From 25c29575cbb306ef4d81077ab6652d66a9a21bd3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 12:20:38 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 1/7] chore(harness): bootstrap package gate honesty run --- .../package-gate-honesty/codex-thread-ids.md | 16 +++ .../package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md | 65 ++++++++++++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md | 16 +++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md | 98 +++++++++++++++++++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md | 22 +++++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/supervisor.md | 31 ++++++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md | 93 ++++++++++++++++++ 7 files changed, 341 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/codex-thread-ids.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/supervisor.md create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/codex-thread-ids.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/codex-thread-ids.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..b43adc4280 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/codex-thread-ids.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +# package-gate — Codex implementation thread +- **Thread / session id:** `01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5` +- **Rollout:** `/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/15/rollout-2026-08-15T12-16-45-01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5.jsonl` +- **Worktree:** `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-package-gate` +- **Branch:** `fix/package-gate-honesty` @ `05fc3132b` (NO upstream by design). +- **Push rule:** explicit refspec only — `git push origin HEAD:refs/heads/fix/package-gate-honesty`. +- **Requested route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=medium +- **Observed route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=medium +- **Route verdict:** matched +- **Runtime:** approval=never · sandbox=dangerFullAccess +- **Brief (staged):** `/home/codex/package-gate-brief.md` +## Steering (same thread — never a second send-message-v2 at this worktree) +```bash +codex exec resume 01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5 -- "" +``` +_Written by `.llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts`._ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..be17922472 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +# Context Pack: package-gate-honesty + +## Run Metadata + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | +| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | +| Current phase | `research` | +| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` | +| Scope overlays | `docs` | + +## Current State + +Harness bootstrap is active at immutable base `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b`. +Research and the bounded plan remain to be completed; implementation is unauthorized. + +## Completed + +- Requested skills and mandatory harness/doctrine references loaded. +- Worktree identity verified; coordinator thread record preserved. + +## In Progress + +- Bootstrap commit and draft PR opening. + +## Next Steps + +1. Open the draft PR from the bootstrap commit. +2. Read all three issues live and research source evidence. +3. Complete research, plan, Design checkpoint, push, comment, and stop for PLAN-EVAL. + +## Key Decisions + +| Decision | Source | Notes | +| -------- | ------ | ----- | +| PLAN-EVAL required | Harness run-loop | Separate session; this thread will not self-launch it. | + +## Files Changed + +| Path | Status | Notes | +| ---- | ------ | ----- | +| `/*` | new | Harness bootstrap artifacts only. | + +## Gates + +| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | +| ----------- | -------------- | -------- | +| Static | NOT_RUN | Planning phase. | +| Fitness | NOT_RUN | Planning phase. | +| Runtime | NOT_RUN | Coordinator mutex not granted. | +| Consumer | NOT_RUN | Planning phase. | + +## Open Questions + +- Exact narrowed edit paths and per-package JSR audit denominator. + +## Drift and Debt + +- Drift: launcher-generated thread record was present before the clean-worktree check; preserved. +- Debt: none identified yet. + +## Commits + +- See the draft PR's commit list + per-slice PR comments (V3 retired `commits.md`). diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..e863efa664 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +# Drift Log: package-gate-honesty + +Drift is append-only. Record facts that diverge from the plan, RFC, doctrine, or current-state +documentation. + +## 2026-08-15 — Coordinator thread record preseeded the run directory + +- **What:** The first ground-truth status check found only + `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/codex-thread-ids.md` + as untracked content. +- **Source:** `git status --short` and the launcher-generated file contents. +- **Expected:** A completely clean worktree before bootstrap. +- **Actual:** The agentic launcher had staged this exact session's identity in the target run dir. +- **Severity:** minor +- **Action:** accept +- **Evidence:** `codex-thread-ids.md` identifies this thread, worktree, branch, base, and matched route. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..86ff88a7c9 --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md @@ -0,0 +1,98 @@ +# Plan: package-gate-honesty + +## Run Metadata + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | +| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | +| Phase | `plan` | +| Target | CLI/package gate honesty for #1604, #1618, and #1622 | +| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` | +| Scope overlays | `docs` | + +## Archetype + +Pending research-backed plan. + +## Current Doctrine Verdict + +Pending focused lookup against the current verdict table. + +## Axioms in Play + +| Axiom | Why it matters | +| --- | --- | +| A14 | Gates must fail closed and preserve the behavior they claim to verify. | + +## Goal + +Produce a bounded, evaluator-ready plan only. No implementation is authorized in this phase. + +## Scope + +- Pending exact narrowed edit surface. + +## Non-Scope + +- Implementation, runtime execution, publication, merge, and issue mutation. + +## Hidden Scope + +- JSR audit planning for every touched publishable workspace member. + +## Locked Decisions + +| ID | Decision | Rationale | +| --- | -------- | --------- | +| L0 | No implementation before a separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. | The work spans multiple packages, docs, JSR checks, and a serialized runtime gate. | + +## Open-Decision Sweep + +| Decision | Status | Notes | +| -------- | ------ | ----- | +| Exact edit surface | must resolve now | Research must narrow the frozen outer bound before PLAN-EVAL. | + +## Risk Register + +| Risk | Mitigation | +| ---- | ---------- | +| False-green gate repair | Require regression tests that prove each gate fails when its protected condition regresses. | + +## Anti-Patterns to Resolve or Avoid + +| AP | Status | Plan | +| -- | ------ | ---- | +| AP-18 | risk | Prefer semantic assertions over broad snapshots. | + +## Fitness Gates + +| Gate | Required | Expected evidence | +| ---- | -------- | ----------------- | +| F-6 | yes | Per-touched-package JSR audit and isolated-declaration publish dry-run. | +| F-10 | yes | Targeted regression tests for the three dishonest gates. | +| F-19 | yes | Structured scoped wrapper evidence. | + +## Arch-Debt Implications + +| Entry | Action | Notes | +| ----- | ------ | ----- | +| Pending | none expected | Reassess after research. | + +## Validation Plan + +| Order | Gate | Command or check | Expected result | +| ----- | ---- | ---------------- | --------------- | +| 1 | Plan gate | Separate-session PLAN-EVAL | `PASS` before implementation. | + +## Risks + +- Pending research-backed register. + +## Dependencies + +- Coordinator-held mutex for the future `scaffold.runtime` gate. + +## Drift Watch + +- Any exact required edit outside the frozen outer bound is a rescope and stop condition. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..28a943f4be --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +# Research — package-gate-honesty + +## Re-baseline + +- Carried-in source: issues #1604, #1618, and #1622 plus the coordinator's frozen contract. +- Re-derived against `main` @ `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b` on 2026-08-15. +- What changed vs the carried-in version: pending live issue and source research. + +## Findings + +| # | Finding | How to verify | +| - | ------- | ------------- | +| 1 | Pending research. | Pending `file:line` evidence. | + +## jsr-audit surface scan (package/plugin waves) + +- Surface scanned: pending exact touched publishable-member selection. +- Slow-type / surface risks: pending. + +## Open questions + +- Which exact paths are necessary inside the unusually broad frozen outer bound? diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/supervisor.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/supervisor.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..4b62205c3b --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/supervisor.md @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +# Supervisor Identity — package-gate-honesty + +Written at run start per `workflow/lane-policy.md` § Supervisor identity. A run dir without this +file is not activated. Other supervisors cross-peek a run by reading this file — it is how this +run's operating identity is discoverable without chat memory. + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Model | OpenAI GPT-5.6 Sol | +| Session | `01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5` | +| Host | Linux / WSL, Codex | +| Checkout | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-package-gate` | +| Worktree | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-package-gate` | +| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | +| Baseline | `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b` (`main`, 2026-08-15) | +| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | + +## Routes in force + +| Task lane | Provider / model / effort | Role in this run | +| --- | --- | --- | +| `normal_implementation` | OpenAI / GPT-5.6 Sol / medium | Bootstrap, research, and plan generator; implementation explicitly unauthorized this turn | +| `formal_plan_evaluation` | Anthropic / Fable 5 / medium | Required separate-session PLAN-EVAL, launched only by the topic supervisor | +| `formal_impl_evaluation` | Anthropic / Fable 5 / medium | Required separate-session IMPL-EVAL after future implementation | + +Reference `.llm/harness/workflow/lane-policy.md`; the complete route table is not duplicated here. + +## Recorded lane/eval overrides + +None. The coordinator explicitly prohibited this implementation thread from launching PLAN-EVAL; +the selected evaluator route is recorded for supervisor handoff only. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8350e5845a --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md @@ -0,0 +1,93 @@ +# Worklog: package-gate-honesty + +## Run Metadata + +| Field | Value | +| --- | --- | +| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | +| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | +| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` | +| Scope overlays | `docs` | + +## Design + +Design checkpoint pending research. No implementation files may be created before this section is +completed and PLAN-EVAL returns `PASS` in a separate session. + +### Public Surface + +- Pending. + +### Domain Vocabulary + +- Gate honesty — a gate must execute the intended selection and fail on protected regressions. + +### Ports + +- None anticipated; confirm during research. + +### Constants + +- Pending `closeScoreGap` research. + +### Commit Slices + +| # | Slice | Gate | Files | +| - | ----- | ---- | ----- | +| 1 | Pending research-backed plan. | Pending. | Pending. | + +### Deferred Scope + +- Implementation — explicitly unauthorized until PLAN-EVAL disposition. + +### Contributor Path + +Pending research-backed design. + +## Progress Log + +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| ---- | ----- | ---- | ----- | +| 2026-08-15 | bootstrap | activated | Coordinator-generated thread identity preserved; mandatory artifacts created. | + +## Decisions + +| Decision | Reason | Source | +| -------- | ------ | ------ | +| Formal PLAN-EVAL required | Cross-package, docs-overlay, JSR-applicable work with a serialized expensive gate is decision-heavy. | `workflow/run-loop.md` §4 | + +## Drift + +| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | +| ----- | -------- | ------------------ | +| Worktree initially contained the launcher-generated untracked `codex-thread-ids.md`. | minor | yes | + +## Gate Results + +### Static Gates + +| Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | +| ---- | ---------------- | ------ | ----- | +| bootstrap identity | `pwd`; `git rev-parse HEAD`; `git status --short` | PASS with noted preseed | Correct worktree/branch/base; only coordinator thread record was untracked. | + +### Fitness Gates + +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ---- | ------ | -------- | ----- | +| Plan-Gate | NOT_RUN | No evaluator verdict exists. | Topic supervisor must launch the separate evaluator. | + +### Runtime Gates + +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ---- | ------ | -------- | ----- | +| `scaffold.runtime` | NOT_RUN | Coordinator mutex not granted. | Planning only; prohibited from Aspire/Docker/E2E runtime execution. | + +### Consumer Gates + +| Consumer | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| -------- | ------ | -------- | ----- | +| Pending | NOT_RUN | Planning phase. | No implementation authority. | + +## Handoff Notes + +- Inspect the exact narrowed edit surface, per-slice false-green defenses, and JSR plan first. From 72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 12:31:15 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 2/7] docs(harness): plan honest package gates --- .../package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md | 99 +++--- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md | 16 +- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md | 282 ++++++++++++------ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md | 83 +++++- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md | 144 +++++---- 5 files changed, 431 insertions(+), 193 deletions(-) diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md index be17922472..14a9ecc225 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md @@ -2,64 +2,83 @@ ## Run Metadata -| Field | Value | -| --- | --- | -| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | -| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | -| Current phase | `research` | -| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` | -| Scope overlays | `docs` | - -## Current State - -Harness bootstrap is active at immutable base `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b`. -Research and the bounded plan remain to be completed; implementation is unauthorized. +| Field | Value | +| -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | +| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | +| Current phase | `plan-eval` handoff; hard stop | +| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` (supporting MCP member A2) | +| Scope overlays | `docs` | + +## Current state + +Bootstrap, live issue research, source research, JSR surface scan, bounded plan, and Design +checkpoint are complete. Draft PR #1663 targets immutable `main` base +`05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b`. The plan owns exactly six product/config files and +requires formal PLAN-EVAL. No implementation is authorized, and the expensive gate has not been +requested or run. ## Completed -- Requested skills and mandatory harness/doctrine references loaded. -- Worktree identity verified; coordinator thread record preserved. +- Bootstrap commit `25c29575c` pushed with explicit refspec. +- Draft PR #1663 opened with exact closing keywords, checkable DoD, `type:fix`, `area:tooling`, + `status:research`, milestone `0.0.7`; no acceptance-evidence blocks. +- All three issues re-read live. +- Three cwd failures and MCP fmt config crash reproduced through structured wrappers. +- `closeScoreGap` definition, consumption, and decorative test behavior traced. +- Six-file plan and per-member JSR audit plan locked. + +## In progress -## In Progress +- Awaiting topic-supervisor PLAN-EVAL after the research + plan handoff commit/comment. -- Bootstrap commit and draft PR opening. +## Next steps -## Next Steps +1. Topic supervisor launches a fresh native opposite-family Fable 5 medium PLAN-EVAL. +2. If and only if verdict is `PASS`, coordinator grants implementation authority. +3. Future implementation follows S1-S4; S4 requests the serialized `scaffold.runtime` mutex. -1. Open the draft PR from the bootstrap commit. -2. Read all three issues live and research source evidence. -3. Complete research, plan, Design checkpoint, push, comment, and stop for PLAN-EVAL. +## Key decisions -## Key Decisions +| Decision | Source | Notes | +| ------------------------------------ | -------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Root config excludes invalid fixture | plan L3/L4 | Exact standalone formatter command must work; fixture remains malformed/tested. | +| Module-derived CLI paths | plan L1/L2 | No ambient cwd and no weakened assertion. | +| `0.5` pinned both directions | plan L5/L6 | Inside/outside identity conflict makes movement observable. | +| Formal PLAN-EVAL required | plan judgement | This thread cannot self-launch or self-certify. | -| Decision | Source | Notes | -| -------- | ------ | ----- | -| PLAN-EVAL required | Harness run-loop | Separate session; this thread will not self-launch it. | +## Authoritative product/config edit surface -## Files Changed +1. `deno.json` +2. `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts` +3. `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts` +4. `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts` +5. `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts` +6. `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` -| Path | Status | Notes | -| ---- | ------ | ----- | -| `/*` | new | Harness bootstrap artifacts only. | +Everything else in the frozen outer bound is read-only, especially both docs sources and the broken +fixture. A seventh path is rescope. ## Gates -| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | -| ----------- | -------------- | -------- | -| Static | NOT_RUN | Planning phase. | -| Fitness | NOT_RUN | Planning phase. | -| Runtime | NOT_RUN | Coordinator mutex not granted. | -| Consumer | NOT_RUN | Planning phase. | +| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | +| ----------- | ---------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | +| Plan-Gate | REQUIRED / NOT_RUN | `plan.md`; evaluator absent by design. | +| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | +| Fitness/JSR | planned | `research.md` and `plan.md` per-member tables. | +| Runtime | NOT_RUN | Coordinator mutex not granted. | +| Consumer | baseline failures reproduced | `worklog.md` research diagnostics. | -## Open Questions +## Open questions -- Exact narrowed edit paths and per-package JSR audit denominator. +- None that change implementation. Only external authorization/mutex state remains. -## Drift and Debt +## Drift and debt -- Drift: launcher-generated thread record was present before the clean-worktree check; preserved. -- Debt: none identified yet. +- Drift: coordinator thread file preseed; root task wrapper exclusion does not fix standalone + command. +- Debt: no new/closed entry; named CLI/MCP baseline debt remains unchanged. ## Commits -- See the draft PR's commit list + per-slice PR comments (V3 retired `commits.md`). +- Draft PR commit list + phase comments are authoritative; no `commits.md`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md index e863efa664..fcf80b2971 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md @@ -13,4 +13,18 @@ documentation. - **Actual:** The agentic launcher had staged this exact session's identity in the target run dir. - **Severity:** minor - **Action:** accept -- **Evidence:** `codex-thread-ids.md` identifies this thread, worktree, branch, base, and matched route. +- **Evidence:** `codex-thread-ids.md` identifies this thread, worktree, branch, base, and matched + route. + +## 2026-08-15 — Root task exclusion does not satisfy standalone formatter acceptance + +- **What:** Root `fmt:check` already supplies a wrapper-level exclusion for the MCP doctor fixture, + but the exact standalone scoped command in #1618 still selects fixture TS and aborts during nested + config discovery. +- **Source:** `deno.json:139-148`; exact wrapper reproduction in `worklog.md`. +- **Expected:** The issue report could have implied no exclusion existed anywhere. +- **Actual:** Task-level selection is protected, but the reusable standalone wrapper remains red. +- **Severity:** minor +- **Action:** fix +- **Evidence:** Baseline 115 selected / one config crash; explicit wrapper exclusion 110 selected / + exit 0. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md index 86ff88a7c9..baeeb37681 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md @@ -2,97 +2,197 @@ ## Run Metadata -| Field | Value | -| --- | --- | -| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | -| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | -| Phase | `plan` | -| Target | CLI/package gate honesty for #1604, #1618, and #1622 | -| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` | -| Scope overlays | `docs` | - -## Archetype - -Pending research-backed plan. - -## Current Doctrine Verdict - -Pending focused lookup against the current verdict table. - -## Axioms in Play - -| Axiom | Why it matters | -| --- | --- | -| A14 | Gates must fail closed and preserve the behavior they claim to verify. | +| Field | Value | +| -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | +| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | +| Phase | `plan` — hard stop pending formal PLAN-EVAL | +| Target | Gate honesty for #1604, #1618, and #1622 | +| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` (frozen leaf profile) | +| Scope overlays | `docs` | + +## Archetype and doctrine verdict + +The frozen leaf profile is Archetype 6 because the owning behavior is package/CLI verification and +the strongest consumer proof is the CLI scaffold harness. The supporting `@netscript/mcp` member is +currently classified Archetype 2; this plan preserves that package's token-bounded integration +boundary and does not reshape it. + +- `packages/cli`: **Keep** — preserve the Archetype-6 kernel/surface split + (`doctrine/10-codebase-verdict-and-handoff.md:33`). +- `packages/mcp`: **Keep** — keep MCP transports behind token-bounded tool contracts (`:42`). +- Relevant open accepted debt is baseline only: CLI public doc completeness; MCP horizontal-shape + classification; MCP tool-contract file size; CLI E2E scaffold directory cardinality. None is + closed or deepened by these six edits. + +## Axioms in play + +| Axiom | Why it matters | +| ----- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| A1 | Published/exported boundaries remain unchanged; tests and comments describe the actual contract before implementation. | +| A7 | Use Deno's supported exclusion and `import.meta`/URL path primitives instead of bespoke cwd discovery. | +| A8 | Changes stay in the existing role-named files; no helper or new folder is introduced. | +| A9 | Preserve CLI A6 and MCP A2 package shapes; the leaf profile does not authorize reshaping either. | +| A14 | Each repaired guard must have a negative control that proves it can fire; a non-fired command is not green. | ## Goal -Produce a bounded, evaluator-ready plan only. No implementation is authorized in this phase. - -## Scope - -- Pending exact narrowed edit surface. - -## Non-Scope - -- Implementation, runtime execution, publication, merge, and issue mutation. - -## Hidden Scope - -- JSR audit planning for every touched publishable workspace member. - -## Locked Decisions - -| ID | Decision | Rationale | -| --- | -------- | --------- | -| L0 | No implementation before a separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. | The work spans multiple packages, docs, JSR checks, and a serialized runtime gate. | - -## Open-Decision Sweep - -| Decision | Status | Notes | -| -------- | ------ | ----- | -| Exact edit surface | must resolve now | Research must narrow the frozen outer bound before PLAN-EVAL. | - -## Risk Register - -| Risk | Mitigation | -| ---- | ---------- | -| False-green gate repair | Require regression tests that prove each gate fails when its protected condition regresses. | - -## Anti-Patterns to Resolve or Avoid - -| AP | Status | Plan | -| -- | ------ | ---- | -| AP-18 | risk | Prefer semantic assertions over broad snapshots. | - -## Fitness Gates - -| Gate | Required | Expected evidence | -| ---- | -------- | ----------------- | -| F-6 | yes | Per-touched-package JSR audit and isolated-declaration publish dry-run. | -| F-10 | yes | Targeted regression tests for the three dishonest gates. | -| F-19 | yes | Structured scoped wrapper evidence. | - -## Arch-Debt Implications - -| Entry | Action | Notes | -| ----- | ------ | ----- | -| Pending | none expected | Reassess after research. | - -## Validation Plan - -| Order | Gate | Command or check | Expected result | -| ----- | ---- | ---------------- | --------------- | -| 1 | Plan gate | Separate-session PLAN-EVAL | `PASS` before implementation. | - -## Risks - -- Pending research-backed register. - -## Dependencies - -- Coordinator-held mutex for the future `scaffold.runtime` gate. - -## Drift Watch - -- Any exact required edit outside the frozen outer bound is a rescope and stop condition. +Make three misleading package gates truthful: their canonical commands run from their documented +cwd, configuration discovery cannot consume a deliberately invalid fixture, and the tuned ranking +boundary cannot move materially while tests stay green. + +## Exact narrowed edit surface (authoritative) + +These are the only product/config paths implementation may edit. Run artifacts under this slice +directory are updated alongside every future slice but are not product scope. + +| Path | Justification | +| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| `deno.json` | Add the deliberately invalid MCP doctor-fixture directory to the supported root exclusion so Deno tooling never auto-discovers it as real config; leave the fixture itself intact. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts` | Resolve the relative script argument against the already module-derived `REPO_ROOT` before `Deno.stat`; retain the real gate command and existence assertion. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts` | Resolve `docs/site/quickstart.vto` from the test module/repository root while retaining exact command-parity assertions. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts` | Resolve the authoritative streams doc and run-owned scratch directory from a module-derived repository root so the semantic example execution works from package cwd. | +| `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts` | Record the empirical, non-scale-derived rationale adjacent to `closeScoreGap`; do not change the value or public exports. | +| `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Replace the decorative boundary arrangement with observable just-inside and just-outside controls that fail for both widening and narrowing. | + +Adding any seventh product/config path is rescope and requires coordinator approval before editing. + +## Frozen contract entries deliberately not touched + +- `docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md` — authoritative source is read and executed, not + rewritten. +- `docs/site/quickstart.vto` — authoritative commands remain unchanged. +- `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json` — must remain deliberately malformed. +- The broad/duplicate `packages/cli/`, `packages/cli`, and `packages/*` entries — no other CLI file, + package, generated asset, member config, or dependency pin is edited. +- The broad `packages/mcp` entry — no other MCP source, test, README, entrypoint, export, or config + is edited. +- No `.llm/tools/**`, workflow, lock, cache, receipt implementation, Aspire, Docker, or release + file. + +## Hidden scope + +- Both publishable members receive JSR audits even though the public export maps do not change. +- The CLI package's known doc-lint/isolated-declaration debt must be reported honestly rather than + silently converted to pass. +- Docs accuracy and source-format gates still run because two tests consume docs as executable + contracts even though those docs are read-only. +- Negative controls must show raw non-zero exit and distinguish a real finding from a config crash. +- `scaffold.runtime` is required because the changed documented-stream helper is called by the full + scaffold consumer path; it remains coordinator-mutexed. + +## Locked decisions + +| ID | Decision | Rationale | +| -- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| L1 | Anchor repository-owned CLI test paths with `new URL(..., import.meta.url)` / `fromFileUrl`, not `Deno.cwd()`. | Module location is stable under both root and package-cwd invocation; process cwd is explicitly the defect. | +| L2 | Preserve production gate command arguments; resolve only when the test performs filesystem verification. | The runtime gate correctly interprets `GATE_DIR` relative to `context.project.repoRoot`; changing it would expand behavior scope. | +| L3 | Root `exclude` owns the invalid doctor fixture boundary. | Deno documents it as the cross-tool exclusion for directories that must never be treated as real config; it makes the exact standalone wrapper command work without editing the wrapper. | +| L4 | The malformed fixture and its existing failing-doctor assertion remain unchanged. | Validating the fixture would destroy the behavior under test and produce a false green. | +| L5 | Keep `closeScoreGap = 0.5`; add one observable just-inside case at exactly the boundary and one early-sorting just-outside case at `0.5 + epsilon`. | Narrowing breaks the inside reorder; widening breaks the outside score order. Both directions become observable. | +| L6 | Record the empirical rationale next to the policy: observed gap ≈0.3019801982, headroom ≈0.1980198018, regeneration movement ≈0.0748587452. | The value is tuned from observed headroom, not mathematically derived from an arbitrary score scale. | +| L7 | No new public export, dependency, port, helper, asset, or runtime read. | The work is regression hardening, not API or architecture change. | +| L8 | Evidence commands fire through structured wrappers/`run-gate.ts`; empty selection, crash, NOT_RUN, or missing mutex is not PASS. | This leaf exists to eliminate false verdicts. | +| L9 | Do not run `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, or any CLI runtime smoke until the coordinator grants the mutex. | Explicit cluster-wide serialization contract. | + +## Open-decision sweep + +| Decision | Status | Notes | +| ------------------------------------ | ------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Root exclusion versus wrapper change | resolved now | L3; wrapper path is outside the frozen bound and unnecessary. | +| Test path mechanism | resolved now | L1/L2; module-derived roots only. | +| Close-score boundary data | resolved now | L5/L6; both directions observable and rationale exact. | +| Public API/export changes | resolved now | None permitted. | +| Where `scaffold.runtime` runs | safe to defer | Coordinator chooses the mutex holder/execution lane; the exact command and required head are locked. | + +No unresolved decision would cause implementation rework. + +## Ordered implementation slices + +Every slice also updates `worklog.md` and `context-pack.md`, then is committed, pushed, and +commented before the next slice. No implementation begins before separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. + +| # | What it proves | Exact product/config files | Proving gates | +| -- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| S1 | MCP formatting selects and checks real source while Deno ignores the intentionally invalid fixture as configuration. | `deno.json` | Exact scoped fmt wrapper returns exit 0, `failedBatches: 0`, non-empty selection; `doctor-families_test.ts` remains green; sibling-invalid-config survey; temporary real MCP source formatting defect returns raw non-zero with a formatting finding, then exact file restoration is verified. | +| S2 | The canonical package-cwd CLI task no longer has three root-relative `NotFound` failures and no assertion is weakened. | The three exact CLI files listed above | Structured targeted three-file test first (6/6), then exact `deno task --cwd packages/cli test`; scoped check/lint/fmt on the three owned TS files; docs-source-format and docs-accuracy. The final consumer proof for this slice is deferred to S4 under mutex. | +| S3 | `closeScoreGap` is pinned from both sides and its empirical rationale ships with the policy. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Structured targeted guidance test; controlled `0.5 -> 5` and `0.5 -> below-inside-gap` mutations each raw non-zero, followed by exact restoration and green rerun; MCP scoped check/test/lint/fmt; quality gate. | +| S4 | The integrated head meets the frozen proving contract and publish/docs claims are honest. | No new product/config files; run artifacts/evidence only | Commit-bound `check`, `test`, `publish-dry-run`, `quality-job`, docs-source-format, docs-accuracy, per-member JSR suite; then coordinator-granted one-pass `deno task e2e:cli run scaffold.runtime --cleanup --format pretty`. Missing mutex remains NOT_RUN, never waived or inferred. | + +## JSR audit plan per touched publishable member + +| Member | Planned public surface delta | Exact-pin audit | Isolated-declaration / publish audit | Runtime asset / `import.meta` audit | +| ---------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| `@netscript/cli` | None; all edits are under publish-excluded `e2e/`. | Confirm six `@netscript/*` imports remain exact `0.0.6`; run `check:netscript-jsr-specifiers`. | Full export-map doc-lint and package/root publish dry-run; report existing `isolatedDeclarations: false` and doc-completeness debt as baseline, with no new diagnostic. | Verify changed E2E-only module-relative reads do not enter the published file list; reject any published `import.meta`/filesystem asset read. | +| `@netscript/mcp` | None; policy stays internal. One comment in published `src/**`, one excluded test. | Confirm aspire and telemetry subpaths remain exact `0.0.6`; run exact-pin scan. | `audit-jsr-package.ts --root packages/mcp`, full export-map doc-lint, targeted root isolated-declaration check, member/root publish dry-run, and published file-list inspection. | Static scan of the changed published source must show no `import.meta`, `fromFileUrl`, `Deno.read*`, or runtime asset dependency; release preflight remains green. | + +For both, reject new slow types, self-bare imports, upstream re-exports, dependency ranges, runtime +asset reads, or publish-list drift. A dry-run is necessary but not sufficient; S4 keeps the +coordinator-owned consumer runtime gate. + +## Anti-patterns to resolve or avoid + +| AP/F | Status | Plan | +| ------------ | ------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| AP-18 / F-10 | risk | Retain semantic assertions; no snapshots, skips, deletions, or renamed-only boundary claims. | +| AP-25 | avoid | Module-relative filesystem access remains in publish-excluded E2E edge code; no MCP published-source effect is added. | +| F-5/F-6/F-7 | required | Audit full export maps, docs, and publish file lists for both touched members. | +| F-19 | required | All static/test/fmt evidence comes from scoped structured wrappers; empty selection refuses green. | +| F-CLI-* | no structural delta | `quality:gate`/manual review confirm no A6 boundary change; existing accepted debt is not deepened. | + +## Gate plan and durable receipts + +Durable final evidence is invoked through `.llm/tools/gates/run-gate.ts` with unique IDs and the +actual branch head. Receipts are not hand-edited; child JSON reports are attached where the command +already produces them. A receipt proves only its command. Before and after every gate, compare +`deno.lock` and source status with Git ground truth. + +| Order | Frozen gate | Command/check shape | Passing condition | +| ----- | --------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 1 | check | Root/task structured check plus scoped owned-file checks (`--unstable-kv` where targeted). | Fired at current head; non-empty selection; exit 0. | +| 2 | test | Structured targeted tests, MCP package tests, then exact CLI package task. | All execute; no ignore/skip added; exit 0. | +| 3 | quality-job | `deno task ci:quality` plus `deno task quality:gate`. | Both exit 0; no new allowance/cast/lint-ignore. | +| 4 | docs-source-format | Scoped formatter over the two read-only docs source files and changed TS files; never a directory containing receipts. | Non-empty selection, zero findings/crashes. | +| 5 | docs-accuracy | `deno task docs:accuracy`. | Exit 0 with sources unchanged. | +| 6 | publish-dry-run / JSR | Root/member publish dry-runs, full export-map doc-lint, per-member JSR audits, exact-pin and release preflight scans. | No new warning/finding, correct publish lists, isolated-declaration expectations met or named baseline debt unchanged. | +| 7 | `scaffold.runtime` | Exact one-pass command with `--cleanup --format pretty`, only after coordinator mutex grant. | Fired at current head, raw exit 0, suite report complete. | + +## Risk register + +| Risk | Mitigation | +| -------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Root exclusion also hides a real project file from other Deno tools. | Exclude only the named doctor fixture directory; existing doctor test explicitly reads it and must stay green; survey shows no sibling invalid configs. | +| `fmt.exclude` may select files differently than top-level exclusion. | Use the documented top-level config-discovery boundary and prove the issue's exact wrapper command, its non-empty count, and a negative formatting control. | +| Module-root arithmetic is off by one directory. | Derive from each file URL, assert/read known repo files, and run from `packages/cli` cwd first. | +| Fixing only doc reads leaves `.llm/tmp` cwd-sensitive. | Anchor both authoritative doc and run-owned scratch paths in the helper; cleanup remains scoped to the created temp directory. | +| Boundary test still passes under one-sided policy drift. | Separate observable inside/outside ordering plus explicit widen/narrow mutation controls. | +| Floating-point equality makes the inside case ambiguous. | Use exactly representable test values/differences where possible and a deliberately larger outside epsilon; assert order, not raw floating equality. | +| Publish audit expands into known CLI debt. | Record baseline debt and require no new diagnostics; do not edit public CLI files or claim debt closure. | +| Expensive gate is run without ownership or omitted. | S4 cannot pass until the coordinator grants the mutex and the exact command fires. | +| Validation churns locks/caches. | Never reload/delete; inspect exact Git status and lock blob before accepting any receipt. | + +## Arch-debt implications + +- No new entry expected. +- Do not close or modify existing CLI/MCP/E2E debt entries. +- Any newly discovered doctrine or JSR finding that cannot be fixed inside the six-file surface is + `FAIL_DEBT`/rescope, not an implicit waiver. + +## Explicit deferrals / non-scope + +- No implementation in this turn; no evaluator launch by this thread. +- No full CLI/E2E/runtime execution without the coordinator mutex. +- No docs prose change, fixture repair, wrapper change, CI workflow change, dependency/version + update, public export change, score-algorithm change, or package reshape. +- No merge, publish, ready flip, issue checkbox mutation, acceptance-evidence block, or phase + relabel. +- No `deno.lock`, cache, generated asset, or receipt implementation change. + +## PLAN-EVAL judgement + +**Required.** This is one PR but not a ceremonial three-line plan: it spans the A6 CLI harness and +an A2 publishable MCP member, a root Deno config boundary, executable docs, JSR audits for two +members, bidirectional mutation controls, and a serialized global consumer gate. A wrong exclusion +or path decision can create another false green, and the coordinator explicitly retains plan-gate +authority. The topic supervisor must launch a fresh native opposite-family Fable 5 medium evaluator; +this thread stops after publishing the plan and must not create a self-authored verdict. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md index 28a943f4be..d3418f5efb 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md @@ -2,21 +2,86 @@ ## Re-baseline -- Carried-in source: issues #1604, #1618, and #1622 plus the coordinator's frozen contract. +- Carried-in source: live issues #1604, #1618, and #1622 plus the coordinator's frozen contract. - Re-derived against `main` @ `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b` on 2026-08-15. -- What changed vs the carried-in version: pending live issue and source research. +- The local branch differed from that immutable base only by the harness bootstrap commit while this + research was performed; none of the researched product paths differed from the base. +- What changed vs the issue reports: their three defects reproduce at this base. Root `fmt:check` + already supplies a wrapper-level fixture exclusion (`deno.json:139-148`), but the issue's exact + standalone scoped command does not inherit task arguments and still aborts. That distinction is + load-bearing for the plan. + +## Live issue contracts + +| Issue | Current state | Acceptance that constrains the plan | +| ----- | --------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| #1604 | open, `priority:p2`, milestone 27 | Package-cwd task green; all three paths cwd-independent or explicitly skipped; no assertion removed/weakened. | +| #1618 | open, `priority:p2`, milestone 27 | Exact scoped formatter exits 0 with no crashed batches; malformed doctor fixture remains malformed and tested; a real source formatting defect is reported as a formatting finding; sibling invalid-config fixtures surveyed. | +| #1622 | open, `priority:p2`, milestone 27 | Widening and narrowing `closeScoreGap` both make a test fail; misleading boundary label corrected; empirical rationale recorded. | ## Findings -| # | Finding | How to verify | -| - | ------- | ------------- | -| 1 | Pending research. | Pending `file:line` evidence. | +| # | Finding | `file:line` / command evidence | +| --- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| R1 | `packages/cli` defines its canonical package test as `deno test --allow-all`, so `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` deliberately runs every nested CLI/E2E unit with `packages/cli` as process cwd. | `packages/cli/deno.json:14-22`. | +| R2 | Exactly three tests fail under that cwd. The structured targeted reproduction selected only the three named test files and returned `passed: 3`, `failed: 3`: the documented-stream test cannot read `docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md`; quickstart drift cannot read `docs/site/quickstart.vto`; the service-env script-existence test cannot stat `packages/cli/e2e/.../configure-service-env.ts`. | `run-deno-test.ts --cwd packages/cli -- --allow-all `; test locations below. | +| R3 | The service-env failure is not the subprocess probe. The gate registry intentionally stores `GATE_DIR` relative to repository root and returns a relative script argument for the fixture gate, while the test calls `Deno.stat(script)` directly. The same test already derives `REPO_ROOT` from `import.meta` and uses it for subprocess cwd, so the honest fix is to resolve the asserted command path against that root without changing the production gate command. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates.ts:26-27,46-64`; `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:31-34,96-102,124-143`. | +| R4 | The quickstart drift test directly reads a repo-root-relative string. Its assertion compares every marked shell line with `QUICKSTART_DOCUMENTED_COMMANDS`; only path acquisition is defective. | `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:4-15`. | +| R5 | The documented-stream test calls a helper whose `DOC_PATH` and `.llm/tmp` paths are process-cwd-relative. The failing read is `DOC_PATH`; the helper then extracts and actually imports the published example. Anchoring repository-owned source/scratch paths to a module-derived repo root retains the semantic runtime assertion. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15,21-30,33-39`; `run-documented-stream-example_test.ts:4-35`. | +| R6 | The malformed MCP fixture is deliberate and exactly malformed as reported: `workspace` is a string, while Deno expects an array/object workspace config. The doctor test reads the fixture by module-derived absolute path and asserts `deno_workspace: fail`; changing the fixture would destroy the test. | `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json:1`; `packages/mcp/tests/doctor-families_test.ts:10-33`; `project-wiring-doctor-family.ts:78-87`. | +| R7 | The exact formatter reproduction selects 115 TS/TSX files, exits 1, reports one failed batch and zero findings, then identifies a config-parse crash. Wrapper-level `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'` selects 110 files and exits 0. Passing explicit `--config deno.json` selects all 115 and exits 0 because it disables nested auto-discovery. | Research commands recorded in this session; wrapper filtering and explicit-config support are at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:67-87,103-201,255-301,312-331`; crash refusal at `:370-415,439-488`. | +| R8 | The supported in-repo solution that keeps the issue's exact no-extra-flag command is Deno's root configuration exclusion. Root `exclude` is the cross-tool mechanism for a directory Deno should never discover as real configuration; `fmt.exclude`/CLI `--ignore` are formatter-only mechanisms. This plan uses the narrow cross-tool root exclusion for the deliberately invalid fixture tree; the doctor test's explicit runtime read is unaffected. | Root `exclude` currently contains only `.llm/tmp/` at `deno.json:10-12`; official Deno config reference: `https://docs.deno.com/runtime/reference/deno_json/#exclude`; formatter-specific alternative: `https://docs.deno.com/runtime/reference/cli/fmt/#including-and-excluding-files`. | +| R9 | Root `fmt:check` already excludes the doctor fixture at the wrapper-selection layer, which is why only editing that task would not fix the acceptance command and would leave the false-green blind spot. | `deno.json:139-148` versus the exact issue command with no `--exclude`. | +| R10 | `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap` is a typed exported internal-module policy value of `0.5`. `orderGuidanceSections` first sorts by route/score/identity, then groups candidates whose score is at most that value below the group leader, and reorders each close group by slug. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:20-44,181-211`. | +| R11 | The only close-score unit uses a 10.4 leader and 9.8 `outside-leader-band`, but that candidate's `pages/gamma` slug already sorts last. Widening the band therefore does not alter the asserted order. No just-inside control exists either, so narrowing is also unpinned. | `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`; live #1622 mutation evidence reports `0.5 -> 5` remained green. | +| R12 | The empirical rationale can be made exact without inventing score-scale meaning: the observed pair's gap is about `0.3019801981861221`; `0.5` leaves `0.1980198018138779` headroom, about 2.6 times the observed regeneration movement `0.0748587451731435`. | Live #1622 body; policy definition `guidance-index.ts:33-44`. | +| R13 | The full repository has no other deliberately malformed `workspace: "packages/*"` fixture. The healthy MCP sibling correctly uses an array. | `rg` over `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, `.llm/tools/**`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1`. | + +## jsr-audit surface scan + +JSR audit is applicable because the plan touches two publishable workspace members, even though the +CLI edits are under its publish-excluded E2E harness and MCP's public export map does not change. + +### `@netscript/cli` + +- Export map: `.`, `./scaffolding`, and `./testing`; binary `netscript` + (`packages/cli/deno.json:6-13`). +- Planned edits are only under `packages/cli/e2e/**`, which the publish allow/exclude rules omit + (`packages/cli/deno.json:57-76`). No public symbol, export key, binary, or publish asset changes. +- Exact internal `@netscript/*` pins are all `0.0.6`: aspire, config, fresh-ui, mcp, plugin, and sdk + (`packages/cli/deno.json:23-29`). No dependency edit is planned. +- Existing debt: package `isolatedDeclarations` is false (`packages/cli/deno.json:46-55`) and the + public doc-lint completeness debt remains open (`arch-debt.md:870-885`). This leaf must not claim + to close it or weaken the existing publish task. +- Runtime asset / `import.meta` rule: module-relative reads are confined to publish-excluded E2E + tests/helpers. No new read or `import.meta` use may enter the published CLI graph. + +### `@netscript/mcp` + +- Export map: `.`, `./cli`, and `./openapi-projection` (`packages/mcp/deno.json:6-10`). The planned + `guidance-index.ts` comment and test do not add or change an exported package entrypoint or + symbol. +- Exact internal `@netscript/*` pins are `@netscript/aspire@0.0.6` and two telemetry subpaths at + `@netscript/telemetry@0.0.6` (`packages/mcp/deno.json:11-17`). No dependency edit is planned. +- `src/**/*.ts` is published while `tests/` is excluded (`packages/mcp/deno.json:19-31`). Therefore + the policy-comment change is publishable and must pass the package audit, full export-map + doc-lint, isolated-declaration analysis, and publish dry-run; the regression test itself is not + published. +- `guidance-index.ts` has no runtime asset read and no `import.meta` use. The plan forbids adding + either. `deno doc --filter GuidanceResult packages/mcp/mod.ts` resolves the current public + contract cleanly; the internal policy remains intentionally absent from the package export map. +- Existing debt `MCP-A6-V2-SHAPE` and `mcp-tool-contracts-a8-1102` are not touched or deepened + (`arch-debt.md:2073-2093,2220-2234`). -## jsr-audit surface scan (package/plugin waves) +### Planned JSR gates -- Surface scanned: pending exact touched publishable-member selection. -- Slow-type / surface risks: pending. +For both members: full export-map `doc:lint`; `audit-jsr-package.ts`; exact-pin scan; root +isolated-declaration check/publish simulation; and member/root publish dry-run. Inspect publish file +lists and fail on any new runtime asset read, top-level `import.meta`/`fromFileUrl`, self-bare +import, slow type, or non-exact `@netscript/*` dependency. Existing documented CLI debt is baseline, +not a waiver for a new finding. ## Open questions -- Which exact paths are necessary inside the unusually broad frozen outer bound? +- None that may change implementation shape. Coordinator ownership of the serialized + `scaffold.runtime` mutex is an execution precondition, not an open design decision. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md index 8350e5845a..00e6c5d7a9 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md @@ -2,92 +2,132 @@ ## Run Metadata -| Field | Value | -| --- | --- | -| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | -| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | -| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` | -| Scope overlays | `docs` | +| Field | Value | +| -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | +| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | +| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` (supporting MCP member remains A2) | +| Scope overlays | `docs` | ## Design -Design checkpoint pending research. No implementation files may be created before this section is -completed and PLAN-EVAL returns `PASS` in a separate session. +### Public surface -### Public Surface +- No package export, subpath, symbol, binary, or command name changes. +- `@netscript/cli` changes remain under publish-excluded `e2e/`. +- `@netscript/mcp` keeps `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY` internal to its source graph; only the rationale + comment and test change. +- Root Deno configuration gains one narrow exclusion for a deliberately invalid test fixture. -- Pending. +### Domain vocabulary -### Domain Vocabulary - -- Gate honesty — a gate must execute the intended selection and fail on protected regressions. +- **Gate honesty** — a gate fires on its intended subject, distinguishes a finding from a crash, and + fails when its protected condition regresses. +- **Repository-owned path** — a path anchored to the owning module/repository, never ambient cwd. +- **Invalid-config fixture** — checked-in malformed config explicitly read by a test, never consumed + through automatic configuration discovery. +- **Close-score group** — same-route candidates no more than `closeScoreGap` below one group leader. +- **Inside control / outside control** — candidates whose ordering observably changes if the + threshold narrows/widens. ### Ports -- None anticipated; confirm during research. +- None. All changed behavior uses Deno/Web Platform primitives at existing test/tooling edges. ### Constants -- Pending `closeScoreGap` research. +- `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap = 0.5` remains unchanged. +- Empirical values documented beside it: observed gap ≈ `0.3019801981861221`; headroom + `0.1980198018138779`; observed regeneration movement `0.0748587451731435`. +- Test-only outside epsilon is strictly greater than zero and chosen to remain observable. -### Commit Slices +### Commit slices -| # | Slice | Gate | Files | -| - | ----- | ---- | ----- | -| 1 | Pending research-backed plan. | Pending. | Pending. | +| # | Slice | Gate | Exact files | +| -- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | +| S1 | Exclude deliberately invalid config from Deno discovery while retaining doctor failure semantics. | Exact MCP fmt clean + real-formatting negative control + doctor test. | `deno.json` | +| S2 | Make all three CLI tests package-cwd independent without weakening assertions. | Structured targeted 6/6 + exact package task + docs gates; final runtime consumer in S4. | Three exact CLI files in `plan.md` | +| S3 | Pin close-score policy on both sides and record rationale. | Targeted test + widen/narrow RED controls + scoped MCP/quality gates. | `guidance-index.ts`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | +| S4 | Integrated evidence and serialized consumer gate. | Frozen full gate set + coordinator-granted `scaffold.runtime`. | Run artifacts/evidence only | -### Deferred Scope +### Deferred scope -- Implementation — explicitly unauthorized until PLAN-EVAL disposition. +- Any seventh product/config path, wrapper/CI change, docs edit, fixture repair, public API change, + dependency update, or algorithm change. +- `scaffold.runtime` execution until coordinator mutex grant. +- All implementation until separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. -### Contributor Path +### Contributor path -Pending research-backed design. +To extend these guards, keep repository-owned paths module-relative; declare deliberately invalid +fixtures in the root exclusion and pair them with explicit tests; for tuned ordering boundaries add +one candidate on each side whose identity order conflicts with score order. Then prove both green +behavior and a controlled red mutation through structured gates. -## Progress Log +## Progress log -| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | -| ---- | ----- | ---- | ----- | -| 2026-08-15 | bootstrap | activated | Coordinator-generated thread identity preserved; mandatory artifacts created. | +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| ---------- | --------- | ---------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 2026-08-15 | bootstrap | activated | Exact worktree/branch/base verified; coordinator thread record preserved; commit `25c29575c`; draft PR #1663 opened. | +| 2026-08-15 | research | live issue/source read | All three issues fetched live; exact three-test reproduction returned 3 pass / 3 fail from package cwd. | +| 2026-08-15 | research | fmt controls | Baseline exact command: 115 selected, config crash; wrapper exclude: 110 selected/green; explicit root config: 115 selected/green. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | Design checkpoint | Six-file authoritative surface locked; formal PLAN-EVAL selected; implementation remains prohibited. | ## Decisions -| Decision | Reason | Source | -| -------- | ------ | ------ | -| Formal PLAN-EVAL required | Cross-package, docs-overlay, JSR-applicable work with a serialized expensive gate is decision-heavy. | `workflow/run-loop.md` §4 | +| Decision | Reason | Source | +| -------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | +| Root exclusion, not fixture repair or wrapper edit | Exact acceptance command must work and frozen surface excludes `.llm/tools`. | plan L3/L4; Deno config docs | +| Module-derived paths | Package cwd is the defect; module location is stable. | plan L1/L2 | +| Bidirectional score controls | Current identity ordering masks both threshold directions. | research R10-R12; plan L5/L6 | +| Formal PLAN-EVAL | Multi-member/config/docs/JSR/runtime interactions are decision-heavy. | run-loop §4; plan judgement | ## Drift -| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | -| ----- | -------- | ------------------ | -| Worktree initially contained the launcher-generated untracked `codex-thread-ids.md`. | minor | yes | +| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | +| ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | ------------------ | +| Launcher preseeded exact thread record before clean check. | minor | yes | +| Root task already had a wrapper-level fixture exclude, but standalone acceptance command remains red. | minor research clarification | yes | + +## Gate results + +### Research diagnostics (not merge evidence) -## Gate Results +| Check | Result | Notes | +| -------------------------------------------- | ---------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Targeted three-file package-cwd test | FAIL as expected | Structured report: 3 pass / 3 fail; exact three `NotFound` paths reproduced. | +| Exact scoped MCP fmt | FAIL as expected | 115 selected; one config-parse crash; zero findings. | +| Scoped MCP fmt with wrapper `--exclude` | PASS diagnostic | 110 selected; no failures/findings. Not the acceptance command. | +| Scoped MCP fmt with explicit root `--config` | PASS diagnostic | 115 selected; no failures/findings. Informs config-discovery cause. | -### Static Gates +### Static gates -| Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | -| ---- | ---------------- | ------ | ----- | -| bootstrap identity | `pwd`; `git rev-parse HEAD`; `git status --short` | PASS with noted preseed | Correct worktree/branch/base; only coordinator thread record was untracked. | +| Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | +| -------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Plan artifact format | Structured wrapper over five exact run-artifact files | PASS | 5 selected; zero findings/crashes; `git diff --check` clean. | -### Fitness Gates +### Fitness gates -| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| ---- | ------ | -------- | ----- | -| Plan-Gate | NOT_RUN | No evaluator verdict exists. | Topic supervisor must launch the separate evaluator. | +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ---------------- | --------------------- | ------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Plan-Gate | NOT_RUN | No evaluator artifact/comment exists. | Required; topic supervisor launches separate evaluator. | +| JSR surface scan | PASS (planning input) | `research.md` JSR section | No public delta; both members still receive full planned audits. | -### Runtime Gates +### Runtime gates -| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| ---- | ------ | -------- | ----- | -| `scaffold.runtime` | NOT_RUN | Coordinator mutex not granted. | Planning only; prohibited from Aspire/Docker/E2E runtime execution. | +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ------------------ | ------- | ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | +| `scaffold.runtime` | NOT_RUN | Mutex not requested/granted. | Correct state; this thread may not run it. | -### Consumer Gates +### Consumer gates -| Consumer | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| -------- | ------ | -------- | ----- | -| Pending | NOT_RUN | Planning phase. | No implementation authority. | +| Consumer | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| -------------------- | ------------- | ------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------- | +| CLI package-cwd task | baseline FAIL | Research structured targeted reproduction. | Future S2 must make the full exact task green. | -## Handoff Notes +## Handoff notes -- Inspect the exact narrowed edit surface, per-slice false-green defenses, and JSR plan first. +- PLAN-EVAL should inspect L3 root-exclusion semantics, the exact six-file bound, the two-direction + score controls, and the honest treatment of existing CLI JSR debt. +- No implementation authority exists. The topic supervisor owns evaluator launch and the future + `scaffold.runtime` mutex. From be2b1872823cbbb07a393633fcccb684f753afc1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 12:42:37 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 3/7] docs(harness): PLAN-EVAL FAIL_PLAN for package-gate-honesty Formal separate-session PLAN-EVAL of plan head 72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff. Root deno.json exclude does not make the #1618 acceptance command exit 0 (executed proof); PR slice numbering and plan slice numbering diverge; scaffold.runtime rationale overstated. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0176qkbF4eKUt7TxJiEPdTrk --- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md | 213 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 213 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..48b9577aea --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md @@ -0,0 +1,213 @@ +# PLAN-EVAL — release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty + +- Plan evaluator session: Claude Code `9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be` / 2026-08-15 +- Run: `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` +- Surface / archetype: `packages/cli` E2E harness + `packages/mcp` + root `deno.json` / Archetype 6 + (CLI / Tooling), supporting MCP member A2 +- Scope overlays: `docs` +- **Evaluated head:** `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` (plan head) +- **Immutable base:** `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b` + +## Identity, independence, route + +| Field | Value | +| ------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Model | Anthropic Claude Fable 5 (`claude-fable-5`) | +| Session ID | `9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be` | +| `bridgeSessionId` | `cse_0176qkbF4eKUt7TxJiEPdTrk` (Remote Control, non-empty) | +| Daemon short / job | `9078ecb6` (`~/.claude/jobs/9078ecb6/state.json`, backend `daemon`) | +| PID | shell parent `711275` (`claude bg-spare`), evaluator shell `728133` | +| cwd | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-package-gate` | +| Requested route | `formal_plan_evaluation`: Anthropic / Fable 5 / medium / `--remote-control` | +| Observed route (`respawnFlags`) | `--model claude-fable-5 --effort medium --remote-control --permission-mode bypassPermissions --name "NetScript 0.0.7 #1663 PLAN-EVAL"` | +| Route verdict | matched (native opposite-family binding in `lane-policy.md:45`) | + +Independence: this session is a fresh Claude session and is not the Codex GPT-5.6 Sol author thread +`01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5` nor the topic supervisor +`f7691917-0be2-4bcd-8839-43d3fc809c34`. It shares no conversation state with either; it read only +the committed run artifacts, the PR, the issues, and the tree. + +## Target verification + +| Check | Observed | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Local `HEAD` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | +| `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/fix/package-gate-honesty` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | +| PR #1663 `headRefOid` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | +| `git diff --stat 05fc3132b HEAD` | 7 files, all under `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/` (+579/-0); **no product source changed** | +| PR state | draft; base `main`; milestone `0.0.7`; labels `type:fix`, `area:tooling`, `status:research`; body `Closes #1604`, `Closes #1618`, `Closes #1622` | +| Worktree | clean before and after evaluation (all evaluator experiments ran in `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp` copies, never in the checkout) | + +## Checklist results + +| Plan-Gate item | Result | Evidence / location | +| --------------------------------------- | -------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Research present and current | PASS | `research.md` re-baselined against `main` @ `05fc3132b` on 2026-08-15. Spot-checked R3 (`service-env-gates.ts:26-27,44-66`, `_test.ts:31-34,96-102`), R5 (`run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15`), R10/R11 (`guidance-index.ts:33-44,181-211`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`) — all match the tree. R7's numbers (115 selected / 1 crash; 110 / green with wrapper `--exclude`) reproduced by execution. R8's _conclusion_ is falsified by execution — see finding F1. | +| Decisions locked | FAIL | L1, L2, L4, L5, L6, L7, L8, L9 are stated with rationale and hold. **L3 (`plan.md:90`) is locked on a mechanism that does not achieve the slice's own passing condition** (F1). | +| Open-decision sweep | FAIL | The plan's sweep (`plan.md:100-108`) marks "root exclusion versus wrapper change" resolved by L3. Evaluator-run sweep finds it _unresolved_: no in-plan mechanism makes the #1618 acceptance command exit 0 (F1). Deferring it forces S1 rework → automatic unchecked box. | +| Commit slices (< 30, gate + files each) | PASS (with reconcile note) | Four slices (`plan.md:115-120`), ordered, each names proof, files, gates. Numbering conflicts with the PR body checklist (F2). | +| Risk register | PASS | `plan.md:160-172`. Row 2 ("`fmt.exclude` may select differently") anticipated the class of F1 but the mitigation ("use the top-level boundary") is the thing that fails. | +| Gate set selected | PASS (with rationale note) | Frozen contract gates all mapped (`plan.md:150-158`); A6/F-* + docs overlay covered. `scaffold.runtime` rationale is overstated (F3, advisory). | +| Deferred scope explicit | PASS | `plan.md:181-189`. | +| jsr-audit surface scan (pkg/plugin) | PASS | `research.md` § jsr-audit surface scan + `plan.md:122-131`; both publishable members scoped correctly (see item 4). | + +## The six specific proofs + +### 1. Root `deno.json` exclusion — **FAILS by execution** (F1) + +The plan's L3/S1 claim (`plan.md:51,90,117`; `research.md` R8) is that adding the fixture directory +to root `exclude` makes the exact #1618 acceptance command +(`deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/mcp --ext ts,tsx`) +exit 0 with `failedBatches: 0`, without touching the wrapper. + +Executed on Deno 2.9.5 against a `git archive HEAD` copy of `deno.json`, `deno.lock`, `packages/`, +`plugins/`, `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` in `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp/repo-copy`, with +`"exclude": [".llm/tmp/", "packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/"]` written into the copied root +`deno.json`: + +```text +{"command":"deno fmt --check","mode":"check","summary":{"filesSelected":115,"batches":1,"failedBatches":1,"findings":0,"ignoredFindings":0},"findings":[]} +1 deno fmt batch(es) failed without producing formatting findings. +error: Failed to parse "workspace" configuration. +Caused by: + invalid type: string "packages/*", expected struct WorkspaceConfig +EXIT=1 +``` + +Control in the same copy, wrapper `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'`: +`filesSelected:110, failedBatches:0`, EXIT=0. + +Why: `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` does its own file selection (`collectRoot`, lines 263-286; +`SKIP_DIRS` + regex filters only — it never reads `deno.json` `exclude`) and passes every selected +file **explicitly** to `deno fmt --check` (`runBatch`, lines 312-331). The 5 fixture `.ts` files +under `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/**` are therefore always in argv, and Deno resolves the +nearest config for an explicitly named file regardless of root `exclude`. Minimal-repro matrix +(scratch project, explicit `src/a.ts` + `tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/netscript.config.ts`): + +| Config variant | Explicit-file `deno fmt --check` | Directory-arg `deno fmt --check packages/mcp` | +| ----------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | +| no exclusion | crash | ok (fixture `deno.json` treated as a JSON file, not config) | +| root `exclude: [fixture dir]` | **crash** | ok, fixture skipped | +| root `fmt.exclude: [fixture dir]` | crash | — | +| member `packages/mcp/deno.json` `exclude` | crash | — | +| CLI `--ignore=` | crash | — | +| root exclude + `--config deno.json` | ok (only via wrapper flag) | — | + +So root `exclude` is a supported, narrowly scoped, non-masking boundary for directory walks (it +provably does not hide `packages/mcp/src/**` — 110 real files still format, and the negative control +via the wrapper path is unaffected), **but it is not the mechanism that satisfies #1618's acceptance +row 1** as written, because the wrapper's explicit-argv invocation bypasses it. The plan's S1 +passing condition ("Exact scoped fmt wrapper returns exit 0, `failedBatches: 0`", `plan.md:117`) is +unreachable inside the six-file surface as planned. + +### 2. `import.meta`-derived roots (#1604) — PASS by close reading + +- `service-env-gates_test.ts:34` already derives `REPO_ROOT` via + `import.meta.resolve('../../../../../../../../')` — eight segments from + `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/` land on the repo root (counted). + Resolving the `.ts` argument against it for `Deno.stat` (`:96-102`) is correct from both cwds; the + gate command itself keeps the relative `GATE_DIR/...` argument and `commandGate` runs with + `cwd = context.project.repoRoot` (`gate-factory.ts:53,67`), so production semantics are unchanged + (L2 verified). +- `quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:5` reads `'docs/site/quickstart.vto'` — module is four segments + below root; the assertion (`:15`) is untouched. +- `run-documented-stream-example.ts:3,10-14` — `DOC_PATH` and the `.llm/tmp` scratch dir are both + cwd-relative; the module is seven segments below root. The only production consumer is + `consume-flow-b-stream.ts:127`, spawned by `otel-gates.ts:53-64` with cwd = repoRoot, where the + anchored absolute path equals today's cwd-relative resolution. No behaviour shift. +- Risk row "off by one directory" (`plan.md:166`) plus L1 cover the derivation; the plan does not + state the segment counts — the implementer should assert a known repo file exists at the derived + root, as the mitigation says. + +### 3. `closeScoreGap` observability (#1622) — PASS by close reading + +`orderGuidanceSections` (`guidance-index.ts:181-211`) groups leader-relative with +`leader.score - candidate.score <= closeScoreGap` and re-sorts each group by slug. The plan's L5 +adds one early-slug candidate exactly at `leader − 0.5` (inside: reorders ahead of the leader on +slug; a narrower gap leaves it behind → fails) and one early-slug candidate at `leader − (0.5+ε)` +(outside: stays behind on score; a wider gap pulls it ahead → fails). Expected orders are literal +slug lists, not derived from the constant, so the assertion is non-tautological in both directions. +Float check: `10.4 - 9.9 === 0.5` and `10.5 - 10.0 === 0.5` in V8; `10.4 - 9.8` is +`0.5999999999999996`, still `> 0.5` — the risk row (`plan.md:169`) correctly tells the implementer +to prefer exactly representable values and a visibly larger outside ε. The existing `pages/gamma` +element (`guidance-retrieval_test.ts:80`) is correctly diagnosed as decorative (R11). + +### 4. Two-member JSR/publish evidence — PASS + +- `@netscript/cli`: all edits under `e2e/`, which `packages/cli/deno.json:69-72` publish-excludes; + `isolatedDeclarations: false` (`:50`) and the doc-lint completeness debt are named as **baseline** + (`research.md` § `@netscript/cli`; `plan.md:126,170`) with "no new diagnostic" as the bar — not + reported clean. +- `@netscript/mcp`: `src/**` is published, `tests/` excluded (`packages/mcp/deno.json:24-27`); the + policy comment is publishable, so the full member audit + doc-lint + isolated-declaration + + dry-run is proportionate; the test is not published. Static `import.meta`/`Deno.read*` scan on the + changed published file is the right rejection rule. + +### 5. `scaffold.runtime` load-bearing? — **not on the merits** (F3, advisory) + +The only changed production path is `run-documented-stream-example.ts`, whose full semantic +behaviour (doc read → extract → temp module → import → SSE consume) is executed end-to-end by its +unit test (`run-documented-stream-example_test.ts`) against a local `Deno.serve`. After anchoring, +running that unit test from both cwds proves the change; the `scaffold.runtime` consumer +(`consume-flow-b-stream.ts` from cwd = repoRoot) exercises the identical absolute path. The gate +matrix (`gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md:66-75`) classes `scaffold.runtime` as `n/a` for runs that do +not touch scaffold output / plugin scaffolding / DB wiring / Aspire helper generation / publish +shape — none of which this leaf touches. It is in the plan only because the frozen contract lists +it; the plan's rationale ("required because the changed helper is called by the full scaffold +consumer path", `plan.md:81-82`) overstates its evidentiary value. If the coordinator keeps it, the +plan's execution contract (exact one-pass command, `--cleanup --format pretty`, current head, +mutex-gated, NOT_RUN otherwise, `plan.md:120,158`) is sufficient. Recommendation to the coordinator: +waive it for this leaf and record the waiver, rather than serialize an aspire+docker+postgres run +for a path already proven by a unit test. + +### 6. PR checklist vs plan slice order — **do not reconcile** (F2) + +| # | PR #1663 body `## Slices` | `plan.md:117-120` | +| -- | ------------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------- | +| S1 | Make the three CLI package tests cwd-independent | `deno.json` fixture exclusion (MCP fmt) | +| S2 | Exclude malformed fixtures from MCP formatting | The three CLI files | +| S3 | Pin `closeScoreGap` | same | +| S4 | Gates + `scaffold.runtime` | same | + +S1/S2 are swapped between the two surfaces; per-slice PR comments and checkbox ticks would drift. + +## Open-decision sweep (evaluator-run) + +1. **#1618 mechanism** — unresolved (F1). The plan must pick a mechanism that empirically satisfies + the acceptance command. Options I verified or can bound: (a) wrapper change in + `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` (skip fixture trees / pass `--config` — the issue's own option 2; + **outside the frozen file surface**, needs coordinator rescope); (b) stop the fixture's `.ts` + files from being selectable or present as `.ts` (issue option 3 — construct the malformed fixture + at runtime in the doctor test, or otherwise keep no `.ts` under a directory whose nearest config + is deliberately broken; inside `packages/mcp`, which is in-surface, and still "not repairing the + fixture"). Root `exclude` may additionally be kept as belt-and-braces for directory-walk tools, + but it cannot be the load-bearing decision. +2. Everything else in the plan's sweep holds. + +## Verdict + +`FAIL_PLAN` + +### If FAIL_PLAN — required fixes + +1. **L3 / S1 / R8** (`plan.md:51,90,102,117,164-165`; `research.md` R8) — observed: root `exclude` + leaves the exact acceptance command at `filesSelected:115, failedBatches:1`, EXIT=1 (evidence + above). Required: re-decide the #1618 mechanism with an executed pre-plan proof of the exact + command exiting 0 with `failedBatches: 0` and non-empty selection, the doctor test still green, + and the fixture still malformed; if the chosen mechanism needs `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts`, + obtain the coordinator's explicit surface rescope before locking it, and update the "not touched" + list (`plan.md:70`) accordingly. Update S1's file list, gate row 4 and risk rows 1-2 to match. +2. **Slice numbering** (PR #1663 body `## Slices` vs `plan.md:117-120`) — required: make the two + agree (either renumber the plan or edit the PR body) before any implementation slice is + committed, so per-slice comments and checkbox ticks reference the same S-number. +3. **`scaffold.runtime` rationale** (`plan.md:81-82`, S4) — required wording fix, not a mechanism + change: state that the gate is contract-frozen, that the matrix classes it `n/a` for this + surface, and that the coordinator may waive it; do not claim the helper change needs it. + (Advisory on its own; would not block a PASS.) + +## Notes + +- Nothing was executed against the checkout; all reproductions ran on `git archive HEAD` copies or + minimal scratch projects under `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp`. No expensive gate, Aspire, Docker, or + `e2e:cli` was run. No labels, issues, or central state were changed. +- Cycle count: this is PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 of the two allowed. From ccf256884fb552869e6bc468ac58d6914187ec04 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 13:02:19 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 4/7] docs(harness): repair package gate plan after evaluation --- .../package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md | 72 +++++--- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md | 75 ++++++++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md | 171 ++++++++++-------- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md | 36 ++-- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md | 141 ++++++++++----- 5 files changed, 331 insertions(+), 164 deletions(-) diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md index 14a9ecc225..e8c0432a62 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md @@ -6,17 +6,18 @@ | -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | | Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | -| Current phase | `plan-eval` handoff; hard stop | +| Current phase | repaired plan; hard stop pending twelfth-path decision, then cycle 2 | | Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` (supporting MCP member A2) | | Scope overlays | `docs` | ## Current state -Bootstrap, live issue research, source research, JSR surface scan, bounded plan, and Design -checkpoint are complete. Draft PR #1663 targets immutable `main` base -`05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b`. The plan owns exactly six product/config files and -requires formal PLAN-EVAL. No implementation is authorized, and the expensive gate has not been -requested or run. +PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 correctly returned `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit `be2b18728`: root exclusion +cannot affect the optimized wrappers' explicit argv. The coordinator granted an eleven-path rescope +for child-only marker semantics plus nearest-config batching in both wrappers, and waived +`scaffold.runtime` as `n/a`. The corrected proof selects 114: lint is green and fmt honestly reports +one unformatted healthy fixture file. Its scratch-only repair is proved but awaits a twelfth-path +grant. No checkout product/config implementation exists. ## Completed @@ -26,26 +27,35 @@ requested or run. - All three issues re-read live. - Three cwd failures and MCP fmt config crash reproduced through structured wrappers. - `closeScoreGap` definition, consumption, and decorative test behavior traced. -- Six-file plan and per-member JSR audit plan locked. +- Eleven-path repaired plan and per-member JSR audit plan locked. +- Exact no-extra-flag lint prototype green at 114; fmt reports exactly one genuine healthy-fixture + finding at 114; separate fmt/lint negative controls red with real findings; doctor 4/4; all + negative-control source files restored byte-exactly. +- Scratch-only formatting of the pending twelfth path makes exact fmt green at 114 while lint and + doctor remain green. ## In progress -- Awaiting topic-supervisor PLAN-EVAL after the research + plan handoff commit/comment. +- Awaiting topic-supervisor disposition of the twelfth-path request, then Tier-A review and + separate-session PLAN-EVAL cycle 2. ## Next steps -1. Topic supervisor launches a fresh native opposite-family Fable 5 medium PLAN-EVAL. -2. If and only if verdict is `PASS`, coordinator grants implementation authority. -3. Future implementation follows S1-S4; S4 requests the serialized `scaffold.runtime` mutex. +1. Coordinator grants or rejects the proved + `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` twelfth path. +2. Topic supervisor reviews the resulting reachable plan and launches PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 in a fresh + separate evaluator session. +3. If and only if verdict is `PASS`, coordinator grants implementation authority. +4. Future implementation follows S1-S4; `scaffold.runtime` remains waived `n/a` and must not run. ## Key decisions -| Decision | Source | Notes | -| ------------------------------------ | -------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Root config excludes invalid fixture | plan L3/L4 | Exact standalone formatter command must work; fixture remains malformed/tested. | -| Module-derived CLI paths | plan L1/L2 | No ambient cwd and no weakened assertion. | -| `0.5` pinned both directions | plan L5/L6 | Inside/outside identity conflict makes movement observable. | -| Formal PLAN-EVAL required | plan judgement | This thread cannot self-launch or self-certify. | +| Decision | Source | Notes | +| -------------------------------------------- | -------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Child marker + config batching owns boundary | plan L3/L4 | Both select 114; lint green; fmt exposes one real pending-path finding. | +| Module-derived CLI paths | plan L1/L2 | No ambient cwd and no weakened assertion. | +| `0.5` pinned both directions | plan L5/L6 | Inside/outside identity conflict makes movement observable. | +| Formal PLAN-EVAL required | plan judgement | This thread cannot self-launch or self-certify. | ## Authoritative product/config edit surface @@ -55,28 +65,34 @@ requested or run. 4. `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts` 5. `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts` 6. `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` +7. `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` +8. `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts` +9. `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` +10. `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts` +11. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` Everything else in the frozen outer bound is read-only, especially both docs sources and the broken -fixture. A seventh path is rescope. +fixture config. A twelfth path is rescope. ## Gates -| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | -| ----------- | ---------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | -| Plan-Gate | REQUIRED / NOT_RUN | `plan.md`; evaluator absent by design. | -| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | -| Fitness/JSR | planned | `research.md` and `plan.md` per-member tables. | -| Runtime | NOT_RUN | Coordinator mutex not granted. | -| Consumer | baseline failures reproduced | `worklog.md` research diagnostics. | +| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | +| ----------- | ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------- | +| Plan-Gate | cycle 1 `FAIL_PLAN`; cycle 2 pending | `plan-eval.md`; repaired `plan.md`. | +| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | +| Fitness/JSR | planned | `research.md` and `plan.md` per-member tables. | +| Runtime | N/A | Explicit coordinator waiver; must not run. | +| Consumer | baseline failures reproduced | `worklog.md` research diagnostics. | ## Open questions -- None that change implementation. Only external authorization/mutex state remains. +- Twelfth-path authority for the proved healthy-fixture formatting repair; implementation authority + then still depends on cycle-2 `PASS`. ## Drift and debt -- Drift: coordinator thread file preseed; root task wrapper exclusion does not fix standalone - command. +- Drift: R8 falsified by execution; authorized eleven-path rescope; rejected parent-family false + exclusion; corrected 114-file proof exposes one pending twelfth path. - Debt: no new/closed entry; named CLI/MCP baseline debt remains unchanged. ## Commits diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md index fcf80b2971..d564967847 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md @@ -28,3 +28,78 @@ documentation. - **Action:** fix - **Evidence:** Baseline 115 selected / one config crash; explicit wrapper exclusion 110 selected / exit 0. + +## 2026-08-15 — R8 root-exclusion conclusion falsified by execution + +- **What:** Research R8 and plan L3 claimed root `deno.json` `exclude` would make the exact + optimized wrapper command green. +- **Source:** Separate-session PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 at evaluator commit `be2b18728`; accepted + coordinator finding. +- **Expected:** Root exclusion would prevent Deno from consuming the malformed fixture config. +- **Actual:** Both wrappers select files independently and pass explicit argv. Deno resolves each + named file's nearest config, so root exclusion is not consulted by selection and the batch + crashes. +- **Severity:** significant +- **Action:** fix in plan; retain root exclusion only as non-load-bearing native directory-walk + protection. +- **Evidence:** `plan-eval.md` §1; baseline fmt/lint matrix in `worklog.md`. + +## 2026-08-15 — Coordinator granted eleven-path marker rescope and runtime waiver + +- **What:** The authoritative implementation surface grew from six to eleven paths: both optimized + wrappers, both wrapper tests, and one narrowly named marker beside the malformed fixture were + added. The coordinator selected the marker family and waived `scaffold.runtime` as gate-matrix + `n/a`. +- **Source:** Topic-supervisor resume instruction after PLAN-EVAL cycle 1. +- **Expected:** Original plan prohibited `.llm/tools/**` and awaited a serialized runtime lease. +- **Actual:** Wrapper changes are explicitly authorized; adding a twelfth path is still rescope. The + expensive gate must not run and is not `NOT_RUN` pending a lease. +- **Severity:** significant (authorized rescope) +- **Action:** accept and repair plan; no implementation before cycle-2 `PASS`. +- **Evidence:** Eleven-path table and gate row 7 in repaired `plan.md`. + +## 2026-08-15 — Child-only marker interpretation remained red + +- **What:** A scratch prototype that skipped only `doctor/broken/` removed the malformed config's + single TS file but did not produce a truthful fmt verdict. +- **Source:** `git archive HEAD` proof under `.llm/tmp/`; no checkout product/config edits. +- **Expected:** Marker-local subtree skip might be sufficient at 114 selected files. +- **Actual:** Deno next exposed the root/healthy nested-config conflict; after config-aware + batching, fmt still found the healthy fixture's root-style drift. The accepted explicit + parent-scope marker omits exactly the five-file doctor family and yields the established 110-file + surface. +- **Severity:** significant design finding +- **Action:** reject child-only semantics; lock the narrowly named `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore-parent` + convention and test both marked and unmarked directions. +- **Evidence:** Executed pre-plan matrix and exact collateral list in `worklog.md`. + +## 2026-08-15 — Parent-family marker draft rejected before push + +- **What:** Local plan-repair commit `71e803807` proposed `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore-parent`, which made + both wrappers green by dropping the entire five-file `doctor/` family. +- **Source:** Topic-supervisor correction received before any push; independent arithmetic and + archive proof. +- **Expected:** The marker must skip only its own marked subtree while an unmarked sibling remains + selected. +- **Actual:** The parent marker dropped `broken/netscript.config.ts` plus all four unmarked healthy + TS files (115→110), converting a loud real finding into a silent false-positive exclusion. +- **Severity:** significant plan correction +- **Action:** reject and amend before push. Lock child-only marker semantics plus nearest-config + batching; preserve all four healthy files in the 114-file selection. +- **Evidence:** Corrected 114-file matrix in `worklog.md`; remote branch remained at `be2b18728`, so + the rejected commit was never published. + +## 2026-08-15 — Honest 114-file proof reveals one pending twelfth path + +- **What:** With child-only marker and nearest-config batching, lint is green but fmt reports one + genuine finding in unmarked `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`. +- **Source:** Corrected `git archive HEAD` proof; coordinator independently reproduced the + file-level finding. +- **Expected:** Removing batch poisoning should expose real findings rather than suppress them. +- **Actual:** Exactly one marked file leaves selection. The remaining healthy source has no + competing fmt configuration; it is simply unformatted. Formatting only that file in scratch makes + exact fmt green at 114 while lint and doctor remain green. +- **Severity:** significant pending rescope +- **Action:** prepare proof only; do not touch the checkout path until the coordinator grants it as + a twelfth path. Implementation and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 remain blocked. +- **Evidence:** Proposed one-file diff and fmt/lint/doctor results in `worklog.md`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md index baeeb37681..07c58c1d0e 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md @@ -23,17 +23,17 @@ boundary and does not reshape it. - `packages/mcp`: **Keep** — keep MCP transports behind token-bounded tool contracts (`:42`). - Relevant open accepted debt is baseline only: CLI public doc completeness; MCP horizontal-shape classification; MCP tool-contract file size; CLI E2E scaffold directory cardinality. None is - closed or deepened by these six edits. + closed or deepened by these eleven edits. ## Axioms in play -| Axiom | Why it matters | -| ----- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| A1 | Published/exported boundaries remain unchanged; tests and comments describe the actual contract before implementation. | -| A7 | Use Deno's supported exclusion and `import.meta`/URL path primitives instead of bespoke cwd discovery. | -| A8 | Changes stay in the existing role-named files; no helper or new folder is introduced. | -| A9 | Preserve CLI A6 and MCP A2 package shapes; the leaf profile does not authorize reshaping either. | -| A14 | Each repaired guard must have a negative control that proves it can fire; a non-fired command is not green. | +| Axiom | Why it matters | +| ----- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| A1 | Published/exported boundaries remain unchanged; tests and comments describe the actual contract before implementation. | +| A7 | Use explicit marker semantics and `import.meta`/URL path primitives instead of ambient cwd or implicit config discovery. | +| A8 | Changes stay in existing role-named files plus one narrowly named fixture marker; no new folder is introduced. | +| A9 | Preserve CLI A6 and MCP A2 package shapes; the leaf profile does not authorize reshaping either. | +| A14 | Each repaired guard must have a negative control that proves it can fire; a non-fired command is not green. | ## Goal @@ -46,16 +46,22 @@ boundary cannot move materially while tests stay green. These are the only product/config paths implementation may edit. Run artifacts under this slice directory are updated alongside every future slice but are not product scope. -| Path | Justification | -| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| `deno.json` | Add the deliberately invalid MCP doctor-fixture directory to the supported root exclusion so Deno tooling never auto-discovers it as real config; leave the fixture itself intact. | -| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts` | Resolve the relative script argument against the already module-derived `REPO_ROOT` before `Deno.stat`; retain the real gate command and existence assertion. | -| `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts` | Resolve `docs/site/quickstart.vto` from the test module/repository root while retaining exact command-parity assertions. | -| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts` | Resolve the authoritative streams doc and run-owned scratch directory from a module-derived repository root so the semantic example execution works from package cwd. | -| `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts` | Record the empirical, non-scale-derived rationale adjacent to `closeScoreGap`; do not change the value or public exports. | -| `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Replace the decorative boundary arrangement with observable just-inside and just-outside controls that fail for both widening and narrowing. | - -Adding any seventh product/config path is rescope and requires coordinator approval before editing. +| Path | Justification | +| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| `deno.json` | Add the doctor fixture family to root `exclude` only as non-load-bearing protection for native directory-walk tools; wrapper acceptance is owned by the marker mechanism below. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts` | Resolve the relative script argument against the already module-derived `REPO_ROOT` before `Deno.stat`; retain the real gate command and existence assertion. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts` | Resolve `docs/site/quickstart.vto` from the test module/repository root while retaining exact command-parity assertions. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts` | Resolve the authoritative streams doc and run-owned scratch directory from a module-derived repository root so the semantic example execution works from package cwd. | +| `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts` | Record the empirical, non-scale-derived rationale adjacent to `closeScoreGap`; do not change the value or public exports. | +| `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Replace the decorative boundary arrangement with observable just-inside and just-outside controls that fail for both widening and narrowing. | +| `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` | Skip only a marker's own subtree, then batch selected files by effective nearest Deno config before constructing explicit-file argv; preserve non-empty refusal and finding/crash classification. | +| `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts` | Prove a marked subtree is skipped while an unmarked sibling remains selected, and prove nearest-config groups cannot poison one another. | +| `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` | Apply the same child-only marker and nearest-config batching semantics to lint so the optimized tool family cannot diverge. | +| `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts` | Prove marked-skip and unmarked-selection behavior for lint, retaining real lint-finding and empty-selection refusals. | +| `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` | Declare only the deliberately invalid `broken/` subtree excluded from automatic fmt/lint selection; the unmarked `healthy/` sibling remains selected. | + +These eleven paths are coordinator-authorized. Adding a twelfth path is rescope and requires +coordinator approval before editing. ## Frozen contract entries deliberately not touched @@ -65,10 +71,10 @@ Adding any seventh product/config path is rescope and requires coordinator appro - `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json` — must remain deliberately malformed. - The broad/duplicate `packages/cli/`, `packages/cli`, and `packages/*` entries — no other CLI file, package, generated asset, member config, or dependency pin is edited. -- The broad `packages/mcp` entry — no other MCP source, test, README, entrypoint, export, or config - is edited. -- No `.llm/tools/**`, workflow, lock, cache, receipt implementation, Aspire, Docker, or release - file. +- The broad `packages/mcp` entry — no other MCP source, test, fixture, README, entrypoint, export, + or config is edited. +- No other `.llm/tools/**`, workflow, lock, cache, receipt implementation, Aspire, Docker, or + release file. ## Hidden scope @@ -78,46 +84,51 @@ Adding any seventh product/config path is rescope and requires coordinator appro - Docs accuracy and source-format gates still run because two tests consume docs as executable contracts even though those docs are read-only. - Negative controls must show raw non-zero exit and distinguish a real finding from a config crash. -- `scaffold.runtime` is required because the changed documented-stream helper is called by the full - scaffold consumer path; it remains coordinator-mutexed. +- `scaffold.runtime` is frozen in the incoming contract but the archetype gate matrix classes it + `n/a` for this surface; the coordinator has explicitly waived it, so it is neither `NOT_RUN` nor + pending a mutex. ## Locked decisions -| ID | Decision | Rationale | -| -- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| L1 | Anchor repository-owned CLI test paths with `new URL(..., import.meta.url)` / `fromFileUrl`, not `Deno.cwd()`. | Module location is stable under both root and package-cwd invocation; process cwd is explicitly the defect. | -| L2 | Preserve production gate command arguments; resolve only when the test performs filesystem verification. | The runtime gate correctly interprets `GATE_DIR` relative to `context.project.repoRoot`; changing it would expand behavior scope. | -| L3 | Root `exclude` owns the invalid doctor fixture boundary. | Deno documents it as the cross-tool exclusion for directories that must never be treated as real config; it makes the exact standalone wrapper command work without editing the wrapper. | -| L4 | The malformed fixture and its existing failing-doctor assertion remain unchanged. | Validating the fixture would destroy the behavior under test and produce a false green. | -| L5 | Keep `closeScoreGap = 0.5`; add one observable just-inside case at exactly the boundary and one early-sorting just-outside case at `0.5 + epsilon`. | Narrowing breaks the inside reorder; widening breaks the outside score order. Both directions become observable. | -| L6 | Record the empirical rationale next to the policy: observed gap ≈0.3019801982, headroom ≈0.1980198018, regeneration movement ≈0.0748587452. | The value is tuned from observed headroom, not mathematically derived from an arbitrary score scale. | -| L7 | No new public export, dependency, port, helper, asset, or runtime read. | The work is regression hardening, not API or architecture change. | -| L8 | Evidence commands fire through structured wrappers/`run-gate.ts`; empty selection, crash, NOT_RUN, or missing mutex is not PASS. | This leaf exists to eliminate false verdicts. | -| L9 | Do not run `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, or any CLI runtime smoke until the coordinator grants the mutex. | Explicit cluster-wide serialization contract. | +| ID | Decision | Rationale | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| L1 | Anchor repository-owned CLI test paths with `new URL(..., import.meta.url)` / `fromFileUrl`, not `Deno.cwd()`. | Module location is stable under both root and package-cwd invocation; process cwd is explicitly the defect. | +| L2 | Preserve production gate command arguments; resolve only when the test performs filesystem verification. | The runtime gate correctly interprets `GATE_DIR` relative to `context.project.repoRoot`; changing it would expand behavior scope. | +| L3 | `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` excludes only the directory that carries it; both wrappers group all remaining files by effective nearest Deno config before batching explicit argv. | The child-only marker removes exactly `broken/netscript.config.ts` (115→114) while retaining all four unmarked healthy files. Config-aware batching prevents one config from poisoning another; lint becomes green and fmt honestly reports the one genuinely unformatted healthy file. | +| L4 | The malformed fixture and its existing failing-doctor assertion remain unchanged. | Validating the fixture would destroy the behavior under test and produce a false green. | +| L5 | Keep `closeScoreGap = 0.5`; add one observable just-inside case at exactly the boundary and one early-sorting just-outside case at `0.5 + epsilon`. | Narrowing breaks the inside reorder; widening breaks the outside score order. Both directions become observable. | +| L6 | Record the empirical rationale next to the policy: observed gap ≈0.3019801982, headroom ≈0.1980198018, regeneration movement ≈0.0748587452. | The value is tuned from observed headroom, not mathematically derived from an arbitrary score scale. | +| L7 | No new package public export, dependency, port, runtime asset, or runtime read; wrapper behavior changes only at selection. | The work is regression hardening, not API or architecture change. | +| L8 | Evidence commands fire through structured wrappers/`run-gate.ts`; empty selection, crash, NOT_RUN, or a waived gate reported as green is not PASS. | This leaf exists to eliminate false verdicts. | +| L9 | Do not run `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, `e2e:cli`, or any runtime smoke for this leaf. | The matrix classes the expensive gate `n/a` and the coordinator explicitly waived it; no lease will be granted. | +| L10 | Do not edit `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` without a twelfth-path grant. | Scratch proof shows formatting this one real file is the only remaining fmt blocker at 114, but it is outside the current authority. | ## Open-decision sweep -| Decision | Status | Notes | -| ------------------------------------ | ------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Root exclusion versus wrapper change | resolved now | L3; wrapper path is outside the frozen bound and unnecessary. | -| Test path mechanism | resolved now | L1/L2; module-derived roots only. | -| Close-score boundary data | resolved now | L5/L6; both directions observable and rationale exact. | -| Public API/export changes | resolved now | None permitted. | -| Where `scaffold.runtime` runs | safe to defer | Coordinator chooses the mutex holder/execution lane; the exact command and required head are locked. | +| Decision | Status | Notes | +| -------------------------------- | --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Invalid-fixture boundary | resolved now | Child-only marker plus nearest-config batching in both wrappers; root `exclude` is non-load-bearing only. | +| Test path mechanism | resolved now | L1/L2; module-derived roots only. | +| Close-score boundary data | resolved now | L5/L6; both directions observable and rationale exact. | +| Public API/export changes | resolved now | None permitted. | +| `scaffold.runtime` applicability | resolved now | Gate-matrix `n/a`; coordinator waiver recorded; it must not run. | +| Healthy fixture formatting | pending rescope | One-file scratch patch proves final fmt green at 114, but the twelfth path awaits coordinator authority. | -No unresolved decision would cause implementation rework. +The mechanism is locked. The only unresolved scope decision is whether the coordinator grants the +proved twelfth-path formatting repair; implementation and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 remain blocked until the +authoritative surface can express a reachable green fmt acceptance state. ## Ordered implementation slices Every slice also updates `worklog.md` and `context-pack.md`, then is committed, pushed, and commented before the next slice. No implementation begins before separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. -| # | What it proves | Exact product/config files | Proving gates | -| -- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| S1 | MCP formatting selects and checks real source while Deno ignores the intentionally invalid fixture as configuration. | `deno.json` | Exact scoped fmt wrapper returns exit 0, `failedBatches: 0`, non-empty selection; `doctor-families_test.ts` remains green; sibling-invalid-config survey; temporary real MCP source formatting defect returns raw non-zero with a formatting finding, then exact file restoration is verified. | -| S2 | The canonical package-cwd CLI task no longer has three root-relative `NotFound` failures and no assertion is weakened. | The three exact CLI files listed above | Structured targeted three-file test first (6/6), then exact `deno task --cwd packages/cli test`; scoped check/lint/fmt on the three owned TS files; docs-source-format and docs-accuracy. The final consumer proof for this slice is deferred to S4 under mutex. | -| S3 | `closeScoreGap` is pinned from both sides and its empirical rationale ships with the policy. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Structured targeted guidance test; controlled `0.5 -> 5` and `0.5 -> below-inside-gap` mutations each raw non-zero, followed by exact restoration and green rerun; MCP scoped check/test/lint/fmt; quality gate. | -| S4 | The integrated head meets the frozen proving contract and publish/docs claims are honest. | No new product/config files; run artifacts/evidence only | Commit-bound `check`, `test`, `publish-dry-run`, `quality-job`, docs-source-format, docs-accuracy, per-member JSR suite; then coordinator-granted one-pass `deno task e2e:cli run scaffold.runtime --cleanup --format pretty`. Missing mutex remains NOT_RUN, never waived or inferred. | +| # | What it proves | Exact product/config files | Proving gates | +| -- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| S1 | MCP fmt/lint isolate deliberately invalid config without removing the unmarked healthy sibling from verification. | `deno.json`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` | Wrapper tests prove child-only marked skip, unmarked-sibling selection, and nearest-config batching. Exact lint returns raw exit 0 at 114 selected files; exact fmt must select 114 and initially report exactly one real finding on `healthy/netscript.config.ts`, never a crash. Doctor stays 4/4; malformed config hash unchanged; separate real fmt/lint defects are detected and restored byte-exactly. Final fmt exit 0 is blocked on the pending twelfth-path grant, whose scratch patch is already proved. | +| S2 | The canonical package-cwd CLI task no longer has three root-relative `NotFound` failures and no assertion is weakened. | The three exact CLI files listed above | Structured targeted three-file test first (6/6), then exact `deno task --cwd packages/cli test`; scoped check/lint/fmt on the three owned TS files; docs-source-format and docs-accuracy. The helper's focused semantic unit test is the final consumer proof; the matrix-waived runtime gate is not substituted or run. | +| S3 | `closeScoreGap` is pinned from both sides and its empirical rationale ships with the policy. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Structured targeted guidance test; controlled `0.5 -> 5` and `0.5 -> below-inside-gap` mutations each raw non-zero, followed by exact restoration and green rerun; MCP scoped check/test/lint/fmt; quality gate. | +| S4 | The integrated head meets the applicable frozen proving contract and publish/docs claims are honest. | No new product/config files; run artifacts/evidence only | Commit-bound `check`, `test`, `publish-dry-run`, `quality-job`, docs-source-format, docs-accuracy, and per-member JSR suite. `scaffold.runtime` is recorded `n/a` by coordinator waiver and is not executed. | ## JSR audit plan per touched publishable member @@ -127,8 +138,8 @@ commented before the next slice. No implementation begins before separate-sessio | `@netscript/mcp` | None; policy stays internal. One comment in published `src/**`, one excluded test. | Confirm aspire and telemetry subpaths remain exact `0.0.6`; run exact-pin scan. | `audit-jsr-package.ts --root packages/mcp`, full export-map doc-lint, targeted root isolated-declaration check, member/root publish dry-run, and published file-list inspection. | Static scan of the changed published source must show no `import.meta`, `fromFileUrl`, `Deno.read*`, or runtime asset dependency; release preflight remains green. | For both, reject new slow types, self-bare imports, upstream re-exports, dependency ranges, runtime -asset reads, or publish-list drift. A dry-run is necessary but not sufficient; S4 keeps the -coordinator-owned consumer runtime gate. +asset reads, or publish-list drift. A dry-run is necessary but not sufficient; S4 combines the +applicable static, test, docs, quality, and publish evidence while recording the runtime gate `n/a`. ## Anti-patterns to resolve or avoid @@ -147,43 +158,47 @@ actual branch head. Receipts are not hand-edited; child JSON reports are attache already produces them. A receipt proves only its command. Before and after every gate, compare `deno.lock` and source status with Git ground truth. -| Order | Frozen gate | Command/check shape | Passing condition | -| ----- | --------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| 1 | check | Root/task structured check plus scoped owned-file checks (`--unstable-kv` where targeted). | Fired at current head; non-empty selection; exit 0. | -| 2 | test | Structured targeted tests, MCP package tests, then exact CLI package task. | All execute; no ignore/skip added; exit 0. | -| 3 | quality-job | `deno task ci:quality` plus `deno task quality:gate`. | Both exit 0; no new allowance/cast/lint-ignore. | -| 4 | docs-source-format | Scoped formatter over the two read-only docs source files and changed TS files; never a directory containing receipts. | Non-empty selection, zero findings/crashes. | -| 5 | docs-accuracy | `deno task docs:accuracy`. | Exit 0 with sources unchanged. | -| 6 | publish-dry-run / JSR | Root/member publish dry-runs, full export-map doc-lint, per-member JSR audits, exact-pin and release preflight scans. | No new warning/finding, correct publish lists, isolated-declaration expectations met or named baseline debt unchanged. | -| 7 | `scaffold.runtime` | Exact one-pass command with `--cleanup --format pretty`, only after coordinator mutex grant. | Fired at current head, raw exit 0, suite report complete. | +| Order | Frozen gate | Command/check shape | Passing condition | +| ----- | --------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 1 | check | Root/task structured check plus scoped owned-file checks (`--unstable-kv` where targeted). | Fired at current head; non-empty selection; exit 0. | +| 2 | test | Structured targeted tests, MCP package tests, then exact CLI package task. | All execute; no ignore/skip added; exit 0. | +| 3 | quality-job | `deno task ci:quality` plus `deno task quality:gate`. | Both exit 0; no new allowance/cast/lint-ignore. | +| 4 | docs-source-format | Scoped formatter over the two read-only docs sources, three CLI TS files, MCP policy/test TS files, and both wrapper implementation/test pairs; never a directory containing receipts. | Every intended set is non-empty; zero findings/crashes; the marker is plain text and the malformed JSON remains byte-identical. | +| 5 | docs-accuracy | `deno task docs:accuracy`. | Exit 0 with sources unchanged. | +| 6 | publish-dry-run / JSR | Root/member publish dry-runs, full export-map doc-lint, per-member JSR audits, exact-pin and release preflight scans. | No new warning/finding, correct publish lists, isolated-declaration expectations met or named baseline debt unchanged. | +| 7 | `scaffold.runtime` | `n/a` — gate-matrix classification and explicit coordinator waiver for this surface. | Not executed; no lease requested; focused semantic coverage is the applicable proof. | ## Risk register -| Risk | Mitigation | -| -------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Root exclusion also hides a real project file from other Deno tools. | Exclude only the named doctor fixture directory; existing doctor test explicitly reads it and must stay green; survey shows no sibling invalid configs. | -| `fmt.exclude` may select files differently than top-level exclusion. | Use the documented top-level config-discovery boundary and prove the issue's exact wrapper command, its non-empty count, and a negative formatting control. | -| Module-root arithmetic is off by one directory. | Derive from each file URL, assert/read known repo files, and run from `packages/cli` cwd first. | -| Fixing only doc reads leaves `.llm/tmp` cwd-sensitive. | Anchor both authoritative doc and run-owned scratch paths in the helper; cleanup remains scoped to the created temp directory. | -| Boundary test still passes under one-sided policy drift. | Separate observable inside/outside ordering plus explicit widen/narrow mutation controls. | -| Floating-point equality makes the inside case ambiguous. | Use exactly representable test values/differences where possible and a deliberately larger outside epsilon; assert order, not raw floating equality. | -| Publish audit expands into known CLI debt. | Record baseline debt and require no new diagnostics; do not edit public CLI files or claim debt closure. | -| Expensive gate is run without ownership or omitted. | S4 cannot pass until the coordinator grants the mutex and the exact command fires. | -| Validation churns locks/caches. | Never reload/delete; inspect exact Git status and lock blob before accepting any receipt. | +| Risk | Mitigation | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Marker handling becomes a blanket `tests/fixtures`/parent skip or silently empties selection. | The marker applies only to its own directory; tests pair a marked subtree with an equivalent unmarked sibling and assert the sibling remains selected. Wrapper empty-selection refusal remains intact. | +| Config-aware batching reveals a real finding and implementers are tempted to exclude its unmarked file. | Require 114 selected files. The only allowed drop is `broken/netscript.config.ts`; tests pin all four healthy files as selected. The one fmt finding is a legitimate blocker requiring the separately authorized formatting fix, never another exclusion. | +| Module-root arithmetic is off by one directory. | Derive from each file URL, assert/read known repo files, and run from `packages/cli` cwd first. | +| Fixing only doc reads leaves `.llm/tmp` cwd-sensitive. | Anchor both authoritative doc and run-owned scratch paths in the helper; cleanup remains scoped to the created temp directory. | +| Boundary test still passes under one-sided policy drift. | Separate observable inside/outside ordering plus explicit widen/narrow mutation controls. | +| Floating-point equality makes the inside case ambiguous. | Use exactly representable test values/differences where possible and a deliberately larger outside epsilon; assert order, not raw floating equality. | +| Publish audit expands into known CLI debt. | Record baseline debt and require no new diagnostics; do not edit public CLI files or claim debt closure. | +| Waived expensive gate is accidentally run or reported `NOT_RUN`. | Record `scaffold.runtime` as coordinator-waived `n/a`; do not request a lease or invoke Aspire, Docker, or `e2e:cli`. | +| Validation churns locks/caches. | Never reload/delete; inspect exact Git status and lock blob before accepting any receipt. | ## Arch-debt implications - No new entry expected. - Do not close or modify existing CLI/MCP/E2E debt entries. -- Any newly discovered doctrine or JSR finding that cannot be fixed inside the six-file surface is - `FAIL_DEBT`/rescope, not an implicit waiver. +- Any newly discovered doctrine or JSR finding that cannot be fixed inside the eleven-path surface + is `FAIL_DEBT`/rescope, not an implicit waiver. ## Explicit deferrals / non-scope - No implementation in this turn; no evaluator launch by this thread. -- No full CLI/E2E/runtime execution without the coordinator mutex. -- No docs prose change, fixture repair, wrapper change, CI workflow change, dependency/version - update, public export change, score-algorithm change, or package reshape. +- No Aspire, Docker, `e2e:cli`, `scaffold.runtime`, or other runtime smoke; the expensive gate is + coordinator-waived `n/a`, not pending. +- No docs prose change, malformed-fixture repair, other wrapper change, CI workflow change, + dependency/version update, public export change, score-algorithm change, or package reshape. +- No edit to `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` until the coordinator + grants the pending twelfth-path rescope; its exact scratch patch and green 114-file proof are + recorded in `worklog.md`. - No merge, publish, ready flip, issue checkbox mutation, acceptance-evidence block, or phase relabel. - No `deno.lock`, cache, generated asset, or receipt implementation change. @@ -192,7 +207,7 @@ already produces them. A receipt proves only its command. Before and after every **Required.** This is one PR but not a ceremonial three-line plan: it spans the A6 CLI harness and an A2 publishable MCP member, a root Deno config boundary, executable docs, JSR audits for two -members, bidirectional mutation controls, and a serialized global consumer gate. A wrong exclusion -or path decision can create another false green, and the coordinator explicitly retains plan-gate +members, bidirectional mutation controls, and marker-aware optimized tooling. A wrong exclusion or +path decision can create another false green, and the coordinator explicitly retains plan-gate authority. The topic supervisor must launch a fresh native opposite-family Fable 5 medium evaluator; this thread stops after publishing the plan and must not create a self-authored verdict. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md index d3418f5efb..7ca28253d1 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md @@ -21,21 +21,23 @@ ## Findings -| # | Finding | `file:line` / command evidence | -| --- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| R1 | `packages/cli` defines its canonical package test as `deno test --allow-all`, so `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` deliberately runs every nested CLI/E2E unit with `packages/cli` as process cwd. | `packages/cli/deno.json:14-22`. | -| R2 | Exactly three tests fail under that cwd. The structured targeted reproduction selected only the three named test files and returned `passed: 3`, `failed: 3`: the documented-stream test cannot read `docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md`; quickstart drift cannot read `docs/site/quickstart.vto`; the service-env script-existence test cannot stat `packages/cli/e2e/.../configure-service-env.ts`. | `run-deno-test.ts --cwd packages/cli -- --allow-all `; test locations below. | -| R3 | The service-env failure is not the subprocess probe. The gate registry intentionally stores `GATE_DIR` relative to repository root and returns a relative script argument for the fixture gate, while the test calls `Deno.stat(script)` directly. The same test already derives `REPO_ROOT` from `import.meta` and uses it for subprocess cwd, so the honest fix is to resolve the asserted command path against that root without changing the production gate command. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates.ts:26-27,46-64`; `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:31-34,96-102,124-143`. | -| R4 | The quickstart drift test directly reads a repo-root-relative string. Its assertion compares every marked shell line with `QUICKSTART_DOCUMENTED_COMMANDS`; only path acquisition is defective. | `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:4-15`. | -| R5 | The documented-stream test calls a helper whose `DOC_PATH` and `.llm/tmp` paths are process-cwd-relative. The failing read is `DOC_PATH`; the helper then extracts and actually imports the published example. Anchoring repository-owned source/scratch paths to a module-derived repo root retains the semantic runtime assertion. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15,21-30,33-39`; `run-documented-stream-example_test.ts:4-35`. | -| R6 | The malformed MCP fixture is deliberate and exactly malformed as reported: `workspace` is a string, while Deno expects an array/object workspace config. The doctor test reads the fixture by module-derived absolute path and asserts `deno_workspace: fail`; changing the fixture would destroy the test. | `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json:1`; `packages/mcp/tests/doctor-families_test.ts:10-33`; `project-wiring-doctor-family.ts:78-87`. | -| R7 | The exact formatter reproduction selects 115 TS/TSX files, exits 1, reports one failed batch and zero findings, then identifies a config-parse crash. Wrapper-level `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'` selects 110 files and exits 0. Passing explicit `--config deno.json` selects all 115 and exits 0 because it disables nested auto-discovery. | Research commands recorded in this session; wrapper filtering and explicit-config support are at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:67-87,103-201,255-301,312-331`; crash refusal at `:370-415,439-488`. | -| R8 | The supported in-repo solution that keeps the issue's exact no-extra-flag command is Deno's root configuration exclusion. Root `exclude` is the cross-tool mechanism for a directory Deno should never discover as real configuration; `fmt.exclude`/CLI `--ignore` are formatter-only mechanisms. This plan uses the narrow cross-tool root exclusion for the deliberately invalid fixture tree; the doctor test's explicit runtime read is unaffected. | Root `exclude` currently contains only `.llm/tmp/` at `deno.json:10-12`; official Deno config reference: `https://docs.deno.com/runtime/reference/deno_json/#exclude`; formatter-specific alternative: `https://docs.deno.com/runtime/reference/cli/fmt/#including-and-excluding-files`. | -| R9 | Root `fmt:check` already excludes the doctor fixture at the wrapper-selection layer, which is why only editing that task would not fix the acceptance command and would leave the false-green blind spot. | `deno.json:139-148` versus the exact issue command with no `--exclude`. | -| R10 | `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap` is a typed exported internal-module policy value of `0.5`. `orderGuidanceSections` first sorts by route/score/identity, then groups candidates whose score is at most that value below the group leader, and reorders each close group by slug. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:20-44,181-211`. | -| R11 | The only close-score unit uses a 10.4 leader and 9.8 `outside-leader-band`, but that candidate's `pages/gamma` slug already sorts last. Widening the band therefore does not alter the asserted order. No just-inside control exists either, so narrowing is also unpinned. | `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`; live #1622 mutation evidence reports `0.5 -> 5` remained green. | -| R12 | The empirical rationale can be made exact without inventing score-scale meaning: the observed pair's gap is about `0.3019801981861221`; `0.5` leaves `0.1980198018138779` headroom, about 2.6 times the observed regeneration movement `0.0748587451731435`. | Live #1622 body; policy definition `guidance-index.ts:33-44`. | -| R13 | The full repository has no other deliberately malformed `workspace: "packages/*"` fixture. The healthy MCP sibling correctly uses an array. | `rg` over `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, `.llm/tools/**`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1`. | +| # | Finding | `file:line` / command evidence | +| --- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| R1 | `packages/cli` defines its canonical package test as `deno test --allow-all`, so `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` deliberately runs every nested CLI/E2E unit with `packages/cli` as process cwd. | `packages/cli/deno.json:14-22`. | +| R2 | Exactly three tests fail under that cwd. The structured targeted reproduction selected only the three named test files and returned `passed: 3`, `failed: 3`: the documented-stream test cannot read `docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md`; quickstart drift cannot read `docs/site/quickstart.vto`; the service-env script-existence test cannot stat `packages/cli/e2e/.../configure-service-env.ts`. | `run-deno-test.ts --cwd packages/cli -- --allow-all `; test locations below. | +| R3 | The service-env failure is not the subprocess probe. The gate registry intentionally stores `GATE_DIR` relative to repository root and returns a relative script argument for the fixture gate, while the test calls `Deno.stat(script)` directly. The same test already derives `REPO_ROOT` from `import.meta` and uses it for subprocess cwd, so the honest fix is to resolve the asserted command path against that root without changing the production gate command. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates.ts:26-27,46-64`; `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:31-34,96-102,124-143`. | +| R4 | The quickstart drift test directly reads a repo-root-relative string. Its assertion compares every marked shell line with `QUICKSTART_DOCUMENTED_COMMANDS`; only path acquisition is defective. | `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:4-15`. | +| R5 | The documented-stream test calls a helper whose `DOC_PATH` and `.llm/tmp` paths are process-cwd-relative. The failing read is `DOC_PATH`; the helper then extracts and actually imports the published example. Anchoring repository-owned source/scratch paths to a module-derived repo root retains the semantic runtime assertion. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15,21-30,33-39`; `run-documented-stream-example_test.ts:4-35`. | +| R6 | The malformed MCP fixture is deliberate and exactly malformed as reported: `workspace` is a string, while Deno expects an array/object workspace config. The doctor test reads the fixture by module-derived absolute path and asserts `deno_workspace: fail`; changing the fixture would destroy the test. | `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json:1`; `packages/mcp/tests/doctor-families_test.ts:10-33`; `project-wiring-doctor-family.ts:78-87`. | +| R7 | The exact formatter reproduction selects 115 TS/TSX files, exits 1, reports one failed batch and zero findings, then identifies a config-parse crash. Wrapper-level `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'` selects 110 files and exits 0. Passing explicit `--config deno.json` selects all 115 and exits 0 because it disables nested auto-discovery. | Research commands recorded in this session; wrapper filtering and explicit-config support are at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:67-87,103-201,255-301,312-331`; crash refusal at `:370-415,439-488`. | +| R8 | **Falsified by execution:** root `exclude` is a real directory-walk boundary, but it does not satisfy the acceptance command. Both optimized wrappers perform their own selection and pass explicit files; Deno then resolves the nearest config for each named file. Root exclusion remains defensible only as non-load-bearing protection for native directory walks. | Evaluator proof in `plan-eval.md` §1; fmt selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:263-301,312-331`; lint selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts:268-306,329-335`; baseline exact commands in `worklog.md`. | +| R9 | Root `fmt:check` already excludes the doctor fixture at the wrapper-selection layer, which is why only editing that task would not fix the acceptance command and would leave the false-green blind spot. | `deno.json:139-148` versus the exact issue command with no `--exclude`. | +| R10 | `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap` is a typed exported internal-module policy value of `0.5`. `orderGuidanceSections` first sorts by route/score/identity, then groups candidates whose score is at most that value below the group leader, and reorders each close group by slug. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:20-44,181-211`. | +| R11 | The only close-score unit uses a 10.4 leader and 9.8 `outside-leader-band`, but that candidate's `pages/gamma` slug already sorts last. Widening the band therefore does not alter the asserted order. No just-inside control exists either, so narrowing is also unpinned. | `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`; live #1622 mutation evidence reports `0.5 -> 5` remained green. | +| R12 | The empirical rationale can be made exact without inventing score-scale meaning: the observed pair's gap is about `0.3019801981861221`; `0.5` leaves `0.1980198018138779` headroom, about 2.6 times the observed regeneration movement `0.0748587451731435`. | Live #1622 body; policy definition `guidance-index.ts:33-44`. | +| R13 | The full repository has no other deliberately malformed `workspace: "packages/*"` fixture. The healthy MCP sibling correctly uses an array. | `rg` over `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, `.llm/tools/**`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1`. | +| R14 | Child-only marker scope plus nearest-config batching correctly selects 114 files and isolates the malformed config crash. Lint is green. Fmt then reports exactly one real finding on `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`. There is no style conflict: `healthy/deno.json` has a valid workspace and no fmt options; the source is simply unformatted (one-line object and single quotes). Three of the four healthy TS files already format cleanly. | Executed `git archive HEAD` prototype recorded in `worklog.md`; healthy config/source at `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1` and `netscript.config.ts:1`. | +| R15 | Parent-family skip is rejected: it selected 110 by silently removing the one marked broken file and all four unmarked healthy files. The honest mechanism is `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` on its own `broken/` subtree plus grouping selected files by effective nearest config. Exact lint is green at 114; exact fmt is an honest red with the one finding above. A scratch-only format of that one healthy file makes exact fmt green at 114, lint green, and doctor 4/4, proving the pending twelfth-path request without exercising it in checkout. | Executed archive matrices and proposed one-file diff in `worklog.md`; no checkout product/config file was edited. | ## jsr-audit surface scan @@ -83,5 +85,5 @@ not a waiver for a new finding. ## Open questions -- None that may change implementation shape. Coordinator ownership of the serialized - `scaffold.runtime` mutex is an execution precondition, not an open design decision. +- None that may change implementation shape. `scaffold.runtime` is explicitly coordinator-waived + `n/a`; no mutex or execution lane is pending. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md index 00e6c5d7a9..699b212709 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md @@ -17,7 +17,11 @@ - `@netscript/cli` changes remain under publish-excluded `e2e/`. - `@netscript/mcp` keeps `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY` internal to its source graph; only the rationale comment and test change. -- Root Deno configuration gains one narrow exclusion for a deliberately invalid test fixture. +- Root Deno configuration may carry the doctor-family exclusion only as non-load-bearing protection + for native directory walks. +- The optimized fmt/lint wrappers gain two shared conventions: a marker excludes only its own + subtree, and selected files are grouped by effective nearest Deno config before explicit argv is + built. ### Domain vocabulary @@ -43,51 +47,63 @@ ### Commit slices -| # | Slice | Gate | Exact files | -| -- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | -| S1 | Exclude deliberately invalid config from Deno discovery while retaining doctor failure semantics. | Exact MCP fmt clean + real-formatting negative control + doctor test. | `deno.json` | -| S2 | Make all three CLI tests package-cwd independent without weakening assertions. | Structured targeted 6/6 + exact package task + docs gates; final runtime consumer in S4. | Three exact CLI files in `plan.md` | -| S3 | Pin close-score policy on both sides and record rationale. | Targeted test + widen/narrow RED controls + scoped MCP/quality gates. | `guidance-index.ts`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | -| S4 | Integrated evidence and serialized consumer gate. | Frozen full gate set + coordinator-granted `scaffold.runtime`. | Run artifacts/evidence only | +| # | Slice | Gate | Exact files | +| -- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | +| S1 | Make optimized MCP fmt/lint selection marker- and config-aware while retaining every unmarked sibling. | 114-file selection + honest single fmt blocker + green lint + marked/unmarked tests + negative controls + doctor test. | Six exact S1 paths in `plan.md` | +| S2 | Make all three CLI tests package-cwd independent without weakening assertions. | Structured targeted 6/6 + exact package task + docs gates; final runtime consumer in S4. | Three exact CLI files in `plan.md` | +| S3 | Pin close-score policy on both sides and record rationale. | Targeted test + widen/narrow RED controls + scoped MCP/quality gates. | `guidance-index.ts`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | +| S4 | Integrated evidence for the applicable frozen gate set. | Static/test/docs/publish/JSR gates; `scaffold.runtime` recorded coordinator-waived `n/a`. | Run artifacts/evidence only | ### Deferred scope -- Any seventh product/config path, wrapper/CI change, docs edit, fixture repair, public API change, - dependency update, or algorithm change. -- `scaffold.runtime` execution until coordinator mutex grant. +- Any twelfth product/config path, other wrapper/CI change, docs edit, malformed-fixture repair, + public API change, dependency update, or algorithm change. +- `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` until the coordinator grants the + pending twelfth-path rescope; its formatting-only patch is proved in scratch. +- `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, and `e2e:cli`; the gate is waived `n/a`, not pending. - All implementation until separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. ### Contributor path -To extend these guards, keep repository-owned paths module-relative; declare deliberately invalid -fixtures in the root exclusion and pair them with explicit tests; for tuned ordering boundaries add -one candidate on each side whose identity order conflicts with score order. Then prove both green -behavior and a controlled red mutation through structured gates. +To extend these guards, keep repository-owned paths module-relative; mark only the deliberately +invalid subtree, group explicit argv by nearest config, and pair marked/unmarked selection tests; +for tuned ordering boundaries add one candidate on each side whose identity order conflicts with +score order. Then prove both green behavior and a controlled red mutation through structured gates. ## Progress log -| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | -| ---------- | --------- | ---------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| 2026-08-15 | bootstrap | activated | Exact worktree/branch/base verified; coordinator thread record preserved; commit `25c29575c`; draft PR #1663 opened. | -| 2026-08-15 | research | live issue/source read | All three issues fetched live; exact three-test reproduction returned 3 pass / 3 fail from package cwd. | -| 2026-08-15 | research | fmt controls | Baseline exact command: 115 selected, config crash; wrapper exclude: 110 selected/green; explicit root config: 115 selected/green. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan | Design checkpoint | Six-file authoritative surface locked; formal PLAN-EVAL selected; implementation remains prohibited. | +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| ---------- | --------- | -------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| 2026-08-15 | bootstrap | activated | Exact worktree/branch/base verified; coordinator thread record preserved; commit `25c29575c`; draft PR #1663 opened. | +| 2026-08-15 | research | live issue/source read | All three issues fetched live; exact three-test reproduction returned 3 pass / 3 fail from package cwd. | +| 2026-08-15 | research | fmt controls | Baseline exact command: 115 selected, config crash; wrapper exclude: 110 selected/green; explicit root config: 115 selected/green. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | Design checkpoint | Six-file authoritative surface locked; formal PLAN-EVAL selected; implementation remains prohibited. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan-eval | cycle 1 | `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit `be2b18728`: root `exclude` cannot affect explicit wrapper argv; no product/config implementation occurred. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | coordinator rescope | Authority expanded to eleven exact paths: fmt/lint wrappers + tests and one marker; `scaffold.runtime` waived `n/a`. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | rejected proof draft | Parent-family marker made both wrappers green at 110 by excluding four unmarked healthy files; coordinator rejected it before push as a silent false-positive exclusion. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | corrected mechanism proof | Child-only marker + nearest-config batching selects 114: lint green, fmt one honest healthy-fixture finding, doctor 4/4, negative controls red, restorations byte-exact. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | twelfth-path scratch proof | Formatting only `healthy/netscript.config.ts` makes exact fmt green at 114; lint and doctor remain green. Checkout path untouched pending grant. | ## Decisions -| Decision | Reason | Source | -| -------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | -| Root exclusion, not fixture repair or wrapper edit | Exact acceptance command must work and frozen surface excludes `.llm/tools`. | plan L3/L4; Deno config docs | -| Module-derived paths | Package cwd is the defect; module location is stable. | plan L1/L2 | -| Bidirectional score controls | Current identity ordering masks both threshold directions. | research R10-R12; plan L5/L6 | -| Formal PLAN-EVAL | Multi-member/config/docs/JSR/runtime interactions are decision-heavy. | run-loop §4; plan judgement | +| Decision | Reason | Source | +| ------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | +| Child-only marker + nearest-config batching | Only the marked broken subtree may leave selection; grouping prevents config poisoning while keeping all four healthy files visible. | plan L3/L4; corrected pre-plan proof | +| Module-derived paths | Package cwd is the defect; module location is stable. | plan L1/L2 | +| Bidirectional score controls | Current identity ordering masks both threshold directions. | research R10-R12; plan L5/L6 | +| Formal PLAN-EVAL | Multi-member/config/docs/JSR/runtime interactions are decision-heavy. | run-loop §4; plan judgement | ## Drift -| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | -| ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------- | ------------------ | -| Launcher preseeded exact thread record before clean check. | minor | yes | -| Root task already had a wrapper-level fixture exclude, but standalone acceptance command remains red. | minor research clarification | yes | +| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | ------------------ | +| Launcher preseeded exact thread record before clean check. | minor | yes | +| Root task already had a wrapper-level fixture exclude, but standalone acceptance command remains red. | minor research clarification | yes | +| R8 root-exclusion conclusion was falsified by evaluator execution. | significant | yes | +| Child-only marker proof selected 114 but left fmt red on the healthy nested config. | significant design finding | yes | +| Coordinator expanded the edit surface from six to eleven paths and waived `scaffold.runtime`. | significant authorized rescope | yes | +| Parent-family 110-file draft silently removed four unmarked healthy files and was rejected before push. | significant plan correction | yes | +| One genuine healthy-fixture fmt finding remains; its twelfth-path repair is proved but unauthorized. | significant pending rescope | yes | ## Gate results @@ -100,6 +116,48 @@ behavior and a controlled red mutation through structured gates. | Scoped MCP fmt with wrapper `--exclude` | PASS diagnostic | 110 selected; no failures/findings. Not the acceptance command. | | Scoped MCP fmt with explicit root `--config` | PASS diagnostic | 115 selected; no failures/findings. Informs config-discovery cause. | +### Executed pre-plan marker proof (archive copy, not checkout) + +The corrected prototype lives under `.llm/tmp/package-gate-honesty-plan-proof.xd8Msn/`, extracted +from `git archive HEAD` at evaluator head `be2b1872823cbbb07a393633fcccb684f753afc1` before scratch +edits. Commands were unpiped; exit status below is the direct child process status. The prototype +uses `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` inside `doctor/broken/` to skip only that directory, then groups the +114 remaining files by effective nearest Deno config before batching. + +| Proof | Exact command / mutation | Raw exit | Selection / failed batches | Verdict | +| ------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Baseline fmt | `deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/mcp --ext ts,tsx` in checkout | 1 | 115 selected; 1 failed batch; 0 findings | RED config-parse crash | +| Baseline lint | equivalent `run-deno-lint.ts` command in checkout | 1 | 115 selected; 1 crash batch (`failures.length`; lint currently has no named `failedBatches` JSON key) | RED config-parse crash | +| Corrected fmt | exact fmt command, no `--exclude`/`--config` | 1 | 114 selected; 2 config batches; 1 failed batch; exactly 1 finding | Honest RED naming only `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` | +| Corrected lint | exact lint command, no `--exclude`/`--config` | 0 | 114 selected; 2 config batches; 0 crash/failed batches; 0 occurrences | GREEN, non-empty | +| Doctor semantics | structured `doctor-families_test.ts` | 0 | 4 passed / 0 failed | GREEN; marker file does not perturb asserted directory behavior | +| Fmt negative | append unformatted export to real `packages/mcp/mod.ts`, exact fmt command | 1 | 114 selected; 2 failed batches; 2 findings: deliberate `mod.ts` defect plus known healthy fixture | RED with the real deliberate formatting finding still visible | +| Lint negative | append unused binding to real `packages/mcp/cli.ts`, exact lint command | 1 | 114 selected; one `no-unused-vars` occurrence naming `packages/mcp/cli.ts`; no crash batch | RED for a real lint violation | +| Restoration | archive-restore then `cmp`/SHA-256 | 0 | `mod.ts` hash `8a76331e…c86d841`; `cli.ts` hash `1964acf7…03b87b` match checkout | Byte-exact restore asserted | +| Malformed fixture | SHA-256/cmp against checkout | 0 | both `deno.json` hashes `6815999d…37361` | Deliberately malformed fixture remains byte-identical | +| Proposed twelfth path (scratch only) | `deno fmt packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`, then both exact wrappers | 0 | fmt: 114 selected / 2 batches / `failedBatches: 0`; lint: 114 / 2 / 0 occurrences | Final fmt and lint GREEN; doctor rerun 4/4 GREEN | + +Collateral is exact: 115→114 for both wrappers. The only file removed from automatic selection is +`packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/netscript.config.ts`. All four unmarked healthy TS files +remain selected, as do the unrelated export-surface and telemetry fixture TS files. Planned wrapper +tests independently create a marked subtree and an equivalent unmarked sibling; count/path +assertions require child-only skip, unmarked-sibling selection, and separate nearest-config batches +in both tools. + +The remaining fmt finding is not a config-style conflict. `healthy/deno.json` contains a valid +workspace and no fmt options. Three healthy TS files already pass; `healthy/netscript.config.ts` is +simply unformatted. The scratch-only proposed change is exactly: + +```diff +-const config: { readonly plugins: readonly string[] } = { plugins: ['workers'] }; ++const config: { readonly plugins: readonly string[] } = { ++ plugins: ["workers"], ++}; + export default config; +``` + +That checkout path is a twelfth path and remains untouched pending coordinator grant. + ### Static gates | Gate | Command or check | Result | Notes | @@ -108,16 +166,16 @@ behavior and a controlled red mutation through structured gates. ### Fitness gates -| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| ---------------- | --------------------- | ------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Plan-Gate | NOT_RUN | No evaluator artifact/comment exists. | Required; topic supervisor launches separate evaluator. | -| JSR surface scan | PASS (planning input) | `research.md` JSR section | No public delta; both members still receive full planned audits. | +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ---------------- | --------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Plan-Gate | cycle 1 `FAIL_PLAN` | `plan-eval.md` at evaluator commit `be2b18728` | Plan repaired for required separate-session cycle 2; implementation remains blocked. | +| JSR surface scan | PASS (planning input) | `research.md` JSR section | No public delta; both members still receive full planned audits. | ### Runtime gates -| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| ------------------ | ------- | ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | -| `scaffold.runtime` | NOT_RUN | Mutex not requested/granted. | Correct state; this thread may not run it. | +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ------------------ | ------ | -------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------- | +| `scaffold.runtime` | N/A | Coordinator waiver after gate-matrix review. | Must not run; no lease will be granted. | ### Consumer gates @@ -127,7 +185,8 @@ behavior and a controlled red mutation through structured gates. ## Handoff notes -- PLAN-EVAL should inspect L3 root-exclusion semantics, the exact six-file bound, the two-direction - score controls, and the honest treatment of existing CLI JSR debt. -- No implementation authority exists. The topic supervisor owns evaluator launch and the future - `scaffold.runtime` mutex. +- Tier-A must first dispose the pending twelfth-path request. PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 should then inspect + L3's child-only marker plus nearest-config batching, the marked/unmarked sibling guard, the + two-direction score controls, and the honest treatment of existing CLI JSR debt. +- No implementation authority exists. The topic supervisor owns the rescope decision and future + cycle-2 evaluator launch; `scaffold.runtime` is waived and must not run. From df1d7a96d7fd4ecca0bd61710ba90ff67449da0b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 13:19:43 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 5/7] docs(harness): grant honest fixture normalization path --- .../package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md | 55 +++++----- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md | 17 +++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md | 68 ++++++------ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md | 34 +++--- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md | 103 ++++++++++-------- 5 files changed, 155 insertions(+), 122 deletions(-) diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md index e8c0432a62..50d0901d77 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md @@ -6,18 +6,18 @@ | -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | | Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | -| Current phase | repaired plan; hard stop pending twelfth-path decision, then cycle 2 | +| Current phase | twelve-path plan repaired; hard stop pending Tier-A/cycle 2 PASS | | Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` (supporting MCP member A2) | | Scope overlays | `docs` | ## Current state PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 correctly returned `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit `be2b18728`: root exclusion -cannot affect the optimized wrappers' explicit argv. The coordinator granted an eleven-path rescope -for child-only marker semantics plus nearest-config batching in both wrappers, and waived -`scaffold.runtime` as `n/a`. The corrected proof selects 114: lint is green and fmt honestly reports -one unformatted healthy fixture file. Its scratch-only repair is proved but awaits a twelfth-path -grant. No checkout product/config implementation exists. +cannot affect the optimized wrappers' explicit argv. The coordinator granted child-only marker +semantics plus nearest-config batching in both wrappers, then granted the exact formatting-only +twelfth path exposed by the honest 114-file finding. Both exact no-extra-flag prototypes are now +green at 114; all four healthy files remain selected, parsed meaning is equal, doctor is 4/4, and +the malformed hash is unchanged. No checkout product/config implementation exists. ## Completed @@ -27,35 +27,35 @@ grant. No checkout product/config implementation exists. - All three issues re-read live. - Three cwd failures and MCP fmt config crash reproduced through structured wrappers. - `closeScoreGap` definition, consumption, and decorative test behavior traced. -- Eleven-path repaired plan and per-member JSR audit plan locked. +- Twelve-path repaired plan and per-member JSR audit plan locked; no thirteenth path. - Exact no-extra-flag lint prototype green at 114; fmt reports exactly one genuine healthy-fixture finding at 114; separate fmt/lint negative controls red with real findings; doctor 4/4; all negative-control source files restored byte-exactly. -- Scratch-only formatting of the pending twelfth path makes exact fmt green at 114 while lint and - doctor remain green. +- Scratch-only formatting of the granted twelfth path makes exact fmt green at 114 while lint and + doctor remain green; original/formatted exports are equal. +- All four healthy TS files were individually named selected by genuine or controlled fmt findings, + and every controlled probe was restored byte-exactly. ## In progress -- Awaiting topic-supervisor disposition of the twelfth-path request, then Tier-A review and - separate-session PLAN-EVAL cycle 2. +- Awaiting fresh Tier-A review and separate-session PLAN-EVAL cycle 2. ## Next steps -1. Coordinator grants or rejects the proved - `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` twelfth path. -2. Topic supervisor reviews the resulting reachable plan and launches PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 in a fresh +1. Topic supervisor reviews the reachable twelve-path plan and launches PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 in a fresh separate evaluator session. -3. If and only if verdict is `PASS`, coordinator grants implementation authority. -4. Future implementation follows S1-S4; `scaffold.runtime` remains waived `n/a` and must not run. +2. If and only if Tier-A and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 both return `PASS`, coordinator grants implementation + authority. +3. Future implementation follows S1-S4; `scaffold.runtime` remains waived `n/a` and must not run. ## Key decisions -| Decision | Source | Notes | -| -------------------------------------------- | -------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Child marker + config batching owns boundary | plan L3/L4 | Both select 114; lint green; fmt exposes one real pending-path finding. | -| Module-derived CLI paths | plan L1/L2 | No ambient cwd and no weakened assertion. | -| `0.5` pinned both directions | plan L5/L6 | Inside/outside identity conflict makes movement observable. | -| Formal PLAN-EVAL required | plan judgement | This thread cannot self-launch or self-certify. | +| Decision | Source | Notes | +| -------------------------------------------- | -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Child marker + config batching owns boundary | plan L3/L4 | Both green at 114 after granted formatting-only normalization. | +| Module-derived CLI paths | plan L1/L2 | No ambient cwd and no weakened assertion. | +| `0.5` pinned both directions | plan L5/L6 | Inside/outside identity conflict makes movement observable. | +| Formal PLAN-EVAL required | plan judgement | This thread cannot self-launch or self-certify. | ## Authoritative product/config edit surface @@ -70,9 +70,10 @@ grant. No checkout product/config implementation exists. 9. `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` 10. `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts` 11. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` +12. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` Everything else in the frozen outer bound is read-only, especially both docs sources and the broken -fixture config. A twelfth path is rescope. +fixture config. A thirteenth path is rescope. ## Gates @@ -86,13 +87,13 @@ fixture config. A twelfth path is rescope. ## Open questions -- Twelfth-path authority for the proved healthy-fixture formatting repair; implementation authority - then still depends on cycle-2 `PASS`. +- None that change implementation shape; implementation authority still depends on fresh Tier-A and + cycle-2 `PASS`. ## Drift and debt -- Drift: R8 falsified by execution; authorized eleven-path rescope; rejected parent-family false - exclusion; corrected 114-file proof exposes one pending twelfth path. +- Drift: R8 falsified by execution; rejected parent-family false exclusion; corrected 114-file + proof; authorized formatting-only twelfth path. - Debt: no new/closed entry; named CLI/MCP baseline debt remains unchanged. ## Commits diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md index d564967847..041d5a52cb 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md @@ -103,3 +103,20 @@ documentation. - **Action:** prepare proof only; do not touch the checkout path until the coordinator grants it as a twelfth path. Implementation and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 remain blocked. - **Evidence:** Proposed one-file diff and fmt/lint/doctor results in `worklog.md`. + +## 2026-08-15 — Coordinator granted formatting-only twelfth path + +- **What:** The coordinator added `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` + to the planned implementation surface, bringing the bound to twelve paths. +- **Source:** Topic-supervisor grant after review of plan head `ccf256884` and the honest R14/R15 + scratch proof. +- **Expected:** The real 114-file fmt finding must be fixed without hiding any unmarked file. +- **Actual:** Deno formatting alone expands the object and normalizes quotes. Original and formatted + modules both export `{"plugins":["workers"]}`; both exact wrappers are green at 114, doctor is + 4/4, and the malformed config hash remains + `6815999dbd68bd1ab5bb137b59808cb1f1a38fb3393c9133721f439c0ad37361`. +- **Severity:** significant authorized rescope +- **Action:** accept in the plan only. Do not mutate the checkout path before fresh Tier-A and + PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`; no thirteenth path exists. +- **Evidence:** Final green matrix, four individually named healthy selection probes, semantic + equality, and byte-restoration evidence in `worklog.md`. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md index 07c58c1d0e..61a2b05035 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md @@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ boundary and does not reshape it. - `packages/mcp`: **Keep** — keep MCP transports behind token-bounded tool contracts (`:42`). - Relevant open accepted debt is baseline only: CLI public doc completeness; MCP horizontal-shape classification; MCP tool-contract file size; CLI E2E scaffold directory cardinality. None is - closed or deepened by these eleven edits. + closed or deepened by these twelve edits. ## Axioms in play @@ -59,8 +59,9 @@ directory are updated alongside every future slice but are not product scope. | `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` | Apply the same child-only marker and nearest-config batching semantics to lint so the optimized tool family cannot diverge. | | `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts` | Prove marked-skip and unmarked-selection behavior for lint, retaining real lint-finding and empty-selection refusals. | | `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` | Declare only the deliberately invalid `broken/` subtree excluded from automatic fmt/lint selection; the unmarked `healthy/` sibling remains selected. | +| `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` | Formatting-only normalization of the one real finding exposed by honest 114-file selection; preserve the parsed plugin value and valid-project doctor behavior exactly. | -These eleven paths are coordinator-authorized. Adding a twelfth path is rescope and requires +These twelve paths are coordinator-authorized. Adding a thirteenth path is rescope and requires coordinator approval before editing. ## Frozen contract entries deliberately not touched @@ -101,34 +102,34 @@ coordinator approval before editing. | L7 | No new package public export, dependency, port, runtime asset, or runtime read; wrapper behavior changes only at selection. | The work is regression hardening, not API or architecture change. | | L8 | Evidence commands fire through structured wrappers/`run-gate.ts`; empty selection, crash, NOT_RUN, or a waived gate reported as green is not PASS. | This leaf exists to eliminate false verdicts. | | L9 | Do not run `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, `e2e:cli`, or any runtime smoke for this leaf. | The matrix classes the expensive gate `n/a` and the coordinator explicitly waived it; no lease will be granted. | -| L10 | Do not edit `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` without a twelfth-path grant. | Scratch proof shows formatting this one real file is the only remaining fmt blocker at 114, but it is outside the current authority. | +| L10 | Normalize `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` with Deno formatting only; no value, schema, or behavioral change is permitted. | Coordinator granted the twelfth path because the 114-file gate correctly exposed one genuinely unformatted real file. Scratch imports produce identical `{ "plugins": ["workers"] }`; fmt/lint are green and doctor remains 4/4. | ## Open-decision sweep -| Decision | Status | Notes | -| -------------------------------- | --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Invalid-fixture boundary | resolved now | Child-only marker plus nearest-config batching in both wrappers; root `exclude` is non-load-bearing only. | -| Test path mechanism | resolved now | L1/L2; module-derived roots only. | -| Close-score boundary data | resolved now | L5/L6; both directions observable and rationale exact. | -| Public API/export changes | resolved now | None permitted. | -| `scaffold.runtime` applicability | resolved now | Gate-matrix `n/a`; coordinator waiver recorded; it must not run. | -| Healthy fixture formatting | pending rescope | One-file scratch patch proves final fmt green at 114, but the twelfth path awaits coordinator authority. | +| Decision | Status | Notes | +| -------------------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Invalid-fixture boundary | resolved now | Child-only marker plus nearest-config batching in both wrappers; root `exclude` is non-load-bearing only. | +| Test path mechanism | resolved now | L1/L2; module-derived roots only. | +| Close-score boundary data | resolved now | L5/L6; both directions observable and rationale exact. | +| Public API/export changes | resolved now | None permitted. | +| `scaffold.runtime` applicability | resolved now | Gate-matrix `n/a`; coordinator waiver recorded; it must not run. | +| Healthy fixture formatting | resolved now | Coordinator granted the exact formatting-only twelfth path after the scratch proof; no semantic/config-value delta is allowed. | -The mechanism is locked. The only unresolved scope decision is whether the coordinator grants the -proved twelfth-path formatting repair; implementation and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 remain blocked until the -authoritative surface can express a reachable green fmt acceptance state. +No unresolved decision would cause implementation rework. The twelve-path plan has an executed, +reachable green acceptance state; implementation remains prohibited until fresh Tier-A approval and +separate-session PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`. ## Ordered implementation slices Every slice also updates `worklog.md` and `context-pack.md`, then is committed, pushed, and commented before the next slice. No implementation begins before separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. -| # | What it proves | Exact product/config files | Proving gates | -| -- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| S1 | MCP fmt/lint isolate deliberately invalid config without removing the unmarked healthy sibling from verification. | `deno.json`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` | Wrapper tests prove child-only marked skip, unmarked-sibling selection, and nearest-config batching. Exact lint returns raw exit 0 at 114 selected files; exact fmt must select 114 and initially report exactly one real finding on `healthy/netscript.config.ts`, never a crash. Doctor stays 4/4; malformed config hash unchanged; separate real fmt/lint defects are detected and restored byte-exactly. Final fmt exit 0 is blocked on the pending twelfth-path grant, whose scratch patch is already proved. | -| S2 | The canonical package-cwd CLI task no longer has three root-relative `NotFound` failures and no assertion is weakened. | The three exact CLI files listed above | Structured targeted three-file test first (6/6), then exact `deno task --cwd packages/cli test`; scoped check/lint/fmt on the three owned TS files; docs-source-format and docs-accuracy. The helper's focused semantic unit test is the final consumer proof; the matrix-waived runtime gate is not substituted or run. | -| S3 | `closeScoreGap` is pinned from both sides and its empirical rationale ships with the policy. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Structured targeted guidance test; controlled `0.5 -> 5` and `0.5 -> below-inside-gap` mutations each raw non-zero, followed by exact restoration and green rerun; MCP scoped check/test/lint/fmt; quality gate. | -| S4 | The integrated head meets the applicable frozen proving contract and publish/docs claims are honest. | No new product/config files; run artifacts/evidence only | Commit-bound `check`, `test`, `publish-dry-run`, `quality-job`, docs-source-format, docs-accuracy, and per-member JSR suite. `scaffold.runtime` is recorded `n/a` by coordinator waiver and is not executed. | +| # | What it proves | Exact product/config files | Proving gates | +| -- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| S1 | MCP fmt/lint isolate deliberately invalid config without removing the unmarked healthy sibling from verification. | `deno.json`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` | Wrapper tests prove child-only marked skip, unmarked-sibling selection, and nearest-config batching. After formatting-only normalization, both exact no-extra-flag wrappers return raw exit 0 at 114 selected files in two config batches; fmt has `failedBatches: 0`. All four healthy TS files are individually proven selected. Doctor stays 4/4; malformed config hash remains `6815999d…37361`; parsed config meaning is equal; separate real fmt/lint defects are detected and restored byte-exactly. | +| S2 | The canonical package-cwd CLI task no longer has three root-relative `NotFound` failures and no assertion is weakened. | The three exact CLI files listed above | Structured targeted three-file test first (6/6), then exact `deno task --cwd packages/cli test`; scoped check/lint/fmt on the three owned TS files; docs-source-format and docs-accuracy. The helper's focused semantic unit test is the final consumer proof; the matrix-waived runtime gate is not substituted or run. | +| S3 | `closeScoreGap` is pinned from both sides and its empirical rationale ships with the policy. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Structured targeted guidance test; controlled `0.5 -> 5` and `0.5 -> below-inside-gap` mutations each raw non-zero, followed by exact restoration and green rerun; MCP scoped check/test/lint/fmt; quality gate. | +| S4 | The integrated head meets the applicable frozen proving contract and publish/docs claims are honest. | No new product/config files; run artifacts/evidence only | Commit-bound `check`, `test`, `publish-dry-run`, `quality-job`, docs-source-format, docs-accuracy, and per-member JSR suite. `scaffold.runtime` is recorded `n/a` by coordinator waiver and is not executed. | ## JSR audit plan per touched publishable member @@ -170,23 +171,23 @@ already produces them. A receipt proves only its command. Before and after every ## Risk register -| Risk | Mitigation | -| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Marker handling becomes a blanket `tests/fixtures`/parent skip or silently empties selection. | The marker applies only to its own directory; tests pair a marked subtree with an equivalent unmarked sibling and assert the sibling remains selected. Wrapper empty-selection refusal remains intact. | -| Config-aware batching reveals a real finding and implementers are tempted to exclude its unmarked file. | Require 114 selected files. The only allowed drop is `broken/netscript.config.ts`; tests pin all four healthy files as selected. The one fmt finding is a legitimate blocker requiring the separately authorized formatting fix, never another exclusion. | -| Module-root arithmetic is off by one directory. | Derive from each file URL, assert/read known repo files, and run from `packages/cli` cwd first. | -| Fixing only doc reads leaves `.llm/tmp` cwd-sensitive. | Anchor both authoritative doc and run-owned scratch paths in the helper; cleanup remains scoped to the created temp directory. | -| Boundary test still passes under one-sided policy drift. | Separate observable inside/outside ordering plus explicit widen/narrow mutation controls. | -| Floating-point equality makes the inside case ambiguous. | Use exactly representable test values/differences where possible and a deliberately larger outside epsilon; assert order, not raw floating equality. | -| Publish audit expands into known CLI debt. | Record baseline debt and require no new diagnostics; do not edit public CLI files or claim debt closure. | -| Waived expensive gate is accidentally run or reported `NOT_RUN`. | Record `scaffold.runtime` as coordinator-waived `n/a`; do not request a lease or invoke Aspire, Docker, or `e2e:cli`. | -| Validation churns locks/caches. | Never reload/delete; inspect exact Git status and lock blob before accepting any receipt. | +| Risk | Mitigation | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Marker handling becomes a blanket `tests/fixtures`/parent skip or silently empties selection. | The marker applies only to its own directory; tests pair a marked subtree with an equivalent unmarked sibling and assert the sibling remains selected. Wrapper empty-selection refusal remains intact. | +| Config-aware batching reveals a real finding and implementers are tempted to exclude its unmarked file. | Require 114 selected files. The only allowed drop is `broken/netscript.config.ts`; tests pin all four healthy files as selected. Normalize the granted healthy file with Deno formatting only and prove parsed meaning/doctor behavior unchanged; never add another exclusion. | +| Module-root arithmetic is off by one directory. | Derive from each file URL, assert/read known repo files, and run from `packages/cli` cwd first. | +| Fixing only doc reads leaves `.llm/tmp` cwd-sensitive. | Anchor both authoritative doc and run-owned scratch paths in the helper; cleanup remains scoped to the created temp directory. | +| Boundary test still passes under one-sided policy drift. | Separate observable inside/outside ordering plus explicit widen/narrow mutation controls. | +| Floating-point equality makes the inside case ambiguous. | Use exactly representable test values/differences where possible and a deliberately larger outside epsilon; assert order, not raw floating equality. | +| Publish audit expands into known CLI debt. | Record baseline debt and require no new diagnostics; do not edit public CLI files or claim debt closure. | +| Waived expensive gate is accidentally run or reported `NOT_RUN`. | Record `scaffold.runtime` as coordinator-waived `n/a`; do not request a lease or invoke Aspire, Docker, or `e2e:cli`. | +| Validation churns locks/caches. | Never reload/delete; inspect exact Git status and lock blob before accepting any receipt. | ## Arch-debt implications - No new entry expected. - Do not close or modify existing CLI/MCP/E2E debt entries. -- Any newly discovered doctrine or JSR finding that cannot be fixed inside the eleven-path surface +- Any newly discovered doctrine or JSR finding that cannot be fixed inside the twelve-path surface is `FAIL_DEBT`/rescope, not an implicit waiver. ## Explicit deferrals / non-scope @@ -196,9 +197,6 @@ already produces them. A receipt proves only its command. Before and after every coordinator-waived `n/a`, not pending. - No docs prose change, malformed-fixture repair, other wrapper change, CI workflow change, dependency/version update, public export change, score-algorithm change, or package reshape. -- No edit to `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` until the coordinator - grants the pending twelfth-path rescope; its exact scratch patch and green 114-file proof are - recorded in `worklog.md`. - No merge, publish, ready flip, issue checkbox mutation, acceptance-evidence block, or phase relabel. - No `deno.lock`, cache, generated asset, or receipt implementation change. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md index 7ca28253d1..f863f3115a 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md @@ -21,23 +21,23 @@ ## Findings -| # | Finding | `file:line` / command evidence | -| --- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| R1 | `packages/cli` defines its canonical package test as `deno test --allow-all`, so `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` deliberately runs every nested CLI/E2E unit with `packages/cli` as process cwd. | `packages/cli/deno.json:14-22`. | -| R2 | Exactly three tests fail under that cwd. The structured targeted reproduction selected only the three named test files and returned `passed: 3`, `failed: 3`: the documented-stream test cannot read `docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md`; quickstart drift cannot read `docs/site/quickstart.vto`; the service-env script-existence test cannot stat `packages/cli/e2e/.../configure-service-env.ts`. | `run-deno-test.ts --cwd packages/cli -- --allow-all `; test locations below. | -| R3 | The service-env failure is not the subprocess probe. The gate registry intentionally stores `GATE_DIR` relative to repository root and returns a relative script argument for the fixture gate, while the test calls `Deno.stat(script)` directly. The same test already derives `REPO_ROOT` from `import.meta` and uses it for subprocess cwd, so the honest fix is to resolve the asserted command path against that root without changing the production gate command. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates.ts:26-27,46-64`; `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:31-34,96-102,124-143`. | -| R4 | The quickstart drift test directly reads a repo-root-relative string. Its assertion compares every marked shell line with `QUICKSTART_DOCUMENTED_COMMANDS`; only path acquisition is defective. | `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:4-15`. | -| R5 | The documented-stream test calls a helper whose `DOC_PATH` and `.llm/tmp` paths are process-cwd-relative. The failing read is `DOC_PATH`; the helper then extracts and actually imports the published example. Anchoring repository-owned source/scratch paths to a module-derived repo root retains the semantic runtime assertion. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15,21-30,33-39`; `run-documented-stream-example_test.ts:4-35`. | -| R6 | The malformed MCP fixture is deliberate and exactly malformed as reported: `workspace` is a string, while Deno expects an array/object workspace config. The doctor test reads the fixture by module-derived absolute path and asserts `deno_workspace: fail`; changing the fixture would destroy the test. | `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json:1`; `packages/mcp/tests/doctor-families_test.ts:10-33`; `project-wiring-doctor-family.ts:78-87`. | -| R7 | The exact formatter reproduction selects 115 TS/TSX files, exits 1, reports one failed batch and zero findings, then identifies a config-parse crash. Wrapper-level `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'` selects 110 files and exits 0. Passing explicit `--config deno.json` selects all 115 and exits 0 because it disables nested auto-discovery. | Research commands recorded in this session; wrapper filtering and explicit-config support are at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:67-87,103-201,255-301,312-331`; crash refusal at `:370-415,439-488`. | -| R8 | **Falsified by execution:** root `exclude` is a real directory-walk boundary, but it does not satisfy the acceptance command. Both optimized wrappers perform their own selection and pass explicit files; Deno then resolves the nearest config for each named file. Root exclusion remains defensible only as non-load-bearing protection for native directory walks. | Evaluator proof in `plan-eval.md` §1; fmt selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:263-301,312-331`; lint selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts:268-306,329-335`; baseline exact commands in `worklog.md`. | -| R9 | Root `fmt:check` already excludes the doctor fixture at the wrapper-selection layer, which is why only editing that task would not fix the acceptance command and would leave the false-green blind spot. | `deno.json:139-148` versus the exact issue command with no `--exclude`. | -| R10 | `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap` is a typed exported internal-module policy value of `0.5`. `orderGuidanceSections` first sorts by route/score/identity, then groups candidates whose score is at most that value below the group leader, and reorders each close group by slug. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:20-44,181-211`. | -| R11 | The only close-score unit uses a 10.4 leader and 9.8 `outside-leader-band`, but that candidate's `pages/gamma` slug already sorts last. Widening the band therefore does not alter the asserted order. No just-inside control exists either, so narrowing is also unpinned. | `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`; live #1622 mutation evidence reports `0.5 -> 5` remained green. | -| R12 | The empirical rationale can be made exact without inventing score-scale meaning: the observed pair's gap is about `0.3019801981861221`; `0.5` leaves `0.1980198018138779` headroom, about 2.6 times the observed regeneration movement `0.0748587451731435`. | Live #1622 body; policy definition `guidance-index.ts:33-44`. | -| R13 | The full repository has no other deliberately malformed `workspace: "packages/*"` fixture. The healthy MCP sibling correctly uses an array. | `rg` over `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, `.llm/tools/**`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1`. | -| R14 | Child-only marker scope plus nearest-config batching correctly selects 114 files and isolates the malformed config crash. Lint is green. Fmt then reports exactly one real finding on `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`. There is no style conflict: `healthy/deno.json` has a valid workspace and no fmt options; the source is simply unformatted (one-line object and single quotes). Three of the four healthy TS files already format cleanly. | Executed `git archive HEAD` prototype recorded in `worklog.md`; healthy config/source at `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1` and `netscript.config.ts:1`. | -| R15 | Parent-family skip is rejected: it selected 110 by silently removing the one marked broken file and all four unmarked healthy files. The honest mechanism is `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` on its own `broken/` subtree plus grouping selected files by effective nearest config. Exact lint is green at 114; exact fmt is an honest red with the one finding above. A scratch-only format of that one healthy file makes exact fmt green at 114, lint green, and doctor 4/4, proving the pending twelfth-path request without exercising it in checkout. | Executed archive matrices and proposed one-file diff in `worklog.md`; no checkout product/config file was edited. | +| # | Finding | `file:line` / command evidence | +| --- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| R1 | `packages/cli` defines its canonical package test as `deno test --allow-all`, so `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` deliberately runs every nested CLI/E2E unit with `packages/cli` as process cwd. | `packages/cli/deno.json:14-22`. | +| R2 | Exactly three tests fail under that cwd. The structured targeted reproduction selected only the three named test files and returned `passed: 3`, `failed: 3`: the documented-stream test cannot read `docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md`; quickstart drift cannot read `docs/site/quickstart.vto`; the service-env script-existence test cannot stat `packages/cli/e2e/.../configure-service-env.ts`. | `run-deno-test.ts --cwd packages/cli -- --allow-all `; test locations below. | +| R3 | The service-env failure is not the subprocess probe. The gate registry intentionally stores `GATE_DIR` relative to repository root and returns a relative script argument for the fixture gate, while the test calls `Deno.stat(script)` directly. The same test already derives `REPO_ROOT` from `import.meta` and uses it for subprocess cwd, so the honest fix is to resolve the asserted command path against that root without changing the production gate command. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates.ts:26-27,46-64`; `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:31-34,96-102,124-143`. | +| R4 | The quickstart drift test directly reads a repo-root-relative string. Its assertion compares every marked shell line with `QUICKSTART_DOCUMENTED_COMMANDS`; only path acquisition is defective. | `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:4-15`. | +| R5 | The documented-stream test calls a helper whose `DOC_PATH` and `.llm/tmp` paths are process-cwd-relative. The failing read is `DOC_PATH`; the helper then extracts and actually imports the published example. Anchoring repository-owned source/scratch paths to a module-derived repo root retains the semantic runtime assertion. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15,21-30,33-39`; `run-documented-stream-example_test.ts:4-35`. | +| R6 | The malformed MCP fixture is deliberate and exactly malformed as reported: `workspace` is a string, while Deno expects an array/object workspace config. The doctor test reads the fixture by module-derived absolute path and asserts `deno_workspace: fail`; changing the fixture would destroy the test. | `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json:1`; `packages/mcp/tests/doctor-families_test.ts:10-33`; `project-wiring-doctor-family.ts:78-87`. | +| R7 | The exact formatter reproduction selects 115 TS/TSX files, exits 1, reports one failed batch and zero findings, then identifies a config-parse crash. Wrapper-level `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'` selects 110 files and exits 0. Passing explicit `--config deno.json` selects all 115 and exits 0 because it disables nested auto-discovery. | Research commands recorded in this session; wrapper filtering and explicit-config support are at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:67-87,103-201,255-301,312-331`; crash refusal at `:370-415,439-488`. | +| R8 | **Falsified by execution:** root `exclude` is a real directory-walk boundary, but it does not satisfy the acceptance command. Both optimized wrappers perform their own selection and pass explicit files; Deno then resolves the nearest config for each named file. Root exclusion remains defensible only as non-load-bearing protection for native directory walks. | Evaluator proof in `plan-eval.md` §1; fmt selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:263-301,312-331`; lint selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts:268-306,329-335`; baseline exact commands in `worklog.md`. | +| R9 | Root `fmt:check` already excludes the doctor fixture at the wrapper-selection layer, which is why only editing that task would not fix the acceptance command and would leave the false-green blind spot. | `deno.json:139-148` versus the exact issue command with no `--exclude`. | +| R10 | `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap` is a typed exported internal-module policy value of `0.5`. `orderGuidanceSections` first sorts by route/score/identity, then groups candidates whose score is at most that value below the group leader, and reorders each close group by slug. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:20-44,181-211`. | +| R11 | The only close-score unit uses a 10.4 leader and 9.8 `outside-leader-band`, but that candidate's `pages/gamma` slug already sorts last. Widening the band therefore does not alter the asserted order. No just-inside control exists either, so narrowing is also unpinned. | `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`; live #1622 mutation evidence reports `0.5 -> 5` remained green. | +| R12 | The empirical rationale can be made exact without inventing score-scale meaning: the observed pair's gap is about `0.3019801981861221`; `0.5` leaves `0.1980198018138779` headroom, about 2.6 times the observed regeneration movement `0.0748587451731435`. | Live #1622 body; policy definition `guidance-index.ts:33-44`. | +| R13 | The full repository has no other deliberately malformed `workspace: "packages/*"` fixture. The healthy MCP sibling correctly uses an array. | `rg` over `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, `.llm/tools/**`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1`. | +| R14 | Child-only marker scope plus nearest-config batching correctly selects 114 files and isolates the malformed config crash. Lint is green. Fmt then reports exactly one real finding on `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`. There is no style conflict: `healthy/deno.json` has a valid workspace and no fmt options; the source is simply unformatted (one-line object and single quotes). Three of the four healthy TS files already format cleanly. | Executed `git archive HEAD` prototype recorded in `worklog.md`; healthy config/source at `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1` and `netscript.config.ts:1`. | +| R15 | Parent-family skip is rejected: it selected 110 by silently removing the marked broken file and all four unmarked healthy files. The honest mechanism is `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` on its own `broken/` subtree plus grouping by effective nearest config. The coordinator granted the twelfth formatting-only path because the real 114-file finding should be fixed, not hidden. After the scratch normalization, both exact no-extra-flag wrappers are green at 114 in two config batches, doctor is 4/4, and the original/formatted module exports compare equal. | Executed archive matrices, named four-file selection probes, and one-file semantic/diff proof in `worklog.md`; no checkout product/config file was edited. | ## jsr-audit surface scan diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md index 699b212709..2392b4d069 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md @@ -47,19 +47,17 @@ ### Commit slices -| # | Slice | Gate | Exact files | -| -- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | -| S1 | Make optimized MCP fmt/lint selection marker- and config-aware while retaining every unmarked sibling. | 114-file selection + honest single fmt blocker + green lint + marked/unmarked tests + negative controls + doctor test. | Six exact S1 paths in `plan.md` | -| S2 | Make all three CLI tests package-cwd independent without weakening assertions. | Structured targeted 6/6 + exact package task + docs gates; final runtime consumer in S4. | Three exact CLI files in `plan.md` | -| S3 | Pin close-score policy on both sides and record rationale. | Targeted test + widen/narrow RED controls + scoped MCP/quality gates. | `guidance-index.ts`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | -| S4 | Integrated evidence for the applicable frozen gate set. | Static/test/docs/publish/JSR gates; `scaffold.runtime` recorded coordinator-waived `n/a`. | Run artifacts/evidence only | +| # | Slice | Gate | Exact files | +| -- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------- | +| S1 | Make optimized MCP fmt/lint selection marker- and config-aware while retaining every unmarked sibling. | Both exact wrappers green at 114 + marked/unmarked/config-batch tests + negative controls + doctor/semantic proof. | Seven exact S1 paths in `plan.md` | +| S2 | Make all three CLI tests package-cwd independent without weakening assertions. | Structured targeted 6/6 + exact package task + docs gates; final runtime consumer in S4. | Three exact CLI files in `plan.md` | +| S3 | Pin close-score policy on both sides and record rationale. | Targeted test + widen/narrow RED controls + scoped MCP/quality gates. | `guidance-index.ts`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | +| S4 | Integrated evidence for the applicable frozen gate set. | Static/test/docs/publish/JSR gates; `scaffold.runtime` recorded coordinator-waived `n/a`. | Run artifacts/evidence only | ### Deferred scope -- Any twelfth product/config path, other wrapper/CI change, docs edit, malformed-fixture repair, +- Any thirteenth product/config path, other wrapper/CI change, docs edit, malformed-fixture repair, public API change, dependency update, or algorithm change. -- `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` until the coordinator grants the - pending twelfth-path rescope; its formatting-only patch is proved in scratch. - `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, and `e2e:cli`; the gate is waived `n/a`, not pending. - All implementation until separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. @@ -83,6 +81,8 @@ score order. Then prove both green behavior and a controlled red mutation throug | 2026-08-15 | plan | rejected proof draft | Parent-family marker made both wrappers green at 110 by excluding four unmarked healthy files; coordinator rejected it before push as a silent false-positive exclusion. | | 2026-08-15 | plan | corrected mechanism proof | Child-only marker + nearest-config batching selects 114: lint green, fmt one honest healthy-fixture finding, doctor 4/4, negative controls red, restorations byte-exact. | | 2026-08-15 | plan | twelfth-path scratch proof | Formatting only `healthy/netscript.config.ts` makes exact fmt green at 114; lint and doctor remain green. Checkout path untouched pending grant. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | twelfth-path grant | Coordinator authorized that exact formatting-only path, bringing planned implementation to twelve paths; no semantic/config-value change and no thirteenth path. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | final 114-file proof | Both exact no-extra-flag wrappers green; all four healthy TS files individually named selected; doctor/parsed meaning/hash/negative-control requirements proved. | ## Decisions @@ -95,15 +95,16 @@ score order. Then prove both green behavior and a controlled red mutation throug ## Drift -| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | -| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | ------------------ | -| Launcher preseeded exact thread record before clean check. | minor | yes | -| Root task already had a wrapper-level fixture exclude, but standalone acceptance command remains red. | minor research clarification | yes | -| R8 root-exclusion conclusion was falsified by evaluator execution. | significant | yes | -| Child-only marker proof selected 114 but left fmt red on the healthy nested config. | significant design finding | yes | -| Coordinator expanded the edit surface from six to eleven paths and waived `scaffold.runtime`. | significant authorized rescope | yes | -| Parent-family 110-file draft silently removed four unmarked healthy files and was rejected before push. | significant plan correction | yes | -| One genuine healthy-fixture fmt finding remains; its twelfth-path repair is proved but unauthorized. | significant pending rescope | yes | +| Drift | Severity | Logged in drift.md | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | ------------------ | +| Launcher preseeded exact thread record before clean check. | minor | yes | +| Root task already had a wrapper-level fixture exclude, but standalone acceptance command remains red. | minor research clarification | yes | +| R8 root-exclusion conclusion was falsified by evaluator execution. | significant | yes | +| Child-only marker proof selected 114 but left fmt red on the healthy nested config. | significant design finding | yes | +| Coordinator expanded the edit surface from six to eleven paths and waived `scaffold.runtime`. | significant authorized rescope | yes | +| Parent-family 110-file draft silently removed four unmarked healthy files and was rejected before push. | significant plan correction | yes | +| One genuine healthy-fixture fmt finding exposed a twelfth-path repair; proof led to an exact formatting-only grant. | significant resolved rescope | yes | +| Coordinator granted the exact formatting-only twelfth path after the honest 114-file finding. | significant authorized rescope | yes | ## Gate results @@ -124,29 +125,43 @@ edits. Commands were unpiped; exit status below is the direct child process stat uses `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` inside `doctor/broken/` to skip only that directory, then groups the 114 remaining files by effective nearest Deno config before batching. -| Proof | Exact command / mutation | Raw exit | Selection / failed batches | Verdict | -| ------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Baseline fmt | `deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/mcp --ext ts,tsx` in checkout | 1 | 115 selected; 1 failed batch; 0 findings | RED config-parse crash | -| Baseline lint | equivalent `run-deno-lint.ts` command in checkout | 1 | 115 selected; 1 crash batch (`failures.length`; lint currently has no named `failedBatches` JSON key) | RED config-parse crash | -| Corrected fmt | exact fmt command, no `--exclude`/`--config` | 1 | 114 selected; 2 config batches; 1 failed batch; exactly 1 finding | Honest RED naming only `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` | -| Corrected lint | exact lint command, no `--exclude`/`--config` | 0 | 114 selected; 2 config batches; 0 crash/failed batches; 0 occurrences | GREEN, non-empty | -| Doctor semantics | structured `doctor-families_test.ts` | 0 | 4 passed / 0 failed | GREEN; marker file does not perturb asserted directory behavior | -| Fmt negative | append unformatted export to real `packages/mcp/mod.ts`, exact fmt command | 1 | 114 selected; 2 failed batches; 2 findings: deliberate `mod.ts` defect plus known healthy fixture | RED with the real deliberate formatting finding still visible | -| Lint negative | append unused binding to real `packages/mcp/cli.ts`, exact lint command | 1 | 114 selected; one `no-unused-vars` occurrence naming `packages/mcp/cli.ts`; no crash batch | RED for a real lint violation | -| Restoration | archive-restore then `cmp`/SHA-256 | 0 | `mod.ts` hash `8a76331e…c86d841`; `cli.ts` hash `1964acf7…03b87b` match checkout | Byte-exact restore asserted | -| Malformed fixture | SHA-256/cmp against checkout | 0 | both `deno.json` hashes `6815999d…37361` | Deliberately malformed fixture remains byte-identical | -| Proposed twelfth path (scratch only) | `deno fmt packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`, then both exact wrappers | 0 | fmt: 114 selected / 2 batches / `failedBatches: 0`; lint: 114 / 2 / 0 occurrences | Final fmt and lint GREEN; doctor rerun 4/4 GREEN | +| Proof | Exact command / mutation | Raw exit | Selection / failed batches | Verdict | +| ----------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Baseline fmt | `deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/mcp --ext ts,tsx` in checkout | 1 | 115 selected; 1 failed batch; 0 findings | RED config-parse crash | +| Baseline lint | equivalent `run-deno-lint.ts` command in checkout | 1 | 115 selected; 1 crash batch (`failures.length`; lint currently has no named `failedBatches` JSON key) | RED config-parse crash | +| Corrected fmt | exact fmt command, no `--exclude`/`--config` | 1 | 114 selected; 2 config batches; 1 failed batch; exactly 1 finding | Honest RED naming only `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` | +| Corrected lint | exact lint command, no `--exclude`/`--config` | 0 | 114 selected; 2 config batches; 0 crash/failed batches; 0 occurrences | GREEN, non-empty | +| Doctor semantics | structured `doctor-families_test.ts` | 0 | 4 passed / 0 failed | GREEN; marker file does not perturb asserted directory behavior | +| Healthy-file selection probe | after normalization, temporarily add a fmt defect to each of the three generated healthy registries; exact fmt command | 1 | 114 selected; 2 batches; 3 findings individually naming all three registry files | Proves the unmarked generated siblings remain selected; restored byte-exactly | +| Fmt negative after normalization | append unformatted export to real `packages/mcp/mod.ts`, exact fmt command | 1 | 114 selected; 2 batches; 1 failed batch; exactly 1 finding naming `packages/mcp/mod.ts` | RED for a real source formatting defect | +| Lint negative | append unused binding to real `packages/mcp/cli.ts`, exact lint command | 1 | 114 selected; one `no-unused-vars` occurrence naming `packages/mcp/cli.ts`; no crash batch | RED for a real lint violation | +| Restoration | archive-restore then `cmp`/SHA-256 | 0 | `mod.ts` hash `8a76331e…c86d841`; `cli.ts` hash `1964acf7…03b87b` match checkout | Byte-exact restore asserted | +| Malformed fixture | SHA-256/cmp against checkout | 0 | both `deno.json` hashes `6815999d…37361` | Deliberately malformed fixture remains byte-identical | +| Granted twelfth path (scratch only) | `deno fmt packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`, then both exact wrappers | 0 | fmt: 114 selected / 2 batches / `failedBatches: 0`; lint: 114 / 2 / 0 occurrences | Final fmt and lint GREEN; doctor rerun 4/4 GREEN | +| Parsed-meaning equality | import original and formatted config with `deno eval --no-config`; compare serialized default exports | 0 | original and formatted both `{"plugins":["workers"]}`; `equal: true` | Formatting-only; parsed/config value unchanged | Collateral is exact: 115→114 for both wrappers. The only file removed from automatic selection is `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/netscript.config.ts`. All four unmarked healthy TS files -remain selected, as do the unrelated export-surface and telemetry fixture TS files. Planned wrapper -tests independently create a marked subtree and an equivalent unmarked sibling; count/path -assertions require child-only skip, unmarked-sibling selection, and separate nearest-config batches -in both tools. - -The remaining fmt finding is not a config-style conflict. `healthy/deno.json` contains a valid +remain selected and were individually named by real fmt findings during the proof: + +1. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` — the genuine pre-normalization + finding. +2. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/.netscript/generated/plugin-ai/agents.registry.ts` — + controlled selection probe, restored hash `c5ca3e52…ba1546`. +3. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/.netscript/generated/plugin-ai/tools.registry.ts` — + controlled selection probe, restored hash `c5ca3e52…ba1546`. +4. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/.netscript/generated/plugin-workers/job-registry.ts` + — controlled selection probe, restored hash `c5ca3e52…ba1546`. + +Unrelated export-surface and telemetry fixture TS files also remain selected. Planned wrapper tests +independently create a marked subtree and an equivalent unmarked sibling; count/path assertions +require child-only skip, unmarked-sibling selection, and separate nearest-config batches in both +tools. + +The original fmt finding is not a config-style conflict. `healthy/deno.json` contains a valid workspace and no fmt options. Three healthy TS files already pass; `healthy/netscript.config.ts` is -simply unformatted. The scratch-only proposed change is exactly: +simply unformatted. The coordinator granted this exact formatting-only twelfth path after the +scratch proof. The planned change is exactly: ```diff -const config: { readonly plugins: readonly string[] } = { plugins: ['workers'] }; @@ -156,7 +171,8 @@ simply unformatted. The scratch-only proposed change is exactly: export default config; ``` -That checkout path is a twelfth path and remains untouched pending coordinator grant. +The checkout path remains untouched in this plan-only pass. The grant expands implementation +authority after Tier-A and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`; it does not authorize pre-gate tree mutation. ### Static gates @@ -185,8 +201,9 @@ That checkout path is a twelfth path and remains untouched pending coordinator g ## Handoff notes -- Tier-A must first dispose the pending twelfth-path request. PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 should then inspect - L3's child-only marker plus nearest-config batching, the marked/unmarked sibling guard, the - two-direction score controls, and the honest treatment of existing CLI JSR debt. -- No implementation authority exists. The topic supervisor owns the rescope decision and future - cycle-2 evaluator launch; `scaffold.runtime` is waived and must not run. +- Tier-A should review the now-reachable twelve-path plan. PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 should inspect L3's + child-only marker plus nearest-config batching, the four-file unmarked-sibling evidence, the + formatting-only semantic equality proof, the two-direction score controls, and the honest + treatment of existing CLI JSR debt. +- No implementation authority exists before fresh Tier-A and cycle-2 `PASS`. The topic supervisor + owns that review/evaluator launch; `scaffold.runtime` is waived and must not run. From c415daad2af38690c6195b02c4e949bdc8c8ae6c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 13:32:24 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 6/7] docs(harness): PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 FAIL_PLAN for package-gate-honesty Evaluated head df1d7a96d. Marker + nearest-config batching reproduced green (114/2 batches, four healthy files named, negative controls red), but the lint wrapper is embedded in the published CLI agent-tools barrel, so the twelve-path surface forces a thirteenth path and a CLI publish delta. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn --- .../package-gate-honesty/plan-eval-cycle-1.md | 213 ++++++++++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md | 399 ++++++++++-------- 2 files changed, 427 insertions(+), 185 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval-cycle-1.md diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval-cycle-1.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval-cycle-1.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..48b9577aea --- /dev/null +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval-cycle-1.md @@ -0,0 +1,213 @@ +# PLAN-EVAL — release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty + +- Plan evaluator session: Claude Code `9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be` / 2026-08-15 +- Run: `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` +- Surface / archetype: `packages/cli` E2E harness + `packages/mcp` + root `deno.json` / Archetype 6 + (CLI / Tooling), supporting MCP member A2 +- Scope overlays: `docs` +- **Evaluated head:** `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` (plan head) +- **Immutable base:** `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b` + +## Identity, independence, route + +| Field | Value | +| ------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Model | Anthropic Claude Fable 5 (`claude-fable-5`) | +| Session ID | `9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be` | +| `bridgeSessionId` | `cse_0176qkbF4eKUt7TxJiEPdTrk` (Remote Control, non-empty) | +| Daemon short / job | `9078ecb6` (`~/.claude/jobs/9078ecb6/state.json`, backend `daemon`) | +| PID | shell parent `711275` (`claude bg-spare`), evaluator shell `728133` | +| cwd | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-package-gate` | +| Requested route | `formal_plan_evaluation`: Anthropic / Fable 5 / medium / `--remote-control` | +| Observed route (`respawnFlags`) | `--model claude-fable-5 --effort medium --remote-control --permission-mode bypassPermissions --name "NetScript 0.0.7 #1663 PLAN-EVAL"` | +| Route verdict | matched (native opposite-family binding in `lane-policy.md:45`) | + +Independence: this session is a fresh Claude session and is not the Codex GPT-5.6 Sol author thread +`01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5` nor the topic supervisor +`f7691917-0be2-4bcd-8839-43d3fc809c34`. It shares no conversation state with either; it read only +the committed run artifacts, the PR, the issues, and the tree. + +## Target verification + +| Check | Observed | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Local `HEAD` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | +| `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/fix/package-gate-honesty` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | +| PR #1663 `headRefOid` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | +| `git diff --stat 05fc3132b HEAD` | 7 files, all under `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/` (+579/-0); **no product source changed** | +| PR state | draft; base `main`; milestone `0.0.7`; labels `type:fix`, `area:tooling`, `status:research`; body `Closes #1604`, `Closes #1618`, `Closes #1622` | +| Worktree | clean before and after evaluation (all evaluator experiments ran in `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp` copies, never in the checkout) | + +## Checklist results + +| Plan-Gate item | Result | Evidence / location | +| --------------------------------------- | -------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Research present and current | PASS | `research.md` re-baselined against `main` @ `05fc3132b` on 2026-08-15. Spot-checked R3 (`service-env-gates.ts:26-27,44-66`, `_test.ts:31-34,96-102`), R5 (`run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15`), R10/R11 (`guidance-index.ts:33-44,181-211`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`) — all match the tree. R7's numbers (115 selected / 1 crash; 110 / green with wrapper `--exclude`) reproduced by execution. R8's _conclusion_ is falsified by execution — see finding F1. | +| Decisions locked | FAIL | L1, L2, L4, L5, L6, L7, L8, L9 are stated with rationale and hold. **L3 (`plan.md:90`) is locked on a mechanism that does not achieve the slice's own passing condition** (F1). | +| Open-decision sweep | FAIL | The plan's sweep (`plan.md:100-108`) marks "root exclusion versus wrapper change" resolved by L3. Evaluator-run sweep finds it _unresolved_: no in-plan mechanism makes the #1618 acceptance command exit 0 (F1). Deferring it forces S1 rework → automatic unchecked box. | +| Commit slices (< 30, gate + files each) | PASS (with reconcile note) | Four slices (`plan.md:115-120`), ordered, each names proof, files, gates. Numbering conflicts with the PR body checklist (F2). | +| Risk register | PASS | `plan.md:160-172`. Row 2 ("`fmt.exclude` may select differently") anticipated the class of F1 but the mitigation ("use the top-level boundary") is the thing that fails. | +| Gate set selected | PASS (with rationale note) | Frozen contract gates all mapped (`plan.md:150-158`); A6/F-* + docs overlay covered. `scaffold.runtime` rationale is overstated (F3, advisory). | +| Deferred scope explicit | PASS | `plan.md:181-189`. | +| jsr-audit surface scan (pkg/plugin) | PASS | `research.md` § jsr-audit surface scan + `plan.md:122-131`; both publishable members scoped correctly (see item 4). | + +## The six specific proofs + +### 1. Root `deno.json` exclusion — **FAILS by execution** (F1) + +The plan's L3/S1 claim (`plan.md:51,90,117`; `research.md` R8) is that adding the fixture directory +to root `exclude` makes the exact #1618 acceptance command +(`deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/mcp --ext ts,tsx`) +exit 0 with `failedBatches: 0`, without touching the wrapper. + +Executed on Deno 2.9.5 against a `git archive HEAD` copy of `deno.json`, `deno.lock`, `packages/`, +`plugins/`, `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` in `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp/repo-copy`, with +`"exclude": [".llm/tmp/", "packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/"]` written into the copied root +`deno.json`: + +```text +{"command":"deno fmt --check","mode":"check","summary":{"filesSelected":115,"batches":1,"failedBatches":1,"findings":0,"ignoredFindings":0},"findings":[]} +1 deno fmt batch(es) failed without producing formatting findings. +error: Failed to parse "workspace" configuration. +Caused by: + invalid type: string "packages/*", expected struct WorkspaceConfig +EXIT=1 +``` + +Control in the same copy, wrapper `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'`: +`filesSelected:110, failedBatches:0`, EXIT=0. + +Why: `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` does its own file selection (`collectRoot`, lines 263-286; +`SKIP_DIRS` + regex filters only — it never reads `deno.json` `exclude`) and passes every selected +file **explicitly** to `deno fmt --check` (`runBatch`, lines 312-331). The 5 fixture `.ts` files +under `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/**` are therefore always in argv, and Deno resolves the +nearest config for an explicitly named file regardless of root `exclude`. Minimal-repro matrix +(scratch project, explicit `src/a.ts` + `tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/netscript.config.ts`): + +| Config variant | Explicit-file `deno fmt --check` | Directory-arg `deno fmt --check packages/mcp` | +| ----------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | +| no exclusion | crash | ok (fixture `deno.json` treated as a JSON file, not config) | +| root `exclude: [fixture dir]` | **crash** | ok, fixture skipped | +| root `fmt.exclude: [fixture dir]` | crash | — | +| member `packages/mcp/deno.json` `exclude` | crash | — | +| CLI `--ignore=` | crash | — | +| root exclude + `--config deno.json` | ok (only via wrapper flag) | — | + +So root `exclude` is a supported, narrowly scoped, non-masking boundary for directory walks (it +provably does not hide `packages/mcp/src/**` — 110 real files still format, and the negative control +via the wrapper path is unaffected), **but it is not the mechanism that satisfies #1618's acceptance +row 1** as written, because the wrapper's explicit-argv invocation bypasses it. The plan's S1 +passing condition ("Exact scoped fmt wrapper returns exit 0, `failedBatches: 0`", `plan.md:117`) is +unreachable inside the six-file surface as planned. + +### 2. `import.meta`-derived roots (#1604) — PASS by close reading + +- `service-env-gates_test.ts:34` already derives `REPO_ROOT` via + `import.meta.resolve('../../../../../../../../')` — eight segments from + `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/` land on the repo root (counted). + Resolving the `.ts` argument against it for `Deno.stat` (`:96-102`) is correct from both cwds; the + gate command itself keeps the relative `GATE_DIR/...` argument and `commandGate` runs with + `cwd = context.project.repoRoot` (`gate-factory.ts:53,67`), so production semantics are unchanged + (L2 verified). +- `quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:5` reads `'docs/site/quickstart.vto'` — module is four segments + below root; the assertion (`:15`) is untouched. +- `run-documented-stream-example.ts:3,10-14` — `DOC_PATH` and the `.llm/tmp` scratch dir are both + cwd-relative; the module is seven segments below root. The only production consumer is + `consume-flow-b-stream.ts:127`, spawned by `otel-gates.ts:53-64` with cwd = repoRoot, where the + anchored absolute path equals today's cwd-relative resolution. No behaviour shift. +- Risk row "off by one directory" (`plan.md:166`) plus L1 cover the derivation; the plan does not + state the segment counts — the implementer should assert a known repo file exists at the derived + root, as the mitigation says. + +### 3. `closeScoreGap` observability (#1622) — PASS by close reading + +`orderGuidanceSections` (`guidance-index.ts:181-211`) groups leader-relative with +`leader.score - candidate.score <= closeScoreGap` and re-sorts each group by slug. The plan's L5 +adds one early-slug candidate exactly at `leader − 0.5` (inside: reorders ahead of the leader on +slug; a narrower gap leaves it behind → fails) and one early-slug candidate at `leader − (0.5+ε)` +(outside: stays behind on score; a wider gap pulls it ahead → fails). Expected orders are literal +slug lists, not derived from the constant, so the assertion is non-tautological in both directions. +Float check: `10.4 - 9.9 === 0.5` and `10.5 - 10.0 === 0.5` in V8; `10.4 - 9.8` is +`0.5999999999999996`, still `> 0.5` — the risk row (`plan.md:169`) correctly tells the implementer +to prefer exactly representable values and a visibly larger outside ε. The existing `pages/gamma` +element (`guidance-retrieval_test.ts:80`) is correctly diagnosed as decorative (R11). + +### 4. Two-member JSR/publish evidence — PASS + +- `@netscript/cli`: all edits under `e2e/`, which `packages/cli/deno.json:69-72` publish-excludes; + `isolatedDeclarations: false` (`:50`) and the doc-lint completeness debt are named as **baseline** + (`research.md` § `@netscript/cli`; `plan.md:126,170`) with "no new diagnostic" as the bar — not + reported clean. +- `@netscript/mcp`: `src/**` is published, `tests/` excluded (`packages/mcp/deno.json:24-27`); the + policy comment is publishable, so the full member audit + doc-lint + isolated-declaration + + dry-run is proportionate; the test is not published. Static `import.meta`/`Deno.read*` scan on the + changed published file is the right rejection rule. + +### 5. `scaffold.runtime` load-bearing? — **not on the merits** (F3, advisory) + +The only changed production path is `run-documented-stream-example.ts`, whose full semantic +behaviour (doc read → extract → temp module → import → SSE consume) is executed end-to-end by its +unit test (`run-documented-stream-example_test.ts`) against a local `Deno.serve`. After anchoring, +running that unit test from both cwds proves the change; the `scaffold.runtime` consumer +(`consume-flow-b-stream.ts` from cwd = repoRoot) exercises the identical absolute path. The gate +matrix (`gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md:66-75`) classes `scaffold.runtime` as `n/a` for runs that do +not touch scaffold output / plugin scaffolding / DB wiring / Aspire helper generation / publish +shape — none of which this leaf touches. It is in the plan only because the frozen contract lists +it; the plan's rationale ("required because the changed helper is called by the full scaffold +consumer path", `plan.md:81-82`) overstates its evidentiary value. If the coordinator keeps it, the +plan's execution contract (exact one-pass command, `--cleanup --format pretty`, current head, +mutex-gated, NOT_RUN otherwise, `plan.md:120,158`) is sufficient. Recommendation to the coordinator: +waive it for this leaf and record the waiver, rather than serialize an aspire+docker+postgres run +for a path already proven by a unit test. + +### 6. PR checklist vs plan slice order — **do not reconcile** (F2) + +| # | PR #1663 body `## Slices` | `plan.md:117-120` | +| -- | ------------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------- | +| S1 | Make the three CLI package tests cwd-independent | `deno.json` fixture exclusion (MCP fmt) | +| S2 | Exclude malformed fixtures from MCP formatting | The three CLI files | +| S3 | Pin `closeScoreGap` | same | +| S4 | Gates + `scaffold.runtime` | same | + +S1/S2 are swapped between the two surfaces; per-slice PR comments and checkbox ticks would drift. + +## Open-decision sweep (evaluator-run) + +1. **#1618 mechanism** — unresolved (F1). The plan must pick a mechanism that empirically satisfies + the acceptance command. Options I verified or can bound: (a) wrapper change in + `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` (skip fixture trees / pass `--config` — the issue's own option 2; + **outside the frozen file surface**, needs coordinator rescope); (b) stop the fixture's `.ts` + files from being selectable or present as `.ts` (issue option 3 — construct the malformed fixture + at runtime in the doctor test, or otherwise keep no `.ts` under a directory whose nearest config + is deliberately broken; inside `packages/mcp`, which is in-surface, and still "not repairing the + fixture"). Root `exclude` may additionally be kept as belt-and-braces for directory-walk tools, + but it cannot be the load-bearing decision. +2. Everything else in the plan's sweep holds. + +## Verdict + +`FAIL_PLAN` + +### If FAIL_PLAN — required fixes + +1. **L3 / S1 / R8** (`plan.md:51,90,102,117,164-165`; `research.md` R8) — observed: root `exclude` + leaves the exact acceptance command at `filesSelected:115, failedBatches:1`, EXIT=1 (evidence + above). Required: re-decide the #1618 mechanism with an executed pre-plan proof of the exact + command exiting 0 with `failedBatches: 0` and non-empty selection, the doctor test still green, + and the fixture still malformed; if the chosen mechanism needs `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts`, + obtain the coordinator's explicit surface rescope before locking it, and update the "not touched" + list (`plan.md:70`) accordingly. Update S1's file list, gate row 4 and risk rows 1-2 to match. +2. **Slice numbering** (PR #1663 body `## Slices` vs `plan.md:117-120`) — required: make the two + agree (either renumber the plan or edit the PR body) before any implementation slice is + committed, so per-slice comments and checkbox ticks reference the same S-number. +3. **`scaffold.runtime` rationale** (`plan.md:81-82`, S4) — required wording fix, not a mechanism + change: state that the gate is contract-frozen, that the matrix classes it `n/a` for this + surface, and that the coordinator may waive it; do not claim the helper change needs it. + (Advisory on its own; would not block a PASS.) + +## Notes + +- Nothing was executed against the checkout; all reproductions ran on `git archive HEAD` copies or + minimal scratch projects under `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp`. No expensive gate, Aspire, Docker, or + `e2e:cli` was run. No labels, issues, or central state were changed. +- Cycle count: this is PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 of the two allowed. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md index 48b9577aea..64bf08a566 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan-eval.md @@ -1,213 +1,242 @@ -# PLAN-EVAL — release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty +# PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 — release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty -- Plan evaluator session: Claude Code `9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be` / 2026-08-15 +- Plan evaluator session: Claude Code `517ac0e7-9951-40ec-ab48-d0175a6d7ebb` / 2026-08-15 - Run: `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` -- Surface / archetype: `packages/cli` E2E harness + `packages/mcp` + root `deno.json` / Archetype 6 - (CLI / Tooling), supporting MCP member A2 +- Surface / archetype: `packages/cli` E2E harness + `packages/mcp` + root `deno.json` + `.llm/tools` + fmt/lint wrappers / Archetype 6 (CLI / Tooling), supporting MCP member A2 - Scope overlays: `docs` -- **Evaluated head:** `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` (plan head) +- **Evaluated head:** `df1d7a96d7fd4ecca0bd61710ba90ff67449da0b` (repaired plan head) - **Immutable base:** `05fc3132b6800a85eb6152691a961b658962571b` +- **Prior cycle:** cycle 1 `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit + `be2b1872823cbbb07a393633fcccb684f753afc1`, preserved verbatim as `plan-eval-cycle-1.md` in this + directory. ## Identity, independence, route -| Field | Value | -| ------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Model | Anthropic Claude Fable 5 (`claude-fable-5`) | -| Session ID | `9078ecb6-e8b3-4d4f-b85c-cb28a1cb34be` | -| `bridgeSessionId` | `cse_0176qkbF4eKUt7TxJiEPdTrk` (Remote Control, non-empty) | -| Daemon short / job | `9078ecb6` (`~/.claude/jobs/9078ecb6/state.json`, backend `daemon`) | -| PID | shell parent `711275` (`claude bg-spare`), evaluator shell `728133` | -| cwd | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-package-gate` | -| Requested route | `formal_plan_evaluation`: Anthropic / Fable 5 / medium / `--remote-control` | -| Observed route (`respawnFlags`) | `--model claude-fable-5 --effort medium --remote-control --permission-mode bypassPermissions --name "NetScript 0.0.7 #1663 PLAN-EVAL"` | -| Route verdict | matched (native opposite-family binding in `lane-policy.md:45`) | - -Independence: this session is a fresh Claude session and is not the Codex GPT-5.6 Sol author thread -`01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5` nor the topic supervisor -`f7691917-0be2-4bcd-8839-43d3fc809c34`. It shares no conversation state with either; it read only -the committed run artifacts, the PR, the issues, and the tree. +| Field | Value | +| ------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Model | Anthropic Claude Fable 5 (`claude-fable-5`) | +| Session ID | `517ac0e7-9951-40ec-ab48-d0175a6d7ebb` | +| `bridgeSessionId` | `cse_01McQHBVtbuX4WYDsaVXEYAn` (Remote Control, non-empty) | +| Daemon short / job | `517ac0e7` (`~/.claude/jobs/517ac0e7/state.json`, backend `daemon`) | +| PID | shell parent `795739` (`claude bg-spare`, spare claim `dc2413ce`); `state.json` carries no `pid` key | +| cwd | `/home/codex/repos/netscript-007-package-gate` | +| Requested route | formal PLAN-EVAL cycle 2: Anthropic / Fable 5 / medium / `--remote-control` | +| Observed route (`respawnFlags`) | `--effort medium --permission-mode bypassPermissions --remote-control --name "NetScript 0.0.7 #1663 PLAN-EVAL c2" --model claude-fable-5` | +| Route verdict | matched (native opposite-family binding for a Codex GPT-5.6 Sol-authored plan) | + +Independence: fresh Claude session; not the Codex author thread +`01a004ec-86a6-7c21-8886-81c09de099f5`, not the cycle-1 evaluator session `9078ecb6-…`, not the +topic supervisor. Inputs were the committed run artifacts, the PR, the tree, and my own executions. ## Target verification -| Check | Observed | -| ---------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| Local `HEAD` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | -| `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/fix/package-gate-honesty` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | -| PR #1663 `headRefOid` | `72d5aca66e46ca21d3d8becbc3d11a93bb9749ff` | -| `git diff --stat 05fc3132b HEAD` | 7 files, all under `.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/` (+579/-0); **no product source changed** | -| PR state | draft; base `main`; milestone `0.0.7`; labels `type:fix`, `area:tooling`, `status:research`; body `Closes #1604`, `Closes #1618`, `Closes #1622` | -| Worktree | clean before and after evaluation (all evaluator experiments ran in `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp` copies, never in the checkout) | +| Check | Observed | +| ---------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Local `HEAD` | `df1d7a96d7fd4ecca0bd61710ba90ff67449da0b` | +| `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/fix/package-gate-honesty` | `df1d7a96d7fd4ecca0bd61710ba90ff67449da0b` | +| PR #1663 `headRefOid` | `df1d7a96d7fd4ecca0bd61710ba90ff67449da0b` — no mismatch | +| `git diff --stat 05fc3132b HEAD` | 8 files, +992/-0, all under this run dir; **no product/config path changed** | +| PR state | draft; base `main`; milestone `0.0.7`; labels `type:fix`, `area:tooling`, **`status:research`** (brief expected `status:plan-eval` — supervisor's to fix, not mine) | +| PR body `## Slices` | S1 marker/batching/normalization, S2 CLI cwd, S3 `closeScoreGap`, S4 gates — **now reconciles** with `plan.md` S1–S4 (cycle-1 F2 fixed) | +| Tree at exit | `git status --short` empty; no `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` anywhere outside `.llm/tmp/`; `healthy/netscript.config.ts` still single-line/single-quoted; `broken/deno.json` sha256 `6815999d…37361` | + +All reproductions ran on `git archive HEAD` copies under `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp/` (never the +checkout), on Deno 2.9.5. The author's own scratch prototype +(`.llm/tmp/package-gate-honesty-plan-proof.xd8Msn/`) was read only to learn the proposed wrapper +code; every number below is my own run. ## Checklist results -| Plan-Gate item | Result | Evidence / location | -| --------------------------------------- | -------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Research present and current | PASS | `research.md` re-baselined against `main` @ `05fc3132b` on 2026-08-15. Spot-checked R3 (`service-env-gates.ts:26-27,44-66`, `_test.ts:31-34,96-102`), R5 (`run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15`), R10/R11 (`guidance-index.ts:33-44,181-211`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`) — all match the tree. R7's numbers (115 selected / 1 crash; 110 / green with wrapper `--exclude`) reproduced by execution. R8's _conclusion_ is falsified by execution — see finding F1. | -| Decisions locked | FAIL | L1, L2, L4, L5, L6, L7, L8, L9 are stated with rationale and hold. **L3 (`plan.md:90`) is locked on a mechanism that does not achieve the slice's own passing condition** (F1). | -| Open-decision sweep | FAIL | The plan's sweep (`plan.md:100-108`) marks "root exclusion versus wrapper change" resolved by L3. Evaluator-run sweep finds it _unresolved_: no in-plan mechanism makes the #1618 acceptance command exit 0 (F1). Deferring it forces S1 rework → automatic unchecked box. | -| Commit slices (< 30, gate + files each) | PASS (with reconcile note) | Four slices (`plan.md:115-120`), ordered, each names proof, files, gates. Numbering conflicts with the PR body checklist (F2). | -| Risk register | PASS | `plan.md:160-172`. Row 2 ("`fmt.exclude` may select differently") anticipated the class of F1 but the mitigation ("use the top-level boundary") is the thing that fails. | -| Gate set selected | PASS (with rationale note) | Frozen contract gates all mapped (`plan.md:150-158`); A6/F-* + docs overlay covered. `scaffold.runtime` rationale is overstated (F3, advisory). | -| Deferred scope explicit | PASS | `plan.md:181-189`. | -| jsr-audit surface scan (pkg/plugin) | PASS | `research.md` § jsr-audit surface scan + `plan.md:122-131`; both publishable members scoped correctly (see item 4). | - -## The six specific proofs - -### 1. Root `deno.json` exclusion — **FAILS by execution** (F1) - -The plan's L3/S1 claim (`plan.md:51,90,117`; `research.md` R8) is that adding the fixture directory -to root `exclude` makes the exact #1618 acceptance command -(`deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/mcp --ext ts,tsx`) -exit 0 with `failedBatches: 0`, without touching the wrapper. - -Executed on Deno 2.9.5 against a `git archive HEAD` copy of `deno.json`, `deno.lock`, `packages/`, -`plugins/`, `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` in `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp/repo-copy`, with -`"exclude": [".llm/tmp/", "packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/"]` written into the copied root -`deno.json`: +| Plan-Gate item | Result | Evidence / location | +| --------------------------------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Research present and current | PASS | `research.md` re-baselined @ `05fc3132b`; R8 correctly re-recorded as falsified; R14/R15 numbers (114/2 batches, one honest finding, lint green, doctor 4/4) **reproduced by execution** (§1–§3 below). R14's "no style conflict" wording is inaccurate (advisory A2) but not load-bearing. | +| Decisions locked | PASS | L1–L10 stated with rationale. L3 now holds by execution: child-only marker + nearest-config batching reach the exact acceptance commands green (§1–§4). L7 ("wrapper behavior changes only at selection") is true of the wrappers but omits the consumer-shipped copy (F1). | +| Open-decision sweep | **FAIL** | Evaluator-run sweep finds one decision the plan did not flag and that forces rework if deferred: `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` is embedded verbatim in the **published** `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts`; editing it under the twelve-path surface makes CI `assets-barrel` red and requires a thirteenth path (F1, executed). Automatic unchecked box. | +| Commit slices (< 30, gate + files each) | PASS (with F1 reconcile) | Four ordered slices, each with proof/files/gates (`plan.md` S1–S4); numbering matches the PR body. S1's file list and S4's gate list must absorb F1. | +| Risk register | PASS | `plan.md` risk table; row 1–2 correctly anticipate parent-family/blanket skips and the "exclude the healthy file" temptation. | +| Gate set selected | PASS (with F1 gap) | Frozen contract gates mapped; `scaffold.runtime` correctly `n/a` by coordinator waiver. **Missing:** the CI "Generated asset freshness" gate (`deno task check:assets-barrel`, `.github/workflows/ci.yml:376-381`), which the plan's `ci:quality` row does not include (`deno.json:21-32`) and which F1 turns red. | +| Deferred scope explicit | PASS | `plan.md` § Explicit deferrals / non-scope. | +| jsr-audit (package/plugin waves) | **FAIL** | `@netscript/cli` row states "None; all edits are under publish-excluded `e2e/`". False once `run-deno-lint.ts` changes: `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts` (published under `src/**/*.ts`, `packages/cli/deno.json:57-68`) must be regenerated, changing the embedded tool text and `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH` (F1). The `@netscript/mcp` row and the two-member audit plan otherwise remain proportionate; baseline CLI debt is not mislabeled green. | + +## The eight specific proofs (re-derived, not re-read) + +### 1. Child-only marker semantics — PASS by code reading + execution + +The proposed mechanism (author prototype, to be implemented in S1) checks for +`/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` at the top of `collectRoot` and returns before descending — so only +the marked directory's own subtree leaves selection; the parent walk and every sibling continue. +Executed on my archive copy with the marker in `doctor/broken/` only: **115 → 114** for both +wrappers, and all four `doctor/healthy/**` TS files were individually named by findings in a single +run (§3). A `--root` pointed directly at the marked directory yields empty selection and the +wrapper's existing non-empty refusal (honest red, not silent green). Explicit `--file`/file-`--root` +arguments bypass the marker — consistent with the plan's "automatic selection" wording. A +parent-family or blanket `tests/fixtures` skip would drop the four healthy files (110) and cannot +satisfy the plan's "114 with exactly one file removed" condition; the plan's wrapper-test rows name +both directions (marked subtree skipped, unmarked sibling still selected). Sufficient at plan level. + +### 2. Nearest-config batching — PASS, and it is genuinely load-bearing + +Executed control: HEAD wrapper (single batch) with only the broken subtree removed via +`--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/'` → 114 selected, **1 failed batch, exit +1**: ```text -{"command":"deno fmt --check","mode":"check","summary":{"filesSelected":115,"batches":1,"failedBatches":1,"findings":0,"ignoredFindings":0},"findings":[]} -1 deno fmt batch(es) failed without producing formatting findings. -error: Failed to parse "workspace" configuration. -Caused by: - invalid type: string "packages/*", expected struct WorkspaceConfig -EXIT=1 +error: Command resolved to multiple config files. Ensure all specified paths are within the same workspace. + First: file:///…/repo-copy/deno.json + Second: file:///…/repo-copy/packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json ``` -Control in the same copy, wrapper `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'`: -`filesSelected:110, failedBatches:0`, EXIT=0. - -Why: `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` does its own file selection (`collectRoot`, lines 263-286; -`SKIP_DIRS` + regex filters only — it never reads `deno.json` `exclude`) and passes every selected -file **explicitly** to `deno fmt --check` (`runBatch`, lines 312-331). The 5 fixture `.ts` files -under `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/**` are therefore always in argv, and Deno resolves the -nearest config for an explicitly named file regardless of root `exclude`. Minimal-repro matrix -(scratch project, explicit `src/a.ts` + `tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/netscript.config.ts`): - -| Config variant | Explicit-file `deno fmt --check` | Directory-arg `deno fmt --check packages/mcp` | -| ----------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | -| no exclusion | crash | ok (fixture `deno.json` treated as a JSON file, not config) | -| root `exclude: [fixture dir]` | **crash** | ok, fixture skipped | -| root `fmt.exclude: [fixture dir]` | crash | — | -| member `packages/mcp/deno.json` `exclude` | crash | — | -| CLI `--ignore=` | crash | — | -| root exclude + `--config deno.json` | ok (only via wrapper flag) | — | - -So root `exclude` is a supported, narrowly scoped, non-masking boundary for directory walks (it -provably does not hide `packages/mcp/src/**` — 110 real files still format, and the negative control -via the wrapper path is unaffected), **but it is not the mechanism that satisfies #1618's acceptance -row 1** as written, because the wrapper's explicit-argv invocation bypasses it. The plan's S1 -passing condition ("Exact scoped fmt wrapper returns exit 0, `failedBatches: 0`", `plan.md:117`) is -unreachable inside the six-file surface as planned. - -### 2. `import.meta`-derived roots (#1604) — PASS by close reading - -- `service-env-gates_test.ts:34` already derives `REPO_ROOT` via - `import.meta.resolve('../../../../../../../../')` — eight segments from - `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/` land on the repo root (counted). - Resolving the `.ts` argument against it for `Deno.stat` (`:96-102`) is correct from both cwds; the - gate command itself keeps the relative `GATE_DIR/...` argument and `commandGate` runs with - `cwd = context.project.repoRoot` (`gate-factory.ts:53,67`), so production semantics are unchanged - (L2 verified). -- `quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:5` reads `'docs/site/quickstart.vto'` — module is four segments - below root; the assertion (`:15`) is untouched. -- `run-documented-stream-example.ts:3,10-14` — `DOC_PATH` and the `.llm/tmp` scratch dir are both - cwd-relative; the module is seven segments below root. The only production consumer is - `consume-flow-b-stream.ts:127`, spawned by `otel-gates.ts:53-64` with cwd = repoRoot, where the - anchored absolute path equals today's cwd-relative resolution. No behaviour shift. -- Risk row "off by one directory" (`plan.md:166`) plus L1 cover the derivation; the plan does not - state the segment counts — the implementer should assert a known repo file exists at the derived - root, as the mitigation says. - -### 3. `closeScoreGap` observability (#1622) — PASS by close reading - -`orderGuidanceSections` (`guidance-index.ts:181-211`) groups leader-relative with -`leader.score - candidate.score <= closeScoreGap` and re-sorts each group by slug. The plan's L5 -adds one early-slug candidate exactly at `leader − 0.5` (inside: reorders ahead of the leader on -slug; a narrower gap leaves it behind → fails) and one early-slug candidate at `leader − (0.5+ε)` -(outside: stays behind on score; a wider gap pulls it ahead → fails). Expected orders are literal -slug lists, not derived from the constant, so the assertion is non-tautological in both directions. -Float check: `10.4 - 9.9 === 0.5` and `10.5 - 10.0 === 0.5` in V8; `10.4 - 9.8` is -`0.5999999999999996`, still `> 0.5` — the risk row (`plan.md:169`) correctly tells the implementer -to prefer exactly representable values and a visibly larger outside ε. The existing `pages/gamma` -element (`guidance-retrieval_test.ts:80`) is correctly diagnosed as decorative (R11). - -### 4. Two-member JSR/publish evidence — PASS - -- `@netscript/cli`: all edits under `e2e/`, which `packages/cli/deno.json:69-72` publish-excludes; - `isolatedDeclarations: false` (`:50`) and the doc-lint completeness debt are named as **baseline** - (`research.md` § `@netscript/cli`; `plan.md:126,170`) with "no new diagnostic" as the bar — not - reported clean. -- `@netscript/mcp`: `src/**` is published, `tests/` excluded (`packages/mcp/deno.json:24-27`); the - policy comment is publishable, so the full member audit + doc-lint + isolated-declaration + - dry-run is proportionate; the test is not published. Static `import.meta`/`Deno.read*` scan on the - changed published file is the right rejection rule. - -### 5. `scaffold.runtime` load-bearing? — **not on the merits** (F3, advisory) - -The only changed production path is `run-documented-stream-example.ts`, whose full semantic -behaviour (doc read → extract → temp module → import → SSE consume) is executed end-to-end by its -unit test (`run-documented-stream-example_test.ts`) against a local `Deno.serve`. After anchoring, -running that unit test from both cwds proves the change; the `scaffold.runtime` consumer -(`consume-flow-b-stream.ts` from cwd = repoRoot) exercises the identical absolute path. The gate -matrix (`gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md:66-75`) classes `scaffold.runtime` as `n/a` for runs that do -not touch scaffold output / plugin scaffolding / DB wiring / Aspire helper generation / publish -shape — none of which this leaf touches. It is in the plan only because the frozen contract lists -it; the plan's rationale ("required because the changed helper is called by the full scaffold -consumer path", `plan.md:81-82`) overstates its evidentiary value. If the coordinator keeps it, the -plan's execution contract (exact one-pass command, `--cleanup --format pretty`, current head, -mutex-gated, NOT_RUN otherwise, `plan.md:120,158`) is sufficient. Recommendation to the coordinator: -waive it for this leaf and record the waiver, rather than serialize an aspire+docker+postgres run -for a path already proven by a unit test. - -### 6. PR checklist vs plan slice order — **do not reconcile** (F2) - -| # | PR #1663 body `## Slices` | `plan.md:117-120` | -| -- | ------------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------- | -| S1 | Make the three CLI package tests cwd-independent | `deno.json` fixture exclusion (MCP fmt) | -| S2 | Exclude malformed fixtures from MCP formatting | The three CLI files | -| S3 | Pin `closeScoreGap` | same | -| S4 | Gates + `scaffold.runtime` | same | - -S1/S2 are swapped between the two surfaces; per-slice PR comments and checkbox ticks would drift. +So removing the malformed file alone is not enough: Deno refuses explicit argv spanning two +workspaces (`healthy/deno.json` is a non-member nested workspace root). Grouping by effective +nearest `deno.json`/`deno.jsonc` (walk from the file's directory up to `cwd`) yields two groups (110 +under `packages/mcp/deno.json`, 4 under `healthy/deno.json`) → fmt 114/2 batches, lint 114/2 +batches, no crash. Properties checked: files are partitioned by `Map` then `flatMap`-ed — none +dropped or merged; order changes only across groups (irrelevant to per-file findings); no empty +group can exist; a group whose nearest config is malformed still crashes but as an attributable +failed batch of its own (honest red, no cross-poisoning); files whose nearest config lies above +`cwd` share the `` key, which is still one consistent group; `--config` short-circuits to +plain chunking (Deno disables discovery). Over-splitting a single workspace into root/member groups +is harmless (same resolution per file). Cost: one `stat` pair per ancestor directory per file — +negligible at 114, acceptable at root scale (advisory A4: memoize per directory). + +### 3. The 114 count and the collateral claim — PASS by execution + +My run after normalization with a formatting defect injected into each of the three generated +registries: `filesSelected:114, batches:2, findings:4`, naming +`healthy/.netscript/generated/plugin-ai/agents.registry.ts`, `…/plugin-ai/tools.registry.ts`, +`…/plugin-workers/job-registry.ts`, **and** `healthy/netscript.config.ts` (the genuine finding) — +all four healthy TS files proven selected in one invocation; registries restored byte-exact (`cmp` +vs checkout). Exactly one file leaves selection: `broken/netscript.config.ts`. The plan's proof +(three injected + one genuine) is sufficient; the fourth file is equally covered. + +### 4. Both wrappers green with no extra flags — PASS by execution + +Exact commands, unpiped exit status, on the copy with marker + batching + `deno fmt` applied to +`healthy/netscript.config.ts` only: + +- `deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/mcp --ext ts,tsx` → + **EXIT 0**, `filesSelected:114, batches:2, failedBatches:0, findings:0`. +- `deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts --root packages/mcp --ext ts,tsx` → + **EXIT 0**, `filesSelected:114, batches:2`, 0 occurrences. + +Also green with the plan's root `deno.json` `exclude` entry added (wrapper ignores it, as cycle 1 +proved). No `--exclude`, no `--config`. + +### 5. The twelfth path is formatting-only — PASS, with one wording correction + +`deno fmt packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` in the copy produced +exactly the plan's diff (object expanded, `'workers'` → `"workers"`). `deno eval --no-config` import +of original vs formatted: both `{"plugins":["workers"]}`, equal. Doctor reads this file only through +`/\bplugins\s*:/` (`project-wiring-doctor-family.ts:101-103`), which the formatted text still +matches; `doctor-families_test.ts` **4 passed / 0 failed** with the marker present. +Serialized-export equality plus "the diff is what `deno fmt` emitted" is sufficient for a +formatting-only claim. + +Correction (advisory A2): R14's "there is no style conflict … the source is simply unformatted" is +inaccurate. Under the repo root config (`singleQuote: true`, `lineWidth: 100`) the **original** file +is correctly formatted (`deno fmt --check --config deno.json` on the original passes; baseline +`--config deno.json` run was 115/0 findings), and the **formatted** file is flagged. The finding +exists because the wrapper's nearest-config semantics make `healthy/deno.json` (Deno defaults: +double quotes, width 80) authoritative for that subtree. That is the correct choice for a fixture +that models a consumer project, but the plan should say so, because it also means the root +`deno.json` `exclude` is **not** merely "non-load-bearing": a raw root `deno fmt` walk applies root +style to that subtree (executed: raw `deno fmt --check packages/mcp` sees 136 files / 6 unformatted +without the exclude vs 127 / 4 with it) and would flip the file back, re-redding the wrapper. Keep +the exclude and state its real role. + +### 6. `broken/deno.json` byte-identical; negative controls fire and restore — PASS by execution + +sha256 `6815999dbd68bd1ab5bb137b59808cb1f1a38fb3393c9133721f439c0ad37361` in checkout and copy. Fmt +negative (`export const y=2` appended to `packages/mcp/mod.ts`) → EXIT 1, 114/2, one finding +naming `packages/mcp/mod.ts`; lint negative (unused binding in `packages/mcp/cli.ts`) → EXIT 1, +114/2, one `no-unused-vars` occurrence, no crash batch. Both restored and `cmp`-equal to the +checkout. + +### 7. Publish/JSR proportionality — **FAILS on the CLI row** (F1) + +`.llm/tools/**` is not itself published, but `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` is a consumer-installed +tool (`.llm/tools/consumer-tools.json:18-22`) embedded verbatim by +`.llm/tools/generate-cli-assets-barrel.ts` into +`packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts`, which `@netscript/cli` publishes +(`src/**/*.ts`) and `netscript agent init` installs into consumer projects +(`init-agent_test.ts:527-556`). Executed on a full `git archive HEAD` copy: + +- control (unmodified copy): `deno task gen:assets-barrel` → barrel identical to HEAD (fresh); +- with the prototype `run-deno-lint.ts` in place: `deno task gen:assets-barrel` → EXIT 0, + `agent-tools.generated.ts` **CHANGED** (contains `nearestConfig`; + `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH` changes); `embedded.generated.ts` and `skills.generated.ts` + unchanged. + +Consequences the plan does not account for: (a) CI job "Generated asset freshness" +(`run-gate.ts --gate assets-barrel` = `deno task check:assets-barrel`, `ci.yml:376-381`) fails +unless the barrel is regenerated; (b) regenerating edits a **thirteenth path** that is published CLI +source, contradicting the surface bound, the "Frozen contract entries deliberately not touched" +bullet ("no other CLI file, … generated asset … is edited") and the JSR table's `@netscript/cli` +"None"; (c) the consumer-installed copy of `run-deno-lint.ts` acquires marker + nearest-config +batching semantics — a consumer-facing behaviour change that the plan's L7/A1 wording does not +mention. `run-deno-fmt.ts` is not in `consumer-tools.json` (only mentioned as text in +`skills.generated.ts`), so the two wrappers' publish exposure differs. `@netscript/mcp` remains +proportionate as planned. + +### 8. Surface discipline — twelve paths one-for-one, but the bound is not implementable green + +The twelve rows in `plan.md` match the coordinator grant described in the brief (6 original + 4 +wrapper files + marker + healthy config), the thirteenth-path guard is present, and slice numbering +now reconciles with the PR body. Because of F1 the bound as written cannot be implemented with CI +green; the coordinator must decide between (i) granting +`packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts` (regenerated only, via +`deno task gen:assets-barrel`, verified by `check:assets-barrel`) as a thirteenth path and recording +the CLI publish delta, or (ii) removing the two lint-wrapper paths (and the marker's lint clause) +from this leaf, leaving lint's identical crash to a follow-up. That is a plan decision, not an +implementation detail. ## Open-decision sweep (evaluator-run) -1. **#1618 mechanism** — unresolved (F1). The plan must pick a mechanism that empirically satisfies - the acceptance command. Options I verified or can bound: (a) wrapper change in - `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` (skip fixture trees / pass `--config` — the issue's own option 2; - **outside the frozen file surface**, needs coordinator rescope); (b) stop the fixture's `.ts` - files from being selectable or present as `.ts` (issue option 3 — construct the malformed fixture - at runtime in the doctor test, or otherwise keep no `.ts` under a directory whose nearest config - is deliberately broken; inside `packages/mcp`, which is in-surface, and still "not repairing the - fixture"). Root `exclude` may additionally be kept as belt-and-braces for directory-walk tools, - but it cannot be the load-bearing decision. -2. Everything else in the plan's sweep holds. +1. **Barrel / thirteenth path** — unflagged, forces rework if deferred (F1). → `FAIL_PLAN`. +2. **Root task-level exclusion** (`deno.json:140` `fmt:check` + `--exclude … packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/ …`) — `deno.json` is already in-surface; after + S1 this wrapper-level parent-family exclusion becomes the same silent over-exclusion of the four + healthy files at the root gate that R9 calls a "false-green blind spot". Not rework-forcing + (advisory A1) but the plan should state whether it is removed in the same `deno.json` edit or why + it stays. +3. Everything else in the plan's sweep holds. ## Verdict `FAIL_PLAN` -### If FAIL_PLAN — required fixes - -1. **L3 / S1 / R8** (`plan.md:51,90,102,117,164-165`; `research.md` R8) — observed: root `exclude` - leaves the exact acceptance command at `filesSelected:115, failedBatches:1`, EXIT=1 (evidence - above). Required: re-decide the #1618 mechanism with an executed pre-plan proof of the exact - command exiting 0 with `failedBatches: 0` and non-empty selection, the doctor test still green, - and the fixture still malformed; if the chosen mechanism needs `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts`, - obtain the coordinator's explicit surface rescope before locking it, and update the "not touched" - list (`plan.md:70`) accordingly. Update S1's file list, gate row 4 and risk rows 1-2 to match. -2. **Slice numbering** (PR #1663 body `## Slices` vs `plan.md:117-120`) — required: make the two - agree (either renumber the plan or edit the PR body) before any implementation slice is - committed, so per-slice comments and checkbox ticks reference the same S-number. -3. **`scaffold.runtime` rationale** (`plan.md:81-82`, S4) — required wording fix, not a mechanism - change: state that the gate is contract-frozen, that the matrix classes it `n/a` for this - surface, and that the coordinator may waive it; do not claim the helper change needs it. - (Advisory on its own; would not block a PASS.) +### Required fixes + +1. **F1 — published asset barrel (`plan.md` surface table, "not touched" list, JSR table + `@netscript/cli` row, S1 files, S4/gate rows 3 and 6, L7).** Observed: + `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` is embedded in + `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts`; `deno task gen:assets-barrel` on a + HEAD copy with the planned lint wrapper changes that published file, and CI `check:assets-barrel` + diffs it (evidence §7). Required: coordinator decision recorded in `drift.md` — either grant the + regenerated barrel as an exact thirteenth path (regeneration-only, no hand edit; add + `check:assets-barrel` to the gate plan; state the `@netscript/cli` publish delta honestly in the + JSR table: embedded tool text + `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH`, no export/API change; note the + consumer-installed tool's new marker/batching semantics), or drop the lint-wrapper paths from + this leaf and re-prove the remaining surface. Update the surface bound, the "not touched" bullet, + and L7/A1 accordingly. + +### Advisory (do not block a PASS on their own) + +- **A1** — decide and record the fate of the `fmt:check` task-level doctor exclusion + (`deno.json:140`) now that the wrapper is marker/config-aware; leaving it is a silent + parent-family skip at the root gate. +- **A2** — reword R14 / L10 / drift: the healthy finding is root-style-vs-fixture-default-style, not + "simply unformatted"; the fixture's own config is authoritative under nearest-config semantics, + and the root `deno.json` `exclude` is what keeps raw root walks from reverting it (§5). +- **A3** — PR carries `status:research`; brief and phase say `status:plan-eval` (supervisor). +- **A4** — memoize `nearestConfig` per directory before this runs at root scale (implementation + note). ## Notes -- Nothing was executed against the checkout; all reproductions ran on `git archive HEAD` copies or - minimal scratch projects under `$CLAUDE_JOB_DIR/tmp`. No expensive gate, Aspire, Docker, or - `e2e:cli` was run. No labels, issues, or central state were changed. -- Cycle count: this is PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 of the two allowed. +- Nothing was executed against the checkout; no product/config path, marker, or fixture was mutated + in the tree (verified at exit). No `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, or `e2e:cli` was run. No + labels, issues, ready-state, or central state were changed. +- Cycle count: this is PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 of the two allowed. Per `plan-gate.md`, a further + `FAIL_PLAN` would escalate to the user; F1 is a single, bounded coordinator decision. From 194e22a3d0aaefe68922ed7a378aafb651a72dff Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rickylabs Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 13:45:06 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 7/7] docs(harness): repair package gate plan after cycle 2 --- .../package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md | 62 +++--- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md | 52 +++++ .../slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md | 180 +++++++++--------- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md | 61 +++--- .../slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md | 122 +++++++----- 5 files changed, 292 insertions(+), 185 deletions(-) diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md index 50d0901d77..d176605a41 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/context-pack.md @@ -2,13 +2,13 @@ ## Run Metadata -| Field | Value | -| -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | -| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | -| Current phase | twelve-path plan repaired; hard stop pending Tier-A/cycle 2 PASS | -| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` (supporting MCP member A2) | -| Scope overlays | `docs` | +| Field | Value | +| -------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | +| Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | +| Current phase | cycle 2 `FAIL_PLAN`; thirteen-path repair pending Tier-A owner review | +| Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` (supporting MCP member A2) | +| Scope overlays | `docs` | ## Current state @@ -17,7 +17,10 @@ cannot affect the optimized wrappers' explicit argv. The coordinator granted chi semantics plus nearest-config batching in both wrappers, then granted the exact formatting-only twelfth path exposed by the honest 114-file finding. Both exact no-extra-flag prototypes are now green at 114; all four healthy files remain selected, parsed meaning is equal, doctor is 4/4, and -the malformed hash is unchanged. No checkout product/config implementation exists. +the malformed hash is unchanged. Cycle 2 correctly returned `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit +`c415daad2`: the lint wrapper is embedded in published CLI source. The coordinator granted the exact +generated barrel as path thirteen and ruled on root task selection, fixture-style wording, and +nearest-config memoization. No checkout product/config/generated implementation exists. ## Completed @@ -27,7 +30,7 @@ the malformed hash is unchanged. No checkout product/config implementation exist - All three issues re-read live. - Three cwd failures and MCP fmt config crash reproduced through structured wrappers. - `closeScoreGap` definition, consumption, and decorative test behavior traced. -- Twelve-path repaired plan and per-member JSR audit plan locked; no thirteenth path. +- Thirteen-path repaired plan and per-member JSR audit plan locked; no fourteenth path. - Exact no-extra-flag lint prototype green at 114; fmt reports exactly one genuine healthy-fixture finding at 114; separate fmt/lint negative controls red with real findings; doctor 4/4; all negative-control source files restored byte-exactly. @@ -35,24 +38,29 @@ the malformed hash is unchanged. No checkout product/config implementation exist doctor remain green; original/formatted exports are equal. - All four healthy TS files were individually named selected by genuine or controlled fmt findings, and every controlled probe was restored byte-exactly. +- Cycle-2 archive proof established that canonical lint-wrapper regeneration changes only + `agent-tools.generated.ts` among generated assets, including its embedded tool text and bundle + hash; `check:assets-barrel` is now planned. ## In progress -- Awaiting fresh Tier-A review and separate-session PLAN-EVAL cycle 2. +- Awaiting Tier-A/owner review after the second and final ordinary `FAIL_PLAN` cycle. ## Next steps -1. Topic supervisor reviews the reachable twelve-path plan and launches PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 in a fresh - separate evaluator session. -2. If and only if Tier-A and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 both return `PASS`, coordinator grants implementation - authority. -3. Future implementation follows S1-S4; `scaffold.runtime` remains waived `n/a` and must not run. +1. Topic supervisor reviews the repaired thirteen-path plan under owner escalation. +2. No cycle 3 is requested or assumed; implementation authority exists only after the supervisor + explicitly disposes the exhausted plan gate. +3. If authorized later, implementation follows S1-S4; `scaffold.runtime` remains waived `n/a` and + must not run. ## Key decisions | Decision | Source | Notes | | -------------------------------------------- | -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------- | | Child marker + config batching owns boundary | plan L3/L4 | Both green at 114 after granted formatting-only normalization. | +| Published lint asset regenerated canonically | plan L7/S1 | Embedded tool text/hash change; no export/API-shape change. | +| Root task parent skip removed | plan S1/gates | Top-level raw-walk exclusion retained for fixture-local style. | | Module-derived CLI paths | plan L1/L2 | No ambient cwd and no weakened assertion. | | `0.5` pinned both directions | plan L5/L6 | Inside/outside identity conflict makes movement observable. | | Formal PLAN-EVAL required | plan judgement | This thread cannot self-launch or self-certify. | @@ -71,29 +79,31 @@ the malformed hash is unchanged. No checkout product/config implementation exist 10. `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts` 11. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` 12. `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` +13. `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts` (canonical regeneration only) Everything else in the frozen outer bound is read-only, especially both docs sources and the broken -fixture config. A thirteenth path is rescope. +fixture config. A fourteenth path is rescope. ## Gates -| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | -| ----------- | ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------- | -| Plan-Gate | cycle 1 `FAIL_PLAN`; cycle 2 pending | `plan-eval.md`; repaired `plan.md`. | -| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | -| Fitness/JSR | planned | `research.md` and `plan.md` per-member tables. | -| Runtime | N/A | Explicit coordinator waiver; must not run. | -| Consumer | baseline failures reproduced | `worklog.md` research diagnostics. | +| Gate family | Current status | Evidence | +| ----------- | ------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | +| Plan-Gate | cycle 2 `FAIL_PLAN`; owner escalation | `plan-eval.md`; repaired `plan.md`. | +| Static | NOT_RUN | No implementation. | +| Fitness/JSR | planned | `research.md` and `plan.md` per-member tables. | +| Runtime | N/A | Explicit coordinator waiver; must not run. | +| Consumer | baseline failures reproduced | `worklog.md` research diagnostics. | ## Open questions -- None that change implementation shape; implementation authority still depends on fresh Tier-A and - cycle-2 `PASS`. +- None that change implementation shape; implementation authority still depends on explicit + Tier-A/owner disposition. No cycle 3 is requested or assumed. ## Drift and debt - Drift: R8 falsified by execution; rejected parent-family false exclusion; corrected 114-file - proof; authorized formatting-only twelfth path. + proof; authorized formatting-only twelfth path; cycle-2 published-asset discovery; authorized + generated thirteenth path; corrected root-vs-fixture formatting semantics. - Debt: no new/closed entry; named CLI/MCP baseline debt remains unchanged. ## Commits diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md index 041d5a52cb..83b3601c3f 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/drift.md @@ -120,3 +120,55 @@ documentation. PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`; no thirteenth path exists. - **Evidence:** Final green matrix, four individually named healthy selection probes, semantic equality, and byte-restoration evidence in `worklog.md`. + +## 2026-08-15 — Cycle-2 evaluation exposed a published consumer asset + +- **What:** The twelve-path plan treated `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` as maintainer-only, but the + canonical CLI asset generator embeds it verbatim in published + `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts`. +- **Source:** Separate-session PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 at evaluator commit `c415daad2`, independently + confirmed by the coordinator. +- **Expected:** The plan claimed no CLI publish delta and omitted generated-asset freshness. +- **Actual:** The planned lint-wrapper edit changes installed consumer behavior, embedded tool text, + and `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH`; `check:assets-barrel` would fail unless the generated + barrel changes too. +- **Severity:** significant plan correction +- **Action:** accept coordinator grant of exactly the generated barrel as path thirteen; + regeneration must use `deno task gen:assets-barrel`, never a hand edit. Add the freshness gate and + disclose the consumer/JSR delta. No fourteenth path exists. +- **Evidence:** Full archive-copy generator proof in `plan-eval.md` §7; research R16 and repaired + plan L7/S1/JSR/gate rows. + +## 2026-08-15 — Fixture-format explanation and root exclusions corrected + +- **What:** The earlier drift entry called `healthy/netscript.config.ts` "simply unformatted" and + treated root exclusion as only non-load-bearing protection. The root task also retained a + wrapper-level parent-family skip. +- **Source:** PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 advisories A1/A2 and the coordinator's binding rulings. +- **Expected:** The honest gate should apply the fixture's own config without allowing either a raw + root walk or a task-level selection filter to undo coverage. +- **Actual:** The original bytes are valid under root style (`singleQuote: true`, width 100) but + invalid under the authoritative fixture-local config's defaults (double quotes, width 80). The + top-level root `exclude` is load-bearing for raw formatter walks because it prevents reversion to + root style, while it remains non-load-bearing for the standalone explicit-argv acceptance command. + Conversely, the `fmt:check` task's wrapper `--exclude` silently drops the whole doctor family and + must be removed. +- **Severity:** significant plan clarification +- **Action:** preserve the historical wording above as append-only drift, supersede it here, update + R14/L3/L10/worklog, retain only the top-level raw-walk boundary, and plan memoized `nearestConfig` + resolution per directory before root-scale execution. +- **Evidence:** `plan-eval.md` §2/§5 and advisories A1/A2/A4; repaired `plan.md` L3/L10/L11 and gate + row 3. + +## 2026-08-15 — Ordinary PLAN-EVAL allowance exhausted; owner escalation owns disposition + +- **What:** Cycle 2 returned `FAIL_PLAN`; the harness allows only two `FAIL_PLAN` cycles before + escalation. +- **Source:** `plan-eval.md` at `c415daad2`; coordinator repair brief. +- **Expected:** No implementation begins without a disposed plan gate. +- **Actual:** The coordinator resolved every finding and granted the exact thirteenth path, but no + cycle 3 exists absent owner escalation. +- **Severity:** process gate +- **Action:** repair and publish run artifacts only, then stop for Tier-A/owner review. Do not + request or assume another evaluator run and do not implement. +- **Evidence:** Repaired thirteen-path plan and this commit's worklog/context pack. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md index 61a2b05035..01c9f67884 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/plan.md @@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ | -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Run ID | `release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty` | | Branch | `fix/package-gate-honesty` | -| Phase | `plan` — hard stop pending formal PLAN-EVAL | +| Phase | `plan` — cycle 2 `FAIL_PLAN`; hard stop pending Tier-A owner review | | Target | Gate honesty for #1604, #1618, and #1622 | | Archetype | `6 — CLI / Tooling` (frozen leaf profile) | | Scope overlays | `docs` | @@ -23,17 +23,17 @@ boundary and does not reshape it. - `packages/mcp`: **Keep** — keep MCP transports behind token-bounded tool contracts (`:42`). - Relevant open accepted debt is baseline only: CLI public doc completeness; MCP horizontal-shape classification; MCP tool-contract file size; CLI E2E scaffold directory cardinality. None is - closed or deepened by these twelve edits. + closed or deepened by these thirteen edits. ## Axioms in play -| Axiom | Why it matters | -| ----- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| A1 | Published/exported boundaries remain unchanged; tests and comments describe the actual contract before implementation. | -| A7 | Use explicit marker semantics and `import.meta`/URL path primitives instead of ambient cwd or implicit config discovery. | -| A8 | Changes stay in existing role-named files plus one narrowly named fixture marker; no new folder is introduced. | -| A9 | Preserve CLI A6 and MCP A2 package shapes; the leaf profile does not authorize reshaping either. | -| A14 | Each repaired guard must have a negative control that proves it can fire; a non-fired command is not green. | +| Axiom | Why it matters | +| ----- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| A1 | Public API shape stays unchanged, but the published CLI asset bytes and bundle hash change honestly with the embedded lint wrapper. | +| A7 | Use explicit marker semantics and `import.meta`/URL path primitives instead of ambient cwd or implicit config discovery. | +| A8 | Changes stay in existing role-named files plus one narrowly named fixture marker; no new folder is introduced. | +| A9 | Preserve CLI A6 and MCP A2 package shapes; the leaf profile does not authorize reshaping either. | +| A14 | Each repaired guard must have a negative control that proves it can fire; a non-fired command is not green. | ## Goal @@ -46,22 +46,23 @@ boundary cannot move materially while tests stay green. These are the only product/config paths implementation may edit. Run artifacts under this slice directory are updated alongside every future slice but are not product scope. -| Path | Justification | -| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| `deno.json` | Add the doctor fixture family to root `exclude` only as non-load-bearing protection for native directory-walk tools; wrapper acceptance is owned by the marker mechanism below. | -| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts` | Resolve the relative script argument against the already module-derived `REPO_ROOT` before `Deno.stat`; retain the real gate command and existence assertion. | -| `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts` | Resolve `docs/site/quickstart.vto` from the test module/repository root while retaining exact command-parity assertions. | -| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts` | Resolve the authoritative streams doc and run-owned scratch directory from a module-derived repository root so the semantic example execution works from package cwd. | -| `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts` | Record the empirical, non-scale-derived rationale adjacent to `closeScoreGap`; do not change the value or public exports. | -| `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Replace the decorative boundary arrangement with observable just-inside and just-outside controls that fail for both widening and narrowing. | -| `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` | Skip only a marker's own subtree, then batch selected files by effective nearest Deno config before constructing explicit-file argv; preserve non-empty refusal and finding/crash classification. | -| `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts` | Prove a marked subtree is skipped while an unmarked sibling remains selected, and prove nearest-config groups cannot poison one another. | -| `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` | Apply the same child-only marker and nearest-config batching semantics to lint so the optimized tool family cannot diverge. | -| `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts` | Prove marked-skip and unmarked-selection behavior for lint, retaining real lint-finding and empty-selection refusals. | -| `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` | Declare only the deliberately invalid `broken/` subtree excluded from automatic fmt/lint selection; the unmarked `healthy/` sibling remains selected. | -| `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` | Formatting-only normalization of the one real finding exposed by honest 114-file selection; preserve the parsed plugin value and valid-project doctor behavior exactly. | - -These twelve paths are coordinator-authorized. Adding a thirteenth path is rescope and requires +| Path | Justification | +| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| `deno.json` | Add the doctor fixture family to top-level `exclude` so raw root formatter walks cannot rewrite fixture-local-default formatting, while removing the `fmt:check` task's wrapper-level doctor-family exclusion so the root gate still selects all unmarked healthy files. The standalone acceptance fix remains the marker/batching mechanism. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts` | Resolve the relative script argument against the already module-derived `REPO_ROOT` before `Deno.stat`; retain the real gate command and existence assertion. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts` | Resolve `docs/site/quickstart.vto` from the test module/repository root while retaining exact command-parity assertions. | +| `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts` | Resolve the authoritative streams doc and run-owned scratch directory from a module-derived repository root so the semantic example execution works from package cwd. | +| `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts` | Record the empirical, non-scale-derived rationale adjacent to `closeScoreGap`; do not change the value or public exports. | +| `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Replace the decorative boundary arrangement with observable just-inside and just-outside controls that fail for both widening and narrowing. | +| `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts` | Skip only a marker's own subtree, then batch selected files by effective nearest Deno config before constructing explicit-file argv; preserve non-empty refusal and finding/crash classification. | +| `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts` | Prove a marked subtree is skipped while an unmarked sibling remains selected, and prove nearest-config groups cannot poison one another. | +| `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts` | Apply the same child-only marker and nearest-config batching semantics to lint so the optimized tool family cannot diverge. | +| `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts` | Prove marked-skip and unmarked-selection behavior for lint, retaining real lint-finding and empty-selection refusals. | +| `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` | Declare only the deliberately invalid `broken/` subtree excluded from automatic fmt/lint selection; the unmarked `healthy/` sibling remains selected. | +| `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` | Formatting-only normalization of the one real finding exposed by honest 114-file selection; preserve the parsed plugin value and valid-project doctor behavior exactly. | +| `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts` | Regenerate only through `deno task gen:assets-barrel` after the lint-wrapper change so the published consumer tool text and `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH` stay fresh; never hand-edit it. | + +These thirteen paths are coordinator-authorized. Adding a fourteenth path is rescope and requires coordinator approval before editing. ## Frozen contract entries deliberately not touched @@ -70,8 +71,9 @@ coordinator approval before editing. rewritten. - `docs/site/quickstart.vto` — authoritative commands remain unchanged. - `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json` — must remain deliberately malformed. -- The broad/duplicate `packages/cli/`, `packages/cli`, and `packages/*` entries — no other CLI file, - package, generated asset, member config, or dependency pin is edited. +- The broad/duplicate `packages/cli/`, `packages/cli`, and `packages/*` entries — except for the + canonically regenerated `agent-tools.generated.ts` named above, no other CLI file, package, + generated asset, member config, or dependency pin is edited. - The broad `packages/mcp` entry — no other MCP source, test, fixture, README, entrypoint, export, or config is edited. - No other `.llm/tools/**`, workflow, lock, cache, receipt implementation, Aspire, Docker, or @@ -91,52 +93,56 @@ coordinator approval before editing. ## Locked decisions -| ID | Decision | Rationale | -| --- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| L1 | Anchor repository-owned CLI test paths with `new URL(..., import.meta.url)` / `fromFileUrl`, not `Deno.cwd()`. | Module location is stable under both root and package-cwd invocation; process cwd is explicitly the defect. | -| L2 | Preserve production gate command arguments; resolve only when the test performs filesystem verification. | The runtime gate correctly interprets `GATE_DIR` relative to `context.project.repoRoot`; changing it would expand behavior scope. | -| L3 | `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` excludes only the directory that carries it; both wrappers group all remaining files by effective nearest Deno config before batching explicit argv. | The child-only marker removes exactly `broken/netscript.config.ts` (115→114) while retaining all four unmarked healthy files. Config-aware batching prevents one config from poisoning another; lint becomes green and fmt honestly reports the one genuinely unformatted healthy file. | -| L4 | The malformed fixture and its existing failing-doctor assertion remain unchanged. | Validating the fixture would destroy the behavior under test and produce a false green. | -| L5 | Keep `closeScoreGap = 0.5`; add one observable just-inside case at exactly the boundary and one early-sorting just-outside case at `0.5 + epsilon`. | Narrowing breaks the inside reorder; widening breaks the outside score order. Both directions become observable. | -| L6 | Record the empirical rationale next to the policy: observed gap ≈0.3019801982, headroom ≈0.1980198018, regeneration movement ≈0.0748587452. | The value is tuned from observed headroom, not mathematically derived from an arbitrary score scale. | -| L7 | No new package public export, dependency, port, runtime asset, or runtime read; wrapper behavior changes only at selection. | The work is regression hardening, not API or architecture change. | -| L8 | Evidence commands fire through structured wrappers/`run-gate.ts`; empty selection, crash, NOT_RUN, or a waived gate reported as green is not PASS. | This leaf exists to eliminate false verdicts. | -| L9 | Do not run `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, `e2e:cli`, or any runtime smoke for this leaf. | The matrix classes the expensive gate `n/a` and the coordinator explicitly waived it; no lease will be granted. | -| L10 | Normalize `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` with Deno formatting only; no value, schema, or behavioral change is permitted. | Coordinator granted the twelfth path because the 114-file gate correctly exposed one genuinely unformatted real file. Scratch imports produce identical `{ "plugins": ["workers"] }`; fmt/lint are green and doctor remains 4/4. | +| ID | Decision | Rationale | +| --- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| L1 | Anchor repository-owned CLI test paths with `new URL(..., import.meta.url)` / `fromFileUrl`, not `Deno.cwd()`. | Module location is stable under both root and package-cwd invocation; process cwd is explicitly the defect. | +| L2 | Preserve production gate command arguments; resolve only when the test performs filesystem verification. | The runtime gate correctly interprets `GATE_DIR` relative to `context.project.repoRoot`; changing it would expand behavior scope. | +| L3 | `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` excludes only the directory that carries it; both wrappers group all remaining files by effective nearest Deno config before batching explicit argv. | The child-only marker removes exactly `broken/netscript.config.ts` (115→114) while retaining all four unmarked healthy files. Config-aware batching prevents one config from poisoning another; lint becomes green and fmt honestly reports that `healthy/netscript.config.ts` is valid under root style but invalid under the authoritative fixture-local config's Deno defaults. | +| L4 | The malformed fixture and its existing failing-doctor assertion remain unchanged. | Validating the fixture would destroy the behavior under test and produce a false green. | +| L5 | Keep `closeScoreGap = 0.5`; add one observable just-inside case at exactly the boundary and one early-sorting just-outside case at `0.5 + epsilon`. | Narrowing breaks the inside reorder; widening breaks the outside score order. Both directions become observable. | +| L6 | Record the empirical rationale next to the policy: observed gap ≈0.3019801982, headroom ≈0.1980198018, regeneration movement ≈0.0748587452. | The value is tuned from observed headroom, not mathematically derived from an arbitrary score scale. | +| L7 | No package export/API, dependency, port, runtime read, or command name changes; the published CLI asset text and `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH` do change. | `run-deno-lint.ts` is a consumer-installed tool embedded in published `@netscript/cli` source. Canonical regeneration ships the marker and nearest-config batching semantics to upgrading consumers without claiming a no-publish delta. | +| L8 | Evidence commands fire through structured wrappers/`run-gate.ts`; empty selection, crash, NOT_RUN, or a waived gate reported as green is not PASS. | This leaf exists to eliminate false verdicts. | +| L9 | Do not run `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, `e2e:cli`, or any runtime smoke for this leaf. | The matrix classes the expensive gate `n/a` and the coordinator explicitly waived it; no lease will be granted. | +| L10 | Normalize `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` with its effective fixture-local Deno defaults only; no value, schema, or behavioral change is permitted. | The original is root-style-valid (`singleQuote: true`, width 100) but fixture-local-default-style-invalid because `healthy/deno.json` has no `fmt` options. The fixture config is authoritative under nearest-config semantics; scratch imports remain identical, both wrappers become green, and doctor remains 4/4. The top-level root exclusion prevents raw root walks from reverting this normalization. | +| L11 | Memoize effective `nearestConfig` resolution per directory in both wrappers before root-scale use. | Naively probing both config names at every ancestor for every file is correct at 114 files but needlessly repeats filesystem work at repository scale; a directory-keyed cache preserves grouping semantics and explicit `--config` short-circuiting. | ## Open-decision sweep -| Decision | Status | Notes | -| -------------------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| Invalid-fixture boundary | resolved now | Child-only marker plus nearest-config batching in both wrappers; root `exclude` is non-load-bearing only. | -| Test path mechanism | resolved now | L1/L2; module-derived roots only. | -| Close-score boundary data | resolved now | L5/L6; both directions observable and rationale exact. | -| Public API/export changes | resolved now | None permitted. | -| `scaffold.runtime` applicability | resolved now | Gate-matrix `n/a`; coordinator waiver recorded; it must not run. | -| Healthy fixture formatting | resolved now | Coordinator granted the exact formatting-only twelfth path after the scratch proof; no semantic/config-value delta is allowed. | - -No unresolved decision would cause implementation rework. The twelve-path plan has an executed, -reachable green acceptance state; implementation remains prohibited until fresh Tier-A approval and -separate-session PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`. +| Decision | Status | Notes | +| -------------------------------- | ------------ | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Invalid-fixture boundary | resolved now | Child-only marker plus memoized nearest-config batching in both wrappers. Top-level root `exclude` protects raw formatter walks but does not satisfy standalone wrapper acceptance. | +| Test path mechanism | resolved now | L1/L2; module-derived roots only. | +| Close-score boundary data | resolved now | L5/L6; both directions observable and rationale exact. | +| Public API/export changes | resolved now | None permitted. | +| `scaffold.runtime` applicability | resolved now | Gate-matrix `n/a`; coordinator waiver recorded; it must not run. | +| Healthy fixture formatting | resolved now | Coordinator granted the exact formatting-only twelfth path after the scratch proof; no semantic/config-value delta is allowed. | +| Root `fmt:check` selection | resolved now | Remove its task-level doctor-family `--exclude`; the marker alone removes only `broken/`, so all four healthy TS files remain selected by the root wrapper gate. | +| Published lint-wrapper asset | resolved now | Coordinator granted the exact generated barrel as path thirteen; canonical regeneration plus `check:assets-barrel` is mandatory, with consumer behavior and hash delta disclosed. | + +No unresolved decision would cause implementation rework. The thirteen-path plan has an executed, +reachable green wrapper acceptance state and a reproduced canonical asset-regeneration consequence. +Implementation remains prohibited after cycle 2 `FAIL_PLAN` until the topic supervisor's Tier-A +owner review disposes the gate. This thread does not request or assume a cycle 3. ## Ordered implementation slices Every slice also updates `worklog.md` and `context-pack.md`, then is committed, pushed, and commented before the next slice. No implementation begins before separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. -| # | What it proves | Exact product/config files | Proving gates | -| -- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| S1 | MCP fmt/lint isolate deliberately invalid config without removing the unmarked healthy sibling from verification. | `deno.json`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts` | Wrapper tests prove child-only marked skip, unmarked-sibling selection, and nearest-config batching. After formatting-only normalization, both exact no-extra-flag wrappers return raw exit 0 at 114 selected files in two config batches; fmt has `failedBatches: 0`. All four healthy TS files are individually proven selected. Doctor stays 4/4; malformed config hash remains `6815999d…37361`; parsed config meaning is equal; separate real fmt/lint defects are detected and restored byte-exactly. | -| S2 | The canonical package-cwd CLI task no longer has three root-relative `NotFound` failures and no assertion is weakened. | The three exact CLI files listed above | Structured targeted three-file test first (6/6), then exact `deno task --cwd packages/cli test`; scoped check/lint/fmt on the three owned TS files; docs-source-format and docs-accuracy. The helper's focused semantic unit test is the final consumer proof; the matrix-waived runtime gate is not substituted or run. | -| S3 | `closeScoreGap` is pinned from both sides and its empirical rationale ships with the policy. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Structured targeted guidance test; controlled `0.5 -> 5` and `0.5 -> below-inside-gap` mutations each raw non-zero, followed by exact restoration and green rerun; MCP scoped check/test/lint/fmt; quality gate. | -| S4 | The integrated head meets the applicable frozen proving contract and publish/docs claims are honest. | No new product/config files; run artifacts/evidence only | Commit-bound `check`, `test`, `publish-dry-run`, `quality-job`, docs-source-format, docs-accuracy, and per-member JSR suite. `scaffold.runtime` is recorded `n/a` by coordinator waiver and is not executed. | +| # | What it proves | Exact product/config files | Proving gates | +| -- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| S1 | MCP fmt/lint isolate deliberately invalid config without removing the unmarked healthy sibling from verification, and the published consumer lint tool stays fresh. | `deno.json`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt_test.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts`; `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint_test.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/.deno-fmt-lint-ignore`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`; `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts` (canonical regeneration only) | Wrapper tests prove child-only marked skip, unmarked-sibling selection, memoized nearest-config batching, and explicit-config behavior. After fixture-local formatting normalization, both exact no-extra-flag wrappers return raw exit 0 at 114 selected files in two config batches; fmt has `failedBatches: 0`. All four healthy TS files are individually proven selected. Doctor stays 4/4; malformed config hash remains `6815999d…37361`; parsed config meaning is equal; separate real fmt/lint defects are detected and restored byte-exactly. Remove the root task-level family skip, run `deno task gen:assets-barrel`, and prove `deno task check:assets-barrel` green with only the agent-tools barrel changed among generated assets. | +| S2 | The canonical package-cwd CLI task no longer has three root-relative `NotFound` failures and no assertion is weakened. | The three exact CLI files listed above | Structured targeted three-file test first (6/6), then exact `deno task --cwd packages/cli test`; scoped check/lint/fmt on the three owned TS files; docs-source-format and docs-accuracy. The helper's focused semantic unit test is the final consumer proof; the matrix-waived runtime gate is not substituted or run. | +| S3 | `closeScoreGap` is pinned from both sides and its empirical rationale ships with the policy. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts`; `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | Structured targeted guidance test; controlled `0.5 -> 5` and `0.5 -> below-inside-gap` mutations each raw non-zero, followed by exact restoration and green rerun; MCP scoped check/test/lint/fmt; quality gate. | +| S4 | The integrated head meets the applicable frozen proving contract and publish/docs claims are honest. | No new product/config files; run artifacts/evidence only | Commit-bound `check`, `test`, `check:assets-barrel`, `publish-dry-run`, `quality-job`, docs-source-format, docs-accuracy, and per-member JSR suite. Verify the generated barrel matches a fresh canonical regeneration and the published CLI file list includes the intentional tool-text/hash delta. `scaffold.runtime` is recorded `n/a` by coordinator waiver and is not executed. | ## JSR audit plan per touched publishable member -| Member | Planned public surface delta | Exact-pin audit | Isolated-declaration / publish audit | Runtime asset / `import.meta` audit | -| ---------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| `@netscript/cli` | None; all edits are under publish-excluded `e2e/`. | Confirm six `@netscript/*` imports remain exact `0.0.6`; run `check:netscript-jsr-specifiers`. | Full export-map doc-lint and package/root publish dry-run; report existing `isolatedDeclarations: false` and doc-completeness debt as baseline, with no new diagnostic. | Verify changed E2E-only module-relative reads do not enter the published file list; reject any published `import.meta`/filesystem asset read. | -| `@netscript/mcp` | None; policy stays internal. One comment in published `src/**`, one excluded test. | Confirm aspire and telemetry subpaths remain exact `0.0.6`; run exact-pin scan. | `audit-jsr-package.ts --root packages/mcp`, full export-map doc-lint, targeted root isolated-declaration check, member/root publish dry-run, and published file-list inspection. | Static scan of the changed published source must show no `import.meta`, `fromFileUrl`, `Deno.read*`, or runtime asset dependency; release preflight remains green. | +| Member | Planned public surface delta | Exact-pin audit | Isolated-declaration / publish audit | Runtime asset / `import.meta` audit | +| ---------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| `@netscript/cli` | No export/API or binary-command change. Published `agent-tools.generated.ts` changes its embedded `run-deno-lint.ts` text and `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH`; upgrading consumers receive the marker-aware, nearest-config-batched lint selection semantics. | Confirm six `@netscript/*` imports remain exact `0.0.6`; run `check:netscript-jsr-specifiers`. | Run canonical regeneration plus `check:assets-barrel`, full export-map doc-lint, and package/root publish dry-run; inspect the published file list and report existing `isolatedDeclarations: false` and doc-completeness debt as baseline, with no new diagnostic. | Verify the generated constant remains the only delivery mechanism: no runtime filesystem/import-attribute read or top-level `import.meta`; changed E2E module-relative reads remain publish-excluded. | +| `@netscript/mcp` | None; policy stays internal. One comment in published `src/**`, one excluded test. | Confirm aspire and telemetry subpaths remain exact `0.0.6`; run exact-pin scan. | `audit-jsr-package.ts --root packages/mcp`, full export-map doc-lint, targeted root isolated-declaration check, member/root publish dry-run, and published file-list inspection. | Static scan of the changed published source must show no `import.meta`, `fromFileUrl`, `Deno.read*`, or runtime asset dependency; release preflight remains green. | For both, reject new slow types, self-bare imports, upstream re-exports, dependency ranges, runtime asset reads, or publish-list drift. A dry-run is necessary but not sufficient; S4 combines the @@ -159,35 +165,37 @@ actual branch head. Receipts are not hand-edited; child JSON reports are attache already produces them. A receipt proves only its command. Before and after every gate, compare `deno.lock` and source status with Git ground truth. -| Order | Frozen gate | Command/check shape | Passing condition | -| ----- | --------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| 1 | check | Root/task structured check plus scoped owned-file checks (`--unstable-kv` where targeted). | Fired at current head; non-empty selection; exit 0. | -| 2 | test | Structured targeted tests, MCP package tests, then exact CLI package task. | All execute; no ignore/skip added; exit 0. | -| 3 | quality-job | `deno task ci:quality` plus `deno task quality:gate`. | Both exit 0; no new allowance/cast/lint-ignore. | -| 4 | docs-source-format | Scoped formatter over the two read-only docs sources, three CLI TS files, MCP policy/test TS files, and both wrapper implementation/test pairs; never a directory containing receipts. | Every intended set is non-empty; zero findings/crashes; the marker is plain text and the malformed JSON remains byte-identical. | -| 5 | docs-accuracy | `deno task docs:accuracy`. | Exit 0 with sources unchanged. | -| 6 | publish-dry-run / JSR | Root/member publish dry-runs, full export-map doc-lint, per-member JSR audits, exact-pin and release preflight scans. | No new warning/finding, correct publish lists, isolated-declaration expectations met or named baseline debt unchanged. | -| 7 | `scaffold.runtime` | `n/a` — gate-matrix classification and explicit coordinator waiver for this surface. | Not executed; no lease requested; focused semantic coverage is the applicable proof. | +| Order | Frozen gate | Command/check shape | Passing condition | +| ----- | ------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| 1 | check | Root/task structured check plus scoped owned-file checks (`--unstable-kv` where targeted). | Fired at current head; non-empty selection; exit 0. | +| 2 | test | Structured targeted tests, MCP package tests, then exact CLI package task. | All execute; no ignore/skip added; exit 0. | +| 3 | quality-job | `deno task ci:quality` plus `deno task quality:gate`. | Both exit 0; root `fmt:check` selects the four healthy TS files and no task-level parent-family exclusion remains; no new allowance/cast/lint-ignore. | +| 4 | generated-asset freshness | `deno task check:assets-barrel` after canonical `deno task gen:assets-barrel`; inspect generated diff. | Exit 0; barrel is fresh; generated delta is limited to `agent-tools.generated.ts`, including embedded lint text and bundle hash; no hand edit. | +| 5 | docs-source-format | Scoped formatter over the two read-only docs sources, three CLI TS files, MCP policy/test TS files, and both wrapper implementation/test pairs; never a directory containing receipts. | Every intended set is non-empty; zero findings/crashes; the marker is plain text and the malformed JSON remains byte-identical. | +| 6 | docs-accuracy | `deno task docs:accuracy`. | Exit 0 with sources unchanged. | +| 7 | publish-dry-run / JSR | Root/member publish dry-runs, full export-map doc-lint, per-member JSR audits, exact-pin and release preflight scans. | No new warning/finding, correct publish lists including the regenerated CLI asset, isolated-declaration expectations met or named baseline debt unchanged. | +| 8 | `scaffold.runtime` | `n/a` — gate-matrix classification and explicit coordinator waiver for this surface. | Not executed; no lease requested; focused semantic coverage is the applicable proof. | ## Risk register -| Risk | Mitigation | -| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| Marker handling becomes a blanket `tests/fixtures`/parent skip or silently empties selection. | The marker applies only to its own directory; tests pair a marked subtree with an equivalent unmarked sibling and assert the sibling remains selected. Wrapper empty-selection refusal remains intact. | -| Config-aware batching reveals a real finding and implementers are tempted to exclude its unmarked file. | Require 114 selected files. The only allowed drop is `broken/netscript.config.ts`; tests pin all four healthy files as selected. Normalize the granted healthy file with Deno formatting only and prove parsed meaning/doctor behavior unchanged; never add another exclusion. | -| Module-root arithmetic is off by one directory. | Derive from each file URL, assert/read known repo files, and run from `packages/cli` cwd first. | -| Fixing only doc reads leaves `.llm/tmp` cwd-sensitive. | Anchor both authoritative doc and run-owned scratch paths in the helper; cleanup remains scoped to the created temp directory. | -| Boundary test still passes under one-sided policy drift. | Separate observable inside/outside ordering plus explicit widen/narrow mutation controls. | -| Floating-point equality makes the inside case ambiguous. | Use exactly representable test values/differences where possible and a deliberately larger outside epsilon; assert order, not raw floating equality. | -| Publish audit expands into known CLI debt. | Record baseline debt and require no new diagnostics; do not edit public CLI files or claim debt closure. | -| Waived expensive gate is accidentally run or reported `NOT_RUN`. | Record `scaffold.runtime` as coordinator-waived `n/a`; do not request a lease or invoke Aspire, Docker, or `e2e:cli`. | -| Validation churns locks/caches. | Never reload/delete; inspect exact Git status and lock blob before accepting any receipt. | +| Risk | Mitigation | +| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| Marker handling becomes a blanket `tests/fixtures`/parent skip or silently empties selection. | The marker applies only to its own directory; tests pair a marked subtree with an equivalent unmarked sibling and assert the sibling remains selected. Wrapper empty-selection refusal remains intact. | +| Config-aware batching reveals fixture-local style drift and implementers are tempted to exclude its unmarked file. | Require 114 selected files. The only allowed drop is `broken/netscript.config.ts`; tests pin all four healthy files as selected. Normalize the granted healthy file under its nearest config's Deno defaults, prove parsed meaning/doctor behavior unchanged, and retain the top-level root exclusion so raw root walks cannot revert it; never add another wrapper exclusion. | +| Module-root arithmetic is off by one directory. | Derive from each file URL, assert/read known repo files, and run from `packages/cli` cwd first. | +| Fixing only doc reads leaves `.llm/tmp` cwd-sensitive. | Anchor both authoritative doc and run-owned scratch paths in the helper; cleanup remains scoped to the created temp directory. | +| Boundary test still passes under one-sided policy drift. | Separate observable inside/outside ordering plus explicit widen/narrow mutation controls. | +| Floating-point equality makes the inside case ambiguous. | Use exactly representable test values/differences where possible and a deliberately larger outside epsilon; assert order, not raw floating equality. | +| Published consumer asset is stale, hand-edited, or misreported as no publish delta. | Regenerate only with `deno task gen:assets-barrel`, require `check:assets-barrel`, inspect the generated diff/hash and publish list, and state the installed lint tool's changed marker/batching behavior; do not claim debt closure. | +| Nearest-config discovery repeats filesystem probes at repository scale. | Memoize by normalized directory in both wrappers; tests cover grouped behavior and explicit `--config` short-circuiting. | +| Waived expensive gate is accidentally run or reported `NOT_RUN`. | Record `scaffold.runtime` as coordinator-waived `n/a`; do not request a lease or invoke Aspire, Docker, or `e2e:cli`. | +| Validation churns locks/caches. | Never reload/delete; inspect exact Git status and lock blob before accepting any receipt. | ## Arch-debt implications - No new entry expected. - Do not close or modify existing CLI/MCP/E2E debt entries. -- Any newly discovered doctrine or JSR finding that cannot be fixed inside the twelve-path surface +- Any newly discovered doctrine or JSR finding that cannot be fixed inside the thirteen-path surface is `FAIL_DEBT`/rescope, not an implicit waiver. ## Explicit deferrals / non-scope @@ -199,7 +207,8 @@ already produces them. A receipt proves only its command. Before and after every dependency/version update, public export change, score-algorithm change, or package reshape. - No merge, publish, ready flip, issue checkbox mutation, acceptance-evidence block, or phase relabel. -- No `deno.lock`, cache, generated asset, or receipt implementation change. +- No `deno.lock`, cache, other generated asset, or receipt implementation change; the one granted + generated barrel is regeneration-only during future implementation, never hand-edited. ## PLAN-EVAL judgement @@ -207,5 +216,6 @@ already produces them. A receipt proves only its command. Before and after every an A2 publishable MCP member, a root Deno config boundary, executable docs, JSR audits for two members, bidirectional mutation controls, and marker-aware optimized tooling. A wrong exclusion or path decision can create another false green, and the coordinator explicitly retains plan-gate -authority. The topic supervisor must launch a fresh native opposite-family Fable 5 medium evaluator; -this thread stops after publishing the plan and must not create a self-authored verdict. +authority. Cycle 2 has returned `FAIL_PLAN`, exhausting the ordinary two-cycle allowance. This +repair is handed to Tier-A/owner escalation; this thread must not self-certify, request, or assume a +cycle 3. diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md index f863f3115a..71e6f93d0b 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/research.md @@ -21,42 +21,48 @@ ## Findings -| # | Finding | `file:line` / command evidence | -| --- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -| R1 | `packages/cli` defines its canonical package test as `deno test --allow-all`, so `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` deliberately runs every nested CLI/E2E unit with `packages/cli` as process cwd. | `packages/cli/deno.json:14-22`. | -| R2 | Exactly three tests fail under that cwd. The structured targeted reproduction selected only the three named test files and returned `passed: 3`, `failed: 3`: the documented-stream test cannot read `docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md`; quickstart drift cannot read `docs/site/quickstart.vto`; the service-env script-existence test cannot stat `packages/cli/e2e/.../configure-service-env.ts`. | `run-deno-test.ts --cwd packages/cli -- --allow-all `; test locations below. | -| R3 | The service-env failure is not the subprocess probe. The gate registry intentionally stores `GATE_DIR` relative to repository root and returns a relative script argument for the fixture gate, while the test calls `Deno.stat(script)` directly. The same test already derives `REPO_ROOT` from `import.meta` and uses it for subprocess cwd, so the honest fix is to resolve the asserted command path against that root without changing the production gate command. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates.ts:26-27,46-64`; `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:31-34,96-102,124-143`. | -| R4 | The quickstart drift test directly reads a repo-root-relative string. Its assertion compares every marked shell line with `QUICKSTART_DOCUMENTED_COMMANDS`; only path acquisition is defective. | `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:4-15`. | -| R5 | The documented-stream test calls a helper whose `DOC_PATH` and `.llm/tmp` paths are process-cwd-relative. The failing read is `DOC_PATH`; the helper then extracts and actually imports the published example. Anchoring repository-owned source/scratch paths to a module-derived repo root retains the semantic runtime assertion. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15,21-30,33-39`; `run-documented-stream-example_test.ts:4-35`. | -| R6 | The malformed MCP fixture is deliberate and exactly malformed as reported: `workspace` is a string, while Deno expects an array/object workspace config. The doctor test reads the fixture by module-derived absolute path and asserts `deno_workspace: fail`; changing the fixture would destroy the test. | `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json:1`; `packages/mcp/tests/doctor-families_test.ts:10-33`; `project-wiring-doctor-family.ts:78-87`. | -| R7 | The exact formatter reproduction selects 115 TS/TSX files, exits 1, reports one failed batch and zero findings, then identifies a config-parse crash. Wrapper-level `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'` selects 110 files and exits 0. Passing explicit `--config deno.json` selects all 115 and exits 0 because it disables nested auto-discovery. | Research commands recorded in this session; wrapper filtering and explicit-config support are at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:67-87,103-201,255-301,312-331`; crash refusal at `:370-415,439-488`. | -| R8 | **Falsified by execution:** root `exclude` is a real directory-walk boundary, but it does not satisfy the acceptance command. Both optimized wrappers perform their own selection and pass explicit files; Deno then resolves the nearest config for each named file. Root exclusion remains defensible only as non-load-bearing protection for native directory walks. | Evaluator proof in `plan-eval.md` §1; fmt selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:263-301,312-331`; lint selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts:268-306,329-335`; baseline exact commands in `worklog.md`. | -| R9 | Root `fmt:check` already excludes the doctor fixture at the wrapper-selection layer, which is why only editing that task would not fix the acceptance command and would leave the false-green blind spot. | `deno.json:139-148` versus the exact issue command with no `--exclude`. | -| R10 | `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap` is a typed exported internal-module policy value of `0.5`. `orderGuidanceSections` first sorts by route/score/identity, then groups candidates whose score is at most that value below the group leader, and reorders each close group by slug. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:20-44,181-211`. | -| R11 | The only close-score unit uses a 10.4 leader and 9.8 `outside-leader-band`, but that candidate's `pages/gamma` slug already sorts last. Widening the band therefore does not alter the asserted order. No just-inside control exists either, so narrowing is also unpinned. | `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`; live #1622 mutation evidence reports `0.5 -> 5` remained green. | -| R12 | The empirical rationale can be made exact without inventing score-scale meaning: the observed pair's gap is about `0.3019801981861221`; `0.5` leaves `0.1980198018138779` headroom, about 2.6 times the observed regeneration movement `0.0748587451731435`. | Live #1622 body; policy definition `guidance-index.ts:33-44`. | -| R13 | The full repository has no other deliberately malformed `workspace: "packages/*"` fixture. The healthy MCP sibling correctly uses an array. | `rg` over `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, `.llm/tools/**`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1`. | -| R14 | Child-only marker scope plus nearest-config batching correctly selects 114 files and isolates the malformed config crash. Lint is green. Fmt then reports exactly one real finding on `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`. There is no style conflict: `healthy/deno.json` has a valid workspace and no fmt options; the source is simply unformatted (one-line object and single quotes). Three of the four healthy TS files already format cleanly. | Executed `git archive HEAD` prototype recorded in `worklog.md`; healthy config/source at `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1` and `netscript.config.ts:1`. | -| R15 | Parent-family skip is rejected: it selected 110 by silently removing the marked broken file and all four unmarked healthy files. The honest mechanism is `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` on its own `broken/` subtree plus grouping by effective nearest config. The coordinator granted the twelfth formatting-only path because the real 114-file finding should be fixed, not hidden. After the scratch normalization, both exact no-extra-flag wrappers are green at 114 in two config batches, doctor is 4/4, and the original/formatted module exports compare equal. | Executed archive matrices, named four-file selection probes, and one-file semantic/diff proof in `worklog.md`; no checkout product/config file was edited. | +| # | Finding | `file:line` / command evidence | +| --- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| R1 | `packages/cli` defines its canonical package test as `deno test --allow-all`, so `deno task --cwd packages/cli test` deliberately runs every nested CLI/E2E unit with `packages/cli` as process cwd. | `packages/cli/deno.json:14-22`. | +| R2 | Exactly three tests fail under that cwd. The structured targeted reproduction selected only the three named test files and returned `passed: 3`, `failed: 3`: the documented-stream test cannot read `docs/site/durable-workflows/streams.md`; quickstart drift cannot read `docs/site/quickstart.vto`; the service-env script-existence test cannot stat `packages/cli/e2e/.../configure-service-env.ts`. | `run-deno-test.ts --cwd packages/cli -- --allow-all `; test locations below. | +| R3 | The service-env failure is not the subprocess probe. The gate registry intentionally stores `GATE_DIR` relative to repository root and returns a relative script argument for the fixture gate, while the test calls `Deno.stat(script)` directly. The same test already derives `REPO_ROOT` from `import.meta` and uses it for subprocess cwd, so the honest fix is to resolve the asserted command path against that root without changing the production gate command. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates.ts:26-27,46-64`; `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/service-env/service-env-gates_test.ts:31-34,96-102,124-143`. | +| R4 | The quickstart drift test directly reads a repo-root-relative string. Its assertion compares every marked shell line with `QUICKSTART_DOCUMENTED_COMMANDS`; only path acquisition is defective. | `packages/cli/e2e/tests/presentation/quickstart-command-drift_test.ts:4-15`. | +| R5 | The documented-stream test calls a helper whose `DOC_PATH` and `.llm/tmp` paths are process-cwd-relative. The failing read is `DOC_PATH`; the helper then extracts and actually imports the published example. Anchoring repository-owned source/scratch paths to a module-derived repo root retains the semantic runtime assertion. | `packages/cli/e2e/src/application/gates/scaffold/run-documented-stream-example.ts:1-15,21-30,33-39`; `run-documented-stream-example_test.ts:4-35`. | +| R6 | The malformed MCP fixture is deliberate and exactly malformed as reported: `workspace` is a string, while Deno expects an array/object workspace config. The doctor test reads the fixture by module-derived absolute path and asserts `deno_workspace: fail`; changing the fixture would destroy the test. | `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/broken/deno.json:1`; `packages/mcp/tests/doctor-families_test.ts:10-33`; `project-wiring-doctor-family.ts:78-87`. | +| R7 | The exact formatter reproduction selects 115 TS/TSX files, exits 1, reports one failed batch and zero findings, then identifies a config-parse crash. Wrapper-level `--exclude '^packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/'` selects 110 files and exits 0. Passing explicit `--config deno.json` selects all 115 and exits 0 because it disables nested auto-discovery. | Research commands recorded in this session; wrapper filtering and explicit-config support are at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:67-87,103-201,255-301,312-331`; crash refusal at `:370-415,439-488`. | +| R8 | **Falsified by execution:** root `exclude` is a real directory-walk boundary, but it does not satisfy the acceptance command. Both optimized wrappers perform their own selection and pass explicit files; Deno then resolves the nearest config for each named file. Root exclusion remains defensible only as non-load-bearing protection for native directory walks. | Evaluator proof in `plan-eval.md` §1; fmt selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts:263-301,312-331`; lint selector/argv at `.llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts:268-306,329-335`; baseline exact commands in `worklog.md`. | +| R9 | Root `fmt:check` already excludes the doctor fixture at the wrapper-selection layer, which is why only editing that task would not fix the acceptance command and would leave the false-green blind spot. | `deno.json:139-148` versus the exact issue command with no `--exclude`. | +| R10 | `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY.closeScoreGap` is a typed exported internal-module policy value of `0.5`. `orderGuidanceSections` first sorts by route/score/identity, then groups candidates whose score is at most that value below the group leader, and reorders each close group by slug. | `packages/mcp/src/domain/docs/guidance-index.ts:20-44,181-211`. | +| R11 | The only close-score unit uses a 10.4 leader and 9.8 `outside-leader-band`, but that candidate's `pages/gamma` slug already sorts last. Widening the band therefore does not alter the asserted order. No just-inside control exists either, so narrowing is also unpinned. | `packages/mcp/tests/guidance-retrieval_test.ts:76-95`; live #1622 mutation evidence reports `0.5 -> 5` remained green. | +| R12 | The empirical rationale can be made exact without inventing score-scale meaning: the observed pair's gap is about `0.3019801981861221`; `0.5` leaves `0.1980198018138779` headroom, about 2.6 times the observed regeneration movement `0.0748587451731435`. | Live #1622 body; policy definition `guidance-index.ts:33-44`. | +| R13 | The full repository has no other deliberately malformed `workspace: "packages/*"` fixture. The healthy MCP sibling correctly uses an array. | `rg` over `packages/**`, `plugins/**`, `.llm/tools/**`; `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1`. | +| R14 | Child-only marker scope plus nearest-config batching correctly selects 114 files and isolates the malformed config crash. Lint is green. Fmt then reports exactly one real finding on `doctor/healthy/netscript.config.ts`. The bytes are valid under root style (`singleQuote: true`, `lineWidth: 100`) but invalid under the effective fixture-local config: `healthy/deno.json` has no `fmt` options, so Deno defaults (double quotes, width 80) apply. The fixture's own config is authoritative under nearest-config semantics; three of its four TS files already pass those defaults. | Executed `git archive HEAD` prototype and evaluator control in `worklog.md` / `plan-eval.md` §5; root options at `deno.json`, healthy config/source at `packages/mcp/tests/fixtures/doctor/healthy/deno.json:1` and `netscript.config.ts:1`. | +| R15 | Parent-family skip is rejected: it selected 110 by silently removing the marked broken file and all four unmarked healthy files. The honest mechanism is `.deno-fmt-lint-ignore` on its own `broken/` subtree plus grouping by effective nearest config. The coordinator granted the twelfth formatting-only path because the real 114-file finding should be fixed, not hidden. After the scratch normalization, both exact no-extra-flag wrappers are green at 114 in two config batches, doctor is 4/4, and the original/formatted module exports compare equal. | Executed archive matrices, named four-file selection probes, and one-file semantic/diff proof in `worklog.md`; no checkout product/config file was edited. | +| R16 | `run-deno-lint.ts` is a consumer-installed tool embedded verbatim in published `@netscript/cli` source. A full archive-copy control regenerated identically; substituting the planned lint prototype and running the canonical generator changed only `agent-tools.generated.ts`, including embedded nearest-config text and `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH`. CI's generated-asset freshness job runs `deno task check:assets-barrel`, so omitting the generated barrel would make the planned implementation red and misstate the consumer delta. | `.llm/tools/consumer-tools.json:18-22`; `.llm/tools/generate-cli-assets-barrel.ts:325`; `packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts:15-16,44,54-55`; `.github/workflows/ci.yml:376-381`; executed cycle-2 evaluator proof in `plan-eval.md` §7. | ## jsr-audit surface scan -JSR audit is applicable because the plan touches two publishable workspace members, even though the -CLI edits are under its publish-excluded E2E harness and MCP's public export map does not change. +JSR audit is applicable because the plan touches two publishable workspace members. The public +export maps do not change, but the CLI's published generated asset does. ### `@netscript/cli` - Export map: `.`, `./scaffolding`, and `./testing`; binary `netscript` (`packages/cli/deno.json:6-13`). -- Planned edits are only under `packages/cli/e2e/**`, which the publish allow/exclude rules omit - (`packages/cli/deno.json:57-76`). No public symbol, export key, binary, or publish asset changes. +- The three CLI test/helper edits remain under publish-excluded `packages/cli/e2e/**`, but the + planned lint-wrapper edit is embedded into published `src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts` + (`packages/cli/deno.json:57-76`). Canonical regeneration changes the embedded tool text and + `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH`; no public symbol, export key, or binary-command shape changes. + An upgrading consumer receives the new marker-aware and nearest-config-batched lint selection + behavior. - Exact internal `@netscript/*` pins are all `0.0.6`: aspire, config, fresh-ui, mcp, plugin, and sdk (`packages/cli/deno.json:23-29`). No dependency edit is planned. - Existing debt: package `isolatedDeclarations` is false (`packages/cli/deno.json:46-55`) and the public doc-lint completeness debt remains open (`arch-debt.md:870-885`). This leaf must not claim to close it or weaken the existing publish task. -- Runtime asset / `import.meta` rule: module-relative reads are confined to publish-excluded E2E - tests/helpers. No new read or `import.meta` use may enter the published CLI graph. +- Runtime asset / `import.meta` rule: the consumer tool remains embedded as a generated TypeScript + string constant. Module-relative reads stay confined to publish-excluded E2E tests/helpers; no + runtime file read, import attribute, or top-level `import.meta` may enter the published graph. ### `@netscript/mcp` @@ -78,10 +84,11 @@ CLI edits are under its publish-excluded E2E harness and MCP's public export map ### Planned JSR gates For both members: full export-map `doc:lint`; `audit-jsr-package.ts`; exact-pin scan; root -isolated-declaration check/publish simulation; and member/root publish dry-run. Inspect publish file -lists and fail on any new runtime asset read, top-level `import.meta`/`fromFileUrl`, self-bare -import, slow type, or non-exact `@netscript/*` dependency. Existing documented CLI debt is baseline, -not a waiver for a new finding. +isolated-declaration check/publish simulation; and member/root publish dry-run. For CLI, canonical +`gen:assets-barrel` plus `check:assets-barrel` must prove generated freshness, and the publish list +must include the intended embedded-text/hash delta. Fail on any new runtime asset read, top-level +`import.meta`/`fromFileUrl`, self-bare import, slow type, or non-exact `@netscript/*` dependency. +Existing documented CLI debt is baseline, not a waiver for a new finding. ## Open questions diff --git a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md index 2392b4d069..71c8f5e1a7 100644 --- a/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md +++ b/.llm/runs/release-0.0.7-internals--orchestration/slices/package-gate-honesty/worklog.md @@ -14,14 +14,18 @@ ### Public surface - No package export, subpath, symbol, binary, or command name changes. -- `@netscript/cli` changes remain under publish-excluded `e2e/`. +- `@netscript/cli` has an intentional published-byte delta: canonical regeneration embeds the + changed consumer `run-deno-lint.ts` and updates `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH`; an upgrading + consumer receives marker-aware, nearest-config-batched lint selection. - `@netscript/mcp` keeps `GUIDANCE_RANKING_POLICY` internal to its source graph; only the rationale comment and test change. -- Root Deno configuration may carry the doctor-family exclusion only as non-load-bearing protection - for native directory walks. +- Root Deno configuration carries the top-level doctor-family exclusion to stop raw root formatter + walks from reverting fixture-local-default formatting, but removes the `fmt:check` task's + wrapper-level family exclusion. The top-level entry does not satisfy standalone wrapper + acceptance. - The optimized fmt/lint wrappers gain two shared conventions: a marker excludes only its own subtree, and selected files are grouped by effective nearest Deno config before explicit argv is - built. + built. Nearest-config lookup is memoized per normalized directory before root-scale use. ### Domain vocabulary @@ -47,19 +51,20 @@ ### Commit slices -| # | Slice | Gate | Exact files | -| -- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------- | -| S1 | Make optimized MCP fmt/lint selection marker- and config-aware while retaining every unmarked sibling. | Both exact wrappers green at 114 + marked/unmarked/config-batch tests + negative controls + doctor/semantic proof. | Seven exact S1 paths in `plan.md` | -| S2 | Make all three CLI tests package-cwd independent without weakening assertions. | Structured targeted 6/6 + exact package task + docs gates; final runtime consumer in S4. | Three exact CLI files in `plan.md` | -| S3 | Pin close-score policy on both sides and record rationale. | Targeted test + widen/narrow RED controls + scoped MCP/quality gates. | `guidance-index.ts`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | -| S4 | Integrated evidence for the applicable frozen gate set. | Static/test/docs/publish/JSR gates; `scaffold.runtime` recorded coordinator-waived `n/a`. | Run artifacts/evidence only | +| # | Slice | Gate | Exact files | +| -- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------- | +| S1 | Make optimized MCP fmt/lint selection marker- and config-aware while retaining every unmarked sibling; regenerate the published CLI consumer tool asset. | Both exact wrappers green at 114 + marked/unmarked/config-batch tests + negative controls + doctor/semantic proof + `check:assets-barrel`. | Eight exact S1 paths in `plan.md` | +| S2 | Make all three CLI tests package-cwd independent without weakening assertions. | Structured targeted 6/6 + exact package task + docs gates; final runtime consumer in S4. | Three exact CLI files in `plan.md` | +| S3 | Pin close-score policy on both sides and record rationale. | Targeted test + widen/narrow RED controls + scoped MCP/quality gates. | `guidance-index.ts`; `guidance-retrieval_test.ts` | +| S4 | Integrated evidence for the applicable frozen gate set. | Static/test/docs/publish/JSR/generated-asset freshness gates; `scaffold.runtime` recorded coordinator-waived `n/a`. | Run artifacts/evidence only | ### Deferred scope -- Any thirteenth product/config path, other wrapper/CI change, docs edit, malformed-fixture repair, +- Any fourteenth product/config path, other wrapper/CI change, docs edit, malformed-fixture repair, public API change, dependency update, or algorithm change. - `scaffold.runtime`, Aspire, Docker, and `e2e:cli`; the gate is waived `n/a`, not pending. -- All implementation until separate-session PLAN-EVAL `PASS`. +- All implementation until Tier-A/owner escalation disposes the cycle-2 `FAIL_PLAN`; no cycle 3 is + requested or assumed. ### Contributor path @@ -70,28 +75,31 @@ score order. Then prove both green behavior and a controlled red mutation throug ## Progress log -| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | -| ---------- | --------- | -------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| 2026-08-15 | bootstrap | activated | Exact worktree/branch/base verified; coordinator thread record preserved; commit `25c29575c`; draft PR #1663 opened. | -| 2026-08-15 | research | live issue/source read | All three issues fetched live; exact three-test reproduction returned 3 pass / 3 fail from package cwd. | -| 2026-08-15 | research | fmt controls | Baseline exact command: 115 selected, config crash; wrapper exclude: 110 selected/green; explicit root config: 115 selected/green. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan | Design checkpoint | Six-file authoritative surface locked; formal PLAN-EVAL selected; implementation remains prohibited. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan-eval | cycle 1 | `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit `be2b18728`: root `exclude` cannot affect explicit wrapper argv; no product/config implementation occurred. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan | coordinator rescope | Authority expanded to eleven exact paths: fmt/lint wrappers + tests and one marker; `scaffold.runtime` waived `n/a`. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan | rejected proof draft | Parent-family marker made both wrappers green at 110 by excluding four unmarked healthy files; coordinator rejected it before push as a silent false-positive exclusion. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan | corrected mechanism proof | Child-only marker + nearest-config batching selects 114: lint green, fmt one honest healthy-fixture finding, doctor 4/4, negative controls red, restorations byte-exact. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan | twelfth-path scratch proof | Formatting only `healthy/netscript.config.ts` makes exact fmt green at 114; lint and doctor remain green. Checkout path untouched pending grant. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan | twelfth-path grant | Coordinator authorized that exact formatting-only path, bringing planned implementation to twelve paths; no semantic/config-value change and no thirteenth path. | -| 2026-08-15 | plan | final 114-file proof | Both exact no-extra-flag wrappers green; all four healthy TS files individually named selected; doctor/parsed meaning/hash/negative-control requirements proved. | +| Time | Slice | Step | Notes | +| ---------- | --------- | -------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | +| 2026-08-15 | bootstrap | activated | Exact worktree/branch/base verified; coordinator thread record preserved; commit `25c29575c`; draft PR #1663 opened. | +| 2026-08-15 | research | live issue/source read | All three issues fetched live; exact three-test reproduction returned 3 pass / 3 fail from package cwd. | +| 2026-08-15 | research | fmt controls | Baseline exact command: 115 selected, config crash; wrapper exclude: 110 selected/green; explicit root config: 115 selected/green. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | Design checkpoint | Six-file authoritative surface locked; formal PLAN-EVAL selected; implementation remains prohibited. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan-eval | cycle 1 | `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit `be2b18728`: root `exclude` cannot affect explicit wrapper argv; no product/config implementation occurred. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | coordinator rescope | Authority expanded to eleven exact paths: fmt/lint wrappers + tests and one marker; `scaffold.runtime` waived `n/a`. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | rejected proof draft | Parent-family marker made both wrappers green at 110 by excluding four unmarked healthy files; coordinator rejected it before push as a silent false-positive exclusion. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | corrected mechanism proof | Child-only marker + nearest-config batching selects 114: lint green, fmt one honest healthy-fixture finding, doctor 4/4, negative controls red, restorations byte-exact. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | twelfth-path scratch proof | Formatting only `healthy/netscript.config.ts` makes exact fmt green at 114; lint and doctor remain green. Checkout path untouched pending grant. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | twelfth-path grant | Coordinator authorized that exact formatting-only path, bringing the then-current bound to twelve; no semantic/config-value change. Cycle-2 F1 later superseded that bound. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | final 114-file proof | Both exact no-extra-flag wrappers green; all four healthy TS files individually named selected; doctor/parsed meaning/hash/negative-control requirements proved. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan-eval | cycle 2 | `FAIL_PLAN` at evaluator commit `c415daad2`: planned lint-wrapper bytes also ship in the published CLI asset barrel; ordinary two-cycle allowance exhausted. | +| 2026-08-15 | plan | thirteenth-path grant | Coordinator granted canonical regeneration of exactly `agent-tools.generated.ts`, required generated-asset freshness, removal of the root task-level parent skip, corrected fixture-style wording, and nearest-config memoization. No implementation file changed. | ## Decisions -| Decision | Reason | Source | -| ------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | -| Child-only marker + nearest-config batching | Only the marked broken subtree may leave selection; grouping prevents config poisoning while keeping all four healthy files visible. | plan L3/L4; corrected pre-plan proof | -| Module-derived paths | Package cwd is the defect; module location is stable. | plan L1/L2 | -| Bidirectional score controls | Current identity ordering masks both threshold directions. | research R10-R12; plan L5/L6 | -| Formal PLAN-EVAL | Multi-member/config/docs/JSR/runtime interactions are decision-heavy. | run-loop §4; plan judgement | +| Decision | Reason | Source | +| ---------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | +| Child-only marker + memoized nearest-config batching | Only the marked broken subtree may leave selection; grouping prevents config poisoning while keeping all four healthy files visible, and directory memoization makes the same rule viable at root scale. | plan L3/L4/L11; corrected pre-plan proof | +| Canonically regenerated published lint asset | `run-deno-lint.ts` is embedded in published CLI source; freshness and consumer behavior must be explicit. | cycle-2 F1; plan L7 | +| Module-derived paths | Package cwd is the defect; module location is stable. | plan L1/L2 | +| Bidirectional score controls | Current identity ordering masks both threshold directions. | research R10-R12; plan L5/L6 | +| Formal PLAN-EVAL | Multi-member/config/docs/JSR/runtime interactions are decision-heavy. | run-loop §4; plan judgement | ## Drift @@ -105,6 +113,8 @@ score order. Then prove both green behavior and a controlled red mutation throug | Parent-family 110-file draft silently removed four unmarked healthy files and was rejected before push. | significant plan correction | yes | | One genuine healthy-fixture fmt finding exposed a twelfth-path repair; proof led to an exact formatting-only grant. | significant resolved rescope | yes | | Coordinator granted the exact formatting-only twelfth path after the honest 114-file finding. | significant authorized rescope | yes | +| Cycle 2 exposed the published lint-wrapper asset and generated freshness gate omitted by the twelve-path plan. | significant plan correction | yes | +| Coordinator granted the generated barrel as exact path thirteen and ruled on root task exclusion/style wording. | significant authorized rescope | yes | ## Gate results @@ -158,10 +168,13 @@ independently create a marked subtree and an equivalent unmarked sibling; count/ require child-only skip, unmarked-sibling selection, and separate nearest-config batches in both tools. -The original fmt finding is not a config-style conflict. `healthy/deno.json` contains a valid -workspace and no fmt options. Three healthy TS files already pass; `healthy/netscript.config.ts` is -simply unformatted. The coordinator granted this exact formatting-only twelfth path after the -scratch proof. The planned change is exactly: +The original bytes are correctly formatted under root options (`singleQuote: true`, width 100), but +the wrapper correctly applies `healthy/deno.json` as the nearest authoritative config. Because that +fixture config has no `fmt` options, Deno defaults (double quotes, width 80) apply and the same +bytes are fixture-local-default-style-invalid. Three healthy TS files already pass those defaults. +The coordinator granted this exact formatting-only twelfth path after the scratch proof. The +top-level root exclusion is retained so raw root formatter walks cannot flip the normalized file +back to root style. The planned change is exactly: ```diff -const config: { readonly plugins: readonly string[] } = { plugins: ['workers'] }; @@ -171,8 +184,23 @@ scratch proof. The planned change is exactly: export default config; ``` -The checkout path remains untouched in this plan-only pass. The grant expands implementation -authority after Tier-A and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`; it does not authorize pre-gate tree mutation. +The checkout path remains untouched in this plan-only pass. The grant expands planned surface only; +it does not authorize pre-gate tree mutation. + +### Executed generated-asset consequence (cycle-2 archive copy, not checkout) + +The separate evaluator ran the canonical generator in a full `git archive HEAD` copy. The control +barrel matched HEAD byte-for-byte. Replacing only the scratch copy of the planned `run-deno-lint.ts` +prototype and running `deno task gen:assets-barrel` exited 0 and changed only +`packages/cli/src/kernel/assets/agent-tools.generated.ts` among generated assets: + +- embedded `run-deno-lint.ts` text gained marker and nearest-config batching semantics; +- `EMBEDDED_AGENT_TOOL_BUNDLE_HASH` changed; +- `embedded.generated.ts` and `skills.generated.ts` stayed unchanged; +- CI's independent freshness verdict is `deno task check:assets-barrel`. + +This proof is recorded at `plan-eval.md` §7. The checkout generated file remains untouched. Future +implementation must regenerate it canonically and never hand-edit it. ### Static gates @@ -182,10 +210,10 @@ authority after Tier-A and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`; it does not authorize pre-g ### Fitness gates -| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | -| ---------------- | --------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -| Plan-Gate | cycle 1 `FAIL_PLAN` | `plan-eval.md` at evaluator commit `be2b18728` | Plan repaired for required separate-session cycle 2; implementation remains blocked. | -| JSR surface scan | PASS (planning input) | `research.md` JSR section | No public delta; both members still receive full planned audits. | +| Gate | Result | Evidence | Notes | +| ---------------- | --------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | +| Plan-Gate | cycle 2 `FAIL_PLAN` | `plan-eval.md` at evaluator commit `c415daad2` | Ordinary two-cycle allowance exhausted; plan repaired for Tier-A/owner escalation, with no cycle 3 requested. | +| JSR surface scan | PASS (planning input) | `research.md` JSR section | No export/API shape delta, but the published CLI embedded tool text/hash delta is now explicit; both members receive full planned audits. | ### Runtime gates @@ -201,9 +229,9 @@ authority after Tier-A and PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 `PASS`; it does not authorize pre-g ## Handoff notes -- Tier-A should review the now-reachable twelve-path plan. PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 should inspect L3's - child-only marker plus nearest-config batching, the four-file unmarked-sibling evidence, the - formatting-only semantic equality proof, the two-direction score controls, and the honest - treatment of existing CLI JSR debt. -- No implementation authority exists before fresh Tier-A and cycle-2 `PASS`. The topic supervisor - owns that review/evaluator launch; `scaffold.runtime` is waived and must not run. +- Tier-A should review the repaired thirteen-path plan: child-only marker plus memoized + nearest-config batching, all four healthy files retained, fixture-local-default normalization, + task-level parent exclusion removed, and canonical published-asset regeneration/freshness. +- No implementation authority exists until Tier-A/owner escalation disposes the exhausted cycle-2 + `FAIL_PLAN`. This thread does not request or assume cycle 3; `scaffold.runtime` is waived and must + not run.