tier-A and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 PASS. +- Fixes durably reconciled #1661 at topic `8169b1a0e` and released + `sdk-cache-surface-and-telemetry` (#1637/#1619/#1620/#1598/#1623) from main `baf1cdf67` on matched + Sol/medium Codex thread `01a00516-2033-7ed3-936a-a616cee47447`. It is research/plan-only and must + open one draft PR before stopping for PLAN-EVAL. + +## 2026-08-15T11:25:08Z — final plan gate passes, honest cycle 2, and SDK feasibility review + +- #1664 cycle-2 PLAN-EVAL passed at pushed evaluator commit `c53726c69`, comment `5301997528`, + under fresh native Fable 5/medium Remote Control session `8c756943-…`, bridge + `cse_01UrhsQgBYpLZWHKAhCvESi6`. Direct typed emission and both gate classes remain locked. Three + implementation constraints are carried into the first bounded author slice; neither expensive + gate is leased or running. +- #1663's final plan repair is clean/pushed at `df1d7a96d`: five run artifacts only. Tier-A passed + after independently confirming the real fixture remains unformatted/unmutated, the marker is + absent, the scratch proof selects 114 and is green, all four healthy files are observed selected, + doctor is 4/4, and semantic/hash/negative-control restoration proofs hold. Fresh cycle-2 evaluator + `517ac0e7`, bridge `cse_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn`, is active on that immutable head. +- #1665 opened draft at final handoff head `20e7aed41`, run artifacts only. Tier-A returned bounded + `FAIL_FIX` at fixes topic `3fdf4b2c7`: define a span-time overflow deferral seam including the + no-span composite site; stage invalidation entries so a rejected report cannot leak partial + evidence; and replace aggregate doc-lint counts with raw combined/cache-entrypoint evidence naming + six exact existing diagnostics. The same author is repairing plan artifacts; no evaluator ran. + Coordinator grants the four acceptance/proof paths plus the one exact published query-bridge page + that quotes the changing diagnostic, while refusing unrelated doc-lint remediation. Live GitHub + classification skipped every unrelated/costly lane. +- Corrected #1663 recovery wording: local-only `71e803807` was amended before its first remote push; + no remote history rewrite occurred and the original author thread was preserved. + +## 2026-08-15T11:36:00Z — first feature slice accepted and hidden CLI asset surfaced + +- #1664 S1 is independently Tier-A `PASS` at `5ac6efa30`, features checkpoint `6ea7a17fb`. + The SDK public surface is unchanged; the focused check and two semantic tests use TanStack's real + `partialMatchKey` behavior and pass. Two `QueryClient` private-type-ref doc-lint findings were + reproduced on the pre-S1 head and are carried as baseline, not misreported as green or folded into + this leaf. The same original author is executing S2 only; both expensive gates remain unleased. +- #1663 cycle-2 PLAN-EVAL returned `FAIL_PLAN` at `c415daad2`, comment `5302030430`. Execution found + that `run-deno-lint.ts` is embedded verbatim in the published CLI agent-tool bundle. Coordinator + keeps the wrapper architecture and grants exactly path 13, + `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts`, regeneration-only, with asset freshness + and the CLI publish/hash behavior delta binding. The redundant task-level doctor skip must be + removed while the root formatter exclusion remains. No product mutation is authorized yet. +- #1665's first bounded plan repair is pushed at `92bf26e11`: the overflow handoff, per-report + invalidation staging, and raw six-diagnostic doc-lint baseline are substantively repaired. The + superseding fifth-path docs ruling is being reconciled on the same author before fresh Tier-A; + no evaluator or implementation has started. + +## 2026-08-15T11:44:15Z — #1665 final plan admitted to formal evaluation + +- The same #1665 author completed the superseding fifth-path repair at clean/pushed head + `ee1b44c6d`: the stale query-bridge diagnostic is owned in place with a single dynamic URL token, + the runtime test must normalize only that token before byte comparison, and the obsolete debt + record is removed. The branch still contains run artifacts only. +- Fresh Tier-A passed at fixes topic `318bd087c`, independently closing T-1 through T-4 and + confirming exactly four declared plus five granted paths. Coordinator released one fresh native + Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL: session `0287ccbe-2740-45ee-b378-33d1c1c59429`, bridge + `cse_01GaNTjv6oY6MaxnKHH1ZfrB`, exact cwd and source head `ee1b44c6d`. No implementation or + expensive gate is authorized before its terminal verdict. + +## 2026-08-15T11:51:00Z — #1665 implementation admitted; #1663 reaches owner boundary + +- #1665 PLAN-EVAL independently passed at evaluator commit `cd5193b66`, comment `5302080198`. + It reproduced the eleven calls plus definition, the partial invalidation leak, all six named red + doc diagnostics, the dynamic-URL docs proof, the real Deno KV failure route, and the exact 4+5 + surface. The fixes supervisor corrected its own non-semantic 12-vs-11 call-count wording at topic + `7658df7e2`. Coordinator released only S1 on the same original author: fail-safe telemetry plus + bounded namespace admission, no KV-limit or diagnostic/JSDoc slice yet, and no expensive gate. +- #1663's final artifact-only repair is clean/pushed at `194e22a3d`; fresh Tier-A passed at internals + topic `b2e0529be`, preserving all 114-file, 4/4 doctor, byte restoration, publish delta, and asset + freshness contracts. Because two formal PLAN-EVAL cycles are already consumed, the coordinator + surfaced the exact owner-only decision: authorize one exceptional final evaluator or stop the + leaf. No implementation starts while that decision is pending; other topics continue. + +## 2026-08-15T12:21:00Z — independent slice gates catch two stale contracts and release next work + +- #1664 S2 required two bounded same-author repairs before acceptance. Tier-A first proved the add + path wrote appsettings, workspace membership, and Aspire helpers before the generator's + all-manifest contract validation; `f784606d0` extracted a shared preflight and added a true + zero-write `addService --with-client` regression. The broader CLI suite then exposed a second, + directly S2-caused false positive: `route-templates_test.ts` still required the forbidden + `bridgeInvalidation` import. `3669e9b87` replaced that stale assertion with exhaustive SDK import + set equality, forbidden-symbol coverage, and direct-literal ordering. Fresh Tier-A independently + reproduced 598/0 and asset freshness, passing S2 at features topic `3eab955b1`. +- Coordinator released #1664 S3 only: canonical cache-age hydration, omission coverage, the + public-wrapper browser fixture/task, package README notes, and canonical embedded regeneration. + `fresh-browser` and `scaffold.runtime` remain unleased and forbidden until the next Tier-A. +- #1665 S1 passed fresh Tier-A at product head `0e4e26c51`, fixes topic `f6f8f0fcb`. The supervisor + re-executed SDK check/lint/fmt, cache 26/0, whole SDK 65/0, and both raw doc-lint surfaces with + exactly the six pinned red diagnostics. Coordinator released S2 only: real Deno KV persistence + failure isolation with RED-before/GREEN-after and awaited `closeKv()`/`resetKv()` teardown. S3 + and every expensive gate remain fenced. + +## 2026-08-15T12:36:26Z — #1664 S3 passes and artifact-only S4 begins + +- #1664 S3 is fresh Tier-A `PASS` at leaf `1df8a5274`, features checkpoint `c91c2084a`. The + supervisor independently reproduced the complete CLI source suite at 598/0, verified clean + canonical asset regeneration, both island-specific `initialDataUpdatedAt` guards, the public + Fresh browser task wiring, the two ruled package README notes, and preservation of the earlier + C1 import/invalidation assertions plus S2 add-path pre-write atomicity. +- Coordinator completed the pre-expensive convergence review and released S4 only on the preserved + Sol/high author. S4 is artifact-only: per-member CLI/Fresh/SDK exact-pin, export/doc, JSR and + isolated publish audits followed by four immutable-head catalog receipts (`check`, `test`, + `publish-dry-run`, `arch-check`). A red result must stop for exact attribution; it cannot trigger + an inline product repair. `scaffold.runtime`, `fresh-browser`, Aspire, Docker, S5, and every + evaluator remain explicitly unauthorized and the singleton runtime lease remains free. + +## 2026-08-15T15:12:31Z — final cheap evidence converges; pre-lease scenario gap intercepted + +- #1665 completed S2 at `1cf76c6dd` and S3 at `9a26c107a`. The fixes supervisor independently + reproduced the real Deno KV RED, focused 1/0, SDK 66/0, root 4203/0/19, uncached 2925-file check, + exact fail-loud/teardown boundaries, normalized provider-message/docs identity, mandatory-evidence + JSDoc, exact six named red diagnostics, publish dry-run, quality, and architecture evidence. Its + S3 Tier-A checkpoint is `aa4749da4`. One fresh native Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL is + active as job `1fbb1c07-…`, bridge `cse_01JePyQuiERLe8GeWWKQp5wL`, bound to `9a26c107a`; evaluator + mutation is verdict-artifact-only. +- #1664 S4 needed two honest stops. First, the formatter wrapper exposed a root-exclusion plus + multi-batch interaction; the corrected CLI proof used the same neutral style in one 1000-file + batch and retained the original failure report. Second, the binding test gate—not the earlier + `./src/` stand-in—found the leaf-caused stale service-suite expectation. Topic review authorized + one exact order-sensitive insertion; fresh receipts then passed check, test 4202/0/19, + publish-dry-run, and arch-check at content head `32ea23f50`. S4 Tier-A passed at evidence head + `1c1f45820`, topic `84568f2ff`. +- Coordinator rejected the initial S5 lease request because accepted `plan.md` release condition 3 + is not implemented. Full-tree and base-to-head searches find no `payments` add/generate scenario, + no users/payments key-isolation proof, and no live Rename assertion requiring exactly one settled + `users.list` refetch plus persisted DOM value. The same original Sol/high author must add a named, + bounded CLI e2e proof slice, renew affected cheap gates and all four receipts, and stop for fresh + Tier-A. `scaffold.runtime`, `fresh-browser`, Aspire, Docker, and the singleton lease remain unused. + +## 2026-08-15T15:25:00Z — #1665 passes formal evaluation; #1664 F2 plan locks before code + +- #1665's recovered exact evaluator `1fbb1c07-…` completed native Fable 5/medium Remote Control + IMPL-EVAL with terminal `PASS` against immutable product source `9a26c107a`. Its only mutation is + `impl-eval.md` at pushed head `0fed4d7ff`, comment `5302881354`. It independently reproduced + root test 4203/0/19, an uncached 2925-file zero-diagnostic check, SDK publish dry-run, the exact + six red doc diagnostics, the identical 517-entry surface MAJOR set at base and head, and the + 13/13 JSR source-child baseline. The README raw-format observation is advisory because the + repository format gate is TypeScript-only. +- Coordinator reconciled all verified acceptance evidence in place: five PR definition-of-done + boxes and thirteen issue boxes across #1598/#1619/#1620/#1623 are checked; #1637 defines none. + `status:plan` is replaced by `status:ready-merge`, and #1665 left draft at the same evaluated + head so required readiness CI—not the vacuous draft check set—now runs before merge. +- #1664's same original Sol/high author committed and explicitly pushed the F2 plan amendment + `4be440020` before any product edit. It binds three scaffold/static gates into both service and + runtime suites after init, one live CDP refetch gate into runtime only after readiness, pure + fail-capable unit assertions, and four new exact-head binding receipts. Implementation is active; + the singleton lease, Aspire, Docker, `scaffold.runtime`, and `fresh-browser` remain unused. + +## 2026-08-15T15:34:28Z — readiness finding recovered; executable proof defects intercepted + +- #1665 exact-head readiness run `31892668157` passed close-gate, change classification, lint, + TypeScript format, and docs accuracy, then quality job `95031217843` failed honestly at + `check:agent-docs-prose`. The authorized query-bridge page is a bundle source, leaving only + `.llm/assets/agent-docs/prose.json.gz` and `provenance.json` stale. The fixes supervisor committed + and pushed scope amendment `ef396767a`; the same original Sol/medium author ran the canonical + generator, proved the immediate diff contains exactly those two assets, and is executing bounded + freshness/docs/SDK/no-new-doc-diagnostic gates. Formal product IMPL-EVAL PASS is preserved, but + readiness is withdrawn until fresh Tier-A and a focused fidelity delta evaluation pass. +- #1664 justified the browser transport split because the combined probe crossed the 500-line + doctrine threshold and pushed exact plan amendment `93fb5532d` before product commit `787cfa928`. + Direct inspection then found two executable defects still present: a response-stage Fetch pause + resumed through `Fetch.continueRequest`, and a fixed 750ms sleep established a baseline without + proving every initial request completed and remained stable. Topic checkpoint `37372cbae` records + the interception. The same original Sol/high author must repair additively, add the negative + late-initial-request case, renew all four binding receipts, and stop for fresh Tier-A. No runtime + lease or evaluator is authorized. +- The unrelated typed-queue DLQ count timing flake is tracked separately as #1667 rather than being + hidden by retries or folded into either leaf. + +## 2026-08-15T15:50:53Z — corpus fidelity passes; transitive barrel and zero-request baseline caught + +- #1665 repair `7549d9fc0` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at topic `7fe2f433e`. Fresh Fable 5/medium + Remote Control delta evaluator `08eb7184`, bridge `cse_01Jc8aRcLQFVyVWKogq6SaFC`, independently + regenerated and byte-compared the corpus, proved only query-bridge plus its aggregate changed, + preserved the prior product verdict, and returned `PASS` at artifact head `72d57229f` with comment + `5302983190`. +- Exact-head readiness still failed: run `31893659579`, quality job `95033583015`, reaches + `check:assets-barrel`, whose canonical regeneration changes only + `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-docs.generated.ts` from the old embedded corpus to the new + one. The fixes supervisor reproduced that in a disposable worktree, removed it, and pushed exact + scope amendment `215aae4b2`. Both prior PASS verdicts remain valid for their actual scopes; neither + proves this newly discovered transitive generated dependency. Same-author repair, fresh Tier-A, + and one focused asset-chain delta verdict are required before readiness resumes. +- #1664's author repaired additively at `2c8219968` and pushed local == remote == PR. The live probe + now clicks the generated Refresh control because hydrated data with `staleTime: 15_000` may issue + zero automatic list requests; it then requires at least one observed request, all IDs completed, + and a stable confirmation window before recording baseline. Response-stage Fetch resumes through + `continueResponse`, and the same exported stability primitive is driven by the negative late- + initial-request unit case. Focused tests are 8/0; fresh binding receipts are active. Lease closed. + +## 2026-08-15T15:57:31Z — F2 Tier-A passes and the known four-link asset cascade is restored + +- #1664's author completed four fresh exact-head receipts at evidence head `b14975af7`: check, + 4210/0 tests with 19 ignored, publish dry-run, and architecture check all exited 0. The evidence + evaluator returned `SUFFICIENT`; fresh features Tier-A independently confirmed the three probe + repairs and pushed `63d190d4b`. After a clean Docker/Aspire-application/browser/port audit, the coordinator + granted the singleton S5 lease: `scaffold.runtime` first with cleanup, then `fresh-browser` only + after a clean inter-gate audit. PR #1664 stays draft and no evaluator is authorized yet. +- #1665's original author regenerated exactly the authorized CLI barrel and independently found the + next consumer, `packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts`, correctly refusing to mutate it + outside the `215aae4b2` grant. The fixes supervisor proved `check:publish-assets` is red only on the + branch and named one path; exhaustively classified the only fifth candidate as a pre-existing red; + and pushed the link-4 amendment and exact closure proof at `92ea9f829` before mutation. +- Central state already contained the same four-path generated-asset cascade from shipped #1652. + Failure to reuse that precedent for #1665 caused two avoidable readiness cycles. The correction is + now structural: converge source, corpus, CLI barrel, and MCP publish asset on one content head + before fresh Tier-A, the focused delta evaluator, or readiness can resume. + +## 2026-08-15T16:03:00Z — runtime gate falsifies its proof; link 3 lands cleanly + +- #1664 acquired the S5 lease only after preflight and ran the suite-owned `scaffold.runtime` gate. + Service add and generate passed, but `generated.service-client-contract` failed: the temporary + consumer imports a users contract whose canonical DB Zod output does not yet exist, and sends the + users list input shape to the differently typed payments list factory. Result was 6 pass / 1 fail / + 0 skipped. `fresh-browser` never started. In-suite Aspire cleanup and post-run leak-check passed; + Docker, AppHost/DCP, ports, and survivors are empty. The lease is released at topic `d2e83f690`. +- The first feature attribution mentioned three errors but explained only the two input mismatches. + Coordinator interception required F3 to include TS2307, inspect the canonical DB-generation + lifecycle, remove the false equal-tail assumption, and prove each real service's typed key/filter + behavior. Scope amendment must be pushed before the same original author mutates; fresh Tier-A is + mandatory before a new runtime lease. +- #1665 link 3 landed at `27a64ea4c`, exactly the CLI generated barrel plus run artifacts, explicitly + pushed with repair receipt `5303037805`. The fixes supervisor inspected the predicted six + provenance-field deltas and queued the already-amended link-4 brief on the same author thread. + +## 2026-08-15T16:14:20Z — four-link closure passes; F3 isolates generated-app dependencies + +- #1665 link 4 landed cleanly at `9a2c74c41`, exactly + `packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts` plus run artifacts, with receipt `5303077056`. + Fresh fixes Tier-A ran `check:agent-docs-prose`, `check:assets-barrel`, and + `check:publish-assets` together on that immutable head in a detached worktree; all three exited 0 + and all generators left the tree clean. Topic checkpoint `cbd32230e` records PASS and the honest + lint coverage limits. Exactly one fresh native Fable 5/medium Remote Control chain evaluator is + active as `262ef8e1-…`, bridge `cse_01E3QfD1wkvb1naZKS6m7bp2`; its mutation is artifact-only and + readiness remains fenced until its terminal verdict. +- #1664's cheap replay found that importing the parent runtime probe into a generated app pulls in + parent-package import-map dependencies. The original Sol/high author widened only the internal + proof surface, committing and explicitly pushing `c4a900adc` before creating the new + dependency-free input-derivation module. Earlier F3 product edits remain inside the prior grant; + the new file had not been created at the immutable amendment boundary. The author continues cheap + tests and four fresh receipts; no runtime lease, Aspire, Docker, or browser gate is active. + +## 2026-08-15T16:27:03Z — final asset-chain evaluation passes; F3 check receipt stops honestly + +- #1665's fresh native Fable 5/medium Remote Control chain evaluator returned `PASS`, committed only + `delta-eval-asset-chain.md` as `ac274a464`, pushed explicitly, and published verdict comment + `5303120561`. It independently reproduced all three generators simultaneously, byte-compared the + common prose/provenance payload through the CLI barrel and MCP asset, found no fifth branch-caused + mirror, and confirmed the authorized source set plus all carried reds. Fixes topic checkpoint + `7a81326a6` reconciles the terminal verdict. Exact-head readiness has all checks terminal green or + intentionally skipped except `check-test`, which remains active; merge and relabel stay fenced. +- #1664's original Sol/high author completed and pushed F3 product head `6e822a74b`: canonical DB + codegen precedes the contract gate, real generated service schemas derive their own inputs through + a dependency-free primitive, focused tests are 29/0, and bounded structured checks are clean. + The first new immutable-head receipt then failed root check honestly at unchanged + `verify-producer-reconnect.ts:268` with `Type 'Timeout' is not assignable to type 'number'`. + Receipt `s4-f3-check.json` is preserved and all later receipts stopped. Because F3 replaced + `@std/path` with `node:path` in a shared Deno batch while the pre-F3 exact-head receipt passed, the + same author is running isolated before/after attribution; no retry, lease, runtime gate, or + evaluator is permitted until that evidence is terminal and any leaf-caused repair is scoped and + pushed before mutation. + +## 2026-08-15T16:31:00Z — #1665 ships; #1664 preserves its failed binding evidence + +- #1665's final `check-test` completed successfully at `ac274a464`; every exact-head check was then + terminal green or intentionally skipped, `review_threads` remained empty, the PR head and closing + keywords were unchanged, and exactly one lifecycle label was advanced from `status:impl-eval` to + `status:ready-merge`. The coordinator squash-merged PR #1665 as + `3e8e146a4aedf8ee0afec15c83ddaefc171c71f9` at 16:29:46Z. Issues #1598, #1619, #1620, #1623, + and #1637 all closed automatically. The fixes supervisor is reconciling the terminal lifecycle and + may advance only its next dependency-ready queued leaf through the normal serial gates. +- #1664 committed and pushed the original immutable-head failed receipt and attribution report as + artifact-only `3278cca34`. The pre-F3 `c53726c69` archive ran the same root check over 2,924 files + with zero diagnostics, whereas F3 selected 2,937 files and failed the unchanged reconnect timer + assignment. The supervisor therefore rejected a carried-baseline classification and instructed + the same original author to restore a non-Node path boundary, prove the victim and repaired probe + in one batch, preserve the failed receipt, and use distinct replacement receipts. No runtime or + evaluator work is active. + +## 2026-08-15T16:43:09Z — F3 repair passes and receives the singleton runtime lease + +- #1664's isolated attribution proved the leaf caused the shared-batch timer red: the unchanged + victim passes alone and with the F3 probe on `@std/path`, but fails when the probe imports + `node:path`. Features checkpoint `ca10ffaeb` recorded that evidence before the same Sol/high author + repaired the boundary. Product head `193e665ba` restores only a Deno-native path dependency and + evidence head `8940e9266` preserves the first FAIL plus four distinct PASS/SUFFICIENT receipts: + root check 2,937 files/25 batches/0 diagnostics, root test 4,212/0/19, publish dry-run PASS, and + architecture zero failures. Fresh features Tier-A independently reran the decisive combined batch + and passed at topic `c7ce2c3f6`. +- Clean preflight verified leaf local = remote = PR at `8940e9266`, zero Docker containers, no Aspire + application/AppHost/DCP, no browser, no relevant listener, and no competing expensive lease. The + coordinator persisted active lease `app-service-client-wiring-f3-runtime` before dispatch. The + features supervisor must run suite-owned `scaffold.runtime` first, clean Aspire/Docker and prove an + empty host, then may run catalog-backed `fresh-browser` serially only on scaffold PASS; a second + cleanup and empty-host audit are mandatory before release. +- Central state now also reconciles #1663's stale evaluator lease to its terminal cycle-2 + `FAIL_PLAN` owner boundary; no third evaluator was launched. Internals #1666 is clean/pushed at + amended plan head `a3f6b87b5`, with the tenth refusal-test path and browser waiver recorded before + fresh Tier-A/PLAN-EVAL. Fixes #1461 is active on its original/new Sol/medium author in + research/plan-only mode. PR #1665 and its five closed issues have sole `status:shipped`; follow-up + export-corpus debt is tracked by #1668. + +## 2026-08-15T16:49:14Z — #1666 enters formal plan evaluation; #1461 plan surfaces a second stale claim + +- Internals independently passed Tier-A on #1666 amended head `a3f6b87b5` and pushed topic + checkpoint `d5f5ea55a`. Separate evaluator job `68c31fcc`, bridge + `cse_01DcmCJnvESF3a4nVDvUR8u8`, is verified native Claude Fable 5/medium Remote Control and active + artifact-only over that exact head. The rendered reference page makes the browser waiver a named + risk, not evidence of absence; docs build/source gates remain binding and fresh-browser remains + truthfully NOT_RUN. +- Fixes author pushed plan-only head `7e5be1514` and opened draft PR #1669 for #1461. It chooses the + existing callable action plus metadata read rather than a new public API and plans real overlapping + stale-reader proof plus the known four-link generated-asset cascade. Coordinator audit also found + the same false background-refresh claim in + `docs/site/tutorials/live-dashboard/03-sdk-cache-first-query.md`; that exact path requires a + scope amendment before implementation so the leaf does not knowingly leave duplicate stale prose. + +## 2026-08-15T16:53:06Z — #1664 runtime stops on a false idempotency premise; lease released cleanly + +- #1664 ran the exact suite-owned `scaffold.runtime` command at run-only head `ab78eaa35`, product + content `193e665ba`, and returned 20 passed / 1 failed / 0 skipped. The sole red was the leaf's new + `generated.service-client-contract`: after multiple plugin installs changed the Aspire-helper + inputs, a later `service generate` wrote zero client modules, skipped both current clients, and + reconciled three Aspire helper files. The probe called that a second idempotency run and demanded + zero helper writes, but the intervening plugin mutations mean it was not a consecutive same-input + rerun. This is a leaf-caused proof-contract false positive, not a carried product failure. +- Evidence head `e1dcb726b` and PR comment `5303253456` preserve the raw suite log and exact failure. + Suite cleanup passed; run-owned teardown removed nothing; independent final leak-check reports + Aspire ok, Docker ok, and zero survivors. Fresh-browser is truthfully NOT_RUN. The coordinator + released the singleton lease. F4 must be amended and pushed before mutation, then prove one + reconciliation run followed by a second identical zero-client/zero-helper run; cheap receipts and + fresh Tier-A are required before another lease. + +## 2026-08-15T16:57:59Z — #1666 cycle 1 fails honestly; three-lane repairs continue + +- #1666's fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL returned `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit + `5d229e0f3`, comment `5303254623`. It found three additional shipped Contracts JSDoc examples that + import symbols from the non-exporting root, so issue #1296 row 1 was not otherwise satisfied. + Coordinator authorized exactly those three JSDoc-only paths and kept `Closes #1296`: transformer + imports move to `/transform`; filter/pagination examples move to `/query`. SA-2 must also correct + the inherited wiring claim—`docs-accuracy` is already fail-closed in non-draft CI—and address all + evaluator N1-N5 before fresh Tier-A and one cycle-2 evaluator. #1663 remains untouched. +- #1664's false-positive attribution is now empirically terminal: after the failed post-plugin run + reconciled three helper files, two consecutive identical generates each reported 0 clients + written, 2 clients skipped, 0 helpers written, and complete helper hashes stayed byte-identical. + Features F4 is active on the preserved author under amendment-before-mutation rules. +- #1461 plan head `ebf8977c1` reconciled its SDK doc-lint baseline. Fixes topic `20856dce0` is + delivering the already-authorized second tutorial page amendment to the same author; no product + mutation, evaluator, or runtime lease exists yet. + +## 2026-08-15T17:11:14Z — #1664 F4 passes Tier-A and immutable attempt 3 is leased + +- #1664's preserved Sol/high author pushed the amendment at `b40616a81` before product repair + `7876aa109`, then committed four binding receipts at evidence head `6f813b0db`. Check selected + 2,937 files with zero diagnostics; root test passed 4,213 with zero failures; publish dry-run and + architecture checks passed. Features Tier-A independently reproduced the 11/0 focused sequence + proof, including second-write and byte-drift rejection, recomputed the receipts sufficient, and + pushed topic checkpoint `35f3a6975`. +- Clean-host preflight proved local == remote == PR and found no Docker container, Aspire + application process, watched listener, or competing lease. Central attempt 3 is bound to final + evidence head `6f813b0db` before execution. Run suite-owned `scaffold.runtime` first; cleanup and + empty-host audit are mandatory; `fresh-browser` is eligible only if scaffold passes. +- #1461's exact second-source amendment is pushed at `eadd672d0`, but fresh fixes Tier-A correctly + returned `FAIL_FIX` at `9e9d02ebb`: the same authorized tutorial repeats the SWR narrative at + lines 13, 15, 75, 76, and 80 while demonstrating pure-read `getCachedEntry`. The preserved author + must give each line an explicit retain/correct disposition before PLAN-EVAL. #1666 SA-2 remains + plan-only on its preserved author; no evaluator or product mutation exists there yet. + +## 2026-08-15T17:18:10Z — #1666 SA-2 passes Tier-A and cycle 2 attaches + +- The preserved #1666 author committed and explicitly pushed plan-only SA-2 head `80046696e` with + the full nine-line Contracts inventory, four wrong-root examples, thirteen-path/fourteenth-refusal + guards, corrected existing CI enforcement chain, all N1-N5 mechanics, and four-file #1533 + sequencing. No JSDoc or product edit occurred. +- Internals Tier-A passed at topic `bb8c12f56`. Fresh native evaluator session + `580832d7-53e8-4828-ad41-e2f9219c9340`, PID 379716, runs Fable 5/medium with `--remote-control` + over exact head `80046696e`. The bridge identifier has not yet been emitted, so central state + records pending attachment metadata and the observed native session/process proof. This is cycle + 2 of 2; a further `FAIL_PLAN` returns to the owner boundary rather than creating cycle 3. + +## 2026-08-15T17:19:55Z — #1664 attempt 3 stops at generated format and releases cleanly + +- Suite-owned `scaffold.runtime` passed 32 gates, including the repaired service-client convergence + and identical-repeat proof, then failed only `generated.deno-fmt-check`; generated workspace + `fmt:check` exited 1. `fresh-browser` is ineligible and remains NOT_RUN. +- `cleanup.aspire-stop` passed. Run-owned teardown found no AppHost, container, or escalation, and + independent leak-check reports Aspire ok, Docker ok, zero survivors. The singleton lease is + released. The author is preserving raw output and performing before/after attribution only; no + product mutation or runtime retry is authorized. + +## 2026-08-15T17:29:40Z — two plan evaluators active; #1664 attribution challenged + +- #1461 T-1 repair `23db20f30` gives explicit dispositions for every matched claim on both + authorized pages, including tutorial lines 13, 15, 32, 75, 76, 80, 94, 100, and 107. Fresh fixes + Tier-A passed at `f71e860f9`. Separate native Fable 5/medium Remote Control evaluator job + `01f0eda8`, bridge `cse_01SWnk7LwvoLaamvEwR5WLfX`, is active over that immutable head. +- #1666 cycle-2 session `580832d7...` completed re-derivation and was interrupted before writing an + artifact. There was no verdict or mutation, so the same evaluator history resumed—rather than a + replacement cycle—as job `0e2d1e57`, bridge `cse_01K6SbsotG5MyjyjTd11SrfK`, still Fable + 5/medium Remote Control over `80046696e`. +- #1664 evidence head `09a771c8e` preserves the 32/1/0 result and clean host. Coordinator rejected + a blanket pre-existing attribution based on one unchanged helper: the exact format red has twelve + paths, including leaf-owned generated users/payments clients and payments service/contract output. + Fresh features Tier-A must classify every path before a bounded repair ruling. + +## 2026-08-15T17:32:06Z — #1666 plan passes; #1664 repair surface remains under review + +- Recovered #1666 cycle-2 evaluator returned `PASS` at `45c249b9c`, comment `5303401348`. It + independently found no fifth wrong-root example, accepted the thirteen-path/refusal design and + N1-N5 mechanics, and kept all product paths immutable. Internals topic `fd96c2075` resumed the + preserved author into S1 only; S2/S3 remain serially gated by fresh slice review. +- Features Tier-A at `0d0ba1b7a` correctly proved the format gate leaf-caused: both users and + payments client modules come from the leaf-modified scaffolder and violate `deno fmt`. The report + also exposed seven unchanged helper reds and three payments outputs needing baseline measurement. + Coordinator returned the topic for a corrected 2 + 3 + 7 = 12 inventory and a repair that can + actually make the load-bearing gate green; no F5 product dispatch or retry exists yet. + +## 2026-08-15T17:36:05Z — #1669 plan passes and S1 starts; #1664 F5 is held to F4 + +- #1669's separate native Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL returned `PASS` at evaluator + commit `d555cc971`, comment `5303412171`. It independently confirmed the no-new-public-API + callable-action design, policy-aware persistence-complete single-flight, deterministic two-reader + proof, exact two-page/four-mirror closure, and pinned raw doc-lint reds. It also correctly refuted + a Tier-A overclaim: `docs-accuracy` has no chapter-3 assertion, so the S2 sentence requires manual + Tier-A plus IMPL-EVAL evidence rather than a false mechanical receipt. Fixes topic `370ff6eba` + dispatched only S1 to the preserved Sol/medium author; S2 remains held for fresh slice review. +- Features topic `f5f75adc8` corrected the format inventory to 2 clients + 3 payments outputs + 7 + Aspire helpers and established one post-init canonicalization root cause. Coordinator authorized + a same-author F5 plan amendment only, while rejecting a post-write-only formatter shape because + it would compare unformatted rendered content to formatted disk content on the next run and + regress F4's zero-write invariant. The amendment must bind exact paths and canonicalize before + equality/write, then stop for fresh Tier-A. No product mutation, runtime retry, browser run, or + lease is active. + +## 2026-08-15T17:55:29Z — two fresh reviews advance honestly; one metric-game is rejected + +- #1666 S1 head `678840603` passed fresh internals Tier-A at topic `6c183ef16`. The review + independently exercised empty/unknown/garbage policy refusal, verified 168 live Fresh UI exports + plus exactly seven labeled non-exports, required non-empty structured selections, and preserved + the nine unrelated Contracts doc-lint findings as red. The preserved author is now active on S2 + only: named task, fail-closed docs-accuracy child surfacing, and one repo-root Pages step with no + duplicate execution. S3 remains held. +- #1664 same-author plan-only F5 amendment `3204ffa98` binds all twelve outputs to four writer + owners and proposes one internal formatter port across a 15-product/12-test ceiling. Fresh + features Tier-A returned `FAIL_FIX` at topic `c8d3acb92`: the architecture is defensible, but the + proof matrix must add piped-stdin timeout/kill closure, defined empty-content behavior, unknown + extension refusal, and justify or remove `services-group.ts`. The same author is repairing only + the plan; no product mutation or lease exists. +- #1669 S1 behavior was pushed at `e05a54145` with focused 5/5 and SDK 68/68 green, but coordinator + pre-review rejected its claimed F-1 closure: the author deleted useful private-method JSDoc and + blank-line structure to land at 499 lines. That is metric gaming, not architectural reduction. + The same preserved author is restoring the documentation and must either reduce structurally + within the two-file grant or return an exact one-file internal-helper proposal before widening. + S2 remains blocked on fresh fixes Tier-A. + +## 2026-08-15T18:00:45Z — #1666 S2 lands; #1664 F5 implementation is released + +- #1666 S2 committed and explicitly pushed `47ca22abe`. The leaf is clean and local, remote, and PR + heads match. The exact implementation adds the least-privilege `docs:exports-drift` task, has + `docs:accuracy` invoke that named fail-closed child with output surfacing preserved, and adds one + guarded repo-root Pages step. The internals supervisor was recovered from an old prompt and is now + performing fresh Tier-A; S3 remains held until that verdict. +- #1664 plan-only F5-A1 repair `630185e2c` binds the EOF-before-timeout proof, writer closure and + kill return, explicit supported-extension zero-byte behavior, fail-closed absent/unknown extension + handling, and the `services-group.ts` dependency-projection reason. Fresh features Tier-A returned + `PASS` at topic `53f97644d` and dispatched the same original Sol/high author under the unchanged + 15-product/12-test ceiling. Four new exact-head receipts and a fresh Tier-A remain mandatory; no + runtime lease, Aspire, Docker, browser, or evaluator is authorized. +- #1669's corrective working tree now restores all named method documentation and replaces duplicate + `getCachedData`/`getCachedEntry` store-read spans with one private cache-entry read path. It is 497 + lines versus the 490-line base, an honest structural reduction with headroom. Commit/push and fresh + fixes Tier-A remain pending; S2 is still blocked. + +## 2026-08-15T18:07:44Z — fresh slice reviews release #1666 S3 and #1669 S2 + +- #1666 S2 `47ca22abe` passed fresh internals Tier-A at topic `dbe72c50e`. Independent review + reproduced direct and aggregate raw exit 0, checked least-privilege child execution, verified the + checker runs once per path, and observed the guarded Pages build terminal green. S3 is active on + the same original author and may create run artifacts only: seven exact-head receipts, focused + drift proof, JSR audits, thirteen-path authorization audit, and byte-identical lock proof. +- #1669 transparent correction `e100ea205` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `c01f32141`. The review + compared comment, blank-line, and code counts against base; executed 5/5 focused and 68/68 SDK + tests; verified both A2/A3 regressions are sleep-free; and confirmed the documented source is 497 + lines with no F-1. The earlier pushed head remains in history and its overclaim is superseded by + PR comment `5303528330`. The same original author is being recovered into S2 only; IMPL-EVAL remains + after fresh S2 review. No runtime lease is active. + +- Delivery recovery completed at 18:11Z: the original #1669 author is active on S2 with the exact + two-page/one-test/four-mirror grant. The dispatch explicitly carries A1 manual-evidence truth, A4 + default-versus-`preferFreshOnStale` posture, generated-cascade containment, pinned red reporting, + and a hard stop for fresh Tier-A before IMPL-EVAL. + +## 2026-08-15T18:17:33Z — #1669 executable docs proof exposes a pre-existing option defect + +- The new query-factory regression correctly stopped S2 before generation or commit: a fresh cached + entry still fetched when called with `preferFreshOnStale: true`. Inspection confirms the condition + `isExpired || preferFreshOnStale` predates S1 and runs before `isFresh`, contradicting the public + stale-only option contract. +- Coordinator authorized plan artifacts first and exactly one additional source path, + `packages/sdk/src/cache/cache-query.ts`. The repair must retain expired-entry precedence while + applying the preference only to stale entries. The existing authorized factory test covers fresh + zero-fetch, missing one-fetch/current timestamp, and two overlapping blocking stale loaders with + one shared refresh. No cache-query test or other source is granted without a fresh necessity + finding. Current dirty docs/test changes remain uncommitted while the amendment is reviewed. + +## 2026-08-15T18:25:53Z — three fresh gates advance in parallel + +- #1666 final S3 Tier-A returned `PASS` at internals topic `18eed10c9`. Evidence head `d095c1260` + contains run artifacts only and attests immutable source `47ca22abe`; all seven receipts are unique, + exact-head PASS and recompute SUFFICIENT. One fresh native Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL + is launching artifact-only. #1663 remains parked. +- #1669 S2-A plan-only head `ef3e43f06` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `684c37d63`. The exact five + artifact paths, baseline attribution, expired-preserving predicate, query-factory proof, and + preserved S1 A2/A3 plus 497/no-F1 invariants are accepted. The same author is resumed for the + one-line repair and remaining S2 work. +- #1664 F5 content `fda78ee43` and evidence `1263f655b` are clean/pushed. Four exact-content-head + receipts PASS and recompute SUFFICIENT: check 2,944 files/25 batches/0 diagnostics; root test + 4,226/0/19; publish dry-run; architecture check. Fresh features Tier-A is active. Independent + pinned-Deno probing accepts all 26 allowlist extensions; current surface is 15 product, 11 test, + zero outside the 27-path ceiling. No runtime lease exists. + +## 2026-08-15T18:30:23Z — final F5 review passes and attempt-4 runtime lease is granted + +- #1664 final fresh features Tier-A is `PASS` at topic `9a5521aa0`. The review accepted the exact + 15-product/11-test/zero-outside surface, exact-12 generated formatting proof, immediate + byte-identical repeat, retained F4 and S2 atomicity, and the timeout/EOF/zero-byte/extension + boundaries. Local, remote, and PR heads equal immutable evidence `1263f655b`. +- The Aspire-orchestration preflight is clean: `aspire ps --format Json` returned `[]`; Docker has + zero running containers; no AppHost, DCP, application, browser, or relevant listener exists; no + competing runtime lease exists. Idle `aspire mcp start` helpers remain untouched. Attempt 4 owns + the singleton lease at evidence `1263f655b` / content `fda78ee43`: run `scaffold.runtime`, clean + and audit, then run `fresh-browser` only on PASS and clean/audit again. No evaluator is authorized. +- #1666 IMPL-EVAL is confirmed active as native Fable 5/medium Remote Control session + `3882ca70-7857-46ca-aa24-8b1ae2664516`, bridge `cse_013RnnFDtHQhEbFhJCLbkEsD`, judging immutable + implementation `47ca22abe` plus evidence `d095c1260` artifact-only. #1669 has made exactly the + approved one-line `!isFresh` predicate correction and continues the bounded S2 completion. + +## 2026-08-15T18:41:18Z — #1666 IMPL-EVAL finds one durable-test defect + +- #1666 cycle-1 IMPL-EVAL is terminal `FAIL_FIX` at evaluator commit `4c09e9203`, comment + `5303665087`. The evaluator mutation-tested all four refusal assertions: OMITS is discriminating, + but reason, mode, and INVENTS can stay green because a fixture `NotFound` or a simultaneous OMITS + error supplies the same nonzero result. The checker behavior and every other acceptance, scope, + receipt, baseline-red, pin, lock, wiring, and waiver judgment independently hold. +- Internals topic `3c8db8178` returned the exact already-authorized test path to the same original + Sol/medium author. The repair must assert each specific refusal cause, use a real fixture directory, + prevent OMITS from masking INVENTS, mutation-prove all four named tests fail independently, re-cut + all seven receipts at one new immutable head, and stop for fresh Tier-A before cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL. + No product, checker, workflow, runtime, merge, label, ready, issue, or central-scope mutation is + authorized. + +## 2026-08-15T18:48:52Z — #1664 attempt 4 stops at a cleanup exception and releases the lease + +- Suite-owned `scaffold.runtime` passed 69 gates, including the previously red generated format + gate, then failed `behavior.service-client-refetch`: after the browser child had already exited, + `collectBrowserRefetchEvidence` called `child.kill('SIGTERM')` and Deno threw `TypeError: Child + process has already terminated`. Raw exit is red; no behavioral verdict is inferred from the + cleanup exception. Raw log SHA-256 is + `b476da4ce039d03785e46669d51919b48c41fbae80ca41ca9188bcbb53e97f23`. +- Suite `cleanup.aspire-stop` passed. Independent Aspire-orchestration audit reports `aspire ps []`, + Docker zero, no AppHost/DCP/application/browser process, and no relevant listener. The singleton + lease is released; `fresh-browser` remains `NOT_RUN`. Preserve evidence and attribute the child + lifecycle contract before any scoped repair; no retry, browser gate, or evaluator is authorized. + +## 2026-08-15T19:03:12Z — completed leaf heads are recovered into fresh review + +- #1664's same-author F6 plan-only amendment is clean and explicitly pushed at `36da13fa1`, with + structured PR receipt `5303765269`. It authorizes no new path: the later repair is confined to the + existing browser probe and runtime-probe test, names an internal termination helper, tolerates only + Deno's exact already-terminated `TypeError`, awaits status and drain, and requires deterministic + natural-exit, active-termination, unrelated-error, drain-rejection, and production-delegation + proofs. Fresh features Tier-A is active; no source repair or runtime lease precedes its PASS. +- #1666's focused test repair is committed at `423867017`; local evidence `010da98a2` contains all + seven replacement receipts at that immutable content head. Each replacement exits 0 and binds + `gitHead == actualGitHead`. The first root-test receipt remains red because the author's temporary + mutation archive contained forbidden command strings; the archive was removed and the distinct + `test-attempt2` receipt is green. Internals is completing explicit push/comment before fresh Tier-A + and cycle-2 native Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL. +- #1669 S2 is clean and pushed at evidence `9aa54ae2d` over content `eba0b0924`, with implementation + receipt `5303754598`. The focused factory suite is 6/0, SDK is 69/0, root is 4206/0/19, root check + is 2925 files with zero failures, all three committed-head generated freshness gates pass, and the + known doc-lint and surface-diff reds remain reported red. Fresh fixes Tier-A is active before a + separate IMPL-EVAL; no runtime lease is involved. +- Cleanup verification went beyond `aspire ps []`: an explicit process scan found four stopped + `aspire-managed nuget search` children left by attempt 4. Exact-PID TERM/CONT and bounded KILL + removed them without touching foreign `aspire mcp start` helpers. Final `aspire ps` is `[]`, Docker + is empty, and no AppHost/DCP/application/browser process or relevant listener remains. + +- Follow-on delivery proof: #1666 local, remote, and PR now equal `010da98a2`; structured repair + comment is `5303770640`, so internals is performing fresh Tier-A without waiting on the old author + process heuristic. #1664 F6 plan received fresh features Tier-A `PASS` at topic `f436df086`; the + same original author is active on exactly the two reviewed paths, with no runtime action allowed. + +## 2026-08-15T19:08:30Z — two final implementation evaluators are attached + +- #1666 repair passed fresh internals Tier-A at `0646f429f`. Native Fable 5/medium Remote Control + cycle 2 is active as job `7a3b4645-5548-42e6-84fa-35c1f90158dd`, attached at + `https://claude.ai/code/session_01MDMbe68iYvjHBLuUGKZqBS`, and bound to repaired content + `423867017` plus evidence `010da98a2`. It is the final ordinary IMPL-EVAL cycle. +- #1669 S2 passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `a374977d8`; root tests independently reproduced + 4206/0/19 without the #1667 flake. Native Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL cycle 1 is active + as job `f40814ce-5b41-49ae-8cf2-e65014de01de`, attached at + `https://claude.ai/code/session_01CMrdm9P2YwHxiNCT49C4Hf`, and bound to content `eba0b0924` plus + evidence `9aa54ae2d`. +- Both evaluator leases are artifact-only. They may not mutate product, run runtime gates, merge, + flip ready, relabel, close issues, or touch central state. #1664 continues independently. + +## 2026-08-15T19:14:29Z — #1666 final IMPL-EVAL passes + +- Cycle-2 native Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at `ee67d12b4`, PR + comment `5303804773`. The evaluator wrote only `impl-eval.md` plus the preserved cycle-1 artifact, + independently made all four named tests red under their exact mutation, and accepted the repaired + checker/test/receipt/acceptance surface without a required fix. +- Two sentences in the dispatched brief still named the cycle-1 implementation head `47ca22abe` for + receipt binding, contradicting the brief's correct three-head table and repair section. The live + evaluator artifact was already committed when detected, but it consistently binds all eight + physical `fix1` receipts to `423867017` and selects seven PASS gate ids with the initial red + preserved. The stale text therefore did not contaminate the verdict; the brief-generation mistake + remains append-only drift to prevent recurrence. +- PR #1666 is still draft. Artifact-only-head Actions classified and skipped unrelated lanes while + the docs build remained green; internals is preparing the five-box coordinator close-gate mapping. + No ready flip, label change, issue edit, merge, or #1663 action has fired. + +## 2026-08-15T19:18:20Z — #1666 enters the real close-gate + +- The coordinator updated the PR body to reflect the delivered repair/evaluator heads and checked + all nine authoritative Definition-of-Done rows. One `acceptance-evidence` block maps the exact five + live #1296 boxes by index to evaluator/repair/readiness URLs in PR comment `5303825255`. +- `status:impl` was replaced by `status:ready-merge` while the PR remained draft. The live mirror + dry-run accepted the mapping against issue-body SHA-256 + `f66987e42a7c88f7a1741cfb0fdc5f25f7189686d9c6b43a18e5f9ba4cd14037` and proposed #1296 without + mutation. The PR was then marked ready for review, preserving head `ee67d12b4` and the evaluator. +- Ready-for-review created current-head CI run `31903523137` plus current companion workflows. Merge + remains prohibited until the real acceptance mirror checks all five issue boxes, close-gate and + core visibility report SUCCESS rather than SKIPPED, and every required current-head check is green. + +## 2026-08-15T19:24:31Z — readiness rollback and two evidence-preserving recoveries + +- #1666 CI run `31903523137` exposed two different conditions. `close-gate` raced the ready label, + observed no `status:ready-merge`, and therefore left all five #1296 boxes unchanged. That run is + eligible for an existing-run rerun only after the real blocker is repaired. `quality` is a genuine + leaf-owned red: `docs/site/reference/fresh-ui/index.md` changed while + `.llm/assets/agent-docs/prose.json.gz` and `provenance.json` remained stale, with the generator-owned + CLI/MCP publish cascade still to be verified. +- The coordinator immediately removed `status:ready-merge`, restored `status:impl`, converted #1666 + back to draft, and left #1296 untouched. The accepted cycle-2 IMPL-EVAL remains append-only + pre-finding evidence but cannot authorize readiness at a future head. Internals received a precise + same-author plan-before-mutation rescope: verify the exact four-link cascade, fresh Tier-A, generate + and recut applicable receipts, a second Tier-A, then a fresh delta IMPL-EVAL. +- #1664 product `7fa29ad3e` passed its first F6 binding check, then the root test stopped honestly at + 4228/1/19 because `forbidden-commands_test` traversed an ignored root-owned attempt-4 Postgres data + directory. Evidence `4c7792f20` preserves both receipts and the attribution. With Docker empty and + no process owning the path, the exact tree was moved recoverably to + `/tmp/netscript-f6-quarantine.7kXcDX/plugin-smoke-20260815-203755`. Features must create a distinct + `f6-test-attempt2` at unchanged content; no receipt is overwritten and no product repair is implied. + +## 2026-08-15T19:31:02Z — #1669 enters current-head readiness + +- Native Fable 5/medium Remote Control IMPL-EVAL completed `PASS` at artifact-only commit + `313cc08d5`, PR comment `5303850473`. The only path after implementation evidence `9aa54ae2d` is + `impl-eval.md`; local, explicit remote, and PR heads all equal the evaluator commit, and the + thread-level review query found zero review threads. +- The coordinator rewrote stale readiness prose in the PR body and checked all eleven current DoD + rows. Comment `5303873817` is the sole structured mapping of the six live #1461 acceptance boxes. + With the PR still draft, `status:plan` was replaced by `status:ready-merge`, `impl-eval:skip` was + applied to attribute the already-complete external evaluation, and a live dry-run accepted all six + entries against issue-body SHA-256 + `20b6370fdf3ed8491c30a052c75b6a6c33b529b4a278c8a39a6243847f47387e`. +- Ready-for-review then created exact-head CI run `31904125478`. No issue box has yet been mutated and + merge remains prohibited until the mirror, close-gate, required checks, and visibility are green. + +## 2026-08-15T19:39:00Z — #1664 attempt 5 receives the singleton runtime lease + +- Evidence `a8a160285` is clean/pushed and binds product `7fa29ad3e`; fresh features Tier-A passed at + topic `a4224dbb1`. The first and replacement test receipts each contain 4,248 total results: + 4228/1/19 red before quarantine versus 4229/0/19 after it. Check, replacement test, publish dry-run, + and architecture receipts are the four selected PASS/SUFFICIENT gates; the original red remains. +- Coordinator preflight proved local == remote == PR, `aspire ps []`, Docker zero, and no + AppHost/DCP/application/browser/runtime process or relevant listener. The `aspire ps` query briefly + spawned its own managed NuGet helper; a separate post-query audit proved it exited rather than + misclassifying it as a leak. +- Attempt 5 owns the singleton lease. Run suite-owned `scaffold.runtime` exactly once, clean and audit, + then run `fresh-browser` only if scaffold passed and the audit is empty. Any red stops without a + retry or second expensive gate; evaluator/readiness remain prohibited. + +## 2026-08-15T19:40:10Z — #1669 ships and releases the next fixes leaf + +- CI run `31904125478` completed success at exact head `313cc08d5`: acceptance mirror, close-gate, + quality, repo-wide check/test, and core-lane visibility all passed. The mirror checked all six live + #1461 boxes; a final GraphQL query found zero unresolved review threads and GitHub reported CLEAN / + MERGEABLE. +- The coordinator squash-merged PR #1669 as main commit + `0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb` at 19:39:50Z. #1461 closed at 19:39:51Z. PR and issue + status labels were normalized from ready/triage to exactly `status:shipped`. +- The non-blocking evaluator advisories are ruled as follow-up debt, not hidden: three other docs + loaders make no false revalidation claim and remain compatible with layer-owned background policy; + the warm-stale persistence-failure return shape deserves an explicit future contract. Fixes may + file one Backlog/Triage issue from reviewed topic draft `70307f47c`. +- #1350 is released serially on fresh main. #1348 must remain open until every implementation child + named in its final coordinator checkbox is merged; its normative RFC Stage-0 prerequisite is already + satisfied and therefore does not block its explicitly first implementation child #1350. + +## 2026-08-15T19:44:30Z — #1666 generation released and #1350 attaches + +- #1666 same-author SA-3 amendment `f98cfabac` is explicitly pushed with comment `5303922392`. + Fresh internals Tier-A passed after independently verifying the exact four-output chain, 17-path + ceiling, real CLI/MCP publication delta, second-pass idempotence contract, and full coherent recut. + `gen:mcp-export-corpus` remains excluded: isolated base and leaf runs produce byte-identical output + while its check is already red at base. Canonical generation is active on the preserved author; + second Tier-A and a fresh delta evaluator still gate readiness. +- The reviewed advisory draft became Backlog/Triage issue #1670 with its non-blocking framing intact. + This preserves the cross-page consistency and warm-stale persistence-failure contracts without + retroactively widening or invalidating #1669. +- Fixes created `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-leaf-typed-error` on exact main `0ef48c2ec`, branch + `fix/sdk-typed-error-channel`, and attached Codex Sol/medium thread + `01a006f3-ae2d-7941-bd17-2ac71dd3d0f0`. #1350 is plan-only and must open a draft PR then stop for + PLAN-EVAL; #1348 remains open and untouched. + +## 2026-08-15T19:47:30Z — #1664 attempt 5 exposes the browser-launch failure + +- `scaffold.runtime` again completed 69 gates and stopped on one red, but F6 changed the quality of + the evidence: teardown no longer throws. `behavior.service-client-refetch` itself timed out while + waiting for the Chrome DevTools target. Raw log + `.llm/runs/feat-app-service-client-wiring--1355/reports/s5-attempt5-scaffold-runtime-20260815-2139.log` + hashes to `ff349b40f7f70341934e170df7c67d147c0ed983173b41871421755ad55e062b`. +- Suite `cleanup.aspire-stop` passed and `fresh-browser` remained `NOT_RUN`. Post-run Aspire was `[]`, + Docker was empty, and no AppHost/DCP/browser/runtime process or relevant listener remained. Three + stopped `aspire-managed` NuGet children were proven run-owned by exact attempt-tree cwd and `/init` + parent, terminated by exact PID with TERM/CONT, and independently re-audited absent. Foreign Aspire + MCP helpers were untouched; the singleton lease is released. +- No retry or product edit is authorized. Preserve the attempt-5 red, measure Chrome launch/target + causality on the same original Sol/high author, commit a plan-only amendment before mutation, then + require fresh features Tier-A before a later lease decision. No evaluator yet. + +## 2026-08-15T19:57:21Z — terminal evaluator metadata reconciled + +- Live #1669 evidence already proved evaluator cycle 1 completed `PASS` at artifact-only + `313cc08d572ea7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb`, comment `5303850473`, before the exact-head close gate + and merge. The leaf record and GitHub lifecycle were terminal, but the parallel evaluator-lease + record still said `active`. +- Remote `main` is exactly `0ef48c2ec661a7e6d55ec2faf5def6ae7dd2e6eb`; the cluster's + `currentMainSha` still named its pre-#1669 predecessor. Both stale fields are now reconciled from + independent live evidence. The observed PID is a Claude background spare and was not stopped. +- No supervisor, leaf worktree, PR/issue state, acceptance box, evaluator artifact, or runtime lease + changed. This is an atomic control-plane truth repair only. + +## 2026-08-15T20:17:10Z — three topic-local queues cross reviewed boundaries + +- #1664's original author replaced the unreviewed false capability-gap F7 plan with pushed F7-C1 + `a2e9515f5`, comment `5304036438`. Managed Linux Chromium 151 is executable; the defect is the + probe's unverified allowlist/selection plus discarded startup status/stderr. Features Tier-A + passed at `8ec20d606` and released exactly the existing probe/test paths to the same Sol/high + author. No runtime lease, attempt 6, Aspire, Docker, browser, or evaluator is authorized yet. +- #1666's one unchanged-head root-test retry passed at content `46528ae4c` with 4203 passed, 0 failed, + 19 ignored in 244980ms. Recovery head `b67414f4f` and comment `5304045867` retain the earlier + 4202/1/19 red, attribute it to the internals supervisor's ignored hook transcript, and prove its + recoverable quarantine byte-identical at SHA-256 `d0251bc2…ab2`. Fresh second Tier-A is active; + delta IMPL-EVAL still follows and readiness remains revoked. +- #1671 amendment `2fa2f71dc` is run-artifact-only, clean, pushed, and commented at `5304017800`. + It locks the six paths, denies the metadata barrel/vocabulary, preserves the empty fourth generic, + and retains the breaking disclosure. Fixes Tier-A passed at `6c9486004`; one separate Fable + 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL is active as job `50898ac7`, PID 636411, session + `session_015RuDy1h3UiCkLzo1PLk5Sc`. Product implementation remains prohibited before PASS. + +## 2026-08-15T20:23:15Z — #1671 passes PLAN-EVAL; #1666 enters delta evaluation + +- #1671's sole Fable 5/medium Remote Control PLAN-EVAL returned `PASS` over `2fa2f71dc`; commit + `f76a3c45b` adds only `plan-eval.md`, is explicitly pushed, and comment `5304059808` is live. + Fixes released S1 only—`contract-primitives.ts`, `readme-doctest_test.ts`, and existing run + artifacts—to the same original author. Both TS18046/TS2339 REDs, contracts-exported schemas, + retained `SafeFailure` default, empty metadata slot, and the seventh-path refusal are binding. +- #1666 second Tier-A passed at internals topic `8933f58f2`. It independently accepted the generated + cascade, coherent evidence, recovery receipt, quarantine, path/lock/publication/baseline-red and + NOT_RUN boundaries while naming idempotence as carried rather than re-executed. One fresh delta + IMPL-EVAL is therefore active as `f281b8cf`, PID 793975, Remote Control + `session_01UDGunAVYYPRC6KBNxEwZWA`, over content `46528ae4c` and evidence `b67414f4f` with + idempotence explicitly required. Readiness remains revoked and runtime remains untouched. + + +## 2026-08-15T20:38:42Z — delta evaluation passes; three bounded recoveries advance + +- #1666 delta IMPL-EVAL is terminal `PASS` at artifact-only `0d4c82d6e`, comment `5304103041`. + The evaluator independently proved the exact four-output cascade, two-run idempotence, root + 4202/1/19 red plus 4203/0/19 replacement, honest recoverable quarantine, 14-of-17 scope, unchanged + lock, bounded MCP selection, known reds, and all five #1296 rows. A live merge-tree against main + `0ef48c2ec` exposes conflicts only in those four generated assets because #1665 advanced the same + cascade. Internals checkpoint `268544516` dispatches the original author to integrate main and + regenerate deterministically before fresh Tier-A and another delta evaluation; readiness stays + revoked. +- #1671 S1 is clean, pushed, and commented at `dc034d680` / `5304110615`. Its sole baseline check + captured TS18046 plus TS2339 once; final exact six-code/empty-meta assertions and focused gates are + green. Fresh fixes Tier-A passed at `7281cebac` after independently running a 105-file check, + doctest 2/0, and Contracts plus SDK 77/0. S2 alone is released to the same author over `errors.ts`, + `service-client.ts`, and the doctest; S3/docs and metadata remain held. +- #1664 F7 product is `e45144db6`; focused behavior is 22/0 and binding check is green. The root test + stopped honestly at 4236/1/19 because the unchanged repository scanner could not read the retained + attempt-5 Postgres tree. Red evidence `885f352e7` is preserved. Features moved only that run-owned + tree recoverably to `/tmp/netscript-f7-quarantine.iXF6fb`, verified leak-check clean, and recorded + `d81b99143`. The original author may run one exact-content `test-attempt2`, then publish and + architecture gates only on PASS, before another Tier-A. Runtime remains unleased. + + +## 2026-08-15T20:56:25Z — #1664 attempt 6 leased; #1671 S3 released + +- #1664 F7 recovery evidence `ed3f78e0d` and comment `5304173729` retain the exact-head check, + superseding test-attempt2 at 4237/0/19, publish dry-run, and architecture PASS receipts; the original + 4236/1/19 red remains. Fresh features Tier-A passed at `4a65a2670`. Aspire was empty, Docker zero, + runtime/browser processes and ports absent, and no unreadable residue remained. Three older readable + plugin-smoke trees were moved—not deleted—to `/tmp/netscript-preattempt6-quarantine.9mNpwE`. + Features checkpoint `ac1ec35cf` owns the singleton attempt-6 lease over content `e45144db6` and + evidence `ed3f78e0d`, using managed Chrome 151.0.7922.34. One scaffold run, mandatory audit, and + conditional one fresh-browser run are authorized; no retry or evaluator. +- #1671 S2 is clean/pushed/commented at `ca7ade409` / `5304171376`. Both suppressions became positive + exact-union/data assertions; public oRPC error types flow through `ServiceClientMethod` and `safe`, + and `SafeFailure` remains. Fresh fixes Tier-A passed at `ac0b2c4c3` after + 105-file check, doctest 3/0, Contracts plus SDK 78/0, lint, and format. S3 alone is released over + `sdk.md` and `how-to/discover-services.md`; no product, metadata, final-gate, or runtime scope. + +## 2026-08-15T21:03:30Z — #1666 integration refresh passes Tier-A and enters delta evaluation + +- #1666 integrated current main without rewriting evaluated history. Merge content `8c03d8629` + retains prior evaluator `0d4c82d6e` and main `0ef48c2ec` as its two parents; artifact evidence + `021c7ffc6` is clean, explicitly pushed, and commented at `5304205247`. +- The integration proves the exact four generated conflict outputs contain both #1665 and #1666, + two canonical cascade cycles converge without a fifth output, all twelve selected receipts bind + `8c03d8629` and pass, the implementation set remains 14-of-17, and `deno.lock` is unchanged. + Fresh internals Tier-A passed at topic `6658ad9c0`. +- One fresh native Fable 5/medium Remote Control integration-delta evaluator is active as job + `be3774eb`, session `cse_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV`, over `8c03d8629` / `021c7ffc6`. The older + `f281b8cf` lease was stale in the control plane and is now reconciled to its already-proven PASS at + `0d4c82d6e`; lane-local serialization therefore remains one active evaluator, not two. + +## 2026-08-15T21:18:24Z — #1666 delta passes, then changed-source CI revokes readiness + +- The fresh integration-delta evaluator returned terminal `PASS` at artifact-only head `05ac90d00`, + comment `5304256350`, and Remote Control session + `https://claude.ai/code/session_01RQ7Eb4N4NaQEuAA6zPtpxV`. It independently re-derived the + history-preserving four-output union, two-run convergence, twelve exact-content receipts, + 14-of-17 scope, lock identity, known reds, all five #1296 acceptance rows, and NOT_RUN boundaries. + Evaluator job `be3774eb` is terminal and its lease is released. +- Coordinator rewrote the PR body to the final heads, applied `status:ready-merge` and the existing + attributed `impl-eval:skip` while draft, verified the live acceptance mirror dry-run, then marked + #1666 ready. Core CI run `31908897973` passed close-gate and checked all five #1296 boxes; the issue + remains open pending merge. Broad `quality` also passed. +- Dedicated changed-source run `31908898023` found two real leaf-owned findings in + `check-exports-drift.ts`: an explicit `any` at line 356 and an unsafe cast at line 372. This is not + retryable infrastructure. The coordinator immediately returned #1666 to draft, restored sole + `status:impl`, removed `status:ready-merge`, and did not merge. The same original Sol/medium author + is assigned one focused type-safe repair; fresh internals Tier-A and a fresh delta evaluator must + precede any later readiness restoration. + +## 2026-08-15T21:31:49Z — #1664 attempt 6 reaches an honest browser-probe timeout + +- The one authorized `scaffold.runtime` run selected the strict managed-browser override exactly: + Chrome for Testing `151.0.7922.34` from `NETSCRIPT_E2E_BROWSER_EXECUTABLE`. It passed 69 gates and + failed only `behavior.service-client-refetch`; the child emitted no evidence and exited 143 at the + suite-owned 900,030 ms boundary. Raw exit is 1, retry count is zero, and `fresh-browser` is + `NOT_RUN` because its prerequisite failed. +- Evidence head `2385cdb72` is clean, explicitly pushed, and commented at `5304325367`. Raw log hash + is `1bf8cb03…aaa0`; structured NDJSON hash is `ffab7e7f…e356`; the browser-selection JSON is + separate. The red is not relabelled as a proven application-refetch failure: valid browser + selection is proven, but the deeper hang remains for fresh Tier-A attribution. +- Suite cleanup passed. The independent audit found three stopped run-owned Aspire NuGet helpers + and one unreadable Postgres directory; exact helper cleanup succeeded, and the generated project + moved recoverably—not deleted—to `/tmp/netscript-s5-a6-quarantine-20260815-4M9v8k`. Final Aspire, + Docker, process, port, and unreadable-residue audits are empty. The singleton runtime lease is + released; no evaluator or later runtime attempt is authorized. + +## 2026-08-15T21:36:48Z — #1666 quality repair passes Tier-A and enters cycle 5 + +- The same original author pushed focused repair `e357938df`, comment `5304327917`. The untrusted + exports boundary is now `unknown`, all enumeration is narrowed, the unsafe cast is gone, and + discriminating tests cover string/default/missing/falsy/null/malformed shapes. No allowance, + suppression, scanner change, generated-output delta, or lock change occurred. +- Fresh internals Tier-A passed at `138ad7436`. It first rejected its own false green after noticing + the scanner was in repository mode and had not selected `.llm/tools`; the corrected exact + `changed-files` invocation selected both edited paths, found zero issues, and exited 0. Focused + tests, full drift/check/test, cascade/lock identity, and append-only evaluator history all hold. +- One fresh separate native Fable 5/medium Remote Control delta evaluator is active as job + `dc433b8d`, bridge `cse_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC`, URL + `https://claude.ai/code/session_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC`. State proves + `bridgeOutboundOnly:false` and exact remote-control/model/effort flags. Readiness remains held. + +## 2026-08-15T21:42:53Z — #1671 S4 stops on new private-type doc-lint reds + +- S3 docs head `c7cba6d9b` passed fresh fixes Tier-A at `580bd8ec0`; both pages contain all six + literals, explicit success/defined branching, terminal non-defined handling, and schema-derived + code-specific data. S4 then ran from that immutable content head. +- S4 evidence `db8aadd95`, comment `5304357008`, preserves green uncached root check/test, scoped + lint/fmt, quality, architecture, docs, and publish gates. Raw surface-diff stays red but attributes + exactly the authorized +15 signature delta; the normalized 972-entry remainder is byte-identical. +- Raw doc-lint is a real new leaf red: Contracts 9→11 and SDK 3→13 private-type references. + Remaining JSR/specifier/export gates are honestly `NOT_RUN`. No product was changed during S4. + Coordinator authorizes a plan-only repair amendment on the same author, limited to the three + already-owned product paths; fresh fixes Tier-A precedes any repair mutation. + +## 2026-08-15T21:54:00Z — #1666 reaches exact-head CI; quota-blocked plan chores reroute canonically + +- #1666 cycle-5 IMPL-EVAL is terminal `PASS`. The fresh Fable 5/medium Remote Control evaluator + independently selected all nine changed source paths with zero quality findings, passed 12 focused + tests and six targeted mutation kills, proved malformed top-level values fail closed, reran root + check at 2,925 files and root test at 4,217/0/19, and preserved the four generated outputs plus + `deno.lock` byte-identically. Evaluator commit `92988da30`, comment `5304391856`, Remote Control + `session_016v2se871QD9Q9Rd6YADAKC`; its lease is terminal and released. +- The coordinator rewrote #1666's PR body to the final repair/evaluator heads, verified zero review + threads, ran a live acceptance-mirror dry-run and local close-gate PASS at `92988da30`, applied + `status:ready-merge` while draft with attributed `impl-eval:skip` retained, posted readiness comment + `5304405717`, and marked the PR ready. Exact-head CI runs `31910676720` and `31910676700` are active; + merge is prohibited until every current-head context, especially changed-source code quality, is + terminal green or an intentional policy skip. +- Fresh detached Sol probes prove the OpenAI implementation quota is account-wide, not thread-local: + #1664 thread `01a00766-…` and #1671 thread `01a00767-…` both returned + `usageLimitExceeded`, `hasCredits:false`, `balance:0`, reset `2026-08-20 05:31`. No further Codex + retry is authorized before reset. +- This does not park plan-artifact maintenance. #1664's two-line F8 provenance restoration is routed + to a fresh separate canonical `chore_code` Claude Opus 5/medium agent, followed by a fresh Minimax + M3/high PLAN-EVAL through the native-quota fallback. #1671's run-artifact-only S4-R amendment is + routed to a fresh canonical `documentation_review` Claude Sonnet 5/high agent, followed by the same + fresh Minimax PLAN-EVAL fallback. Both supervisors remain non-authors and neither lane may + self-certify. #1671's later three-product-file repair remains parked on canonical Codex until reset; + no outside-plan product implementation is authorized.