docs(harness): record DevTools RFC filing ledger - #1523
Merged
Conversation
Proves the one-shot filing happened exactly as ratified, and makes it auditable draft-ID by draft-ID. Filed 14 new issues (#1468-#1481), amended 6 existing via 4 rows, and did not file DT-18 because D-0b was never decided. Epic #400 was AMENDED, not replaced -- a second umbrella would fragment the very board this RFC de-fragments -- with the ownership thesis, the three acceptance lines and the killed-surfaces list preserved VERBATIM. Successor-before-supersede was executed literally: #1471 was filed before #412's supersede comment, and #1472/#1477 before #424's. Both superseded issues stay OPEN and close only on delivery, so no seam is unowned in the interval. Zero filing-time closes. Preservation guarantees verified rather than asserted: #922 and its 24 children received zero changes -- #933 and #944 got nothing, and the only #922-adjacent action anywhere was the single authorized informational cross-post on #929 reporting the .strict() defect that #890's contract C8 rests on. The 2026-07-19 train is intact with no issue re-milestoned. No labels and no milestones were created; the only milestone edit was stripping a stale clause from 0.0.14's description, leaving its 11 issues untouched. Two deviations are recorded rather than hidden: DT-8 was filed as "six-state" because the manifest predates the amendment that added the sixth quarantine state, and bodies cite rfcs/0005 rather than the manifest's rfcs/0000 since the number was assigned at acceptance. Before any issue linked to it, the merged path was verified on origin/main -- a broken permalink in 14 issue bodies is expensive to correct. Refs #1450 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DChBXWYP9LStvjQztUJV5b
rickylabs
added
type:docs
area:docs
priority:p2
rickylabs
marked this pull request as ready for review
August 11, 2026 20:43
Owner
Author
|
@openhands-agent model=openrouter/minimax/minimax-m3 output=pr-comment iterations=400 use harness SKILL
Act as a cheap-and-quick documentation accuracy evaluator. Do not edit source, documentation,
Keep the iteration budget small. Prefer one to three decisive manual checks over broad exploration, |
Owner
Author
OpenHands Agent — CompletedOPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS Model: OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS Documentation accuracy —
|
| File | Verdict | Commands / snippets tested | Observed vs claimed | Blocking findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
.llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/filing/FILING-LOG.md |
accurate | git ls-tree origin/main -- rfcs/ (P0 evidence citation) |
git ls-tree origin/main -- rfcs/ lists rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md as claimed; current origin/main HEAD is 3bd058f55 (the historical claim origin/main = 03680f6e8 is the merge commit at filing time, one commit ahead of the chore(labels) follow-up — consistent with the doc's "Preconditions at filing time" framing) |
none |
Local-repository accuracy checks (all PASS)
| Claim in FILING-LOG | Evidence | Result |
|---|---|---|
RFC file path rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md exists on main |
git ls-tree origin/main -- rfcs/ returns the blob; head rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md shows rfc: 0005, status: Accepted, target-milestone: 0.0.6 |
✅ matches |
| RFC 0005 body is the six-state taxonomy (deviation #1) | grep zone-contract-mismatch rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md → line 1245 + 1351; line 529 says "this RFC's own taxonomy is six"; line 1338 "The six-state taxonomy is adopted" |
✅ matches |
epic:dev-dashboard exists in .github/labels.yml |
grep -c name: epic:dev-dashboard → 1 |
✅ matches |
epic:devtools, area:devtools, area:frontend do NOT exist |
grep -c for each label returns 0 |
✅ matches the claim "do not exist and were not created" |
status:triage exists (one status: per issue at filing) |
.github/labels.yml contains status:triage |
✅ matches |
| Drift IDs D-10, D-11, D-15, D-16, D-18, D-19 exist | grep -nE "D-(10|11|15|16|18|19)" .llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/drift.md returns one heading per ID |
✅ matches |
| Forks F-1, F-3, F-9, F-11 exist | decision-brief.md defines F-9 + F-11 inline; drift.md D-19 RATIFIED F-1 + F-3; filing-manifest.md references F-9 for the no-re-milestone rule and F-11 for the CR-DDX-HOSTAGNOSTIC accept |
✅ matches |
| PR #1450 is the seed-run's draft PR | context-pack.md row "Draft PR [#1450]", filing-manifest.md references PR #1450 throughout, workflows/stage-*-workflow.js references draft PR #1450 |
✅ consistent across run artifacts |
rfcs/0000-<slug>.md → rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md post-acceptance naming (deviation #2) |
grep "rfcs/0000-template.md" rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md shows the RFC's own process note explaining the rename |
✅ matches the recorded deviation |
0.0.6 is RFC 0005's target milestone |
target-milestone: 0.0.6 in rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md frontmatter |
✅ matches DT-RFC row |
rfcs/0000-template.md exists (precondition for the rename narrative) |
ls rfcs/ shows it |
✅ matches |
Branch base is 3bd058f55 (so the 03680f6e8 "filing-time" snapshot is internally consistent) |
git merge-base HEAD origin/main → 3bd058f55; git log origin/main shows the RFC acceptance commit 03680f6e8 as the immediate ancestor of the chore(labels) commit |
✅ consistent |
Unverifiable from local repo (no gh API in this evaluator)
The following claims are about GitHub state and cannot be cross-checked here. They are internally consistent with the run's own artifacts (supervisor.md, context-pack.md, drift.md, filing-manifest.md, workflows/*.js) and follow standard NetScript process, so there is no signal of a hallucination:
- Issue numbers docs(rfc): ratify RFC 0005 — DevTools contribution architecture #1468–fix(fresh-ui): /design ships ungated — the defect class RFC 0005 guards against #1481, Epic: NetScript DevTools contribution and host architecture #400, [dashboard DDX-2] plugin-dashboard-core scaffold + contract seam #412, [dashboard DDX-14] CLI surface + auto-launch #424, [dashboard DDX-17] DashboardPanelContribution seam (.withDashboardPanel) #427, feat(design): Dev Dashboard E2E Claude Design prototype + production design-sync system (tools/design-sync) #507, [process-manager PM-33] DashboardPanelContribution "Process Control" panel #544, feat(plugin): dashboard-panel contribution axis in the plugin manifest #734, [frontend-contrib S7] @netscript/plugin pointer axis (.withFrontend) #929, [frontend-contrib S8] Frontend registry emissions: transactional replace-set #930, [frontend-contrib S11] Workers dogfood: zone panel + console route + island #933, [frontend-contrib S12] Generated deny-by-default procedure gateway #934, [frontend-contrib S15] Doctor frontend check + five-state taxonomy #937, [frontend-contrib S16] Quarantine render states + provenance chrome #938, [frontend-contrib S22] Sagas/triggers/streams dashboard-zone panels #944, RFC: Frontend Contribution Layer — plugins that ship UI (dashboard · auth · ai · deploy) #890, Epic: NetScript Process Manager — bare-metal supervisor + admin console (pup/pm2 done right) #510, [dashboard DDX-4] plugins/dashboard thin plugin + E2E join #414, [dashboard DDX-5] Fresh build-console shell + app-registration + IA #415, [dashboard DDX-10] Plugin Control host + registry/overview #420, [dashboard DDX-13] Introspection endpoint (/_netscript/*) #423, [dashboard DDX-16] E2E dashboard join + panel smoke #426, [dashboard DDX-18a] workers per-capability dashboard section #428, [dashboard DDX-18b] sagas per-capability dashboard section #429, [dashboard DDX-18c] triggers per-capability dashboard section #430, [dashboard DDX-18d] streams per-capability dashboard section #431, [dashboard DDX-20] S3: Runtime-Config Monitor & Control (flagship) #551, [deploy-plugin DPB-26] AWS-PROBE-HTTP: live Lambda Web Adapter conformance #918
- PR RFC: NetScript DevTools contribution architecture — plugins that ship developer tooling #1450
MERGEDtimestamp2026-08-11T20:27:09Z - The verbatim preservation of Epic: NetScript DevTools contribution and host architecture #400 body content
- The "24 children of Epic: Frontend contribution layer — plugins that ship UI #922" untouched claim
- The 22-finding tally from the Qwen D2 design pass
- The exact label set on each filed issue (other than their existence in
.github/labels.yml, which is verified)
Blocking findings
None. No hallucinated verb, flag, path, label, or package was detected. The single command-cited string (git ls-tree origin/main -- rfcs/) reproduces the claimed output against the live tree.
Required fixes
None.
Summary
The PR adds a single filing-ledger artifact under a tracked run dir. Every locally-verifiable claim — RFC path, RFC content (six-state taxonomy), label existence/non-existence, drift IDs, fork IDs, PR reference, milestone, branch topology — is accurate. The doc is a record of past actions, not a how-to; there are no executable claims to hand-test beyond the single evidence-cited git ls-tree invocation, which reproduces as quoted.
Changes
None made to the repo (evaluator-only run).
Validation
git diff origin/main..HEAD --name-only→ one file, as expected.git ls-tree origin/main -- rfcs/→rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.mdpresent.head rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md→rfc: 0005,status: Accepted,target-milestone: 0.0.6.grep -E "zone-contract-mismatch|six-state" rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md→ quorum (six-state taxonomy confirmed).grep -E "name: \"(epic:dev-dashboard|epic:devtools|area:devtools|area:frontend)\"" .github/labels.yml→ onlyepic:dev-dashboardexists.grep -nE "D-10|D-11|D-15|D-16|D-18|D-19" .llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/drift.md→ each ID has a heading.grep -nE "F-1|F-3|F-9|F-11" .llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/{decision-brief.md,drift.md,filing-manifest.md}→ each fork is defined or referenced consistently.git merge-base HEAD origin/main→3bd058f55, confirming the temporal context for the03680f6e8snapshot.
Responses to review comments or issue comments
No review threads on this PR are present (pr-review-comments.json is [\n]\n); no thread replies needed.
Remaining risks
- The doc is a one-shot record of a past board migration; if PR RFC: NetScript DevTools contribution architecture — plugins that ship developer tooling #1450 was not actually merged on
mainat the recorded timestamp, the P0 row's "origin/main = 03680f6" claim becomes a factual error. The run's own artifacts corroborate the framing, but direct GitHub verification is out of scope for this evaluator. - GitHub-state claims (issue bodies, comments posted, labels/milestones/state on real issues) are not reproducible from the local checkout and rely on the run's own audit trail.
Verdict
OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS
Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/31534383045
8 tasks
github-actions
Bot
added
the
canary:0.0.6-canary.2
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Summary
Records the completed, owner-approved RFC 0005 one-shot board filing and exact issue disposition ledger. No product or roadmap mutation is performed by this PR.
Validation
Acceptance