Skip to content

docs(harness): record DevTools RFC filing ledger #1523

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Merged
rickylabs merged 1 commit into from
Aug 11, 2026
Merged

docs(harness): record DevTools RFC filing ledger #1523

Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
1 commit
Select commit
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension
Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
96 changes: 96 additions & 0 deletions .llm/runs/plan-devtools-contribution--seed/filing/FILING-LOG.md
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,96 @@
# FILING-LOG — DevTools contribution RFC

**Filed:** 2026-08-11 · **By:** supervisor session `session_01DChBXWYP9LStvjQztUJV5b` (Claude Opus 5 · high)
**Ratification:** owner in-turn, drift **D-19** · **Board migration approved:** owner in-turn, 2026-08-11
**RFC of record:** [`rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md`](https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/blob/main/rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md) — **merged on `main`** at `03680f6e8`, via PR #1450

> **PLAN-EVAL:** cleared by **written owner waiver**, drift **D-18**. The formal Codex GPT-5.6 Sol
> evaluator returned **`FAIL_PLAN` twice**; every supervisor-fixable finding was closed before the
> waiver. **No evaluator `PASS` exists — do not cite one.**

## Preconditions at filing time

| # | Precondition | Evidence |
| - | ------------ | -------- |
| P0 | RFC merged on `main` and path verified **before** any issue linked to it | `git ls-tree origin/main -- rfcs/` → `rfcs/0005-devtools-contribution.md`; `origin/main` = `03680f6e8`; PR #1450 `MERGED` 2026-08-11T20:27:09Z |
| P1 | Plan-Gate cleared | **owner waiver**, drift D-18 |
| P2 | Blocking forks ratified + filing authorized | drift D-19 |
| P3 | Adversarial design pass satisfied | owner-approved substitute route — Qwen 3.8 Max + Kimi K3, drift D-15/D-16; 22 findings closed |
| P4 | F-1 / F-3 resolved | drift D-19 — F-1 self-contained `packages/devtools-core` first; F-3 `.passthrough()` before any manifest-visible pointer |

## Draft ID → live issue

| Draft | Slice | Live | Milestone | Action |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DT-RFC | — | **#1468** | `0.0.6` | NEW — RFC 0005 tracking issue |
| DT-1 | W0-a | **#1469** | `0.0.15` | NEW — disposable probe |
| DT-2 | W0-b | **#1470** | `0.0.15` | NEW — disposable probe |
| DT-3 | W1-a | **#1471** | `0.0.15` | NEW — **successor to #412** |
| DT-4 | W1-b | **#1472** | `0.0.15` | NEW — **successor to #424** |
| DT-5 | W1-c | **#1473** | `0.0.15` | NEW |
| DT-6 | W1-d | **#1474** | `0.0.15` | NEW — F-3 precondition |
| DT-7 | W2-a | **#1475** | `0.0.15` | NEW — boundary vs #930 stated |
| DT-8 | W2-b | **#1476** | `0.0.15` | NEW — boundary vs #937/#938 stated |
| DT-9 | W3-a | **#1477** | `0.0.15` | NEW — **co-successor to #424** |
| DT-10 | W3-b | **#1478** | `0.0.15` | NEW |
| DT-11 | W4-a | *(none)* | — | **AMEND #427** — folded, stays open as the slice |
| DT-12 | W4-b | **#1479** | `0.0.15` | NEW |
| DT-13 | W5-a | *(none)* | — | **AMEND #423** — boundary vs #934 stated |
| DT-14 | W5-b | **#1480** | `0.0.15` | NEW — public-surface change, consumer gate |
| DT-15 | W6-a | *(none)* | — | **AMEND #428** — boundary vs #933 stated |
| DT-16 | W6-b | *(none)* | — | **AMEND #429 / #430 / #431** — boundary vs #944; streams degraded state required |
| DT-17 | F-20 | **#1481** | `Backlog / Triage` | NEW — outside the epic |
| DT-18 | D-0b | **NOT FILED** | — | D-0b never decided; gap stays recorded in drift D-10/D-15 |

**14 new issues** (#1468–#1481) · **1 not filed** · **6 existing issues amended via 4 rows**.

## Epic

**#400 amended** — not replaced (standing decision D-11; a second umbrella would fragment the very
board this RFC de-fragments). Preserved **verbatim**: the ownership thesis, the three acceptance
lines, and the killed-surfaces list. Rewritten: the invent-your-own-discovery premise, the dead
`beta.6` prose, and the S1–S13 screen list → RFC 0005 pointers. Milestone unchanged
(`Backlog / Triage`).

`CR-DDX-HOSTAGNOSTIC` — raised on #400 on 2026-07-06 from epic #510 and **never resolved** — is
recorded as **accepted** (owner fork F-11). This un-dangles #544. #544 itself was **not** edited;
that body belongs to #510's lane.

## Successor-before-supersede ordering — as executed

| Superseded | Successor(s) | Order actually used | State now |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **#412** | **#1471** | successor filed **first**, then the supersede comment | **open** — closes when #1471 is delivered |
| **#424** | **#1472**, **#1477** | successors filed **first**, then the supersede comment | **open** — closes when both are delivered |

**Zero filing-time closes.** Every `FOLD` / `SUPERSEDE` / `CLOSE-LATER` was recorded as a comment
and left open, because each has a precondition that filing does not satisfy. No seam is left
unowned in the interval.

## Comments posted

- **Supersede:** #412, #424 · **Fold:** #427, #734 · **Close-later:** #507
- **Re-baseline (AMEND):** #414, #415, #420, #423, #426, #428, #429, #430, #431, #551
- **Epic:** #400 body rewrite + the `CR-DDX-HOSTAGNOSTIC` resolution
- **Cross-post:** **#929** — the *single* authorized #922-adjacent touch, reporting the `.strict()`
defect that #890 contract C8's "older CLIs ignore the block" claim rests on. Informational; it
changes no label, milestone, or scope.

## Preservation guarantees — verified

| Guarantee | Result |
| --- | --- |
| **#922 and its 24 children untouched** | ✅ zero body/label/milestone/state changes. #933 and #944 received **nothing**. The only #922-adjacent action anywhere was the informational #929 cross-post |
| **2026-07-19 milestone train preserved** | ✅ no issue re-milestoned. New sub-issues default to `0.0.15`, matching the ratified train |
| **No undocumented labels created** | ✅ every label used exists in both `.github/labels.yml` and live. `epic:devtools`, `area:devtools`, `area:frontend` do **not** exist and were **not** created — `epic:dev-dashboard` used instead |
| **No milestones created; no issue moved** | ✅ only edit was stripping the stale "Dev dashboard (thin, contribution-based)" clause from `0.0.14`'s **description** (owner fork F-9). Its 11 open issues are unchanged |
| **No closing keyword in any issue body** | ✅ `Part of #400` only |
| **Exactly one `status:` per issue** | ✅ `status:triage` at filing |

## Deviations from the manifest — recorded, not silent

1. **DT-8 title says "six-state", the manifest said "five-state."** The manifest predates Amendment A,
which added a sixth quarantine state (`zone-contract-mismatch`) to close a Qwen finding. Filing the
manifest's literal title would have contradicted the merged RFC. **Substance unchanged.**
2. **All issue bodies cite `rfcs/0005-…`, not the manifest's `rfcs/0000-…`.** Per the owner's
instruction to use the canonical `main` link; the number was assigned at acceptance.
Loading