Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
89 changes: 89 additions & 0 deletions .llm/runs/fix-1377-gate--leaf/context-pack.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,89 @@
# Context Pack: #1377 gate half

## Run Metadata

| Field | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Run ID | `fix-1377-gate--leaf` |
| Branch | `fix/1377-docs-reference-gate-scope` |
| Current phase | `implement` — S3 complete; IMPL-EVAL pending |
| Archetype | 6 — CLI / tooling |
| Scope overlays | Docs |

## Current State

Fallback PLAN-EVAL cycle 1 returned `FAIL_PLAN` on `5ba4bc339`; cycle 2 returned `PASS` on
`706c2bf05`. S1–S3 are implemented and gate-green. The implementation retains the confirmed alias
and whole-publish-set design, locks command coverage to the exact two-page union, requires
structural root matching plus tokenized path resolution and exact equality with 91 root/direct
obligations, and includes only the four authorised deploy rows as bounded prose scope.

## Completed

- Required skills and harness policy read.
- `supervisor.md` created first.
- Carried research, live #1377, comments, merged PR-C #1541, reference index, release tool/tests,
docs checker/tests, and live public command catalog inspected.
- 35/35 alias-resolved reference arrival coverage verified.
- FAIL_PLAN B1–B3 and non-blocking findings resolved in the revised plan.
- Native Opus 5 fallback PLAN-EVAL cycle 2 passed immutable head `706c2bf05`.
- S1 whole-publish-set reference coverage committed as `dedd7804508f6cbe0d1ce97174cb7642f49dc96a`.
- S2 tree-derived command coverage committed as `29557faa858e832d8cabdc452ed4692ae26031e2`.
- Both raw negative controls exited 1 and named the missing page/command.
- S3 composed gates passed, including publish dry-run with no worktree churn and the full repository
suite with 3,258 passed, 0 failed, and 17 ignored.

## In Progress

- Final run-artifact commit, explicit push, PR/issue evidence update, then stop.

## Next Steps

1. Commit and push the final S3 evidence.
2. Update PR #1586 and truthfully tick #1377's completed gate rows, leaving the post-merge row
unticked.
3. Stop for orchestrator-dispatched native Opus 5 IMPL-EVAL on the final immutable head.

## Key Decisions

| Decision | Source | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Alias map | `plan.md` D-1 | Four exact deployable-plugin aliases; no URL moves |
| Whole-set placement | `plan.md` D-2 | Directly after publish-set; separate evidence row |
| Release unblock | `plan.md` D-3 | Canonical page or explicit tracked stub; no bypass |
| Command coverage | `plan.md` D-4–D-8 | Materialized tree, two-page union, structural/tokenized match, colon-safe, exact 91 obligations |
| Prose unblock | `plan.md` D-9 | Four bounded deploy lifecycle rows are S2 scope |

## Files Changed

- S1: release readiness tool/test, reference index convention, and run artifacts including
`plan-eval.md`.
- S2: docs accuracy tool/test, four deploy command rows, exact two-page union wording including the
two authorised `cli-reference.md` sentences, reference-index command contract, and run artifacts.

## Gates

| Gate family | Current status | Evidence |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Plan | PASS | Native Opus 5 fallback, cycle 2, head `706c2bf05` |
| Static / Fitness | PASS | Release wrappers: 42 files; docs wrappers: 22 files; 0 findings |
| Docs / Release | PASS | Accuracy 91/91 from 149; links 102/0/0; publish dry-run exit 0 with clean status |
| Negative controls | COMPLETE | Both raw controls exited 1 with required diagnostics |
| Repository tests | PASS | 3,258 passed (622 steps), 0 failed, 17 ignored in 8m46s |

Gate counts, raw exits, and diagnostics are recorded in `worklog.md`.

## Open Questions

- None for implementation design; no external content predecessor remains.

## Drift and Debt

- Drift: PLAN-EVAL correction recorded append-only in `drift.md`.
- Debt: none created.

## Commits

- `dedd7804508f6cbe0d1ce97174cb7642f49dc96a` — S1 whole-publish-set reference audit.
- `29557faa858e832d8cabdc452ed4692ae26031e2` — S2 public-tree command-reference audit.
- S3 evidence commit: pending final sign-off commit.
49 changes: 49 additions & 0 deletions .llm/runs/fix-1377-gate--leaf/drift.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,49 @@
# Drift Log: #1377 gate half

Append-only.

## 2026-08-12 — strict direct-subcommand census finds four additional prose gaps

- **What:** Executing the existing public command catalog and checking root/immediate-child paths
against the public CLI reference surfaces found four paths with no exact occurrence:
`netscript deploy start`, `netscript deploy stop`, `netscript deploy status`, and
`netscript deploy uninstall`.
- **Source:** `createPublicCommandRegistry()` materialized through `PublicCliCommandCatalog`; focused
search over `docs/site/reference/cli/commands.md`, `docs/site/cli-reference.md`, and `docs/site`.
- **Expected:** PR-C had landed all content required for the strict subcommand gate to be green.
- **Actual:** 87 of 91 root/direct-child paths have an exact occurrence; these four do not.
- **Severity:** significant.
- **Action:** defer to PR-C/orchestrator as a sequencing dependency. PR-D will neither author the
prose nor weaken the predicate. PLAN-EVAL must assess the boundary before implementation.
- **Evidence:** `research.md` finding 9; `plan.md` D-7.

## 2026-08-12 — PLAN-EVAL corrects corpus scope, unblock ownership, and path-consumer premise

- **What:** The first plan left the command corpus implicit, treated four missing deploy rows as an
ownerless external dependency, and inherited a false claim that the accuracy checker hardcodes
the short sagas reference path.
- **Source:** fallback PLAN-EVAL `FAIL_PLAN` on `5ba4bc339`; independently confirmed corpus counts
25/25/4 and checker search.
- **Expected:** A decision-complete plan whose S2 can reach green and whose alias decision rests on
true consumers.
- **Actual:** `commands.md` and `cli-reference.md` each miss 25/91 while their union misses 4/91;
no open content owner existed; `check-accuracy-and-discoverability.ts` has no sagas path.
- **Severity:** significant.
- **Action:** fix. Lock the two-page union, ratify it in the reference index, let S2 add the four
bounded rows, require structural longest-path matching and exact 91 equality, and restate the
alias rationale without the retracted premise. This entry supersedes the earlier action that
deferred the four rows externally; the original finding remains as historical provenance.
- **Evidence:** revised `research.md` findings 9/11 and `plan.md` D-1/D-4/D-6–D-9 on the
superseding plan head.

## 2026-08-12 — cloud evaluators stalled; native fallback completed PLAN-EVAL

- **What:** Forward-looking run artifacts named an automatic status-driven evaluator and paid
retrigger that did not complete either plan cycle.
- **Source:** orchestrator Phase-2 resume after native Opus 5 read-only fallback verdicts.
- **Expected:** A separate evaluator verdict for each immutable plan head.
- **Actual:** Cloud evaluators stalled and were cancelled; the orchestrator dispatched native Opus 5
fallbacks without label cycling. Cycle 1 failed `5ba4bc339`; cycle 2 passed `706c2bf05`.
- **Severity:** procedural.
- **Action:** correct active routing instructions and preserve both verdicts in `plan-eval.md`.
- **Evidence:** `supervisor.md`, `plan-eval.md`, `worklog.md`, and `context-pack.md`.
41 changes: 41 additions & 0 deletions .llm/runs/fix-1377-gate--leaf/plan-eval.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
# PLAN-EVAL — fix-1377-gate--leaf

- Plan evaluator: native Claude · Anthropic · Opus 5 read-only fallback
- Run: `fix-1377-gate--leaf`
- Surface / archetype: release tooling and public CLI docs gate / Archetype 6
- Scope overlay: docs
- Dispatch: orchestrator-dispatched per immutable head; no label cycling or paid retrigger

## Verdict cycles

| Cycle | Immutable head | Verdict | Outcome |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | `5ba4bc339` | `FAIL_PLAN` | Lock the exact command corpus; reconcile the two-page IA contract; give the four missing deploy rows an executable owner; retract the false sagas-path consumer premise; clarify census and matching semantics. |
| 2 | `706c2bf05` | `PASS` | Cycle-1 blockers verified fixed by execution; counts 15 roots / 76 direct children / 91 root+direct / 149 recursive and five colon roots reproduced from the live tree. |

## Cycle 2 checklist results

| Plan-Gate item | Result | Evidence / location |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Research present and current | PASS | `research.md`, including finding 11 retraction |
| Decisions locked | PASS | `plan.md` D-1–D-10 |
| Open-decision sweep | PASS | `plan.md` Open-Decision Sweep |
| Commit slices (< 30, gate + files each) | PASS | `plan.md` S1–S3 |
| Risk register | PASS | `plan.md` Risk Register |
| Gate set selected | PASS | `plan.md` Validation Plan |
| Deferred scope explicit | PASS | `plan.md` Deferred Scope |
| jsr-audit surface scan (pkg/plugin) | N/A | Tooling/docs gate; no package export or manifest surface change |

## Open-decision sweep (evaluator-run)

None. The two-page corpus, alias resolver, whole-publish-set placement, subcommand depth, colon
rendering, exact census, four-row content owner, and raw negative controls are decision-complete.

## Verdict

`PASS`

## Notes

The evaluator confirmed cycle 1's three blockers by executing the live tree/corpus measurements,
not only by reading the revised diff. Implementation was forbidden until this cycle-2 verdict.
Loading
Loading