Skip to content

chore: drop the dev-agent scratch report that rode into main with #616 - #618

Open
lis186 wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
chore/remove-report-611
Open

lis186 wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
chore/remove-report-611

Conversation

@lis186

@lis186 lis186 commented Sep 3, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

摘要(繁中)

REPORT-611.md#611 實作端的驗證報告草稿,隨 #616 誤入 main。派工 prompt 明寫「untracked is fine」,但沒有任何機制保證,我也沒在 commit 前查——所以它被一起 commit 了。本 PR 刪除它,並加上 REPORT-*.md.gitignore,讓那句話由結構保證而非靠 agent 記得。

Why remove rather than keep

  • Nothing references it: grep -rn 'REPORT-611' --include='*.{js,json,md,sh}' returns zero outside the file itself.
  • Its content is already in the PR body of feat(index): per-session Claude launch account snapshot (accountEmail/accountDomain) #616 — guard-by-guard commands, exit codes, the explicit "not verified" list. The PR body is where a reviewer actually looks; a stray root-level markdown file invites the next reader to wonder whether it is maintained.
  • It is a point-in-time scratch artifact, and two of its claims were already superseded during review (it reports a suite failure that does not reproduce in a clean env, and predates the two P2 fixes).

Second review

codex-exempt — deletes an unreferenced scratch file and adds one .gitignore
line. No source, no tests, no behaviour. Claiming a cross-model review ran would
be noise; the exemption is recorded so the merge hook sees a decision rather than
an omission.

Verification

  • grep for references across *.js, *.json, *.md, *.sh: 0 outside the file.
  • git ls-files --error-unmatch REPORT-611.md: tracked (so the deletion is real, not a no-op on an already-ignored path).
  • Nothing imports or reads it, so no test can regress; the full suite is unchanged by construction.

Not verified: I did not re-run the full suite for a file-deletion-plus-gitignore change, since no code path can reach a root markdown file. CI covers it.

REPORT-611.md was the implementer's verification write-up for #611. The
dispatch prompt asked for it explicitly and said "untracked is fine", but
nothing enforced that, so it was committed with the feature and rode into
main via #616.

It is scratch: no source or test references it (grep across js/json/md/sh
returns zero), and its content -- guard-by-guard commands, exit codes, a
"not verified" list -- is already in the PR body, which is where a reviewer
looks. Leaving it would make the next reader wonder whether it is a
maintained document.

Also adds REPORT-*.md to .gitignore so the next dispatch cannot repeat this:
the prompt's "untracked is fine" is now true by construction rather than by
the agent remembering.

No behaviour change; the file was never loaded by anything.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant